City of Chicago City Council Rules of Conduct for Public Meetings 2023-2027 Pursuant to Rule 58 of the Chicago City Council Rules of Order and Procedure, the Sergeant-at-Arms sets forth the following rules of conduct for members of the public. These rules shall be in effect at all times that a viewing gallery or room is open for a meeting of the City Council or any of its committees. All individuals and their belongings are subject to search at entry or upon request. Individuals must remain seated at all times except, one, when entering or exiting the gallery, two, when providing public comment during the portion of a meeting, set aside for that purpose, or three, when asked to rise and be acknowledged by a member of the and asked to rise and be acknowledged by a member of the city council. Profane, threatening, harassing, abusive. The meeting of the Public Safety Committee is hereby called to order. We'll begin with a roll call. Vice Chair Yancey, Alderman Chico, Alderwoman Gutierrez, Alderman Lopez, Alderman Curtis, Alderman Tabarez, Alderman Cinchel Lopez, Alderman Fuentes, Alderman Telly Farrow, Alderman Spisado, Alderman Vasquez, Alderman Knudsen, Alderman Gardner, Alderman Martin, Alderwoman Mena Hoppenworth, Alderwoman Haddon, Alderman Silverstein. Okay, we have a quorum present. We'll begin with public speakers. Our first speaker is Jessica Jackson. So this is Cook County domestic violence. So Alderman Tabaris, you're not going to turn around and listen when I'm talking? Okay. Because you're upset. Because I'm asking you and Donna Miller to do your job. You come up there to those Cook County meetings, and you had this thing on domestic violence. But yet, when I asked you and Donna Miller a question, which was, When it comes to domestic violence, what do you and Donna Miller, Commissioner Donna Miller, have in place for when the abuser is Cook County officials? Because it's Cook County officials that's cheating in court, that would be the judges, that's causing financial abuse. That's causing financial abuse on people like myself, J.B. Prisker and the corrupt public administrators which are under Cook County are abusing me because they continue to cheat in court and trying to steal my real estate. I've told you to bear us and showed you where that green sticker from Cook County Sheriff's with that fraudulent case number that they put on my basement tended door after they told to put after the public administrators told them to squat on me for three years for financial abuse against me. I told you, Tabaris, that the public administrators went into the Cook County court records and took out the domestic violence charge that me and my daughter had filed down there on 555 West Harrison against the basement tenants that the public administrators put in my basement to squat against me. I told you ultimate to bearish that the Cook County officials and city ordinance the residential landlord tenant ordinance that prohibits a landlord yeah look at the clock because I've got more time just because it's this meeting I'm going to get at you and get at you and get at you because I'm going to get you the way you're allowing these Cook County officials to get me and as a woman a full fledged woman I take offense to the fact that you and Donna Miller hold these bogus seminars and panels like this and gonna have these women and act like you doing something for domestic violence when in fact you are not you are a disgrace to women Women. I dare you walk away when you see me and run out the room. You phony. Oh, the woman. Oh, the woman. The next speaker is Zoe Lee. This is public safety. And as you know, Chicago has a public safety crisis, but clearly no one doesn't care. I don't care as long as it fits y'all agenda. now seven year old girls stabbed on cottage grove uh the other day and it's unfortunate that um you know that happened but that's what happens when you put illegal aliens in our community when we've asked for that not to happen because you know it is against the U.S. Constitution even though I know that you guys don't read the U.S. Constitution and you guys are trying to manipulate the U.S. Constitution to what you guys want it to be but you're not supposed to bring people from another country over here and don't make sure that they're vetted and put them in you know make sure they have citizenship and all that so then you put them in our communities they're already under-resourced dealing with the mental health issues that we already deal with that you guys keep getting money for like this domestic violence scam that you guys always act like y'all are for people are fighting for what's right when you aren't we have a whole domestic violence crisis out here we have a whole humanitarian crisis out here because you guys don't care about anybody but that's a democratic party the democratic party you guys are honestly like actors and actresses yeah honestly like actors and actresses y'all y'all are y'all feel like y'all are advocating for what's right but you're advocating for what's it what's going to go in your pockets so the worse that it looks the more money that y'all get brandon johnson allowed that seven-year-old girl to get stabbed and then all of you guys who voted for that money you guys also allowed that to happen and majority of you guys who are hispanics that are on this um city council majority of y'all are racist i call y'all the hispanic kkk so y'all were okay with that little girl getting stabbed i didn't see not none of y'all go over there and talk about it because she's venezuelan right and a lot of y'all don't get along with them we all know that a lot of mexicans don't even rock with the Venezuelans. Jesse Fuentes, you're Puerto Rican, but you're a traitor to Puerto Rico. They don't even rock with you like that because you are with the Puerto Rican scam that's over there at the Puerto Rican Culture Center. So you don't care and what you use your LGBTQ super weapon to act like you're for the people, but you're not, just like your wife too. But this is what happens when you get a bunch of incompetent people, popular dummies, in these positions, That don't know nothing about government, don't know nothing about the U.S. Constitution, don't know nothing. The next speaker is Peter Lara. Safety in Chicago is the biggest scam known to man. A seven-year-old getting stabbed? Children that get shot or killed or injured? That's a crisis. And none of yous will confront that. CTA, where people are getting pushed and shoved off the platform? Why is there no concern for that? There are so many incidents of crime that happen, but they don't report the true statistics. Because they're afraid once people see the true statistics, not the fake ones, they'll start realizing, yeah, it's getting real, it's getting serious. And all these illegal migrants look up United States Code 1325. It states clearly that if you enter this country illegally, you are committing a crime. They're nothing but criminals. Say it like it is, it's criminal. They're criminals. But you guys don't have the balls to say it. We need to remove them out of this city. Look at Sheridan Gorman, an innocent college girl that got killed, brutally killed, by an illegal migrant. What was he doing here? The city basically gave them all sorts of free commodities, and this is what they do? Get rid of them. Nobody's challenging that welcoming ordinance. Get rid of it, too. You, you're saying that ICE can't come into this city and perform their duties as federal agents? You guys don't have the power to do that. The federal, look at the supremacy clause. Everything federal overrules state and local. Why has no one looked into that? The DOJ is looking into Chicago's situation as we speak. Because too much corruption, too much self-centered interest have been going on. And we're going to talk about this task force? This is insanity. This is absurdity. You should be ashamed of yourselves for allowing that. And the mayor and the governor won't defend us, won't defend those people that got killed. Bethany McGee, who got caught on fire. Sheridan Gorman, or this little girl. We're done. And to this agenda, I only got one message for it. it's garbage we need to stand up for us as American citizens whether you guys are listening or not I don't care we're going to keep speaking the truth and we're going to throw it in your faces thank you the next speaker is Freddie May Moon the next speaker is Anton Seals please add Alderman Vasquez and Alderwoman Silverstein and Alderman Curtis to the attendance roll call for purposes of quorum. The next speaker is Malcolm Weems. Good morning, Chairman, Committee. There you go. Thank you. My name is Malcolm Weems. I am the owner and founder of Tequity Partners, an IT solutions company that has partnered with Mark 43, with Mark 43, a company that has a records management system contract with the city of Chicago. I'm here again. I came a few months ago where we tried to demonstrate that OPSA's inability to award a records management system contract for the city over literally over the last five years has cost this city, you know, over $250 million. And so here we are three months later, since I've been here before, you know, the bill is still racking up. So after reading the articles about the budget here and overtime being an issue, I want to again remind this committee that having a proper records management system will allow you to save about $35 to $40 million a year in overtime. It will reduce the time it takes for police officers to write police reports, which is incredibly long. So I'm here to ask this committee to, again, push on OPSA to make a decision. After reading about the CAD system, and it's taken so long to implement this system, OPSA seems to want to bend and twist to give a contract to Motorola. If that happens, that would be a problem. But I will tell you this, implementation of a brand new system is going to take you at least two to three years. If you look at what the CAD has gone through, it's been longer than that. So, you know, Mark 43 is here already. During the time that I've been talking to this committee, we started a deal with the Park District and got them implemented in 50 days. So while we're still back and forth for two years, this RFP has been out here for two years, and that means two years of money you all could have been saving and no decision has been made. So