item that poses a potential safety hazards, as determined by the sergeant-at-arms, is prohibited in the gallery. Such items include, but are not limited to, 1. Any pointed objects, including knives of any kind. 2. Banners, flyers or other forms of signage. 3. Food and beverages, including in glass or metal canisters. 4. Backpacks, large bags, and sealed packages. Clear bags, not tinted in color, that do not exceed 12 inches by 6 inches by 12, are permitted and subject to search. And 5. Firearms, ammunition, fireworks, laser pointers, stun guns, tasers, mace pepper spray, and toy weapons. Cell phones and other small handheld recording devices must be placed in silent mode, can only be used while seated, and can only be used in a manner that does not interfere with the ability other individuals to view or hear the proceedings. Individuals or groups failing to adhere to these rules will be subject to removal from the remainder of the meeting by the sergeant-at-arms. City of Chicago City Council Rules of Conduct for Public Meetings 2023 to 2027 pursuant to rule 58 of the chicago city council rules of order and procedure the sergeant at arms sets forth the following rules of conduct for members of the public these rules shall be in effect at all times that a viewing gallery or room is open for a meeting of the city council or any of its committees all individuals and their belongings are subject to search at entry or upon request. Individuals must remain seated at all times except, one, when entering or exiting the gallery. Two, when providing public comment. two when providing public comment during the portion of a meeting set aside for that purpose or three when asked to rise and be acknowledged by a member of the city council profane threatening harassing abusive or defamatory behavior or speech which in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the sergeant at arms may lead to a breach of the peace or disrupt the orderly conduct of the meeting is not permitted. Disruptive or distracting actions, such as the stomping of feet, waving of arms, throwing any item, whistling, booing, shouting, or other loud utterances, are not permitted when in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the sergeant-at-arms, such actions are disrupting or impeding the orderly conduct of the meeting. Any item that poses a potential safety hazards, as determined by the sergeant-at-arms, is prohibited in the gallery. Such items include, but are not limited to, 1. Any pointed objects, including knives of any kind. 2. Banners, flyers or other forms of signage. 3. Food and beverages, including in glass or metal canisters. 4. Backpacks, large bags and sealed packages. Clear bags, not tinted in color, that do not exceed 12 inches by 6 inches by 12 are permitted and subject to search, and 5. Firearms, ammunition, fireworks, laser pointers, stun guns, tasers, mace pepper spray, and toy weapons. Cell phones and other small handheld recording devices must be placed in silent mode, can only be used while seated, and can only be used in a manner that does not interfere with the ability other individuals to view or hear the proceedings. Individuals or groups failing to adhere to these rules will be subject to removal. adhere to these rules will be subject to removal from the remainder of the meeting by the sergeant at arms city of chicago city council rules of conduct for public meetings 2023 to 2027 pursuant to rule 58 of the chicago city council rules of order and procedure the sergeant at arms sets forth the following rules of conduct for members of the public these rules shall be in effect at all times that a viewing gallery or room is open for a meeting of the City Council or any of its committees. All individuals and their belongings are subject to search at entry or upon request. Individuals must remain seated at all times except 1. when entering or exiting the gallery. 2. when providing public comment during the portion of a meeting set aside for that purpose. Or 3. When asked to rise and be acknowledged by a member of the City Council. Profane, threatening, harassing, abusive, or defamatory behavior, or speech, which in the judgment of the meeting's chair, or the sergeant at arms, may lead to a breach of the peace, or disrupt the orderly conduct of the meeting, is not permitted. Disruptive or distracting actions, such as the stomping of feet, waving of arms, throwing any items. feet, waving of arms, throwing any item, whistling, booing, shouting, or other loud utterances, are not permitted when in the judgment of the meeting's chair, or the sergeant-at-arms, such actions are disrupting or impeding the orderly conduct of the meeting. Any item that poses a potential safety hazards, as determined by the sergeant-at-arms, is prohibited in the gallery. Such items include, but are not limited to, 1. Any pointed objects, including knives of any kind. 2. Banners, flyers or other forms of signage. 3. Food and beverages, including in glass or metal canisters. 4. Backpacks, large bags and sealed packages. Clear bags, not tinted in color, that do not exceed 12 inches by 6 inches by 12, are permitted and subject to search. And 5. Firearms, ammunition, fireworks, laser pointers, stun guns, tasers, mace pepper spray, and toy weapons. Cell phones and other small handheld recording devices must be placed in silent mode, can only be used while seated, and can only be used in a manner that does not interfere with the ability other individuals to view or hear the proceedings. Individuals or groups failing to adhere to these rules will be subject to removal from the remainder of the meeting by the sergeant-at-arms. City of Chicago City Council Rules of Conduct for Public Meetings, 2023-2027 Pursuant to Rule 58 of the Chicago City Council Rules of Order and Procedure, the Sergeant-at-Arms sets forth the following rules of conduct for members of the public. These rules shall be in effect at all times that a viewing gallery or room is open for a meeting of the City Council or any of its committees. All individuals and their belongings are subject to search at entry or upon request. Individuals must remain seated at all times except, one, when entering or exiting the gallery. Two, when providing public comment during the portion of a meeting, set aside for that purpose. Or three, when asked to rise and be acknowledged by a member of the City Council. profane threatening harassing abusive or defamatory behavior or speech which in the judgment of the which in the judgment of the meeting's chair, or the sergeant at arms, may lead to a breach of the peace, or disrupt the orderly conduct of the meeting, is not permitted. Disruptive or distracting actions, such as the stomping of feet, waving of arms, throwing any item, whistling, booing, shouting, or other loud utterances, are not permitted when in the judgment of the meeting's chair, or the sergeant at arms, such actions are disrupting or impeding the orderly conduct of the meeting. Any item that poses a potential safety hazards, as determined by the sergeant-at-arms, is prohibited in the gallery. Such items include, but are not limited to, 1. Any pointed objects, including knives of any kind. 2. Banners, flyers, or other forms of signage. 3. Food and beverages, including in glass or metal canisters. 4. Backpacks, large bags, and sealed packages clear bags not tinted in color that do not exceed 12 inches by 6 inches by 12 are permitted and subject to search and five firearms ammunition fireworks laser pointers stun guns it's not a formal gavel but we can do the committee on immigrant and refugee rights will now come to order today we have three items on the agenda two rule 45 reports and a subject matter hearing on the work of the community commission for public safety and accountability regarding police interaction with federal immigration enforcement agents votes will not be taken on any items aside from the two rule 45 reports we will begin with the roll call to establish quorum alder woman dow alder woman gutierrez Alderwoman Gutierrez, Alderperson Knudsen, Alderperson Rodriguez, Alderperson Fuentes, Alder Tellyferro, Alderwoman Cruz, Alderman Cardona, Alderwoman Rodriguez-Sanchez, Alderman Casada, Alderwoman Manal Hoppenworth, Alderwoman Haddon, vice chair taylor and myself there are seven members present we have a quorum alder persons dowell quesada fuentes uh uh and cruz uh option for committee hearing attendance in accordance with rule 59 of the city council rules of order can i get a motion to allow them to attend this hearing virtually so moved by alderman rodriguez sanchez here are no objections, so ordered. At this time, we'll begin the public comment period. The period is limited to 30 minutes. Out of respect for everybody's time, each speaker is limited to three minutes. Remote speakers will comment first, followed by those in person. As of 1030 a.m. Wednesday, July 16th, 2026, zero callers have requested to speak today, so we will move on to in-person speakers. Our first speaker will be Mr. George Blakemore. In the city of Chicago. to see only one black Altman here. When several, most of all our Altman voted for illegal immigrants, illegal means people that didn't go through immigration and naturalization. The only one that's present is Tyler Farrow, and he voted for it too. I've been traumatized down here. When this room was just packed with illegal immigrants and people advocating for these people to come and get jobs, goods, and service that the Native Americans, enslaved in America, couldn't get. So I don't see any of our black alternates here but one. And the seats are all empty because the illegals got everything that they wanted. So they didn't have to show up. it's not 12 of them here and then the last quest it's Vasquez sir wait shut up this is my time you the one that drug me out like a Georgia slave you you the one that took my minutes away and gave them you say because of the immigrants it was packed each one of you committed people have the same rules you don't have one rule for your committee and another gonna have another rule for their committee. So it's a sad day in the city of Chicago that the black people are not here. And then some of them are advocating for flip red or go red because this is an all-democratic cesspool. Well, this bird has two wings, the Democrat and the Republican. And I am advocating for killing both of those birds with one stone. And that stone I'm advocating on is go black. Go black. And do for self. Self-preservation is the first law of nature. And these people seem to be selfish. These other people are. You don't have to love nobody but you. Your nappy hair, your big nose, your thick lips, and your black hole. That's all you have to do is be selfish. do is be selfish. And I advocate for my people to be selfish. Self-preservation is the first law of nature. Advocating for you. Advocating for yourself. So it's a sad day. Look how empty these feet. And look at no altruists are here. But the illegals got what they wanted. so they didn't have to show up and show out. Thank you, Mr. Blakemore. Our next speaker is Zoe Lee. Hello, this is Zoe Lee from CFR. And this is immigration and refugee rights. I've been coming to this meeting since the first day was put together in 2023 when it was Andre Vasquez And then we have Beatrice Ponce de Leon that has hidden somewhere as the deputy mayor of immigration and refugee rights. And then Christine Paceon-Zayas, I think that's how you say her last name, that is chief of staff now for Brandon Johnson. And actually is giving the black women in his administration a problem, you know, since he's so blickety-blickety black. now i know that you guys are not having another meeting until december or something like that because it's election season and y'all can't have us on this mic i get it dayo carter walters for mayor 2027 we need these signatures so she can get on this ballot we had 28 shelters in this city in this city. $700,000 a day. One was in Streeterville, Vasquez. You were running that shelter. You also were running the standard shelter that was downtown. A lot of people that were in the nightlife, they go out. I know a lot of, like I said, y'all didn't know who I was, But I know a lot of promoters and all that that was getting knocked upside their head during them times because you had all them illegals downtown robbing them. And every time they went to the police, they couldn't get any help because they're all not U.S. citizens. But y'all were paying $700,000 a day. Now, some of these