We are going to get started momentarily. Can someone from tech services confirm that the feed is good to go? Thumbs up. Great. Good morning, everybody. The Committee on Ethics and Government Oversight will now come to order. We have two items on today's agenda. First, a subject matter hearing on the Office of Inspector General's quarterly report for the second quarter of 2026. And second, a subject matter hearing of the communications and advertising practices of World Business Chicago. We will begin with a roll call to establish quorum. Please note that your yes or present response will be deemed a yes vote when this quorum call is used for a reference vote for later items. Chairman Martin is present. Vice Chair Haddon. Alderwoman Lee. Alderman O'Shea. Alderwoman Taylor. Alderwoman Tabarez. Alderman Taliaferro. Alderman Wagesback. Alderman Sposato. Alderwoman Nugent. Alderman Vasquez. Alderman Lawson. Okay. No non-committee members. We have a quorum. No Rule 59s, to my knowledge. Oh, Taylor, excuse me. We have received Rule 59 requests from Alderman Riley and Alderwoman Taylor specifically to request remote participation. Is there a motion to allow Alders to attend remotely? Alderman Vasquez. So moves. All those in favor signify by saying aye. All those opposed. In the opinion of the Chair, the ayes have it. Alderman Riley and Alderwoman Taylor are allowed to participate. At this time, we will begin public comment. This period is set aside for 30 minutes. Out of respect for everyone's time, each speaker is limited to three minutes. We have four people signed up for public comment. The first is Peter Lara, followed by Jessica Jackson. This is the Board of Ethics. I'm going to ask this question. Many others have said it, too. But I'm going to ask this pretty clearly. When are the audits happening? Where's the review on what the city is spending? I'm not going to go into detail what I called out at the previous meeting that just happened, because God forbid, oh, if I'm out of order. But this city has spent so much money on things that we do not need. Do we need to spend it on care? You know how much care ends up costing the average taxpayer here in Chicago? $48,000. That's crazy. $48,000 per call. And they claim, oh, well, we have a couple million. You know, we're just going to keep letting it flow. It adds up. It keeps adding up. There are so many restaurants that are having to deal with so many of fees that have been implemented. And why do you think these businesses go out of business? Because they can't afford it. Regardless of what the city claims, that we have the highest tourism or whatnot. Tourism is going down. When people come to this city, they expect, like even a decade ago, hustle and bustle. The city that was just gleaming 20 years ago. But when they come here, they see nothing but a bunch of abandoned buildings. Buildings that are on lease. So many empty buildings that are just unbelievable. And yet they still want to claim that we're doing great. No. It's absurd. Third, it's the whole city is acting in such a grotexed behavior. It's bizarre. Why is it so bizarre? Us citizens are asking for transparency. That's all we're asking. We're not asking for whatever you may think. We just want transparency on what our tax money is going into. That's what we are asking. And we still haven't got answers. The funding that went to the migrants. The funding that's spent with DEI. And our mayor, Mayor Johnson, is going to claim that, oh, well, certain companies can, you know, they can't work with us because they need to follow our DEI plan. Why does that have to be a thing? I'm going to say this again, as I said in the last meeting. If you can get the job done, if the job is done and everything is completed, why do we need to have race as a factor? This all started out. This all started propagating a decade ago. And you know what? Us citizens are done with it. And we're waking up. And we're going to fight it. Thank you. Recognizing Alderman Vegas as a noncommittee member. Thank you for joining. Next up, Jessica Jackson, followed by George Blakemore. However, if you are the chairperson of ethics, one would have to require you to be ethical. And you're not, right? You know that you're not. Can we agree on that? Can we agree on that, Matt Martin? That you're unethical? Anytime you're supposed to be a civil rights attorney, and I call you, and I call your office to investigate the issue of my case, and you repeatedly refuse to do it? And you're sitting there, the chair of ethics? This explains why this city is allowed to operate the way that it operates. Now, this new inspector general, when he first took that seat right there, he said that he was going to investigate you all. Now, while he doesn't have the power or the authority to fire you, what he does have the authority to do, just like every other inspector general, is to report it to the appropriate authority for prosecution. However, the proper authority in this city, in this county, in this state, would be that of a no-good-for-nothing-sorry lowlife de Kwame Raul, who refuses to investigate any complaint against any public official, which is why public officials are allowed to continue on in their corruption, because they know that there's absolutely no type of discipline that's going to stop them. Now, that's what we know for sure. Kwame Raul only comes out when it's the issue of illegal immigrants because he's a Haitian. Even though he did, like what Brandon Johnson did, like what Barack Obama did, like what Carmela Harris was going to try to do, run on that black card. Then get in office and care less about black people. But running as a Haitian, who's going to pay attention? Now, you lining up this, what is his name, Alexei Guglielis, to be a mayor, a person who's already been caught in corruption, bank corruption, with the likes of a J.B. Brisker. So you all are looking to recycle yet another Democrat in office so that they can continue the same things, the same corruption, the same overspending, the same looking the other way, the same flooding in our communities with illegal immigrants and blaming it on Donald Trump. You all are lining up the city for more of that garbage. Danielle Carter Walters for mayor. For mayor. Somebody that's coming with a clean and new agenda. Somebody that doesn't have a bunch of corrupt politicians that they owe a bunch of favors to because they're bankrolling their campaign. You need to get out of your seat, crook. Next up is acknowledging Alderwoman Tavaris for purposes of quorum. Next up, George Blakemore, followed by Henry Hughes. Thank you, sir. The citizens of the city of Chicago, you deserve the government you get. You got to get. You deserve this. You deserve these ultimates. These black ones. These white ones. Hispanic. Asian. You deserve this. These corrupt politicians. You deserve this. All of you are a problem. You're not the solution because you're sour. You go along to get along. What motivates these people to do this? The love of money. They get paid. And did you understand what happened to a re-internet, a revolution? She