We ready guys? Great. Uh, where's she at? Oh, there you're, come on. Yeah. Just wanted to make sure, um, in case there's a question about, um, airlines. An, oh, sorry, Andrew gave me this to say, but tell me if you're okay with about airlines. All right. The Committee on Workforce Development will now come to order today. We have two agenda items. First, the approval of the September 20th meetings, rule 45 report, and second in ordinance oh 2 0 2 3 dash 0 0 2 9 8 0. Amending the City of Chicago Municipal code concerning mandatory sick time and paid leave for employees in the city of Chicago. Before we begin, I will conduct a roll call to establish Quorum. Alderman Yancy Alderman Yancy's, presence, alderman Hall. Alderman Beal. Alderman Beal's. Present, alderman Chico. Alderwoman Ramirez. Alderwoman Ramirez. Present Alderman Quinn. Here, alderman Quinn is present. Alder person. Gutierrez Alderman Coleman. Alderman Coleman is present. Alderman Curtis. Chair Rodriguez is present. Al Alderman Hall is present. Alderman Talley Farrell. Alderman Talley Farrell is present. Alderman Ramirez. Rosa Alderman sro. Alderman SRO is present. Alder person. Vasquez Alderwoman Clay had Alderman Chico here. Was he earlier? Okay. I'll recognize, uh, non committee members at this time. We have here non community members. Alder person Fuentes, alderman Cardona, alderman Conway, and Alderwoman. R uh, Rodriguez Sanchez. All right. We got Alderman Harris. We have Alderman O'Shea, we have Alderwoman Mana Haworth. Ah, with Clay, we have quorum. Thank you so much. Alder men. Dao is present. Alderman Moore is present. It's the glasses, not the eyes. Alderman. Kurt Curtis is present. Okay. We have 10 members. Uh, we have a quorum at this time. We will begin public comment. Um, the public comment period is 30 minutes out of respect for everyone's time. Each speaker will be limited to three minutes. We will have, we will have, uh, uh, per the ruling of the chair, we will have five proponents and five prop, uh, opponents speak to the matter. Um, and we will go in alternating order. Right? Uh, the chair recognizes Alderman Beal, Iman. Um, thank you. Um, it is my understanding that the 30 minute, um, public comment only addresses to city council meetings. And that if you have numerous people that have signed up, we are obligated to hear everyone that has signed up for public comment. And there's no time period associated with that. I also talked to law about that. I think it would be wrong to, to cut people off today. This's a very important topic. This is in city council, and I don't know how many people sign up. May only be three people, but I don't know why we would cut anybody off today. So Guys, I, I think it's been common practice city council that we have 10 speakers, we limit to 30 minutes, um, for the good of, uh, the committee. We have asked each of the proponent side and opponent side to, um, uh, to have five individuals each. Um, I think I'm gonna keep it to that In your, in at the last meeting, you that whatever past, you've talked about how great democracy was and everything, and I think this would lack democracy, not letting, I don't know if some people came a long way and I don't, I don't care. I don't care if there's 20 people for it and one against it. I just think everybody should be able to speak. That's just my 2 cents, but you're the chairman, so, um, I dunno if we got law around to give us an interpretation on that. But I, I think it, to me, it'll be important that everybody speaks and I don't care if it's lopsided or not. So I'll say two things to that. One is, we did have written comments that were sent to the committee, um, and it should be in your packet. And since you asked for, uh, law to opine on the matter, I did hear you ask that. Uh, I think Ray Phillips, Santos, um, from law, do you wanna opine on the matter? And then my question would also be, Ray, do we have to be consistent moving forward? Do all the committee chairs have to allow 30 minutes then, or, or would it still be up to discretion of the shares? Or can we one meeting 30 minutes, another meeting, 10 minutes, another meeting an hour. So that's a multitude of questions. Good morning everyone. Uh, Ray Phillips, Santos, on behalf of the city, Chicago's department of law, um, the rules that the city council made for itself, uh, result in the chair, having the discretion to, um, uh, to organize this. For example, if the chair wanted to do two minutes, uh, per person, he could, um, it, uh, it, it's quite flexible. Um, so that, uh, uh, and, uh, if you're curious, the rule is, uh, rule 58. Um, last paragraph says, the chair of the meeting has the authority and discretion, uh, to curtail or limit public comment if the commenter fails to comply with this rule, and, uh, to allow reasonable variances from the three minute time limit in appropriate non-discriminatory circumstances. Um, so for example, in this case, uh, uh, uh, depending on the circumstances, he could, he could vary it. So Would every, so this is for future for me 'cause I am a chair, so would every chair, can I change from meeting to meeting? Can I say one meeting is 30 minutes, another meeting is an hour, another meeting is 10 minutes. Yeah. The Department of Law would encourage you not to go below the 30 minutes. Okay. Um, beyond that we can, we can certainly speak offline. Okay. Thank you. Sure. Thank you Chairman Alderman. Be, Um, question for law, uh, is your ruling, uh, for the 30 minutes, is that directly affected to City Council Alderman Beal? Do you mean that the 30 minute threshold, the 30 minutes could Be longer Public comment? Is that directly, uh, reflecting on city council meeting and not committee? Uh, no. It, it, it applies to both. It can you show me that in, in the language, Um, any member of the general public may address orally any committee or, uh, meeting of the city council at any meeting required to be open to the public. That's shall open beginning of rule 58. And so let me just state that if we have a hundred people that have signed up for public comment, we are shutting out the voices of the people of this great city from having their voices heard for or against. And I think we're doing a disservice if we're going to cut this to 30 minutes, this is a hot topic that's gonna put people outta work. This is a hot topic that's gonna affect businesses throughout the city of Chicago, and we're gonna limit this to 30 minutes when we have probably 300 business people here that are worried about their existence. Something's wrong with that picture. Mr. Chairman, again, you all do what you want to do. I think we're doing a disservice to, to the people of City of Chicago by shutting their voices out. Thank you. We are actually including the, the, uh, voices of the public here and we are remaining consistent with the previous meeting. Um, any further questions on the matter? Um, alderman, Ramirez, Rosa, Mr. Chair, if you Or one of your staffers could just share for the record the email where individuals can submit, uh, written comment. Yeah. So, um, the written comment, John, email John here photo if you want, is that top agenda package, abuse Agenda. So somebody on workforce development at c@cityofchicago.org or John JOHN dot H-E-R-O-F f@cityofchicago.org. And the first one was Committee on Workforce development@cityofchicago.org. Thank you. Vice Chair Gutierrez, we'll begin public comments with Jennifer Aguilar. Good morning. Good morning. My name is Jennifer Aguilar and I serve as the executive director of the Little Village Chamber of Commerce. Bless you. I am here today to voice our collective concerns regarding the Chicago paid Leave ordinance and its potential detrimental impact on small businesses in our community. Our community was blindsided by the introduction of this ordinance. Upon learning about it, I promptly reached out and engaged with our small businesses along our 26th Street corridor. Their reaction was nothing short of frustration and dismay Upon understanding the potential blow this ordinance could inflict under small businesses. Recently we held a meeting with Alderman Rodriguez, during which our local businesses passionately expressed their concerns about this ordinance. They voiced their frustration citing the passage of the tip worker ordinance as the first blow. And now this is another significant challenge for them to handle. These businesses are in the process of recovery from the profound losses endured during the C Ovid 19 pandemic. The continual implementation of these ordinances only add to their challenges making it exceedingly difficult for them to get back on their feet. Most of our small businesses lack dedicated HR departments or staff that handle administrative task complying with such stringent requirements