shelters was ran for three to four years. When you look at it, that's twenty eight billion dollars. Where that money at? Because we have twenty two thousand four hundred and thirty eight CPS students that are unhoused. None of y'all could help me or Miss Jessica with our property issue. But y'all had twenty eight billion to get to some illegals to house. Danielle Carter Walters for mayor. Thank you for your comments. Next up, Ms. Jessica Jackson. So you probably shuffled those sheets so that these illegals can talk last and then people feel for their hearts. But the reality is this. The city of Chicago is in a real bad. in a real bad way in every way now because of illegal immigration. Our money is all messed up because it went to a bunch of people who had not poured any money into this city, but they took billions of it out. It made a mockery of our police because people were allowed to attack federal agents that were sent here by the government to get illegal immigrants out of this city, something that the city, the state of Illinois, had percentages that showed that it was more Republican votes here in the last election that had been in the state of Illinois and the city of Chicago for decades. So that meant that there was X amount of people here in the city of Chicago and the state of Illinois that wanted our president, Donald J. Trump, to do exactly what his campaign promises were, and that was to engage in mass deportation with these sanctuary cities. In order to get all this money for sanctuary cities, we witnessed Alderman Carlos Ramirez Rosa, cheat this entire city by sabotaging the vote to get it on a referendum if this city wanted to remain a sanctuary city or not. We were all as citizens of the city of Chicago suppressed. Our vote got suppressed by Rosa and what was the result? He ended up getting promoted to the Park District. All these illegal immigrants here have not improved the quality of life in this city this city for all the money that was spent on them. So now, for Famous Friday, Mayor Brandon Johnson at one o'clock in the afternoon tomorrow, we're inviting you Mayor Johnson. We're going to do Famous Friday on Mayor Brandon Johnson. We're inviting him, Chicago Flips Red is inviting him to come to the link and defend his sorry mayorship here give him the opportunity to answer to us give him the opportunity to answer to the black community how he warned the black community to save a bunch of illegal immigrants how he warned the chicago police department how he warned our money for generations to come answer for you thank you very much our next speaker joanna raymond My name is Johanna Raymond. I'm an attorney. I live and work in Chicago. I'm also a rapid responder. I'm here today on behalf of Indivisible Lincoln Square, along with Illinois Fighters Against Fascist Overreach, which advocates for holding federal immigration officials accountable, as well as those who collaborate with them. We support this committee's advocacy for the towing ordinance, and we'll work to support it as we work to support the disclosure amendment to the procurement ordinance as to that procurement amendment we urge this committee to involve itself amendment we urge this committee to involve itself in the rules that are drafted to implement it the details will matter we urge this committee to stay involved in the ccpsa selection of candidates for the police commissioner superintendent snelling falsely claimed the cpd could not investigate potential crimes committed by federal agents then the cpd falsely claimed that cpd could investigate but only if a formal complaint was made no candidate should be put forward unless they commit to the cpd investigating any potential violation of illinois law by federal law enforcement without condition period full stop on the issue of collaboration between the cpd and federal immigration officers i understand this committee is considering an amendment to the welcoming city ordinance that would require CPD to deny support to any request and to report it. I ask the committee to take care in pursuing this. I certainly agree with the aim. However, I do have some concerns. First, the welcoming city ordinance already prohibits the CPD from cooperating with federal agents in civil immigration enforcement. So it really just adds a CPD reporting requirement. Second, practically speaking, federal agents are smart enough not to ask CPD to help with civil immigration enforcement. Based on a FOIA request we issued, what they did during the Midway Blitz was to call CPD and say that they were being threatened by residents that were gathering to witness and protest their actions. The problem was that the CPD came out and just watched and policed the residents and did nothing while federal agents were trespassing, threatening residents and assaulting them. My third concern is that CPD officers that are illegally collaborating with federal enforcement agents aren't going to report it that they were asked and so this isn't really going to provide any useful information and my final concern is that the welcoming city ordinance was the result as this committee knows of years of negotiation and compromise offering amendments could potentially open that up to chipping away at it by opponents. I hope this committee is speaking with ICER and Fred Sow about the perils of this. But I applaud the work of this committee going forward. And I will add, based on former comments today, I am the daughter of an immigrant, and I think immigrants make this country the great country that it is. Thank you. Thank you very much. Our next speaker is Ellen Palmer. This is going to be very fast. The person who just preceded me, I second all of what she said. I come from immigrants, and my grandparents were immigrants, and I feel that they give more back than they take. And I also feel that we can do, as a city, we can do better to take care of everybody. With regard to the police interacting with immigrants and ICE and DHS, I would like to see that they get some training as to how to walk that line, because I understand that it is a line that they have to walk. And just remembering that the motto that they're here to serve and protect applies to all residents, regardless of their immigration status. Thank you. thank you very much our next uh before that i'd like to mark alderwoman hadden alderwoman gutierrez both president for quorum our next speaker is james mccoy all right i thought more people were going to be here today i think this is very disappointing to see to be honest because i think this is an interesting subject when i see the support for immigrants and refugee rights for immigrants and refugee rights i find it very hypocritical because i don't see anything equivalent to this for black chicago black people who are the foundation of the city who are the foundation of the country there is no type of commission or any set aside anything like this for black people these people who are here advocating for immigrants would not be here let's be very honest would not be here if this was just about black people Now, we're supposed to talk about holding federal officers accountable and holding ICE accountable, but nobody's talking about holding police accountable when they're doing things to black people. And a large reason for that is because a lot of the police who are doing things to black people are Hispanic. About a week ago, not even that, you all have voted, city council have voted for a quarter of a billion dollars, $260 million, $260.8 million for a lawsuit for wrongful convictions of black residents in Chicago by a Hispanic cop, Gravira, or something. I'm not trying to mispronounce his name, but that, yeah, you're shaking your head so you know exactly. Yet we don't see nothing like this for the black residents here. Black residents get ignored, and yet when it comes to immigrants, Now it's time to talk about immigrant rights and refugee rights and how immigrants make this country better, legal or illegal, whether they're supposed to be here or not supposed to be here. We do know that the Foundation Black Americans are supposed to be here, yet we don't have anything where the city specifically and exclusively addresses their grievance like the city makes sure they do for immigrants and what you all call refugees, refugees, which are people who are just here for economic opportunity. That does not make them a refugee by definition. We know that. Alright? So, I think we should re-change, we should change the name a little bit. But what I'm saying is I want every, I wish everybody was here, I wish more people were more people were here, because this is very disappointing to see. This is very disappointing, especially for Brandon Johnson, who claims to be a descendant of slaves, yet he's not doing anything for the actual descendants of slaves in this country. Yet we see him bending over backwards for refugees and for immigrants. Despite the fact that there's nobody here, people are going to see this. This is why the black Chicago is turning differently now. This is why you don't see black people supporting Brandon Johnson, why his approval rating is so low. This is why you don't see black people supporting the Democratic Party as a whole, period. And you guys are going to see what this midterms is going to be very disappointing for you all. You're going to see what the next mayoral election and the next presidential election. Thank you. Thank you for your comments. Our next speaker is Mary McCarthy. Hi, I am Mary, and I'm representing Indivisible Lincoln Square this morning. Indivisible Lincoln Square is advocating for, sorry, Indivisible Lincoln Square is advocating for transparency and accountability regarding ICE enforcement activities. And right now there are three things that this means. We encourage CCPSA to recommend candidates for CPD superintendent that are knowledgeable and sympathetic to the concerns of Chicago's immigrant residents. and ready and willing to investigate cases against ICE officers that violate the law. Number two, we want to see an amendment to the Municipal Code 2173020B that ensures that if CPD, Office of the Emergency Management and Communications, the mayor's office or any other department receives a request from ICE, HSI, CBO, or from ICE, HSI, CBO, or any other successor agency to provide civil enforcement assistance or notification that that request will be denied and full documentation of any such request will be reported to city council. This amendment currently sits in rules and we want it to be brought to a vote. And number three, finally, we want to see an amendment to the towing ordinance. 202-602-3361, and that authorizes the city to remove and secure cars and personal belongings left by detained immigrants at no cost to their families. We appreciate that the city council has voted unanimously to pass the Immigration Enforcement Disclosure Act last month, and also that they negotiated hard to ensure that the parking meter vendor is required to divest OmniAir. Those are great first steps that we appreciate and we have so much more to be done. Thank you very much. Thank you very much. Our final speaker is Cole Chief. How you doing? Yeah, I ain't come up here, you know what I'm saying, for a whole lot. I came up here to bear witness because a lot of things I already know. Like, I know that you aware, like I'm aware, and I know you allow, like I wish that it wouldn't. See, I live over east, and on Commercial Avenue, you spent about $178 million on fixing up the street in less than two years, but I've been living over there for 53 years since we moved from the west side. You wouldn't even spend $50,000 on a pothole. I know you don't care, but now that it's getting gentrified, the neighborhood changing... But now that it's getting gentrified, the neighborhood changing, you hooking stuff up, and that ain't cool. You see, it's like as if I got to assimilate, and I'm a foundational black American. That ain't how it worked, you know what I'm saying? And it's the immigrants, it's the immigrants that's assimilating, but they ain't assimilating the right way. They ain't learning the language. They ain't learning how to relate with their brothers and sisters. You dig what I'm saying? They learning how to hold them cannons and blow them foppers, because I was on 87 and commercial and I leave not even two minutes and people got hurt. And it was immigrants that did it. And I know they was immigrants because they wasn't foundational black Americans. You see what I'm saying? My