said, feed the people, Kate. The hell with the people, she said. They cut a neck off, a revolution. All of them are bad. The black ones, the white ones. And you here are bad, too. All of you here are part of the problem. This man doesn't have any power. This man accepted this job knowing the consequence of it, knowing that he didn't have any power. Well, why didn't he accept this job? Money. Well, that's a prostitute that sells herself out, sells herself out. That's what they are. Money. Well, Mr. Braymore, do you get paid? Do you get paid? No, I like the attention. Are you jealous? Somebody call me an attention H. I love it. You do what you do. Don't you like it? You get money. All of you here are corrupt. The system. And it has nothing to do with big head Trump. I want Trump to clean up the swamp. And then I want my people to go black. Not Democrats. Not Republicans. But black. God has given us everything we need. All we have to do is use what God has given us. We are the first man and woman on planet Earth. But we have fallen or fell in love with our enemy, those who enslaved us. If we black people have mental issues. Patty Hearst had a mental issue. She fell in love with a capture. A capture her. Something is wrong. Something is evil here. Thank you. Our last public commenter is Henry Hughes. Can I begin? Good morning, committee. In contrast to the prior speakers, I'm here to meet. I'm not here to meet you with vitriol. I'm here to appeal to you. I'm Henry Hughes. Please let me speak. I'm Henry Hughes, a high school student here in Chicago. And I'm coming to this committee with a proposal which looks to greatly increase the role of the people in our governance. While this committee may not be the most relevant to my proposal, the interconnected nature of its effect compelled me to appeal to you today. My proposal is to create a centralized online petition website where all Chicagoans can submit a petition easily and any other can sign it. Petitions which receive over 10,000 signatures would then be mandated to be spoken on in city council or the relevant committee. This would bring citizens closer to our democracy, demand accountability, and increase transparency. I'm looking for an alder person to sponsor my proposal and submit it to the Legislative Reference Bureau to create a fully functional ordinance. I emailed the offices of all the aldermen in attendance today with my proposal, which I also have printed here, if any of you are interested. So, thank you for hearing me. Thank you for your time. And I hope to get to work with any of you aldermen in front of me. Thank you. Thank you. That concludes our period of public comment. Our first order of business is the Rule 45 report from September 2026, which was distributed to the committee via email. Can I get a motion to approve the Rule 45 order report? Alderman O'Shea, so moves. All those in favor, signify by saying aye. All those opposed, in the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. We will now discuss the first substantive item on our agenda, a subject matter hearing on the Office of Inspector General's quarterly report for the second quarter of 2026. We have General Glockner and Deputy General Richardson and their team who are here to provide a brief presentation and answer questions. Once you are set, General, please continue at your convenience. Are you able to see the slide presentation? Not yet. Well, let me start by… Yes, we're good. Great. Thanks. So, let me start by saying good morning and then also just taking a moment to introduce the members of the OIG leadership team who are with me here today. First, immediately to my right, Tabara Richardson, the Deputy Inspector General for Public Safety, who oversees our public safety work. Next to her, Megan Morrissey, who recently joined us as our general counsel. To my immediate left, Darwin Jones, who leads our audit and performance review work. And then finally, George Louder, who leads our investigations work. And all of us are available to answer questions after my brief remarks. So, what I wanted to do was provide a brief recap of the work of the Office of Inspector General during the second quarter, along with some Q3 updates where available, since we just completed the third quarter yesterday. Overall, it was a very productive quarter for the Office. We had a particular focus on completing aged investigations and audits and resetting some of our internal processes to ensure that our work going forward is completed in timeframes that reflect the needs of the city. I'll briefly take you through each of our four major categories of work. And you'll see that I think that we've made solid progress in reducing the backlog of work. And our audit and public safety teams have produced a number of reviews that address important issues for the city. After that, and before I stop for questions, I'll speak briefly about how we're rethinking some of our internal operations to better serve the city. I'll start with investigations, so that managing our misconduct investigation caseload is one of our core functions, and it's a substantial part of our work. A core challenge for the OIG has been that over the last few years, the number of investigations pending for more than a year has substantially increased to the point where roughly three-quarters of our pending investigations have been pending for more than a year. That is not sustainable or acceptable, and there are a lot of challenges that flow from that. As a result, we've had a very strong focus on getting our older cases out the door and streamlining our processes going forward so that we don't recreate the situation that we found ourselves in. Looking at this slide, which covers Q2, you see the beginnings of some progress with a reduction in the number of pending cases. If you look at the next slide, if you look at the next slide, which covers the third quarter, and this is preliminary data through, I think, last Friday, you'll see the beginning of what I think is some real change. So the number of cases opened for more than 12 months fell by roughly 30 percent, which was meaningful progress. And we also completed 80 cases in that quarter, which is more than double the amount in the prior quarter. And we're on track. We're confident to continue that progress into the fourth quarter and beyond. With the audit and performance review work, the total number of products published in Q2 and Q3 of this year is equal to the highest number of reports published by the office in any year of its existence. So they, in this half year, the team that Darwin leads has completed and published as many reports as the office has ever completed in a single year. And we're on track. back to issue a number of others through the end of the year. We have been taking in the neighborhood of two years, sort of start to finish with audits. That's problematic in an organization that moves as fast as the city. And there's a strong recognition on our team that we are much more relevant when we are faster. And so we are making sure that we're getting kind of the backlog of work