within a short implementation period, coupled with a threat of potential lawsuits due to the stringent private right of action could jeopardize their very survival. Many of these businesses already provide paid leave to their employees acknowledging the importance of fair and balanced agreements. However, components such as rollover days and payout are predicted to be devastating for them in Little Village. Our commercial corridor is the heart of our community. Should these businesses face closures, the effects will exceed beyond their storefronts. Jobs will be lost, vacancies will increase, and the funds available to maintain the beauty and vitality of our commercial corridor will decrease. This pivotal issue that demands serious consideration is being rushed and we asked for further consideration to be able to have more time. I urge the committee to take the time to thoroughly deliberate on this ordinance and consider the broad ramifications it may have on small businesses. Its impact stretches beyond business operations. It affects our entire community as a whole. Thank you for your attention and consideration. Thank you. Next up is Sarah Lab. Sarah. Hi, my name is Sarah Labadi. Um, and I'm here speaking on behalf of Women Employed. My colleague Sharmi Mdar is gonna speak on our behalf later. So I will just say I'm in support of the ordinance and thank you all for taking the time to listen to us today. Next up will be Michael Jacobson. Good morning. I am Michael Jacobson. I'm president and CEO of the Illinois Hotel and Lodging Association. I'm disappointed to even be standing here this morning. We were hopeful that we would've found a compromise by now. We were never fully opposed to this ordinance. We said from day one that we were ready to begin negotiations and that started months ago, but we were reto repeatedly told by the proponents that they wanted to wait. Once conversations began just three weeks ago, we came to the table wanting to find a reasonable compromise that worked for both workers and their employers. Unfortunately, it became overwhelmingly clear that labor and the proponents are not interested in finding a compromise and has rejected every single offer we have put forth, including our most recent offer to provide 10 days of paid leave without even including a pre-approval process by employers, which was one of their major demands as recently as last week. But suddenly it changed once we agreed to provide it most. This is now the most costly and burdensome paid leave requirements in the country as being proposed today. A few months ago, they praise the state law that was passed in Illinois, but now they say it's worthless. Is it truly about providing days to take care of you and your family's health? If so, we're in full agreement, but they have indicated that it's more about becoming a cash grab than about sick leave. The structure that they have created with different buckets, having different sets of complicated rules is extremely hard and comp to comprehend. And, oh, if, if it only takes we, uh, effect six weeks from now, and small businesses in particular are subject to lawsuits if they make one simple mistake in hotels, we're lucky enough to have HR departments to comprehend this. And we're even hearing from those HR and payroll firms that they will struggle to be in compliance by January 1st, let alone the small businesses that are subject to these lawsuits. We were told multiple times by alders in the mayor's office that they found our offers reasonable only to immediately be rejected once brought to the proponents. Just last week, one of our largest hotel employers announced they were selling their Chicago hotels and completely exiting the market because of the challenges of running a business. Here City council has a choice to make stand up for the small businesses in your community that are the lifeblood of Chicago's economy or capitulate to the activist groups who have refused to work in good faith and find a compromise that works for both sides. Thank you. The next speaker is Wendy P*****k. Good morning. My name is Wendy P*****k. I'm the director of the Women's Law and Policy Initiative at the Shriver Center on Poverty Law. The Shriver Center fights for economic, racial and gender justice, and that is why we support the paid leave ordinance. On behalf of the Shrier Center, I have been involved in city, county, and state efforts to protect worker rights for over 25 years. While I am proud of what we have accomplished in passing a state paid leave law earliest earlier this year, that law sets a floor not a ceiling. I am excited to advocate for policies that ensure Chicago improves upon state law and further demonstrates that Chicago cares about its workers. It's important that workers continue to have paid leave, paid sick leave, but it is also vital that all workers have access to paid leave that can be used for any reason. That is something that many workers in Chicago take for granted yet is denied to mainly, mostly low wage workers. These workers are forever struggling to find a work-life balance for themselves and their families without jeopardizing their already meager paychecks or their jobs. Paid leave allows workers to take time from work to support their families and their communities. Whether it is time to serve as a volunteer for a child's school field trip to take time to enjoy a day at our beautiful lakefront or our world, world class museums to get their car fixed or attend a a ball game. Or how about spending a few precious days visiting grandma? Paid leave makes us all better workers, workers benefit business benefits, our communities' benefits. Thank you. Uh, next up is, uh, and I'm gonna spell the name, forgive me. C-H-I-N-H fam uh, Sochi Saigan Kitchen. And after that will be Isabel Santos. Good morning everyone. My name is Chin Fa. My husband and I own Sochi Kitchen in the world. 40, uh, in 40 forward. I'm from Vietnam. I have been in Chicago since 2016. We love city of Chicago. That's why we moved to this state. We put everything. We had to build a dream in this city, but we are exhausted and we feeling we are being squeezed and squeezed from one to other regulations from the city that pushed we to the edge of falling. We thought we had passed the Cru term during the pandemic and barely made it through. But again, we cannot believe we are being pressed down again. We not like some big corporation. We are small people, both my husband and I working countless of hours to keep the business running. We never have enough staff to cover when someone is off. We do not have a budget to keep backup staff. We will be the ones to jump in to cover for employee who are off and at the same time doing our work. We created job opportunities for our 16 employees. We created the best working environment in our kitchen. Our employee feel proud of being part of Sochi Kitchen. We love working with our employees. They told us they always felt so happy coming to work, just like to be home. Can you imagine that? It is real? It unfortunately, we are running out of the ability to take care of our employees. We foresee with many of the city new ordinance and on top of inflation, rent, high cost of goods and elimination of the tip credit. Everything has gone beyond our ability to hold on. We are sure we may have to cut jobs, reduce ships. All the worst is we will have to close the business thing. We can no longer make enough paying for all expensive expense as well as complying with the city regulations. Restaurant work is not like office work. We cannot leave the work until the next day or have someone else to take over the, the the job. We cannot ask the cook to go to the bar to make drinks when the bartender is off and vice versa. Yeah, restaurant work either daily mission. If we don't have enough staff to finish the whole list of work that need to be done for the day, that's mean We screw up the service and we for sure will be hungry for that day. Thank, thank you. Thank you. Next up is followed by Scott Baskin. Uh, it is going to be read in Spanish and I'm gonna do, uh, providing translation. Forget the Hi, my name is Isabel Santos. I am a nanny and a member of Rice Chicago. I'm here to ask the committee for your votes for paid time off. As a working mother for me and many others, it is very difficult to ask for a day off to the employer because there's no law mandating them. Many times I had to choose between being with my daughters on days that were so important to them, like school events and outings their concerts or telling them, I'm sorry, I can't go with you. I have to work because we have to pay the bills. And seeing the sad faces, I ask you, how would you feel when you decide to go to that school sports or mu musical event