Test, test, test, one, two, three, test, test, one, two, three, test, test. Okay, we are going to get started momentarily. Can tech services confirm that the stream is good to go? I see a thumbs up. Thank you so much. Well, good morning, everybody. The Committee on Ethics and Government Oversight will now come to order. We have nine items on today's agenda. Two appointments to the Board of Ethics and eight appointments. So actually that number is ten total. eight appointments to the Reverend Jesse L. Jackson, Sr. Advisory Council on Access to Democracy. on access to democracy. We will begin with a roll call to establish quorum. Please know that your yes or present response will be deemed a yes vote when this quorum is used for a reference vote for later items. Chairman Martin is present. Vice Chair Haddon, we will get to. Alderwoman Lee. Alderman O'Shea. Alderwoman Taylor. Alderwoman Tabares. Alderman Taliaferro. Alderman Wagus pack will be joining us momentarily alderman spazato alderman nugent alderman vasquez alderman riley alderman lawson we have a quorum vice chair haddon has requested remote participation in the committee meeting under rule 59 due to a qualifying event is there a motion to allow her to attend remotely alderman lee so moves all those in favor say aye all those opposed in the opinion of the chair the eyes have it and vice chair hadden is allowed to attend the committee meeting remotely at this time we will begin public comment this period is set aside for 30 minutes out of respect for everyone's time each speaker is limited to no more than three minutes of public comment we have one person signed up for public comment as well as five five signed up for in person i believe the person who signed up uh for a virtual public comment is bob winslow tech support do we know if he is on by chance bill please press star six to unmute bob winslow you have three minutes oh bill winslow excuse me bill you can you press star six to unmute okay i think we have you please get please go ahead We'll see you then. Good morning. Good morning. Am I on now? Yes, you are. Go ahead. Hi, my name is Bob Whistlow, and thank you very much for giving me the opportunity to provide this information about Michael Schlesinger's position for the Board of Ethics. I am a founder of multiple businesses here in Chicago. I'm a longtime investor in our city. I'm a civic leader in the city, along with my wife, and I'm a lifelong resident of this city and never planned to live anywhere else. And I can't think of any professional who I would give a higher recommendation to than Michael Flessinger for this position. Mr. Flessinger's entire professional career has been based here in the city of Chicago. And he was with a mid-sized law firm, which gave him the unique opportunity to represent Chicago businesses from the foundation of the business, through their operation, through internal disputes, through external disputes, and even through exits. And it put him in a position to have relationships with those businesses, where he really became not just their lawyer, but their business counsel and their ethic counsel. And I know he entered into many situations where he helped those businesses through ethical decisions. You know, in today's world, it's really dominated by specialized attorneys. It's a unique position for somebody to be in that kind of position as a business and ethical and a cultural consultant for their law firms. Mr. Schlesinger was a graduate of John Marshall Law School, and he believed that it was his moral and ethical responsibility to give back to the students, to the school, to its faculty, beyond just monetary donations. So he actually began by giving back his time and investing his time as an adjunct professor investing his time as an adjunct professor and became a full professor at the school where he also created and directed the business enterprise law clinic for the school. And the whole purpose of that law clinic was to educate and inspire law students to use their legal education as an instrument to contribute to building a better Chicago by providing pro bono business services and legal services to Chicago not-for-profits and startup business enterprises. And not unlike his relationship with his law clients, Mr. Schlesinger is able to teach these students how to counsel their pro bono clients in legal business and in ethical decision making. All of this, I think, makes him a great candidate for this position. You know, the breadth and the scope and the depth of everything that Mr. Schlesinger has done in these experiences, working through from ground floor to high level business transactions and social and business and political interactions and educational requirements for students and teaching them how to work within our environment and within our legal and ethical structures. Thank you, Mr. Whistlow. Recognizing Alderman Wagespeck and Alderman O'Shea for purposes of quorum. Our next public commenter is Jessica Jackson, followed by Ebony Townsend. It's always amazing to come before this ethics committee because the people on it are so unethical. You know, for you all to be the standard of what is ethical is crazy. Even if the people in the audience were to look towards you all today it's got to be seen as unethical for the pub unethical for the public to be addressing you all and you all looking down at your phones and paperwork, acting like you're busy because you don't want to hear what the public is saying to you about the way that you all have behaved as inadequate or to people. That in itself is a bit unethical. I think we can all agree. I think we can all agree that it's unethical to sit and target one specific group of people, in this instance the black community, and hike property taxes so high that it actually pushes people out of their properties so that J.B. Pritzker, a corrupt governor, can come and steal all our properties over in the South Side areas because of the Obama Center. That's a bit unethical, Wouldn't you say? Wouldn't you say it's unethical, Alderman Lee, Wax and Pat, Wax and Pat? Wouldn't you say it's a bit unethical to say that it's disrespectful to put a railroad through one section of town while you all sit back and watch our community get flooded with illegal immigration? Wouldn't you say that's a bit unethical? Wouldn't you say it's a bit unethical to bear us to be with Commissioner Donna Scott, Donna Miller, about domestic violence? Yet, when you have a woman and women up there that report domestic violence to you, you run out to meetings, act like you don't see us, and turn the other way. That's got to be considered unethical. and look at you looking down now because you know I'm telling the truth. You need to be up out of that seat. And then Matt Martin, the chairperson, you got to know you are the poster child for unethical. unethical. Any time you could be a civil rights attorney and somebody gives you their case to investigate and you refuse to do it because it's going to implicate these crooked aldermen and crooked Cook County officials and you sitting there at the helm of it. So that lets me know that these appointments that you all are doing today, these people are unethical. Any time they would be willing to serve with you to serve with this board you they are unethical anytime you always stand behind brandon johnson it proves that you are unethical our next recognizing alderman talia farrow for purposes of quorum next up is ebony townsend followed by edward salmon oh solomon Excuse me. Good morning, chair and members of the committee. My name is Ebony Townsend, and I serve as executive director at Flora B Foundation in the city's Inglewood community. I actually want to begin with a personal note. My husband was hospitalized over the weekend unexpectedly, and he had an emergency surgery on Sunday. And I share that because, just to underscore how committed I was to being here to support Michael D. Schlesinger's appointment here today. I have had the privilege of working closely with Michael for about two years in 2015 through the Business Enterprise Law Clinic at the John Marshall Law School. In there, we served dozens of micro-businesses on the city, predominantly on the city's city's south and west sides. So I've known Michael for more than a decade now. Michael is principled, he's thorough, and resolute. And I really believe that that matters here today. It is my personal belief, actually now more than ever, that the public's confidence in government must be earned and protected. And that requires people who are willing to uphold ethical standards, even when doing so may be difficult or inconvenient. Michael is exactly that kind of person. For those reasons, I am proud to support Michael Schlesinger's appointment to the City of Chicago's Board of Ethics, and I respectfully urge the committee to recommend his confirmation. Thank you for the opportunity to speak to you this morning. Thank you for joining us, and I hope that your husband has a full and speedy recovery. Next up, Edward Solomon, followed by Annalisa Shork. Good morning. I, too, am an advocate for my friend and colleague, Michael Sessinger. I've known Michael for half a century. Our association as colleagues and partners in the practice of law has endured for 37 years. We worked together on many matters, and I entrusted him with complex issues, which only he was frankly equipped to handle. He brought patience, enthusiasm, and creativity to work in which I and others lacked interest or depth. The proof of an attorney's success is simply the opinion of one's clients of his or her work, intellect, and character. Michael forged lasting relationships with many of his clients and refined his knowledge and expertise to suit their needs. His resume may not have revealed his extensive practice. may not have revealed his extensive practice in medical-related matters, which included regulatory as well as business issues, and demanded extensive discussions of ethics and conflicts of interest. Michael, during his tenure with my firm, was the conscience of the firm. He raised, addressed, and often resolved ethical issues when other senior partners were not merely indifferent to, but frankly unaware, existed. Michael may have understated his extensive and enduring community services. He has provided shelter and sustenance to feral cats in exchange for their successfully chasing and dispatching Logan Square's once-residents rats. He has compelled friends to eat nutritionless but tasty pancakes at the Chicago Boys and Girls Clubs breakfast fundraisers. His commitment to the common good and personal involvement in community and charitable endeavors exceeded that of all my partners combined. Letters of recommendation are often fraught with hyperbole. I have not overstated Michael's integrity, skills, or his commitment to the community in the city of Chicago. I have a few more moments. I just wanted to add one thing to my praise of Michael. We are products of a different generation. Attorneys in our incipient years did not advertise on signs on highways as large as semi-trucks, nor did they advertise in the paper or give themselves seductive nicknames like the hammer. We were a little bit more discreet, and there's something which has largely disappeared from the practice called civility. Michael is and remains a product of that outbreak. remains a product of that upbringing and is a civil, calm, but nevertheless tenacious advocate, sometimes stubborn, but never ever done. Thank you very much. Recognizing Alderwoman Taylor for purposes of quorum, we next have Annalisa Shorek followed by Gleb Stauskunis. Good morning to the committee. Annalisa Shorek here in support of Michael Schlesinger's candidacy. Can you position the microphone up just a little bit? Is this better? Yes, it