>> ANNA VALENCIA: Meeting and log into the new meeting. We will take your quorum shortly. On your iPad, please log out -- or exit out of the old meeting and log into the new meeting. The 12:00 noon meeting. Log into the 12:00 noon meeting on your iPad, and we'll take your quorum roll call here shortly. Raise your hand if you need support. Raise your hand if you need support. Log into the 12:00 noon meeting on your iPad. >> Refresh? >> ANNA VALENCIA: Hit refresh on your iPad if you do not see it. Hit refresh, and the noon meeting will pop up. If you need support, raise your hand. Alderwoman Dowell needs help. I see you. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: Very well. Thank you for being patient with us this afternoon. The council will again come to order. Madam clerk, please take a quorum roll call. >> ANNA VALENCIA: The quorum is now open. The quorum is now open. Please use your edevice. The quorum roll call is now open. If you need support, please raise your hand. Roberto. O'Shea. Okay. I will now take a voice vote for those who do not use the edevice. Alderman La Spata? >> DANIEL LA SPATA: Present. >> ANNA VALENCIA: Oh. Not present in chambers. We'll come back to you. Alderman Hopkins. Alderman Hopkins is present. Alderman Hall. Not present in chambers. Alderman Mitchell. Not present in chambers. Alderwoman Coleman. Coleman is present. Alderman David Moore. Not present in chambers. Alderman Mitchell is present in chambers. Alderwoman Scott. Scott is present in chambers. Alderman Taliaferro. Taliaferro is present in chambers. Alderwoman Cruz. Alderwoman Rodriguez-Sanchez, not present in chambers. I know. She did present. Alderman Vasquez . Vasquez is present. Alderman Knudsen, not present in chambers. Okay. Did I miss anyone that walked in? All right. The quorum roll call is now closed. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: Very well. There are 45 members that are represent. We do have a quorum. The following alders have requested to participate in today's meeting remotely for reasons stated in Rule 59. Can we confirm the presence of alders Hall, Moore, Rodriguez-Sanchez, Knudsen, and La Spata? >> ANNA VALENCIA: Alderman Hall. >> WILLIAM HALL: Present. >> ANNA VALENCIA: Hall is present. Alderman Moore. >> DAVID MOORE: Present. >> ANNA VALENCIA: Moore is present. Alderman Rodriguez-Sanchez. >> ROSSANA RODRIGUEZ SANCHEZ: I'm here. >> ANNA VALENCIA: Rodriguez-Sanchez is present. Knudsen. >> TIMMY KNUDSEN: Present. >> ANNA VALENCIA: Knudsen is present. La Spata. >> DANIEL LA SPATA: Present. >> ANNA VALENCIA: La Spata is present. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: All alders have confirmed their participation online. Can I get a motion to approve their remote participation? It's been moved. All those in favor, signify by saying aye. Any opposed, say nay. In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. Please add those following members to the quorum roll call. Let's please stand and rise for the pledge of allegiance. [ Pledge of allegiance ] Thank you. Please remain standing for our invocation, which will be delivered today by Reverend Dr. Max Lee, professor of New Testament and North Park University. >> Good afternoon. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: Good afternoon. >> Thank you, Mayor Johnson. Madam City clerk Valencia, and beloved councilmembers, allowing me to give this invocation. Will you please pray with me? Heavenly father and gracious God, we confess to you in a season of Thanksgiving, we do have much to be thankful for. Thank you as lord of all creation for the gift of life we breathe each day. Thank you for a common grace that shines on all people. Thank you for the redemption, mediated by Jesus Christ your son who as God became human, experienced our joys and our sorrows. He therefore knows how to help us, and as our mediator, we boldly bring our petitions to you and ask for your blessing upon us. We ask that you might provide for -- for our leader -- the leaders of the City, for our Mayor, our City Clerk, our Aldermen and Alderwomen, and all participants today in this session, a renewed and strengthened spirit to seek the good of the City, its neighborhoods, and families. Grant wisdom and unity in their discernment to manage the complexities of administrating policy, balancing budgets and finance, supporting needed programs for the flourishing of schools, businesses, and public services in Chicago, so we invite your presence and ask for your help. Like King Solomon and for Kings, Chapter 3, we confess with him. He has shown us great kindness, so give your servant a discerning heart to govern your people and distinguish between right and wrong, for who is able to govern this great people of yours. The task of leadership and service can be overwhelming at times, but you are able, o Lord, and you can enable every person here to do good and faithful work. So we lift ourselves to you, this hour, our City, and commend to you the work that we do. And we pray these things in the name of the father, the son, and the Holy Spirit. Amen. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: Amen. You may be seated. Madam clerk, please read the call of the today's special meeting. >> ANNA VALENCIA: The following call for a special meeting on the City Council was filed on November 2nd, at 3:20 p.m. We undersigned members of the City Council of the City of Chicago hereby call a special meeting of the City Council to be convened at 12:00 p.m. on Wednesday, November 18, 2026 for the following purposes and for no other purpose whatsoever. To immediately consider consider O2026-0028873 in order of directing the administration to audit the city vendor that manages or otherwise provides license plate readers with the TRUST act. Respectfully submitted, Daniel La Spata, alder person 1st Ward, Robinson, 4th water, Ramirez, 12th Ward, Rodriguez, 22nd Ward, Fuentes, 26th Ward, Quezada, 35th Ward, Andre Vasquez, 40th Ward, Matthew Martin, 47th Ward, Manaa-Hoppenworth, 48th Ward, and Hadden, 49th Ward. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: Thank you. This is the portion of the meeting for public comments. >> The council will now begin the public comment period which is limited to maximum of 30 minutes. Each speaker is limited to three minutes. Speakers cannot yield or transfer their time to another speaker. Any written comments that have been submitted will be posted and made available for Aldermanic review. Our first speaker this afternoon is Elida Flores followed by Jackie Sample. >> Good afternoon. My name is Elida Flores, and I am here because I have some concerns with the -- with things that are happening in Chicago in public libraries, and also with voter fraud, and I just want to make clear that U.S. sis U.S. citizens of the reasonable ones that should be voting in the United States of America. That's always been common sense to me and to many others, and I think it's wrong that you allow illegal -- I don't hate anybody, okay? I love people, but I know the law and I know that illegal people are not supposed to be voting, okay? It's an agenda that's been happening for decades, okay? The Democratic party has been, you know, the party that has been costing all these divisions, you know, because we just finished up praying to Jesus Christ, and I know what scripture says, okay? I go to the library and I see that they're trying to brainwash children with LGBT stuff. That goes against God, okay? I know what scripture says. So I don't -- you know, I think it's a mockery that if -- I mean, this prayer sounds sincere, but you also have to know scripture, okay? Because what you are allowing -- I don't know if you, Mayor Johnson, or who is, but I go to the library and there's -- they're trying to brainwash children with this nonsense. They have been trying to do it to me when I was little too, and I didn't fall for it, all right? LGBT, abortion, the murder of babies is what it is, okay? And they want to sugar coat it and say, no it's not. It's not. Okay? I know -- I have my body -- I'm a woman, and I recognize that I am a woman. I have my body, but the baby inside me is a separate being, okay? It's not just a clump of cells. It's an actual being that's alive in me, okay? And every women, okay? So I don't buy that nonsense, okay? That -- you're trying to make the women think, you know, that we're trying to control them. No. No. It's not even like that. God loves every baby in the womb. He created every baby in the womb, okay? And this nation is one nation under God, not one nation of under Allah or some other false God, okay? I stand firm in my faith, and I don't care. I'm here just to let you know that many of us are not going to fall for this nonsense, okay? >> Thank you very much for your comments. However, your time has expired. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: Thank you. >> Thank you. Our next speaker is Jackie Sample followed by Jessica Jackson. >> Good morning, everyone. My name is Jackie Sample. Today I want to speak to you about something greater than a courtroom or a case. I want to speak to you about justice, fairness, compassion, and humanity. Judges have on important responsibility. They are entrusted to listen, consider the facts, and make decisions that are -- that deeply affect people's lives . Behind every case is a human being, a family, and a story that a person has a legal right to tell. In addition to justice being about following the law, justice is also about ensuring that every person is treated fairly and afforded due process, dignity, respect, and most importantly, protection of their constitutional rights. The bible reminds us in proverbs 3:31:8. Ensure justice for those being crushed. The scripture reminds us that stand up for those in need and speak out against injustice. My request is that every oversight agency will examine Illinois pending court cases in both State and federal court with open minds and remember that no one is above the law. That includes judges whose conduct is depriving us of our legal property and human rights on a daily basis. Since 2023, my constitutional rights have been consistently violated under the color of law by members of the judiciary. It has been over 1,300 days since my spouse has been allowed to withhold all of my funds, forcing me to remain indigent. That means remain without access to my resource, and other things including health insurance. Judges have have enjoyed impunity since 2023, and William Boyd is following the same path and practice as previous judges I've dealt with. Consistently depriving me of my legal rights under the color of law and causing me significant harm in my case. Justice should never lose its humanity, but it has. It has for me and many other people in the court system. The judiciary's ongoing conduct shows that its members have forgotten that every person deserves due process, equal protection under the law. Galations 6 :2 says, help us with each other's burdens. Help us with the other one's struggles. This is a call to every public official who hears my words. We need you to get involved, take action, and assure that we receive justice. Thank you. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: Thank you. >> Thank you very much for your comments. Our next speaker this afternoon is Jessica Jackson followed by Pastor Sandie A. Norman. >> JESSICA JACKSON: So -- the issue of Chicago flips red, and first of all, let me backtrack. This ordinance that you all are talking about to have an independent person come in and review the statements that were made about the City financials. Personally, I'm against that. And you know why? Because it doesn't need to be a review of statements that were made about the financial status of the City of Chicago. It needs to be a forensic, independent auditor. It does not need to be the Office of Inspector General, the Office of Inspector General does nothing. Let's start with what Weissberg -- Diane Weissberg -- she did absolutely nothing. Let's deal with the fact that the Illinois Attorney General has done absolutely nothing. Let's deal with the fact that, what is it? Eileen Oberg has done absolutely nothing. Let's deal with the fact that you have stacked, like was just said, a bunch of interims, who don't do anything starting with your Corporate Counsel. Why is she there? If she has no authority, so arrest starting with you for cheating in elections. Because it's already been proven that you cheated. Why is she there? According to -- what's her name? Pat Dowell, she came and talked to you about my case and she said there's nothing you can do because you're not appointed yet. Why are you there? You don't want an independent study. You don't want an independent audit because you don't want the issue of this money with illegal immigration to be explored. That's what the issue is, and that's what the issue is with every Alderman in this body. Keep acting like it's about corporation tax. Keep acting like it's about anything except for what it is, how your decisions as the Mayor put this City in the ground with illegal immigration, and every Alderman in here sat back and let you do it. Now since it's time for elections, now everybody want to talk about everything but that still. The same thing with shot spotter. This body should have come against you a long time ago about the fact that you vetoed them when they said to keep shot spotter. Not just because it's election time and now all of a sudden, everybody wanted to seem like they're appalled and they want to speak up for their Wards. This whole body with -- >> Thank you very much for your comments. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: Thank you. >> Our next speaker is Pastor Sandie A. Norman followed by Rayskee Roundtree. >> Thank you to everyone here, this afternoon. My name is Pastor Sandie Norman. I have an organization called life beyond limits and on the street I'm known as my organization is -- chain breakers, and so I want to just first talk about shot spotter. I want you all to know that I'm not just -- I just don't have a CVI organization, but I am a parent of a gunshot victim and survivor, and so I have a balanced perspective, and so in our communities, there are people that because of the trauma, because of retaliation and the things that come along with shootings, there are some people that won't even call the police when there are shootings because they are afraid. And so having shot spotter -- I'm going to say to this council, anything that we can do to save lives, to prevent, you know, tragedy and death, we should be supporting it, and so I'm a supporter of shot spotter. I deal with parents who also like myself, who have, you know, have children that have actually died from shootings in the streets all week, okay? So I deal with these type of things firsthand, not leading from behind a desk, but actually being out there and as a parent, because a lot of times we say well, where are the parents? Well, I am a parent and I'm here, and I'm also a Pastor. I want to say to City Hall today, I had to hire an attorney -- my own attorney because I have a CVI organization, and after a year of constantly requesting access to C -- so I can receive notifications to respond to incidents in our communities, I still don't have access after a whole year. And so when we talk about, you know, forensic audits, we know good and well that City Hall, this is not a Robin Hood story, you know, City Hall where we rob the rich to give to the poor. We know there is corruption, and I see it firsthand even dealing with CVI, and so in some of the communities that I work in, and I know Jason Ervin is gone, but I deal with a lot of the gunshot, you know, victims in his community, and then you have half of the CVI organizations that you give these millions of dollars of funding to, they're nowhere to be found, and so we do need oversight. We do need a forensic audit. It does need to be a check and balance and I'm not, you know, saying that all CVI organizations are bad because we do need CBI, but let's be, you know, honest and transparent. We know that the system is broken, and we know that there's a need for change. I don't want to keep, you know, just seeing all the people that surround you, Mayor Johnson, all of your pastor friends, that's who the funding goes to. Those are the people that run violence prevention. How are you running violence prevention when you can't even get me access after a whole year to CB -- >> Thank you very much for your comments. However, your time has expired. Our next speaker is Rayskee Roundtree followed by Travis. >> Hello. My name is Rayskee Roundtree. It's been a year now since I asked you about my son being abducted and Bill Conway, because my son was abducted in the 34th Ward in the South Loop and I still hasn't got any help. What's going on? It's a judge by the name of Jamie G. Dickler, room 1806 in the Davis Center that's helping people with guardianship fraud because I never received any notice for me to come to court to even say no or yes about my son. So my son is with a non-family member, and he has been getting hurt and no one is reporting it, and I have to get a report through the hospital. So I want to know what's -- what's going on? Y'all not going anything about people getting abducted in your Wards or in the City of Chicago? This is -- this is ridiculous. It's really ridiculous because it's a kid. And I'm the parent. So give me no help. What's going on here? So like So like I said, this happened when I asked you last year about it, still nothing's been done. That's all I need to say. >> Thank you very much for your comments. Our next speaker is Travis followed by George Blakemore. >> Good afternoon. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: Good afternoon. >> I just want to say a lot of Alderman brung up a good point, and I don't know you. I don't have nothing against you, but my concern is, is seeing, like, every time a question or concern come up, you be mute. As a Mayor, you should want to defend yourself and show the proof that you have been actually Mayor. You really let a lot of us down. You know what I mean? We gave you the opportunity to be a Mayor, and I guess you did to the best of your ability, and it's crazy how it's, like, all the talk, but there's nothing really done. Even with the Chicago police, it's not even going back to be reformed of how they deal with peoples. You say about the community and the drugs and all that, but it's nothing. And even with the cameras. Y'all can put flock cameras up and track everybody, but you can't put things in that keep people safe. There's a lot of talk. Everybody is grown and intelligent. You wouldn't be in these offices so why is it so hard to get something done? It don't matter if you're a Democrat or Republican. It's, like, what is the issue? Like, everybody grown with a sound mind so if you can comprehend something, it shouldn't really be nothing, and that's like with everybody. We know it's fraud. We know it's a lot. It might as well just come out because the City is sink. How we got one of the best cities, the most taxes and the worst -- this City supposed to be showing everybody, and nothing against you, but you failed, and as a man and as a human being, you got to take accountability for it. You failed. You failed. Now the people don't do good. You failed, and it's nothing against you. It ain't nothing wrong with saying I failed. You failed. You failed us deeply, and it's nothing wrong, but it's about solving it now, and it's still going back and forth. This stuff probably still don't stop, and it's sad because us -- we the one that bleed. And y'all eat. We starve. Literally starve. You don't have no thing about crime. How we going to fix it? How we going to get the young people -- how we going to do it? How? How we going to get the drug addicts off the street? How? How we don't got facilities for them? Because y'all don't want to pay, because of costs. Drug addicts ain't got no money, so you'll build a senior citizen home, but you won't build nothing for them. Why? Why we can't help people? How -- why we got to life up under the streets? Why? It's crazy. You did do that with the peoples. You found the money for that. There should be nobody homeless here. Nobody. You found money for the immigrants. Why do we live under bridges? Where give them stamps? How you send the police station with a