which in the judgment of the meeting's chair, or the sergeant-at-arms, may lead to a breach of the peace, or disrupt the orderly. conduct for public meetings 2023 to 2027 pursuant to rule 58 of the chicago city council rules of order and procedure the sergeant at arms sets forth the following rules of conduct for members of the public these rules shall be in effect at all times that a viewing gallery or room is open for a meeting of the city council or any of its committees all individuals and their belongings are subject to search at entry or upon request. Individuals must remain seated at all times except 1. when entering or exiting the gallery, 2. when providing public comment during the portion of a meeting set aside for that purpose, or 3. when asked to rise and be acknowledged by a member of the city council. Profane, threatening, harassing, abusive, or defamatory behavior or speech which in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the sergeant at arms may lead to a breach of the peace or disrupt the orderly conduct of the meeting is not permitted. Disruptive or distracting actions such as the stomping of feet. Good afternoon everybody. Good afternoon everybody. we're getting started we're getting started thank you um i see my colleagues are going to make me just like keep no you're fine you're fine now you're closer to where our witnesses will be speaking i'm just teasing you guys committee on environmental protection and energy will now come to order we have four items on today's agenda an ordinance prohibiting city departments from procuring single-use styrofoam containers an ordinance expanding the utility billing relief an ordinance expanding the utility billing relief program to tenants a resolution calling on city departments to prioritize heat mitigation and a resolution calling on the illinois general general assembly to pass the power act first we'll begin with a roll call to establish quorum chair hadden is present vice chair knudson alder lasbada alder ramirez alder lopez alder tabaris alder sigcho lopez alder cruz alder rodriguez sanchez alder conway alder riley alder lawson alder clay alder martin alderman hoppenworth all right there being eight we have a quorum all right um and we've got alderman riley and knudson who have requested per rule 59 to join us virtually could i have a motion to approve their virtual participation all right so moved by alderman hoppenworth all those in favor say aye all right alder riley are you present riley's present all right and i don't see alder knutson yet so we will mark alder riley present for purposes of quorum um do we have any non-members all right um so thank you all for attending the meeting we have a lot um all right so agendas are on the website for the environmental protection committee we don't do a lot of printing so we've got a lot of public speakers today and everyone's going to wait their turn and to make sure that everyone gets to be heard mr mr blakemore uh mr blakemore and other members of the audience members of the public. Excuse me. Hey. excuse me hey members of the public everybody in the gallery mr mr blake mr blake mr blakemore mr blakemore just be patient with us mr blakemore we'll get there okay all right i know it's been a long day you've been to a lot of committee men a lot of committees but if folks can't refrain from um i'm sorry what okay mr blakemore our committee member one of my staff is going to bring you an agenda okay everyone um knows the agenda and it's been noticed virtually so i think other people do but if anybody else would like a paper copy just raise your hand and we'll we'll get you one if you want a paper copy all right so just be patient with us so we can get started for public comment because we have a lot of folks today can we be in agreement about that can i get it can i get an agreement about that mr blakemore no hey mr blakemore mr blakemore and i will ask for guests in the gallery to refrain from talking to one another unless you are with somebody we don't need any additional conflict and you guys don't have to police one another either right so everyone's got a right to be here and a right to speak um and so let let council services do their job let me do my job we don't need facilitators from the audience and if if there's someone that's irritating to you we've got a lot of other seats and people can shuffle around as well so let's keep it moving um so i'm going to start with our first public commenter in order to make room for everyone we're going to limit public comment to two minutes um today so that everyone can actually speak so that we don't have to knock anybody off okay we're going to start with uh jessica jackson a bit off topic yet relevant um my mother used to say the only way to not get old is to die young and i'm realizing for sure that's true But to live in a time where people want to hide their ages and not be proud of their age, you know, as a 64-year-old person, one thing that keeps me going is because I do, in fact, know the history of who I am and the history of my community and the history of our people here. I thank God that I've lived long enough to be able to see it and to see the trends change and to see us go from one space to another economically and to see where we are now versus where we were, let's say, when I was in my 20s and 30s. And for that reason, I thank my parents for teaching me to look at the word of God and to look at the life of Jesus, who in fact is the Christ. And when you look at how people came against him for telling the truth and for standing for the people and standing for love and how people attacked him, the government, the Roman soldiers attacked him, the Pharisees, the Sadducees, the people, and then ultimately even the disciples themselves betrayed him. But he kept his eyes fixed to Calvary because he believed his father. That's what keeps you going. And the blessing is to live long enough to understand that. Thank you. Thank you, Ms. Jackson. Next speaker is George Blakemore. Mr. George Blakemore. Thank you. The reason is fundamental. I was appalled to hear your response when I asked for an agenda. I'm an old man, and I have not embraced a certain technology. And for you to say that it's online or something is unacceptable. you had a whole month to print out the agenda reading this fundamental so there's no excuse never let this happen again and take it as a constructive criticism you and these other people were just looking at me like I'm a crazy man you're supposed to still have the paper copy and they had a whole month to have these agendas and I was insulted by your response, telling me it's on the website or something. Don't let that happen again. So it's very important important for a man of Mr. Blakemore caliber to come to these meetings. So dealing with technology and energy and pollution, most of the toxic waste is always in the black communities, in the poor people community. So that's life. The rich get rich at the expense of the poor because the poor haven't learned how to navigate the system. The system is broken, and racism is a big problem. When I was a young man down in Texas, I didn't know that all the waste from the hospital was coming to the branch where I live. I played in that water. So I waited in that water because that's what they do. They put all the toxic energy. Thank you, Mr. Blakemore, and I'll make sure I accept the constructive criticism. I'll make sure we have printed agendas in the future. All right. Michael Young Bay. I requested to be last, but evidently she ain't tell you. But I ain't got to be last. I was first to last me. Like I said, I'm going to make it known. You know, I come down here, and I, you know, one of my first speeches down here was about the environment, the community, how nasty it is in the community, how all these vacant lots, vacant land, all this trash, about how people that like violence and drug dealings and drug using like to be in dark, nasty places, you know? Reflection