is. Thank you. Okay, great. Good morning to the committee. I'm here to support Michael Schlesinger's candidacy to the board as well. I had the pleasure of first meeting him as a student at UIC Chicago School of Law, formerly John Marshall Law School, and actually was taught corporate law by Michael and also was an early participant in his business enterprise law clinic shortly after he had founded it at the law school. I've personally witnessed his dedication to community involvement, his outreach to underserved communities. He would regularly take students to community chambers of commerce to interact with people in the city, with people looking to start up businesses with not-for-profits. And I can't express how important and valuable that commitment was. And I'm glad I was able to be an early participant in his efforts. I've been able to continue my connection to him over the years in his efforts to support the law school's business clinic and also to encourage further community involvement and similar programs. I can't express how diligent and community-minded he is and how much support and valuable contribution he would. valuable contribution he would give to the board. I would express my support for his candidacy without any reservation. So I'll keep it short and sweet. Thank you so much. Thank you. And our final public commenter, Gleb Staskunis. Good morning, Chairman Martin and members of the committee. It's nice to see you again. My name is Gleb, and I'm a Chicago student. I'm here to raise a question that I believe many Chicagoans want answered. When the city allocates millions of taxpayer dollars to infrastructure who makes sure that money is spent properly and actually delivers results. The Chicago Office of Inspector General examined how the city plans and evaluates its capital improvement spending. In its follow-up report, it found that out of nine corrective actions assigned to the Office of Budget and Management, only one had been substantially implemented. Six were partially implemented, and only two had not been implemented at all. Two of the outstanding recommendations are especially important. They call for better ways to measure whether completed projects achieve their goals and to evaluate projects so the city could learn from the results. This raises a basic question. If the city is not consistently evaluating completed projects, how can taxpayers know whether their money is being spent effectively? Consider the Clark and Lake station. In November of 2024, the CTA announced $10 million in plan improvements to the elevated platform. The wider station renovation also involves the private developer redeveloping the former Thompson Center. I'm not suggesting that money has been misused on this project. I'm asking how the city and relevant agencies check that work is completed as promised and that spending is properly documented and that the public gets improvements it was promised. Chairman Martin and the members of the committee, I have three questions. First, has this committee checked whether the outstanding inspector general recommendations have since been implemented? second will the committee request an updated report explaining what has been completed what remains outstanding and which departments are responsible and And third, will the committee refer the transportation issues to the appropriate committee and push for clear public reporting on major projects, including budgets, payments, delays, and results? This follow-up report from the Inspector General's office dates back to 2023. It's now 2026. So I want to know what progress has been made since then. Chicagoans deserve more than a budget and a promise. they deserve to know what their tax dollars achieved and whether the city learned from past mistakes. I ask this committee to help provide those answers and make the results public. Thank you for your time. Thank you for your comment. That concludes the public comment portion of today's hearing. Our first order of business is the Rule 45 report from October 1st, 2026, which was distributed to the committee via email. Can I get a motion to approve this report? alderwoman nugent so moves all those in favor signify by saying aye all those opposed in the opinion of the chair the eyes have it now we will discuss the first two substantive items on today's agenda the appointment of michael schlesinger and the reappointment of ryan cordazar as members of the board of ethics i'd like to thank our appointees for accepting their appointments and being here today if both of you could come just on the other side of this black rope and i believe both of you have brief remarks that you'll share so uh ryan why don't we start with you as the the reappointment and then we'll take you up michael and then we will uh do questions after that so ryan please begin at your convenience all right thank you chair martin and members of the committee i'm honored to have been reappointed to the board of ethics for another term i am proud of the work that the board has done over the last five years that I have served and I look forward to helping guide it into its next chapter. I've lived in Chicago for 18 years, the last 10 of which have been in the Edgewater community. A commitment to good government has been a through line from the earliest years of my career. For years out of college, I began working For years out of college, I began working in the city's Office of Inspector General, helping the city achieve substantial compliance with the decades-old Shackman Decrees and Shackman Accord. That work led me to pursue my law degree at Harvard, during which time I worked at the Office of Congressional Ethics for the House of Representatives and the Massachusetts Attorney General's Office. After graduation, I returned to Chicago and worked for a year-long fellowship at the Chicago Lawyers Committee for Civil Rights. While there, I worked in the Voting Rights Project, where we helped pass automatic voter registration in Illinois and led voter protection programs throughout the city and the suburbs. After my fellowship, I clerked for Judge Hamilton on the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals before joining my current firm at Corantillary. At Corantillary, I've continued my pro bono practice in voting rights, habeas corpus, and education rights. From day to day, I work in complex civil litigation representing purposes suing large corporations who have violated antitrust law and consumer protection statutes. And for nearly five years, I have served on the Board of Ethics. There, I am guided by three principles. First, the text of the ethics ordinance. Second, the board's precedent applying that ordinance. And third, the bedrock principles of justice and equity. In every case that comes before the board, I apply these principles to the facts presented and ensure that every person who comes before us has a fair opportunity to be heard. For the last year, I have served as the vice chair and acting chair of the board. In this role, I have led the public meetings and helped shepherd the board's vigorous discussions of its casework. I look forward to the opportunity to continue this work on behalf of the city and all of its residents. Thank you for your consideration, and I am happy to answer any questions that you may have. Thank you very much. Michael, we'll take you next. Can you position the microphone down a little bit more? Thank you. Thank you very much. Good morning. Good morning. Chairperson Martin and members of the Committee on Ethics and Government Oversight, Thank you for the opportunity to speak this morning. My name is Michael Schlesinger. I'm honored to have been appointed to serve on the Board of Ethics. I have lived in Chicago for 59 years in the uptown Rogers Park and Lincoln Park neighborhoods, and for the last 53 years in Logan Square. I graduated from the John Marshall Law School, where I was a member of the Law Review. For all but the first three years of my career, I practiced law, business and transactional law with the firm of Robin, Solomon, and Pat. From 2004 to 2011, while continuing to practice law, I taught corporation law in the evening as an adjunct professor at the law school from which I graduated. In 2011, I withdrew from the law firm to join the law school full-time as the founding director of the Business Enterprise Law Clinic. The clinic provided pro bono business and transaction legal services to entry-level entrepreneurs, starting and growing businesses in their communities. After retiring from the law school, I served as a William J. Fulbright scholar and visiting professor at the Faculty of Law, Polatsky University in the Czech Republic, working with the law school's faculty to develop its clinical program. Throughout my career as a practicing lawyer and law teacher, I had occasion to counsel clients and law students as they encountered ethical issues. At the law school, when I taught corporation law, a significant part of the course focused on fiduciary duty, conflict of interest, and confidentiality. The ethics ordinance addresses these issues in a governmental context. If confirmed, I will use my practice and academic backgrounds to review and evaluate. practice, and academic backgrounds to review and evaluate the conduct of subjects alleged to have violated the cities of Chicago's ethics ordinance independently, impartially, and without bias based on the evidence presented as applied to the language of the ordinance and respecting a subject's right to due process and fairness. The ordinance's ethics pledge confirms that an appointment to the Board of Ethics is a position invested with the public trust. If confirmed, in all instances, I will act in the best interest of the city of Chicago, putting the interests of the city first, following the governing language of the ethic ordinance, and maintaining confidential information in strict confidence. I'm enthusiastic about the opportunity to contribute my time talent and experience to the city of chicago and to work with an outstanding group of board of ethics members and staff thank you and i'm pleased to answer any questions that you may have thank you we will open the floor up to questions from committee members do we have any yeah yeah alderman taylor sorry yes fine well thank you I do. I do. Sure. Well, I've had a wonderful career, and I'm grateful for the opportunities I had. It's a privilege to be appointed as a candidate, and the best things that have happened to me professionally in my career and other good things have been my public service work. I always received much more than I gave of my time. Whether I was, my wife and I were working in Central America on construction projects in Central America on construction projects, and I was learning how to mix cement and build bricks, or whether I served on the board of the Chicago Boys and Girls Club, the Logan Square unit, for a number of years, and a term as a president, as the privilege of sitting in with the Torch Club, comprised of young men who had formerly been engaged in gangs and were working towards a better life and just observing what they have done. The opportunity to serve for many years as a member of the board of directors of St. Augustine College, junior college, the first bilingual junior college, accredited junior college in Illinois in the Midwest. I met many wonderful people there. uh uh as uh as Bo Whistle mentioned um one of the things I try to instill and I believe myself instill in law students and inspire them to use their law degree as an instrumentality to make a contribution whether it's to their community uh to the city to their church synagogue mosque wherever it is a law degree is a powerful powerful tool uh if we're in the right hands to do good and also to get, as we did in the business