meetings 2023 to 2027 pursuant to the Chicago city council Rules of Order and procedure rule 49. The sergeant-at-arms sets forth the following rules of conduct to be followed during the public comment period and the duration City of Chicago city council rules of conduct for public meetings to City of Chicago city council rules of conduct for public meetings 2023 to 2027 pursuant to the Chicago city council Rules of Order and procedure rule 49 the sergeant-at-arms sets forth the following rules of conduct to be followed during the public comment period and the duration of all committee and City Council meetings profane vulgar threatening abusive or disruptive language is not permitted demeaning discriminatory harassing behavior and speech directed towards others is not permitted disruptive behavior, including disruptive or disrespectful conducting others presentations is committed clear bags not tinted in color that do not exceed 12 by 12 by 6 in will be permitted in our subject to search food and beverages including in metal canisters are not permitted cell phones must be placed on silent prior to entering the meeting room individuals must remain seated public comment speakers are permitted to stand only when providing public comment small handheld devices may be used only while seated and the user must refrain from interfering with the viewer hearing of other individuals individuals or groups failing to adhere to these rules will be asked to see such disruptive conduct and failure to comply will result in their being subject to removal from the meeting by the sergeant-at-arms. Morning morning. You know, I just want to make sure. So the joint committee on police fire and Workforce Development will now come to order today. We have 1 item on the agenda subject matter hearing on the Chicago Fire Department's hiring Plan before we begin. I'm going to conduct a roll call of our members Alderman Robinson. We'll get them all. Um alderman, yansyi. Alder is present Alderman Chico. Armand Chico's present alderwoman Lee is present all the woman Ramirez. All the woman Ramirez is present Alderman Quinn Alder person Gutierrez Alderman Coleman Curtis all the woman tailor. Alderman Taylor is present Alderman Mosley Cher Rodriguez is present alderman tobars. Alderman Ervin is present Alderman T Farrell chairman chairman is present Alderman Cardona. Almond Cardona is present Alderman Ramirez Rosa alderman pasado. Alderman pasado is present Alderman Nugent Alder person Vasquez. Alder Mercedes in Vasquez is presente alderman. Alderman kuden is present Alderman Gardiner alderwoman clay. All the women Clay is present Alderman Silverstein Alderman Robinson. President Alderman Robinson is present seeing that we have 14 members present. We do have a quorum, uh by rule 59 committee members Alderman nents Alderman Mosley Alderman Gardiner Alderman Coleman alderwoman Gutierrez and Alderman Ramirez Rosa have requested attendance by remote means on the rule of 59 due to unrelated emergencies. Uh, can I get a motion to allow their participation remotely? So moved all those in favor signify by saying I any opposed any opinion of the chair the eyes have it. I'd like to also uh, recognize Alderman Bernett and I believe alderwoman, uh uh, Alderman dowel also our present either in person or remotely and we will recognize that for quorum. Um at this time, we will begin public comment the public comment period is 30 minutes out of respect for everyone's Time Each speaker is limited to 3 minutes. Our first speaker is I believe it's Jim. jablonowski in Alderman Johnny is president. for purposes of a quorum Thank you chair. Um, we'll start with Jim jablonowski and then following. Uh, we'll be uh, Gloria Hannah if you could be uh, just ready when we're um ready for you. You have 3 minutes. Good morning, everybody. My name is Jim jablin elowsky. I'm a retired Chicago Fire Department battalion chief 36 years on the job. Um, I also have a Facebook page for the last 10 years for Chicago Fire Department hiring. I have about 4,000 followers. I get contacted uh every day by dozens of people, uh, And I've done probably 300 foyers to try to peel back the curtain on this hiring process. The hiring process is terrible everything's secretive and it shouldn't be secretive as I walk through the county building today. I realize I could look up any of your your taxes. I could look up your mortgages. I could look up all these things and yet these people that give up their time to take this test for the world's greatest job cannot see where they are at on this list. Since doing this since 2014 on the last list, I uncovered over 500 mistakes made by the city of Chicago. I met with cfd, uh, Deputy Commissioners and I met with the inspector General's office to get that list changed and that list was changed and over 350 mistakes were found. I don't know how many mistakes are made on this list. Just terrible. I'd like to say 1 thing about Alderman's Spa because of his push for City residency for this test. We're going to have 90% of the people that get hired on our job on the world's greatest job. They're going to be City residents, which I think is great. uh What can the city do very simple host the numbers and the referrals on on the city website? So these people that take the test instead of them get reaching out to me to see where they're at on the list because I got a foyer request and I got the information, you know from back in the closet. They can go on and take a look themselves and then they can see what mistakes are made if they got their proper preference or not. What they need to do also is the medical the medical standards need to be posted. So these people that end up having bad Medicals can find out why they have bad Medicals or they can in fact find out that maybe the city made another mistake. so and going forward with this new test, let's not fail 50% of the Chicago Police Department that took the test 50% of the Chicago Fire Department paramedics that took the test 50% of the veterans. How about all your Alderman in here? If you had to take a test the sixth grade reading test which is what they take for fire department to be an Alderman and then they come back and say you know what 50% of you failed. And you go. Well, how did I fail? Well, we're not telling you. Well, what's the standard? We're not telling you. We're not telling you anything. Would you be devastated? Because the fire department is not the same job as being a garbage truck driver. It's a career. And if you talk to anybody on the fire department, there's not 1 person that doesn't love this job. And 1 more quick thing. The next hearing we need to have is the the the terrible line of duty death rate on the Chicago Fire Department. We have the worst line of duty death rate of all large city fire departments. Thank you. Sir. Next up is Gloria hanana followed by Burke Smith, Gloria your 3 minutes start now. Good morning. My name is Gloria Hannah. I am actually a retired first responder. I retired as a deputy chief from the Chicago Police Department in December of 2020. I'm actually here on behalf of my oldest son who applied to be a Chicago Fire Department, uh Chicago firefighter. He could not be here because he's actually at home working. So I'm just going to give you a timeline of his experience and this is probably an experience that a lot of people also this happened to them, but they did not have the wherewithal to push to be able to sit for the exam. So on November 17th, my son received a notice saying he was ineligible to take the exam because he had a low lottery number 93.99 will we wonder he lives in the city of Chicago? He graduated from Gwendolyn Brooks a city of Chicago high school was his preferences applied and And I will tell you this he submitted everything on time and we went back into to and we checked that on November 23rd. He sent an email to to the city asking if his preferences were applied were applied. He received the response on the 27th. Asking for his candidate number he responded on the 28th. He he provided that on the 30th of November. He was told it was being researched on December 7th. He he actually did receive an admission ticket to take the exam 10 days prior to the exam. But my question is how many other Keenan Smiths were there that this happened to in their preferences were not given to them when they should have been thank you. I hope that you all really will address this issue. Thank you, ma'am. Next up is Burke Smith followed by Rodney Shelton. Burke Smith if you wish to speak Okay, Burke you uh, uh relinquish your wish here. Okay. We'll go to Rodney Shelton, then you have 3 minutes, sir. How you doing? Uh, I'm Rodney Shelton. I'm a member of the Chicago Fire Department. Uh, I'm also a member of the Lewis class the uh, the class that we got on, uh, due to the 1995, uh entry exam. uh, my concern is the enforcement or the lack of enforcement of appendix G in its entirety and that is in basically every section of that. Uh Independence G. It has not been enforced appendix G is our affirmative action policy. And the way that that has there's been a lack of uh enforcement is through the scoring of the exams. They use this, uh methodology, which is considered linear transformation, which after getting it, uh, getting it reviewed by Northwestern University in that sense. The city uses a negative curve, uh to give you an example the battalion chief exam. Out of 104 they uh out of 104 candidates 30 were black when the results came out. They said 12 was eligible for promotion when we went back and did the actual math, which is considered Pro rat of math simple, arithmetic 27 out of 30 blocks were eligible. So you went from saying 40% was eligible. And then when we correct when we went back and saw the corrected version, it was 90% eligible even with the uh, the captives exam from 2016. These exams are from 2016, even with that out of the 53, uh candidates. They said 18 was eligible for promotion for decades. The City attorney has gone on record to say that they've been using this methodology and they don't see what the problem is. Well, it's a violation in the section of the the contract of of appendix G that's specifically says anything as far as examinations that harms blacks and Hispanic. You should stop doing it. And I've asked that it be I've asked from our elected officials. To the the official of that Mary or me, not Lori Lightfoot mayor Lori Lightfoot appointed. Um the affirmative action, uh officer I've I've written no responses written no responses with the help of the uh, Westside NAACP. We've been able to get some traction get with the IG and and and and move forward with this but the fact of the matter is there's key things in that affirmative action policy. That's that that that's holding us back. There's no affirmative action officer, which supposed to be appointed by the mayor and only supposed to report to the mayor and there's no Community Advisory board. So when we look at these things, This is how you can get the answers because that that's the checks and balances. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Shelton. Uh, your time is expired. Next up will be Orlando Martinez followed by Jeffrey. I believe the last name is zoron Orlando Martinez. You have 3 minutes, sir. All right. Good morning. My name is Orlando Martinez. I'm a Chicago resident. I graduated from CPS high school with honors. I was in the cpfta and I currently am working as a EMT. I took the most recent exam and December 2022 and it is discouraging that such a well-known fire department such as the Chicago fire department is failing people like myself based on a self-pity test. That isn't explained. That's all I had to say. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Martinez up next Jeffrey. I believe it's zoron and following. Uh, Jeffrey will be warshaw king. You have 3 minutes sir. Good morning, everyone. Good morning. My name is Captain Jeffrey Porter. I was denied a promotion to the battalion chief in December of 2019. based on fraudulent claims by the city The city called me to BC class in December of 2019 because I had all the requirements needed per the job announcement. Then at the end of the class when our batteries were being passed out mine was withheld without reason. Later, they claimed. I did not have the requirements to be promoted to Chief. Their claims did not have any validation. It wasn't true. Otherwise, they would not have called me to the class for the promotion in the first place. Now calculating they owe me 4 years of back pay as a battalion chief and also adjusting all my status as Captain Captain to the Titan Chief meeting my pay my pension and everything else in in regards. That's all I have. Thank you. Thank you very much, Mr. Porter forgive my uh mistreating your name. Next up is warshaw King followed by George, Blakemore. Good morning. My name is warshaw King. I'm a retired battalion chief with 36 years of the on the job. Uh, just want to bring up to the attention that the years that I've been on the job the number of the black. firefighters have decreased now on the pick G we have that you supposed to have 45% Of blacks, they say minorities black and Hispanics where the Hispanics are getting these numbers, but the blacks are not getting this numbers. You throwing out the the uh, bad narrative that hey, there's no black that want the job but the blacks that are on the list. For the job you're not calling them. Their numbers are being passed over. and they nobody bringing that to know 1 attention so the number of black need to increase it said 45% and it should be 45% each. new recruitment class I mean if you look around you got a lot of kids right here that's on the list having been called. Got the qualification. Got the qualification got everything in the ears. They not waiting. They getting the EMT license they prepared and they waiting to get the call. But yet you all going to pass them up. Now we got immigrants that's coming in the city and now y'all ready to get them city jobs. City jobs, you got people that have been in the city all day in life. Trying to get a city job. So I'm just going to bring that to your attention. Thank you. Thank you. Sir. Next up is George Blakemore followed by Michael Young Mr. George Moore to you, sir. You have 3 minutes. All of you out here. You got these Black Faces in high places. Several years ago. They had a consent decree for about the black Farm. They didn't get nothing. Then 20 years later. You're still not getting nothing. Don't talk about Brown. We talking about black you got black. Your black official black someone who smokes be hate on the plantation the white man made a in. And you're acting hating each other. You don't see no other group crying up here about that but black. low, lighted black leadership No black leadership. instead It's a sad day and then you have I been waiting back here trying to keep me from this meeting black story. Don't worry. Don't worry. Maybe the Republicans don't want to either maybe the United States. Thank you. Maybe you hated by the government when they promised over here. This is Chad. This is not a new struggle with these problems. The white problem would beat up the black F in the fire station this little white lady over there. She used to say Mr. Blakemore. Pray for me. That's what that lady said that that black lady. She said pray for me dear Lord help my people help them help them help them. It's the help of don't wait on the Lord. You got to help you get really need somebody black leadership. They don't even do they tell you. They they keep going this way, but this Democratic machine that not the same damn thing over and over and