is the business of man. So the people are saying the environment they live in, and that's why they get the conditions they get, you know. conditions they get you know a lot of people try to revert to things etc try to throw their little jabs etc at a person on the mic etc you know and i'm straightforward i'm straight shooter you know uh and i always been that way so you know don't try to have no comments to say towards me or or whatever because i'm just gonna let it be known what it is you know I ain't gonna hold no punches back you know yeah Jesus did all them things sure did but you're not Jesus neither am I you know let the record reflect we man we got faults and we got errors and we got higher self and we got lower self we know good and we know evil you know but you know don't do it cause I'm gonna get up here and I'm a clown y'all ain't doing it for nobody I'm not getting paid by nobody or nothing you can check my account my stuff can be public record I'm talking about bank account business account y'all know I've been on the floor all the Manhattan the chair that she know I've been sleeping in my car with my wife and child you know I'm saying I'm not down here playing I'm not trying down here trying to get likes and views etc I ain't trying to mislead the people we need to clean up thank you mr. young Bay our next speaker is Zoe Lee I saw a press conference outside talking about, I guess, with the water and the bills. Let me tell you something. They are trying to take our properties. They're going to try to take our properties in any type of way because... any type of way because we have allowed it to happen for so long and when you come down here to try to get any help from any of these people they cannot help you so they tell you to get a group together and you know sit here and talk about what you what we need changed and they're never going to change it you know why because they're stealing all of the money we should never have no issues, especially seniors, when it comes to anything. Water bills, housing. Everybody always talking about housing is a human right. Is it? Is it? Is it in Chicago? Is it? Because I know as a homeowner or a property owner in the city of Chicago, you can't get no help at all. And And y'all know this because it's a trillion dollar business. TIF money. If any of y'all bills are astronomical high, like this, I mean, doesn't make any sense. You're probably in a TIF district. And a TIF district is all the property tax money that your people have been paying for a very long time. And they need to take that money, that TIF money, and use it for whatever else they their agenda they have affordable housing whatever so in order for any of this to change y'all gonna have to start asking for a forensic audit and once you start asking for a forensic audit then we all can be on the same page of getting these people up out of office all right thank you our next speaker is peter lara yeah you know chair i think it's pretty disgraceful that none of these were printed out and at every meeting they should be printed meeting they should be printed out because it why should people have to look on their phones it should be printed but we're going to move on from that anyhow so i don't understand why this committee wants to push so much for solar for wind and all this other stuff why not push for nuclear why not push for coal why would you not push for all of these other ones because energy is now scarce. I'm going to tell you why it's becoming scarce. Governor Pritzker loves data centers because he owns part of it, especially the ones that are in DeKalb right now. And you know what? It's absurd because you know what? The people that live around it, they have higher utilities. They lack the resources now. Like look at the documentaries across America right now. Those people that live right by it, they have to deal with noise pollution, polluted water whatever water little water they have now because everything is getting sucked into the data center it could be used appropriately but it's not it's only for personal interest of the politicians it's absurd and then also you guys are pushing for chicago residents to have their water metered so what you guys can charge us extra on top of that no and plus when you change out the pipelines that lead to the houses, they end up getting broken because whoever puts them in doesn't know how to do it correctly. And then you know what? Then the city forces the citizens to pay it. You don't even offer to pay it. Chicago residents, do you want these people running it this way? It's a serious question. If you don't do something now, who knows where we're heading? Thank you. Thank you. Our next speaker is Thomas Haley. Good afternoon. My name is Thomas Haley, and I'm here on behalf of the Indiana, Illinois, Iowa Foundation for Fair Contracting. We work day in and day out with responsible contractors and the skilled construction workforce that builds major infrastructure throughout Illinois. We support responsible data center development, and we recognize that energy, water, and environmental impacts have to be addressed. But we do not believe the POWER Act strikes that right balance. the power act now singles out one class of large load customer data centers and imposes a separate framework focused on bringing new renewable energies new renewable generation onto the system that serve it and despite imposing significant new obligations on these projects HB 5513 does not require prevailing wage project labor agreements registered apprentice utilization or any similar construction labor standards that's especially concerning because data centers are major construction projects. They create substantial work for operating engineers and other skilled trades supporting apprentice opportunities and bring significant private investment into Illinois communities. Illinois can address legitimate infrastructure and environmental concerns without creating unnecessary barriers to responsible development or reopening broader energy policy compromises on an industry-by-industry basis. For those reasons, the foundation opposes the POWER Act as currently written and respectfully ask this committee to reject resolution r 20 26 0028728 in its entirety thank you thank you saeeda um uh cabell saeeda you gave me a great phonetic pronunciation of your first name and then i like stumbled on the last name you know You know, you're not going to look. Okay. Um, good morning. My name is Saida Cabell and I'm the organizing director at Southsiders Organized for Unity and Liberation, also known as SOUL. I'm standing here because many of the mostly direct or mostly impacted residents had to go to work to pay their bills while we gather here in the middle of a work day on a Thursday, um, to wait for our representatives to get it together. You know, this struggle has been going on for eight years through two mayoral administrations. And, um, it's just to get our community's affordable water bills which is insane the city says it doesn't have money for this but they do and water for all will actually generate revenue for the city people would get bills they can actually afford and there would be a pathway to eliminating water debt and everyone wins the city's wasting more of the money not passing the ordinance the water debt is over 800 million dollars and it continues to grow while the city asks us to wait the administration at the City Departments of Environment, Finance, and Water Management came out at the 11th hour yesterday morning at 10.30 a.m., like 11th hour, saying they need more time and for there to be some compromises. They've asked us to wait some more, but how long must we wait? This is a stall tactic, and we do not believe it's in good faith. What legislation have y'all passed this year? People are losing their houses because of unpaid water bills while we wait. Elders on fixed incomes are being turned away from the utility billing relief because they're somehow