they will tell you that it's a policy decision not to discuss who the winner of a procurement is. As you all are aware, policy is what you decide it will be. There's no law saying that they can't do that. saying that they can't do that. So what it looks like is they don't want to tell you what their plan is. So I'll tell you, they are trying to figure out how to give this contract to Molarota. This is the second time they have tried to do this. So, you know, I urge you all for as a taxpayer, please push on OPSA to give you some answers around the records management system and save us some money, please. Thank you. Yeah. Thank you, Mr. Williams. Your remarks are timely and relevant and i hope the administration's listening uh next we have a rule 45 report for approval by this committee can i get a motion to adopt uh did you uh support the yes okay moved by elder woman fuentes uh hearing no objection so ordered we also have before us a substitute for resolution 28875 reinstatement of the city of chicago cook county violence against women task force for the second phase of operations uh alderwoman tabaris makes a motion to substitute any objections hearing none the matter now is substituted and before us the chair recognizes alderwoman tabaris on the substitute this is just amending and codifying language to make it clear that the city was not going to mandate the county to make sure agencies are executing the recommendations it's more collaborative so i ask for an aye vote and if i may close at the end thank you we do have some speakers in the box uh katrina watkins lloyd uh sarah brown elizabeth Gerald and Carmen Navarro-Girchione. Alderwoman Tavares, who do you want to open witness speakers? I like to start with the ladies in the box with Carmen Navarro-Girchione and then Sarah Brown and work our way down with Katrina. Thank you. Carmen, please restate your name for the record and begin your remarks. Thank you. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Alderman. My name is Carmen Navarro-Jarcon. Today, I am here as one of the founders of the City of Chicago Cook County Violence Against Women Task Force and the All-In Alliance, which is our survivor-led effort to ensure survivors' voices are driving the policies and reform efforts. We are not lobbyists, nor do we have government contracts. We are volunteers trying to save the lives of women, children, and vulnerable communities. Last July, as the first phase of the task force concluded, domestic murders had decreased 58 percent in just six months. In years previous, even during the financial windfall of ARPA funding, the domestic murder rate in Chicago had continued to increase. Chicago had an intimate partner murder rate higher than LA and New York combined. The task force proved that transparency, transparency, collaboration, and helping government agencies better serve victims seeking care could save lives in all of our communities. There is so much more urgent work to do, but contemplating defunding a police unit that is vital to victim services is not helpful to these efforts. We have victims and survivors here today. We were here the other day, and part of what my comments are are going to speak to that as well. This is why it's important to have one conversation so that the information is not fragmented. As Sarah stated earlier, and you'll hear from her again, they shouldn't have to spend time searching, seeking, gathering information, and putting everything together to find out the truth. The same should be about their government. Hearings and information should be available in one place at one time. That's why we're speaking on this as well. As we shared in the final report for the task force, the Chicago Police Department and all police agencies throughout Cook County remain the front lines of the domestic violence crisis. with over 100,000 domestic-related calls a year and 335 per day. and 335 per day, the Chicago Police Department received four times as many calls as the domestic violence hotline. To be clear, we have also called for more funding for housing and programming. If the civic, philanthropic, and government sectors can coalesce and fundraise tens of millions for community violence intervention, we should also be able to do so in order to save the lives of women and their children. This conversation today does not factor the research behind victimization nor the pathways to becoming a survivor. A victim calling a hotline or walking into the door of a courthouse is ready for help or to learn more about resources. This is a stark difference to those who may first interact with CPD after a neighbor may call 911 about a domestic dispute. By empowering that victim with information, making follow-up calls to check in, and helping them navigate their cases, this unit is providing a lifeline to victims for when they decide they are emotionally ready for help. Offering pathways for victims to become survivors saves lives. The Chicago Police Victim Services Unit works 24-7 and helps residents in all neighborhoods of the city of Chicago. We know that most domestic murders and shootings occur between 12 and 4 a.m. and that they spike on the weekends when most providers are closed. The victim specialists work tirelessly with enormous caseloads. We have heard directly from survivors that specialists from this unit helped save their lives. Some of them, one of them, is here today. As this conversation continues, the All-In Alliance is currently working to replicate CPD's model with partners in the south suburbs of Cook County because we know that data and research from across the country has proven that when police and advocates work together, lives are saved. So all we're asking is that we make it easier for survivors to play a part in saving their to play a part in saving their lives. Thank you. Thank you, Ms. Navarro. And as Ms. Navarro mentioned, we have a survivor with us today who has experienced both the best and the worst of the system, and she can testify through her lived experience. Sarah Brown? Thank you, Chairman. Today I stand in full support of the City of Chicago's commitment to passing Phase 2 of the Cook County Violence Against Women Task Force recommendations. recommendations. We have spent enough time identifying the cracks in our system, and now it's time to seal them. Phase two is a critical bridge between acknowledging the problem and enforcing the solution. By moving these recommendations into concrete city policy, we are sending a clear message. The safety of survivors is not an optional priority. It is non-negotiable mandate. I want to specifically commend Alderwoman Tabaris for her steadfast leadership on this issue. Her commitment to this cause has been instrumental in ensuring that the voices of survivors are not just heard, but are being translated in legislative action. Alderwoman Tabaris understands that transparency in our courts and accountability across our agencies are the only ways to restore the trust that has been broken for so many families. By aligning the City of Chicago with the broader efforts the of the Cook County Task Force, City of Chicago Cook County Task Force, we are creating a unified survivor-centered front. We are moving towards a system that finally puts the safety of victims ahead of bureaucratic convenience. I I urge the city council to follow the lead of Alderman Tavares and move swiftly to pass the second phase. Let's make our city a place where justice is not just a goal. where justice is not just a goal but a guaranteed standard for every survivor thank you thank you uh the next speaker is katrina watkins lloyd it's katina watkins lloyd tina i apologize good morning i too stand here in support of the city of chicago cook county violence against Women Task Force, phase two to move forward. Not only do I sit here and support, I also sit here in support of the Chicago Police Department Office of Victim Services. I sit here today as a mother, a sister, a daughter, a 23-year veteran of the Chicago Police Department as well. I have answered many calls for victims of domestic violence. I've comforted them, I've listened to them, and I have offered hope to them. As I've offered hope, I've also needed those same words of encouragement. As I've stood there and I was a victim of domestic violence. For the year of 2024 and 2025 and 2026, I entered a post-decree child custody battle with my abuser. If it wasn't for the Office of Victim Services, I wouldn't be here today. Their support has been invaluable to me. They have stood with me through many court proceedings. they have answered the call during the day and in the middle of the night to have agencies to sit and fight for funding and to have that on the table to be eliminated would not only be a travesty eliminated would not only be a travesty, it would be unjust. Thank you, Ms. Watkins-Lloyd, and our final witness is Elizabeth Gerald. Hello, everyone. My name is Elizabeth. Hello, everyone. My name is Elizabeth Gerald, and this will be my first time speaking. I don't really speak, but I like to listen to what everybody's saying, and I want to speak on two different things because I don't like the way some of the people have been speaking in here. I've buried two kids, not one. My son was murdered, shot in the head, fighting over a girl. And my daughter died by suicide as a result of being beaten. Maybe she was 14. And I can say this. The town of Flossmoor, from day one to the time the guy took my daughter and assaulted her and left her for dead to the day I buried her, they stood by me. There was no Democrat or Republican thing. Nobody ever said anything. And the people, the guy who did it to my daughter, he don't care if you're a Democrat or Republican. So I don't understand what, you know, your political views has to do with this meeting at all. Because when I go to the cemetery, I can't say, well, it's a Democrat, Republican that got you in here. It has nothing to do with that. we can't blame the aldermans and the mayors for everything that goes on because they're not the ones telling these people to go out and do these they do what they want to do um so and with they don't care when they're doing it you know and a lot of times people do stuff they can even get caught and you know sometimes they don't but people have to learn to blame the folks who do the stuff. Osborne Tavares is not the reason