only reason I'm here because like I said I know that you allow things. You know what I'm saying? And what I'm saying you allow last time I was here when I say you, I mean you, all of y'all. I'm saying y'all allow a young dude to get down on an elderly sister, an older sister. And that ain't cool because I know you wouldn't allow me to do that yo immigrants put a case on me as a young man so I've been to jail you know I'm saying but now I'm out of jail and I ain't scared that's why I'm here I ain't here to talk to you I'm here cuz if I see somebody step to an elderly sister I'm a flottish joint and then when I get to the county I'm gonna fly that joint you see I'm saying but I need y'all to get on top of things that's going on and show some love for us because we've been here and we've been working hard we've been nice and I ain't got nothing against immigrants like it's The young lady right there, she was just real nice to me. Told me that, you know what I'm saying, she felt sorry for me, the way that the immigrant police just treated me when I was coming to South City Hall. You know what I'm saying? Y'all ain't really the nicest people to us, because when we moved over east in 1973, three years before that, the immigrants and the Europeans had a fight for a beach. They was fighting for that neighborhood. But when I got there, one of the first black families, they unified, came against us. One would have thought the immigrants would have came to us. like yeah brothers I'm glad you here we can get out on them or you know we can find not our numbers though we can all talk and things can get greater but they can get greater, but they ain't do that. They assimilated again the wrong way. They got up with the Europeans. You know what I'm saying? The Europeans that came against me, the foundational black American who made you all welcome and took these knives in the back. I ain't even got to use the last 15 seconds, because I'm saying, I see it's a lot of people up here that agree with that, but that's cool. I want you to know I don't, and as long as I don't, I'm a stand on business. Promise you that. Ain't nobody better than ever stepped in no old lady, no old lady, because I'm going to fly the joint wherever I'm at. That's all. Thank you for your comments. Thank you to all of our speakers today. We would like to note that this committee received zero written public comments. There being no speakers, the public comment period is concluded. The first item on the agenda before our committee is to approve the June 2026 Rule 45 report. Can I get a motion to approve? So moved by Alderman Gutierrez. Hearing no objections, so ordered. The second item on the agenda before our committee is to approve the July 2026 Rule 45 report. Can I have a motion to approve? So moved by Alderman Knudsen. Hearing no objections, so ordered. I will now begin our next item, which is a discussion about the Community Commission for Public Safety and Accountability and their efforts in trying to make sure there's accountability related to ICE and CPD interactions. for background a number of you may know or may not in the last term a number of city council members including myself worked to pass the empowering communities for public safety ordinance which created the community commission for public safety accountability composed of two bodies a district council that is comprised of 66 members three representing each police district and a commission made of seven members we moved that ordinance in the interest of having more police accountability uh in reference to the murder of laquan mcdonald uh some of the misconduct cases just as was referred to earlier today that we continue to pay a year referred to earlier today, that we continue to pay year over year, hundreds of millions of dollars for misconduct and treatment of Chicagoans by people who shouldn't be policed to begin with. In that time, I don't think any of us envisioned we'd be in the world we are now, where the federal government is actively invading cities, targeting neighbors, tear gassing streets, kidnapping residents and in having an understanding of how the city interacts in our own government interacts when the federal government is here uh keeping in accordance with the welcoming city ordinance there's a new value for having the ccpsa uh in the point in the time where sometimes we find challenges in this council and in the city government to get some of the accountability that we need we've had to move legislation to require certain data we've had to push to get information related to those interactions. We haven't received all that information, even as we have executive orders moving forward that one would imagine would supply that for us. To have a different level of government around to be able to similarly push from a different angle with a different level of purview, I think is a benefit to Chicagoans everywhere, not just for the increased public safety of everybody in it, but also for the bottom line and for the taxpayers. And so in that interest, we will begin our subject matter hearing on the work of the Community Commission for Public Safety and Accountability regarding police interaction with federal immigration enforcement agents. With us, we have 17th District Councilor Elizabeth Rochford. We have 9th District Councilor Aaron Vogel. We have Charles Isaacs, Deputy Director to the District Councils. Angel Ruby Navarillo, Commissioner and Vice President of the CCPSA Commission. Angelique Guzman, Commissioner of the CCPSA, and Adam Gross, Executive Director of the CCPSA. So we'll now open it up so that you all can present. Is that okay? Yeah, thank you. Good morning, everyone. everyone my name is aaron vogel i am a district counselor from chicago's ninth police district i'm joined here by my lovely colleague elizabeth rochard from the 17th district first off want to thank you all for being here and thank the committee for inviting us to share more today um moving on forward we have a lot to get through um and so if you see anything in our slides that you have more questions on please just ask today we're going to be giving a high level summary of all the work that we've done in the past three and a half years so elizabeth rochford 17th district counselor um so as you heard um from the chair uh the ccpsa was established in 2021 he has a separate member appointed commission that oversees cpd and um copa and the police board and our commission colleagues will give more update on what their function is um it also includes three district counselors in each of the 22 police districts who were elected with you in 2023 to represent their communities on local policing and safety issues. And there will be a new group of district counselors elected in 2027. So district counselors play two big roles. On a local level, we are focusing on the communities that we serve. The other is a citywide focus, and that is on guiding the commission through recommendations. On a local level, it's our job to help residents raise and work to address policing and public safety concerns. And I just want to note here that public safety is a general term and does not specifically refer to the police. It is our job to work with both how the police engage community as well as how we increase safety for all Chicagoans throughout the city. One of the tools that we have at our disposal is CPD's 2025. disposal is CPD's 2025 GEO 111. That allows us as district counselors to have monthly check-ins with command staff, but it also allows us to call on CPD to participate in our discussions at our monthly meetings, as well as to present at our meetings. And so one of the tools that my district recently used geo 111 for it was to invite the bia to present at our meeting this month one thing that the geo 111 allows us to do is to request information that goes beyond just foia so we can request data documents and information from cpd zooming out looking at a um at a city wide level okay our role is advocacy and input it is not to create policy that is the commission's job it is our job to send recommendations and propose annual priorities to the commission and the commission has the authority to draft review approve general order policies that are not under the consent decree. Under the ordinance, though, district counselors may make policy recommendations, but that's not specific just to general orders. It can be applied to any policies. One of the other things that we do is to bring up, discuss citywide trends and concerns. So later on in our presentation, we'll show how immigration concerns became a predominant trends amongst amongst the districts. One other note here on GEO 111, it allows us to request data beyond just our district. And then the commission also has access to the same GEO 111 tools. So you may be asking yourselves, how is immigrant support relevant to our district council role? It's literally in the ordinance. in the ordinance the ordinance calls on district counselors to address local concerns including police interactions with quote people of all immigrant statuses and it also calls on us to work to ensure that perspectives and experiences of non-citizens are reflected in our dc work the call for dcs to work on immigration began from the time of our inauguration when new arrivals began to be sent to the police stations we will lay out the work at each stage since then including our work around midway blitz and beyond so our communities called on many of us to support the mutual aid that was being done answer questions and concerns and support copa complaints about treatment of volunteers and the new arrivals actually going into those police stations because the new arrivals were unhoused they were more susceptible to being victims of crime and violence and we stepped up to provide avenues for safety when we learned that increased ice presence was coming because of the 2024 elections dc's requested guidance from staff so staff developed and provided resources for us to share many district counselors held trainings on things like temporary guardianship and know your rights as well as the cpd special order around immigration enforcement the toolkit is included in what was sent to the committee and has lots of materials from organizations around the city as well as materials developed by this committee so this time last year is when operation midway blitz was really heating up district counselors like best District counselors, like Beth shared, were equipped with the tools to help keep our neighbors safe. I'm not sure if you all recall, but there was a news article on the drop of 911 calls. And on the ground, what we saw was that community members were afraid to call the police. So we knew that it was important to engage with CPD on building trust at a time where ICE was severely hurting that trust. and for a lot of us mutual aid work from the get-go did not stop when operation midway blitz came through a lot of our district counselors including a lot of people in our working group participated in rapid response efforts as well as school support and I just want to name here that two of our district counselor colleagues were detained by federal immigration agents So that leads us into our work to hold CPD accountable. As the terror of Operation Midway Blitz on our communities continue, district counselors organized to call on the commission to hold a hearing on possible CPD and ICE interaction. We did that by sending a letter that can be found in your materials to the commission. That letter was sent on November 13th. We were calling on them to hold a hearing. That letter was signed by both a majority of district councils and district counselors. Nearly a month after that letter was sent, a meeting with working group members happened with CCPSA President Terry, where, again, the request of a special hearing was reiterated. About a week after that meeting, what we deemed as a lack of urgency from the commission, district counselors submitted over 2,000 petitions, thus triggering a special meeting. In that letter, you will see that we called for the questioning of Superintendent Snelling, panel of subject matter experts, information requested by CPD for them to or information requests sent to CPD, as well as presence of all district commanders to hear directly from the superintendent so everybody could hear the information all at the same time. So we have established after that letter was sent, we established a working group, a working group for welcoming city. This is a working group