law clinic, to get really our essential mission more specifically was to get entrepreneurs and starting growing businesses on a solid legal foundation. And that, in sum, was part of the restorative economic justice movement to reinvigorate communities that suffered disinvestment and lack of proper opportunities. So that was a privilege for me to do that. This is another opportunity that I was asked if I had interest in. And I said, I've jumped at this opportunity once I read the ordinance and got my arms around some of the work that's done. I'm particularly interested in one of the duties of the board, which is to make recommendations to this committee of changes to the ethics ordinance, to tighten it, to make it more transparent, to publicize it so the people of City of Chicago realize that the city is investing real solid resources in making the city a fair, a more just place to live, without favoritism, and everyone treated as on a level playing field. And I think that's what, in essence, this committee does. And I've been very, very enlightened and have much, much more to learn about the, much, much more to learn about the workings of the committee and how I can contribute to it. But it's a privilege, really, and a privilege for me to be asked to serve in this position. I hope I'm confirmed. I'm not showing this group more ethical. I think I can make a contribution to putting forth and supporting existing recommendations that the committee has already made for legislation. For example, there's a substitute ordinance as amended that's been presented before to the Lightfoot administration and I believe also to the administration, a current Johnson administration, that tightens up a number of provisions and clarifies a number of provisions in the ethics ordinance. And that hasn't been enacted. And I observed, really, I just met Ryan personally for the first time today, so we haven't discussed this at all. But I observed that the Ethics Board has changed its strategy in making recommendations and putting things forward. What the Ethics Board has done is they extracted and chose one of the provisions of the substitute ordinance as amended, and they're advocating and recommending it as a standalone ordinance. And this particular ordinance deals with political fundraising committees. And sometimes a political fundraising, as I read it, and when I try to talk about this, I'm not offering an opinion on it because I'm just learning about it. But on a thousand foot level, it sounds like a good idea to me. That doesn't mean that I come to that conclusion when we drill down, I study it and learn it and listen to what the other committee's board members have to say. But in essence, that section that they pulled out and were proposing as a standalone ordinance speaks to political fundraising committees that have gone out of existence and that which committee has been subject to a fine or some other sanction by the Board of Ethics for something or other. I don't know what. And it is a fact, in essence, they're trying to claw back when that candidate or political fundraising committee resurrects itself as another new committee for the same candidate, this ordinance would enable the city to benefit and receive the money that it deserves to receive for fines assessed against the original committee. it's essentially a clawback ordinance. So that very much. I'd also very much like to be involved in outreach. I think the more that members of the committee can go out to the communities the communities and speak before synagogues, mosques, churches, community organizations, chambers of commons, high schools, about the work of the committee and how much effort and resources the city of Chicago puts toward it. Because I see, I can see already how dedicated, because I looked at some of the reports of the Office of Inspector General. I've read some minutes of prior meetings, and I'm impressed by how diligent they were. If they weren't, I would not have permit myself my name to be submitted this far. And I think they're doing good work, and I want to be part of it. I'd like to be part of it. I'd like to support it. I think I have, I can contribute to it. And that's my answer to your question. Thank you. Thank you. Alderman Wagus Peck followed by Alderman Riley. Thank you, Chairman. First, I want to thank Mr. Cortazar for his work in the time that he's been in office. I know that we've seen a lot of difficult decisions come up, but I want to just first say I appreciate you taking on that task originally and then asking for more suffering by taking the reappointment. But we do, I think we all appreciate the work you've done, especially since we've been short on commissioners or members of the board to deal with a lot of these issues that have come up. So thank you very much for your service. Thank you. I appreciate that. And Mr. Schlesinger, thank you for stepping up and, you know, meeting Mr. Cortazar for the first time. I know you're going to have a lot of issues that you will have to discuss in these board of ethics meetings, and there's a constant drum of activity that comes up to the board. One of the things that we talked about with the inspector general recently is he was appointed to recently as he was appointed to his position was to make sure that items that are recommended or referred to the Board of Ethics are done and completed with all due diligence. And that is going to be something I think we would all infer to you too, that we hope that the board can make decisions that are timely when they do come up. And I know Mr. Cortazar has had to deal with lack of quorum on the board of ethics. So hopefully with you there, we'll be able to get back to a regular cadence to get these things done. Just a question for each of you, if you don't mind. And it's pretty straightforward, but when you look at the ethics code, and there's some good information on the city website would you say that all appointees to any board and commission of any kind in the city of chicago are subject to the ethics code all appointees to any board or any commission you're looking at me so uh well either one of you yeah well uh you might have more experience in this but um so maybe let him go first so you can so it's hard to get up there It's hard to say without looking at the text of the ordinance itself. We certainly treat every case that comes before us presumptively as falling under the ethics code, but it's also subject to, we have vigorous debates at every meeting to determine whether or not something is in our jurisdiction. so we're always very uh cognizant of the limits that the city council has placed on us to be honest i'm not familiar with every um city board uh sister i guess sister agencies i don't believe are covered yeah they would be separate right they would be separate but for example today Today, I learned for the first time about the Jesse Jackson Committee, which I think is a strong initiative. As I mentioned earlier, my first job out of law school was working in voting rights, so I'm glad to see the city protecting those going forward in a proactive fashion. So to answer your question, I believe that it's true. I believe that every city employee and official is subject to the ordinance, but as cases come up, it's hard to predict how to interpret the text of the audience as to the facts presented to us. So if, well, I would just add to that. So sister agencies are typically not, but what we've instructed the inspector general's office to do over several years is to have memorandums of understanding with our sister agencies so that when things pop up like tens of millions of dollars and tickets or fines are not being paid by sister agency employees, that somehow they are held to account to make sure that they are following through on their ethics as well. And I know that's sort of an issue that really hasn't risen up to your level yet, but that is something I hope that you both could speak to the inspector general about, about how to make sure that as we are collaborating with those sister agencies, that everyone is following the same set of rules. And then going back to the appointees. So anytime the city council creates appointments for different boards, whether it's the health board, public health board, or any one of the advisory boards, we do so with the intent that everyone on those boards is following the board of what you put in place for ethics through the ethics department or the director. And there are some very broad lines that we are beholden to as aldermen that I think appointees need to be held to as well. appointees need to be held to as well there is no carve out when we do an ordinance or when we appoint people there's no carve out for people to be separate or excluded from that set of rules that that we continue to improve on thanks to the content that you talk about and and give us to make changes to and Mr. Schlesinger in our discussions and this is one of the issues just police district councils seem to not be beholden to any kind of ethics rules for the city of Chicago whether you go through human resources and ask for assistance through the through CCPSA, through the inspector general, and also through the ethics director, there's been a lapse or a, you know, a wide gap in terms of how people are held accountable. So we talked about that briefly. I don't know if you had time to look into it, but how would you hold people accountable who are appointed to any position in the city? Well, here, well, I certainly don't have the breadth of experience that Ryan has having just started looking at this within the last month. But what strikes me about your question and comments of the responsibility of holding people accountable is that I recall the definition of agency in the ethics code. And again, I haven't looked at it since I have read it several times, and my recollection is that an agency includes any commission, board, everybody under them, the whole ball of wax, any subdivision of city government. of city government. It's like almost, I looked at that and thought about that almost like a supremacy cause in the U.S. Constitution, supremacy cause. I don't mean that as a direct analogy, but it does seem that the city and city government and the city ordinances are the highest level of authority governing city employees, officials, and elected officials. And the term officials is the broadest of all of those definitions. It includes elected officials, appointed officials, non-employee appointed officials. So I don't really, I don't see how the ration, a rational basis based on my current understanding. And I, again, I'm a thousand feet here. I don't see how a logical argument is made for a certain council that you mentioned, the police district councils, to say somehow that their employees are not subject to the ethics rules of the city of Chicago. It almost sounds like an oxymoron. That's maybe too strong a statement, I would be, but again, I don't, I'm not voicing an opinion. I haven't studied it. I haven't really been in the weeds. And I, that's, I just want to put it on your plate. And I think as you serve in this position, you, you might see some of these issues come up at the board and I'm not asking you to, I think that was a good answer. I don't think, I'm not trying to put you in a box this morning. I just want you to be aware that these issues are happening. You know, I've had it with my district counselors where we've had death threats, we've had assaults, we've had political activity that continues on city dollars and city time. And to me, it is a clear violation of the ethics. is a clear violation of the ethics code, which says you cannot perform political activity during compensated time or use city personnel to solicit or do anything. And there are clear violations