over again, but at the same time stop It stop it. Oh, this is not a new struggle with the Bible as the old Bible about that lawsuit. Black Faces in high places selling out black people Thank you, sir. Michael Young be followed by Shalom Wilson. Thank you, sir. Go go ahead sir. these people down here complaining brave men and women that's willing to serve this country. Rich willing to serve the people that's willing to serve the community. and they not getting no justice. They not getting no justice and it ain't just on the fire department. It's on the police too. It's on the police force. Just look at just go and y'all everybody go there and that thing just go look and see every time a may get in there. You may see when they having a recruit. You may see 5 or 6. brothers and sisters in that bunch of people that's went through the academy for the police department. You know what I'm saying as well as for the fire department, it's hard for our people just to get in the door. And then some of them don't Gather in the door and they being treated. Like they ain't nothing. You know, but y'all not doing these Europeans like that. Y'all not doing these Europeans like that because we call a fire right it be a fire in this building right now 90% of them that come gonna be European. And I don't use the term black or white. So that's why I'm using the term European because I call our people what we are Asian addicts. you know, so this discrimination need to stop. And the only way it going to stop as he referenced to a I waiting on it to fall out the sky. You gotta take action. Because some of these people may even be down here. Just lobbying where they pay you to come down get up here and say whatever you gonna say Etc. You know, but these people ain't got your interest in heart. They ain't got the interest in heart of the public. Because if they did our communities will look different. Look around in your communities. Y'all y'all know where y'all come from and where your families come from? And where you at? for that matter this discrimination need to stop. When is y'all going to stand up for the people or is you just some cowards? Cuz some of y'all get up here and speak all that Kumbaya stuff and then vote against the interests of your own people. You will hide behind these churches. You will have Behind these organizations. You'll hide behind all this nonsense just to denounce your own people to raise your own people destroy your own people. Our people need to wake up and be strong. And come up from away from them. Come away from them. And most of it is ran by a Democratic party. That's why we say go red. Thank you. Sir. Next up is Shalom Wilson followed by sa Horus. Shalom Wilson Thank you. Order sir. Thank you, sir up next. Hey guys, my name is Chalan Wilson. Um, I applied um, I took the entry exam for the firefighters August 2022. Um, I still have not heard anything back. I've got no response. I've reached out several times in the email that they have addressed in my email for taking the exam never gotten a response. I've emailed them at least 20 times. Um, my dream was to always be a firefighter. I didn't even I've never seen a black firefighter when I was young. I seen a black female firefighter but growing up. I've never seen any firefighters. I didn't know any black firefighters really existed until I came to the black fire brigade and I was introduced to all of these people. I just feel like I don't really have a fair chance maybe being discriminated against because the process is taken so long. I went to CPAP practice with people who? Got their acceptance letters in the summer, but took their entry exam in 2014 10 years ago. I just don't want to have to wait that long. Um, I just feel like I don't have a fair chance. I'm still waiting. I didn't get a new lottery number still haven't heard anything back. So at this point I kind of don't know what to do. It's just still like a waiting game. I know people whose numbers of different ethnicities who were called before me people's numbers in a 5000 and I just don't think that's fair. That's all I got today. Thank you. Sioban Wilson. Next up is essay. Yes almond 1 second almond Patek come by me and give me her information. I'll find out what her status is for her. Okay. Thank you essay Horus. followed by Marco Bannon Go ahead now. Yes. Hi guys. My name is Sago Forest. Um, I attended Kenwood Academy and I go to Alabama A&M. Um, I believe when I was in fifth grade, they used to access. Uh, what we want to be most of the kids raised their hand and said, they wanted to be fired for us and police officers. Um, I don't know whether they are now. However, I literally asked the kid maybe a month ago. What they wanted to be. They told me they wanted to be like meech off vmf. I don't know if you guys know who meet y'all vmf is, but they are a drug cartel family. and I believe that they like the young lady said she didn't know that African-Americans were in the police department and I believe that they don't see a lot of black people in First Response. And I feel like it's so crazy that African-Americans have the second leading population in Chicago and that they only have a percent of African-Americans in the fire department. And only 2% of that are black women. but this young lady just to speak before me and she had that challenge and she still went forward to take that courage to still try to become um in the first response is very wonderful. Um, I also would say that my mom was 1 of the people to take the exam in 1995 and she was declined because of the standards that was raised to 90 89 and she made a 88 and the um requires and were changed right after the exam was taken and she lost her chance to become a 5 to fire. Um for decades fire to fires were looked at as Heroes and I do believe that it's time for African-Americans to be looked at as Heroes as well and the and children's of African-Americans to be able to see the African-Americans to be look as Heroes and to see their opportunities other ways to make changes in the world and to make other better chances than to be what they are labeled as that's all I got to say. Thank you. Thank you. Next up is Mark obannon followed by a dear Hughes Oh Aiden. Got it. Uh first up will be marked though. Good morning, everyone. My name is Mark Oban, and I'm a retired battalion chief for the Chicago Fire Department. um What we have is a history. a pattern a practice and a behavior of discrimination what what we're here for is not new. Brother Blackmore said it. It's nothing new. But it's consistent and it's systemic. and my suggestion there's a we have to force the only time fairness has come to the city of Chicago's hiring practices is with consent decrees Court actions suits Etc. It's clear if you look. But the transparency does not exist when we try to get numbers accurate numbers. How many people are on the job how many white people black people Hispanic people women? It's like pulling teeth. I'm sure Alderman Robinson can attest to the requests that he made that he's still waiting for for these numbers. The suggestion is the sort of simple thing. The 95 exam millions of dollars were spent to fight it. Let's not spend millions of dollars. Let's just hire some black people like the contract suggested. millions of dollars are spent to fight it and when it's when the um facts, excuse me, Mr. Blackmore. Thank you. when it when when this Victory comes millions of dollars are spent. So what we're just trying to say is do the right thing. It's legal. To do what you've been doing. generationally Systematically it's legal. But it's wrong. And we're just asking to do what's right. And not cost the city anymore money. Thank you. Thank you, sir. Next stop is Aiden Hughes. Hello, they hate us. Thank you everybody. Good morning, everybody. Morning. Hi, my name is Aiden Hughes. I am 23 years old. And I am a lifelong Chicago resident a CPS graduate. A cpfta graduate and I am currently a student at Richard J Daly College. It is my lifelong dream to join the Chicago fire department and I took the entrance exam on December 17th 2022. I am here to raise questions related to this exam. I was disqualified from the hiring process to join the Chicago Fire Department because administrators asserted that I did not complete certain sections of the exam. Though to the best of my knowledge. I did complete all sections of the exam and they did not give me any proof. Otherwise I have always had to persevere to achieve my goals as I'm a man with autism and I think diffic I think differently than my typically functioning peers. my request for a reasonable 504 accommodation of being able to take the test using a computer was denied. And I assert that having this accommodation may have made a positive difference to the outcome of my test. Going forward I respectfully request that for future entry-level opportunities. That human resources consider allowing me and others who have disabilities similar to mine to take the exam on a computer. My family has had 4 generations of Chicago firefighters, and I just want to and I just want the same opportunity to be hired on the cfd as my great. Great grandfather who joined back in 1891? That's all I have to say. Thank you. Thank you. Last speaker is Taiwan Sims Taiwan Sims. Yes. Is Michael David is Michael David Rodriguez? Right? Excuse me? It's Michael David Rodriguez. You you have 3 minutes, sir. Go ahead, right but last words. Vasquez So we hear this morning. Thank y'all for coming out. Thank y'all. Thank y'all. because this is the picture this is the 450 future that y'all working on right? These are the people that y'all plan on pushing out of the city. Do y'all representation Mr. Rodriguez Vasquez? See if we I'm not gonna speak to my black Alderman. We Sorry black Alder all the people. We sorry. We will apologize and we will do better. to uphold y'all representation in this city so that we might restructure the power so it might we assert ourselves in this room. Thank you, Mr. Bill for speaking so strongly well, um, oh she's not in the room this morning. the practice of discrimination the practice of the legacy of racism but now it's not even in white Americans in this room. It's practicing our Latino brothers and sisters. That seem to want to try to etch us out even though we invited. Humble Park, all these communities with black black people that we invited Southshore right now with the with the immigrants we invited we're still with no regard with a disregard with a blatant disregard. This is what y'all do what y'all pens and y'all representations that y'all sitting y'all positions. a dishonor to a people a dishonor to a city this is what y'all is. And It's upsetting it's so enraging. I came in this morning praying the Our Father over and over so that I might not stand up on this mic and cuss, but I'm I'm I've been blessed. The father to show me a picture. These people look this not a weak people back here. So imagine doing a physical the physical part of the um, 5 5 minutes, um test no problem the mental part. We not a unintelligible. So the mental part is no problem. However, just like the young lady said numbers way above her have been chosen, but they wouldn't her skin tone. We see this practice. We not we not unaware of it, but we see it. How do we amend it? How do we resolve it? Where's the reparation? Where's the reparation this and y'all powered over the in the committee of work force development work force development. That's the development. Let's focus on that deep. I know look at that clock, but you can watch me because you're gonna see me a lot. I promise you I came here with intent on speaking to you Mr. Rodriguez, but last quiz our Latino brothers and sisters. They is. I came. Because y'all I don't know somewhere along the way y'all been so screwed up. So pushed around that y'all think y'all gonna push us around now. Thank you sir. Um as or 30 minutes for public comment has expired. I want to thank everyone for uh, their comments. Uh, I also want to recognize all those yantee Hall Quinn and Curtis for the Quorum. Uh, all they're in the palatin Irvin you're already in we got the palatin and we got all them in Mitchell as well for the quorum. alderman Alderman, um, you're on Chrome as well. Oh, no, I had a question. Um, let me move this over to Alderman. Uh, uh tariro to take take over the chairmanship. Alderman Ervin Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Uh, I noticed that we've got some witnesses in the Box. My question is is anybody here from either HR or the fire department as well? Thank you. Um Alderman Ervin, I I was going to announce that uh, we did um reach out and invited director Anastasia Walker with public safety administration, uh commissioner and and at hold with the Chicago fire department and we invited um commissioner Blake Moore Department of Human Resources. Um, and unfortunately, they were unable to join us today. But um, go ahead I got no. I just I mean I mean we can we can take in the the testimony uh today, uh, however we at some point, you know, in order to honestly address the issues and concerns that are being brought. We've got to have the people that are empowered with dealing with this come before us and have that conversation that's painful as it may be. Uh, we can't, you know, not do that. So, um while we can take in the people that come down today take in the testimony. We do need to have a part 2 to this that will allow um them to address the issues that are being brought forth as relates to not only appendix G but the hiring process because it do it does seem to be just based anecdotally some challenges that we're we're hearing. However, it's uh, we got to have a dialogue. I mean we hear on 1 side of this we need a dialogue on these issues to so that we can uh, you know reach some reasonable conclusions and write the wrongs that have been done in this particular case. So yeah, and I I certainly appreciate that. Um Alderman now both chairman Rodriguez and I employed upon the administration to allow them to present their testimony and and ask questions before this, um committee today, um, but unfortunately because they have a uh, a pending lawsuit that the city's engaged in as well as um, I believe, uh, the stated reason was also current contract negotiations. um, the administration opted not to allow them to appear today. So, uh as as eloquent as that was said we did push to have them here because I understand the dynamic of having a conversation or dialogue with the the parties that Probably most important to be in here to answer a lot of your questions, um are not present before the joint committee. So, um, I appreciate the uh, The need for them to be here. Um, no, I I agree with that. I I mean I understand and in some respects, but there's a basic stuff that they should be able to answer and I and I I do hope that at some point in the future that we do set aside a time for just without getting into the legalities of it, but there are some very basic process questions. I think all of us need to know and understand and they need to be able to provide that information for us. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you Alderman bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Chairman these Commissioners work for us We appoint these Commissioners and we're going to let the administration tell a commissioner not to come before this body. What is this body for? What are we what are we doing? Why are we elected officials? Why are we all women? Holding committee meetings if we can't get a commissioner to come before us. Yeah. you know, I mean, I mean you we all know I've been around a while, but I I really wish uh a person would tell me that uh commissioner can't come before a body in which You all are chairman and you're allowing somebody to tell you all that. Somebody is not going to come before you all. We will never get anywhere in this city. If we allow this kind of behavior to continue. Now, I mean, we you know what we're talking about today. I've been talking about for 25 years for 25 years. I've been here talking about we need more representation from our community on the police department to fire department the whole I've been fighting the whole hiring process for the police department that how they excluded blacks because if you got bad credit or if you got a psychological you you you didn't pass the psychological. I mean the whole process is skewed and there's no different with the fireman's exam. The whole process is skewed to eliminate people of color, especially black folks and so and you know until you know until this body decides to finally stand up. And be the body that we are elected to be. Without being dictated to and it's nothing against the administration, but it's Pro us. It ain't anti- anybody it's Pro us and throw our community. We're fighting for our community. Not you know, I think you know, I think I said this last month I said this last month. That if you know this body did not you know realize that 1 day we need to wake up. Because we're losing this city. We're losing our city because this body is not standing up to do what's right for the masses of the people who are paying taxes who live here who play here and eventually they die here. We're not fighting for them. We're not fighting for those people. And so I don't want to get on my soapbox any more than I normally do but this is wrong and I wish a person would tell me if I was a chairman. I wish a person would tell me a commission ain't come before me and I'm a chairman. We need to do some soul searching. Thank you so much, Mr. Chair, and and and Al. I'm not I'm not going to um, you know argue. I'm not I'm not going to argue a point because you make a good point the the issue is, you know. You know following the ordinance, so give us subpoena power. You know and and if we had subpoena power they wouldn't be able to dodge around it. They wouldn't be able to direct um or or allow the administration to tell them not to come here. So the argument isn't with this committee. The argument isn't with this body. The argument is with the administration because as much as we can command them or demand them to be here. Hold on. Hold on. Hold on I'm speaking. as as as much as we can command them and demand that they be here. The administration also has the authority to direct them not to be here and and they And and they they are they are going to do what the administration allows them to do because that's who appoints them. Of course we confirm but ultimately, um, I wanted to cancel the meeting because they weren't here. Um because it makes no sense in my opinion to have this meeting when we couldn't get testimony from them to talk about the disparities in hiring to talk about the disparities and promotion. You're right. This has been an argument for years for decades and it's not going to be settled if they're not at the table. Uh, and so I agree with you to some to some point but we need subpoena power if we had the authority to subpoena then they can't go around the subpoena and not show up and not allow the uh, the administration to tell them not to show up and to be very honest with you. Um, uh, the commissioner of fire department wanted to be here. Um, in fact, she really wanted to be here to speak on behalf of the fire department. But um because she was directed not to be here. She's not here today. Alderman Taylor alderwoman Taylor Hold on Walter had I'm sorry Alderman B had a point of information. Then we're going to Alderman pisado hit a point of information and then Alderman alderwoman Taylor point of information. Yeah. I just want to know did you talk to the administration about them business? Yes, we did. Fantastic point of information not questions 1 of information. Not a question. I just been helping people back here. They've been coming up to me and I just want to give some good news about Shalom Wilson. I just found out a real number a real number is 814 which means she will be in most likely in the next class. I told her she'll be getting called soon. Probably. I don't know when maybe you know, June July August so But I just want to let the people know the good news. And and also I just want to reaffirm what you said. It is not the 3 commissioner fault. They were told not to come here. They were asked to come and administration won't let them come. So thank you. Thank you Alden. This is Al alderwoman Taylor. I'm gonna take all my glasses off. Absolutely. We are professional time wasters that that's what we are. So y'all got all these Black Friday Fighters back here who came to actually tell their story and y'all in administration decide because you should have told us before today and don't act like on our watch they didn't get rid of the dissent decree. So are we going to call bulshit? Let's call it all together. Y'all are getting on my last good nerve. I am so sick of y'all. I've asked every I got here in 2019 and every year I've asked the commissioner and Ned Hall. Why does the number of black firefighters? Keep going down? I've got death threats from White firefighters saying that I'm starting trouble and kicking up s***. Really. This is what we do. And now we need y'all to save us now. Y'all want to tell us the numbers now. Y'all want to say it's a problem with testing. Where would y'all at? When I was at these budget hearings asking those same questions nowhere to be found. Nowhere to be found y'all so full of s***, and I'm tired of it y'all just y'all everything needs people say about us is the truth. It is the truth so they decided not to come and y'all keep giving Miss hold a pass like she doing her job. She not her Anastasia Walker and now miss Blakemore because she knew where our problematic they should have been here the first day when we brought this out, but she did. Y'all been talking about it for 20 years. I bet you doing budget season y'all going to vote Yes. Y'all going to hold that budget cuz I will. I wish these black firefighters could go on strike and the union is just as f****** guilty. They are guilty as well. I don't care if they had a contract to GOI or for what so they can keep telling us appendix. You don't have no teeth how long they been telling us. They been saying that to me for 5 years. Y'all when they tell out the city. It's on us. The thought that they were coming you should have y'all on the y'all committee chance y'all should have called every last Committee Member and said they are not allowing them to come testify. I got constituent day today. I could be in my War but I'm here because I want these black men and women to know you got black electors that that support y'all despite what's being said. I'm here. I'm always here. I'm always taking the bullet. And where are y'all at doing? Absolutely nothing. I don't care what administration being here don't act like it was just Lori and Brandon it was wrong ass, too. It was daily, too. It it's been happening. What you say how long uh, Anthony Bill how long has been happening? Absolutely, so we gonna keep playing these games with people livelihoods and y'all wonder why young people out there knocking people outside. They damn head taking their cars why they stealing we forced their hand to it is disrespectful for y'all to call us down the meeting and Miss Blackmore Anastasia Walker and then that hold are not here when they when the ministration told, you know, you should have called us. It's called back up. That's why you got a committee members you committee chairs. It is this the saddest s*** ever and I'm because because they've been cussing all day. I'm just gonna add on to it. Y'all wonder why the public gets mad at us, but this is stupid. You should be more respectful than that, though. no, I'm not. I have a wait a minute. Hold on now. I'm a disrespect you cuz on your watch cuz on your watches when of this you're the person that was in charge of Public Safety in what did you do? Then? You're not going to disrespect. I'm not disrespecting you. How did I disrespect you? That's your problem. That's your problem. You feel like somebody disrespected you I'm I'm practicing freedom of speech. That's what I'm doing when they do it. I don't see you say nothing. So you you feel like you had to interrupt what I was saying. Everybody else say they want to say around here. But when all the woman Taylor said, it's a problem all the woman all the women tailor. What I'm saying is you need to be respectful enough not to not to use profanity in these Chambers what I said show me the rules that it say that cuz I why are you not the chair of Public Safety? entered into the city decree for the police department? Why are you not the chair? I digress know I was not. And if you if you knew your history you would know that. I was not I know that's a lot of me joining call now. Why you trying to be smart saying I'm disrespecting you now see. Come on, I'mma talk to him. I'mma talk to him. Saying you want a chair. Yes. You are. You are the you are the chairman and the last Administration when they got ready to decide you want tell me I'm wrong. Alderman Bernette damn it. So so I just asked uh got a message from the administration that they are currently in active negotiation with the Chicago Fire Department Union Local 2 as such it would be inappropriate for them to allow the Commissioners to discuss anything why they are negotiation. That's why they're not here. That's what the administration just sent me point of clarification want a clarification. Well, well, I'm I'm happy that uh, the the distinguished gentle gentleman from the 27 Wards off 50 to try to carry some more water. But let me just tell you this. Let me just tell you this you don't have to ask certain questions as it relates to the contract. We can ask pertinent questions as it relates to hiring and the other stuff there's no Conflict of asking pertinent questions on what's on the agenda? Asking questions as it relates to the contract. Yeah, maybe. But that's not a good excuse for them not to be here. All they have to say is I can't answer that question, but I can answer this question. So thank you Mr. Jim. Alderman Vasquez Thank you chairman. Uh I just want to add my voice to what our members here saying. I I get frustrated when administrations and it isn't just this 1 Tennessee say that oh people say we're not being transparent but we are being transparent. This is proof about not being transparent not allowing. The Commissioners here is a problem. Yeah, there are challenges we have to face. We need people here to answer questions. They're not going to be the best answers. But if we don't know what scenario we're actually in, how are we going to improve it? I can't blame the Commissioners because they're the employees and if the bosses are telling them not to show up. They're not exactly going to fight back out of fear of losing their jobs. However, ain't nobody in the fifth floor the boss of any city council member here. Our bosses are the people that elected us to each of these wards. So we can say you know, what if they're not showing up here. We're going to reschedule till they can. At Alderman Bealls point the fact that there's a Union contract is not an excuse to not have somebody come up here because they could easily say, you know what? I can't answer that because there's a labor dispute happening and they still have plenty of questions lined up from all the members here. This is a public safety matter. We got people aching for jobs out here. They're applying they're not even being told why they're not being accepted. So it's not only getting more people in cfd, which is a public safety matter. It's getting people who want to get jobs off of the streets necessarily to actually do things to help our city out. If there are impediments to that. We need to have real conversations about it. I understand that you all are trying to hold a hearing so this isn't towards anyone. However, if no 1's here to show up you can reschedule it. Everybody here gets mad as hell and we're late because we can't be here for Quorum. Now, we don't even have people no disrespect to people currently in the box, but we don't have the other Commissioners to talk about hiring. We have enough hiring problems as it is and so I just don't understand. Why this couldn't be rescheduled why couldn't it be communicated if it was something where our city council members could have been spoken to so we could say you know, what we need to have this hearing to hear it the fact that we don't is a huge problem. So yeah, I think actually members here should all work together to draft something too subpoena people so we don't have excuses when people can't show up. Thank you very much open the Vasquez and and I say this to anybody else, um, they keep bringing that point up. Um, it was my intent because they were not going to be here. Um, I didn't see the reason to go forward with this meeting. Um, however, um in speaking with the chief sponsor of this, um, And agreeing with him to go ahead and allow the meeting at his at his request. That's why we're here today. Um, I believe it was going to be unfruitful, uh to have a meeting when I was told that the parties were not going to be here. Um, and it may made no sense to bring all these folks down where we could not have, uh, the Commissioners and the director here to speak on behalf of the city. Um, but in in speaking with the chief sponsor of this message, um this measure he did ask me to move forward with it, and I'm going to respect his wishes and have the meeting Hold on. We have Alderman Nala after Alderman Vasquez Alderman the politano then Alderman spaz. Yeah, I just want to say thank you for the clarification with respect to the sponsor and makes perfect sense. If there's timing there, I I don't want to submerge any of our members who are trying to do the good work. I think for situations like this our Council needs to be in more conversation with each other so we can support each other to actually be in positions to get more stuff done. Um, I believe we all want to do the right thing here. So I think it's just about us figuring out ways to be more organized so we can talk amongst ourselves and make sure that if we're going to have a meeting it's something we can get the most of so that way our chief sponsors are able to move things forward. Uh, thank you very much 1 of the information Alderman bill. Opponent clarification, uh, Mr. Chairman. Um, I just wanted to correct this body. We already have subpoena power. Uh, we were just trying to codify through an ordinance. But this body already today has subpoena power is a cifi. Absolutely. Absolutely. Okay, you know the ordinance number, uh, I don't but if you could get that and let me know because we have done it through finance committee, uh some years back. Uh, so we don't have to uh, wait we already have that power today? We just have to execute it. Okay, I'll check with law as well. Thanks. Paula Tano followed by alderman Uh, thank you chairman. Uh, I just like to point out a couple quick. Quick Concepts here on behalf of your panel and and trying to do the right thing and I do believe you did ask them to come. Uh, and we're told that they can't and you did want to cancel the meeting. I do know that for sure but on that fact too, uh when it comes to uh, A commissioner testifying or speaking on behalf of or in front of a panel. Um, it