Committee on Police and Fire meeting, October 7, 2024
- When: Mon, Oct 7, 2024, 1:00 PM (Chicago time)
- Where: Room 201A, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on Police and Fire
- Video: https://vimeo.com/1017180274
- Transcript: full text (17,824 words, automatic captions)
Video chapters
- 8:56 Public comment
- 36:49 Ordinance establishing bereavement leave following the death of a uniformed service member
- 38:05 Anthony V. Napolitano: Introduced the ordinance, citing line-of-duty deaths and suicides in the department…
- 43:58 Anthony V. Napolitano: Said any problems could be amended later and that off-duty shifts can cover for…
- 46:53 Anthony V. Napolitano: Clarified that a negotiated contract would supersede the ordinance if the parties…
- 1:00:22 Chris Taliaferro: Asked the general counsel whether he was stating the department's position and whether he…
- 1:01:50 Jason C. Ervin: Asked what the current protocol is for a firefighter to take leave after a colleague's death.
- 1:04:05 Jason C. Ervin: Asked how much time firefighters are allotted for physical or mental health issues.
- 1:06:41 Silvana Tabares: Said she strongly supports the ordinance as a step toward supporting firefighters' mental…
- 1:08:05 Nicole T. Lee: Asked who determines when a member on leave is fit to return to duty.
- 1:09:43 Nicole T. Lee: Asked about the city's bereavement policy for family members.
- 1:10:13 Nicole T. Lee: Said she was surprised firefighters lack a policy like police and that the return-to-duty…
- 1:19:56 Chris Taliaferro: Summarized the ordinance as giving administrative leave to members of the deceased's…
- 1:21:10 Timothy R. Knudsen: Asked how long it takes under current practice for a firefighter's bereavement request…
- 1:23:19 Timothy R. Knudsen: Said bereavement leave should be guaranteed rather than questioned and that he would…
- 1:27:20 Samantha Nugent: Said grieving members should not have to deal with HR and supervisors and that she supports…
- 1:28:23 Debra L. Silverstein: Expressed full support for the ordinance and condolences to the firefighters who…
- 1:29:03 James M. Gardiner: Said as a former firefighter the layup program is generous for those who use it, and…
- 1:30:02 James M. Gardiner: Noted firefighters have been without a contract for over three years with no end in…
- 1:31:51 James M. Gardiner: Said firefighters often will not ask for time off and favored mandated time off, urging…
- 1:34:45 Angela Clay: Supported a bereavement policy but asked that the item be held to develop a universal policy…
- 1:37:23 Angela Clay: Said she wanted more due diligence on the police and fire policies and moved to hold the item.
- 1:38:30 Raymond A. Lopez: Voiced support as a non-member, saying it is unreasonable to expect people in their worst…
- 1:39:32 Raymond A. Lopez: Asked how often the department met to improve the ordinance in the 299 days since it was…
- 1:41:21 Raymond A. Lopez: Proposed amending the mandatory provisions to apply with the concurrence of the employee…
- 1:43:52 Ronnie L. Mosley: Asked whether the leave applies to the entire firehouse or only the affected shift.
- 1:45:49 Ronnie L. Mosley: Asked how coverage would be maintained when members take leave.
- 1:46:08 Nicholas Sposato: Clarified that the city would bring in replacement firefighters to staff a house for that…
- 1:46:28 Ronnie L. Mosley: Asked what other mental health services are available to firefighters.
- 1:48:36 Chris Taliaferro: Said as a 23-year Chicago Police Department veteran he supports the ordinance and mental…
- 1:49:59 Jason C. Ervin: Asked whether the sponsor supported Lopez's amendment and said the department should address…
- 1:52:15 Motion to hold bereavement leave ordinance in committee
- 1:53:49 Amendment adding 'with the concurrence of the employee' to mandatory leave provisions
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The Committee on Police and Fire heard eight public commenters, approved its Rule 45 report, and considered a single item: an ordinance sponsored by Alderperson Anthony V. Napolitano establishing bereavement leave for Chicago Fire Department members following a line-of-duty death or suicide of a colleague. Union president Patrick Cleary and three firefighters testified in support, while the Fire Department's general counsel said the department has no written policy but has not denied leave requests, and asked that the matter be deferred so it could be addressed through a department policy. Alderperson Angela Clay moved to hold the item to consider a universal policy for police and fire; the motion failed 13 to 1 on a roll call read aloud. The committee adopted an amendment suggested by Alderperson Raymond A. Lopez changing the mandatory provisions to apply with the concurrence of the employee, and then recommended passage of the ordinance by voice vote.