or spend a day or two on vacation with your children to know that money will be deducted from your check. It happens to many of us. That money is important to pay your bills. It is an impossible and unfair decision to have time with your family or earn money to support it today. Sadly, some of my daughters have grown up and are working now and my family is still incomplete because the same problem repeats itself, not having paid days off. We continue to miss those important days for our family. I know that many of the workers who are here understand my story because it is their story too. You represent us. Do not fail us. That's why we ask for your votes. For US workers who are so necessary and important to the economy, I trust you will not let us down. That you know that we are also human beings and that we all need to take care of our families. I ask you for your vote in favor of the paid time of ordinance. Thank you. Next up is Scott Vaskin, followed by Bob Rider. Uh, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee, thank you for affording me the time to speak about the proposed PTO ordinance. I am Scott Baskin, CEO of the Small Business Advocacy Council. The SBAC is a nonpartisan organization together with our small business members and local chamber of commerce partners. The SBAC works to advance policies that support small businesses and entrepreneurs in Chicago and throughout the state. Simply stated, we want Chicago to be the best place to start and grow a small business that includes making Chicago the best place for small business employees too. The success of a small business is not, not only dependent on the strength of its leadership, but also on the talents of its employees. Making Chicago a great place for employees is a good thing, but creating difficult regulations and steep penalties jeopardizes the success of small businesses and creates a barrier for new businesses to develop and employee opportunities. We are very concerned about the reporting requirements and penalties in the proposed ordinance. In many small businesses, especially startup businesses, the accounting and payroll are handled by the founder or a trusted re relative. Oftentimes without sophisticated and expensive payroll programs that record keeping and employee notifications required by the proposed ordinances are complicated. There will be unintended violations and the penalties are so onerous. One fee, one failure to not accrued PTO time on a paycheck or a mistake on a final paycheck can result in a $500 or a $2,500 fine times the affected number of employees times the number of incidences the violation occurred. A small business owner in Englewood or Little Village, or Roseland or Uptown who makes a math mistake or whose spouse or child makes a math mistake, could face many thousands of dollars of fines. And because of the right of private action, an attorney is likely to file a lawsuit on behalf of the employees. This adds huge legal expense for the business owner who meant no harm. This is a harsh punishment, which could and would put a small business out of business. We urge the committee to consider creating a safe harbor for small business owners who make mistakes and once notified about the mistakes correct them. We also ask that the implementation date of this ordinance be pushed back a reasonable amount of time so businesses can't prepare to comply. Eight weeks is just way too soon. Small businesses are the lifeblood of our city neighborhoods and from small businesses come large businesses. We need to do everything we can to support small businesses and make it easier for the small business owner who works six days a week and is trying their very best to do the right thing. I understand my time, my testimony time is Li Limited and I would be happy to meet with the committee to discuss safe harbor provisions that could be added to the ordinance. Thank you. Next up is Bob Ryder, followed by Sam Toya. Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, my name is Bob Wrighter. I'm president of the Chicago Federation of Labor. We represent 300 unions and in turn represent half a million working people, including hotel attendants, restaurant workers, home healthcare aids, custodians, and many more people who are struggling to make it every day. And I'm gonna do two things today. One, I want to talk about the workers, but first I want to talk about all the things that Michael Jacobson said, misrepresenting the process and how we got here today because I think that's important. And I first wanna start with the fact that we approached the business community to talk about, um, working out an agreed process for this legislation last spring. And they said, we're not interested. I also wanna highlight the fact that they did not come to the table and actually start negotiating with us until this last week. And in doing so, they presented provisions, things that they wanted that were rollbacks of the 2016 earned sick leave ordinance that we had passed, uh, seven years ago. So they first part of their proposal, I wanna be clear about this, was walking back things that we already decided, including now we, we've heard, we've heard a request for a safe harbor and talking about small business, you know, who, you know, who went to the defense of small business in negotiations the last couple days we did because we rejected the preapproval proposal, which was complete nonsense, which would put it on, on businesses that if someone wanted to take a time, take time off that they could take it without any notice. That was, that would be crippling the small business. And it wasn't a real proposal and I have no idea why Jacobson would even bring that up. That is counterintuitive to what they would say in terms of advocating for small business. Now, have they as a business community offered any exemptions? Sure, for a, for one of the biggest industries in the world, they have not once proposed, um, in the last week an exemption or carve out for small businesses. We wanna have a conversation about it. Let's have the conversation. What we did propose was a, um, was a phase in over the course of the next couple years, which is not what you're voting on today because they are not willing to deal. And I cannot negotiate with people who won't negotiate with you. So one, the ordinances before you today is good. It's good public policy. It's six days of, it's six days of, uh, PTO. It's six days of sick days. That's a good policy. Now if you don't work the days, you don't earn the days. So it's not, it's not like we're creating a burden. They can't be handled in terms of scheduling. If the business community wants us to accept their day, accept their last proposal from yesterday, it would be getting, it would be getting, uh, 10 days. And by the way, we could, our workers could take it whenever they wanted. I want something reasonable. What we have on the table is reasonable. Thank you. And I ask for your support today. Thank you. Next up is Santoya and our final speaker is Cordless King. Good morning or good afternoon. Chairman Rodriguez and members of the committee, thank you for the opportunity to speak to you on behalf of, of the Chicago restaurant industry. For those of you who don't know who I am, my name is Sam Toya. I am president and CEO of the Illinois Restaurant Association. I wanna start out, we understand, apply to the woman who just spoke and we feel the business community has come to the table and offered five days of sick time, five days of PTO time and accommodated those requests. Our proposal has been balanced, fair, reasonable. But we can't forget about Soci Kitchen and its small business. Our industry is still trying to recover from the impact of the pandemic. And this new measure will make it even more difficult by tripling the cost of paid leave for Chicago employers, making it the most expensive paid time off policy in the nation. This will even exceed the soon to be required state mandate that we recently negotiated by 160% and provided more days off than other large city in the United States, including New York City and Los Angeles. New York requires five days. Los Angeles requires six. The restaurant industry is only now catching its breath as it tries to come to terms with the elimination of tick credit three weeks ago. And the cost of doing business due to inflation, increased rent, labor shortage, and the price of goods. These difficult magnifies these difficult years. You know, 'cause of the debit coming outta the pandemic and recent changes to consumers' dining behavior. As the largest private sector employer in the state, the city must acknowledge that restaurants fight for their very survival. From Rogers Park to South Chicago and Little Village to Chatham, this