my kids are in the ground. Somebody that's in prison is. And it's the right way and the wrong way to talk to people. I don't care how angry you are. Sit down and talk to them and show them the respect that you would want to be shown. Coming in here cussing and clowning and threatening, it's not going to get you anywhere. But if you talk with kindness and treat people like you want to be treated, you'll get a lot further. So I thought I lost my daughter. I started MJG Movement. I have a documentary. It broke records. I mean, I'm very Google-able. almost every celebrity, every participant. I've had so many people reach out to me because I do stand with survivors of both domestic violence, gun violence, and sexual assault because they're all under the same umbrella. And we have to learn to be there for each other. And just, you know, just sometimes a person might just need a hug or whatever else. And when I was told about the task force, you know, whatever I can do to help, because I do stand by each and every one of these ladies. I stand by everybody. Donna Miller, you know, I don't live too far from her, and she knows anything. They can ask me to do anything, and I'm there. You know, I just came back from New York. I stood in Times Square with Jess Michaels. She's one of the Epstein survivors. They reach out. When I tell you people reach out to me because I don't judge nobody, and I'm one of those people who don't sit there and just try to, you know, pull on somebody's coattails or nothing, they do. and you know I think this task force is very important and one of the things I think needs to be vetted out is when people want to speak maybe have different conversations for different rooms because you don't know what a person's going through in here you know sometimes when you're coming here and you're cussing and you're clowning and you that can trigger people especially victims or survivors that might trigger them because you don't know what they were going through at home. So I stand by each and every one of these ladies and Katie and Donna and Tavares and anything I can do to help this task force, I'm here. Thank you. Thank you. I'd like to to thank our expert witnesses for their courage in coming forward, their willingness to share their stories and their personal accounts, and to reclaim their power. May it be an inspiration to all of us in this room to continue doing this important work. The chair would like to add Alderwoman Maria Haddon to the quorum roll call, and then Alderwoman Tabaris, do you want to introduce Katie? She's got a PowerPoint presentation. I'd like to introduce Katie Dunn, who works with Rebel Health and Chicago 77 Charities. We've been working very closely the past couple of years on this task force. And you may remember her back in July. She was here to present the report and the recommendations that we worked on from January 1st to July 15th on Phase 1. She's here today to introduce Phase 2 and to talk about how we are going to put into action the recommendations that she presented back in july so i'd like to turn it over to to katie to present her presentation thank you thank you um i want to uh thank chair hopkins and rocio and their staff for all of their help um all the other uh persons that are here today um obviously are amazing uh survivors and also um my my teammates here sarah brown and carmen navarro decone um and i also want to echo what sarah said about alderman tabaris um when we started this we had no idea really uh we there was no blueprint we're making it up um as we went along with every conversation with every survivor we talked to we're identifying a longer list and a longer list of things we needed to um look at investigate and hopefully reform and fix and uh this was a 24 seven uh six month endeavor uh phase one and alderman tabaris put in the work it was nights weekends and um we just really appreciate you um i also want to thank the county partners i don't partners, I don't think they stayed around for the hearing, but they've been tremendous on the county side, especially Commissioner Donna Miller. Today is part of Domestic Violence Awareness Month, so this hearing is fitting to be held during October, but we also are looking at violence across the board, in particular against women in vulnerable communities. By fixing these systems and really creating a system we hope to be able to help reduce violent crime overall the the initial partners for phase two is is going to be the city of chicago cook county government the state of illinois partners that were joined us for phase one and we're also adding suburban municipalities because what we have seen is the the lack of transparency from the court system is really impacting the south suburbs. So just for example, some of the suburban areas, they cannot tell you how many women have been killed or what the crime rates are. Chicago does have a dashboard, which is done by the University of Chicago Crime Lab, but that does not include the suburbs. So we don't even have really basic data on the crimes and the crimes against women in Cook County. So I brought data here when we first introduced the task force, I think last July or last fall. In 2025, the year closed out where the murder rate had increased by 27 percent and fatal shootings by 56 percent in domestic related cases. Homicide victims in domestic cases were 70% black residents and 25% Hispanic, equating to 95% of all homicide victims and domestic cases be minority residents. The majority of those cases are women. In 2026, we initiated the task force January 1st of that year. Domestic murders began to decline. They're down currently began to decline they're down currently by 46 percent but shooting victimizations are still up this year homicide victims are reported to be 80 black 8 hispanic and the vast majority are women so i just wanted to show this because when we did this we shared this data before it seemed to have an impact um on some of the other people uh persons that we had talked to afterwards um So out of all violent crimes, all domestic violent crimes, 88% of the victims are minorities, 70% are black residents, and just under 18% are Hispanics. And also for the domestic shootings, and Carmen mentioned this, the majority of the fatal and non-fatal shootings are from 6 p.m. to 1 a.m. Um, and that's when a lot of services are not open and a lot of people will not be answering their phone. Um, that's really why the Chicago police unit that, um, has been discussed recently is, is imperative to keep that funded, but also the, um, to invest in the domestic violence hotline that also runs 24 seven. Um, one thing that I want to note for everyone in this room is this year so far, there has been a fatal or a non-fatal shooting in all 50 wards. so this is impacting every single part of Chicago so the overview of phase two is really to build on phase one we're going to extend it for 24 months this time it was initially a six-month sprint now we know that we have a lot of actionable items to implement and so we're going to be focusing on those recommendations that were issued in the final report and we could recirculate that to this body that was issued in July of 2026, and it has six main recommendations that I'll review now. And we're going to also continue to host executive meetings. Everyone is included. Everyone is invited to join. We've been bringing experts in from across the country and also local. been bringing experts in from across the country and also locally and we're going to continue to do that on a quarterly basis and then alderman tabaris also included this in the county just passed the resolution on the county side where quarterly updates on the task force will also be introduced to this body on a quarterly basis so you could track the progress of the recommendations so these are the six recommendations as i mentioned the list that we talked about probably almost up close to a thousand people survivors people from across all of the different departments the city of the county of the state really try to talk to people up and down the ladders and really got a good sense of what's going on we we put all of these to do's in these six buckets but there's also a lot more that needs to be done and so just to kind of begin this is the overarching issue that we keep running into is that the cook county court system is not subject to FOIA. So we're really going to be pursuing this in 2027. We love to have some champions and some partners among all the persons of Chicago. Although this is more of a court issue and they'll say on the county side, it's a state issue. This impacts all of the residents in the city of Chicago. Sarah and other survivors here can tell you a lot of the court proceedings are still not recorded. It has completely built this culture of, you know, distrust, I would say, in the court system. But there's also, you know, incidents where judges are making rulings that cannot even be appealed because of the lack of recordings. All of the programs under the chief judge and the entire court system is not subject to any sort of transparency. And so that's something that we need to legislate statewide and we'd love to have everyone's help as we move that forward in 2027. The second recommendation was basically a data sharing center based on a based on a different model that would triage cases. The high priority orders are the orders of protection, which had in 2025, a pretty low rate of service. That rate has increased. And as that rate has increased, the murder rate has decreased. So we know how important it is to serve orders of protection, both via the sheriff, which is who's the statutory authority to serve orders of protection, but also in the court and with local law enforcement, including chicago police department being trained as well we also want to focus on warrants which is a major issue in cook county in the city of chicago and then firearms there's a lot of confusion around firearms and there's not really a lot of data and information being shared with law enforcement to safely remove firearms from dangerous situations the third is an independent data dashboard similar to the city of chicago's dashboard but this would track the entire system um so how many orders were filed how many were served how long it took by who and really track all of the variables of the system that are impacting violent