ineligible while we wait. And people are getting their wages garnished from water bills while we wait. Folks are struggling and suffering, and this administration has yet again asked us to wait. We can't and we won't. We're demanding affordable and clean water for all right now. and clean water for all right now we demand that the water for all ordinance be voted on and passed because we're done waiting it's too much thank you thank you our next speaker is vernon cotton vernon cotton all right our next speaker is nicolette face on hi good afternoon i'm nicolette face on i'm the illinois outreach director of faith in place and across the state of illinois we represent over 200 houses of worship and specifically in the chicagoland area over 60. from our conversations with other residents folks who worship here who care about the city of chicago we feel strongly about both issues that are hopefully to be talked about today first is water for all very much like the person before me this is a necessary ordinance that we're hoping to see passed i'm very disappointed to hear that this has been pulled very last minute it's very disrespectful to the efforts that have been going on from organizers in the city for the past eight years and quite frankly it shouldn't be too hard to decide that residents should be able to keep their homes regardless of what their water bills are that regardless of debt that water is a human right it would be nice for our city to actually back the people that pay taxes into it that care for that help build it up to make it the city that it is the other ordinance that i would to speak towards is the banning of polystyrene or styrofoam in the city that's necessary i think that a lot of people tend to forget that this is something that is a problem in a lot of different ways not just with our food quality and making sure that we're not receiving poisons by having by having them in but when you're looking about green spaces across the city oftentimes if you're finding litter there it's going to be these hard plastics they're ugly their eyesores they're not beneficial to the environment and all we do is just create ugly green spaces as someone who lives off of 290 I see what comes off of the highway and and excuse me styrofoam is one of those things if we care about the future of Chicago if we care about the quality of health for our residents, basically moving forward on this would be essential. So thank you. Thank you very much. Raheem Okta. Good afternoon, everyone. My name is Raheem Okta. Thank you to the chair and to members of the council for being here today. I professionally work at the freshwater lab at UIC. I'm a policy researcher and consultant policy advisor i'm speaking on behalf of the third ward in the near south side as a resident we find ourselves in a cost of living crisis that continues to devastate our city i think it's at this time it is our government's responsibility to ensure that people are not removed from their homes for things as basic and fundamental as water i would urge this council to continue pushing forward policies that allow people to stay in their homes and in their communities uh if this is an issue of revenue i would encourage this uh this city to begin to look at a tiered water policy system in which um our industrial and high water users pay a rate that is higher than our residential users for families and residents who have water leaking problems i would encourage us to agitate at the federal level to ensure that we have the resources to replace Chicago's lead pipes and to update Chicago's lead pipes, and to update our water infrastructure to better deliver those resources to our neighbors. I believe that we need to move beyond the Power Act and lobby for pricing structures that force data centers to invest in the infrastructure that they are straining every single day. They should not be allowed to plop onto our grids, and subsequently residents of the city pay a higher cost. I would urge us to pass an ordinance that drives transparency around data center development and requires community input. I mentioned this as a resident of the third ward where we had a development start off as a gaming arena and then switch to a data center. Our residents are quite upset to find that they live near what's considered critical infrastructure, right? These are potential military target zones. They're high militarized areas. These cannot be in our communities thank you all very much thank you our next speaker uh oliver chikiora thank you chair and it's uh sakura um good afternoon my name is oliver sakura i'm the environmental justice coordinator and organizer with south siders organized for unity and liberation soul began this work i'm here to talk about the water for all ordinance um soul began doing this work in 2018 through a series of listening sessions we were hearing residents saying that their bills were going from a couple hundred dollars every couple of months to spikes of over ten thousand dollars with no explanation from the city this led to the creation of the water for all coalition and then the water for all ordinance which is currently on the agenda for today. I also have in my hand over 500 signatures of residents. hand over 500 signatures of residents that really want this to pass and need immediate relief data pulled from 2025 on utility billing relief shows that 41.3 million dollars has been forgiven and that residents have saved over 44 million dollars since inception in 2021 and we know that this will still continue underwater for all as we'll have more folks eligible that'll provide meaningful relief what i will say is how this impacts all of your awards specifically alderman haddon your ward has over a million dollars in water debt alderman knutson your water has over eight hundred thousand dollars in water debt alderman lesbada your ward has over two million dollars in water debt alderman ramirez you have over four million dollars in water debt alderman lopez your ward has over eight million dollars in water debt alderman taberas your ward has over four million dollars in water debt alderman ciccio lopez you have over four million dollars in water debt alderman cruz you have over four million dollars in water debt alderman rodriguez sanchez your ward has over two million dollars in debt alderman conway your ward has over nine hundred and seventy thousand dollars in water debt alderman riley your ward has eight has two million dollars in water debt alderman lawson you have eight hundred thousand clay three million martin one million manahop worth $900,000 in water debt. Thank you for your time. Thank you. Next speaker is Shakina Sims. Good afternoon, everyone. My name is Shakina Sims with NRDC. Thank you, Chairwoman Haddon and the committee members. I'm here today to express support for water for all. 60% of water debt in the city is held by residents in majority black zip codes on the south and west sides of the city. That's our seniors on fixed incomes. That's our neighbors who've hit tough times as our uncles and aunts who've had to cut their hours for medical reasons. who've had to cut their hours for medical reasons it's probably several people in this room today and for some it's another reminder that poverty always finds a way to knock at your door and remind you that you are poor and trapped water for all is an opportunity to support people who despite their best efforts can't get across the finish line without a little help when a resident has a bill that's more manageable and better aligns with their income they are more likely to pay stay engaged and remain current when residents get behind on water bills the city staff invest a great deal of time and money on collections liens and other legal processes sometimes writing off bad debt when bills remain unpaid for a prolonged period of time residents in this city are spending a disproportionate amount of their income on water bills we have the opportunity to stop treating