of this. So I think it'll be coming up on your desk as you move forward. I actually, which I would like to discuss with Ryan in the future and discuss with my colleagues, should I be uh uh confirmed uh a strategy uh if if if if there's happens to be a violation and the ethics board finds a violation imposes a flying then there's an enforcement aspect to it and that would generally uh and generally involve the uh suppose that the corporation counsel's office then let somebody contest it in court get a judicial resolution of it instead of being battered back and forth, and you can take it up, any party can take it up on appeal if they want to, and maybe it'll get to the Illinois appellate or Supreme Court. But it sounds like actually a very, very important issue. The notion that employees of certain agencies with millions of dollars of outstanding fines owed by employees are flouting that in the face of the city of chicago uh sounds um uh sounds unusual and i'm not sure it's correct but again i'm not voicing an opinion i want to study it but uh i think aggressive enforcement uh might yield a uh a judicial result that uh uh people will follow the rule of law as we wish yeah follow the rule law and um the city can move forward in the right direction right thank you very much then put it behind us thank you thank you both for your service then thank you thank you alderman reilly thank you chairman um and good morning um and mr schlesinger and good morning um and mr schlesinger uh although we did not get a chance to speak over the weekend i appreciate you reaching out on multiple occasions thank you based on your voicemails i feel like we did speak and thank you for the detail no no no did you get my text i got all of it i got every last bit thank you uh i was traveling i had to attend a wedding just following instructions no no no no you did it all you did all very well and and clearly there's you No dispute. You're absolutely qualified for the position, and I've had a chance to hear you responding to my colleagues' questions, fully satisfied by that. And this may be a question for both of you, since you're one up for reappointment and another for appointment. And it's more – I want to just talk a little bit about political activity by appointees. And we're about to appoint a whole bunch of folks, presumably, to the Reverend Jesse Jackson, Senior Advisory Council on Access to Democracy. We also have a number of other appointments that will be before various committees at city council in the coming weeks. And I wanted to get your general take on various types of political activity that are taken on by appointees to various city bodies or sister agencies. um what how do you view appointees making campaign contributions within six months of their appointment uh either to the executive branch or to members of the city council either one of you can take that first jump ball yes so from a from an ordinance perspective I'm not exactly I know there are there's a large number of prohibited political activities and we enforce that in terms of whether. um in terms of whether or not that's uh goes beyond the ordinance whether or not something that's appropriate I feel like that's beyond my canon without knowing the circumstances I think that's also one of the reasons why it's so important when we have these investigations to have a thorough record before us so we can see because sometimes there might be innocent sometimes it might not um certainly that type of behavior raises a potential suspicion of pay to play. But it's hard to make a determination without having a full factual record, having had the people come before us and have an opportunity to be heard to explain what the nature of that context absolutely matters. And I appreciate that answer, Mr. Schlesinger. Yeah, well, I view your questions from a different lens and a broader perspective on it. And my whole focus for the last three weeks has been to read and just get my arms to understand the ordinance. And I know that a person appointed to the board of ethics certainly cannot do any of that. I am less certain, less certain that the, Ryan would probably know better that the ethics statute encompasses an appointee, a non-compensated appointee, or a compensated appointee to some of the other boards that don't have this direct authority of decision-making that affects people's lives and reputations by issuing fines or other remedies. So I'd have to really look into that. I thought they did not. I really don't know. But I'm satisfied with that. Balance, you don't want to take away somebody's opportunity because they are a good Samaritan and want to be appointed by the mayor and have the honor of being appointed by the mayor of the city of Chicago the mayor of the city of chicago uh to uh from what i just a brief what i have heard about this access to justice it's a very it's going to be a very good thing a good a good uh good endeavor well let me let me let me help everybody out here and i appreciate your answer yeah thank you um it wasn't specific to this particular body we're going to be i presumably populating today with appointees yeah i'm talking about generally appointments and i'll give you uh one last hypothetical and then i'll cede my time hypothetically there is a candidate for appointment to a sister agency's board this is a membership of a board where you're voting on actual policy and the guidance of that sister agency and say this potential this this appointee who's not yet been confirmed was a consistent campaign donor to whomever the mayor is at that time in small dollar amounts a couple hundred bucks here and there but then suddenly we we see this person writing a five thousand dollar check within weeks of potentially being appointed to a major board so i'm giving you a little bit more specific information optically that's horrible However, in your opinion, does that cross the line ethically? I think if it smells like a potential conflict, smells like a potential pay-to-play, is it or not? Can I ask one question? Sure. I'm not familiar with the term sister agency unless you're talking about metropolitan, you know, the convention board. Oh, no, no. So a sister agency would be something like the CTA. Ah, okay. Or the CHA. Yeah. Oh, boy. Right. So, you know, these are these are folks that are accountable to the mayor, but not directly to the city council. Is that so? Yeah. Well, the question is whether they're accountable to the city of Chicago. Correct. And the governance and the governing ordinance of the city of Chicago. So, you know, I really am not equipped, honestly, to weigh into that. I understand your frustration, but I do want to mention that one of the things I came across in preparations and asked to read, and I did read in considerable detail, was transparency or transparency in elections and so-called dark money. I don't know if you've seen that, a proposal that emanated from this committee. Yeah, that's another discussion we'll have another day. It's dark money, and now we have somebody who's giving relatively small amounts of money, and they're somehow bundling it, either through a political action committee or some type of a funding organization, and it sounds, doesn't pass the smell test. Tom yeah we have a lot of work whether we can do anything about it but again it's a question of how hard you want to push it sure uh whether it's something that uh there could be if if somebody really wants to pull the trigger and get injunctive relief or declaratory relief and put their feet to the fire put the crucible but in the crucible and see how that see how see how they react and see what a judge says I don't know we can address that at a future day Mr. I want to be specific to this hypothetical and i'd like to have ryan take a shot at that so i think one of the difficulties with um the hypothetical is that the sister agencies so the person who would be making the contribution if i understand the hypothetical would not would be subject to the ordinance i think insofar potentially insofar as campaign limits so do whether or not that violated the the limits, I think, is a question, is a legislative question. And so it's not clear to me that the person who made the contribution would have violated the ordinance, but that could be amended potentially. The same is also true for the election. The same is also true for the elected official who's involved in the appointment, that there could be legislative determination to limit the amount of contributions that they can accept from particular persons, particular companies. And so I think that's the appropriate lens to look at as to how can we, if that's a concern, it's a legislative concern that we would, if it were passed, would apply. but it's hard to figure out how to, as an adjudicative body, to figure out how to do that in a hypothetical situation, if that makes sense. I guess what I'm getting at is it's less about the level of the contribution, whether or not that violated a cap. It's more the optics of someone seeking an appointment to an influential position that reports directly to the executive branch and this person is suddenly writing massive checks to the principal of the executive branch that is what i'm trying to get at here would that be a breach of ethics because optically it sure feels that way on the ordinance i'm to be honest i'm not sure what the limits are on this specific hypothetical i do think that it's the type of matter that the inspector general would normally if it were, would conduct an investigation, provide a preliminary assessment of the conduct to the ordinance, and then we would take it ourselves, look at the conduct, look at the ordinance, make a determination of probable cause. From there, we'd have the person come in if we made a determination of probable cause and have them discuss it and decide whether or not there's a violation. But as to whether or not that specific fact is a violation of the ordinance, I couldn't answer that right now, but if it is a concern, I do think that that I don't think that there's anything that would that would. that would that would limit the the council from passing an ordinance from prohibiting certain contributions to the executive branch we know that in the past there has been um there have been uh we have applied executive orders that relate somewhat to this issue um but in executive orders ultimately whether on the federal level or on the state or city level is not going to be as strong as something that's actually passed by the council itself that could provide teeth to say well there's an order maybe there might be a violation but there's no remedy and that's those are ultimately things i think are important for the city council to determine to determine as to whether or not certain actions by appointees or certain actions by city council members or certain actions by members of the executive branch rise level of violation and how to cure that okay well i appreciate you uh i know hypotheticals are difficult um so i appreciate you responding to my question um the reason i raise it is that in order to do if you do business with a sister agency in the city of chicago your political activity is limited at fifteen hundred dollars per year that's per the ethics code yet if you're seeking an appointment to serve on a on a board for one of these agencies apparently you can write thousands and thousands and thousands of dollars in contributions that seems like a bit of a double standard to me and that is something i think this body will take up in the future but thank you for your your answers to my questions and thank you chairman i'll be voting to confirm both thank you any other questions from committee members seeing none Alderman Sposato thank you chairman I'm not going to dare ask a question