it doesn't go against uh Collective baring agreement as long as we're not hitting on every point that is in Collective of our in agreements. So there's questions that can come up that we can ask and that could be answered here today and give clarification that don't fall under that Collective barring agreement discussion. And if it does they can stop at that point and say that is being negotiated now, we can't speak about it. So a lot of questions could be answered in here and we could have a commissioner in here and speak on behalf of of what we want what information we need here. Um, so it it it isn't Against the law or it is an illegal for them to come in front of us and answer what questions they can and to refrain from the ones they can't because of the the collective baring agreement. And on another note to my colleagues here. I especially Janette I agree with you 100% your anger your frustration. Um, and I think as as a body of aldermen here and voting rights and ones that we put people in the positions or we vote when it comes voting time. This is a topic that's near and dear to your heart. And if the administration is telling people not to come and talk on it we have that's when we come together as a council and decide when we're going to vote together as a council and not be so divided all the time when you're told to cast that vote all of us not just you, um Alderman, uh, when we're told to make those votes we need to stop and pull back and say how about this topic? We're not going to vote as a body or a hole until this topic is covered and solved so you're not going to get that automatic. Yes out of all of us when we know it. Probably shouldn't be a yes. It should be a no. So that's where we need to come together as a body and get through term get through issues like this together collectively. We don't work for the administration. We work for them and we work for our Wards I'm with you. And well, that's what I mean Mr. Blakemore. We work for the people. Um, so I'm I'm with you. I'm not against you chairman. I know what you guys are trying to do, but they can come up here and answer the questions they can answer and they can refrain from the ones they can't that fall under the CBA. Um, so we shouldn't fall for that in in general. You're an attorney, you know, there's ways that we can get them in here and answer the question that they need to answer and we can write down the ones that they can't. Um, so I I I think that's that's something we need to push. We need to push for another meeting. They should all be here. Thank you chair. Thank you. Chairman, Tim. Can you slide the chair for me so I could have a better View? No, so I could see here you go. Thank you. All right. Thank. Um, believe it or not. I actually agree with some people over here, but I don't agree with a lot of people too and I want to start with these are at will employees people. Okay? Yes, we can't demand them come in their boss tells them not to come. They'll lose their jobs. Okay, every time I call these 3 ladies every time never a problem. Give me to answer to the question. I just had about 6 people come up to me and ask me for some information. I literally got a quick answer for the young lady just made her day made her week, maybe going to make her life probably a life-changing job. So they're there call these people. They don't have a problem. Sandra Blakemore is awesome. Katie Doyle was awesome, but when it was when she She was acting commissioner. Um, uh Anastasia walked or anytime I call her for anything I get the information so we should not our anger should not be towards them and I don't want to be mad at the mayor either about this. I mean, I you know, I kind of understand his thing and and and you know, I kind of agree with my partner here and kind of not agree with them. There are questions that could be asked but I know what'll happen. We'll be beating the heck out of these people and pushing and pushing and asking questions. They can't answer and they're going to look like fools so we shouldn't do that until they get the okay to come here. So I'm just standing up for them because of how they've been towards me giving me information. Um, but the test was a joke everybody the test was an embarrassment and I'm not an apologist for her but mayor Lightfoot was Furious about this test. This was the worst test probably in the history of the city of Chicago. We're having a test you had honorable students in college fail on this test. I don't know Thorson High School, uh failing this test and I happen to know a kid that took the test is not a very smart kid a good kid, but not a very smart kid, and he passed it. I don't know how he Passed it, but he passed it. I'll tell you how not so smart. He is he got a really good number and then he failed to drug test because he was smoking pack. So um, so but I just want to give you some stats people. I I deal with facts. I don't deal with rumors and lies or Alderman letters, um, you know, we'll get to that but I want to give you Vice chair an opportunity to speak and then we'll get into um, we'll get more into the um, the Crux of Crux of our meeting today. Okay? All right. I thought we were talking now. So not yet. Not yet. Oh, I'm sorry. Okay. I'll call them in Curtis. Yeah, that was that was that was more than the point of information. Okay, give me we'll we'll get back to that though. Alderman Curtis, thank you chairman regarding if it's regarding because Alderman Robinson is going to open up if it's regarding is it a point of information or point of clarification? It's not a point of information. Go ahead. Okay. All right. Be before we start, you know, everybody knows when they get in the envelope in the in the elevator. You don't have to press 2 and 3. There's an option to press 5 and I recommend pressing 5 if you got something to say, um to the mayor about why these folks are not here and so, uh, you can press 2 to get to this floor 3 to get to your other offices, but you can also press 5. Um, let me think. Um Albert McCormack with the retired lieutenant for being here today come and lead a URLs a retired deputy chief. Uh, Deputy District Chief. Um, Ezra mcken who's joining us retired. Um, Captain is joining us by zoom and Quinn Curtis, uh Lieutenant with the Chicago fire department and 1 of the directors of the black fabricate if not the director. Of it. Um I do want to recognize, uh our chief sponsor as we said earlier. There's 1 item on the agenda on the subject matter here in only on the Chicago Fire Department's hiring plan and hiring practices. Um, Let me give the floor to the chief sponsor of this. Um this measure, um, Vice chair Lamont Robinson. Good morning. Let me first. thank chairman Rodriguez as well as chairman talifero. And their staff for allowing. This opportunity this morning. This is the first time in this chamber. We are allowing. the black firefighters an opportunity to share with us the city of Chicago. their issues and concerns also want to thank all of my colleagues that are here today. It's important that we give. this particular group space to be able to share their issues and concerns. on the record because they protect us 365 days a year. And out of respect for this group, I believe as a member of this body we have to do our jobs and protect them as they protect. the residents of the city of Chicago this hearing was initiated by the black firefighters and constituents that have come to me with issues and concerns. For the record, I want to share with this body. 3 different articles that have been written about issues and concerns and the fire department. the first article Is the EEOC says City discriminated against blacks? second article judge, rule City fire exam biased third article exam bias ruling may cause City 80 million in firefighter lawsuit. So ladies and gentlemen. Yes, we know we have a problem. But this is the first time we are allowing this group. The black firefighters and opportunity on the public record. to share their issues and concerns Yes, everybody already knows. But today we will be talking about appendix G. hiring practices recruitment economics exam transparency and lastly how we can finally write these wrongs. And so I want to thank the folks in the Box. To the right of me for taking their time out to be able. On the public record to be able to share these issues and concerns. We also have via Zoom. Mr. McCann Who? I would like to bring. on to explain what appendix G is Mr. McCann, are you there? Uh, we have a person named Ezra. I just promoted them. The chairman recognizes Mr. McCann Mr. McCann are you on Can you hear me now? We can hear you now. Um, you're recognized as Mr. McCann, uh who's a panelist? and retired fire fire captain First I like I'd like to make a correction. Uh, I did not retire as a DDC. um I was not 1 that uh would fit okay the description of who the city wanted to hold that type of position and those that need further explanation can talk to uh, my good buddy Nick who used to be 1 of my co-workers on the fire department. He can explain that to you. Um Ezra McCann, uh, I am a Marine Corps Vietnam veteran. Came home from the military. I wanted a job to took the test in 1973, but could not get hired until 1977 because of a lawsuit that made mayor Daly or mandaly hire a minorities on the fire department. And basically fast be forward it seemed like that's the only way we can get blacks still to this day hiring on the 30th Department. I did 30 years. I retired in 06 I got 18 years in retirement right now. Uh, I could be just far away from you all but I will not stop. Okay, uh doing whatever I can to make sure the black community include included in these great jobs in the city of Chicago we have to offer. Uh, I think that's enough background all them and if you have a question for me, I'm ready. Thank you. Um, thank you Mr. McCann. Vice chair cool and continue I would like to bring that. Okay, chairman recognizes, um, Mr. Quinn Curtis. Lieutenant Quinn Curtis Mr. Curtis What was the reason behind starting? the fire brigade There was 2 uh great reasons behind starting a black fire brigade. The first ones went is that when I came on the job in 1988, there were close to a thousand black firefighters as I began to exit this career this great job this wonderful career. We are down to 422 according to the Chicago Tribune foyer. Which gives us only 8% 8.9% of blacks under the Chicago Fire Department total? Um, the second reason is which is more than my heart. I've seen more kids shot and killed in my lifetime than anybody can imagine then the average guy in Vietnam. I've worked on babies with gunshots. I worked on these streets all my life born and raised in Cabrini Green. They became a point to say enough is enough. We do a lot of talking but these kids are dying. They're dying for 1 reason access to Opportunities. We have to provide opportunities for these kids in the community every time a fire truck pulls up in the black community. They can't see a black fireman. So if they can't see me, they can't believe me. They can't become me. My model became a life if we teach a kid to Save a Life they're going to be less likely to take 1. And since the concept of the black fire brigade we put over 755 kids through this program. 2056 single moms and 14 homeless kids We Are The Number 1 crime prevention program in the state of Illinois. hiring and employing and educating First Responders Thank you, Mr. Curtis. What is the main recruitment source for black and latinx First Responders? The main resource is our day-to-day operation the blackfyre brigades day-to-day operation going inside these communities and working and holding events Citywide and countywide. This is the main source that they get information on becoming firefighter paramedic EMT and police officers. Thank you. As a current member of the department. What is your What is your take of appendix G? Can you explain it as well as another reference, please? Appendix G came in effect 44 years ago. It was set up in design to make sure that there was equity in all communities and we have not done that appendix G is the Only thing in our Union contract that has never ever been enforced. There's a term they want to use is a goal. You could say a goal all day long. The bottom line is this we have violated every rule of appendix G. That's 1 of the reasons. We're here today. I need everybody in this room everybody on this panel to Upright appendix G and put it in full effect affected immediately. Thank you. Can you please give us a breakdown of how many students the blackfyre Brigade has recruited and how many has gone through the program and how many our current firefighters? Again, there's been over 755 kids through the program. There's about 80 in class right now. So they have not completed the program at this time, uh, which is going to increase our uh single moms. That's in that program. Also. Um, we probably on cfd right now, uh, this is a new exam so So we came existence in 2018. We probably have now posted 30 kids on cfd. As of today in this class that started yesterday May 1. We have 10 of our students that are currently in the cfd class. Thank you. Has there ever been an ask for the Chicago Fire Department to have a recruitment and retention team in collaboration with the fee the blackfyre Brigade? We have never had a true collaboration with the fire department with the Chicago Fire Department. We have always been 2 separate entities and we have never collectively worked together. Independents G. Which you referenced The department is required to actively advertised for recruits in communities primarily populated by black and latinx residents. Does that currently happen? To the best of my knowledge. No now when they do have recruitment is close to re is close to examination time, but is a daily base of recruitment. I don't think the Chicago fire department has a recruitment team if they do we we don't know anything about it. Thank you. Referencing appendix G again appendix G also states that the Chicago fire department will seek the aid of and cooperate with church and Community organizations in the black and latinx communities to fulfill those requirements. Is that currently happening again, that's based on the Chicago Fire Department. I do not answer for them. I can only answer for the things that the black fire brigade do and we currently do that. Can you please share the cost of participation for students in the blackfyre Brigade? It costs each student that comes to our program. Absolutely zero. They pay not 1 dime not even for their uniforms. We pay 100% of their education. You have had 7 755 students since June 2018 participating in the blackfyre Brigade program. Has cfd reached out to you to work to increase those numbers. as of this date cfd has not reached out to us with these numbers 1 of our major problems is is trying to build that bridge between BFB and cfd. A cfd express interest in how your organization supports your students during processing? Again cfd and BFB do not partner up. We have been trying to build that relationship for 6 years. Mr. Curtis has the fire department ever published a list of applicants who've passed exam like other large US cities. as a point of clarification, um in the past Chicago fire department has always put up a eligibility list. And to now to this day they don't put up the eligibility list. Nobody knows where they stand on the Chicago Fire Department list. DC if you take their exam your name is up there. You know, where you at La if you take their exam your name is up there, you know where you're at New York. If you take an exam your name is posted, you know exactly where you at. This is a sad day that shelonda has to come to an all demand to find out where she stands on a list that list should be posted. She should have been able to come up here like I did in 1988 and seeing my name on a list and know exactly where I stood what is what is why are we protecting these names? Every other major city post these names Chicago has always posted these names until now what happened today that we don't post these names. I'm confused, but maybe you guys can help me that we can get some transparency. because speaking of transparency what issues have you seen around transparency? You mentioned 1 of them are there other issues that you've seen around transparency? Yes, the lottery system. Everybody's been placed into a lottery system. What is the standard operation? How does it work? Who does Lottery system who witnesses this Lottery system. We're we're trusting in them that they're going to do the right thing. I'll give you 1 example. Everybody got uh a lottery number to take when they signed up for the exam. So there was 15,000 applicants that got a lottery number out of that 15,000. There was a dwindle down to 5,000. Out of the 5,000 it went to down to 2,000. So your your lottery number changed 3 times to this day. Nobody knows what that lottery number is. They only know the original number that they received but the 2023 approximately that passed the exam to this date still don't know their lottery number. Mr. Curtis, are there any barriers to entry in the blackfyre Brigade? Whether it be related to race. uh or sexual orientation, uh, whether it be related to any other barriers if anybody's interested in being a part of the black fire brigade. There's absolutely no barriers. Um, we've had Hispanics in our that come through our organization that came through imts we'd had whites that come through our our organization and being we're 1 of the top EMT programs in the state of Illinois. We have 1 of the most state-of-the-art, uh facilities at 54th in Walbash. There's been no barriers for anybody that came through this organization. If you even look on our website, you're going to see all nationalities not just blacks the name just happened to be the blackfyre big game. Thank you. In the December class, there were 85 people. 