these as data points these data points as just words on a sheet of paper and actually support an ordinance that can make a profound impact on people's lives implementing an affordability program like water for all not only helps residents but helps the city bring in a steadier revenue stream that can strengthen its finances and stabilize future water rates let's remember why and let's remember our why and meet our residents where they are thank you so much thank you alderman riley if you could mute your phone sorry yeah thank thanks for the thanks for the support there um i want to recognize alder uh uh cruz and alder martin for purposes of quorum and alder sigcho lopez for purposes of quorum all right our next speaker is ayana simba good morning committee uh thank you i am here on behalf of the illinois environmental council as their city government affairs director i see we are so excited to see several items on the agenda today first we are thankful for the consideration of substitute ordinance 2026 00 of Substitute Ordinance 2026-002547. We got to go back to the old number system. This is crazy. Championed by Alderman Matt Martin, this ordinance will begin shifting the city purchasing away from toxic polystyrene foam foodware and towards safe, more environmentally conscious alternatives. IEC, along with the Chicago Coalition for Plastic Reduction, had met with several city departments to give feedback on the current purchasing practices and potential impacts. across those conversations no department identified harmful or costly operational issues associated with this proposal by moving forward with this the city procurement moves away from polystyrene foam and establishes reduction goals chicago can also begin reducing unnecessary single-use plastics at the source i urge the committee to support this measure additionally iec will continue to support policies like water for all which is championed by alderman lesbada if passed it would provide an accessible pathway to eliminate water debt and it would ban liens and foreclosures tied to unpaid water bills in short it would ensure that no one is denied water because of their income we know that people when they are given the opportunity to pay their bills in a feasible way that they will so we will continue to work with the city to find a long-term solution for water affordability finally iec we would love to express our support for the resolution that speaks in support of the power act in the illinois general assembly the power act would put nation-leading guardrails on data centers to mitigate their impacts on our water, our air, our climate, and our utility bills. While we understand that data centers are critical infrastructure, we need to take a step back and adopt regulations at both the state and city level that protects our communities, our pocketbooks, and our climate. I urge the committee to support this measure as well. Thank you. Thank you. Our next speaker is Ann Ridge. Get myself together. get myself together. I have to read this. So thank you so much. It's so good to be here today. My name is Anne Ridge, and I'm here with Organizing for Plastics Alternatives. We're a Chicago civic-based group who support this ordinance to ban styrofoam food wear of the city of Chicago, to the city government specifically. So in 2023, the Illinois State Legislature passed Senate Bill 58, banning the purchase of styrofoam by the state for state departments and agencies. The bill has proven successful in that state entities now have many alternatives to buying styrofoam and using styrofoam. So we did a study of that, and we found this has been successful in the state. OPA, my group, is currently partnering with the Illinois Green Business Association and Energy Sense Resilience Center from the University of Illinois, who together have created the Illinois Green Business Program, which works directly with restaurants and food services to help them change from unhealthy plastic containers to compostable, environmentally safe packaging. They have worked with restaurants in Chicago's South Side and are now reaching out to chambers and restaurants in the 47th Ward to help restaurants assess the foods that they sell and determine the packaging that they can use that would be sustainable. They are now doing this under a grant from the EPA and they do it for free. They literally go into businesses and help them. They're giving them new alternatives, and they often save restaurants money. This is a win-win for everyone. The Illinois Green Business Program not only provides this valuable resources to restaurants and businesses, but when this ordinance is passed by the city, they can help the city make these changes. So they are willing to work with different agencies and departments within the city to help them provide the alternatives that they need. And because it's an Illinois-based business, the U of I, the Illinois Green Business Association, Business Association. I think this is a wonderful opportunity for the city of Chicago. Thank you so much for your comments. Our next speaker is Marjorie Isaacson. Good afternoon. I am Marjorie Isaacson, and I'm a board member of the Chicago Recycling Coalition. For the past 43 years, we have been working on recycling, which preserves natural resources and reduces waste going to landfills. That uses less energy and reduces the production of greenhouse gases. But the accelerating proliferation of plastics, particularly single-use plastic, is now harming our climate, human health, and polluting our environment. We cannot recycle our way out of this problem. We need to reduce the amount of plastic we use. Therefore, we appreciate that Alderman Martin has proposed this ordinance to prohibit city departments from single-use plastic procurement. This ordinance is a small first step as written, but it is an important commitment, and we hope just the first step toward larger efforts. CRC is a member of the Chicago Coalition for Plastic Reduction. And I was part of the group that Ayanna mentioned when we went to talk to departments to do our due diligence prior to this ordinance. And many of them said this would be no problem and, in fact, mentioned other efforts that they were already doing towards sustainability and were looking forward to code change that would support their efforts. So I think that it's... So I think that it's time for this ordinance. I urge you to send it to council and get a positive vote on it. Thank you. Thank you. Our next speaker is Tessa Murray. And then our final speaker will be John Schmidt. Good afternoon. My name is Tessa Murray. I'm with Friends of Chicago River. I'm here to express our strong support for the ordinance prohibiting city departments from procuring polystyrene foam containers. Friends is a member of the aforementioned Chicago Coalition for Plastic Reduction, and we've been working for over a year and a half to move forward this ordinance thanks to the leadership of Alderman Martin. This ordinance is an important first step towards a larger effort needed to reduce single-use plastics in Chicago. We're excited for the city to begin moving away from polystyrene foam product use and the reduction of unnecessary disposable foodware. Every day, we see the impacts of plastic pollution directly in the river. An estimated 85% of trash found in and around the river is plastic, and roughly one-third of that is polystyrene foam. Much of this waste consists of food containers and other unnecessary single-use packaging. Once plastic enters the environment, it can persist for extremely long periods and break down into microplastics. And this is evident here. Research by scientists at Loyola University of Chicago have found that nine in 10 fish in our river system have microplastics in our bodies, and it's not just the fish we need to be worried about. Medical researchers found alarming amounts of microplastics in human brains and raised concerns about its impact on our health. Reducing plastics