car and you come from a whole other country? They was at the police station -- >> Thank you very much for your comments. Our next speaker is George Blakemore followed by Nat P. >> GEORGE BLAKEMORE: The song goes we shall overcome. [ Singing ] Not Brandon Johnson. Not these black Aldermans. We black people got to overcome. It's something wrong with us. It's something wrong with us. Where's your mama, little girl? Where's your daddy, little boy? Where's your family value? Where's your store? Where's your bank? Are you -- do you have excellence schools where black people had it all. We shall overcome. Not only Brandon Johnson. All of us have failed and never was brought up in a ghetto like this ghetto, and when I came to Chicago from Fort Worth, Texas, Chicago was not a ghetto. They had banks. They had grocery stores. They had love. They had unity. They had excellent schools. Something is wrong with black people. We -- we black people have failed. Something wrong with us! Nothing wrong with these Hispanics, and these whites, and these illegal immigrants. It's something wrong with us. Some of us voted for them to come here. Some of us woo woos voted for them to come here. Some of the black Alderman voted for them to come here. Black man, black woman. I asked that black girl. I said, I want you to help me. I'm here and you're running these stores and stealing. I said, but you got to have your mama and your daddy come up tomorrow and I have to meet them. That little black girl say, mister. Mister, we don't have no daddy. Oh my god. Mister. Mister, we don't have no daddy. It's embarrassing. We are embarrassing. Something's wrong with us. We knew -- our brains have -- who's shooting? Who's doing the shooting? Is it the western ghetto? Is it the white ghetto? Is it the black ghetto? We fight each other. We need each other. Something happened to each other. You can't put 12 blacks in a house and they get along. You can put 50 Mexicans and they're sleeping on the couch, and on the floor and everything, and they help each other. They they help each other. We will never overcome the way we act. All of us. Mr. Blakemore, you too. All of us. That little girl say, mister. Mister, we don't have no daddy. A lot of these people -- >> Thank you very much for your comments. Our next speaker is Nat P. Followed by Zoe Leigh. >> Hello. I'm Nat. I'm here on behalf of black youth project 100 and the spot the shot spotter coalition I'm here to address something that was addressed in the last meeting. So we have a statement on that. While the City of Chicago is $55 billion in debt, while Chicagoans are struggling to afford gas, jobs, send their kids to fully funded schools, our alderpeople are once again are trying to give more millions to another company with the technology that has never proven to do any of the things that all of these alders get up here and say it does. We are once again, trying to advocate for a gamble with the snake oil salesman on a technology that continuously does not do what they said they were going to do. Originally -- because, you know, y'all said it. It's shot spotter, right? It's not gunshot detection. It's shot spotter. Y'all said it. Originally they marketed it as something that could help decrease police response times. Multiple studies showed that was wrong. Then they switched. They said, oh, no, no. We're here to decrease the amount of shootings. That was proven wrong by multiple studies, not just in Chicago. Then they said the talking point that all of these alders up here like Peter Chico, Marty Quin, Cardona, whoever you want to name, hoping it might save a life at some point. That -- no. That's been proven wrong by multiple other studies. What has been proven by the lawsuit against this City, by multiple reports shows that innocent people are stopped and frisked and then put in jail, that this technology does more harm than good. If we look at all of the studies, cool, that's academic. You're going to be the -- oh my god. We don't care about your fancy woo woo, whatever. Cool. I know people. My friends are the people who are getting shot at. My friends are the people who I grew up with, who I've watched, who I play basketball -- they're the people getting shot at. They're the people in these neighborhoods who might be the people doing the shooting too. And you know what would help them? It's not a gunshot detection technology. You know what would help them when they get shot? If they get shot? It would be the ambulance actually arriving. What happens is even with shot spotter, police arrive and then they block off the place. I know people who've died because the police arrived. What happens with shot spotter is that the police arrive much later as proven by multiple studies than they do without it. People are not going missing. People are not -- not counting bodies. Do you know how people -- how this stuff works? A person doesn't just get shot on the street and then it's not counted. They family report it. They people report it. We are talking about lives, and we have to be principal with how we spend our money and continue to invest in root cause solutions. >> Thank you very much for your comments. Our next speaker is Zoe Leigh -- our next speaker is Zoe Leigh followed by Carol Reyes. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: Okay. Let's return back to order. Thank you, please. Our next speaker. >> Yeah. I'm not even in the politics, but I had to be forced to be in the politics because this acting Mayor sent Maurice Robinson to do his job and didn't tell him the truth about the situation that's going on in the black communities, primarily on the south side. When it comes to taking our elders' generational wealth by way of probate, imminent domain, taxes for that land so y'all can continue to steal our TIF money. I want to acknowledge that our acting Corporation Council, Renee Hatcher is the daughter of the late Richard Gordon Hatcher, who became nationally known during the 1967 election over allegations of voter suppression affecting black voters. Today, we're facing serious questions about petition signatures, photocopied pages, signatures, in the 2027 mayoral election. Submitted by Brandon Johnson and Willie Wilson and a host of a lot of y'all because all y'all do is cheat. Also, you have a little clip going around with Maes, no good Jackson, and you discuss all these black-owned businesses that made money off the migrant crisis. You gave one black -owned person a contract, okay? Her name was Raquel Davis, and it was $57 million. Do you know how many businesses closed during Covid? And you could not figure out as a black man, talking about black-owned businesses, well, S2 which is not really a black-owned business continues to set up shop everywhere in our City. Then you gave Bueno Beef the other contract and he's definitely not black and very well off, to feed migrants. Just like you said that you gave $2.5 billion to the south side. $2 billion to the west side, and $10.5 billion downtown. Now I know that that's not true, and you can't solve nothing because you couldn't even solve my issue. When I went on the breakfast club, I purposefully did not say your name because I was in hopes that you would listen to me and then go back and try to figure out the solution. Instead, you got sassy and have continued to ignore us and send your little minions after us. I never switched up. All I asked was you to do your job. If I was the Mayor of Chicago, I would have been figured out my situation. I would have been figured out her situation. Anybody that came -- anybody that was homeless here, come in here. Anybody, I would have figured out -- y'all keep talking about fully funded. I got to go. >> Thank you very much for your comments. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: Thank you. >> Our next speaker is Carol Reyes. >> Aside of the rest of what's going to come out of my mouth, Brandon Johnson, you are a liar, okay? You're a liar. You're a disgrace to the mother that bore you. First of all, Brandon Johnson and Aldermen, almost every one of you, if not, all of you, betrayed your constituents. Do I need to raise my voice here because you can't shut yours? You allowed illegal aliens to move -- to make their homes in this City. You swept them off the streets to that President Trump wouldn't be able to get them easily. In doing so, you displaced your very constituents who are citizens. You made them wait for social services they were entitled to receive, and many still have not received them. Why? Because you gave them every flipping dime that belonged to your constituents. Housing prices increased 30%. You gave the illegal immigrants enough money, resources, and support to live care-free here in the United States, which is not a cheap place to live, okay? This is not a third world country. Better than your constituents with the taxpayer dollars. Them being here is simply about seats, money, and contracts in the billions you gave to your buddies. All of you here. Regarding this meeting, there shouldn't even be a question, and I mean no question, let alone a vote about whether you should disclose the City's expenses. It's common sense. It's not your money. It's the taxpayers' money. Yes, I'm mad, and yes, I'm hot, and yes I'm heated and everybody in this room should feel like that because we're all suffering as a result of it, financially, physically, emotionally. That should be a given. How dare you even raise the question in here? After a number of people have received your nominating petitions, Mayor, and they as well as almost every other candidate -- every candidate running allegedly, having submitted photocopies, every one of you ought to be disqualified. It should be illegal to pay for signatures and you know you all do it. The only candidate who got her signatures face-to-face is Danielle Carter Walters. President Trump, DOJ Attorney General, please review those original nominating petitions for fraud and act accordingly. President Trump, please bring your forces to Chicago. Many babies, women, mothers, and father are dying daily here in Chicago because Chicago is not safe. Because Mayor Johnson and these Aldermen here in Chicago do not care about the senseless violence, they don't care about the lives that are being lost. They don't care about the broken hearts, which will never be restored until they're in Heaven with my -- >> Thank you very much for your comments. Your honor, there are no further speakers that have signed up for the public comment period. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: Thank you very much. This concludes the public comment period. Alders Coleman and Hadden have asked to participate in the remaining portion of this meeting remotely for reasons stated in Rule 59. Clerk, can we confirm their conference online? >> ANNA VALENCIA: Alderman Coleman. >> STEPHANIE COLEMAN: Present. >> ANNA VALENCIA: Alderwoman Coleman is present. Alderwoman Hadden? >> MARIA HADDEN: Present. >> ANNA VALENCIA: Alderwoman Hadden is present. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: Very well. Can I get a motion to approve their participation remotely? It's been moved. In the opinion of the Chair, the ayes have it. Please add those two members to the quorum remotely. As set forth in the letter calling for the special meeting, the only item up for consideration today is item number Or2026- 0228873 wanting the vendor that maintains, manages, or otherwise provides automatic license plate readers to determine City compliance with TRUST act in order to immediately consider this item. We obviously need to suspend the rules. Can I get a motion to suspend the rules? It's been moved. All those in favor of the suspension of the rules, signify by saying aye. Any opposed, say nay. Okay. All right. There is a request for a roll call. Please use your evote application. Once the -- the motion has been withdrawn. All those in favor of the suspension of the rules signified by saying aye. Any opposed, say nay. In the opinion of the Chair, the ayes have it. All right. The rules have been suspended for the motion that has been set forward for the passage of this item. Does anyone wish to speak to this item? The Chair recognizes Alderman Lopez. >> RAYMOND LOPEZ: Thank you, Mr. President. I move to refer this item to the rules committee. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: Chair recognizes Alderman Martin. >> MATTHEW MARTIN: I move to lay that motion on the table. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: Very well. It's -- there's a motion on the floor to refer this item to the rules. There's a motion on the floor for -- for that item to be laid on the table. It's been motioned by Alderman Martin, seconded by Alder Fuentes. Alderman Lopez has requested a roll call vote. Again, if you vote yes to lay the motion on the table, you wish to proceed with the initial original motion. If you vote no, you wish then to not go with the initial original motion, which is of the ordinance. >> The voting is now open. The voting is now open. Please use your edevices. If you're having difficulty, please raise your hand. Okay. I will now call on those who have not yet cast their vote. Alderman La Spata. >> DANIEL LA SPATA: Yes. >> Alderman La Spata is a yes. Alderman Hopkins. Alderman Hopkins, not present in chambers. Alderman Hall. >> WILLIAM HALL: Yes. >> Alderman Hall is a yes. Alderwoman Coleman. >> STEPHANIE COLEMAN: No. >> Alderwoman Coleman is a no. Alderman Moore? >> DAVID MOORE: Aye. >> He's a yes. Alderman Curtis. Curtis is a no. Alderwoman Scott. Alderwoman Scott is a no. Alderman Burnett. Alderman Burnett, not present in chambers. Alderwoman Rodriguez-Sanchez. >> ROSSANA RODRIGUEZ SANCHEZ: Yes. >> Alderwoman Rodriguez-Sanchez is a yes. Alderman Knudsen. >> TIMMY KNUDSEN: Yes. >> Alderman Knudsen is a yes. Alderwoman Hadden. >> MARIA HADDEN: Yes. >> Alderwoman Hadden is a yes. Alderman Hopkins? Alderman Burnett? Yeah. I just reminded them. They missed that one. Alderwoman Coleman is a no. Okay. And Alderman Hopkins votes no. Alderman Burnett? One more time. Okay. Voting is -- voting is now closed. So it's 26-23. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: There are 26 yeas. There are 23 nays. The motion to lay that item -- to lay that item on the table passes. Back to the initial -- original motion. The Chair recognizes Alderman Martin. >> MATTHEW MARTIN: Thank you, Mr. President. I move for passage of this item, and if there is comment, I would reserve the right to close. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: There's a motion for the passage of this item. Does anyone wish to speak to this item before Alderman Martin closes? Seeing no hands, the Chair -- the Chair recognizes Alderman Lopez. >> RAYMOND LOPEZ: Groan all you want. Just for that, I'll go twice. Good afternoon. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: Good afternoon. >> RAYMOND LOPEZ: Mr. President, members of this committee. I know this seems innocuous. Simply asking that we review our cameras being in compliance, but that's already the case, ladies and gentlemen. What we are doing here with this ordinance, with this question is quite literally the same thing we did with gunshot detection technology. Spreading doubt, questioning whether or not technology is working as a tool to keep our communities safe. The fact that we had several members vote against what their own constituents wanted in our last special meeting, when it came to gunshot detection technology, should not be a surprise to any of us, but when we're talking about license plate readers, it is not a secret that those who hate technology, that those who want to uplift criminals, that those who want to forget victims have been waiting for an opportunity to start putting the question mark behind license plate readers. Hiding behind the TRUST act, hiding behind the cause de jour which is migrants. Hiding behind what we know is true, that we can't do this anyway. A deflection of the worst possible kind. What does a license plate reader do? It reads a license plate. How has this been helpful to our community, particularly African American and Latino neighborhoods? It lets us know when we've got rings running around with people with stolen cars. It allows us to understand when we have businesses that are being hit time and time again by people jumping out of vehicles, how do we make the case that they're all connected in our neighborhoods? By license plate readers. I had a young woman who was shot not one month ago at the intersection of 47th and Western by a road rage incident and the only reason we were able to figure out their path is because of license plate readers. The victim was an undocumented mother. Do you think her husband and her surviving six children questioned the use of those plate readers for their benefit? Those cameras are going to bring to justice the individual that shot their mother in front of their child. There are tools that we know work. There are tools that don't care about your skin color, don't care about your gender, don't care about your orientation, they only capture the facts, whether it's a sound, whether it's a photo. It's not a manipulative piece of data, and yet now we are going to go down this path today. We've spent the better part of three years arguing about the last piece of technology that we got rid of for political purposes. We heard today from the frustration of people who have been trying to bring back something that we know works in our neighborhoods, and now we're going to try to turn certain communities against this technology for the hopes of getting rid of it? Because that's ultimately the goal here? I can't be a part of that. It's not simply a review. It's not simply going to end where people say it's going to end. We know what this is about. We continue to see it. We are afraid to catch criminals when we let people who don't have to worry about that make the decisions for us. Colleagues, think twice, long and hard, before you vote yes or no, because you are setting us up down a path that I don't think you really want to go down because when you need someone to figure out who was in your neighborhood doing bad things, you might not have that opportunity, and then you'll have to answer that question as well. Thank you, Mr. President. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: You're welcome. Thank you. The Chair recognizes -- thank you. You're welcome. Chair recognizes Alder Gutierrez. >> JEYLU GUTIERREZ: Right after. Okay. Thank you, Mr. President. In the 14th Ward as in the southwest side and in the whole City of Chicago, we support our police officers, and we also need to bring light and exactly get the people to go to the system if they're not doing right, but we also need to make sure that they receive the resources they deserve because of course, if they're doing that, it's because there's something happening to them or their families, unfortunately. It tells me now, could be blessed of not having that at home. I could tell you I am blessed to now be an Alderwoman. I was blessed to come here with a U.S. permanent residency. I was blessed enough to become a citizen, and I'm blessed to be raising my three daughters at home in the beautiful City of Chicago, but I also understand that not everybody had -- had those opportunities or blessings, and I'm here to continue to work with you all to bring the resources that all these people need and deserve. With what he said -- it's, like, what is she talking about? What is she going to land on? We just need to make sure that those plate readers are really being used for what it's being contracted for. We just need to make sure that we use them for the right thing, that our police officers, our City departments, use that information for what it is, but we also need to make sure that all of our residents in our beautiful City of Chicago not -- not -- not mattering if they're U.S. citizens or not, if they are undocumented U.S. citizens or whatever status may hold, that they also are protected, that that information is not used against them. We just need to make sure, and I'm for as voting yes for this item because we need to make sure that the residents in the City of Chicago, like -- they should pay taxes because they're living in our communities, that they are protected. And there are some other fights that we need to take to Springfield and to