out the door and adjusting our processes so that as we move forward, we're working in real time. I'm not going to go through in detail any of the specific reports. We're happy to answer questions if you have any about those. But in the second quarter, we issued reports on the management of outstanding debt. COFA's operations and then metered water billing. And then next, turning to our public safety work, which is Tavares space, we published reports concerning the relief of police power practices at CPD, as well as the efforts by COPA to reduce its backlog of cases, and then two follow-up reports. The team also continued the ongoing work that it does on really a weekly basis to review new closed investigations from COPA and the Bureau of Internal Affairs and identify potential issues with those investigations and provide feedback to those teams. One thing that came out of that work in Q2 was a recommendation to CPD regarding enforcement of its rules requiring the reporting of misconduct. Another thing that I think is worth flagging is that the team also met with the independent monitor overseeing the police consent decree, in part to give them an opportunity to observe and discuss the procedures we use to review COPA and BIA investigations. And that was a very productive meeting. And then the last of our principal areas of work is hiring and employment compliance. This is probably the least attention-getting of our work, but it's really critical to continue monitoring city hiring practices and provide assurance with respect to compliance with standards. And you see numbers on this slide, but I think the kind of headline from this space is no significant issues in the past quarters. As we think about how we want the office to work going forward and what kind of at least operational priorities for our team are, it really is on making ourselves more efficient, impactful, and proactive. Efficiency have talked about in terms of making sure that our work is in real time, which makes it more meaningful. Impactful is important to the city that we be addressing issues that really matter for the city. So one of the things that we've been doing is a project to look across the city at essentially city enterprise risks and ensure that as we build out our audit program and we look at what we think about as auditable entities within the city, that our audit program has a strong relationship to where the city's risks are. We also are working to be more proactive in both our audit work and investigations, and part of that is making better use of the access that we have to the city's data. So we have access to virtually any data in the city. We've done a lot in terms of transparency through some of the dashboards that we've built. We have done less over the years in terms of analyzing that data and looking for potential issues. So one project that the team has undertaken recently, just by way of an example, is to build essentially a library of data red flags associated with common municipal fraud schemes, to identify places where we might be able to look in city data to see early indicators of problems. And we're looking at that work to try to identify places that we could prioritize and where we think the available data lines up with issues that are meaningful and our ability to do analysis that will lead to investigations and audit work. So those are a few of the things that we have been up to, but happy to take any questions. Great. Thank you, General. Appreciate it. I may ask one or two questions myself, one through the chair request. We are just a few weeks away from our budget hearings commencing. I believe they'll start sometime the week of October 19th. And as I believe has been past practice, I would just ask you and your team if ideally before October 19th, you can highlight any audits or reports that your office put out this year, the calendar year, that may have budget related relevance. So not necessarily process changes, but especially if they're positions that you've recommended be created or closed, anything along those lines in terms of expenditure changes, we would welcome a summary of that before we head into our budget season. One question I wanted to ask at the top and then I'll open up for committee members and the non-committee members involves your auditing of BIA and COPA investigations. I recall in a prior slide it mentioning that you all proactively audited 50 and found material deficiencies in 19 of those 50 investigations. Might someone be able to put a little bit more, share a little bit more information in terms of particular themes, if any, that were common across those 19 cases where there were material deficiencies? I can speak in generally, not necessarily to those specific 19. I would have to go back and look. But overall, we indicated that we looked at 300 plus investigations during that time period. Of those over 300, we looked at 50 of those open for more in-depth review. I see. And then out of those 50, I found 19 that contained material deficiencies. And then from those, we may issue recommendations to reopen. Once we receive a response from the entity and the investigation is closed, then we actually publish those to our website. And so just with regard to the question as far as common themes, and we have had an opportunity to speak with both COPA and BIA, even outside of the recommendations to reopen. But a lot of times, because we are trying to make sure that the investigations are thorough, complete, fair, and consistent when work is not shown, whether it's the final summary report, then it makes it hard for us to determine. We're having questions. We are looking at the entire investigative file, looking at the body-worn camera footage. And so where we make observations, that those observations are not captured in the reports, it then makes it a little difficult for us to determine whether they were actually taken into consideration and whether that information would have changed the outcome. So I would say that is one common overall theme. And then another common theme, which we again have already spoken with the investigative bodies, but would be that they are always going to do an analysis of credibility. And a lot of times they will indicate that they believe someone has lied or has in fact lied. And with regard to CPD rules for rule 14, which requires like the one there be a lie, but then also that it be willful. So we will see where they have identified a lie. But then there is no nothing to indicate whether there was a consideration with regard to whether that lie was a willful. So I will say those are like two overarching themes that we commonly see. Okay. Thank you. Opening up to committee member questions. Oh, Alderman Sposato. Thank you. Then Alderman Wagsbeck. Thank you, Chairman. Good morning, Inspector General and staff. Appreciate you coming out here today. Earlier slide, you had 243 complaints. Are those to be determined that they're valid complaints or are they already determined that they are valid complaints? You had a number 243 up there. So I know you said most of them in