I'm just going to make a statement One of you that has been here a while, one of you that is new. We're going to be starting. I have a little problem with the way the board operates, I think. I've experienced it one time. There's a well-known stalker on the northwest side that's always complaining about certainly us on the northwest side, but it really applies to anybody in the city, whether you're a worker or an elected. I honestly, truly, in my heart of hearts, believe almost everybody wants to do the right thing, but sometimes we accidentally do the wrong thing and I'm going to give you a case in point what happened to me one time and there were no consequences but I think it could have been simply resolved by saying Nick you can't do that you can't use your apron with the city sale on it so I'm selling t-shirts to raise money for the police memorial foundation and a murdered police officer I get called in saying you can't do that you're wrong like I said no fine, no consequences but I think it's going to have been simply resolved by just picking up the phone and saying, Nick, moving forward, if you're selling T-shirts, don't use your apron that says Alderman Sposado with the city seal. So that would have been my only ask. I have no questions. I'm not asking you to respond, nothing. It's just a statement, just something to consider. You've been around. You kind of know how things work. So as I would say, as you see something going on where it's an elected or a city employee, just pick up the phone and say, hey, you're doing something wrong. You're pushing it. You're pushing here a little cease and desist, and everything's fine. That's it. Thank you, guys. Appreciate you guys stepping up. Thanks, Chairman. Thank you. Any other questions? Okay. Alderman Riley moves to pass the recommended approval of the appointment of Michael Schlesinger as a member of the Board of Ethics. All those in favor signify by saying aye. All those opposed? In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. The appointment passes. Can I have a motion to recommend the approval of the reappointment of Ryan Cortazar as a member of the board? Alderman Riley, so moves. All those in favor signify by saying aye. All those opposed? In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. The appointment passes. Thank you both. We look forward to working with you. Thank you. Thank you very much. And would invite the appointments for the next. the appointments for the next set on the agenda to come up. And specifically, those are nine appointments to the Reverend Jesse L. Jackson, Senior Advisory Council on Access to Democracy. These are appointments involving Deshaun Branch, Stevie Vallis, Jane Ruby, Alison Raddick, Stephen Thurston, Brianna Champion, Christian Taylor, Frank Lally, and Sophia Franco. Reverend Stephen Thurston couldn't be here today, so we will hold his appointment in committee today. The committee received substitute appointments for Deshaun Branch, Stevie Vallis, Jane Ruby, and Allison Raddick, which were sent to the committee via email. Can I have a motion to accept these substitutes? Alderwoman Taylor So Moose, all those in favor signify by saying aye. All those opposed, in the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. We have appointees here today. Oh, Alderwag is back, yes. Just a point of order. So the direct introductions that we have from 8, 9, 10, 11, and 12, what was the reason for the direct introductions? I believe it was because they were not formally introduced at the most recent city council meeting. This body has nine positions. And to operate like any other body, they'd need at least five people for quorum. So these came in several weeks ago and pushed to have that information shared with the committee as quickly as possible. Okay, so they were emergency or what do we, when we do the direct intros, what's the specific? To ensure that there would be a working quorum for the advisory board to operate, to make any recommendations that they see fit in advance of the November, February, and April elections. okay thank you thank you um let's see we have that taken care of okay um we'll uh just take the appointees uh from your left to right i think uh steve Your left to right, I think, Stevie, we're going to have you speak last, as you, I think, will be able to tie stuff up. We're already an hour into the committee. We would ask people to be as concise as you can with your statements. I believe that everybody who provided a written statement in advance, the committee members have that. So we'll start with you. Please continue or start as your convenience. Awesome. Thank you, Chairman Martin and members of the committee. My name is Deshawn Branch, and I currently serve as Interim Executive Director of Change Illinois. We are a nonpartisan nonprofit that champions equitable democracy, ethics, and efficiency in government and elections across Illinois. I became Executive Director of Change Illinois after serving as the Community Organizing Director, where I've led statewide organizing efforts, cultivated meaningful partnerships with community organizations, expanded voter education initiatives, and grew volunteer engagement and civic action for the organization. And I will sum up that I have worked in collaboration with a number of the other organizations and people who are included in this Fair Access to Democracy Advisory Council, and I look forward to working with this coalition as well as council members to make sure that Chicago elections continue to be accessible to all and that voters have the resources they need to exercise their right to vote. Thank you. Thank you. Chair and members of the committee, good morning. My name is Jane Ruby. I'm president of the League of Women Voters of Chicago. It is an honor to be nominated to the Fair Access to Democracy Advisory Council, and I'm grateful to this committee for considering my appointment. I'm deeply honored by this nomination, not least because it represents an opportunity to advance a cause to which I've devoted much of my life, ensuring that democracy is not merely a promise on paper but a right that every eligible voter can exercise freely and without fear. freely and without fear. As president of the League of Women Voters of Chicago, I've seen firsthand both the extraordinary commitment of Chicagoans to our democratic institutions and the very real challenges that continue to threaten access to the ballot. That experience has reinforced a conviction at the heart of the League's mission. Democracy is only as strong as the ability of its people to participate in it. I have served on the League's board since 2018 and its president since 2022. Our work includes voter education, candidate forums, and election protection. The Reverend Jesse L. Jackson Senior Fair Access to Democracy Ordinance, which the league proudly supported, recognizes that democracy requires more than the right to vote on paper. It requires protecting voters and election workers from intimidation and removing barriers to participation. Central to my qualifications is my commitment to strict non-partisanship the league never endorses candidates or political parties as president I'm held to an even higher standard personally refraining from campaign participation endorsements or public support for candidates our side is the voter side always if confirmed I will bring that independence and experience to the council focused on practical solutions that expand participation and strengthen public trust I will bring to this responsibility the experience of the League, the independence, its mission demands, and my own unwavering belief that access to democracy should never depend on your zip code, your income, your background, or which candidate you support. Democracy belongs to all of us. Protecting it is a responsibility we share. I would be honored to serve. Thank you for your consideration. Chairman Martin and members of the committee, my name is Christian Taylor, and I currently serve as the Director of Advocacy and Government Affairs at Asian Americans Advancing Justice Chicago, a nonprofit advocacy organization based. a non-profit advocacy organization based in Uptown that builds power through collective advocacy and organizing to advance racial equity. Advancing Justice runs the largest nonpartisan volunteer poll watching program in the state of Illinois, focusing on monitoring precincts covered under Section 203 of the Voting Rights Act. Through this work, we help ensure that voters can exercise their rights and that language access protections are upheld at the polls. I believe increasing voter turnout is not just about encouraging people to vote, but ensuring that eligible voters can actually exercise their right to vote. That means investing in accessible multilingual voter education, working with trusted community organizations, and addressing barriers that make the voting process confusing or difficult to navigate, particularly for voters with limited English proficiency. When it comes to election security, I believe our elections are secure and we should continue building public confidence through transparency, accurate information, and strong protections against voter intimidation and misinformation. I hope to bring to this council my experience working in both city government and community advocacy, as well as my understanding of how policy decisions affect people's ability to participate meaningfully in our democracy. In my current role, I work with elected officials, government agencies, and community partners to advance policies that make government more accessible and responsive to the communities that it serves. Thank you for your consideration, and I'm happy to answer any questions that you may have afterwards. Thank you. Chairman Martin and members of the committee, my name is Alison Radek, and I'm a youth organizer and advocate in the city of Chicago. I currently work as the Policy and Advocacy Fellow at Chicago Votes and do community organizing work with the Prison and Neighborhood Arts and Education Project. Additionally, I'm a part-time student at the University of Illinois, Chicago, studying public policy and black studies. At UIC, I proudly serve as the president of our Student Advocacy Coalition and was a founding organizer of the Illinois' first public undergraduate union, Housing Staff United. My involvement in this work began in high school. Growing up in Champaign, I attended a Title I high school and saw the effects of the school to prison pipeline firsthand. Watching classmates and friends lose their lives to gun violence and incarceration, I felt pushed to make sure that young voices were included in any conversations surrounding us. It was during high school that I took the opportunity to become an election judge at age 16. I've now served as an election judge in the city of Chicago for the last five years and I've learned the ins and outs of our voting processes and procedures. It's these experiences that have pushed me to work to make sure that young people understand their power and their stake in our democracy, that their voices and their votes can help affect community change on their own blocks. I want to empower young people like me to take action in their own schools, communities and cities. I've dedicated my teen and young adult years to advocating for policies and practices to ensure that Youth Voice has a seat at every table where decisions are being made about us. I'm immensely grateful to have the opportunity to be nominated to serve on this advisory council. And if appointed, I look forward to helping to bring civic access and education to communities across the city and hope to provide more opportunities to build up young Chicagoans to use their power for change. I thank you all for this