violence against women hold everyone to an account and really also give a blueprint of what needs to be changed where training is needed where resources are needed because right now budgeting is done really kind of on a blind basis on a lot of different fronts without any kind of data to be able to track on the court side um the next is the city cook charter this is an ordinance um and this is something that uh we would like um the help of this body um when we move forward in 2027 this ordinance would provide a city cook charter would be the first of its kind um but really it brings together the city and the county in a measurable way and um via legislation um not just uh like another blue ribbon committee why this is so important is the lack of data sharing and transparency and even some of the laws that preclude that currently are causing a lot of chaos um, are causing a lot of chaos in cases and the court system right now is not, there's not anyone over the court system. Um, so there's all independently elected officials and there's not any oversight. And so this would be able to provide both, uh, agencies, the city of Chicago and Cook County, um, more information in a way to build a transparent and accountable, um, courts and justice system where one right now is, is pretty lacking. Um, the next is domestic relations and some of the survivors here today can explain domestic relations court is family court this is impacting all of your communities the family court in cook county is not transparent there's no court recordings cases can go on for 12 years victims of domestic violence their cases if you have children is transferred into this court system they don't get any domestic violence assistance or help and it's causing women to be in horrendously dangerous situations with their abuser for over a decade if not longer it's also really costly system and so it's taking away generational wealth it's putting people through evictions court and it's having a causing a ton of trauma with children that are involved and so this is going to be a main focus going forward in the recommendations and then finally just creating paths to survivorhood what we've we've seen is you know every courthouse is a fiefdom every district police district is a is its own universe um there's not really um a system in place and so we've we've created our own seven point system we want to make sure that we're triaging cases we're making sure that there's resources available at each intercept point where someone may be working with some some level of government um but also um to really look at it from what happens when someone walks in the door throughout every single point until they leave because what we're seeing is so many people and and chairman hopkins mentioned it really being victimized again by the system itself um after by the system itself um after they have gone through these horrible experiences and they come to help and they um like sarah's case is still going on 10 years later um and is being she's being victimized again by the system itself and so we want to really look at this from start to finish and how to get people into a safe place but also um to give resolution to the to these victims so they can become survivors um we're adding additional working groups we did this in round one first responder safety and health we have some amazing groups are going to be a part of that first responders are at the front lines of this crisis of all of the violence in the city of chicago and cook county and we also want to look at a training and policy review because a lot of the policies that we have you know that have been shared with us some of them contradict each other and there's not there hasn't really been a holistic look at the policies across the city board um and so this is just really the the timeline um is to pass this today and pass it before city council it will be passed before um the cook county board of commissioners in december we'll bring back the task force in january 2027 and implement the recommendations over the next course of the next two years um and then the quarterly reports as i mentioned will be submitted to the respective committees um just so you could track the actual item but also if anyone has ideas or suggestions or would like to help we'd love to have you have conversations and have you on board and so that is uh that's the end of this didn't want to flood with you with information but if anyone wants to be a part of this we'd love to talk to you we'd love to meet we'd love your help thank you thank you miss dunn for your excellent presentation and status update we will take questions from members and I will begin actually. You mentioned the need for FOIA reform and transparency within the court system. Have we engaged the chief judge's office? have we engaged the chief judge's office on that specific conversation? And are there any other examples around the country of circuit courts that have various levels of FOIA engagement? Where does Cook County sort of compare to other peer systems? Sure. So I have spoken to the chief judge. I think it was like the second person in his office when he came in to talk about this. This is a legislative need, so it has to go before the state legislators. We're the least transparent large court system in the world, probably, but definitely in the country. We've talked to researchers and experts from across the country that won't even touch Illinois because they know the difficulty of getting information. So for the past year, we still sit here not knowing how many orders of protection there are. um so the the um your colleagues on the county side spent um about 60 million dollars on a record management system and all of the updates the county is now ready for transparency i think the problem was up until this point they didn't have the ability to to it was a paper-based court system um they're ready now for transparency and so i think that's the major change of um it's town it's time now to uh introduce this resolution but also to subject there's these large like pretrial services, electronic monitoring, probation, there's these large units that are under the chief judge's office, and reporters, no one can get any information about those cases. And, you know, in addition, just the lack of court recordings in courtrooms, we have judges that, you know, are mistreating people by the conversations we're having, but we can't, you know, we can't go and prove that. And so it's really hard to inform electorates on who to choose for judicial elections when we don't know. We can't safely say that these are people that are working really hard for the public or these are people that are re-victimizing victims. people that are re-victimizing victims. So transparency is going to help overall. You really just can't have these billion-dollar government agencies without transparency anymore. It's time to get up to speed. So we were able to talk the University of Michigan into doing a project in Illinois. We're going to start bringing in national experts once this data becomes available. When the chief judge assumed his position, he seemed to indicate favorability towards reform and additional transparency measures. Perhaps it's time for us to kind of remind him of that and make sure that he's fully on board with these efforts. Yeah, and he's honestly a great, great guy. And there's probably a lot that he has on his to-do list. But really, this is kind of up to the legislators. So we would love to have just some support as we go into January 2027. We've talked to a lot of the state legislators and everybody seems to be in agreement. That's encouraging to hear. And, of course, the legislators will yield to the chief judge's opinion, so he could really be a leader in making sure that this gets through the General Assembly if he's willing to take that position. Thank you. Further questions? Alderman Lopez? Good morning, Chairman, and good morning, members of the committee. Good morning to our guests. First off, thank you to you and to our colleague, Alderman Tabars, for this resolution. um as somebody who has seen domestic violence firsthand uh both in my own home and in my communities uh i first have to say thank you for just having the wherewithal and fortitude to tell your story um i know that's never easy and then to have to come back and tell your story and come back again and again um so thank you um as well as the fact that my ward used to have one of the few if not only uh women's shelters on the south side for nearly 30 south side for nearly 30 years claire's house in in uh west anglewood um now we have wings in chicago lawn which i think is in your ward but i was there when we opened that with mayor manual but it was mentioned that the office of victim services is looking at some funding cuts is that correct to whom um i think there was a uh conversation about relocating that the funding for that unit um to other line items and how much is that unit um i would say i think it's under it's like three at three point something million so and i won't hold you to that because i know you're not our budget person so roughly three million or so that the city of chicago now is seeking to redirect it's a polite way to say it um to other programs that we don't know work or function as well as what we know works and functions very well in this moment correct sure yes um that's also at a time when in 2025 the illinois domestic violence hotline saw nearly a 5 000 call increase from the previous year um does see now we talked about the fact that the judiciary the courts are not very forthcoming with information how forthcoming is cpd with information honestly they've been a tremendous partner from the beginning so cpd is able to tell us and report out how many calls for domestic violence have been placed every year you would have to ask deputy director milstein but i believe he has presented that information he presented it at one of our executive meetings so i he probably would have updated information meeting so i he probably would have updated information for you and as we talk about like judicial reform and things of that nature i think all of us would say um that this court system is stuck in the 1950s um but how are the bar associations because many i heard a collect um because many of us not only as in our role as alderman but we also serve