ordinance will hit small and minority owned businesses in the city's 77 neighborhoods, the hardest expand paid leave on top of the recent elimination of Tip credit will cripple restaurant that notoriously only make three to 5% profit margin. It's common sense to safeguard an economic engine that employs over 300,000 people in the metro Chicago area. We ask for an appreciate, appreciate and understanding the challenges the restaurants face today. Mr. Chairman and chairman of the committee, on behalf of all the restaurants across the city of Chicago, many of them who are here with us today, I urge you to vote on the sub, uh, not to vote on the substitute largest. I'm always willing to come to the table. It's, I'd rather be at the table than be on the menu. So let's keep negotiating. We can do this, we can do this. We're a great city. Let's come together as one. Thank you. And our last speaker is cordless King. Uh, good morning. Thank you very much for giving me an opportunity to have a, a voice here. And as I listen, I realize I'm uniquely qualified in a lot of ways to speak to this. Uh, my name is Cordless King. I'm a flight attendant with Southwest Airlines and a 20 year employee In 2020, I lost my husband, Terrance Hale at the beginning of the pandemic. He had a chronic illness which periodically required that I support him personally, which meant time away from work. While my employer was empathetic, there was no path to not experience financial loss. I had to care for my family and that's a choice I shouldn't have had to make. My husband and I were also small business owners. I understand and empathize with the concerns. My company employed as many as 35 employees at one time, so I exemplify that small business employer. But what I have learned through my experience is there's no substitution for the time I had with my husband. And no employer should add to the financial burden by making me choose my light bill or my family. I believe workers are not looking for ways to not work. I believe workers are looking for ways that they cannot give their lives to jobs, but balance and work in concert with their jobs. Chicago is an amazing city. We don't need to be compared to New York or Los Angeles because we are Chicago and we take care of our workers here. Our workers are also supporters of these small businesses. Don't forget that 'cause workers won't forget that either. Thank you for your time. Thank you. Uh, the time for public comment has expired. Our first order of business is the approval of the Rule 45 report from September 20th, 2023. Every member of the committee should have received a copy in their email last week. Can I have a motion to approve the Rule 45 report? Alder Gutierrez. So moves all those in favor of passing the resolution respond by saying aye. Aye. All those opposed and the opinion, the chair, the ayes have it for the purposes of quorum. Um, and for the record, we will be adding Alderwoman Cruz all Alder Rodriguez Sanchez, alderman Viegas Alder person Vasquez and Alderman Riley, who have not been previously, uh, recognized. Uh, Alder person, Gutierrez as well. We also have Alderman Bennett Lawson. Let me note you here. He's good. Alderman Chico, we have you. Okay, the second item before the committee today, oh 2 0 2 3 dash 0 0 2 9 8 oh amendments of municipal code titles two and six by modifying various sections governing sick time and paid leave for employees within the city of Chicago. We have a substitute ordinance, so 2 0 2 3 0 0 0 2 9 8 oh. Can I get a motion to accept the substitute? So moved by Alderman Ramirez, Rosa, all those in favor of accepting the substitute resolution, please respond by saying aye. Any opposed in the opinion of the chair? The a's habits? I wanna acknowledge again, we have a number of written communications sent to the committee. Every committee member should have, uh, received a copy of those written comments in your packet today, and they were also previously emailed. Today we have a number of experts to speak on the ordinance and I will, uh, name them as we move forward to to as we move forward. To save a bit of time, we'll have, uh, the, uh, director of policy for the Workforce Committee talk about the change in our ordinance. First, deputy Mayor, uh, Bridget, uh, of labor, Bridget early speaks to the ordinance, and then we'll have three experts on both sides of the aisle, uh, to address us in three minutes each. So I will begin with Meli Pagan of Workforce Development, who worked on this ordinance and can explain the substitute. Good morning, good morning Committee members. Um, I'm going to go through the differences in the original ordinance that was introduced back in July, 2023, and then the one that, uh, the substitute ordinance that was just introduced in committee. Um, in your packet there should be a chart that explains the differences. And so I'm gonna use that to just go through, um, the differences in, in the ordinance. Um, in the original paid leave ordinance, again that was filed in July, 2023. Um, all employees, um, within the city, oh, within, um, working in the city of Chicago would be covered. Um, so any employers with one or more employees in the city of Chicago would be covered. That is continues to be consistent in the new, um, substitute ordinance. In terms of the type of leave that, uh, was originally in the paid leave ordinance, um, the type of leave that was in the original paid leave ordinance was essentially just pay time off that could be used for any reason and that wouldn't be able to be denied by the employer. Um, in the new ordinance, um, there are two types of leave. Um, there is sick and safe leave, um, as well as paid time off, um, for sick and safe leave, though that time would only be able to be used to recover from illness, take care of a family, um, address domestic violence and public health emergencies that is consistent with the current sick leave ordinances. And so the reasons to be able to take that sick time under the new, under the substitute ordinance is the same. Um, in terms of paid time off, um, in the substitute ordinance, that paid time off could be used for any reason. Um, but the request to take the PTO could be denied by the employer understanding that businesses need to continue operations and, and may not have, um, you know, everybody out on the same day. Um, in terms of the number of days, um, granted in, in the accrual in each version of the ordinance, the original ordinance, um, allowed for a full-time. Assuming 40 hours of work, eight hour workday, approximately 15 days of paid time off, that would've been accrued at one hour for, uh, for every 15 hours work. Um, there would not have been a cap in rollover, so, um, employees would have been able to to, to roll over all the time that they've earned that year. But in the new ordinance, as I mentioned, there are two different types of leave, right? So sick eat, sick and safe leave and pay time off. Um, in the new ordinance, an uh, employee is able to earn 48 hours or six, sick up to six days of sick and safe leave. Um, and then they would also be able to earn, um, up to 48 hours or six days in a year, in a 12 month period, they'd be able to earn, um, at least 48 hours and six, six days, right? That would be the, the cap that, um, that would be legally allowed under the ordinance. Um, in the substitute ordinance, all workers would earn one hour for every 35 hours, worked again, capped at 48 hours for both sick and safe leave, as well as as paid time off. Um, in terms of the usage, uh, in the original, again, in the original paid leave ordinances filed in July, 2023, um, an employer, an employee could use the paid time off that they've earned after 30 days of being in the, in the unemployment in the job. Um, and they would have, an employer could set a minimum amount of how, of how much, um, paid time off an employer could use, um, at least a minimum amount of, of two hours. In the new, um, the substitute ordinance, um, for sick and safe leave, uh, an employee can use the sick and safe leave that they've earned after 30 days of being, um, in, in the job and the employment. Um, and again, having a minimum usage that doesn't, uh, a minimum usage not to exceed two hours. Um, in terms of paid time off, um, the employee would not be able to use the pay time off, which is the one that can be used for any reason, um, until after 90 days that they have been in in, in the employment and the job. Um, the minimum usage for pay time off would not be able to exceed for four hours as well. In terms of just rate of pay and benefits. Um, in the original paid leave ordinance, it would just, uh, the employee must be paid the same rate of pay as when they would otherwise be working whenever they take the time off under that