opportunity and for helping to create space for young voices to be heard in rooms that we haven't yet had access to. I look forward to answering any questions that you may have, and I'm incredibly excited to share ideas about how we can increase youth voter engagement across the city of Chicago. Thank you. Chairman Martin and members of the committee, I am Brianna Champion, a lifelong Chicagoan, Who is honored to speak before you as I am being considered for an esteemed appointment to the fair access to them for an esteemed appointment to the Fair Access to Democracy Advisory Council. Born and raised in Chicago, I have seen how our city's commitment to freedom has shaped the fabric of our country. I bring to this council over a decade of experience fighting for Chicagoans on the margins. First, as a bright-eyed activist and student at Lincoln Park High School. Then, as an organizer at Chicago Votes, where I spent the summer of 2013 personally registering over 1,000 young people to vote as a student organizer at UIC, as a founding member of the Black Youth Project 100 Chicago chapter, representing victims of violence and torture at the United Nations in Switzerland, and now as an organizer with the Chicago Black Voter Project. We created the Chicago Black Voter Project, a non-partisan organization to help increase voter turnout on the south and west sides of Chicago. The time I have spent canvassing on the south and west sides has shown me that these communities are often ignored and cast aside from the political process, and only a select few are reached when election season rolls around. Chicago Black Voter Project cannot do the work of reaching these communities alone, and that is why this Advisory Council is important. We know that Chicago serves as a beacon of democracy. So if we can begin to reach disengaged and disillusioned populations here, we will be promoting democratic processes around the world. As leaders on this stage for innovative and creative policy, I am proud to be considered for an appointment to this advisory council to help promote voter access and participation year-round, not just on election day. I look forward to serving on this board and taking steps to protect and ensure fair access to democracy in Chicago together. access to democracy in chicago together thank you for your consideration and i look forward to answering any questions you have thank you um chairman martin and members of the committee as you mentioned chairman martin everyone has the written statements so i'll spare you the whole thing just give the cliff notes my name is frank lally i work as a senior policy analyst at access living which is chicago's center for independent living for those unaware we are a disability advocacy organization and direct service organization my voting policy work there at access living centers around expanding accessible voting opportunities for Chicagoans with disabilities in a previous role while working at mikvah challenge I partnered with the Chicago Board of Elections to manage the student election judge program and through that program for each election we recruited roughly 2 000 chicago high schoolers to serve as election judges on e-day and then um previously before that with the council of state governments i assisted the federal voting assistance program which is a program that um allows it makes it easier for military and overseas voters to cast their ballots safely and securely on each election um you know if given the opportunity to serve on this board i would serve as a voice to amplify communication that the chicago boe about the accessibility measures they are already doing and get that information out to the community and i'll also advocate for increased accessibility messer measures such as a plan putting a plan in place for full ada accessibility in all polling places um thank you i look forward to answering any questions if you have them thank you we have participating virtually sofia franco sofia if you can unmute and share brief remarks we'd appreciate it chairman martin and members of the committee I'm honored to appear before you today, virtually. I'm honored to appear before you today virtually as a nominee to the Fair Access to Democracy Council. I'm currently at Illinois State University studying political science with a minor in women, gender, and sexuality studies. I have experience working with my university's multicultural center where I served as a anti-racism peer leader and I'm currently working with Citizen Action Illinois as a canvasser which I've also done for the past few years. My work with Citizen Action Illinois has included helping motivate students who are not currently politically active and working to increase voter turnout while gaining hands-on experience in the democratic process of elections. My democratic engagement started in high school during my years on the debate team. We spent countless hours researching and arguing different institutions and proposed policies. The debate pushed me to see all perspectives of a given issue, which is a trait that I'll continue to have while serving as a member on this advisory council. For me, fair access to democracy in Chicago means more than just having the right to vote. It involves having the necessary education, the access to resources, and opportunities necessary to participate in elections. Growing up on the southwest side, I've seen that people care and have all the heart, but they don't have the resources or knowledge to go out and exercise the right to vote. As a student, I really hope to engage Chicago's youth. I am also excited to learn from all the other council members and collaborate on future policies that will benefit all of Chicago. I look forward to serving on the Fair Access to Democracy Council, and I appreciate your support and consideration. Thank you. Lastly, Stevie. Oh, and recognizing non-committee member Angela Clay, thank you for joining. Mic check, mic check. Good afternoon, Chair and members of the committee. My name is Stevie Valles. I'm the CEO of Chicago Votes, and I want to thank you first for considering my appointment to the Fair Access to Democracy Council. This council has an opportunity to become a trusted, nonpartisan space for community input during elections and between them, a place where residents help shape House a place where residents help shape how Chicago's democracy works. Its strength will depend on the range of experiences, identities, neighborhoods, and constituencies represented, and on its connection to people beyond this room. The community nomination process we helped facilitate was rooted in that goal, ensuring Chicagoans have a voice in who represents them. A little bit of context for that. I know that we were here a few months ago for the original hearing for this ordinance. When we left, we actually facilitated a community input process, and that's how the names selected today that are presented to you were selected. They were nominated by a group of over 60-plus democracy-focused organizations. My background personally includes national youth civic engagement, work in the United States Senate, work in the Texas legislature, and leadership at Chicago Votes, as well as participation in multiple civic bodies in Chicago, the United States, and internationally. Across these settings, a consistent lesson has emerged. Participation grows when people have accessible information, trusted relationships, and meaningful opportunities to influence decisions. As Chicago votes, civic education, parades to the polls, voting inside the Cook County Jail, as well as automatic voter registration are things that we have worked on to make sure they're part of the civic culture of Chicago. This work underscores the importance of understanding barriers directly from the people experiencing them. This council can carry that approach forward through neighborhood listening sessions, accessible opportunities to contribute you online and in person and clear reporting on how public input shapes reporting on how public input shapes recommendations innovation should help modernize chicago's civic and democratic systems making election information easier to navigate strengthening voter protection and creating new avenues for participation those improvements should account for differences in language, disability, and access to technology. Chicago can set a national example by showing how democracy is strengthened through democratic processes, inviting broad participation, listening across differences, and developing solutions with the communities they will affect. It would be an honor to contribute to that work. Thank you. Thank you. We will now open the floor up to questions, first from committee members and then non-committee members does anyone have a question or comment alderman taylor good morning alderman taylor my apologies for interrupting is it possible to get a microphone thank you apologies for interrupting can you hear me now that's better yes so thank you all for wanting to to be a part of this table we don't have a voter registration problem we have a get out and vote problem and so maybe three of you not all of you can answer the question how will you work with this committee to make sure we're getting people out to actually vote okay just start thank you for your question um i think that i am excited to be a part of this group because I think that I am excited to be a part of this group because a number of us already work together. But to think about the things that we are doing in a streamlined position to work to get people out to vote, if that is transportation. And I think there are a lot of folks who do things with young folks, but something I always think about is older folks or people who have work or people who have children. So I think being in a group like this, where we can already think about the things that we are doing to get our collective out to vote, how can we take that to other communities? How can we be strategic? As the interim executive director of a small organization, we have small capacity, but working together, we can think about how we can synchronize our volunteers, synchronize our efforts to take some of the ideas that we're already working on to bring those to other communities. So I'm really excited about that opportunity. Yeah, I'll just add that part of what I would like to see this Democracy Council do is actually engage with community members to understand what is the exact barrier that folks are facing. I think it's important that we start in those neighborhoods where voter turnout is the worst. to no surprise anyone here, to anyone here, there's a correlation between low voter participation and a lot of economic and socioeconomic factors. I think that, you know, we have automatic voter registration here. We have same day voter registration here. To your point, voter registration actually isn't the challenge. It's actually getting people to go and vote. And there are a lot of reasons for that. And I think being intentional about hearing all those reasons and trying to restore trust in our civic institutions by making educational material accessible to folks in diverse ways, leveraging the power of our different organizations to engage. the power of our different organizations to engage creatives and young people and language access experts and disability access experts to pull together kind of a round well-rounded listening and intentional implementation effort to try to increase voter turnout in a non-partisan way so we know go ahead uh thank you uh alderman uh so i think just to piggyback off of that like those were all are both were all really good comments and i think you know really focusing on taking like a hyper local approach community community approach word by word whatever