comprised of district counselors and our members are from all over the city and represent districts that have really experienced the presence of federal immigration agencies. And what's our vision? We envision the commission to ensure that CPD follows the welcoming city ordinance and avoids ICE collaboration and moreover that there's accountability measures put in place for any potential collaboration. We also want the Commission to ensure that CPD addresses broader safety concerns of Chicago's immigrant communities. So moving on to our request to a hearing, once those petitions were submitted that triggered a 21-day window for a special hearing to take place. What we got instead was on January 8th we had a listening session that was held at Thalia Hall where we had over 1,500 attendees both in person and virtually um from there the commission announced plans to have a hearing in February and said that they would be taking DC input so what our group did was to advocate for a hearing with subject matter experts we provided the commission with recommendations for these subject matter experts locations for the meeting to be held a meeting format peacekeepers to be peacekeepers to be present at this meeting, key questions to ask panelists, and information to request from CPD. So after months of planning and still not having a hearing date set, district counselors set a letter of recommitment, which is also included in your materials, that was signed by even more district counselors than our original letter. The outcome of that was an April 2nd hearing, which is also on the first day of Passover and Holy Thursday, with only the superintendent present, not any of the panelists. Moving on from that hearing, though, as previously stated, one of our responsibilities is to identify city-wide trends and concerns and to discuss them at our quarterly meetings. So you'll see here that the trends show that CPD interaction with federal immigration agencies has been a consistent top trend for district councils. And this info comes from our district council monthly reports and all this can be accessible on ccpsa's website so to continue our work advocating for the immigrant community we did outreach to many local organizations it was an intentional process to get their input on how the next superintendent will impact them we drafted a letter for the commission that is also in the materials sent to the committee with recommendations that will were created and endorsed by many of these organizations that ask the candidates questions the immigrant community cares about most recently we have heard about and seen video evidence of ice in city parking lots because of this many district counselors have joined this working group we then have joined this working group we then reached out to the commission and mayor's office to get answers about these violations of the illinois trust act and the executive orders we have asked for updates on what the commission and the mayor's office are doing around this issue and what is learned from the questions sent to the department and again the letter is included in your packet um from that letter the commission stated that they are reviewing our requests and the mayor's office stated they are working to get answers and have offered time to meet with us next week we can keep this committee updated on what we hear from both cpsa and the mayor's office so what's next for district councils and specifically our working group and where are we headed we are committed to supporting the commission's strategic priority around immigrants the commission and i'm sure they'll talk more about it commission recently adopted a resolution to hold quarterly hearings on immigration issues related to public safety and police accountability this presents our working group with a key opportunity to engage with the commission on the work that we have been doing for the past three and a half years we also are looking forward to working with the new superintendent hope the commission takes our recommendations and to do more work with the committee on immigrant and refugee rights as well as the mayor's office of community safety and i think most importantly knowing that our term ends in may is to transition this work and the the foundation that we've created to the next class of district councils thank you for listening thanks thank you very much uh to you both um my understanding is we have uh as well a statement from commissioner ruby navarillo about the commission's kind of a take on everything that's been happening yes uh good morning chairman vasquez morning chairman vasquez vice chair taylor and members of this committee thank you for inviting the ccpsa the community commission for public safety and accountability to testify today on an issue that is deeply important to our city and the communities we serve i also want to thank our dc's for their presentation today and for their continued leadership and advocacy on this issue i'm here today with the ccpsa but this issue is also deeply personal for me i'm an immigrant and a DACA recipient. And so I completely understand the uncertainty and fear that many families in the city are facing. These past two years have been extremely challenging for us. Aggressive operations by the federal immigration enforcement agents have put our communities in a state of constant fear. Rather than making our city or country any safer, this overreach has directly traumatized families, resulting in unjust detentions, targeting individuals with no criminal record and leading to tragic preventable loss of life the resulting climate of fear has forced hard-working residents to stop sending their children to school to skip vital medical and court appointments and has harmed our local immigrant-owned businesses that serve as a backbone of our communities i'm here today to speak with the committee about how we can work together to ensure the safety of chicago's residents i'm also here to outline the steps we have taken to ensure that cpd is complying with the welcoming city ordinance and that officers receive the training and resources necessary to respond effectively to these challenging and unprecedented situations before i begin i do want to acknowledge the commission should and could have moved faster in its oversight responsibilities the community deserved a timely response from us although we met regularly in the fall of 25 with the district council working group to plan a hearing, and although we took the recommendations on format and location seriously, developing an appropriate response involved real challenges and internal disagreements, and the availability of panelists slowed our progress significantly. progress significantly. The commission was created to address systemic issues rather than investigate individual incidents. As immigration enforcement activity in Chicago increased, concerns emerged that CPD officers were not consistently following the welcoming city ordinance or the related CPD directive. In response, the commission has focused on evaluating and improving CPD's policies, training, and accountability systems to ensure the department complies with the ordinance and upholds Chicago's commitment as a welcoming city. We appreciate the opportunity today to reaffirm the commission's commitment to stronger and more responsive oversight. We are grateful to the committee and to the district councils, and we look forward to continuing our work with both bodies. Before I take questions from this committee, I want to outline some work the commission has undertaken on this issue to date the first hearing that we had around this was of june 2025 with chief angel navales or then deputy chief briefed the commission on department policy governing interactions with federal authorities under the city's welcoming city ordinance commissioners questioned chief navales on cpd's level of cooperation with ice the boundaries of departmental responsibilities and assurances of compliance with the code in september of 25 jason sanford deputy director of public safety in the mayor's office of community safety attended our monthly commission meeting to answer questions about the mayor's office response and actions related to federal immigration enforcement as you all heard today our dcs did the working group uh did submit over 2200 signatures submitted by residents and which triggered a special meeting over a thousand residents attended that meeting in february the commission invited chief administrator of the civilian office of police accountability copa and the public safety inspector general to its monthly meeting to discuss the roles that copa and the inspector general play around this issue and they discuss ways to play around this issue and they discussed ways to strengthen that accountability. And then ultimately, on April 2nd, the Commission held a special meeting with Superintendent Snelling. Additionally, in January of this year, the Commission adopted several strategic priorities to guide its work. One of the priorities adopted by the Commission was to engage with community, the Mayor's Office, City Council, and CPD to strengthen policy and accountability around CPD's interaction with federal immigration enforcement this strategic priority can be tracked on our website and we do report monthly on our different working groups in the commission during our monthly meetings the strategic priority includes several key objectives working with the city to strengthening the welcoming city ordinance evaluating cpd's policies including its reporting requirements documentation practices during the situations advocate for adequate training to ensure that dispatchers, responding officers, and supervisors manage incidents in compliance with the Welcoming City Ordinance, clarifying and strengthening COPA's authority in cases involving potential CPD federal collaboration and ensuring those allegations are properly routed and investigated, and reviewing CPD documentation of its interactions with federal agencies and pushing for greater public transparency. To advance this work, the Commission has taken several steps, including supporting Alderperson Fuentes' ordinance, giving COPA responsibility for investigating violations of the Welcoming City Ordinance, and then meeting with COPA every month to discuss its implementation. Conducting a comprehensive review of CPD directives to identify potential improvements, regular meetings with members of the Commission's Non-Citizen Advisory Council, submitting multiple information requests to both CPD and COPA. Those requests and responses were given to the chair prior to this meeting and our staff has also been in touch with the committee staff for several months voting on april 2nd 2026 to request that the deputy inspector to request that the deputy inspector general for public safety conduct research or an audit into CPD's compliance with the welcoming city ordinance reviewing the mayor's executive order around the matter pushing for CPD to make changes to his general orders it also took a while to hear from the mayor's office regarding the guidance so the commission for many weeks pushed to make sure that the executive order guidance came out analyzing policies from other jurisdictions in other cities to see what best practices could strengthen CPD and city policy. We held informational hearings with Superintendent Snelling, COPA, and OIG. Meetings with subject matter experts were held, although we did not have a panel. Subject matter experts were consulted on ahead of any of our meetings. Passed the resolution this year. Thank you to my colleague, Commissioner Guzman. We passed the resolution to hold quarterly hearings on this topic in 2027. And lastly, on Tuesday, the commission sent a letter to CPD regarding the recent allegations that ICE is using CPD parking lots. These efforts reflect meaningful progress, but there's still so much work to do. We recognize there were gaps in our response, and I welcome any and all questions from the committee. Thank you very much. Order, please. So I've got a number of questions. Yeah, you know, actually, I'll open it up to the—I've got a number of questions, so I can wait. I'll have the colleagues go first, if that's okay. So, Alderman Terry Farrell? No, thank you guys for appearing today. Just as a matter of record, Mr. Chairman, as you and I spoke earlier and had come to an agreement that whenever we have issues that involve both immigration and CCPSA or the district council, that we convene a joint