a secondary hat many of us um with local politics and oftentimes the bar associations are used as a guide if you will um on whether or not an individual is either worthy of being on the bench or continuing on the bench do any of the bar associations take a deeper dive into seeing whether or not a judge or justice treats survivors of domestic violence with any semblance of dignity well i will just say like right now with the lack of transparency and the lack of transcripts and court recordings there's no way probably for that review to take place um we see i would say where there's all where there's a will there's always a way yeah yeah i'm not uh defending i'm just saying i think hopefully with transparency the reviews would be a little bit more thorough um but injustice watch has done probably the deepest dive on the civil side and they've talked to a lot of survivors um to hear firsthand they'll include the caveat that they can't prove what they've been told but they're at least really trying to do that deep dive. So their judicial edition, I believe, is out right now. And I would gladly pivot to our guests, if anyone would care to share their thoughts on that question or not. or not well i do want to bring shed light on that and to katie's point um there is only one publication um that prints um and they've been in this space for over 20 years in justice watch um i think um you know even them following the journey of the task force um them you know really kind of you know investing um some of their investigative reporters into the space and them having um pretty much um priority that's kind of like their focus anyway for their publication so um I think what was consistent even with the issuance of this new um guide was that hey we do not have anything to vouch for we only can attest to let's say for example a case um gets a judgment right and you know in a lower court and then you go to an appeal judge right so a lot Either that data can kind of speak to, okay, how many times a judge decision is overturned in a situation. But this is the reason why it is vital for the court system to be transparent and foiable or even have a record of account to what was said in the courtroom because then that way it can be tracked and traced. But unfortunately, all we do have is our survivor friends to kind of lean on when we're at the courthouse to say, hey, so how does she judge? How was her demeanor today? Is she in a good mood? This is what we have to go through because of the lack of transparency. And I think that's really unfortunate because oftentimes many of these bar associations put so much emphasis on whether it's an ethnically appealing judge or an academically appealing judge. And none of them put the slightest regard for. And none of them put the slightest regard for empathy and compassion, especially for individuals who oftentimes are not necessarily assigned to family relations court because they want to be there. Yeah. See, and I also just want to note that a lot of judges are appointed. So there's, there's also that process. Yeah. So we want to look at, you know, making sure that what your point that that's also incorporated into that process, which is not transparent. Well, I will tell you, and I will end on this because I'm sure there are other people who wish to speak, but the issue with the judges is something that I've always found something of a concern to me. Whether it is how they deal with violent criminal repeat offenders, whether it's how they routinely manipulate the Safety Act to put people who should be held behind bars out on the streets, or adding to the pile how they treat victims of domestic violence as though that's just another case without any kind of human connection. i think many of us would very much like to start seeing uh the retention numbers change and the appointment slash nomination process amended one we could deal with politically the other we could start dealing with factually which is if you are on the bench and retention is your retention is up if victims don't want to see you stay on the bench then that is very telling And I think we all need to start figuring out who on the bench has no empathy for victims and start booting them off when they come asking to stay in that position. That message will get sent loud and clear to everyone on that bench that people are paying attention, not just to when they deal with the violent criminals that we see that make the headlines, but the violent transgressors who we never hear of. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Alderman. For the record, I'd like to add Chairman Alderman Talleyferro to the role, and I think Alderman Rodriguez-Sanchez was up next. Thank you so much for your presentation. I have a question about what the interaction of the task force looks like when the perpetrator is a law enforcement officer. I was looking at numbers because I've been paying a lot of attention right now at law enforcement around the country using flock cameras to track access, to go after women that they want to pursue. And it seems like it is something that is repeating itself over and over. And in looking at that, I was looking at the numbers in the Chicago Police Department, and between 2017 to 2023, there were 399 officers investigated for domestic violence. and only 26 were found substantial evidence that the domestic allegation occurred. But in most of the cases, there was actually evidence that the allegations were not unfounded. i am wondering how do we go about those investigations and how does the task force interact with perpetrators and cases where there is even less transparency because a lot of times it's internal investigations that take place sure um so we have copa on on our our board our board they've been a part of it from the beginning so they um their unit that investigates domestic violence has been um at the table with us and they've been able to kind of explain some of the difficulties um not just of uh those cases but also the under reporting at times can you speak about the under reporting and why that happens i think sometimes people just there might be allegations but they don't want to file a report and that happens across the board with criminal complaints when you like when someone is actually sitting down they have to sign something a lot of times they don't want to because they might not either want the case to be pursued they don't want like when someone um and sorry if this is like kind of starting from the beginning but if someone across the board whether it's police officer or not the domestic violence cases that are initiated most are dropped and so that's just that's across the country but it's especially in cook county um one of the main factors is child support ends if someone's in custody and so by week two someone might get worried about rent or child support and so they stop showing up to court um the second time is uh or the second factor is just change you know they decide they don't want to pursue those charges um so that would happen across the board there's just a really low rate of initiating a case to the case being where someone stays with the case the whole way through. So say if an investigation is two years long, that's going to be a really low rate of success of the victim or survivor. It's really traumatizing to have to retell your story and over and over. And so I can't speak specifically to that. Like we included COPA. We're trying to look at this across the board. We've had, we have a few survivors whose abuser worry that were first responders everybody's included everybody's invited everybody's voice is heard but we don't have a specific solution to that because that's probably more I hate to say that's more on your end of things to kind of figure out what goes on internally we're just external volunteers so we don't have access to any of those records or anything like that access to any of those records or anything like that I would like to add something to to that response if I may the having dealt with that we the officer wellness portion and safety that Katie mentioned during her presentation we also with some organizations we worked with it's important because not only our perpetrators Chicago or law enforcement in general but we have victims as well in the department and one of the things that we found out was that just something to hear like out of the last 10 suicides of female police officers one of the organizations told us eight out of those 10 were in domestic violence situations so I think one of the ways that the task force is trying to be helpful is having open honest conversations that this happens in every space it's even more dangerous when it's a law enforcement officer because we're talking about the firearm portion so when we keep going back to the courts and transparency and legislation that's why we keep going back there because that's the important legislation is they really need to take hold and that responsibility away so everyone can say first thing is removing those firearms and maybe victims overall not just if the perpetrator is a law enforcement officer or feel safer with proceeding so those are the conversations we're always having openly and honestly um because those are the the most dangerous on both ends yeah can i ask a follow-up question to that um it seems like for somebody that is in a relationship with particularly a police officer that is armed would probably have more reserve calling 9-1-1 because the response that she's gonna get is another officer correct so how are we engaging with potential victims engaging with potential victims and survivors to feel like they can actually ask for help if, you know, a colleague is going to come out and tend to that situation? That's a great question. I think the Chicago Police Department will probably need to tell you about the training that they do, but I'll just say, you know, I think everyone we've talked to, all of the law enforcement agencies that we've talked to and members we've talked to know that that there's an issue there i mean i think that the level of transparency we're talking about is too different like so those officers are showing up have a body-worn camera on there's reports and then like but if a victim goes into a courtroom to your point there's what we're saying is there's no transparency there's no recordings there's no um