78 were males 6 were females and 1 non-binary. Out of the 78 males there were 17 blacks. 31 Caucasian males and 27 latinx males Why is there no equity in these numbers Mr. Curtis? And what are your suggestions on how to fix it? 1 of the problems I believe is with PSA and personnel. not city of Chicago Personnel Chicago Fire Department Personnel, uh the public safety administration They are not working together. To bridge this Gap. That's why no students know where they're at. That's why there was 15 students 15 black students scheduled to start. May 1st on 426 5 of the black fire brigade students got letters saying they have to take a pulmonary test. Well, everybody know you can't take a plumber onary test from the 26th to the 1st because you got to see your doctor. You got to schedule appointment and so they were all picked out of that class. Then they would have had it and our numbers were to increase. But let me say this. We don't have a problem with blacks on the list. They have a ton of them on the list. They've called close to a hundred of them and ranked order. according to them but we have yet to see all of this take place. There are so many variables in so many barriers that they can't get information. And so we need full transparency and somebody to assist these young people so that we don't keep going to funerals. Mr. Curtis our black man just not applying Oh. That is that is the furthest from the truth. If you look at the last exam, it was almost equal down the line. If you look at all the people that took it if you look at the blacks that took it if you look at the Hispanics and you look at the whites, it was almost equal down the line. Are there any barriers that you believe are preventing folks from applying? Again, the very that's all happening through. PSA and the fire department personnel are not getting information out to students and when students give them information students have had to go back 5 times and get them the same paper twice because they don't timestamp anything and if you got to drop a piece of paper off at 35th Street, you are not allowed to come upstairs. Thank you. I would like to recognize this girls. Cheer recognize me. Um, Karma leader Earl Deputy District chief Miss urls how many times have the city of Chicago been sued and won by black firefighters and why? Ottoman there has been multiple, um lawsuits. Class section of the most notable was the Lewis, um, and they won. resulted in a multi-million dollar payoff from the city as well as 111 jobs technically speaking. There's also been a lawsuit up just women the Godfrey women and uh, a lot of them, um are on the job. I believe it was 27 jobs were garnered from that and multiple current lawsuits going on as well as personal lawsuits. from the Chicago Fire Department's um discriminatory practices Mr. Else did you share a number? What's the do we do we have a number that you can share on how many times I have not been given an accurate number because they do not uh comment on lawsuits, but I can tell you it's in the double digits double digit number. Thank you. How many times have you personally sued? And why? I saw the Chicago Fire Department 1 time and um considering a second. The reason I did so is because I contacted my elected officials. I'm born and raised Westside a 31 year Revenue veteran with the Chicago Fire Department who was forcibly retired in 20121 after going to my public officials and getting no resolve after going to uh, the internal affairs Division and getting no resolve going to my supervisors and getting no resolve going to the office of Inspector General. You can pull all this up it's documented and getting no resolve. So the only thing to do people follow their money when you make them pay then certain things change as uh, brother Bob Bannon stated the center and uh and mandates come from court cases. We just cannot do the humanitarian thing and do the right thing and that's unfortunate. So that being stated that's why I sued and um, that's why a lot of people are suing because we just cannot rely upon people carrying out their fiduciary duty And we need to change that. Thank you, uh chairman. I would like to recognize Mr. McCormack. Yes Alderman, I'm sorry. What was that again? I would like to recognize Mr. Recognized Mr. Uh retired lieutenant Albert McCormack. Thank you. Um Alderman Robinson Mr. McCormick What has been the economic impact on the black community by not adhering to appendix G? Well appendix G. Um was a way to guarantee that the black community would get the jobs that it does not get from the Chicago fire department and it has not gotten since 1833. uh, the Chicago fire department is approximately 5,000 employees and right now They have about 20 women. This is the year 2024. women had single females head half of the households in the black community. This is a problem. All right. um 422 firemen there are 20 black wards. That means that there are about 21 fire per Ward. So let's look at where the Chicago Fire Department's funding comes from. It comes from the General Revenue poll. Okay, which is comprised of taxes. Revenue raising Etc. And it is created for the benefit of all citizens not just a certain segment of citizens and from that then the Chicago Fire Department's budget approximately 600 million dollars 6700 million is appropriated every year. so the problem is that the fire department is calcified in its position. They just will not hire women and they will not hire blacks. So let's look at that again. Let's go back to 21 firemen per Ward. That means that the Chicago fire department is subsidizing. And what we're talking about at the point of higher. Yes, once you get your good job, you might move out of that neighborhood to another neighborhood. But at your point of higher in the 21st, okay, that's about 2 million dollars a year out of 600 million that is waking its way back to the origin Ward where you hire were hired from so that's about 160 dollars a month, right? Okay warts. And neighborhoods are businesses. They are economies within themselves. Okay. And so you have business strips, then you have housing. Anybody in here have vacant houses on their block? Raise your hand. Do you have vacant housing on your block? Okay at the last 2020 census? Chicago was uh determined to have a surplus of housing about 10% vacancy. Guess where that vacancy is. The majority of that vacancy is it's in the black worlds Wards. It's in the 20 black wards. So if appendix G were enforced for the last 44 years, that means each Ward would have been subsidized by 4 times. As much capital from the 600 million, uh fire department budget. Or to the tune of 8 million dollars a year or 640,000 a month. All right, but that's not the case. They didn't do that. so now if you extract that money, all right, that means there's 30 Wards left. All right. and 30 Wards remaining received about 14 million dollars a year out of the 600 million dollars and that's why they don't have any vacancies. Do you see the difference there? The other 30 Wards are getting 10 times the amount of capital subsidy from the fire department budget. This is why you have problems in the bad Community you have unemployment and the fire department is directly contributing to that by not. Enforcing appendix G appendix G is a part of the contract that is. Agreed to by 2 s entities the city of Chicago on 1 side and the Union on the other and then they presented to the public that they were going to hire 30% black. They have not done it at all. period um so this is why we have vacancy. This is why our business strips are not plentiful and full of the stores that once were you have to properly nourish. You have to properly nourish the economy in each neighborhood. Thank you Mr. McCormack in your experience. Is there a disparity in the attrition rate of the Chicago Fire Department? in order to stand black employment in the Chicago Fire Department The higher rate must exceed the attrition rate. It cannot Trail it. Okay, so when I was in the firehouse, okay in 1998 when I exited There were about 600 firemen. Black and today there are 422. There are 422. Only because of the fight we took up in 95 to get 111 of those 422 higher, but guess what? Those 111 are at the point of a short career and getting ready to exit. So what happens to your 422? Your 422 will be 255mm overnight. Okay, and this is long-term systemic racism. You will not hire Chicago Fire Department will not hire calcified doesn't matter whether the justice department is a on them doesn't matter whether they're holding Court. They are not hiring black people the attrition rate. The higher rate must exceed the attrition rate. In order to stand black employment this class in December. It shows 20% if we take every class preceding and I have stood across the street from the academy just to stand there and count in hopes that this class is going to show me 30% There is normally about 13 out of 100. I I I have writings where I documented. Uh, I think it was the glass class of July 2021 77 candidates 8 black males 2 Black 2 2 females Okay. It it we're it's 75 to 80% what male? Which is 16% of the city. Thank you. This question is uh for all of our our panelists today How has working as a black firefighter in Chicago impacted you and your family directly? Currently the URLs. I'll start. Born and Raised on the west side not necessarily seen in African-American firefighter come off that beautiful red truck. In 1985. Thank God for the late mayor home Washington who wanted to integrate the fire department. I took the exam. I took the exam in 1985. I was um hired in 1990 started at 275. Ended making um, that being said a very good salary a very good salary you can look it up for yourself. But however, um, it impacted my family because number 1 the females in my family realized that they can only do what they put their mind to the only limitation they had is in their minds and as a woman a woman have been taught that the only thing she needs to use is what's between her ears to succeed. So the fire department taught me some things that um has actually I didn't know about myself. I've garnered some sisters and brothers from other mothers. of various nationalities and the interesting part about it is this job has pushed me to a limit that my sex is irrelevant. The only thing that I needed was the opportunity. And that's what the city gave in 1990 an opportunity to cross the threshold into the unknown not multi-generational like the Hues, uh good for you Jerry. Um, my father was not my grandfather was not my great-grandfather was not but common leader URLs because she was there was a lot of things in the Chicago Fire Department that will never be the same given an opportunity to be your first African-American woman to run your fire academy your first Chief to run your O'Hare and Midway airports your first fire marshal in the state of Illinois. That's what opportunity gives and that's what opportunity will give these young people if you just open the door because they too They too will not just make history or history. They will make you proud. This is Chicago. Chicago were better than this I'll say this in close. I've been taught by some great leaders. start leaders the German man by the name of Walter. Steinley ended up being my fire father. Taught me 1 way to do things. And that's to be a servant leader. so to lead her ship is what we need here leadership. By anyone that has a position. leadership Do the right thing? Because I guarantee you if you give the opportunity we won't have to go past the 77 neighborhoods of Chicago and recruit outside the city. We have everything we need right here. Thank you for listening. Mr. McCormack, yes. Um I achieved the career rank of lieutenant in the fire department. And for me, um examinations were really not a challenge and that's all been. I've been fortunate in that regard all my life. But what I want to tell you is that without stable employment. I could not be here today. I could not come here and speak to you and look all of you squarely in the eye. And whatever your background is, wherever you come from. What I want you to know is that the fire department is learned behavior. And at this particular point I'm speaking to all of the alderman the city council and I'm addressing the mayor. There is no magic potion here. Okay. Um, this is learned behavior. we have a fire commissioner that came in as a woman black. At the time she came into the firehouse. Did anybody want to teach her nothing period okay, but she went through the ranks learned all the way up to every rank all the way up to fire commissioner. That is the same for my colleague sitting right here. Each of you can do this. All right, instead of us having examinations to find the greatest rocket scientists. What we need to do is identify the minimum skill necessary. To be a fireman. And that's all that is necessary. That's all I had. Is the minimum skill and then everything else somebody in the firehouse taught me? They took me in they gave me opportunity. That's what we need. That's what Quentin has done with the fire brigade. Whereas they said. No, you got to be this you got to come from this neighborhood. You got to notice all them and you got to notice person. You got to know that's not true Quinton has taken some people that were homeless. All right giving them the skill set. All right, and they're in the firehouse being productive we need Our 1500 jobs our Wards do not to be subsidized at 1 tenth. the fire department budget but equitably with all other Awards we need each of the 20 black Wards to Garner. 