Topics: firefighter bereavement leave, first responder mental health, Fire Department policy, collective bargaining, employee assistance program, public comment
Agenda items discussed
- 8:56 Public comment: discussed
- 36:17 Rule 45 report: passed
- 36:49 Ordinance establishing bereavement leave following the death of a uniformed service member: passed
- 1:52:15 Motion to hold bereavement leave ordinance in committee: failed
- 1:53:49 Amendment adding 'with the concurrence of the employee' to mandatory leave provisions: passed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Chris Taliaferro (chair): Asked the general counsel whether he was stating the department's position and whether he had ever had to work the day after losing a loved one. (1:00:22); Summarized the ordinance as giving administrative leave to members of the deceased's firehouse and shift and for attending services. (1:19:56); Said as a 23-year Chicago Police Department veteran he supports the ordinance and mental health treatment and education for first responders. (1:48:36)
- Anthony V. Napolitano (alderperson): Introduced the ordinance, citing line-of-duty deaths and suicides in the department and the lack of a written bereavement policy for firefighters. (38:05); Said any problems could be amended later and that off-duty shifts can cover for grieving firefighters without closing firehouses. (43:58); Clarified that a negotiated contract would supersede the ordinance if the parties later agreed on a different approach. (46:53)
- Jason C. Ervin (alderperson): Asked what the current protocol is for a firefighter to take leave after a colleague's death. (1:01:50); Asked how much time firefighters are allotted for physical or mental health issues. (1:04:05); Asked whether the sponsor supported Lopez's amendment and said the department should address such work rules without council legislation, while understanding why it reached council. (1:49:59)
- Silvana Tabares (alderperson): Said she strongly supports the ordinance as a step toward supporting firefighters' mental health and would vote yes. (1:06:41)
- Nicole T. Lee (alderperson): Asked who determines when a member on leave is fit to return to duty. (1:08:05); Asked about the city's bereavement policy for family members. (1:09:43); Said she was surprised firefighters lack a policy like police and that the return-to-duty process does not address mental health. (1:10:13)
- Timothy R. Knudsen (alderperson): Asked how long it takes under current practice for a firefighter's bereavement request to be approved. (1:21:10); Said bereavement leave should be guaranteed rather than questioned and that he would support the ordinance. (1:23:19)
- Samantha Nugent (alderperson): Said grieving members should not have to deal with HR and supervisors and that she supports the ordinance. (1:27:20)
- Debra L. Silverstein (alderperson): Expressed full support for the ordinance and condolences to the firefighters who testified. (1:28:23)
- James M. Gardiner (alderperson): Said as a former firefighter the layup program is generous for those who use it, and asked whether the department wanted the issue handled in bargaining. (1:29:03); Noted firefighters have been without a contract for over three years with no end in sight, making bargaining an uncertain route. (1:30:02); Said firefighters often will not ask for time off and favored mandated time off, urging the committee to move forward. (1:31:51)
- Angela Clay (alderperson): Supported a bereavement policy but asked that the item be held to develop a universal policy for fire and police, citing concern about EAP staffing. (1:34:45); Said she wanted more due diligence on the police and fire policies and moved to hold the item. (1:37:23)
- Raymond A. Lopez (alderperson): Voiced support as a non-member, saying it is unreasonable to expect people in their worst moment to ask for help. (1:38:30); Asked how often the department met to improve the ordinance in the 299 days since it was introduced. (1:39:32); Proposed amending the mandatory provisions to apply with the concurrence of the employee to address the department's concern. (1:41:21)
- Ronnie L. Mosley (alderperson): Asked whether the leave applies to the entire firehouse or only the affected shift. (1:43:52); Asked how coverage would be maintained when members take leave. (1:45:49); Asked what other mental health services are available to firefighters. (1:46:28)
- Nicholas Sposato (alderperson): Clarified that the city would bring in replacement firefighters to staff a house for that day. (1:46:08)
Exchanges between members
- 1:06:41 Tabares thanked Napolitano for bringing the ordinance forward.
- 1:08:01 Lee said she was following up on the questions Ervin had asked.
- 1:21:06 Knudsen said Lee had asked many of the questions he planned to ask.
- 1:24:36 Napolitano clarified for colleagues that there is no existing policy.
- 1:25:12 Knudsen thanked Napolitano for clarifying the distinction between policy and ordinance.
- 1:28:29 Silverstein thanked Napolitano for bringing the ordinance.
- 1:28:55 Gardiner thanked Napolitano for the ordinance.
- 1:34:23 Gardiner referenced a saying he attributed to Ervin about not letting perfection stand in the way of progress.
- 1:34:47 Clay told Napolitano they share a love for the Fire Department before raising her concerns.
- 1:36:46 Napolitano responded to Clay that police helped draft the ordinance and waiting for a universal policy could delay protections.
- 1:37:23 Clay agreed something could happen soon but said she wanted more due diligence before a decision.
- 1:37:57 Taliaferro asked Clay whether she was moving to hold the item.
- 1:38:14 Lopez offered to wait on his comments until the motion was addressed.
- 1:38:24 Taliaferro asked Lopez to proceed with his questions before the motion was taken.
- 1:43:49 Mosley thanked Napolitano for the ordinance.
- 1:46:08 Sposato answered Mosley's coverage question, saying the city would bring in replacement firefighters.
- 1:49:59 Ervin asked the chair whether the sponsor supported Lopez's proposed amendment.
- 1:50:30 Taliaferro told Ervin the amendment would be addressed after the motion to hold.
- 1:54:17 Napolitano adopted Lopez's suggested language making leave subject to the employee's concurrence.
- 1:56:49 Napolitano thanked the chair for working with him on the ordinance.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error