or 75 percent in a year or more. So so the the 243 figure was the number of investigations open at the beginning of Q3. So the so we receive way more complaints than we open investigations. I mean there's a big funnel. About 10 percent valid or something like that. About 10 percent valid or something like that. It's less than that. Less than that. OK. And a lot of what comes to us and gets logged as a complaint or an intake. It's a question about city services. It's something that's really an HR matter. So part of what we try to do is is where the question isn't suitable for us, get it to the right place. But these 243 were all things that the office opened as investigations. Many of them. Yeah, I don't know that I've got statistics on percentage of things that open as investigations that end up being sustained. But there those are all things that we have determined merit work by Georgia's team. Does that answer your question? I mean, just trying to get a handle on it. But can we go back to the hiring slide over there? Sure. The complaints you got on that. So I'm unsure how that goes, if you can help me with this. So complaint status, newly initiated, pending, closed, declined. So I'm more concerned about when somebody initiates a complaint. So what is a valid complaint? So if I apply for a job and I, in my mind, I think I'm the most qualified and somebody less qualified than me gets it and is a DEI hire, is that a valid complaint? So do we. Can that be a legitimate complaint? I say I got all these qualifications and somebody else you took less qualified for me and that's because you're trying to fill quotas. Is that a valid complaint or no? So this is the there's some nuances there that I would like to get back to you on. No, no problem. Because it I'm not trying to check your right out or anything. A. Our focus is very much on compliance with the city's hiring plan, and I would expect that the issue you describe is part of the city's hiring plan and that that is the sort of thing that we would consider within our jurisdiction. But the the the person who kind of directly oversees that work is not with us this morning. And I don't want to make it. And I know there's a big problem. I'm not knocking anybody here. So if people are listening, I'm not knocking you. I know there's a big problem like what fire hiring. And that's only because of the way they put the list together. So you get a number and you think your number is fifteen thousand. You're really fifteen hundred. And then you had a shot at it and you moved to Plainfield and you relocated. And then three years later, you're called to be a fireman. You're like, I would have never moved. But I know I was going to get called in three years. I'm willing to help them. I know they need some help. And I tell them all the time. I mean, people need to know what their real number is. You give them a fake number or BS number or whatever that number is, only to find out when you reorganize with that number, you have a different number. So I guess you get a lot of complaints about that. So, yeah, and I'm and I'm not asking to categorize them or anything like that. I'm just. Yeah, no, the the so the audit and performance review section recently released a study on the demographic impact of Chicago Fire Department hiring and promotion. And one of the things that they looked at was was exactly the dynamic that you talk about, where, you know, the most recent test was twenty twenty two. The city is still hiring off of that test. And this test has hardly been up for a while. It's only been a few years. So the fire department has a history of 10 year long tests or lists. I'm sorry. But but one of the things that they observed is that as you move through the process, and particularly when you get to the point where somebody's taken the test, obtained a passing score and becomes eligible for an invitation to to join, there's so much time may have passed that they may be at different points in their life and you lose a lot of people. Took me eight years, Inspector General. Some of them to Plainfield. Took a test in 85, got hired in 93. So but yeah, the the the report, which we're we're happy to talk about, if you have questions, goes into a lot of detail about the processes and the different steps in that process and the demographic implications of the way that the hiring process works. Well, it's a lot of draw hiring process. So that that's not a good not a good system. So that's just my opinion, because the test I took was based off of physical fitness qualifications. But all right. Yeah, I'm just appreciate you guys. All you're doing everything and appreciate you coming out today and best wishes to you the rest of the year and moving forward. Thank you. Thank you. Alderman Wagus back followed by Alderman O'Shea. Thank you, Chairman. Welcome, everyone. I just wanted to go back over a couple of the reports that came up here. And I've I read them, but some time ago, so I might forget a few things in them. But one was the catalyst fund and the other was the outstanding debt, both of which are. In my estimation, causing serious problems with our finances and the structural inefficiencies that we have seen over the last several years. So on the first one on the catalyst fund in the catalyst fund report, it states a few different things. We gave money to nine Chicagoans. We have non-voting advisory board membership that is defunct or not not working. You talked a little bit about what it would require to get these things up and running. And there was a response from the law firm that basically countered what you put in your report. But one of the things that you put in there was that if this catalyst fund cannot get things together, perhaps the fifty seven million dollars that's sitting in the account should go back to specific purposes within the city accounts or general municipal purposes. Could you talk a little bit about that? And maybe I mean, in my estimation, if we haven't done anything with it, it's been not been working at all or in the appropriate way that the city council should dissolve that. You know, and not create another one, but essentially. Could you just talk a little bit about what you did there? And sure. So and it's not it's not my office's place to recommend what you do. With that money. But I think that to some extent, this is kind of a fund that time forgot. Yeah, it was set up with the best of intentions there. And and it just never quite became what it's its sponsors and creators and the city council when it approved it intended. And since 2020, there has been no process for applying for loans from the fund. And and and as you might expect with a fund that really wasn't actively operating, some of the administrative processes around it fell off. I mean, there's no suggestion that the money disappeared or went places that it shouldn't, with with the exception of a relatively small number of loans that went to out of state people. Sorry, out of state, not just out of Chicago. Right. Made made made by the the city's third party contractor. But I think our our observation