congress, and that's why we have some other colleagues fighting those things in other City -- other levels of government, but let's continue to do our work here in the City as Aldermen, and that's why I'm voting yes, because what my colleague is asking with this, is just for an audit. We just need to make sure that that information is nothing new. You know I come from working in the County, and in the County, it's also protections and when I was working with Commissioner Aania, I worked for those protections to happen. We need to continue to make sir that whatever information we have out there, whatever information that is critical about our residents and our families and our kids, it's not used in a way where our kids are going to be exposed and our kids are not going to be able to be with mom and dad when the only thing they're doing is providing ends meet, working to provide them with a better life than the one that they had. So that's why, Mr. President, and colleagues, I'm in support of this. Because we just need to make sure. We're talking about being honest and transparent, right? Let's be honest and transparent with the information that we have. Let's just make sure that it's not used against anybody. Thank you, Mr. President. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: Thank you. The Chair recognizes Alderwoman Hadden. >> MARIA HADDEN: Thank you, Mr. President. I will be supporting this item, and I encourage my colleagues to also support this item. I -- I hear my colleague, Alder Lopez's statements and concerns, and based on, you know, one of the items in our prior meeting, I get -- I get where you're coming from. Like, hey. Maybe folks are trying to take away other tools. Maybe people are -- I hear that. What I'll say is that's not this. Similar to my colleague, Alderwoman Gutierrez's final thoughts there, what we covered in our last meeting and what brought us to special City Council meetings today, I would put into two categories. One is efforts of committing ourselves to action around transparency and accountability, no matter what, and the second is being responsive to the voice of Chicagoans. We know -- we know from -- I know from my 49th Ward constituents, but we know from Chicagoans. We know -- we could look at the November 3rd election results. People do not want the abuse and misuse of data that is collected from technology to go into the wrong hands. Outside of concerns around I.C.E. or inappropriate or illegal actions by our federal government, people want more security around their data, period. I'm someone who supports license plate readers, and in the 24th district, they have been very useful. So to be clear, these have been useful tools in a time where it is difficult to track folks down. We know we have been dealing with the city-wide robberies, right? Car thefts, all kinds of things. These tools have proven themselves to be very useful. We are using them. We should continue to use them. It is my opinion, and just like I supported the review and giving our Finance Chair the review, because we've got questions around what's been happening with finances and the CFO in the Mayor's office. We have demonstrated experience in other cities -- it's been a nationwide issue of certain companies taking this data and having agreements and practices of sharing this data with agencies outside of the -- the municipalities that they serve. We have State Law -- the TRUST act, that we should follow, and that is highly supported by the people of the State of Illinois. So in the spirit of, one, giving the people what they voted for, and two, making sure that we are working on accountability and transparency, that's what this ordinance does. We just need to review to make sure. We're currently not working with company in question, and that's great, which means we're not looking at a disruption of service here. Just to be clear, and we should make sure, especially as we are moving our procurement office, like, our procurement Commissioner, which I voted for, in our previous meeting, to move forward, we need to make sure we're not in a situation with a company that is not in alignment with our values as Chicagoans, and is not doing the will of the people, or that is using the private data collected in the -- in the technology that they're using for what we've hired them for, for additional purposes outside the scope of what we want. This is just good governance, and while I say, you know, again, understand the concerns, I'm sure the lead sponsor there close on this, but I'm sure this is transparency. This is accountability, and it's also keeping in line with what people want. So let's not over -- over-politicize this. This is coming from your colleagues in council, and this is -- this is good legislation. So I encourage and So I encourage an aye vote on this matter. Thank you, Mr. President. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: Thank you. Alderman Sposato, you are recognized. >> Thank you. Let's get on your phone, call your commander. Call whatever area it is, the detective commander and ask them if you think this is a good thing for us to have, and ask them if they think -- if he feels that we use this stuff to go kick doors down of women that had abortions or illegals in here, and drag them out of their and arrest them and everything, this is a good tool. You want safety for your community? This is a tool. What do you think they're going to tell us in a report? Oh, yeah. We use this to terrorize people and everything? No. We know what they use it for. They use it to chase down bad guys mainly on the expressway, and stop this terrorizing of our communities and it's not just the west side or the south side. It's all over. I can assure you. It goes on in the northwest and the southwest sides. This is a great tool. They're not going to come in here and throw dramatics, what you are thinking. You're going to say they're using this for bad things. No. We know what they're using it for. Come on, everybody. This is a much needed tool. This is a charade of trying to have an investigation and want to know what they're doing with this investigation. We know what they're doing. They're getting bad guys. Thank you, Mr. President. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: Thank you. The Chair recognizes Alder Vasquez. >> ANDRE VASQUEZ JR.: Thank you very much, Mr. President. I don't want to repeat too much of what my colleagues have said. Part of it is clear, if we're investing anything that we're putting taxpayer dollars towards, we should be able to know what goals we want -- we are addressing with it, and metrics to track how effective it is. Nothing about auditing that pauses it. Nothing about it stops it from continuing the current service that it has, but I do think we should identify what right can look like, and it would be a good model for all the technology and everything we use. The same by we're asking for transparency and good government, just a meeting ago, this is a same in line. Making sure it's working properly. As the chair of the committee on refugee rights, I tame umbrage to it being referred to as the flavor de jour when it comes to causes. We are in a moment where we know the government is accessing certain information. I don't know how you would track when we access it from us, and so having the same kind of audit makes sense. We've seen systems break down because of artificial intelligence agents and if we don't even know how to protect ourselves from anything like that, we'll succumb to it when these tools are helpful. We use LPRs in the 40th Ward as well. It has helped in some of the robbery cases. No one's saying that everyone's doing bad with it or thinking that someone's going to admit to that, but we do have we do have instances because we pay because police officers shouldn't be officers and they're patrolling and they're police. We have things in place to track when that occurs, to make sure it's working, to figure out what right looks like, and to make sure if we know how to measure those things, that they're getting better with more usage as we spend the tax dollars on it. So I would look at it from that standpoint. This is not anybody trying to shut anything down or stop anything. We just want to make sure it's working. It's working well, and we can continue to make it work better, and if there's things that we find out that lead us to different tools or different solutions, those are all good things for Chicagoans and this council. I'm in support. I would ask my colleagues to do the same. Thank you, Mr. President. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: Thank you. Are there any other alders who wish to speak? Before Alderman Martin closes? Seeing no hands, I recognize Alderman Martin. >> MATTHEW MARTIN: Thank you, and good afternoon, colleagues. I want to be clear this ordinance does two things and two things only. It directs OPSA to see who has access to our contracts, and report back to City Council. It does nothing beyond that. Alderman Sposato, I agree with you in terms of the utility of our automated license plate readers. Where I think we need to go is to ensure that who has access to them are the people who we have told through contracts have access to them. We would not be the first people who are doing this. You know who else did it? The secretary of State's office in the State of Illinois just last year. They did an audit. They concluded that several different entities improperly had access to the State's license plate reader program. They told them, fix it, which I believe that they have, and those readers still stay in place. That's what happened at the State. I also want to emphasize why this audit is needed. This is not hypothetical. In neighboring Cities and States, government employees have used automated license plate reader cameras to stalk ex-partners and private citizens. This is not a hypothetical. This has happened. We need to make sure that doesn't happen here in Chicago. The State of Texas used automated license plate readers in another state to track a State of Texas citizen who was seeking abortion care in another State. That was not hypothetical. That happened. If that were to happen here in Illinois, that would violate the State's law. Not hypothetical. That happened, and it shouldn't and can't happen here. We also know that here in Chicago, technology like this was leveraged against Chicagoans just a few months ago when companies like Flock illegally shared data with immigration enforcement agents. This is not a hypothetical. This happened, and this should not happen moving forward. We all need to know who has access to our sensitive data, and we need to know that it is not being used improperly, whether it's to be sold to private companies, or be used by other governments outside of the State of Illinois in violation of City or State Law. As I mentioned at the outset, this has already been done just last year by the State of Illinois. They found multiple violations. The State still has those ALPRs, and I believe that our State is better and safer because of the audit that the State of Illinois did. I believe that we should do the same thing here in Chicago, and I would respectfully ask for everyone's favorable consideration. And I renew my motion. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: Very well. There's a motion before us to pass this order. All those in favor of the passing of this order -- there's been a request for this motion to be taken up by a roll call vote. Madam clerk, please make the evote application available at this time. City Council members, you can cast your votes once the application is available. >> The voting is now open. The voting is now open. Please use your edevices. Okay. I will now call on those who have not yet cast their vote. Alderman La Spata a. >> DANIEL LA SPATA: Yes. >> Alderman La Spata is a yes. Alderman Hopkins. Alderman Hopkins is a no. Alderman Hall. >> WILLIAM HALL: Yes. >> Alderman Hall is a yes. Alderwoman Coleman . Alderwoman Coleman. Alderman Moore. >> DAVID MOORE: Aye. >> Alderman Moore is a yes. Alderwoman Scott. Alderwoman Scott is a yes. Alderwoman Rodriguez-Sanchez. >> ROSSANA RODRIGUEZ SANCHEZ: Yes. >> Alderwoman Rodriguez Sanchez is a yes. >> Alderman Knudsen. >> TIMMY KNUDSEN: Yes. >> Alderman Knudsen is a yes. Alderwoman Hadden? >> MARIA HADDEN: Yes. >> Alderwoman Hadden is a yes. Alderwoman Coleman. >> STEPHANIE COLEMAN: Yes. >> Alderwoman Coleman is a yes. So Hadden and Coleman are both yeses. Okay. The voting -- Coleman and Hadden are both yeses. Okay . Voting is now closed. 41-9. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: There are -- >> Sorry. 42-8. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: 42 yeas and 8 nays. This motion passes. Alderman Mitchell, on a motion to reconsider. >> GREGORY MITCHELL: Move to reconsider the vote. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: All those in favor of reconsidering this vote, signify by saying aye. Any opposed, say no. This motion fails. Just a second, you all. Just -- just a second. Quiet. Just for a second. Alderman Mitchell, on a motion to return back to the regular order of business. >> GREGORY MITCHELL: Move that we return back to the regular order of business. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: All those in favor of returning to the regular order of business, signify by saying aye. Very well. A motion to adjourn? >> GREGORY MITCHELL: I move that we adjourn. >> MAYOR BRANDON JOHNSON: Hearing no objections, so ordered. The meeting is adjourned. Thank you all.. [ Meeting adjourned ]