that looks like um and also you know trying to figure out and talk with people like why aren't you voting like do you not believe in the system like have you been um uh you know like punished by the system like why and and seeing that uh seeing how we can tie all those comment threads together to show that, you know, government is powerful and really can improve people's lives. But we just have to ensure that we go out and vote and exercise that right. And I think, you know, some other specific examples we can do is really tapping into a variety of our organizations and organizations and community, you know, national networks, affiliations, other coalitions that we are on nationwide, or throughout the state or the county or whatever. And then trying to just create structures that align with the needs of community. And maybe that's advocating for more funding for the board of elections so that there can be more community people, you know, more of a presence in community and doing the things that people want and need to increase that turnout. So speaking of the board of elections, I don't think when this was created, there was a great intention and job to work with the board of elections. And that's really where the problem lies imagine going to vote and they tell you it's not your polling place but they don't tell you where your polling place is imagine it not being in walking distance imagine is imagine it not being in walking distance imagine it not being in you move there are a lot of things that go and so how will you all work with the board of elections because i feel like when when this was created that was the biggest mistake that was made doing this while we honor reverend jackson we know he believed in bringing groups together and this was a mistake in the creation of this and so to the people who haven't spoke how are you all going to work with the board of elections to reassure because the problem is while the board of election does these things there is no way to make sure that it's done there is no what do you call it no it's another word I'm looking for maybe follow through that's it maybe no follow through and nobody to help make sure reassure that the board of elections are doing those things and so like making sure it's ADS accessible, making sure they have the right ballots. I've went and gotten the wrong ballot, a ballot that didn't even have my name on it, and I'm voting in my own ward. And so those are some of the issues that we also have when it comes to elections. And so how will you all do the work to make sure that you're working directly with the Board of Elections to reassure we move some of those barriers out the way for people to vote? Thank you, Chairman. I appreciate the the question I mean I'll say from a disability perspective the the board does offer a lot of accessibility measures for for voters with disabilities I don't think that everyone in the community knows about it there's accessible vote-by-mail for for example for blind voters where they can use their you know technology marking device to to cast that ballot but I don't think that all blind motors in the city of Chicago know about that and so I do see you know, my role at Access Living and, you know, potentially being on this committee, talking with the board to figure out what is the best way they can advertise and we can help amplify. can advertise and we can help amplify those resources that they have i think another thing like you mentioned um polling places moving or not being walking distance another thing is not all polling places are physically accessible and how do you get the communication out to um the community so that they know what what to expect when they get to their polling place that that's a role that i that i see that i would take on there yeah and if i can just add first thank you for that question um from my experience the board of elections is an amazing resource if anyone here has worked in voter engagement they've accessed the board for maps and information about different dates and etc but um i know that our purpose is to simply support the work that they do and we look forward to working with them um i also know that a member of the board of elections will be a part of this advisory council as well, if that's not clear. Thank you so much for your question, Alderwoman. I would also like to add, in addition to supporting everything that the other nominees have also said, is that the League of Women Voters has had a longstanding relationship with the Board of Elections. We work really closely, especially informing them of what our efforts are around elections and in between elections to ensure that there's more trust with the community and the Board of Elections systems and processes. And I see this advisory council as a great sort of way to further those connections with the Board of Elections, but also with members of city council. You, as city council, you know your communities better than most people as a whole, and we are really looking forward to meeting with all of you as the body, you know, if we are appointed to discuss what are specific areas and how we can bring that into our coordination with the Board of Elections and with and with our other organizations during elections and also in between election cycles. So usually the problem is on election day. So normally the older person is the committeeman, I am not, because that is another full-time job that I don't have time to take care of. And so we get hundreds and hundreds of calls on that day. How will you all be working with the Board of Elections to help that call? Because that's when we lose those voters. If I go to a place and they're like, this is not your polling place, all the women, Taylor, going to be honest, I'm going home. I'm going to miss that vote. And so how do we, where is the, are you all creating a campaign to reassure there's an election coming up? And so a campaign to get people to have a voting plan to make sure that people know where their polling place is way earlier. Because I'm going to be honest, they bellowed those cards months in advance. You know I ain't looked at that card. You know it's in the Palomar with everybody. But I'll be looking for a text or email to say, hey, this is your polling place. This is where you go vote. This is the type of election it is. Because some people don't feel like all elections are important. They all are, of course. And so I want you all to think about a plan to put out in communities very early, maybe two months before election time, so that people have their plan in place. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you. Alderwoman Nugent, followed by Alderwoman Lee. Thank you, Chair. And thanks, everybody, for being here today. I appreciate it and appreciate you wanting to be involved in helping to ensure people have access to the polls and more people do vote. I, you know, I was struck by something that Jane had said that through your work with League of Women Voters, there's no endorsing of candidates. I'm just curious for the folks up here in the groups that you're with. Are you all nonpartisan or 501C3s? OK. And do you guys, does anybody here make endorsements? okay nobody nobody makes endorsements at all candidate questionnaire endorsements at all candidate questionnaires non-partisan candidate questionnaires so ones that don't have an endorsement process it's just candidate voter information okay and then you should you share the questionnaires with your membership yeah and the general public like they appear on websites and stuff i think most organizations up here do some form of candidate questionnaire or candidate forums but they're all done in a 100 non-partisan space that don't in lead to endorsements or any leading questions there's like robust systems in place too sure now you you spoke for the league of women voters and it sounds like you guys do have a really robust program but just does everybody else have that type of program too with the candidate questionnaire specifically meaning the non-partisan nature of the organization do you as board members will you guys be making any endorsements in city races no we don't endorse i don't think any of our organizations endorse, no. Okay, that's helpful. And then how do you, and I don't know if you guys answer this or if staff from the city has to answer this, who do you guys report to? We are responsible for submitting a report on our findings over the course of the year. We have to have four meetings and then we submit that report to city hall and to the mayor's office with recommendations. I think that would constitute our responsibility. Like you meet four times and just, it's, just help me understand, like, have you already been asked what you should be researching over these four meetings of the year or like, who do you self-identify what you're working towards or is that laid out in the ordinance? It's, I don't have the language of the specific ordinance right in front of me. I know that it is laid out in the ordinance so I can defer to if somebody has that so i can defer to if somebody has that like listing i know it's like voter protection language accessibility um accessibility of public infrastructure public education and outreach efforts strategies for connecting residents who are disengaged approaches to increasing civic engagement and participation coordination between city departments and election authorities, potential impacts of federal law enforcement activities, barriers to voting access, recommendations for city policies, practices, or programs to improve access to the polls, recommendations for changes to state law or election administration, and recommendations to facilitate dialogue among community organizations. Okay, no, I appreciate that. Thank you. And then you report to the mayor's office, or do you report to this committee? Do you know? And this isn't fair. Like, I don't know if, is there a city staff or chair perhaps? I don't know who. Sheila Betty is here on behalf of the mayor's office to answer these questions. The written, the written report and its findings will be submitted to the mayor and the council no later than June 1st of each year. Miss Betty, do you want to, do you have the same interpretation or uh yep excuse me yes alderwoman that that is the exact same interpretation and the mayor's office would provide uh staffing and administrative support for this council okay and just so i'm clear is so the same recommendations are shared with council and the administration for action that is correct and i can confirm that as well i have the final substitute pulled up that the committee considered and i see this um on page five of six subsection e about the report it does say no later than june 1st of every year uh findings and recommendations to the mayor and the city findings and recommendations to the mayor and the city council perfect thank you um just two more i just want to make sure i'm understanding um christian you had mentioned on in your remarks i just wanted to i'm curious section 203 the voting rights acts is that a language component yes it's language accessibility for minority languages okay thank you and then frank is your your component more deals with how you like mobility accessibility yeah just all accessibility for voters with disabilities okay so yeah mobility is part of it but as i mentioned um you know blind voters who are you screen readers and things like that no that makes sense we've done some work on our polling um you know locations throughout my word for accessibility laying all the things um just Just another question, and this is, I don't know the statue intimately, but Sophia, I think, who is on remotely, I think mentioned is a student at ISU. How do you, maybe Sophia, could you speak a little