original paid leave ordinance. Um, for tit employees, um, gratuities would, um, be included in determining the rate of pay, um, in the substitute ordinance. On the other hand, um, again, for both sick and safe leave and paid and paid time off under the substitute ordinance, employees must be paid the rate, the same, um, rate of pay as they would when they're working. But, um, for tipped employees, gratuities would not be considered as part of what their rate of pay would be and either, uh, scenario would, they would have to be paid at least the, the minimum wage, the full minimum, the full minimum wage. Um, in terms of notice and documentation in the original paid leave ordinance, the employer, um, you know, would've been able to require seven days notice if, um, the need. Um, if the employee, um, knew that they would need to take the time off seven days in advance, or as soon as they were aware that the need for leave, um, and under the original paid leave, um, ordinance, employers wouldn't be able to require documentation, um, for the reason for their leave. Under the new, uh, substitute ordinance, um, for sick and safe leave, an employer can require seven days notice if foreseeable, or as soon as, um, the employee is aware of the need for leave. That is, um, what is the same in the current paid sick leave ordinance. So that does not change. Um, and then if, uh, documentation may be requested after the third consecutive day, which is again, consistent with the current sick leave, um, paid sick leave ordinances, um, in terms of paid time off and employer would be allowed, um, to establish a pre-approval policy, again to ensure continuity of business operations, uh, business operations. But under, if the employee is taking their earned pay time off, then they wouldn't, an employer wouldn't be able to require documentation since it can be used for, for any reason. Um, in the original, um, paid leave ordinance, there was, uh, no cap in terms of the yearly rollover. Um, in the new substitute ordinance there um, is a cap of 80 hours or 10 days for the paid sick and safe leave, um, that a employee can earn. So it's a cap of 80 hours in terms of the paid time off that can be used for any reason. Um, there is a rollover of 24 hours that would be allowed or three days, but if the paid time off is front loaded, let's say an employer decides I'm going to grant you, um, the minimum hours of paid time off under the ordinance, they wouldn't have to carry that over. In terms of payout upon separation of employment, um, under the original, um, ordinance, um, all unused paid time off would, um, be required to be paid out when the employee leaves, um, the, the the job or the employment, um, in terms of the new substitute. Um, thus under time that, um, is accrued under sick and safe leave would not be paid out. So any unused time, um, that an employee has earned for sick and safe leave would not be required to be paid out. In terms of paid time off that an employee would earn under the substitute ordinance, um, it would be required to be paid out, but at most, um, the employer would, assuming that an employee never takes their time, never uses their p their paid time off, um, and is leaving at the end of the year, that most the employer, an employer would be required to pay out is 72 hours or or nine days. Um, in terms of enforcement, um, both the original and the substitute ordinance would be enforced by the Office of Labor Standards. Um, in the original ordinance, there's a 25, uh, $2,500 fine for each separate offense. Under the new substitute ordinance, the, there's a range of fines from 1000 to $3,000 fine for separate offense that would be, um, determined by the Office of Labor Standards. Um, in terms of the effective date, um, the, in the original ordinance, the effective date is December 31st, 2023. Um, and then there would be the part right of action would also be effective, um, upon the ordinance effective date, um, in the new ordinance. Um, there, the effective date continues to be December 31st, 2023, although there is a delay of the private right of action until July 1st, 2024. Um, but during that time, LLS can continue to enforce, um, that the new substitute ordinance, the private right of action delay does not include violations that are, um, occurred prior to December 31st under the paid, uh, current paid sick leave ordinance since that will continue to be in effect until this ordinance goes into effect. Um, and then the last thing is in both versions of the ordinance, um, there's a requirement for OLS to work on a study with stakeholders on providing options and how the city can develop a, a portable pay time off system for domestic workers in both, um, ordinances. Thank you. Thank you, Meza. Now we have Deputy Mayor of Labor, Bridget, early. You also have three minutes please. Thank you. Uh, thank you to the chairman and members of the committee this morning. This is an important subject matter that benefits workers across all 50 wards, uh, and to emphasize on day one of his administration, the mayor signed executive order to 20 23 18 establishing the city's first ever deputy mayor of labor. I sit before you today, the daughter of a retired union electrician and a healthcare administrative assistant as the first person to serve in this role, I grew up understanding that a day my dad did not work, meant a day without pay. And as the oldest of five sisters, I've certainly served as a stop cap for childcare coverage. As many of you may be aware, most working people in the US do not have paid family leave through their jobs, including about 77% or approximately 5 million workers here in Illinois. Even unpaid leave under federal FMLA is inaccessible for 62% of Illinoisans. The lack of paid leave exacerbates the state's economic and care challenges. Coupled with the rising cost of living to an aging population has devastating impacts for all Illinoisans, their families, public health and the economy, paid sick and caregiving leave lets workers care for themselves and loved ones when ill or injured and reduce, reduces financial insecurity and stress during those times. As a woman, I have witnessed firsthand how access to paid leave impacts women in the workforce force the most. For context, in March of 21, US Women's Labor Force participation rate was 56.1%, a 33 year old, three year low, excuse me, with women of color having been hit the hardest women of color, more likely than white women to face difficult choices between their caregiving and work responsibilities because they're also more likely to be the primary breadwinners for their families. For context, again, in Illinois, 84% of black mothers, 47% of Latina mothers, 47% of white mothers, and 43% of AAPI. Mothers are key family breadwinners. And although being the financial backbone of their families, women of color are paid less on average than white non-Hispanic women and men, even within comparable jobs, and are dramatically overrepresented in low wage jobs that are less likely to offer family friendly workplace policies. Meanwhile, emerging research confirms what many families already knew. Caregiving responsibilities are a significant driver of women's exit from the labor force. Currently, women ages 18 to 34 reported the lowest rates of access to all types of leave, including paid leave for birth of adoption, despite being, despite being the most likely to give birth to a new child. Among those, excuse me, among those with access to paid parental leave, 16% are limited to two weeks and 55% reported they could take more than two paid weeks off for this reason. Similarly, about 30% of those with paid leave said they could only take two weeks off to care for an ill family member. Many were unsure how many weeks of paid leave they could take for any reason. And why is this important to Chicago? Because women comprise nearly half the city's workforce at 48%. If women in Illinois participated in the labor force at the same rate as women in countries with paid leave, there would be an additional estimated 124,000 workers in the state and 4.4 billion more in wages. As many of you know, mayor Johnson's vision to create a better, stronger, and safer future where Chicago's youth and their communities have access to the tools and resources they need to thrive. Workplace, workplace policies like leave, earn, leave and earn sick leave can help more youth join and stay connected to the workforce. Protective workplace policies can also boost productivity and decrease employer costs. Studies show that businesses in states with paid family leave laws, which include protections for part-time workers have higher firm-wide productive productivity rates as compared to similar, similar business without leave. Chicago has a long and proud