80 Fire Department jobs Then we will get rid of our vacant strips. Then we will have more children in school stabilizing the classroom environment because they have medical dental vision. They're single mother has a strong job. We need in 2024 to find a way out of 5,000 jobs. To hire more women. This is ridiculous. It is a shame. And God is watching. Absolutely. God is watching. So let's pull together. Let's pull together what the other 10 Hispanic Wards which represents a majority and create a home rule that there is no employment without Equitable employment. Not only in the fire department in the police department in the water department in every city capacity. Once that happens. You get rid of vacant business trips. You get rid of all this excess money and overtime that you're spending on violence and lawsuits and everything in essence. You're going to repurpose your budget. To a more value added position of opening up an equitable and fair. hiring policy that is compliant with Federal state County and Municipal law equal employment opportunity and that's why I'm here today. That's why I stopped my life to do this and stop my life to do this because we talk about this every day in the firehouse Lieutenant Captain Khan is here. We had this discussion 20 years ago. We're having the same Firehouse discussion today. Why? I implore you I asked. Tarnish situation around let us not be the tail for the rest of the world in the nation. Let us be the head. Let's show the way. Let's create the way. We need 26 alderman. To get the legislation on the floor. pass it and every Community then is parallel and equal. We need an equal employment hiring policy. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Curtis. the briefly the Chicago Fire Department job as elevated me to a whole another level and just tell a quick story. I remember being 12 years old and seeing my first black fireman get off a truck and at that point in my life. I knew what I wanted to become in life. I knew at that point because I seen somebody that looked like me. And now I knew that I could really be this because I saw I was affected as a child. The job allowed me to send my kids to school to become. Firefighter paramedic and police officers to this day. I have 2 Sons that serve on the Chicago Police Department. That's the kind of that's the kind of world that's job gives you it allows your kids to have opportunities exposure. Yes, because they're exposed to it. And that's what this means giving your family giving your kids an opportunity so that they can do some and be positive and have a positive impact and a positive role. Thank you. Mr. McCann, can you please share? How being a firefighter has impacted you directly and your family directly. Uh, yes, I I would love to do that. Um Because of this great job. Okay. Um, I was able to send 2 kids through college. Well, let us back up. First of all, I've always had a great place to live without worrying how to pay a mortgage. Uh, I've driven great cars. I took on a family. I got 2 young, uh adults right now. My daughter's a medical doctor. My son is in the media for uh, NBC Sports. um I mean, it just made a life of a difference. And there's something that I've always wanted to pass on okay to the rest of the black community. I am convinced that they had the opportunities that I have had. Okay, we will see a much much better day in the black community and what we see have been delivered now never had to steal a car because I was able to buy a car. Okay, never had to steal anything of that enough money never missed a meal, but I had enough money to buy meal for me and my family. Uh before you dismissed me. I would just like to give uh, the ottoman that in the chambers a little history on the appendix G. And um appendix G is a contract agreement that the city of Chicago and the Chicago firefighters Union Local too sign on to All the way back in 1981 44 years ago. This agreement which is still in the contract states that 30% of all hiring and promotions would be black. 44 years after this great agreement. The black community is still waiting for our fair share of these great jobs. The city has to offer. That provides great salaries great benefits. and a great pension after 30 years of service. Within These 44 years and we the black community have sued the city of Chicago to make them comply. Uh, we work in firefighters that file grievances with Local Number 2 for them to make the city to comply. Uh and honor appendix G neither the city of Chicago nor the firefighters Union. Have made appendix g a priority to hire black citizens until the Chicago Fire Department. Or properly promote blacks once they are employed by the Chicago Fire Department. the last 4 mayors Daily Emmanuel Lightfoot and now mayor Brandon Johnson have made no serious commitment to give the black community. their fast share of these great City of Chicago jobs In closing there are no poor. I repeat. There are no poor white communities in the state of Chicago when we look at these communities. We see where 75% of city jobs not just fire. We talking about police streets and Sands and everything else where these jobs are are are are delivered. 500 44 years We have been through 7 mayor. 3 Black uh 4 black fire commissioners We the black community have always sent 19 black all of them in the city hall and all of above admit that the black community have been underserved especially when it comes to employment. But we are here today still demanding jobs for the black community. So the question from us the black community as of this hearing will appendix G finally be taken serious and honored by the city of Chicago and supported by the Union Local Number 2. reminder They both the city of Chicago and the union agreed to appendage G 44 years ago. Um We the black community. Uh, what do we want? job I repeat. What do we want? We just want a job do we get jobs and we can compete and do anything to this city has to offer we can be just as successful as any other neighborhood in this city. If the city is Chicago who is the largest employer in the city of Chicago would just make an example. And put the black community to work. Indeed. We need to start somewhere and right now I don't see them starting trying to correct. The poor situation that we have dumped our black community into by neglecting them and jobs Education Health Care and everything else. So, uh, I'd like to end this by saying, uh, By saying that uh, I have to definitely agree with all of them and bills. And this is for not well, I won't say it's for naught but it would have been real good. We could have had the powers to be to be in this room today and I'm sort of disappointed that I took my time okay to help explain this but can't nobody really address these issues better than the folks that who are not in the rooms. And uh, that was a shame. Uh, Alderman Irving. Okay, definitely for sure, uh not often do we agree? But I have to agree with you also that um, you know, if you're going to waste our time any longer, okay, uh, it's going to fall on who you would all them in for. Sure. And definitely right now is definitely got to fall on the on the uh, the mayor the mayor's put 2 classes in the fire academy and nowhere near the 30% Have we received? I thank you for your time. And hopefully hopefully we can move forward and again, yes, it should be another meeting. We need all the people in the room to address them. Thank you, Mr. McCann. Thank you very much chairman. Chairman for my last 2 remaining questions. I would like to recognize Mr. Curtis. Um chair recognizes Mr. Curtis Mr. Curtis we in the city of Chicago have a fire department Community Advisory Board currently in place. There are 11 seats with 3 active appointees to your acknowledge. What is their role and how often are they meeting? To my knowledge. I think they only met 1 time since they've been in the fact and I reached out to every last person on there and they have not had a meeting yet. That is 1 of the things that we need to Upright effective immediately because if we have done that we wouldn't probably be sitting here today. What is their role? Can you share with this body their role is the oversight of cfd? So when you when there was a testing issues coming up the testing issues get addressed by that. They were supposed to be the board that ensured that appendix G was followed through. Last question for me, Mr. Curtis would be what would make the fire department more equitable? The first thing the fire department need is it meant it oversight from the Chicago fire department and PSA? Both departments need immediate oversight. We need a committee that looks at uh, uh candidates has been disqualified. You know, who's making those decision on this qualifications. We need to have an opportunity to look at that. We need pure transparency a student should be able to find out uh, where they sit a candidate should know exactly where they sit in the Chicago fire department and PSA or Chicago Fire Department should be able to give them that information instantly. Mr. Curtis, thank you very much. Let me also thank you, uh for the work that you are doing with the flat the the black fire brigade you certainly should be commended. for your time and dedication to the city of Chicago and allowing folks to have the opportunity, uh to be in the Chicago Fire Department. So thank you very very much, sir. I I also want to thank you, uh for standing up and being uh 1 of the all of them. Is that stood for and I'd like to thank uh Janette Taylor. I'd like to thank uh, All the men Curtis and I like to thank all the ultimates here who helped us, uh create a form today that we can all be here and at least start addressing these issues. And the last thing I would like to say is what is our next steps and how do we follow up from this? So I'm really interested in the next steps and something that's going to happen immediately because everything that we talked about is already contractual we don't even have to go to court with this. This is this is written in our contract today. next slide to the panelists and um The chair recognizes for purposes of presence today Alderman. Um, Byron Lopez, um chair recognizes chairperson Rodriguez Uh, thank you. Thank you Mr. Chair. Uh, I'd like to uh continue on the line of thanks. First of all, uh Alderman Vice chair Robinson, uh, your legislative experience in Springfield is showing here in city council my good friend. This is an excellent effort. I'm happy to be with you and stand with you on this most worthwhile of efforts. Um, the tenant Curtis. I I want to say Uh, thank you for the inclusivity of the blackfyre the Brigade. I've spoken most recently to the number of Hispanic, uh firefighters who count the Brigade as an ally and um the inclusive way in which you approach your work I think is the right way to do things. Uh, so I commend you very much on those efforts and to the rest of the panelists. Thank you so much, uh for being here. Um, I do have a question regarding the outbreak decree, um, which I thank you, um to uh, Mr. McCann for explaining the origination of appendix G. Um, my understanding is in 2022 a federal judge abolished, uh that decree which included appendix G and correct me if I'm wrong and please make me understand because I do want to join you Mr. McCannon next steps and figuring out how we resolve this issue. Is that the case has that Appendix G been been been abolished. Is it still part of the contract? Please? Help us understand that as a council appendix G is still a part of the contract. That's a contract between Local 2 and the city of Chicago. So that stands as it is right. Now today The Descent decree was dismissed based on inaccurate numbers that was presented to them. Very good and then you where does where does appendix G stand now? So you're saying it's still part of the agreement between the city of Chicago and the labor union, right Local 2 in the city of Chicago that stands right. Now today as we sit here and speak appendix G is still in effect in the contract and appendix G for clarity requires 405% or or mandates 45% hiring, uh to achieve forgive me in hiring to achieve that 45% of minorities 30% black 15% Hispanic is my understanding what that reads I believe that's correct. Okay. Thank you. That's all sure. Thank you. Oron chairman Alderman spaz followed by Alderman Curtis Okay, well buckle up because I'm gonna take a lot of time. I'm gonna be a Ray Lopez here. So Ray I love you. I don't take it personal. Okay, so you got some good information, but you sure they get a lot of misinformation. So so I'm just going to correct some stuff and give you some facts. I'm not going to give you. Misinformation but it's facts. So you guys could check it. I don't know who would be checking it. But I guess it's up to the 2 chair up there to be checking this. So I'm gonna I'm just gonna start because I got a lot of stuff here. So I'm just gonna start. Um, I'm gonna start with the 2 classes that are in right now. I'll give you the December class. You have 85 candidates 58% of them are my minorities. So let me I should start with appendix G. So appendix G is just the goal. It's not a contractual thing. It's a goal to achieve. I believe it was 45% So I'm not I shouldn't I shouldn't use the number but I believe it's achieved 45% minority hiring. So so this is just these 2 classes. This isn't the job. This is these 2 classes the December class, which has only 85 candidates in there or started with 85 was 58% uh, Black and Hispanic the make class has 64% Black and Hispanic, which is 118 in that class. So I'm not I'm not gonna I'm not gonna I'm not gonna excuse me, excuse me, and guys. Mr. Bay Miss Mr. Bay. Yeah, do you mind do you mind and altemus pisado? Please don't respond. Um Mr. Bay if we can just be respectful and allow altemus pisado go ahead and finish. Thank you my understanding as we're talking about Black and Hispanic so and that's what the appendix is. All right, I'm giving facts. Once again. I'm giving facts people, okay. Here's another fact. Here is a sergeant and arms here chairman Mr. B. I'm asking you to please please don't disrupt disrupt. Um any of the speakers on the floor? Alderman pisado. Okay, let's try it again. Okay. So I'm gonna give kudos to my 1 friend here. I have many of friends. I don't know maybe not after this I won't but uh because all of this about what's been going on. I've had 1 1 just 1 of my like well, I can't account you a little bit Chris. So um, but we're we're good buddies so I don't really count you but it's Derek Curtis Derek. Sorry you singing you out. Um, I saw you learn at that press conference or that meeting which I'm glad you learned but you're the 1 guy that's out. The time has asked me questions and what's going on and how to figure out what to do and where stuff is so hats off to you on that 1 What what what is 1 of the questions? What should be the main source of hiring? I feel it should be the alderman most of us have pretty extensive email lists to get the word out there to our people. Um, so I think that we should be the ones and we should be putting the job out there many of my colleagues. I follow a lot of my colleagues Emails black white and Hispanic and there's a lot of people on this job meaning all their men did not promote the recent fire exam. So the sign up for the exam. Um, I promoted it. I know some people did and this isn't the only place to get to get a job as a fireman people. So let me tell you so since January 1 since January 1, here's what I put in my email blast