was that that the structure is not serving the function that it was created to serve. And, you know, there's a policy choice for the city to either kind of fix it or use the money for some other purposes. And my understanding is that the city treasurer has who is the chair of the catalyst fund entity has recommended that the city council dissolve the fund. Yeah. And I think that's a lot of my colleagues and I have also suggested that to put the fifty seven million back into the general fund or whatever are the purposes we need. But it doesn't make sense to let it sit there and not be utilized in the correct way and have these inefficiencies. So I appreciate you doing that report. That's it's a really important one. I think people who don't realize that you do audits for us, that's your task that somehow need to be educated on it. But this is very important one. Fifty seven million is a lot of money sitting there being wasted or inefficiently used. So the second one going to outstanding debt. So for a couple, three years now, we've been talking about this outstanding debt during budget season, over eight billion dollars in outstanding debt. You outlined it in the report. And. We we've seen issues with sister agencies, with employees not paying their debt. We've asked for municipal agreements or MOUs to get this payment system going. And I'm really not sure how far that's gone with this administration. But it's in the tens of millions of dollars. And it's pretty outrageous that we have sister city employees that just refuse to pay their bills. Those of us who are in office, we have to make sure that if there's a ticket or something that we have to pay it. Otherwise, you cannot perform your. So we've seen. We've seen some of those issues. functions. I don't know if we're going to get further into that with a future audit, but one of the things that's been also coming up on this backlog, and I think you broke it down really well. I think when we talked about this at the EY hearings last year, this is something I think we're really going to have to dive into a little bit more. So I just want to say thank you for providing this report, for giving us more information on what's really happening with DOF. But I wonder, you know, yesterday the mayor put out a press release talking about the backlog of PPLT and collecting the most ever from what I think is two city vendors from that backlog of PPLT taxes. It just came out yesterday, so I'm not sure if anybody's seen it. But I wonder if you could look into why we are looking at PPLT for the backlog on two city vendors when we have $8 billion in outstanding debt from everyone else and we're focused on two city vendors. I'm not really sure who they are, what they were alluding to, and why we're focused on that, but I'd like, if you, if you already know, that's great, but... So, no, I was going to say I don't know. The one point, and Darwin can certainly add additional information about the city debt because he led that work, but much of that $8 billion is aged. And the percentage of that that is actually collectible is difficult to determine and may not be especially high. And so, you know, I think as we look at issues and are prioritizing our own work, I mean, if we see the opportunity to recover a meaningful amount of money from the city, for the city, from a vendor or for any source, we're going to try and push to do that, even if it may not be the single biggest pot out there. I would just, you know, I was going to add that last year during the budget hearings, we saw this outstanding debt. And I understand it's aged and it goes back pretty far, decades. We've been told that we can't write that off and that it just sits on the books. And I think what we're seeing here is a discrepancy between what one side is saying, what another side in terms of financial policies are. It just seems absurd that we have to keep it on the books and say we have a billion or plus in outstanding debt that goes back decades. We're never going to collect it, but we're putting it on our books. I don't understand. That's a question of municipal accounting that I would encourage you to take up with the controller. One of the – We did. And that's the right place to take that question because he – you know, they have institutional expertise in this space that we don't. So I can't – I'm not going to sit and comment on the city's accounting practices. One – Go ahead. Maybe what you could weigh in on, maybe not today, but as we build up to the budget. So last year, we looked at this debt, and my colleagues and I tried to get – I think it was a few hundred million in debt collected. And what we got back from the budget director was we'll work with you guys on about $40 million out of the $8 billion. $40 million out of $8 billion. And it's pretty much a slap in the face from the administration that we're just not going to go collect from people who owe the city money. So the way I look at it is we're – we're just telling people it's okay if you have a red light camera ticket. Go ahead and keep running those red light cameras. Go ahead and park at the hydrants. Go ahead and speed or do all these things that are basically breaking the law. Become a scoff law, and the administration will forgive you because of whatever policy function the mayor thinks is necessary to put out there. How does that undermine government when you have people who are being told you don't have to worry about your debt, whether you're from a sister agency, whether you're just a resident or business out there? How does that affect government overall when you basically are saying we're not going to collect debt from anyone except maybe these two unknown entities that can't be shared with us from the PPLT? So I appreciate the question. It's pretty broad, I know. It is a little broad. And I also think that in looking at how the city is prioritizing debt collection, the devil is often in the details. And I don't know which $40 million they're prioritizing. There are, I think, fair – it is a topic that is fair for discussion, but I'm in no position with the information that I have sitting here to agree or disagree with your characterization of the city's efforts to collect. Debt collection is good, but you also have to prioritize it and be realistic about the costs and benefits of collection. Yeah, and looking back again at the aged debt, I understand that part of it. Prioritizing that is very important. And I almost agree, if it's too long ago, if those persons are gone, if they're deceased or out of the country or out of the state, probably never going to get it. So wipe it off the books. I think my problem is we've built up a couple billion just over the last three years. And I just find it unfathomable that when somebody gets ticketed in administrative hearings and they get a $1,000 ticket for maybe an illegal billboard or something – and this goes back years. Alderman Riley and I used to push on this. Somebody would rack up $10,000 in administrative hearing fines, and first of all, they'd get them knocked down by three quarters maybe, maybe pay $1,000, but then nobody collects on it. So I think what I'm trying to figure out is why aren't we collecting the new debt where we know people are here, where we know where they are, where we have agencies that refuse to follow through on our request for making those payments. And we're talking about CPS, CHA, CTA, MWRD, I believe, in your report, and a few others. That's where I'm having – I'm struggling as a professional where we look at this stuff over and over again. You put it in your report, and we just have no effort whatsoever by the mayor to basically say, yeah, I'm going to follow through with this. Instead, we get the hand in the face that says, don't touch people because that's just my new policy. So for me, it just undermines government, and we've had enough of that, I think, over the last three years. And it just – I think your report, for me, just really lays out the problem very well. But I guess it's up to us to really follow through with that. That is to say, I just appreciate the report, and hopefully we can follow through with it. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you. Alderman O'Shea. Thank you, Chairman. Good morning, David. Good morning. Good morning, David. Good morning, David. I'll defer to George, but my strong hope is that those are resolved by the end of the year because it's been a while since we've opened them. I think virtually all of those are aged at this point. The vast majority of those 50, the investigative work is done, and we're at the stage where we are doing the analysis and writing up the memos. George, how many did we have total going back the past six years, five years, whatever? I don't have a specific number, but it was over 100 for sure. And how many departments do we think that covered? I'd have to get back to you on that. Okay. I want to switch gears here and talk about City of Chicago employees' timekeeping systems. We have a ballpark of about 35,000 city employees. Roughly. I think the number that I'd seen was about 33. And I know the OIG has investigated much of this. I've been a proponent of every department, every ward office. Should have a time clock. Is that something you agree with? And what have you uncovered? So actually, it's a very timely question because Darwin's team is. Not as long as Wagusbeck's question. So there are some things I'm just not going to comment on. But but Darwin's team is is finishing up a review of the timekeeping practices in the city and in particular, the swiping practices, which I think will inform discussion and policymaking about that. And Darwin, anything you want to add? Yeah, actually, a few years ago, we did a an audit of committee spending. And in that we talked about timekeeping. And the recommendation was to basically follow the city policy of having time clocks in all ward offices. And there was a commitment to do that if memory serves at that time. And I believe the only department that. The only committee that did that was finance. Not sure. Yeah. I want to switch gears again and talk about. A little bit about what my colleague, Alderman Wagusbeck, talked about outstanding debt to the city. Do we have any ongoing investigations right now as far as city employees who owe any outstanding debt or sister agencies that owe outstanding debt? So I think the I don't know that we open investigations simply because someone owes debt. Am I? I think that's a fair characterization. I'm not familiar, and I don't believe we have any cases open right now that specifically address a nonpayment of. I mean, we're I don't think we've generally viewed ourselves as a debt collection agency for the city. And and and people can fail to pay debts for a whole variety of reasons that may not be misconduct as within the city rules. OK, thank you. Any other questions from committee members or noncommittee members? Seeing none, general deputy, your team, thank you so much for coming. We are going to transition to the second and final item on today's agenda, a subject matter hearing on the communications and advertising practices of World Business Chicago. As committee members know, I received a request from nine of you several weeks ago to hold a subject matter hearing on this topic. Given our upcoming fall budget hearings and the uncertainty of committee schedules around that, I committed to holding this hearing in the month of October, which began today. World Business Chicago received an invite from me to attend this hearing, as well as if this hearing would not work, attend a future date in the month of October. And asked specifically for them to provide alternative dates. If this did not work, World Business declined to attend today's hearing or to provide alternative dates. Instead, the organization submitted a short written statement, which has been sent out to committee members via email. I will open up the floor to comments, perhaps not questions, unless they're rhetorical. Orderwoman Nugent. Thank you, Chair Martin. Thank you for agreeing to talk to them. There we go. Good morning. Thank you, Chair Martin. And thank you for calling this meeting today. As you can see, there's nobody from World Business Chicago here. And in the letter that myself and seven other colleagues signed, so eight of the 13 members of this committee, asking for World Business Chicago to present themselves, I just want to read one line because I think it's relevant. Quote, we respectfully request that the committee convene a subject matter hearing and invite representatives of World Business Chicago, the mayor's office, relevant city departments, and any outside vendors involved in developing or disseminating the communications at issue. End quote. Quote, as you can see, apparently none of the aforementioned believe that there is any validity to the letter we sent or any merit because nobody has has come. I am not surprised. I am disappointed. And I read the letter that World Business Chicago sent to the chair that was shared with all of us several times. And I'm not particularly pleased with that either. In their statement, you know, just so folks that are here know, you know, they did say that they are a non-profit public-private organization. They do receive funding from the city, the state, and from businesses. And in their very brief statement that they shared with the chairman said that no public funds were used in the advertisement that we've called into question. Well, I'd like to ask them questions about that. I didn't know that they bifurcate their funds or that they set their funds up in such a way that would divide it up. And so I am disappointed. And quite frankly, they do receive money from the city and from my colleagues and I. And I'm prepared to not give them more funding until I hear from them. And so I just want to thank you, chair, for convening this and inviting them and let it be known publicly. I'm quite disappointed in World Business Chicago for not being here. Thank you, chairman. Thank you, Alderwoman. I do want to note that in addition to committee members that representatives from the state, specifically State Representative