committee meeting. So, I appreciate your commitment there to collaborate on having joint committees as it relates to immigration and ccpsa and the district councils um could CSA and the district councils. Um, could, could I get a copy of the, um, the opening statement that was read into record? Yes, absolutely. Okay. And also a copy of the slide deck. Yeah. With, with regard to the, um, the duties and responsibilities that I saw on the slide, it moved pretty quickly. Could we go back to that so I could see, um, where those responsibilities and duties are outlined in in the ordinance you're talking about this one yes and that's 280 does that fall under um 070a and 070h okay thank you that's all I had and if I could get a copy of that I appreciate it absolutely uh any other yeah uh Alderman Gutierrez thank you chairman and thank you all for coming this morning to present to our committee i have a couple questions first of all instead of starting with the question i want to again reiterate how thankful in the 14 ward we're with you all and with many of your colleagues because we need to put it in record that not all of the district counselors have been working for our communities. I know they come from different backgrounds. They have different ideas and different things that move them to be elected in this position. But I just want to thank you all and the ones that have been day in, day out, really understanding the difference in the wards and the districts within. Because I know there's pockets or districts that are more immigrant than others. There are situations, of course, City of Chicago, we share a lot of concerns, a lot of things citywide, but there's some other issues, right, that happen more in some other pockets than in others. So I just want to thank you again for. so I just want to thank you again for stepping up and doing the right thing no secret to anybody and I always will be so proud I'm an immigrant myself and yes there's things that we need to continue to do better in our city but we just need to understand that we are all human beings that we all deserve a safe space to lay our head our kids deserve to be safe and I know there's policies in place there's other political things around there that we're not going to discuss right now because we're talking about this but I just wanted for everybody I'm familiar with your work and in the and how it's divided but I think if you can help us so everybody understands because I know for example there were some vacancies there are some districts where there's three or two uh counselors is there any way you can uh explain a little bit in the um what are those districts because how many police districts we have how many counselors are in each district so maybe we can have a little bit more information for people that don't know like this is also like a hearing right so we can understand a little bit more of the information and with that said there's police districts right that with some counselors as I mentioned they I'm interested also on knowing the amount of from the total when you tell us exactly how many there are and how they're divided like how many joined your efforts because I have two districts right I have the eighth and the ninth I know who signed but there's other areas where nobody signed nobody cared nobody understood so it's important for people to to see uh the work that you guys are doing and how and who is doing it thank you sorry for all the run around but thank you yeah so if there's any piece that i miss just remind me so um there are 66 slots there are 66 slots for district counselors um three district counselors in each of the 22 police districts there are currently three vacancies um there's a vacancy in the third district there's a vacancy in the 12th district and there is a vacancy in the 25th district And the process for filling those positions is that when someone resigns, the two remaining district counselors are required to create an application, to send the application to the community, get people to fill out the application in 30 days, and then they have 30 days to interview and submit three names to the commission the commission then has 30 days to review those application or those candidates um interview them if they choose to and then send one of those names uh forward to the mayor's office to then um nominate them and have city council through the police and fire committee would have to essentially advise and consent on that. And then it goes before the full city council. So then it's an election like everybody else here, right? You get your signatures, you get in the ballot, you get elected and you serve for four years correct so then council members could be up for re-election if they wish there's no term limits and then uh but when uh someone steps down because it has happened i've seen it so then someone then gets appointed there's no special election right just election, right? Just for all to be clear, because I know there's a lot of questions out there and it's important to put everything on the table and be able to have everything right. Okay. And then the second question, and I'm sorry. So then from those 66 with the vacancies, how many sign off on the efforts that you were leading? I believe, and it's probably in the packet here, I believe there were 38. I believe there were 38 district counselors that signed the initial letter. So it's more than half of us. And I believe that there were more than half of people in different district councils um so again a majority of a majority of majorities um um and aaron is is quickly counting also if you want to provide through the chair kind of a breakdown of like which district council signed on in which districts i kind of break down i think that's what you're looking yeah and that would be important uh to showcase and for people to understanding the city of Chicago and and also city council members too right sometimes it's 50 of us uh we all we're individuals right like so nobody's gonna think the same way I do we need to understand and remember that but then we are colleagues right and we understand that even though I represent the 14th ward in the southwest side I'm not blinded or or I should care and I should know what's happening in the north side in other areas right with my 50 colleagues so it's same thing you are an elected board right you all need to talk to each other you all need to work to each other and you need to convene and work towards a goal right and sometimes people won't be okay with it sometimes they will and it's the beauty about this type of work that we do that's it absolutely thank you for that do any of the other colleagues have any questions so i'll of the other colleagues have any questions for us so i'll just add to that so there were um 38 initial people who signed on and then the recommitment letter actually had 40 and um i just lost so i i put one two 16 and then 16 of the 22 districts had um counselors sign on so again a majority. And to my previous remarks, too, I think it's important for us to remember that I've been in so many of those meetings, too. And unfortunately, sometimes people are not even engaged to attend the meetings. And if they're for the initiatives they're pushing or they're against it, it's important for them to show up. They have an opportunity to voice their opinions for or against. Again, the beauty of getting together, the beauty of working together, and the beauty of having council members that each of you root for different things. So a special invite for everybody out there to continue to join those meetings are interesting. I know counselors try their best to bring speakers and talk about different issues around the communities. So it's always it's not only about immigration. It's always about things that they care for in the community. And I've seen it. They're open to hear about other things that they can improve or do and bring to the table or speakers or whatever they need. They're open to listening to the community. So it's important that we all take part of it. Instead of just complaining, come in those meetings and let's work together. Thank you. Thank you for that. Next question. Ms. Jackson. Next, Alderwoman Manal-Havenworth. Thank you, Chairman. I want to express my gratitude that we are here today, that you... that we are here today that you have been doing the work for so long that you exist and that all of the work that you have done together with every district counselor and the commission it's uh it's astounding to me that we are in this moment and who knew that you would have to go through what we all did last year through operation midway blitz that we're here on the other side of it for a minute and yet we know that there are still challenges so i represent the 48th board edgewater and uptown we are the most diverse community in chicago across many different things identity race class ethnicity and we have a very engaged community with rapid responders still organizing today especially around our elections which are coming up in november and i have two fantastic commanders in the 20th and 24th districts and i'm very grateful for them we have seen a decrease in in our statistics and public safety and we're grateful for that too um i am most curious about the transition between your work and the new district counselors that are coming in and i would love to hear from each of you on what you have learned and what you would like to impose um moving forward we talked earlier dc uh vogel thank you for all your work I do also believe that we have an opportunity to fix some systems. And if we address that, then that takes care of a lot of the work ahead. It's foundational. It's exactly what you said. And then we need individuals to do their part as well. But first, I would love to hear more on where we are today and where we need to be, and speaking to folks that are going to be stepping into your roles, hopefully, you know, this next election in February when you change hands, but moving forward in the future, how can we build on what you have done? Thank you. What a wonderful question. We as district counselors joke a lot that when we first started, we were building the plane while we were flying it. There really was no blueprint in how to be a district counselor. the ordinance gave us a little bit of guidance but really it was up to us to to create the role that we envision for ourselves and so what I shared with you right was my legacy as a district counselor on a city-wide level is a foundation of systems processes things to hand off to the next class of district councils so that we actually do have systems that work one of the main things that we've done is to develop our priority proposal process um so how we send priorities to the commission that includes our monthly reports um we recently have heard from the commission their um their sop so like how do we communicate with them how do we actually have systems and processes with how we communicate with the commission how we get our important items to them um and one thing that you'll notice that i just want to comment on is that um there was not a district um priority proposal we never submitted proposals for the work that was done um on immigrant support that happened in a like off time um with when we're submitting our annual priorities to the commission um by the boundaries that we sent so again us So again, us, the systems that we formed with the commission definitely can use tweaking. So like when we submit our annual priorities to them in September, right, so they can do their goals for the year and not in December for our last quarterly meeting, it's, there are going to be things that come up mid-year for us. And so we are working as district councils to really make our processes better so that if something like operation midway blitz comes up in the middle of one of our cycles that we can still make sure the commission has it so that it makes into their annual priority process or it's something that we can make resolutions on that they can focus on um mid-year so i hope that answers your question that is helpful thank you so much uh i would love to hear from vp um ruby never eat hope because we all have to work together absolutely absolutely uh i agree with district council vogel there isn't enough processes that kind of explain how we engage collaboratively together and there's been a lot of changes um i would say to how we've worked together we work together on cares the as a goal we're working together on