at the source also helps address very practical impacts of litter. Trash can clog drains and sewers, contribute to localized flooding, and require significant cleanup resources, ultimately making their way into our waterways. So we encourage the city to view this ordinance as a starting point and continue strengthening its approach to reducing single-use and continue strengthening its approach to reducing single-use plastics. And we look forward to working with this committee to keep the momentum going. Thank you. Thank you. And for our final speaker, John Schmidt. Alder Hadnan, committee members, first, I apologize for my voice. Okay. Eighteen months ago, this committee came together with the Health and Human Relations Committee for a subject matter hearing on the global problem of single-use plastics. If you recall, we named the devastating impacts of single-use plastics on the environment. Single-use plastics takes generations to biodegrade, and when they do, they disintegrate into ever more toxic materials that are almost impossible to recover. There are forms of plastic all along our food chain that are with us now. We know that plastics enter our bodies in vitro to corpse. The health consequences are immense and contribute to infertility, diabetes, heart disease, cancer, and dementia, among other illnesses. Single-use plastics is an environmental problem, it's a global warming problem, it's a human health problem, and it's a waste management problem that's unfairly left to municipalities to solve while industry gets off scot-free. But the plastics industry is planning to ramp up single-use plastics production by two or three-fold within the next two decades. It argues that we can just recycle our way out of this mess. We know that we can't because less than 5% of plastics gets recycled. If industry won't change their practices and the people represented by their government at local and state levels need to join together to intervene, It's up to the government to begin the process of turning off the spigot. You have the opportunity to do that today in Chicago City government. It's a modest step, given the volume of plastic waste and certainly our planet, but it's an important step, a significant step, and a signal to the city. um and significant step and a signal to the city state and country that we care enough about human wellness and environmental health to take a decisive step to begin the march to finally eliminate single-use plastics it'll belong in a society that cares for planet and health thank you so much thank you all right thank you to all of our commenters um there being no more speakers uh we'll conclude um alder knutson are you with us yeah chair i'm here thank you fantastic all right we're going to mark you down for uh for quorum all right i'd like to note that the committee received 24 written public comments um those have been sent out to committee members via email our first order of business is the rule 45 report from september 2026 which was sent to the committee over email could i have a motion to approve the rule 45 report alder martin so moves all those in favor say aye any opposed say nay the opinion of the chair the eyes have it so we're going to go a little bit out of the order on the agenda today we're going to start with our third item our third item is r2026-0028725 calling on the city of chicago departments to prioritize heat mitigation maintain and expand cooling centers and install heat resilient infrastructure members of the committee were sent a copy of the resolution ahead of today's meeting Karina Hans, directly to my right, is a high school junior at the University of Chicago Lab School who worked on the creation of this resolution during her summer internship with our Committee on Environmental Protection and Energy, and she's here to talk about this item. With that, Karina, I'll turn it over to you. Thank you, Chair Haddon. As the Alderwoman said, my name is Karina Hans, and I am a junior at the University of Chicago Laboratory Schools. I chose to write this resolution as a result of the increase in the teen mental health crisis. This topic, unlike physical health, is quite stigmatized with people finding it hard to talk about their mental health struggles despite it being quite common. about their mental health struggles, despite it being quite common. Therefore, I chose to do this resolution to raise awareness about possible contributing factors to mental health issues in order to be proactive and to combat it. Chicago has been experiencing an increase in temperature with a 2.6 to 2.8 degree Fahrenheit increase since 1980. This summer, we experienced numerous heat waves and are expected to have more extreme heat events with the rising global temperature. Extreme heat events have been found to be associated with a mental health-related hospital visits, and an increase in mental health-related mortality. Extreme heat is believed to impact mental health through altering brain chemicals that regulate stress, sleep deprivation, and extreme physical stress on the body. I wanted to bring this to the attention before the committee to recognize we need to adapt to the changing climate in order to protect our citizens' health and safety. This is why I'm here in front of you today to ask this Council to support this resolution and call on the city to be better prepared for mental health services as climate change is causing increasing mental health issues. Thank you, Karina. I want to open it up to the committee. Any comments or questions from committee members on this item? Aldo Despada. Number one, Karina, thank you so much for your work on the resolution. Eyewitnesses in my family. I have two daughters, and on days when it's too hot to play outside, I directly see that impact on who and how my daughter is at the house. I want to put forward part of a solution that we can move on with your resolution. So I don't know if you're familiar with the company J.C. Decoe. It's a French company that manages the so-called street furniture of the city. Bus shelters, soon-to-be automated public bathrooms, but they recently reached out to bathrooms. But they recently reached out to our office with a whole host of new green, sustainable landscaping and streetscaping products that they want to be able to offer to the city to essentially green both our existing street furniture and other products. I say this in particular, I will find a way to drop off a copy of this to Ottawa Manhattan for you to peruse, but also to mention for you and my colleagues, part of their new five-year contract with the city includes $150,000 annually of new or improved street furniture and streetscaping. So far for 2026, the city hasn't used none of that $150,000. So I say this because there's opportunities for us to not just pass your resolution, which we're going to today and the next week in city council but then actively and at no cost to the city move on the values that you're describing here today so thank you so much for bringing forward it's really really timely thank you and thank you chair thank you all rosvada any other comments or questions from committee members um then i'll i'll add my two cents um so karina we really appreciate the the research and the work and also the frame of I know we've worked with different groups the deferring disasters extreme kind of heat and cold coalition many of the the speakers who are part of organizations and community groups here today I think care a lot about the issue of increasing heat and extreme cold and how we respond to it. And I really appreciate the additional piece around mental health and how it's impacting us that you bring forth. I know certainly we've worked at this on the angle of goal of how are we creating more cooling centers right which you've got here how are we creating more um protections right uh we've got legislation that i've been working on for heat protections for outdoor workers um we've had um other legislation that we've