Curtis Tarver, is also looking into this issue. We will remain in touch with him to see if there might be opportunities for continued conversation and collaboration. Any others? Alderman Wagesback, Alderwoman Lee, did you have a hand? And then followed by Alderman Dias. Thanks, chairman. Just very quickly. So over the last several years, World Business Chicago has received roughly $1.6 million per year from the city of Chicago. And in some years, it's been much higher. Over the period that they've received funds, I think it's in the tens of millions. And that's just from the city alone. So if you include the state, it is a very substantial amount of public funds. And I think that what we saw with the issue that we're dealing with here, which is campaigning using city funds, WB, it's simple, should be beholden to the same rules that those of us in this council are held to and that the inspector general holds us to over many years and even in the past year. So I just hope that they commit to coming to this council to explain and show us how they're appropriating the funds that taxpayers are giving them and that they need to make sure in the future never to utilize public funds for political purposes like they did in the recent video. So thank you very much, chairman. Thank you. Alderwoman Lee. Thank you, chairman. I'll just echo all of the sentiments from my colleagues. I'm really disappointed that nobody from World Business Chicago showed up today to talk to us about how they're using funds that they get from the city as well as other entities for political purposes, very seemingly for political purposes. I would have loved to be able to ask what the track record of World Business Chicago is in terms of advertising. How much have you spent on advertising in the past? What were you advertising if it was strictly about boosting Chicago? How often did sitting mayors fall into that category of featuring? So I'm disappointed that we were not able to have that conversation today. I'm hopeful that they will come before us at a later time because I think there are a lot of questions that need to be answered for all of us that sit on this committee and for the council as well as on behalf of the people of the city of Chicago. Thank you. Thank you, Alderman Vegas. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. You know, it's very apparent that a campaign that is unable to raise dollars is attempting to utilize public dollars in order to up their campaign. You know, 2015, 2.5 million to World Business Chicago, 2016, 1.5, 2017, 1.5, totaling from 2015 to 26, 21.7 million dollars. Mr. Chairman, when you do send – when you do get a response from WBC, could they provide a list of all past commercials that WBC has done with previous administrations to highlight the world to the city of Chicago? And, Inspector General, I'm glad you stayed here because I was hoping that you were going to stay here. Have you had an opportunity – can we ask you a couple of questions regarding this as to what you're going to do here, if anything? If you can come up, that would be great. Welcome to – I was wrestling with the – I was wrestling with the – I was wrestling with the – Question of whether whether to stay. So but but all over in Vegas, I think. So. So first, the the rules that the OIG. Well, first, Mr. Inspector General, have you seen the commercials? Have you seen. I have. I've not seen them. I've spoken to people who have reviewed them and I've read descriptions of them. The. So. I can't comment on anything that we we may or may not investigate that that just wouldn't be appropriate for us. But I think is is the committee and the council thinks about this issue. I would encourage you to look at the city's ethics ordinance, which which is quite explicit about what constitutes political. Activity. And think about whether the whether what you see in those commercials meets the the test under the ethics ordinance. And and. You know, also think about to what extent this is an issue of sort of judgment as opposed to a rule violation. You know, the the there can be things that are. There can be things that that may not be a clear violation of a rule, but but which you may from a policy perspective disagree with. And. And, you know, those are those can be different things, but I really I don't think there's much beyond. Those comments that I could get here. All right. Well, I just find the timing of it and I understand that you're saying that you think it's subjective, but. You haven't seen it personally. I've not seen it personally. Right. So. Point of information. Yeah. That's all. I mean, Nugent. Should we watch it? Can we watch it now so you can get a sense? I'd be wonderful. So I'm I'm not going to comment on anything that that I watch here that just they wouldn't be appropriate for me. Could you just watch the commercial so that way you could think about it as you're. I think, you know, as you're. We can put a request through the chair for that. That's. Yeah. Well, could you watch it and then through request through the chair, provide comment on it, give you a time to digest it? I could watch it, but I think it is unlikely that I would be able to provide any useful comment. But I'm I'm I'm happy to consider that. All right. Well, again, I just think the timing of it raises question, especially when you have an organization that's charged with promoting the city to the world. And it's sitting here promoting the city to the city. And at a time right before an election, at a time when the mayor's campaign has been able to raise money, utilizing public dollars to promote himself, I think is wrong. And I hope that at some point, World Business Chicago is here to defend their comments, because, as President Pro Temp mentioned, we should be taking a look at zeroing them out, especially when you have a department that's not even you have an agency that's receives public dollars, not even coming to discuss in a public forum. Why they're doing these types of things, and it's never been done before, unless they can produce all these commercials from 2015 to 2025, showing that in previous years that mayors have have spoke to Chicago about about Chicago and what it's done versus speaking to the world. World Business Chicago is the marketing arm for the city to promote globally. I don't think it was not intended to promote to the north side, the south side, east side. As a commercial, hopefully you get to see states. I think that hopefully your department looks into this, because this is very blatant. And also taking a look at all the signs that have popped up on vehicles all of a sudden around around the mayor's name on all vehicles. Again, this is just a campaign that just can't raise money and utilizing public assets to promote itself. So thank you, Inspector General. I hope that you get a chance to to watch that. Watch those commercials. They're pretty entertaining. Thank you. Any other questions? Oh, Alderman Lagos back. Well, actually, Inspector General. Sorry. Just to add to that. So in years past, the Inspector General has made requests to elected