alternative response as discussions as we move forward. I'm also coming up on the end of my term. So the strategic priority was a way to kind of leave that fundamental. And Commissioner Guzman got all the hints and did a great job and led on the vote. But the bylaws also changed. So now commissioners as a majority have to vote to add things under the agenda. These are all things that although are ongoing, we're not done yet to make sure that we have one solidified pathway with our district counselors to work together and we did start on our goals process and we're going through that now and we're starting much earlier than we did last year which i see as an accomplishment thank you that's really helpful i mentioned that we have a very engaged ward we we mentioned that we have a very engaged ward we we were not immune to ice raids and wrongful deportations and we had an incident where there was a chase and it happened on duceau lakeshore drive down to sheridan road i just i want to be able to explain to my constituents what's going to happen in the future if something again like we experienced last year comes up again i want to assure them that that our police department is going to prioritize our people versus homeland security's priorities what is the path forward so that i can assure them that the city of chicago is prioritizing our people uh awesome question right um i think that's why it's imperative that our district council working group and the work of um organizations who've been working on immigrant and refugee rights gave recommendations um question recommendations qualification recommendations to the commission on what that new superintendent has because that's the top, right? Starting at the top, it's imperative that we have a superintendent that cares about all people living in the city of Chicago and to really prioritize all people living in the city of Chicago. And I would just add that I would hope that going forward now that there have been some changes in the special order that governs, sets the policies and procedures for CPD in those interactions around ICE with those improvements. around ICE with those improvements, and then the district counselors continuing to push their local commanders on what the community's expectations are of their local officers. Each time that there's an improvement in a process and the community is engaged around that, I think we have a better chance of things being better in the future. You know, people ask me all the time, you know, can I guarantee that things will improve? And I say I can't, but that each time we try to improve the process, each time we let every level of policing know what the community's expectations are, the better chance we have of things being better in the future. thank you i appreciate that and once again i want to congratulate you on your work the foundational work that you have done together uh with cpd you know we have in on my side of town we have a great caps program too very engaged community and people people want to know like what what is it going to look like moving forward thank you for your work and uh thank you chair Sure. Thank you very much. Before I begin questions, Alder Persons Rodriguez and Vice Chair Taylor have requested a virtual option for committee hearing attendance in accordance with Rule 59 of the City Council Rules of Order. Can I get a motion to allow them attend the hearing virtually? So moved by Alderman Knutson, hearing no objections, so ordered. I really appreciate the beginning of this conversation. I think there's a number of things I want to ask questions about, some related to the process between the councils and the commission, because it feels to me like there have been challenges in getting some things accomplished and having both parts of what feels like one governmental body kind of working in tandem. um and then i have questions related to how cpd has responded to all of the questions and things so i'll just kind of i think i'll start kind of with some background on what the challenges have been so you all uh i'm sorry the district counselors mentioned kind of strategic priorities that you all put together uh that then gets sent to the commission what does the commission do with it uh commission do you want to answer that or i'm happy to yeah either party could that's fine can you repeat the question yeah so if uh let's say the district councils are putting together strategic priority they send it to the commission what is there in either law or policy that then leads to anything on the commission side is that just a recommendation that commissioners can decide to listen to or not like how does what's the mechanism for getting something done are they just suggestions yeah so the commission has to kind of vet the feasibility of recommendations so yes, we would receive recommendations and then we would either accept them or not. We would show further interest. If a majority of commissioners showed interest, we would pursue that more, see how that connects with our existing processes. I'll let our executive director speak to any sort of existing policies that exist, but I'm not aware of any policy that says this is what happens when you receive this kind of information. It kind of just, the staff helps us put that into our workflows and then we decide from there whether or not we adopt these things or not i appreciate that and the reason i asked it is right obviously we wrote the ordinance so if there's things that we need to change on our end and make sure it's working more properly we're more than happy to start delving into that but we'd like to see if you all can figure that out before we need to step in so uh yeah i will say i feel like there's been meaningful progress and there's going to be a new commissioner coming on and you know whoever that is you're going to have to get up to speed too but I do feel like eventually we will have something in writing that will help guide us instead of trying to guess or, you know, assume, which I do believe was done on either end. But nonetheless, I do think there will be some progress in the next year, I hope. Yeah, and I appreciate your points in DC Vogels, right? You guys are the first doing it. So you are kind of building the plan as it flies. So I think that's why the questions would be definitely informative for us as we think about it. So yeah, Mr. Gross, right? I have Bob. Thanks, I just add that the commission staff has been working with District Counselor Vogel and commissioners on a standard operating procedure that gets at exactly this question and that lays out um a clear process for what happens when district counselors present the priority proposals um and among other things lays out the kinds of factors they would take into consideration when um when selecting among them one of the things uh one of the sorry yeah just for the record before you all answer if you can introduce yourselves again just to make sure we've got all that yeah b to the punch great how about that all right good stuff hi uh district council vogel um one of the things that i would like to mention and like how we as district counselors have gotten smarter over the last three and a half years um was our priority proposal process so um two years ago actually if you look at our our original ones from 2023 um it's like 50 if a vote on a priority got over 50 percent of district council support that got passed on to the commission we had a ton of priorities that were sent to the commission the first year and not all the priorities that were sent were actually within the scope of work for what the commission can actually do so one of the things that we've a few of the things that we've done to tighten up our own process is one we we heighten the level of district council support to actually push something forward to the commission one in order to even have a priority proposal be heard, it requires 12 district counselors plus the person. 12 12 district counselors plus the person who wrote it um so that already is like to even hear priority there must be some support um and then for a priority to pass on to the commission uh it now requires two-thirds of all district councils instead of just 50 so that threshold was also increased so that really only the priorities um that had the top amount of votes so i have a follow-up yeah why was the threshold two-thirds for that vote just curious our council has had conversations about thresholds so i'm just curious what you guys have one uh we we thought it was a more meaningful number um so if our body is recommending something to have over 50 percent um we thought it was more meaningful number because again the first time a lot of stuff went not a lot of stuff is important work right went through but also we recognize that the commission has a lot on their plates so we're not submitting you know like 10 priorities right really only the ones that like yes we as a body of district councils from across the aisle right um agree that this is something important that we should have the commission focus on i appreciate that um i do have a follow-up yeah yeah do you have a follow-up question absolutely um thank you so one one other thing that we did like i said the first time we we did our best right um but now we also have uh priorities that get submitted or excuse me get proposed go through legal review so is this with even in the purview of the commission is it legal right um the commission staff also reviews this like is this something the commission can actually take on so there's now steps for district councils to submit these priorities that didn't exist when we did this the first you know year sure um i guess for for uh the lawyers on here uh could you all through the chair if possible share instances where you all said something was not legal that was proposed by the commit uh district counselors and the reason i say it is we go through it with our department of law and sometimes we push a little harder than what they recommend to us uh so just want to see kind of i'm curious as to the responses of what those are and in a similar are and in a similar manner to our members of the commission what i'm curious about um is commissioner vice president uh ruby navadillo mentioned you know we get the priorities we vet them and then we either do or don't go forward with some of them is there a response whenever the commission doesn't go forward with an item that's being recommended um i would say so i from what i'm remembering on issues that i've worked with dcs we've had had a response there may have been instances where we didn't provide a response uh i'll leave it to executive director to see if it's mandatory for a response but that's yeah and it may not be i would imagine it's not mandatory more than like as you're developing your standard operating procedures right is there a formal response whenever something not agreed to so at least as an understanding on why right that's more the question yeah i think our staff do well communicating in-house um you know our district council team and our commission team so i would i would assume so however uh i don't think we have policy that outlines that we could definitely do a better job of communicating with district councils about the priority proposals yeah like i say my interest is more just on process because i think i think some of the tension that i've seen is that things being proposed from the commission might feel unheard in a way that then spills out into the public and headlines and arguments which happens with we're city council we're not those are not foreign concepts to us but i think the processes sometimes are helpful in that regard um and so that's that's kind of why I was curious because you know I was at the um hearing that was kind of mandated after the petition process right and so um I have questions that felt to me less like a hearing and more like a long public comment period and so I was wondering what in particular the petitions accomplish is it for a public comment period is it a full hearing what kind of um powers are kind full hearing what kind of um powers are kind of enabled in that process and that would be for our lawyer friends i would imagine yeah so the ordinance says that uh uh that residents of the city of chicago can petition for a commission meeting and they can specify uh stuff about the purposes of the meeting and the issues to be addressed um and then the and then the commission has to, uh, has to take that up sort of within the scope of the