passed requiring large buildings and senior buildings to have cooling and air conditioning requirements um and we're still not quite doing enough so um want to appreciate you in this resolution and uh ask my colleagues for their favorable support and recommending approval of this item all right so moved by alder lopez um all in favor say aye all right any opposed in the opinion of the chair the ayes have it and the chair uh i'll report this vote as a recommendation to pass at the next city council meeting on october uh 21st 2026 oh october 14th oh that's so funny or the 21st but the october 14th 2026. all right thank you karina all right still going out of order we'll now hear the fourth item on the agenda this is resolution 2026 dash zero zero two eight seven two eight calling on the illinois general assembly to pass the power act or house bill five five one three committee members received a copy of the resolution ahead of today's meeting, and Ambika Barrows is a senior at Evanston Township High School and is joining us today. To my next right, she helped draft this resolution during her summer internship with our Committee on Environmental Protection and Energy, and with that, I'll turn it over to you, Ambika. Thank you. My name is Ambika Barrows, and I'm a senior at Evanston Township High School. I have a strong stance against generative AI, and I try to advocated against it at school with my teachers and peers. After I told my friends and family about my opinions, my stepmother suggested that I apply for an internship with the Committee on Environmental Protection Energy. I feel and energy. I feel very passionate about the environment, and I want to make a difference with environmental regulations and safety for wildlife and our community. The POWER Act, if passed, would establish critical protections to limit pollution and protect vulnerable communities by requiring that data centers provide their own renewable energy, establish sustainable water use, and require transparent reporting of their impact. It's currently referred to assignments in the Illinois State Senate. In other states, Delaware recently passed similar legislation that prevents data centers from passing the costs of their facilities to rate payers and that the centers generate their own clean energy. In New Jersey, they implemented a new law that prevents data center energy costs from being passed down to other utility customers and requires data centers to pay for the electrical and clean energy infrastructure upgrades they create. If the POWER Act is passed, it can serve as a model framework for other states to follow because it protects protects citizens from the environmental risks data centers pose i'm happy to answer any questions you all have for me thank you very much ambika okay i'll open it up to committee members for questions or comments alder lopez thank you chairman and good afternoon members of the committee and good afternoon to you both thank you for your work um I actually have a substantive question with regards to this resolution, and I appreciate that your office has always allowed your interns to participate in this manner. Actually, my only edit would be that they get to put their names in there, too, for their future CVs. But the POWER Act that this is in reference to is what failed, correct, in the General Assembly? it did so there's also senate bill uh i think it's 40 16 um but i believe it's still active believe is still active which is another alternative um this was introduced and drafted kind of before it finished but the spirit of it i believe is the same so perhaps there's a uh an amendment or we can make um to the resolution um redirecting it to legislation that's still active okay um okay yeah but i believe senate bill 4016 um so i would entertain a motion uh for uh striking uh hb 5513 from this resolution and substituting with sb 4016 All right, Alder Laspata. So moves, all in favor? Okay. In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it, and I appreciate that substantive question. Alder Lopez, back to you. Now, the General Assembly versions, House bill or Senate bill, but in this case now the Senate bill, that was passed by the Senate, or is that just introduced and awaiting action? i believe that is introduced in awaiting action and as i'm not familiar with that um senate bill um was that created in consultation with industry or was this advocate-led only i'm not sure i could get to that through the chair but i i will say if um i know we had commenters um um from uh foundation representing a lot of the construction industry workers earlier and understand we also had written comment submitted to the committee with some of the broad concerns around some of the lack of uh project labor uh kind of peace labor agreements that were in some of the legislation that was there i think that even I think that even considering some of the concerns that I hope most of us would agree we would like to see Springfield address, that the general spirit of what we are all hoping to accomplish in regulations of what the Power Act wanted to do, and I do think we heard that from our public commenter as well, is that we want to see smart regulation around noise, around energy, around air, around water use that keeps the consumer centered, as well as our environmental concerns, while still creating a path forward for the vital infrastructure that we need. And of course, the good uh partnerships with labor to make sure that we've got um labor unions involved and at the table so i will just echo that concern um because i think we cannot create policy in a vacuum something that we have oftentimes discussed here in this committee um keeping in the spirit of what was created i'm not going to try to derail this because i understand it's good to have young, visionary minds putting things together. And I don't want you moving to the 15th Ward to run against me because I defeated your resolution. Just kidding. But I think that, you know, as just as a part of the legislative process for both of you, it's always good to incorporate both sides to an issue, the pro and the con, so that you could have a more balanced conversation. And And hopefully the next pieces of legislation that the two of you author, you will keep that in mind moving forward. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Elder Lopez. Quick pause. okay um to alder lopez's point i'll also add actually we have had i think some great conversations as my team um has worked with our interns so both of these uh young policy makers and on the issue of data centers you know just i'll take a moment um you know we've run into some frustration early on as every piece of data center regulation legislation that was proposed in city council at our last city council was all sent to rules which is a you know a small barrier a setback and at the same time my note to to our kind of witnesses here today was that is frustrating as it is oftentimes to in our legislative space have arguments and disagreements that though it may not always seem that way to our public and our constituents that on 80 percent of things I would argue we all kind of are looking for a similar outcome right and I think that especially on this issue where we have a lot of I think public awareness and public urging us to act that we have real opportunities to make sure we have all of our stakeholders that together and that most of our disagreement is going to be on the how we get there and I want to speak I'll say that extends to the water for all legislation right there's a lot of disagreement about how we get there's a lot of disagreement about how we get there maybe with the administration and departments and also I think that there's a lot of agreement though on the outcome that we're hoping to get and that is certainly an important legislative lesson that I hope I hope they take with him I hope you guys take with you as you go now one quick thing I did not make I did not do my motion