history of being an ally for workers and leaders in establishing worker product protections. Our forward thinking approach is demonstrated through instituting AV var various landmarks ordinance in the last eight years, including the minimum wage gradually increasing from $10 in 2015 to 1580. In 2023, the Fair Workplace Week ordinance passed in 2020, the first ever contract requirement for domestic workers passing in 22. And most recently, the passage of one fair wage at the helm of Chicago's Workforce Worker Protections is the Office of Labor Standards, which was created to oversee Chicago's labor laws through community engagement and enforcement. Prior to the creation of the office, the city of Chicago is actively evaluating its worker protections. Um, in 2017, the Chicago, the City of Chicago passed the, again, the minimum wage and paid sick leave ordinance and joined an ever-growing list of jurisdictions in the US requiring employers to pass paid leave. We are here today since earlier this year, governor Pritzger signed SB 2008, also known as the paid Leave for All Workers Act. Effective January one covered employees will be able to earn and use up to 40 hours of paid leave during a 12 month period for any purpose of the employee's choosing. While the paid leave for all Workers Act does not preempt the city's minimum wage and paid leave ordinance or the Cook County earned sick leave ordinance that require employers to give paid leave and paid sick leave to their employers after December 31st, 2023. Any changes the city makes regarding paid leave legislation must be at least in full compliance with the state law, the proposed leave ordinance before you makes important changes to paid time off, including increasing the amount of paid leave workers are entitled to, and two in a, uh, in two rena's paid sick leave as paid sick and save leave to raise awareness regarding the numerous ways workers are entitled to use this paid time. This is inclusive of Chicago's Chicagoans experience violence in the home. By bringing our ordinance into alignment with the state, we are going to ensure Chicago remains a leader on earned leave because workers should not have to choose between their health and financial security. Thank you. Thank you Bridgett. Just a reminder to keep your remarks to three minutes. Next up it's Chauncey Rice Alman Podo. Madam Chair, I'm sorry to do this to you 'cause I know you got thrown into this, but if we're gonna give one person six and a half minutes, we have to give everybody six and a half minutes, so it's only right, we said three minutes, so I don't care which side you're on. I don't care if 10 people are for one way, one or the other way. We're, we're gonna have to give everybody six and a half minutes. So that's Just my, you counted it. It was six minutes was She spoke six and a half minutes. I had my timer on, so, okay. Thank you. Uh, next Up, I I think we know it was over three minutes, that's for sure. So Sure we'll be here all day if needed. Uh, next up is Chauncey Rice, associate Vice President for government relations, uh, for the Illinois Retail Merchants Association. Good morning, Mr. Chair and members of the committee. My name is Chauncey Rice, associate Vice President of Government relations for the Illinois Retail Merchants Association. Thank you for allowing me to speak on behalf of Chicago's retail community on this very important matter of providing additional paid leave to Chicago workers. First, I'd like to go on record and let it be known that we are not here today to attempt to deny workers additional paid time off. I'd actually go out on a limb here and say that just about every single person in this room understands the importance of being able to take time off from work to care for loved ones or themselves. In fact, it's actually been proven that the business community supports workers' abilities to do so as the business community just a few short months ago reached an agreement to provide workers all across the state of Illinois paid time offer any reason they deemed necessary. This was an agreement to a balanced paid leave policy that even labor leaders praised some of the phrases that were used to describe the recently passed state law were actually quite pleasant in their own words labor leaders described the recently passed state law as, and I quote forward thinking a policy that quote provides peace of mind to every worker in the state. And another one, a policy that provides a stable work life balance. These are words from the very labor leaders that rejected a balanced proposal from the business community that would've double paid time off for Chicago workers while also taking into account employer concerns just as was done at the state level. So as our great city continues to struggle to recover from the pandemic with commercial corridors across all 77 neighborhoods experiencing exorbitantly high vacancy rates, as we so gracefully push for employers to encourage employees to return to office, as we so desperately try to attract and retain grocery stores, pharmacies and restaurants alike and neighborhoods like Little Village, Washington Park, Inglewood Uptown Austin, south Chicago and North Lawndale, where I myself was born and raised. As we as a city look to address the ever-growing pension obligations for which a robust economy is directly tied to the city's ability to meet those very obligations. As we consider all of these things, I ask that you in that same vein, consider the $31.7 billion that Chicago employers currently deploy for paid leave and the additional $177 million burden that you will be placing on Chicago's minority owned businesses for each additional mandated day of paid leave forced upon employers. I simply ask that you take a balanced approach to paid time off one that supports both workers and businesses. Thank you for your time. Thank you Mr. Rice. And next we have Chairman Lee mda, executive Vice President of Policy Programs and Research for Women Employed. Thank you so much, vice chair. Um, good morning. Thank you to Chairman Rodriguez and to the committee for the opportunity to speak to the committee on this important important ordinance. I'm Sharmi Lee Maj Madar and I serve as the Executive Vice President of Policy Programs and Research at Women Employed. We work to build women's economic power through e employment education and entrepreneurship. Women employed is celebrating our 50th anniversary and during that time, one of the most critical policies we have advocated for is paid leave, particularly for workers in low paid occupations and part-time workers who work in jobs that often don't provide benefits beyond what is required by law. We know these workers are more likely to be women and are also more likely to be black or Latina. Paid leave takes many forms, two of which we are discussing today. Paid sick days and paid time off. Women employed was intimately involved in passing Chicago's current paid sick days ordinance almost seven years ago and would like to help to illuminate why this ordinance is so important. The paid sick days ordinance that we passed was so successful that it's not only been replicated in cities and states across the country, but it's been expanded upon. Access to paid time off is critical to workers and their families who are struggling to make ends meet in a challenging economy. That same economy that we talked about earlier that has inflation and increased food costs are also affecting these individual workers. Paid time off gives workers time to spend time with their families, care for their health without having to risk their livelihood. It also affords workers the ability to stay home when they're sick and preventing their colleagues also from getting sick and missing work, paid sick time and paid time off. Mean working people are not forced to make the impossible choice between their jobs and their families. Data is important because it can help us understand whether reality actually bears out fears. And according to the National Partnership for Women and Families, access to paid time off improves worker retention, which reduces employer turnover costs. It also increases productivity, labor force participation because working while sick reduces in employee's productivity by as much as 20% and that is a cost to business. Last year we worked with the Mayor's Advisory Council for Women World Business Chicago and the Civic Consulting Alliance to research the economic impacts of Covid to 19 on women in Chicago as well as what their recovery would require. And that study found that working women and especially black and brown women were already economically vulnerable before C Ovid 19. And the pandemic only exacerbated this economic divide. Women were earning