January 4th. These are jobs that fire department January 4th, Edison, January 4th killing Med City, January 11th, Handover Park, January 11th Creek Township, January 11th, Bartlett, January 11, uh, Chicago Ridge, January 18th lions January well, January 21st, we always promote the cpfta which anybody has any kids. It's a great program. It used to be if you took their class and Q would agree with me on that your guaranteed to get to jab. Now, all of a sudden these kids are failing it and they're not, you know, getting good numbers and they're not getting it. So, um, Back, hopefully that changes again. She februari 1st North Palos. Februari 1st, Hinsdale. Februari 1st, Warrenville. Februari 8th, Oak Brook Terrace. Februari 15th, Chicago Heights. Februari 15th, Aurora. Februari 22nd Lake in the Hills. Februari 29th, Norwood Park februari 29th, Bowling Brook. March 28 Bensenville, March 4th, Sauk Village, March 4th W Keegan, March 4th. Tri-State, March 18th, Elgen. March 25th, Marinette Park, March 25th elep March 25th, Lombard, februari 2nd West Chicago februari 2nd North Lake and februari 2nd, Arlington Heights. So there's a whole load of Jabs Fire Department jobs out there people. So I'd say check things out. It doesn't just have to be Chicago. There's many of opportunities, uh, once again, um, I don't know recently I heard at at press conference that that black kids don't want to be police officers for for years. I've been hearing we don't have enough blacks as police officers. Uh, and then I hear that they don't really want to be it now. I just heard today they do it. They want to be firefighters. So there's some good opportunities. We do have we do have 2 recruiters though. Okay, we do have 2 Recruiters on the job and they're both black recruiters for the fire department. So the commissioner has 2 recruiters, uh, and they're both black. Uh, um, I don't know why we're not talking about this because at the press conference, I heard some some of the worst things I ever heard and I and I know I have some black firefighter friends here and that were very well respected and and good firefighters. I don't know all of you that were on the job, but I don't know why I know why we didn't address the standing down. I don't know why we did not address the fact that At that meeting it was said or a meeting was said that white fire firefighters go to black neighborhoods and stand there to watch the neighborhood burned down. That is that is such a lie people and any of my friends are here that are on the job or even any of my enemies are on the job here notice. That's not true. So and the way the way you get to a firehouse people, so just to let you 2 know up there or you 3 that you get the firehouse by seniority. That's how it works. Anybody could go anywhere basically and especially nowadays. I hear oan is 5 6 years on the job for a fireman. for a fireman. I don't know how long for a chief or a lieutenant or a captain so anybody could go anywhere if somebody's not happy somewhere. They they go there for a year. They could leave they could go someplace else. Based off of seniority okay to maybe not get the ideal house they want but it's all based off of seniority. And the lottery the lottery number is only changed once they did not change twice for everybody. You got 1 number and they changed it with the preferences. Uh Uh, I have 3 friends that pale the pulmonary test. Also, I think that's a problem. I agree with whoever said that this is a big issue. I don't know how these kids are failing this I know kids that are athletes, um, that needs to be looked into I don't know what's going on with that. So, um, Also just the to debunk something else was said we don't have 400 blacks on the job. We have 683. Uh, we don't have 20 women on the job. We have 467. Uh, Um, and and the guy I'm the guy that fought for 85% um City preference. That's a big thing. We never had City preference and it absolutely killed me that we're giving our jobs to kids from and I'm just making this up, you know, Indiana, Wisconsin Naperville, uh, you know, uh will met or whatever. So the these jobs should be for Chicago kids as far as I'm concerned. Um, I had a friend of mine who's on the job just so happens to be black. He called me. He said he was at that meeting or press conference whatever it was and he said he had some issues and that's why he supported it and he told me about a friend of his 1 of the guys 1 of the so-called 500 that took the drug test that failed it. Well I said give me his number. I'm not going to mention his name. Give me give me his number. I'll reach out to him. Well, it was a mix-up the kid never failed the drug test, but I'll take it the kid was Never got a chance to take the test. His number was 111000 something therefore. He wasn't 1 of the people that got to take the test. So uh, and once again, like I said before there wasn't 500 people that got a letter saying they failed the drug test. It was uh, 96 people, uh, 43 of them were white, uh, 34 were Hispanic and 18 or 19 were black, Uh, the majority of those kids, uh, ended up getting the jobs. Some of them got it before this may class. Some of them are in the May class and there's a few of them that will be in the December class. So, uh, no no 500 people got a letter saying they failed the drug test when I Taken it. I hate to mention her name because it sounds like my colleagues are after her but Anastasia Walker owned up to it. She had a meeting here. She said it was a Monumental mistake. Consequences for the people that did it they got it right said it'll never happen again. So that was a huge mistake that was talked about and was corrected. Uh, so I guess that won't be talking as long as I thought I well because now I just want to talk. I just want to talk about this current past and sign up. Once again, it was a terrible test mayor Lightfoot was Furious about it. So I don't know how you can have a test that 50% of the people fail and I'm sure everybody in here knows a smart kid on a real soon in high school college or just a plain old smart kid that failed this test. I know a bunch of smart kids that failed I even know a kid, that's really not smart at all. They passed it. So, I don't know how they made up this test, but it was a terrible test. 15,000 2 200 signed up to take this test. 4,991 were white, which is 32.7 4,928 were Hispanic, which is 32.3 3,952 were black which is 25.9 1,329 were others which is 9% So not quite a third a third a third but if if you take a take a a percent or 2 away from the white and Hispanic and give it to the blacks. We we pretty much be a third of the people signing up. So but once again I say that's on us meaning the alderman. The word out there to get people to take this test. Unfortunately, the big screw-up was I don't say it was a screw-up because people weren't going to get hired. So there's no sense of giving them false. Hope only 5,433 were invited to take the test. 2034 were Hispanic, which was 37% 1798 were white, which is 33% 1118 were black, which is 26% the sad thing people is the really sad thing is there was like 900 know shows. Okay 311 were Hispanic, which was 15% 269 were white which is 15% and 297, which is 26 and a half percent were black that never showed up to take the test when they 1 hit the lottery to be able to take the test to get this job. So then the pass numbers I'll give you all the pass numbers only 2,238 passed it 869 were Hispanic, which is 38% 765 which is 34% were white. 393 were black which is only 17% and 2111 or others. I don't know what others means if they're Asians or mixed race or whatever was 11% So that's where we stand on that. I mean, um, I'll be sticking around if anybody has any questions for me. Unfortunately, I agree with you about the silliness about getting a number and people don't know what the real number is. I believe everything should be on a uh, And a computer you can look and see your name and see what your new number is. I'm believing that some kids now are getting called and maybe moved because they thought they never had a chance because their real number to young lady had talked to her. Her number was 6000 something and it's really 8 or 80014. So somebody like her might have moved and said well, I don't have a chance. Now. I'm going to move then they move and get settled in somewhere only to find out they get called for the fire department. It's too late to uproot your family or whatever. So, uh, there does need to be better communication. I am not remotely not remotely blaming the HR Director. She's new. Uh, the person that was these acting those 2, you couldn't ask her 2 people. My colleagues couldn't ask for better people to give me more information more Communications. So that is on you. You you you you meaning us that's on us find out if there's something wrong to reach out to either. Sandra Blakemore, Anastasia Walker and that really doesn't have anything to do with hiring people. So you all shouldn't be mad at her. She's just the commissioner. Okay, and what what did she do she put a team out there to to recruit so I think we all know where to recruit and they're not recruiting in my neighborhood. I can guarantee you that so uh with that. Um, like I say anybody here want to stick around want me to find anything out for you. I'm more than willing willing. I got about 5 6 people come up to me already. I'm waiting on the not I'm Thank you, Alderman Curtis. Thank you, uh chairman. Uh, actually I'm I'm I just decided I'm not going to speak on this issue. Uh right now, uh, what I am going to do is thank everyone. For coming out, uh this morning. I want to thank uh our leaders, uh that put this together an Taylor and Robinson. uh I uh, you know as everyone basically in the back probably know that I've been with uh uh, the black fabricates since his existence in 2018, and and I I believed in the program because I saw it. I saw the program I see that at work. um I I really think that we should activate. activate tomorrow as soon as tomorrow our subpoena power and get those 3 Commissioners in this room to answer those questions. Uh, I do want to say um that my colleague Nick spazo who I always reach out to for this. He shouldn't have been the 1 to give these. Uh statistics it should have been 1 of those 3. And it was wrong that they're not here, but I also agree with uh Altima Taylor. When it comes budget time. That's when we should act on this because they should not tell us what to do. We should be telling them what to do. I also would like uh, and it was so ironic. I do want to take this opportunity, uh, and again of all of the candidates, uh, that went through the black fire brigade at zero cost at zero cost. I want you to know that I'm always raising money help raising money. And also, uh, when I go to the events I make sure I pay because I want to pay my fair share. Also, I made sure that any city worker in the city of Chicago. with our contribution, er, uh area you will now be able to contribute to the black fabricade because again, uh, it shows that they're doing an awesome job. Just like 1 of the uh, people that came through the program. She saved the life of a baby. Back, uh with 2 summers ago. Coming right out of uh, the black fabricade program. She saved the baby right on Chicago's Lakefront. Uh is awesome. And again, I bought into this program because I believe in it and I also want to recognize this. So ironic that my colleague to my right is here and I would like her to stand so everyone back here to see because the last time that we had the black fabricade in the Box, I think it was um a couple months ago for Black History Month when they gave their testimony she turned around and I want you to turn around to them she wrote. She wrote a cheque 2 minutes later to the black fiber Brigade to help pay for you guys. She did not send any questions, and I want to thank you so much. I wanted everybody to recognize the support that you have. Thank you. Thank you, Alderman Curtis. Alderwoman T. I'm sorry Alderman. Jansy B the woman tailor. Uh again, I want to join the chorus of thanks for you know, all the retired and current firefighters, uh, black firefighters who are making this issue. Uh, The putting on the Forefront making sure we don't forget about it. I had a labor question with respect to appendix G has there been any board charges filed against Chicago Fire Department with the Illinois, uh, labor board or any or nlrb to sort of push this issue add more pressure to it. I think uh Shelton's still here. any other panelists answer the question because we oh, I'm sorry, uh, you can't reach out into the um, okay and then it the panelists answer the answer is yes, and and Chelten, uh filed that grievance. Thank you. That's it. Alderwoman Taylor followed by Did Alderman see Joe Lopez leave? alderwoman Taylor so all due respect to Alder Miss pisado, but it's funny how you got the information and I've asked for for The Last 5 Years through public comments. I didn't send an email. I didn't have a side conversation. I didn't have the relationship, but I've asked every public budget meeting for those same numbers and got an answer. So if at the press conference that We had my information is correct. It's because I wasn't informed. And the thought that anybody got a letter to say they failed a drug test that we didn't take and all hell didn't break loose says what y'all think about black people for real? Let's let's call this what it is. Let's not stop the problem with y'all is y'all love to cover people because you have the relationship and you could pick up the phone, you act like we picked up the phone to call to check on our people either. We haven't done the same thing. So it's funny how you can get the information and I can't. Cuz I'm not a firefighter was because I'm black you could choose. I won't choose for you. At the end of the day the thought that we have any of these issues when it comes to black people getting in a job that they are overqualified for is a problem. Is a real problem and so it's this whole thing of I I was called a liar. So I guess I'm they lying, huh? Cuz now they here to tell you. talk about the secret clubhouse that they got where they take the test at and people that look like you could actually go and we can't I'll wait. We ain't going to have that talk are we we ain't going to win. We ain't going to talk in honesty. Are we are we going to talk about the firefighter? They got fired because he went back in to save a firefighter a woman that y'all that thought. She was told to leave. We don't want to have that conversation. Do we we don't want her how the conversation about them saying you don't tear up houses up north but on the south and west side tear it down. No, are those my stories they're not I've never been a firefighter never wanted to be as a matter of fact when they have when we go to the fire house with them suits on I refuse I'm already fought not about to put that extra weight on me not interested. But we don't want to talk about all of the issues that are there and so it's great that you throw out those numbers. It wasn't 500. It should have been zero. It shouldn't have been done the thought that they are less women in the fire department that are black that get and we ain't want to talk about when we're talking about people taking the exam to move up. Half our people never even get to make it to battalion chief. They don't they don't get to be Lieutenant. They don't get to be where is that conversation? It it and it's the point of y'all trying to act like people lie. I was I was I was told our liar because none of this happened. I'm I'm the liar, though. Y'all love and I'mma say this to you and you probably