video so we don't know how that judge might um we have a survivor she'll say she's probably still being victimized so victim survivor i'm sorry i use it interchangeably but she's a law enforcement officer and so is her ex-husband and the judge was his friend you know so so we need transparency and accountability throughout the whole system and making it i think then that would hopefully improve the trust of someone making that call but you have to remember void cards is another main issue um so if a void card is removed a lot of times officers are going through issues will not go pursue help because of the void card issue um and then some of the um the just the resources are under funded as well for law enforcement officers um they're now tying um concussions to abuse so that goes from someone playing football to someone getting a concussion on duty um we just had a conversation this week about that. That's a national discussion. The traditional therapies don't work. Like there's different therapies. So we just like, we have to look at it differently. So we'd love to talk to We just like we have to look at it differently. So we'd love to talk to you more about that. But I think we're just trying to build a system that's trustworthy for everybody. No, I would love to talk more about it. And thank you so much. Very informative. All right. Thank you for your great question. I'd like to add Alderman Gutierrez to the role. And then next up, Alderman Curtis and then Alderman Haddon. Thank you, Chairman. First, I would like to thank Alderman Tabaris for championing this initiative. She's out of the room right now, but as she knows, I've stood with her on this issue for quite a while. And also with Sarah Brown and her mom for some years now, as we discussed her trauma that she went through for years and years, she cried, I cried, we cried. And it's really amazing to listen to this and understand, man, it's so heartbreaking. And as as as we talked about this even a few years back, I've noticed a lot of men that actually went through domestic violence also. And they're survivors. But for some reason, they won't come forward. You know, the macho man. So how do we get them more involved? all? I think so. We started where we knew there was the bleed. Let's just put it that way. Women were dying at a rate higher in Chicago than anywhere in the country. Most of the larger most of the larger cities combined. So we knew we had to start there, but we're really trying to look at this holistically through family violence and through, you know, next conversations will definitely involve also the children who grew up there watching this because we hear a lot of that and it's painful and you could see the emotions come out of people 40, 50 years after they experienced that. And so it's to look at it holistically is our goal. And that's always just been an intention um but we're trying to create safe spaces we have a survivor network we meet um once a month right now we we do community engagements and i think just trying to create a safe space where survivors you know can share their stories and and and encourage each other um is what what's been missing for a long time there's not really that safe space to come and tell your story and so we're trying to create that through the all-in alliance i'll i'll share the information for that as well with everybody uh through chairman hopkins yeah i think that's very important that that um we get a a link or or a phone number uh because there are actually a lot of people that that that needs help and and they're already afraid to come forward um but it would help if we could could help push that if they had someone if all automatic offices had a number that they could call or a place that they can actually go to get this help unfortunately even this week just this past week I had a fatal shooting uh in my ward domestic uh with siblings uh uh just a couple days ago they had a bedridden brother and one of the siblings thought the other was hurting them when they were changing them uh they were bedridden and They were bedridden, and they actually shot him, the other sibling. So this is a very difficult concern that we all need to be aware of. I have to honor all the women here today because I feel that you are the real heroes that's not afraid to stand up and say, no more. We're not going to stand for it no more. so I am standing here with you and I do want you to know that as I help bring more survivors to the program alright thank you thank you for your question next up Alderman Manhattan and then followed by her Alderman Sposado thank you chair thank you for the presentation and apologies for being in and out we have housing committee next door as well um uh thanks to uh alderman tabaris uh for for bringing this forth and and kind of continuing this effort uh i wanted to dig a little deeper and and ask you guys a little bit more on the recommendation around the recording and transparency um i um uh i'm thinking about how you how within the recommendation i know we're seeing the high level what what do you think and what are some of the best practices around this maybe in other jurisdictions that also protect privacy because i think about sometimes you know survivors or folks even just constituents who might disclose things and how so much of um working with survivors is also on um making sure that they have control over who has their information um right so sometimes i've had constituents who So sometimes I've had constituents who, the way that they want to, and you've touched on this, right? And some of the concerns, whether it be, you know, the consequences through systemic processes that impact them when they're moving through forward towards justice. And so sometimes there are constituents who may disclose something and ask for the help that they need. That isn't necessarily what I would like to do. Right. And like, hey, let's like let's call the police and let's get law enforcement involved and let's get a lawyer and let's do this thing. And so when I think about the implications as well of of foiable information, could you speak a bit to that? Because I imagine it's kind of tricky and maybe somebody's figured it out. You know, so I feel like there's not probably the perfect model just because it's such a fine line between transparency and privacy. obviously everything is foible in terms of like 9-1-1 calls court cases um that is available I think what what we're looking at really is the difference between civil court and criminal court and so what we found is more victims are going through civil court than criminal court due to orders of protection being civil and family cases being on the civil side um and so even just the orders of protection we found one and four were being um issued out of family court um and so the there's a fine line there of say we have and i'm just once again there's no way to prove this but like repeating stories we've heard of the judge saying like keep crying and i'll take your kids away you know keep crying i'll put your kids in dcfs we can't prove that right now so that culture is when you hear that you hear it from the same person about the same judge and a similar story over and over and over you know there's an issue there and it's also we they just go back to their abuser why would you continue with a 10-year case when you have to be put through that a 10-year case when you have to be put through that a few years ago and carmen was on the county side um through chicago 77 we proposed legislation where you could redact information out of orders of protection we're mostly worried um about women's health care uh anything having to do with gender gender and um also um just if you wanted to redact parts of it so that law passed like in a form, it's not perfect. We wanted to automatically redact anything with healthcare information, just anything that would be covered by HIPAA should not be public record. But now you do have to take proactive steps. That's the legislation we'd love to update. And to your point, be able to take out some things in just an easier way to protect your own privacy. But I think there's not a perfect model, but every other jurisdiction has much more transparency, even the federal courts. Like if you're in court today, there's an unofficial transcript up in a couple hours. You could order it. It's a $4 to order your whole transcript. I just got a transcript for someone the other day and it was $300 or something. They charge per page of the county. Like everything is set up against victims. And then if you want a transcript, so we had someone whose order was denied by the judge. We wanted to see why she got like a private Zelle from somebody that was supposed to then be able to transcribe it send me a hundred dollars and i'll send it might be more but i'll begin transcribing it i mean they'll just even be able to get access to transcripts now if there is a court reporter is this costly burden that nobody can pay um and so we were never able to even figure out why the judge turned down disorder protection so there's really it's hard to fix a system when there's just no evidence at all um and then also we're just seen patterns through the conversations we're having and some of them are really troubling I've worked on the criminal justice reform for 12 years I know I've never heard anything like some of the stories I've heard on the civil side so I think it's really like trying to figure out how to put that under the microscope next yeah um it's embarrassing um right like that's yeah um so maybe then a follow-up question this could be through the chair right in the um spirit of wanting to learn more in ways we can help as as you guys talk about these recommendations and how we can be advocates um if we don't necessarily have good models on kind of the recording piece that's one size fits all maybe there are other kind of court reform pieces to your point around kind of the transcript process access to information for parties involved and and of course i know that these were in criminal court proceedings but i think about some of the um uh the criminal justice reform efforts that have been most successful around kind of um court watching and and i'm wondering if you could speak to because i don't know um what are um how does that work in civil court as far as access so let's say right or who is allowed