much less than their male counterparts and they were overrepresented in the low quality, low paid jobs that have fewer benefits and do not offer paid time off and often only offer paid sick time because it is required by law in the City of Chicago. Women also experience significant economic insecurity due to caregiving responsibilities, both for their own children, for their parents, or extended family. Research also shows that job quality in the US is on a 40 year decline and has been worse for younger workers. Those without a college degree, and again black and Latinx workers. And one of the key characteristics of what is considered a good high quality job is paid to leave the Society of Human Resource Management. SH RM revealed how important employee vocation is not only to the individual in the family, but that it also reduces costs for employers with fewer sick days, less turnover and lower healthcare costs. As an organization that also supports women of color entrepreneurs and small business owners, we are keenly aware of the challenges small business owners face and it's exactly why we have been part of the coalition efforts and compromised as much as possible. We should absolutely support small businesses, but not at the expense of their workers. This ordinance will be good for business and also good for working people. Chicago has always been a leader on forward-thinking policies that support working people and families. And in this moment, Chicago workers need your leadership. We urge you to vote yes on this ordinance. Thank you. And my apologies if I've missed, uh, I've been mispronouncing any names. Uh, next up we have Brad tz. Uh, sure. Thank you Chair. And, um, I will keep my remarks. Uh, sorry. 2, 3, 3 minutes that we're allotted. Brett, Let me just introduce you. Well, yes, gimme one second. I'm so sorry. And I'm tz, is that how you pronounce your last name? Uh, tz, yes. tz. Oh my apologies. Vice President of Government Relations and Strategy for the Chicagoland Chamber of Commerce. Uh, good afternoon again, my name is Brad Heats, VP of Government Relations and Strategy with the Chicagoland Chamber of Commerce. I will keep my remarks brief. We were told three minutes and I intend to stick to that. Uh, the chamber represents every industry throughout Chicago and has, has heard from every industry in size of business on the paid lead proposal before you today. Um, I've had the privilege of helping lead the negotiate lead, the negotiations for the business community. I do wanna thank, uh, chair Rodriguez for holding true on his commitment to convening the negotiations that have occurred. It's been a tough but healthy dialogue, and I'm hoping we can continue that dialogue. It's unfortunate that I'm having to testify in opposition today to this proposal. We have been and remain committed to reaching a compromise that is fair for both Chicago workers and businesses. First, I do wanna make sure the committee knows, uh, despite what, uh, the gentleman from the, uh, Chicago Federation of Labor was saying, we've only had three weeks to negotiate this. Yes, the chair will say, he introduced us in July and we had time, but my group and every other opposing group also met with him in August and September, and we were told that a, a negotiating table would be convened when the chair was ready. Apparently, that only meant three weeks ago. We officially kicked off negotiations on October 13th, a little over three weeks ago. Like I said, most of Chicago and many, uh, even many members of City City Council are now just learning of this ordinance and are now just learning. This all happened, but nevertheless, we came to the table in good faith because we want or reach a compromise on this. The business community truly understands there is a balance that needs to be struck on paid leave policies. Every worker should have the ability to have time for their own health, to care for a loved one, or simply enjoy their life. No one denies that. That's why my organization and other business groups came to the table on the new state law that is not even effective yet. And it's why we've been committed to reaching a deal throughout these negotiations that that is, again, fair for both workers and businesses. It's why we put on the table last week, a 10 day paid leave policy. I'll repeat that. The business community offered a proposal whereby Chicago workers would get 10 days total, five paid sick leave days, and five paid time off days, which would've been, if not the most, one of the most expansive forms of paid leave required in the country. But our offer was rejected. As many of you are aware, the issue of payout and employer pre-approval has become a major sticking point. Just yesterday, well, it was a topic of discussion a little bit ago. We offered a 10 day paid leave proposal with no employer pre-approval for use of days. In exchange for no payout, an employee could simply take the days as they see fit. But once again, that offer was rejected. And I'll, I'll be clear, this has not been something we take lightly. 10 days of paid leave is going to harm small businesses, but we're also very aware of the political climate in which we find ourselves. And 10 days is better than 15 or 24 days as they had previously proposed. Um, unfortunately, I think the sad lesson on our end is that it turns out many, um, alderman sitting on city council care more about big labor than small businesses and their wards. And just for the record, while there are certainly, you know, um, some businesses, big businesses who care downtown businesses, um, or I'm sorry, not many downtown, it's the small businesses in all your wars. You're truly impacting the ones who sponsor your, your little league events. The ones who sponsor your community events. The proposal before you simply goes too far, much too quickly, does not contain the important employer protections. We continue to seek and is simply poorly drafted, which will lead to lawsuits for the most minor of infractions. We're not asking for much 10 days total. Five paid sick leave days, and five paid time off days, a one hour for every 40 hours worked accrual rate, which aligns with the state, no payout upon separation, which also aligns with Illinois, New York City and Los Angeles. A fair regulatory process before a potentially devastating lawsuit can be filed for a minor infraction, a small business exemption, and importantly, a one year delay of enforcement mechanism so businesses can implement these new requirements. And just for the record, on January one, no business in Chicago will be in compliance. Just for the record, we urge you to oppose this measure before committee today and answer the chair and the other side, get back to the negotiating table with us. We remain committed and prepared to reach a compromise that is fair for both Chicago workers and businesses. Thank you for your time today, and we, and we look forward to your questions. Thank you so much, Brad. Next up we have Dr. Steve Ashby, professor of labor relations at the University of Illinois. Thank you. My name is Steven Ashby. I'm a professor of the School of Labor and Employment Relations at the University of Illinois at Urbana Champaign. Uh, however, I live in the Westtown neighborhood of Chicago. I'd like to provide a little global and historical context to our discussions. Norway 25 paid weekday vacation, five weeks Denmark, five weeks paid vacation, federal law, New Zealand, Australia, four weeks paid vacation. Federal law, Belgium, Germany, four weeks. Every worker and any of the 27 countries in the European Union are mandated by law to get four weeks paid. Vacation. America, none. We have no federal law. Zero paid days vacation. The same true we're talking about paid sick days. There is no federal law in America paid maternity leave. There is no federal law in America, and yet we are the richest country in the world. We're not broke. How can Denmark do it? How can New Zealand do it? How can dozens of countries that are not as rich as America provide paid time off for their workers and a lot more than the six days we're offering here? You know, who does get five weeks paid vacation every year? People will make six figure salaries. The less money you make, the less time off you have and the more likely you have no time off at all. The averages in America's two weeks paid time off, at least 28 million Americans have no time off. When Congress won't act often because of the filibuster that prevents them from doing anything that helps working people. Our cities and our states step in to lead. Chicago has led on the minimum wage despite Congress doing nothing for almost 15 years. Chicago has led on first scheduling. Chicago is led on paid sick days and led on the fair wage for tip to workers. We've led fighting wage theft. We've led fully funding the Office of Labor Standards to enforce these laws. 137 years ago, Chicago led in the fight for the eight hour day when working people worked 12 hours a day, seven days a week. And that was the norm for factory workers. They had no time to live. All they did was work eight hours for work, eight hours for sleep, eight hours for what we will. That was the slogan. Eight hours to have a life, eight hours to have recreation, eight hours to be a human being. 