not going to like what I say and it don't even matter. You got the complexion for the protection. So, of course you can get the information a lot better than I can and that's a problem. That's that ain't even nothing to clap for its problematic as hell. I'm asking the state to walk. You are absolutely right. She stood right here and took accountability and what happened? Absolutely nothing and then you you threw out the numbers of black people who didn't show up because you send the emails to the spam. It take you so long to call people they change numbers because of course they broke and can't afford it and got to get a change number. Y'all y'all blame it on everybody but who the problem is? Everybody but who the problem is? We have a problem in the city of Chicago when it comes to the higher and of black people period You right. We do got a black leadership and it said had a black community look but don't act like that ain't been happening before we got here. But now we have a responsibility because we have the information to do what's right what y'all going to do with it? Cuz I can't see y'all vote though to CPD nor to cfd and every year that I've asked y'all not to do it y'all continue to do it. Not only that the thought that y'all always talking about they out here rub and they out there stealing that man just said in the state of Illinois. They the biggest back violence prevention. Let's see how many numbers y'all throw to his organization. I'll wait. Thank you. Miss Lee for writing that check. Hey who else going to write a check? And he shouldn't have to Y'all are so problematic that you got a young lady who says she took the test and she didn't know what the lottery is but in 2 minutes you able to pick up the phone and find out. Cuz you are what's important to them not her you important to me sister, wherever you are those black men and women out there are important to me. Y'all gonna still do the circus Y'all Gonna still do the same thing that y'all been doing and the thought that they're in contract negotiation means what? The ask from this body was that we do that Equity officer. And we do that for our commission. How many days it's been? It's been 60 days. This ain't a new fight. at the end of the day Will you hold your vote? cuz I will will y'all keep allowing the same thing that happened and there are plenty of questions that I could ask chairman, but they can't answer because I want numbers tell me how many black women firefighter there are. Tell us how many actually got to be promoted how many people have that? What are that are African-American went to take the test and were promoted why is every class? It's less than less of us and Nick Badu took to answer 1 of your questions. They never email us and tell us when it's testing time. We find out about it after the fact Chicago public schools has a program. Where they're supposed supposed to promote being on the fire department asked me how many black schools have they been in? And 1 of the people who sit on the commissioner scene setting that seat over there in line and said you work with the black fire brigade Mr. Quinton. Do you work with them? No. Have they ever approached you Mr. Quinn about working with you know? Thank you. Thank you chairman. Thank all the women Taylor Allman Co Lopez all the Miss pado then we'll end with that. Oh, I'm sorry Alderman Gardner then alderman pisado. Alderman Gardner. All right. Thank you chairman. Um, thank you chairman Rodriguez and Alderman Robinson, uh for shedding light on the Chicago Fire Department's hiring and promotional practices. I also want to thank Chief URLs Lieutenant Curtis and Lieutenant McCann for your leadership and for your service to our city. Chief roles and Lieutenant Curtis were both instructors of mine when I was in the academy As A Firefighter in 2005. In 1995. I was 1 of the many lost souls in Chicago who didn't know what I was going to do for work at the time. I was working in construction. And a friend of mine mentioned that there was a fireman's test coming up. So I signed up for the test. Um Took the test. Um, but knowing is a first generation American that I didn't have a lot of the connections that a lot of other people had I didn't know the right people quote unquote and I definitely didn't have relationships with elected officials. Correct. I am white. Yes, if anybody didn't notice I am white. um There you go. So in 1995, I took I took the test. Um, but I I I was not qualified. Uh, my my score was in the 80 83 percentile and if you were considered under 90, you were not you were deemed unqualified. Thanks to a lawsuit that was filed by Reverend Jesse Jackson, which I mentioned when he was here just about a month ago. Um. that demanded people who scored over the score of 70 that they had the opportunity, uh to work on the Chicago fire department and lo and behold a white man, like myself as he just mentioned was given the opportunity. Thanks to those efforts. um so when I was hired in 2005 this person who was considered unqualified actually went through the academy. studied to be an EMT with with the uh assistance with the people that I just mentioned and actually won an award for being uh, the most fit, uh candidate in that class. Um, and with that with that, uh nomination or award, I was given the opportunity to serve on a very busy company and for those who know or those who've been in the fire department or police department. It is like a Badge of Courage to go to a busy company. And I was I had the opportunity to go to truck 26 coming out of the Chicago Fire to Academy. I could not be any more proud of the opportunity to serve on that company and work with the men and women on that company, which is in West Garfield Park. Um I served there for 13 years during that time. I took any promotional exam that I could possibly take. I took the Lieutenant's exam in 2009. And I took an engineer's exam. That was I believe in 2016 and I was actually promoted to engineer in 2018 before running. before running for Alderman in 2019 I passed the lieutenant exam Lieutenant's exam. and I was I was my name was next on the list. to be promoted and magically that list was torn down. It's a coincidence. It's a coincidence that I was 1 of The aldermen Who most readily voted against mayor lightfoot's agenda when she was the mayor of the city of Chicago as well. It's a coincidence total coincidence. The problem is is that when when they attempted or somebody attempted or however, it may be to stick it to me. He they also stick to stuck it to 60 other firefighter who who were waiting to get promoted. And anybody in this room who's a fireman? Knows how big and how long you got to wait? To be to be lieutenant. Right. Am I right or am I wrong? That is the hardest promotion to get in the fire department. Is that of going from a firefighter to a lieutenant? That is a huge step there? So 60 other individuals paid the price right for you know the list magically getting torn down. So they filed a lawsuit. And lo and behold after they filed the lawsuit the list that was torn down. Was magically brought back up. Isn't that amazing? It was never done before in the history of the fire department. Once they took down a promotional exam and they brought it back up after a lawsuit was filed. It's amazing. It's amazing and you know what they did. They called me to say hey, if you want to take that promotion now you can all you got to do is resign as an alderman. You you think this is this is not of a movie right like this. Don't really happen. No, but it happens. It happens. So the reason why I'm here and the reason why I'm speaking on this. Is because games are being played. And let me tell you and I'm gonna I'm gonna keep it real I got I gotta keep it real. I know I'm probably gonna get in trouble now, right? So it's not just it's not just happening to black people. It's not just happening to brown people. It's happening to as Mr. Blakemore just said to white people just like me too. There's games being played. So I I can go on and on this is just this is I'm just on the tip of this. I'm just getting started. So that's my story and that's what I've experienced. I will never be able to serve or gain the recognition of earning or something that I earned. I earned to be a lieutenant on the Chicago Fire Department. I I I I I can't do that now for whatever for coincidence reasons right total coincidence. So when I heard that Alderman Robinson was bringing this and and and wanted to talk about this. I hey, let's talk about it. Let's let's bring some let's shed some light on what's going on, but you actually have an Alderman. Here sitting in the city council. That was affected by the games that are being played. So I just want to bring some truth and and and some real stories about what's going on. And that's 1 of I don't know hundreds maybe thousands of stories probably. I mean it just so happens that I'm a white guy though. This this this happened to me. I'm a white guy. I'm sure it's happening to other people as well. There's there's games being played but you know, so I'm all for it. Let's shedding some light on what's going on. Let's get some transparency as Lieutenant Curtis mentioned. Let's let's shed some light on what's going on because as as I said earlier, I was once deemed unqualified. I was unqualified to serve on the fire department. But you give me the opportunity you give me the opportunity you open that door for for me to serve. And what happens I go through there. I'm I'm gong busting I'm I'm whatever you want me to do. You want me swing in next? You want me to carry hose? Will you want me to run some stairs that I all a sudden? I graduate on the very top of the class. This this person who was once deemed unqualified now. I'm on the very top of my class. So again, this is not the story of me. I'm saying if it's happening to me, it's happening to other people as well. So thank you for your time. And and thank you all of you for uh being a part of this conversation. Thank you. So I too, um couple things I had never took a test on the job. So I never deserved to get promoted. I don't know I just felt. I don't know. I just didn't want to study. Maybe I wasn't for me. I'm not sure why I never did it, but I never did so. Like I can't say I ever got screwed but there was there was a lack of communication when I signed up and took the test. Um my number and I'll never forget it. It's 20049. Of course anybody had a number of 20049 you didn't think he had a chance and uh, I had a cousin that was on the job and my brother came on the job a few years before me and then as I got to know what was going on with the numbers starting to get they're up to 500. They're up to 1,000 up to 1500. Then I thought I actually had a chance and lo and behold I got called 8 years later to just life-changing job. Um, I had a great job before it but uh, this was obviously the best job I ever had in my life. There's nothing like a helping people out. So I loved it. Uh, most people do. I don't know many guys. I think I worked with 1 guy that hated this job and he retired after 10 years. Um, but you know, it is what it is. So, once again people it's not. Nothing to be put on a net hole. Nothing should be put on Sandra Blakemore that shouldn't be putting in that stage of Walker. I could assure you they all wanted to come here. That is her boss. Okay, you there? They're they're at will exempt employees. Okay, you defy your boss you're gone. Okay, so believe me. They all wanted to come you can't buy your butt. So I regularly call. I never asked them obvious. I'm a white guy too, but I never asked them what they are to 3 ladies, but I'm just assuming they're all 3 black women. So I don't know why they would say. Oh, we're we're only going to help you because you're white nick, you know and and and and you're black and brown colleagues. We're not going to help them. So, um so that third the help is there for anybody and um, once again 96 failed that drug test, uh with that mistake only 19 of them were black. I'm not sure how many of them got the job. Um, and so um, but I'd like to share a little experience. We had 1 time Chris if it's all right with you, is that okay with you? No, go ahead. All right. So Chris came to me and and a lot of my colleagues come to me and I'm I'm guessing this is because of firemen and I'm a self-proclaimed expert you know, so that's self-proclaimed. I'm not so nobody said I'm an expert other than myself about stuff like this. So Chris called me. Uh, this was after a white instructor called me, uh about a kid that was in the academy. He was a black kid. He lived on the west side. He actually didn't live too far away from where Mayor Johnson lives. And Chris said hey, this kid got bounced out of the Academy. I don't know what to do, you know, so I jumped in I helped him out. So Chris did the right thing. He said hey Nick. What can we do here? Can you help me? I don't know what to do about this. I don't know who to talk to. Um, so I had Chris just said Hey Hey kid. There's nothing I could do to help you or anything like that. The kitten wouldn't be on the job. So we were able to correct the the wrong that was done to him and the kids on the job still today. Um, I don't know I haven't talked to him in 4 years. I don't know if Chris ever talks to him. But once again life's about building communication those 3 women, um, obviously on that doesn't have any any say on, you know, she doesn't know what your number is or anything like that, but certainly, uh, certainly HR and PSA could help you out. They told me they may be mad because they're gonna maybe be floodgates gonna open for my colleagues calling them. But if you're worried about calling them ask me, I'll call them for you. Uh, hopefully the 3 people that asked me today I got some got some information for you today, and that's about it. But once again, um, you know, it's a lot a lot of Good people a lot of hard workers. But the thing that upset me the most the thing that upset me the most about those meetings is saying white guys go to Black communities only to watch the neighborhood burn down. Nothing. Nothing could be more false from the truth than that. There's not a black fireman back here. That would say that they've ever seen anybody stand out black white or Hispanic going to a fire if anybody got in trouble on this job. The thing they get in trouble for is racing too fast to the fire. Jim was the driver of a truck and he'll tell you he's a fast driver. it is people. He really probably dro. fire. I worked with many of you guys. I didn't we all would jump up out of bed. gear on Race to the fire. I worked on the west side for a few years Jim worked there for his whole career. So that doesn't happen people. So um, and that's about it. So, you know, I say, maybe we come back with them. I don't know I would hope that our colleagues wouldn't be beating them up, but sounds like that's what we want to do waiting for a budget, but I won't be 1 of them. So, but thank you. Thanks for the opportunity to speak. Uh, and I appreciate it. Thank you almond pisado there being no further hand raised. Uh, let me thank our panelists for uh being here this this, uh this afternoon, uh, Lieutenant McCormick Lieutenant Curtis, uh Chief URLs as well as participating in Zoom participating Zoom. Uh, Captain McCann. Also, let me think, um, the chief sponsor of this measure, uh, Vice chairman Robinson for your leadership as well. Uh, can I get a motion to adjourn so moved by alderman? spaz all of those in favor, I all of those opposed nay and opinion of the chair the eyes have it the meeting The Joint Committee of Workforce Development and police and fire is adjourned.