appropriately for our amendment so um law has given me a little reflect uh reflection here so i'm gonna say this again um but in order to do so all right you have a copy of the resolution all right fantastic all right so we're gonna make an amendment using rule 30 and so um let's see um right now this reads whereas um hb 5513 the power act before the general illinois general assembly would establish policies that ensure uh data centers pay their fair share to protect consumers and our climate and in the be it resolve section we also it reads be it resolved that we members of the city council of the city of chicago do hereby call upon the illinois general assembly to pass the power act hb 5513 to safeguard environmental protections and responsible development of data centers in illinois and consideration of climate goals and citizens well-being for both those sections i move that we strike hb 5513 and amend with sp4016 so it would then read in first section whereas sb4016 the power act before the illinois general assembly would establish policies that ensure data centers pay their fair share to protect consumers and our climate and in the be it resolved section be it resolved that we members of the city council of the city of chicago do hereby call on the interrelated general assembly to pass the power act sb 4016 to safeguard environmental protections and responsible development of to safeguard environmental protections and responsible development of data centers in Illinois in consideration of climate goals and citizens' well-being. I'd like to strike that language that I read and add the language that I just read. I say I'll motion from Alderman Hoppenworth to do so. All in favor? All right. Thank you for doing that again with me. As amended, may I get a motion? Oh, I'm sorry. it's all right i i just wanted to speak to the the resolution again so again like thank you so much for the work on it bringing it up on my phone like regardless of where it stands in the senate committee incredible list of co-sponsors on this right now and i want to give a a brief shout out to among them senator villavalam uh peters my own senator graciella guzman sarah feigenholz mike Simmons, Karina Villa, Julie Morrison, and many, many more. It's a good list, a list that makes me hopeful for future passage. I did want to ask if you could share what is an aspect of what is being called for in the Illinois Power Act that particularly speaks to you, that really made you want to work on this resolution? Well, a typical data center uses 300,000 gallons of water per day and electricity bills have increased 70 percent in the last six years and just so much pollution is going on right now and the power act would put regulations on that it wouldn't completely stop construction of data centers they would just put regulations on the policies they're using right now and seeing that the climate has been changing a lot recently I want to start making to change with that. I really appreciate it. It actually comes up in our summer preparedness hearings with ComEd because we talk about an agency. with ComEd, because we talk about an agency called PGM that conducts auctions for power, for demand across our particular region, and learning how data centers and their power demands drives up prices for all Chicanguans is part of what made this even more concerning for me. So, like, I really appreciate you raising this up as an issue for us. Thank you so much. Thank you, chair thank you all right um if i could have a motion to pass uh r2026-0028728 as amended all right so moved by alderwoman rodriguez sanchez all in favor all right in the opinion of the chair the ayes have it and i will report this vote as a recommendation to pass at the next city council meeting on october 14 2026 and um congratulations ladies on passing committee and now we'll uh we'll release you from the hot seats and you can continue uh watching from a more comfortable space if you would like all right all right still going out of order we're going to go to our second item on today's agenda and that's uh substitute ordinance 2023-0002972 amending municipal codes titles 5 and 11 regarding the utility billing relief program. I want to turn it over to Alderman LaSvada, lead sponsor of this item, to share a few words. Thank you so much. So this is an issue that I've been working on for the last six years with many of the individuals behind us. And why would that be? I want to speak some facts into the record here today, the fact that since 2007, water rates in the city of Chicago have increased 373%. 373 percent. So that's an annual increase of 20 percent every year. What has the result of that been? I would argue that DWM delivers two things effectively, water and debt. And I say that from the perspective of Chicago's water debt has now reached $724 million. That is an increase of $100 million just in the last two years. 37% of that debt is held in just five zip codes. Five zip codes that are all low-income, south side, majority black zip codes. It has become crippling for the city. I would expect, with water being an enterprise fund, that what we took in to be roughly equivalent of what it takes to operate the system. That is unfortunately not the case. In fact, on an annual basis, our revenue exceeds our expenses by, again, an average of $252 million a year. This has resulted in, I would say, extraordinary cash reserves for the Department of Water Management. Even just 10 years ago, that number was $895 million. Today, the cash reserves for the Department of Water Management stands at $2.5 billion. All of this I find concerning. I found it just concerning when I learned, because we were trying to understand, are there efficiencies that can promote deeper water affordability for Chicagoans? When it was confirmed to me by our former budget director, Ned Guzman, that the Ernst & Young study from last year did not even look at efficiencies for the Department of Water Management, precisely because it is an enterprise fund. for all of these reasons and I will not get into get into the emotional and economic suffering of tens of thousands of Chicagoans. I believe that we need and deserve deeper water affordability. The first time I met with the mayor on this topic was July 6, 2023. I checked my calendar. Now, the first time departments were brought together to give their feedback on the Waterfall Ordinance was yesterday at 10 30 a.m. To that end, I'm grateful for this item having been put on the agenda because I do not believe the meeting would have happened otherwise. I'm going to speak now into the record the cadence of actions that have been put forward to me, which is the reason I agreed to hold this item today. I say this so that advocates can hold me accountable, so that my colleagues can hold me accountable, and so that I can hold decision makers accountable. The proposed meeting dates would be as follows. Friday, October 16th. Friday, October 23rd. Friday, October 30th. Following these three meetings, we would request another two weeks to finalize policy proposals where we are seeking to have an agreed policy proposal by the week of November 16th, thereby teeing up the ability for final agreed ordinance to be socialized and voted on before the end of the year. That end of the year goal is arguably later than what a lot of chicagoans deserve but it is a goal that in good faith i agree to in this meeting advocates hold me accountable colleagues hold me accountable i will hold others accountable thank you chair thank you espada um open up to questions or comments and and i'll i'll start off here um this is this is an ordinance that i support i support your work i support the work of the the organizers in the space who've been fighting for this so i just want to appreciate you for moving this forward to appreciate you for moving this forward um thank you for sharing the dates um um i am kind of shocked frankly um that the administration couldn't get departments together