80,000 people marched and May 1st, 1886 down Michigan Avenue, chanting, demanding a life that'd be a half a million Today with a population increase, we stand on the shoulders of those workers in 1886. We are again declaring workers deserve a life. They deserve to be happy. Just as 137 years ago, workers fought for eight hours to play with our kids, eight hours to be with our families, eight hours to go to the park, eight hours to read a book, catch up on sleep. Today we're fighting for paid days off to have time for every person in Chicago, to have time to play with their kids, to be with our families, to go to the state parks, to go to the national parks, to have a full life. We all know rests and vacation reinvigorates. You. We all know work can really drag you down and exhaust you. Vacation paid time off gives you something to look forward to. You're ready to tackle the world again. 55 years ago in Memphis, African-American sanitation workers galvanized the country when they went on strike and carried the sign, I'm a man. They were all male workers. And man, I'm a human being. It meant I deserve respect. I deserve to be treated like anyone else. I deserve the same rights as everyone else. I deserve a living wage and I deserve time off from work to live my life. And we stand also today on the shoulders of those 1968 sanitation workers Dec Declaration of Independence. 1776 includes the words, the pursuit of happiness. The founders of these words were self-evident unalienable rights. That means their obvious. It means they should be clear to everyone. You can't take those rights away, but you cannot live a happy life if all you do is work 52 weeks a year, year after year after year. We all have a right to live a full life, a complete life, a happy life. We deserve personal time off to be with our families, to be with our friends. And we're saying today, Chicago must again lead on workers' rights and then the nation will follow. Thank you. Thank you doctor. Now we have Pedro Guerra, executive director of the Pilsen Chamber of Commerce. Oh, Thank you. I'd like to thank the council, um, and everybody that's here today. Again, my name is Pedro Guerra. I'm the executive director for the Pilsen Chamber of Commerce. I'm here to represent members of the small business community group that has businesses in Pilsen. For those of you who don't know, Pilsen is a rich cultural, multi-generational business owner community. And I'm here to speak on the behalf. The proposed CH Chicago paid leave ordinance aims to triple the state's existing paid time off requirements, which would place a significant burden on Chicago's business, irrespective to their size or sector. Having said that earlier today, we heard somebody from the Chicago Federation of Labor mentioned that they know that this is going to put a hurt on small business owners Chicago in ho. 7% of businesses in the Chicago land market are ch uh, Latino owned. Out of those 7%, 67% are one to four employees. Those are the, are the uh, members that I represent. At this point, it's important to acknowledge that further research is necessary to fully understand the effects of the proposal ordinance of businesses with fewer 10. The proposed paid leave ordinance when combined with the existing restrictions on scheduling the elimination of tip credits and other regulatory challenges, challenges will put a burden on businesses across all Chicago lands. The co compound effect could especially determine for small businesses and business and minority business owners. These enterprises are already grappling with supply chain disruptions, labor challenges, and recent regulatory passes by the council. So we, what we know is Latino business owners aim to contribute to the long-term growth of the city and provide opportunities to residents. We believe that policies to promote sustainability and economic growth rather than hindering. A lot of our members have stressed and said, at what point is this? It's not a business owners versus employees. We wanna make sure that we could come together. And I think hearing my colleagues to the left, the proposal that we've put on table kind of speaks to that. The spell business owner, the one to 10 is the rep, again, who I represent. They're not villains and they feel like that's something that they've been portrayed. Majority of them would work and make sure one of their employees takes time off. That's just the nature of what the businesses are during the pandemic, the retail, the restaurants in the Pilson community took a big hit while surrounding suburbs. Were less ordinance, were able to open and take majority of the profit. So what we believe, we believe in balance approach that benefits both employees, employers. So we call the city council to engage in a con constructive dialogue to develop policies that address the needs of all shareholders. Thank you. Thank you Pedro. And last but not least, we have Ugo re policy director for the Raise the Floor Alliance. Good morning chairs, the members of the committee and to all the folks in the gallery. I'll keep my comments in three minutes 'cause I don't have that much content. So My name is Hugo o Carey. My pronouns are he, him, and I'm the policy director for Raise the Floor Alliance. Raise The Floor Alliance is an alliance of worker centers around the city of Chicago, county of Cook and state of Illinois. I represent primarily black and brown workers in low wage and highly exploited industries. These are the domestic workers of rise, Chicago and Latino Union. These are the factory and logistics workers of warehouse workers for justice, the assembly line workers of CCWR and unidos, the temp workers of Chicago Workers Collaborative and formerly incarcerated Workers of Worker Center for Racial Justice. These are the workers this city council held up as essential during the pandemic. Well, they're back and they're demanding just the bare minimum of what they are owed. That is the time to live a life worth living. Workers are not simply cogs in machines that need to be turned in order to maximize the generation of profit for big or small business. They are real people with real families, real aspirations, goals, and the very real need to be happy and fulfilled. People. Workers of all kinds deserve what everyone on this side of the chamber gets the ability to take care of sick and ailing loved ones, the ability to take care of their own mental health, to ensure their own safety during episodes of domestic violence, to take their family on vacation or just to watch their kids' little league game. I wanna stress that everything that you see before you today is a product of compromise. Compromise with the city of Chicago. Compromise with the business community, when you all signed onto this ordinance back in July, was vastly different than what you see today. And it's because we have heard folks, we listened and we moved and all that we're technically asking for here is seven more days. Five days are already required by the city, by the city of Chicago for employers to provide city council. I urge you to vote yes on this ordinance, not just to give the labor movement a win or to deal with the potential legal disaster that comes if we don't pass this soon. But because you recognize the humanity and the workers who are sitting right behind you, that they too deserve to live a life worth living. There's a famous saying by a labor rights activist named Robert Owen that Steve mentioned earlier, eight hours for work, eight hours for rest, and eight hours to do what we will. He said that in the year 1817. Now 200 years later, we're just asking for a little bit more time to do what we will. Thank you. Please. Yes, please. Thank you. Thank you very much. Um, this committee will stand in recess, uh, to the call of the chair. I'm thinking around, uh, 10 minutes. I'll come back. Um, at that point, if, uh, at that point I will come back in 10 minutes. Thank you so much. We'll stand in recess at the call of the chair. We'll reconvene our meeting in five more minutes. Five. I'll be recessing, the Workforce Development Committee to reconvene on Thursday, November 2nd at Chicago City Council Chambers at 9:30 AM We are in recess until that time. Thank you.