officials to remove social media posts or other things similar to social media or mailers or things like that, where they've been told you can't use a city logo. Even in the background, you can't use a city facility, like a fire station or a police station in the background. A historic picture. What would or sorry? A historic picture. A historic picture. Basically, you've got to stand in a white room and kind of put stuff up. But what would be the turnaround time for, I don't know, if it's an audit or of that type of situation or a investigation? So I appreciate the question. I understand the concern. But I don't think that I can commit one way or another to will we open an investigation of this specific issue? And if so, what the turnaround time would be? We try to be very thoughtful about the matters that we look into. We have limited resources. We try to put them where we think they're most impactful. We are very sensitive to election-related misconduct issues. But beyond that, I just am not comfortable going here. Would all those reports be on the OIG website or Board of Ethics? Which reports? If an alderman in the past had a firetruck behind them, would that report be on the OIG advisory or would it be on the Board of Ethics? So the OIG website goes back quite a long way. And how far? Board of Ethics. Probably. I'm not sure where that particular thing would sit. I think we'll just wait whenever you are able to review and get back to us. We'll wait for that. Thank you. Alderman Vasquez. Thank you, General. And I apologize if this has been asked. So you've got – how far back would you say kind of the reporting goes related to the number of mayors or terms? Mayors are probably more specific because they do more than one term. What sort of reporting? Like how many mayors back do you go in reporting? How far back does our website go? 2012. 2012. Okay. So if the question either through the chair would be how many times have there been investigations related to the matter at hand throughout that time as a way to kind of compare? I think that's kind of – I'm curious because I know it's being brought up now related to the ads that were here. And in looking at it, it appears to me they're talking – and, again, I know you can't speak on all this – they're talking about things that the city has done, which is different than positioning themselves in public buildings and such. So I'm just curious of, like, all the different mayors, how many different investigations there might have been on similar matters. So I think it would be not a complicated project and something that might be interesting to do if you would find it useful. We could pull publicly reported incidents relating to election misconduct and provide those. I mean, I think there'd be – apart from whatever value that may be to you in kind of thinking about the incident under discussion today, I think it could be a helpful sort of resource for people thinking about how to navigate election-related issues going forward. Because I think the context would be important to have an understanding of what all different instances might have triggered something like that if there is, at that point, like, video of what those are to compare it in a way that might be informative for this body going forward if there wanted to be more specificity on what would be allowed or wouldn't. So just two points. One, what we would have available through the website would be published reports of sustained violations. And we'd also, I think, have to think through what's with the Board of Ethics and what's with us. I don't know how far back Board of Ethics reporting goes. And then – so it wouldn't include investigations that don't result in – And sustained findings. And then the other thing is, is that our website would have the text of reports that there's not going to be video associated with those. And I apologize to kind of go along the same route. The way it plays out in real life, right, is there'll be perhaps an investigation and then whether sustained or not, there might be associated headlines with something that occurred, like in the current moment. Right. The ads drop. There's a concern raised by people. Is that anything you would have as a reference point in like in the past? Should there have been any of those kind of either investigations or sustained findings? So the question is, should do we have a way of figuring out whether there were incidents we should have looked at but didn't? Or headlines related to things you looked at. So even though you couldn't share the investigation or how they came, it's like, oh, that actually the public did discuss this around the time, even though there was sustained or not. If there's if there's if there's any level of reference list, I guess. Yeah, I don't think we could do that. OK. Part partly because everybody else has the same access to that information that we do. Yeah. I think we can we can we can usefully identify our activity in the election related space. Sure. I don't. But but doing like a Google search for for headlines about or if there was campaign controversies, controversies, controversies, not our mission. And totally. You guys can do it as well as we can. Or if there was like a press or independent bodies like the Better Government Association, for example, to be able to put it. The reason why I ask that is. I think there sometimes we get in one situation without looking at the whole context, and I'd be pretty confident that the dailies might have had commercials about what Chicago did during their time that might not have been considered the same way things are now. But it's a good conversation to have in case we do want to change what those rules are going forward. Well, and remember, our Web site goes back to 2012. Yeah. So I just meant like to your point about the press or somebody else, somebody could go further back than the portal would and kind of, hey, look, this is what was the standard. This is what we're looking at now. Do we want to change government in a way or have better guidelines to be more instructive on what can or can't happen with a mayor and the way to do ads? Sure. Sure. It's a good conversation to start now, but also to take into account what's happened before is important is my take on it, at least. Yeah. No. And I think I mean, one one other I mean, this is this getting a little bit of field from what you're focused on. But but but there are certain types of campaign finance violations that we see on a recurring basis and kind of being able to flag in a collected way. Like what are what are issues that people often trip over could be useful? Yeah. No, I appreciate that. That's all the question. Thank you. Anyone else have questions? OK, there being no further business for before the committee. Can I go to motion to adjourn? Alderman Lee, so moves all those in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. All those opposed in the opinion of the chair, the eyes have it. The meeting is adjourned. Thank you, general and team for sticking with us. Have a good rest of the day, everybody. I already have.