request. Um, in that particular instance, um, one of the things I think that was alluded to earlier was, uh, we had really bad timing. The, um, the ordinance requires a pretty quick turnaround from the time, um, a petition is submitted until there's a hearing. The petition was submitted, um, right before Christmas and new year's uh so we had to you know work to organize the hearing try to get people to show up um and do that all within 21 days um so uh trying to follow the rules of the ordinance on that timeline at that time of year didn't allow um uh for the kind of hearing uh at that time that i think any of us um would have liked so that was certainly disappointing um uh i think that i understand the the reason for the 21 day requirement um in that particular instance i think it worked against all of us the challenge in practice okay and then uh dc rochford i could follow up thank you uh elizabeth rochford 17th district counselor um i just want to add that um For several of the prior instances where the community had submitted. submitted signatures to trigger the hearing. The people who were responsible for those petitions, they were negotiated with about the date, about the place, about the content of those hearings. And they were not all held within 21 days. um and yet the district council members were not afforded those um those accommodations um everything was decided by the commission and the date was decided by the commission without any negotiations that were given to just regular community bodies so that is something that i think we need to address going forward that if the impetus for the petitions our district counselors that we should be able to get the same um uh respect um that other community groups have gotten in the past yeah and i think it's like that part of it is because we do draft the ordinance and make the amendments like i here's the part i'm i'm a bit curious about so in that regard the district counselors in each of their district councils focused and worked like one body to try to get the commission to act in that way as opposed to some people view our colleagues the district council positions as hey just focus on your own district but it seems like you all seem to work as a whole group to try to get the commission to do something uh is that how you would characterize it would you want to be enabled more as a body to get something like that done or you prefer just each individual council just stick to your own district? I would say that many of us do work across district council boundaries because um district council boundaries because immigration um uh crime clearance rates um uh the treatment of crime victims um is is universal to the city so i would say that there probably would be a benefit to us having more authority as a district council body than we have as individual little just stick to your own district i appreciate and i feel like you all operated kind of the question um alderman guteris asked about how you guys got like all the recommendations and the letters and the petitions and the body kind of signing on citywide i think speaks to a lot of it because the similar way the council works right we've got an executive branch that's looking at things citywide then you've got 50 of us that similarly could just focus on potholes in our wards but we do convene once a month to talk about these larger city issues in ways that i think is material and important so um i guess i have a follow-up yeah yeah so in addition to the counselor sign-ons and letters and requests and petitions um we also are creating like a district council assembly moving forward right now what we have is regional representation via planning team something that i've been on since its inception so two from the north side two from the west side two from the southwest side two from the southeast side we have pushed also for the commission to have processes for district counselors to request agenda items for their meetings and that's also in the works how are the region was determined like how do you guys decide which tour from which region how did you guys decide that sorry no how do you decide with the north side that no uh we we were nominated by our colleagues so folks folks that were interested in being on the planning team um within it then all y'all kind of like voted on it as a body okay uh got it uh thank you for that i guess for the commission side i have a question you for that i guess for the commission side i got questions related to how what the challenges you all saw and getting something on the agenda one because it took it felt like the district counselors petitioning and having a push to get that and i know that there were some conversations prior um i also my understanding is there's a point where certain commissioners wanted there to be hearings on this but then that became its own challenge and so i was wondering if any of the commissioners were able to speak to like what challenges they saw and having those hearings happen and i'm curious as to how the quarterly hearings then came about um there were so around the time that the signatures were submitted we were having regular meetings with the dc working group then these signatures were submitted up until that time internally we as commissioners knew that we wanted to have another hearing um unfortunately during that time uh before our current bylaw change, the president of the commission has the ability to put things on the agenda. So it took a while to kind of come to an agreement on what we wanted to do. And then the panels were recommended to us and that kind of fell apart. We did still meet with the subject matter, but I wouldn't say there was one particular challenge, but just commissioners, uh in particular you know in the executive we disagreed on on uh when and the urgency of the meeting sure yeah i appreciate that answer it feels like a it feels like one challenge that multiple bodies are experiencing and it's because it's a new body of government right so if the commissioners felt like they wanted to hear something but the president is the one in charge of the agenda and there's no process for you all to have done that i could see why that created the kind of tension some of us were reading about as you all were looking to get something put on the agenda I think similarly watching the district counselors not have the process as well to get something on the agenda then leads to a petition process and leads to what felt like a petition process and leads to what felt like more frayed relationships and maybe an inability to move forward in a faster um manner as a governing body so how ultimately and this is for um i think commissioner guzman because i believe you're the one who introduced it uh how did the quarterly hearings then come about came about how did they come about sorry uh thank you chairman so um i think i have now served four months on the commission and uh those four months i've been to the monthly meetings which have been filled with public common uh public common centered around uh wanting some sort of accountability uh for uh allegations of cpd and ice interaction um so i once we had the bylaw amendment passed uh i made sure that we had those hearings to assure some sort of protection and make sure that uh community is hearing from cpd uh in order to my understanding in order to get that done there needed to be some level of change so you had to change the bylaws to do so how did that part get done like and i apologize if i'm getting very wonky in it i think all of it that i'm learning is things that i want to then look at the ordinance again to figure out how to simplify some of those things that seem to be hurdles in a time where we needed the whole city to act quicker and i'll say council had to move quicker as well so it's not like it's exclusive to what we're hearing now i will say well before i Regan. I have respect for President Ramel Terry. We simply disagreed on a lot of the aspects coming to the organization of this hearing. The bylaw change came about. The immigration, the whole immigration inquiry was inflamed, the bylaw change, but really where it came was when there when there was another topic the commission was bringing forth we had a majority and we found ourselves continuing to uh feel stalled and pushing business from the uh the commission on many items there were things taken off of the agenda without explanation and you know that's that's that's not an effective way of governance so we all agreed to change the bylaws and that we all have a say and what goes on the main meeting agenda it gives us a little more wiggle room and negotiating time uh to do things correctly um and president terry has her own reasons i don't want to speak on her behalf but there were disagreements around the bylaw change in itself um whether it was needed or not but ultimately as a body we decided it was because as a majority commissioners we decided to address the topic it was not being moved forward and we thought that was concerning okay no i i appreciate that i got one more question related to kind of these interactions before getting to like cpd component because i have a number of i'm curious how they work with y'all compared to what we've seen on our end right but before that there's a um there's a line in the ordinance of ecps that relates to like the commission having oversight over the district council so i was curious how that's interpreted by each person here because i don't know when we were drafting it that we really thought about it because i know i didn't envision it as like one governing over the other more than kind of co-equal but just kind of wondering how you all uh has that played out anywhere as far as how the two bodies interact um as a commissioner i i definitely see it as a collaboration maybe not every commissioner may have that same perspective um i don't know if that answers your question no and then thank you does and for the district counselors um i would just add that i would see it as something where if there was an issue that arose that wasn't addressed. wasn't addressed um in some other fashion that they could then say hey district counselors we need you to do this in your district so that they could give us some direction if there was an unusual or new situation that presented itself so that's how i see that and then we have some again um ability to impact them by our policy recommendation so we can say hey this is what we're seeing so we're gonna forward this to you as um something that we're asking you to address so i do see that there is sort of a a check and balance there sure and then i'd like to open it up to our lawyers see what you all think about the language like the line related to commission oversight over the district councils or and we kind of want to see like your interpretation or thoughts on that uh so for starters i'd say i was pretty deeply involved in the development of the ordinance and could tell you a pretty long story about almost every provision that's in the ordinance and all the conversation and deliberation that went into each provision. I don't have a story for you about that provision. So that has always been, um, kind of a mystery to me and I think others involved in the ordinance. Um, in that, in that context, um, I understand oversight to mean what oversight means in a lot of contexts, um, including in the city of Chicago, um, where, um, for example, the, um, the office of inspector general has oversight authority overall of city government they don't have the ability to discipline or to punish anybody they can look at things they can make recommendations recommendations um they can make suggestions um for uh for improvements they could hold hearings on things uh so i think the the commission potentially um could do uh those sorts of things but there's nothing in the ordinance that gives the uh the commission as i read it or as lawyers on our team read it um nothing that gives the commission any authority over uh over district councils who were elected officials and are accountable to the people who elected them i appreciate that and then mr isaacs i don't know if you have a take on it passing right back teams for it okay thank you uh for that much appreciated so okay so i want to kind of go to uh was it general order 111 so the district counselors is it or the commission either or can require certain data from cpd what data have you requested and what have you received what has that been like good question i believe i believe you