to be in the courtroom so whether that be outside of counsel whether that be a victim's advocate right if I think about what if maybe they're not assigned to a specific person but maybe there's a an effort of you know trained volunteers that could go and watch what are what's allowed in civil court proceedings and would something like that um could we build towards something like that to help gather data in in the short term while working on longer term reforms sure well first i probably didn't answer your first question like you and i could jump on a zoom right now and ai will transcribe it so there's ways to do it right now so it's not like we don't have the technology out there i just don't know if there's like a perfect model i know california mandates it in every courtroom and if you that's what i mean more for like that access of like because like the technology to do it you're right that's that's easy i mean more i i this is like a process like a process question right like how does someone get their transcript who holds it yeah yeah the federal government oddly has the best example right now because they've really invested in these record management systems and all the technology and all the courtrooms just because of probably the nature of those cases but the federal government probably does it the best and they have a specific system we'll probably be able to tell you the name of it but the county chose not to go with that system for some reason it has their own it has a lot of issues but ideally it would just be part of the court record where like you would click you could listen to the recording you could get an unofficial transcript and if you needed an official transcript for an appeal then you could pay for that or order that and have that done by a court reporter but nothing like that is in existence on the county side right now. I just wanted to just respond to the other question related to who can be inside the courtroom. So you guys can actually go right across to the daily center right now and sit in a domestic relations courtroom and court watch and so typically what we um as you know surviving through our court proceedings um we will find very pretentious judges that do not like to be observed they would literally kick court watchers out of their courtroom um and so as as i've been i've been sitting through a lot of the various hearings here in city hall and i you know some of the comments so you know you guys gotta sit through right you would think um in a courtroom um they you know should be under that same kind of um scrutiny not scrutiny but you know the public being able to sit in the courtroom um well they refuse a lot of times court watchers. You do not have to be a litigant on the case. In the case, you can even sit in domestic violence courtrooms or, you know, in those courtrooms, you can go to five five you know right down the street here um so i want to to say i think that for sure um definitely shares and tells um to the judge that someone is watching but i think again it goes again to the chief judge's office um the standing order is that that anyone from the public can can watch yeah thank you and i would like to add um she uh sarah is correct i did have one particular judge where she allowed no one in the courtroom. She did allow, like I said before, I had full support from the Office of Victim Services. So my advocate was allowed in the courtroom on my behalf and this one particular judge that I did have. We did have a court reporter it was a court reporter that was paid for a private court reporter that was paid for by um the respondent which was my ex-husband so um and it cost it cost a great deal of money um I believe um it cost forty five hundred dollars because he filed a motion to get me to pay for it. So. Thank you. No, thank you. All right. Thank you. Next up, we have Alderman Sposado followed by Alderman Gutierrez. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you all for coming out. Thank you, my esteemed colleague and close ally and friend, Sylvana, for bringing this forward. I have to tell you all, this is something I've never experienced in my family with my parents or my wife or my daughters, my heart goes out for you all. So I'm glad we're finally having this hearing and bringing this out so more and more people know about it. But just want to thank you all. I know it's tough to come out in front of a group of people and talk about this kind of stuff, and especially for the one young lady. this kind of stuff and especially for the one young lady that's a police officer i'm sure it's really hard so but appreciate you all especially uh like i said once again my esteemed colleague and of course my my friend and neighbor carmen and uh that's about it so thank you chairman thank you uh next up all the women gutierrez and then there there are any other questions uh i'll reserve that closed for uh all the women to bars i'm sorry all the men lopez gutierrez lopez to bars. Thank you. First of all, I wanted to thank all the women Tavares to putting this forward. And I just wanted to mention a couple of statements, but also one question that I have. As you all know, I worked at different schools, Catholic schools and um cps schools here in chicago and since day one working here um i've been able to help a lot of moms go through the process also being mandated reporter on kids being in situations like this and my heart goes to all those families not only in the seventh district of cook county that i was also working first appointed as a women's commissioner and then as the district director but also to the kids and families in the 14th ward that now always serve as the other woman but my heart goes out to all the families not only in chicago but the entire city in in country right and also in all different parts of the world per se unfortunately we know it's something that throughout the years continues to happen unfortunately people migrate to this country and they continue to have that mentality that women it's not valuable that women should not speak up that women should not stand up and fight back and unfortunately we continue to see it over we continue to see it over and over again in our communities and of course we all get the chills right on just remembering the suffering and how our families struggle throughout the system as well first because of the language second because sometimes and we all know the process is lengthy and sometimes it's not for our people so I'm glad that we are continuing to talk about this Out of all these bad things, I'm hopeful and this shine light that is now upon us to continue to work diligently in order to make changes. And I will continue to advocate. I'm going to continue to work alongside you all because we are in this fight together. I'm also a mom of three beautiful girls. Three beautiful girls that also need to learn and understand that they're valuable. that they are going to go ahead and pursue their dreams and nobody will stop them. So let's continue fighting and working together. And with this, I wanted to ask, because I've seen it throughout the years in the system, how it works. When unfortunately, it takes time, and I don't remember the statistics, but I think six or seven times when a woman is already pursuing to have an order of protection to already make that 911 call after many, many other attempts, right? Many reasons stop women undoing it. Once they're ready, okay, no more, I'm going to do it. Then is when they face those challenges from the system that we are all talking about. I've seen women going through the system, and they go confident to pursue an order of protection because no more. They can take no more and they should not. But unfortunately, then the perpetrator comes back to their home. home. They thought that they already went to court. They already were approved for two years that they're safe and ready to be able to protect their own families. But then the perpetrator comes in that night, sometimes drunk, sometimes just under the influence or just wanted to mess up. And then this person, this woman calls 911. Police shows up. And the mom or the woman is asking for that person to be locked up because she has an order of protection and then the officer unfortunately mrs so-and-so we cannot take him into custody because he has not been served so what can we do how can we help so that process to be faster and better for our constituents well one thank you because that's one of the reasons why we even started this work was just we just kept hearing over and over and over that the orders were not being served so what the other person is describing is when you go in there's five different kinds of protective orders the most common is emergency order protection and you get that initial protection and then you have to have a plenary hearing that can give you protections for up to two years after that both orders have to be served and the person has to come to court the service rate was down to, it depends on kind of who you're believing, but I think CBS did a really thorough investigation and it was one in four. And that includes being served in court and being served by Chicago police and the other local law enforcement that are helping. Orders of protection go to the Cook County Sheriff to serve in Cook County. That's a difficult job right now to find people and to serve them. Um, but there's other opportunities into like most people have a current court case in some way, whether they're on the criminal side or they have an eviction case or there's or there's something so we need to train across the board and how to serve in court um the horrific murder of that young girl last week if you track that case there was an open warrant and she had been in and out of court without the warrant being um enforced orders of protection are going through that same process where people are coming in for current court dates and nobody's checking for orders of protection so that would increase exponentially the service rate but it's still not giving that immediate response, which is we want when someone goes in on a Tuesday for it to be served on a Tuesday or a Wednesday, not three months from now in court. And so that's really what we're trying to put the dashboard and the data together so that it's properly staffed and properly resourced, the units that do that, that serve