bit to how that works if you're away at school? Or if you're, maybe you're in the city and studying remote, I don't know. I live in Chicago. I am a senior at ISU, so I should be graduating soon and then going back home to Chicago. But I have so far done everything virtually, but my plan is to go back to Chicago starting December. Did you say December, Sophia? Yes, that's when I am supposed to graduate. Noted. Thank you. Do you have, sorry to ask, but Sophia, do you have residency in Chicago? Just being, are you registered to vote in Chicago? yes i am okay um okay i think that's the extent of my questions um and it just i think i've asked this but i just want to confirm so nobody that is going to be on this committee will committee will be circulating petitions or does any type of electioneering is that can everybody just answer it sorry like with words the Chicago Black Voter Project is wholly non-partisan and we do not make endorsements but as a member of the board will you guys be sir I guess what I'm trying to get out of I if this is truly a non-partisan board to get people engaged in voting I just want to make sure I get the audible from everybody they won't be circulating petitions yes okay we will not be searched i will not be circulating petition i will not be circulating petition i will also not be circulating petitions i will also not be circulating petitions i will not be circulating thank you i just um when we when we record our meetings a head nod doesn't it's not because i don't trust you as you're nodding at me it's just so that when you look back at the hearings or listen back pardon me um thank you that that is my questions and um I'll be happy to support your nominations. Thank you. Thank you. Recognizing Alderman Mosley as a non-committee member, thank you for joining. Alderman Quezada was also here. Appreciate him coming. Alderman Lee followed by Alderman Wagspack. Thank you, Chairman, and thank all of you for your willingness to step up into a voluntary role to help move democracy forward in our city. I just have a couple of questions. Mr. Valles, can you talk to us about the process? Because I heard you say earlier that you spearheaded the nomination process. Your organization did. Is that right? I would like to think that we democratically nominated each other, but I initiated the nudge to get us going. Okay. Can you, through the chair, just provide the list of the 60 plus organizations that participated? All 60? Can I just name as many as I can? Just through the chair. Oh, through the chair. yeah i was like yeah sorry that's when we go by through the chair i'll do the best i was like what kind of jerk would i be asking you for names no that's i'm just interested No, that's I'm just interested in what the process was like, because I know that these nominations came through the chief policy and the mayor's office. I just wanted to understand what the process was like for gathering everybody together to be part of the nomination process. Can you talk a little bit about how that went? Yes. So after we passed this ordinance in the spring in May, the groups we have we have been convening a large number of civic engagement, nonpartisan voter protection organizations to start to plan the coordination of all of our election activity. um things like uh election protection trainings candidate forums um parades to the polls so on and so forth uh and through that process this ordinance also came across our desk and so we gathered those groups together talked about the original ordinance uh all of the groups came on in support of the original ordinance we passed the original ordinance and then we went back to that same group of organizations and said, like, okay, as part of this ordinance, we're going to be able to appoint a slate of members to serve on the Democracy Council. This is what the role of the Democracy Council will look like. We invite everybody to nominate folks from the community that you think would be a good fit to serve in these roles that the ordinance lays out for the different members of the Democracy Council. And over the course of a few months, organizations nominated different folks. And everybody here was nominated through that process. So when you say the call for nominations that went out to those 60 plus organizations, or was there like a public, you know, blast out that went out to say, hey, city, we've got this Democracy Council that's coming. Nominate people that you think would be good, or was it limited to the organizations? Did you have to be nominated by an organization, I guess, is more the... No, it was both. I know from our end, we got it moving through these 60-plus organizations. We also put it out publicly, and I think also the city had its own process where they requested nominations as well. I think Ms. Betty wants to make a comment on that. Yes. Thank you. Thank you for the question. The other part of this process was an email that went out to city council requesting nominations. The only response that we got was from Chairman Laspata, who nominated Ms. Ruby. So that was another important part of the process. Great. Thank you. And do you know how many people were nominated? Total? I would have to look. You can give it to me later. I'm just curious. It wasn't very many more than what you see sitting before you. And part of the reason, I'll just add, we did that process was part of feedback we got when we were hearing this ordinance and committee and when it was heard on the floor around establishing these councils and an inability to actually find people to sit on them. And so we, Chicago Votes and Rainbow Push, Reverend Thurston, committed to making sure that we went through this process. and so that's great if you can provide that through the chair that would be great along with that list um how are you all working together before this well before the establishment of this council and like what do you see as the biggest benefits to the formation of this council and having a more formal platform anybody thank you alderwoman for your question um through the years it's there's been a lot of really incredible overlap and coalitions particularly in the election protection space a lot of our coalitions are a lot of our organizations historically have sort of operated inside organizations, historically have sort of operated in silos and really have kind of come together and are like, you know, let's coordinate better. There's many of us sit on multiple coalitions with each other, you know, around election protection, voter registration. We co-sponsor events like parades to the polls together. We volunteer for, you know, each other's get out the vote efforts to ensure that, you know there's maximum participation um you know of members of this coalition uh you know many of us will you know do candidate forums together or you know just um make sure that we're all in coordination we have the same set of sort of uh rules and obligations and information to ensure that voters you know have all the information to participate in our democracy great anybody else want to. It's my last question. I'll just say Access Living as an organization has not really historically been involved in these voting situations. This is something that the community that we serve, we receive feedback that they're looking for more information about accessible voting opportunities and things like that. And so this is something that as a disability service organization, you know, we're hoping to kind of expand and connect with these types of voting rights organizations that are already doing voting access work. The last thing I'll add is one of the things that I know we're really looking forward to is the formal structure that this council creates for us to, one, collaborate with each other and to like bring city officials into that collaboration more intentionally, including the Chicago Board of Elections. I think through this council, it actually adds an immense amount of capacity to all of our organizations, as well as to the Chicago Board of Elections and the city of Chicago, because we'll finally all be in one spot on the same page. One of the reasons we started our outside coalition. One of the reasons we started our outside coalition personally is because I was getting calls from Jane about candidate forums and I was getting calls from Brianna about doing this talk here and Ellie and I was just like, you know, if we were all together in the same spot talking, this would make things more streamlined and bringing the city into that process enhances the structure that we've been already creating tremendously. Well, thank you again for all of your volunteerism throughout your careers and everything that you've done in this space and appreciate your willingness to serve. Happy to support all of your nominations today. Thank you. Thank you. Alderman Wagesbeck. Thanks, Chairman. So a couple of the things in the list of to-dos or the type of activity that you'll be doing, public education and outreach efforts, that almost always entails some type of budget. So what would the budget be for that, and how much are you expecting for the 2027 budget? I know, personally speaking, we already do a lot of civic education independently as organizations that come out of our own fundraising capacity and our capacity as entities. I'll let Sheila speak to the actual fiscal note, but from my vantage point, we're more so trying to coordinate our civic education efforts to make sure we can identify gaps and leverage each other's resources to coordinate and be on one accord. but okay thank you alderman i'll just add that there's there is uh no budget line item for this commit for this advisory council again we will be staffing it out of the mayor's office budget but there's no particular line item for any kind of programic activity okay thank you um and then if you each of you could answer um do you each consider yourselves i mean um do you each consider yourselves i mean you are uh you have agency as appointees now once you are uh appointed to this position so do each of you consider yourselves accountable to the city ethics code if you could answer on the record please this is frank uh yes i do uh this is brianna yes i do stevie vaez yes i do ellison redec yes i do christian taylor yes Jane Ruby, yes. Deshaun Branch, yes. Sophia Franco, yes. Okay. That's all I had, Chairman. I appreciate you having them come before us and answer these questions. I know some of them are a little tougher than normal, but I think based on what we've been seeing, we just need to make sure that we're vetting all of these issues. And as you move forward, add to what the Board of Elections does. and assist them. And I think the committeemen and every, well, committeemen is going to be kind of tough because it is partisan, but they are the ones who essentially handle a lot of the work day to day prior to the election. So I look forward to seeing the work that you guys have committed to and what the outcome is. Thank you very much. Thank you. Any other questions from members? Seeing none, can I get a motion to recommend the appointments of Dushan Branch, Jane Ruby, Christian Taylor, Alison Raddick, Brianna Champion, Frank Lally, Sophia Franco, and Stevie Valles. Alderman Vasquez, so moves, and this is to be clear, to the Reverend Jesse L. Jackson Senior Advisory Council on Access to Democracy. All those in favor signify by saying aye. All those opposed, in the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. There being no further business before the committee, can I get a motion to adjourn? Alderman Taliaferro, so moves, all those in favor, signify by saying aye. All those opposed, in the opinion of the chair, chair of the ICE Habit. The meeting is adjourned. Thank you all. Thank you. Thank you.