guys have we can actually provide we can make sure the chair gets that information um because we requested a lot uh leading up to the april 2nd hearing so i guess my answer is how much have you received um i may not i guess in terms of actually answering our questions a lot of what we receive is redirection back to policy cbd's policy so not necessarily the answers that we were looking for um so what you guys would say that to your point one is talking about policy as an answer but when you're asking for actual data and actually if you want to send this to the chair that'd be great to see what actual data you all receive because i know we've asked for data held the whole time and haven't really seen much of anything except for I think a little bit after the June 4th incident there's like a report that we get that is all of a tracking number with tracking number with not a lot of information in it and so i'm just curious like if you all glean any more information than we do it wasn't a lot okay no like i said that's this is why we want to hear what accountability looks like right if we're asking for that for cpd and your body isn't getting it and we aren't getting it then there's a larger problem right because you don't get accountability without receiving that information and so that's that is kind of the question what about the mayor's executive orders right there's a lot of things related to what cpd is supposed to do when there's ice cpd interaction information they're supposed to provide there's a time where policy had to be written but out of all the you know mayor's executive orders of welcoming city ordinance has any of those have any of those things provided any material improvement accountability or anything more than statements of value thank you chairman um i think that the information that we've been receiving from cpd a lot of commissioners have not been satisfied with the information that we've gotten and we're hoping in 2027 when we have these hearings we can ask for more clarifying information um can you repeat your question in regards to you you quoted a certain issue there i i what i was saying is um if if the information is such that it's not been sufficient um i think what i'm trying to get at is we go through the same thing and it's an unfortunate reality that hope doesn't get a lot accomplished. And so I'm trying to understand what the challenges have been when you guys are asking for information and what kind of responses you get. Yes. So first things I'll say is that there appeared to be a back and forth between CPD's legal team and DOL about the release of the guidance for the executive order. I can't speak too much into why that was, but it was several months. The executive committee was internally pushing for that. Now we've come to find out there's a special unit doing doing an investigation that uh processes within cpd with reports are being looked at and we want to better understand that but from what my understanding is the information we've received from cpd doesn't really paint a full picture of all the actions that have occurred even after the executive order yeah if through the chair you all be able to provide kind of more information on the special unit you're referring to because i think again these things are sometimes happening in a way that we're not getting information either and we want to make sure uh that we do uh absolutely how does ccpsa work with some of the cpd immigrant liaisons like the folks that are cpd that kind of do this work what's that engagement look like and that's both the district counselor counselors and the commissioners yes i've interacted a lot with that office mainly for victim services understanding the unt visa process um the oversight of that particular policy is a little difficult because it overlaps with state law and things like that so there are some things that we can't provide recommendations on but mostly i believe quality assurance making sure that they are being responsive to the many inquiries that are coming in from our immigrant community who might have questions about any law enforcement function okay um i've got about two more i apologize i know going long here um this is for commissioner guzman related to the quarterly hearings as you were the one who introduced and moving forward what do you envision those hearings to be like who would be at the table how do you how do you see the commission implementing what's now become part of the bylaws and should be moving forward quarterly uh yeah so i can only speak to what i'm envisioning as a commission as a whole we have not uh fully discussed how these hearings are going to look like but I would envision both superintendent and COPA chief administrator to be present at the table as well as subject matter experts and making sure that we have a period for and making sure that we have a period for public comment and as well as making sure that they're answering the public's questions thank you yeah absolutely for those for those hearings would they be regularly scheduled or how how would that work i know schedules are hard to to work around how could you make it more predictable so that people are available yeah so right now uh it's written in the resolution that it will be every quarter uh they're required uh to come but i would imagine we would work with staff to uh plan a date where all parties are available to attend thank you and thank you for the question i think it's an opportunity for us to kind of i think it's an opportunity for us to kind of partner up and elevate those events as well raise we all kind of make sure this is a constant conversation that's not only happening in city council but across the city to other bodies so i really appreciate that um superintendent search right now the commission is charged with figuring out the nominees that then get presented to the mayor as it relates to the superintendent as well as a whole process and what qualifications one would want to see in such candidates so as we're discussing what feels like a challenge related to cpd ice interactions or cp or ice in parking lots or getting information from the police department related to any of this each of you what would you all want to see as a priority as mandates as non-negotiables related to any of the candidates that would then be put forth to be appointed as a superintendent of police? Yeah, so I think for me, a superintendent that understands that municipal governments have been challenged with a lot of things that municipal governments don't things that municipal governments don't usually have to tackle and that we're going to have to take an innovative and transparent approach to this problem until we can rebuild trust um i i had tried to say a version of that at the talia hall meeting but not the right place to say it but we should be able to trust our police and call 9-1-1 when we need help and um no matter who you are you should be able to call 9-1-1 it's certainly at the top of my head when i'm doing superintendent stuff, which I can't get really into, but it's certainly at the top of my head because whoever the next superintendent is, they're going to really have to glean over these really complicated issues with their team as well. So hopefully, even if the superintendent can't show up, he will have a team that is dedicated to ensuring that these issues are important to them. Thank you. I would want a superintendent that prioritizes bringing in youth and their perspective and really understanding youth of minority background. I think right now we're seeing a lot of issues with policing and youth, and it has been a history of that as well. So just a superintendent who's actually willing to listen and willing to take that feedback and really turn it into action. Thank you. uh district council um i think it's imperative that we have a new superintendent who embodies compassion um and who knows the history of not only policing in the u.s but policing in chicago and the impact that that has had specifically on our black and brown communities um so from the black community i heard you in the public comments right um all the way to our folks who are undocumented, it is so important that we have a commander who cares about everyone who's in the city of Chicago, regardless of their documentation status. city of chicago regardless of their documentation status thank you and then uh and then uh district counselor rochard i would just add that um as i said in um our presentation that we really worked with communities that represent the immigrant um experience and we got their feedback on what kinds of questions they want answered and what they actually saw as a um as a good answer to those questions and so i would really want the person to have have answered that question or those questions we set we sent two questions and then some follow-up questions i would want them to have had good answers to those questions um so that the the direct um response to the what the community is looking for is actually uh somebody who has those qualifications thank you very much um before i kind of wrap up unless anyone has questions uh i'd like to do the chair um kind of a comparison to other cities equivalent bodies and how they've been kind of interacting with everything that's happening in this current moment right to see how kind of we stack up how their bodies are made up are they able to get more information from their police departments what does it look like for ice cpd interactions that are happening in other cities just to kind of have a comparable for us to look at and see like how are we faring is this a challenge we're seeing nationally or something that we could i'm competitive so make sure we're doing better than other cities so if you'd send that i'd greatly appreciate it um yeah absolutely uh chair would that also include the interactions that were reported on in the last year and if they were investigated or not last year and if they were investigated or not are you saying citywide or nationally citywide yeah yeah that'd be great can we get that through the chair as well um i think trying to get an understanding that would be very important for us um i want to take the time to thank all of you all for an immense amount of work but considering you're a completely new body of government and the first ones to ever do it i think um you know i've had conversations with a number of folks either in government or out that see us alders and kind of the level of power perceived or not that we carry thinking about how many years we've had alders and i can't imagine what the first group of them must have been like trying to put all this stuff together so to see you all do that with something as important as police accountability in a way that leads to any level of improvement in public safety here in the city um is commendable i know it's not easy i've we've seen when you all do things that are working out really well we've seen when y'all are in disagreement because that's part of the public body you guys watch us here monthly it's politics and government is messy and democracy is messy but you all have been doing it well and i would say at a very low cost for the city i think you guys should get paid more for the work that you do both district counselors and commissioners and i think it's something we need to look at when it comes to um our budget process as well as how we look at the ecps ordinance to help empower both of these bodies and make sure that we clarify some things that might be um undefined as of this moment so i think similarly through the chair if each of you could send us uh recommendations for what you'd like to see improved in ccpsa whether it's for the own your own section of it district counselors and commissioners or the other one right each each one what do you see in your interaction that helps inform how we can make sure that you action that helps inform how we can make sure that you as a governmental body is evolving and improving over time I think that would help us and sometimes we have a million things on our plate but I think this is important one to make sure we prioritize so I want to thank the commissioners I want to thank the district counselors and staff everyone here as well as our members in the public for being here for this hearing and with that I would move to adjourn or would anyone care to adjourn, sorry. So moved by Alderman Hoppenworth. Hearing no objections, so ordered the Committee on Immigrant Refugee Rights hearing is now adjourned.