that. But also we've talked to Alderman Tabaris, set up a meeting with the Chicago Police Department about how to better train their staff so more people are trained to do that um but a lot of the whether you know um people understand it or not the court um the notices of the court a warrant most of that is falling on local law enforcement right now to enforce the number one reason for arrests by chicago police department are court warrants for someone missing a court date not for other reasons of arrest so if we get everyone trained to also check for orders of protection that will increase the service rate and the murder rate is already dropping with that that increase that we have right now um the bigger issues there's all there also transparency legislation where an order is not public record unless it's served yes and so that's only protecting those that you know don't have the order served for them so that's an incentive for someone to never receive service or open their door for service it's not a public record if they're not served and so we need to look at legislation as well oh yeah and thank you for all of that and happy to continue to you know draft any other legislations in the city or work with our partners in the county or the legislature or the legislators in the state because we really need to tackle all angles because, of course, someone, either men or women, right, because it also happens the other way, if they did something, they know that they're looking for them. So, of course, even their own parents and family members don't open the door because they saw the sheriff or the CPD trying to serve them, right? So then how can we find other ways for perpetrators to be served and how can we also utilize technology right in order for us to have those systems collaborate between them in order for for us to make this work a little bit easier so let's continue having those conversations let's continue to work because our community deserve to be protected our kids and families deserve to be healthy and happy in our city and in this country thank you everywhere everywhere yes thank you thank you uh alderman lopez thank you chair and again good morning members of the committee i just want to end with one final comment because we've heard it over and over and over and over again and we keep dancing around the judges and i know that it may or may not be reported but i think it's important that And we look and educate ourselves as to who the judges of the Domestic Relation Division are. Starting with Judge Gregory Ahern, Julie Amon, Edward Arce, Karen Bowes, William Boyd, Lloyd Brooks, Iris Cheveria, Bonita Coleman, Yvonne Coleman, Patricia Fallon, Rosanna Fernandez, Ellen Flanagan, Michael Forty, Mitchell Goldberg, Matthew Janisch, Lionel Jean-Baptiste, Kenya Jenkins-Wright, Robert Johnson. Jenkins-Wright, Robert Johnson, Matthew Link, Myron Makoff, Maritza Martinez, Maura McMahon-Zeller, Regina Ann Meskel, Kevin O'Donnell, Erica Orr, Jerry Pinser Rosenberg, Patrick Powers, Jill Rose Quinn, Jean Reynolds, Abby Fishman Romanek, Lori Rosen, Regina Scenicchio, Naomi Schuster, James Shapiro, Rosa Silva, Marita Sullivan, Bradley Trowbridge, Scott Zinberg, Lucy Vasquez Gonzalez, Andrea Weber, and And William Wu, you, all of those people should be paying attention, not only for their own employment security, but because they've all been put on notice again and now called out by name today for the lack of compassion coming out of this division. Two of them, if my rough table math is right, are up for retention. Maritza Martinez and Edward Arce all of them at some point will either be seeking to stay or seeking retention and I think let all the bar associations and let all the candidates and all the incumbents know that as we just heard from all of our colleagues here many of the flaws stem from their courtrooms what they allow what they ignore and how they portent themselves to people in crisis this is not a racket this is not a money-making scheme for attorneys and all of that this should be about victims and i think i for one and now em I, for one, am now eminently more interested in what these judges are doing in that courtroom, and I would defy any of them to throw one of us out if we were to decide to sit in their courtroom, because we'll be throwing them out next. Thank you, Chair. Thank you. I'm sorry. Please. I just had one suggestion that I really think that's important. And as we have our resources, our fairs and things like that, and our individual wards, that Chicago 77 actually set up a table and be one of those resources. Because so many times you may have a mother or father or friend that may get this information because they know that their loved one is in trouble. and they might just that help right there might be something that they may need at that point. Absolutely we'd love to One last comment from Alderman Gutierrez and then Alderman Tabaris to close Thank you Chairman but also thank you Alderman Cordes for that suggestion which also would love to invite my colleagues to also reach out and coordinate to other local organizations that do domestic violence in our wards. Mujeres Latinas en Acción in the southwest side and many others throughout the city. I think we also need to engage all of them because we're all doing the same work, but we just need to have them all together, right? Because if we want to continue to advocate in pushing all of these forward, I think it's important to also bring all of the different organizations to the table and all the different elected officials also open it up to more of our colleagues, right? Not only Public Safety Committee, the Women Caucus, and the 50 us aldermen here. us aldermen here and see who else want to join this table because as much as we want to continue to advocate us here we need to have a bigger table and we're stronger together so I think it's important to bring every everybody else into this so we can move forward and do it thank you may I make one last comment one of the things we need to be clear on is all these bar associations and political organizations, when they make these recommendations, they're making these recommendations not off what the victims are saying. They are evaluating these judges off their peer feedbacks. They are making these recommendations off surveys. They are not taking into account what the victims are saying. That's what needs to be clear. So people need to pay attention to that as well thank you for that all the women to bars no thank you i just want to start by thanking the survivors who are here with us in the box um and who have carried this work when government did not um thank you for standing with us thank you for all in alliance thank you to Chicago 77 Charities, Katie Dunn, Carmen Dracone, Sarah Brown, Katina Watkins, and Elizabeth Gerald. Thank you for being here with us and sharing your stories. I want to thank Chairman Hopkins for his support and leadership on this issue, and I also want to thank the members of this committee who supported phase one of the task force. What we found is that no one owns the whole system so protective orders warrants and firearm records never move fast enough courts stay closed to the public and victims meet that failure at every step phase one of this task force put those failures on the record and it called for a public on the record. And it called for a public dashboard, independent oversight of the court and justice system, and clear data on how law enforcement responds to high-priority court orders. A report on a shelf protects no one. That is why we are bringing this resolution forward. This resolution puts someone in charge. It's going to require FOIA compliance. It's going to require domestic relations court reform and oversight that includes survivors. So every point in the system moves people towards safety instead of away from it. Today, I am urging my colleagues to adopt this resolution to launch Phase 2 of this task force so that we can invite the state of Illinois and municipalities, townships, and government agencies across Cook County to join the work. Phase 2 will not study the problem again. It will drive implementation of the July report and set the next steps. It will stay focused on what government is responsible for doing. The county stakeholders will meet quarterly and agencies will report quarterly on the resources required to do the job. Phase two is going to begin January of next year and it's going to run through December 31st of 2029 with an annual report to the city council and the Cook County board. I'm going to end with this. the drop in domestic murders shows the work can move the numbers the rise in shootings shows we are not finished I urge members in this committee to support the extension and I'm asking the commissioners to adopt this version of the resolution at the county side survivors they did their part when they came forward the task force did its part The task force did its part when it put the gaps in writing. Phase two is our part. We must follow the recommendations, report the progress, and do not let this work end. Thank you. Thank you. Is there a motion to accept the substitute? All right. I'm sorry, resolution. Move do pass. Thank you. All right. Just a moment of privilege. I, to have witnessed domestic violence in my family, like many people. And I think that, well, one, that's why I stood to restore funding for domestic violence survivors in the budget last year. additionally while it is really important for us to expand the resources for domestic violence survivors i think it's equally as important for us to make sure that we are teaching our children that violence is not the way to resolve conflicts more importantly we should honor and respect the people that we are in relationship with especially romantic relationships and i look forward to a world where y'all don't have to come before us and have this conversation again so thank you to all of the survivors who presented today and if there is nothing else I would look for a motion to adjourn I'm sorry hey I'm new here what am I doing alright there being no further business before the committee can I get oh wait where are we it's live TV so a motion to adopt a substitute resolution by voice vote right voice vote Yes. Move, do pass. Voice vote aye. aye uh any nose here's eyes have it now may accept the motion to adjourn thank you