sooner than yesterday to talk about this um i know that this is hard work that we all do and and departments and and the mayor and his team um have a million things to juggle all at once and we all feel that individually in our wards as well um and also you know this feels like a thing that we can come to a solution on and that everyone would want to um and i appreciated the figures on the water debt by ward um and would just say uh soul if you guys want to send that over uh to my committee as well We'll make sure to share it out to all the members of the committee because I think everyone's of interest. And of course, as we enter another year with poor economic conditions and further kind of changes at the federal level that are going to have significant economic impacts on residents in the city of Chicago, this all just becomes more and more urgent. Right. Every every day, every week, every month. So I appreciate your work and working, partnering with us and staying in communication. Yes. I'll add one thing. You should always check people's homework. Check the homework. I want to note that everything that I just stated comes from the city's own reporting. We receive annual reports on the utility billing relief program, including water debt. The city conducts annual comprehensive financial reports called ACFER. That is where all of my data came from. I say this because data points have been shared with me otherwise by departments that directly conflict with the city's own reporting. conflict with the city's own reporting so I always believe was taught this at an early age show your math um thank you chair thank you any other questions or comments for Alderman Lisbada all right so we will hold this item and move on to our final item on the agenda oh yes I'm gonna say Joe Lopez for clarity I know that Alderman Lisbada mentioned like some some dates in terms of water can you repeat when or what are those dates for these sure alder lasvada i would be glad to so the the meeting dates that we're going to meet on to hammer out the policy that will come back to the committee are friday october 16th friday october 23rd friday october 30th and this will include departments as well is this like are we going to call that yes sir and so i i'm not saying that these are committee meetings these are like working meetings to hammer out policy uh followed by the goal of having an agreed policy proposal by the week of November 16th. And what departments are going to be called on this, just to be clear? My understanding from the email is including but not limited to Department of Housing, Department of Finance, Department of Water Management. Yes. I think maybe I would add, maybe it would be good to bring the comptroller as well to these meetings, as they also have some implications on how, especially what a debt has been treated head of the department of finance service i'm very much trusting that he will be there fantastic thank you thank you both all right we're going to close out today's meeting with the first item on the agenda um substitute ordinance 2026-002547 amending municipal code chapter 2-92 by adding new section 2-92-591 prohibiting city departments and agencies from procuring disposable food service containers composed of polystyrene foam steering foam we shared a copy of the substitute ordinance and a one-pager with members via email ahead of today's meeting may have a motion to accept the substitute ordinance for consideration so moved by alderman martin um all in favor fantastic the opinion of the chair the eyes have it with that i would like to turn it over to alderman martin the lead sponsor of the ordinance to share more information on what's before you thank you chairwoman and good afternoon colleagues this is a proposal as was mentioned earlier during public comment to ban the procurement of foodware containing polystyrene foam and other non-recyclable plastics by all city departments if passed this proposal would take effect starting january 1st meaning that departments would be required to shift to more sustainable alternatives next year we are seeking to eliminate the use of these materials and instead encourage the use of compostable recyclable and reusable containers. As was discussed earlier, single-use foam and plastic foodware have impacts spanning well beyond their short time in use. They don't biodegrade, but instead break down into toxic micro- and nanoplastics that pollute our land, our waterways, and can infiltrate our bodies. And while the effects of these microplastics on human health is still being studied, they have been linked to negative health outcomes as serious as cancer, infertility, diabetes, and dementia. This ordinance has been the culmination of advocacy efforts for years, spearheaded by the Coalition for Plastic Reduction, which includes OPA, Organizing for Plastic Alternatives, IEC, the Chicago Recycling Coalition, and the Friends of the Chicago River. I don't want to call out ward specific residents uh who are here i will simply just give them a wink and a nod knowing that it was efforts from people all across the city who uh engaged my office on this but nevertheless a special thanks to 47th ward residents um i uh I also want to note that the state of Illinois has already moved forward with this legislation. It is in effect. We spoke with them about how enforcement has been going, and that helped guide our efforts, most of which were led by the people behind me in the audience who did outreach to some of our largest departments, including the Department of Aviation, to see how this would be implemented on the ground. We made edits based on that. We received very helpful input from several of our departments, including the law department, which I'm grateful for. I'm happy to answer any questions that you have. Finally, I would note in the ordinance itself, the substitute, which is rather short, there are some exceptions that were built in. One notable one I would flag, which addressing accessibility concerns to ensure that some of our disabled neighbors and constituents can have access to straws and other items to ensure that they can access food and drink as easily as possible, and then some other exceptions when it comes to addressing safety concerns, including lids and drink stoppers. So we did try to find this balance, but as we try to shift away from our reliance on single-use plastics, I think it's important for government to lead by example whenever possible. This is a meaningful step in the right direction, following in the footsteps of the state, and i will stop there and hope to earn the committee's favorable consideration thank you thank you um questions or comments for alderman martin i'm reading into the record a thumbs up from alderman la spada and a thumbs up from alderman sigcho lopez um i'll say um thank you for for your work on this alderman martin and to all the advocates in the room um i know i know it's a small step but it's it's planting it's planting a flag in the ground It's planting a flag in the ground that will help us to continue to move forward. So I want to thank you all for your work in moving us to a more sustainable city that is healthier for all of us as we continue our efforts to remove single-use plastics from the city of Chicago. So with that, can I get a motion for a passage of the substitute ordinance? so moved Alder Sigcho Lopez all those in favor all right in the opinion of the chair the ayes have it and I will report this vote as a recommendation to pass at the next city council meeting on October 14th 2026. that concludes the items before the committee today and I just want to take a moment to thank everybody thank you for your patience thank you for your attendance thank you for the work that brought us here and the work that will continue after we leave this room with there being no further business for the committee may have a motion to adjourn so moved by Alderwoman Rodriguez Sanchez and hearing no objection so ordered