Thank you, Charlie. Yeah, you're just going to hold the door and then you just go ahead and to her. That's true. Let me explain what the change is. Let's see, let me see. Vice Chair, how are you sir? I'm doing all right. Doing all right. Is there anyone we need from next door? I'm going to need all the members from over there. Whoever is over there, I know Rosanna is over there. Yes. Yes, I will say. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Good afternoon. The Committee on Contracts, Oversight, and Equity will now come to order. We will first have a roll call to establish a quorum. Jamel, give us a roll call. Chairman Lispada. Vice Chairman Lispada. Alderman Dow. Alderman Harris. Alderman Ramirez. Alderman Coleman. Alderman Taylor. Alderman Burnett. Alderman. Alderman Irvin. Alderman Shelley O'Pero. Alderman Villegas. Alderman Nugent. Alderman Gardner. And Alderman Mitts is present. Seven. We have seven members present. We have a quorum. Now we have our public comment period. Each member will be given three minutes. Starting with our first member. Nora. Nora. Nora Rowley. Nora Rowley. Hello. My name is Nora Rowley. I live in Rogers Park. I am a physician, retired. And I also have a master of public health, where I concentrated in human rights and humanitarian work. I'm very concerned about the immigration. What's not immigration enforcement. It's ethnic cleansing. What's going on. And I'm urging, I'm here to urge all members to vote for the Immigration Enforcement Disclosure Ordinance. And this ordinance will require any company contracting with the city to disclose whether it is also profited from immigration enforcement work, including contracts with ICE and Border Patrol. What's happening in our country is atrocious. It would be, it is the third genocide is happening in our country. And just over the last five days, it's been disclosed that 16,000 people have disappeared from the immigration website for people that are in removal proceedings. So, their names aren't down there. So, it's not even clear where they are. So, they've been disappeared. This cannot stand and we cannot do, and this is not prohibiting business, but the disclosure of business, I think, is citizens of a civil society. We need to know what our city is doing business with, what companies. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Joanna Redman. Raymond. Good afternoon. I'm an attorney and I live and work in Chicago. I'm also a rapid responder and I'm here on behalf of Indivisible along with Illinois Fighters Against Fascist Overreach, which advocates for holding accountable federal immigration officials and those who collaborate with them. One year ago, we were in the middle of Midway Blitz. Federal immigration agents were terrorizing the residents of this city. And it was the people of this city who resisted. It's now one year later, and we need our elected officials to act. The police department failed to protect us. They refused to take complaints. They refused to investigate. And later, they said they couldn't investigate because they had no complaints. State's attorney, Eileen Burke, has failed us. She won't investigate. She won't prosecute. She won't even review the evidence produced by the Illinois Accountability Commission. The city council has a host of bills sitting on its docket, but little has been done so far. Today, you have the opportunity to do what most elected officials in this city lack the courage to do, which is to take real action. Not words, not platitudes, not press conferences, but real action. And in truth, the Immigration Enforcement Disclosure Ordinance is very modest. It requires only disclosure, unlike other cities that require cancellation of contracts. Moreover, it applies only to contracts entered into in 2027 or later. Contractors need only say whether they have contracted with ICE or Border Patrol, the dollar amount, and the term of the contract. That's it. It doesn't even require applicants to disclose anything. Any contractor who has the time and resources to go through the city contracting process should not be heard to say that it's too difficult to state whether they have a contract with ICE or Border Patrol, how much it's worth, and for how long. Today, you have a choice to stand with the people or to stand with federal immigration officials, their sympathizers, and those who would profit off the terror they've brought. Today's vote, simply requiring disclosure in future contracts, should be an easy one. We ask you to stand on the right side of history and vote the Immigration Enforcement Disclosure Ordinance out of committee so it can be voted on tomorrow by the full city council. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you for your time. Jackie Gallo. Jackie Gallo. Good afternoon. My name is Jackie Gallo. I'm our Senior Director of Programs at Revolution Workshop. My comments today are on behalf of both myself and our organization. For those that aren't familiar, Revolution Workshop is a nonprofit that started eight years ago. We offer free training programs in East Garfield Park and in Roseland to help people of color and women get into the construction industry. But not just get a job in construction. More importantly, we're trying to help folks build careers and build wealth for themselves and their families. Thank you. Of the over 800 people we've served, 75% identify as Black, 20% as Latinx, 22% as female. I know firsthand what construction jobs can do for families because it's what helped my family. There are jobs that built the middle class, but too often only a select few have access to. And this is at a time when we have a skilled worker shortage and need more people to join the trades than ever. But not only do we need them to join, we need them to stay. I want to illustrate some of the challenges that our folks experience with the story. We had an alumni who was one of our best, who was super smart, level-headed, laser-focused on his goals. He wanted to be a plumber. He started with the plumbing company, and on his first day, his superintendent, so the head person in charge on his job site, said, I want to call you the N-word, but for today I'll just call you your name. But he said the N-word. I'm not going to. I don't know. Not knowing that this happened, the call that I got from the employer was, hey, your guy walked off the job site in the middle of the day. So the subtext of that was, I tried this community hiring thing, and he was unreliable. Luckily, we had a whole community of partners around us. And so we reported this to other community partners, to other contractors, to developers, and they stepped up to hold that plumbing sub accountable. If not for them, the employer's narrative around, hey, I tried to hire a black man from the community and he was unreliable may have been the prevailing narrative. But because they were willing to step up, they got held accountable. Those developers said, we're not going to hire you for another project until we get a plan of how you're going to fix this, and we're going to hold you accountable to that plan. We relied on their bravery, their willingness to hold someone accountable, even if it hurt their bottom line. And we relied on the trust we had built with those companies, partners, and alumni over time. But this is where we need help. We need the city's help as a developer and influencer of our projects in the city. We need real oversight about what's happening on projects in our communities, and we need real accountability when things don't change. We were lucky to have partnerships that allowed accountability to be possible, but we can't rely on luck as a strategy. With the advisory group proposing our ordinance, this collaboration between CBOs, developers, unions, and contractors could become a structural solution rather than a privileged opportunity. There are far too many stories like this, and for too long, we've allowed people to push paper rather than push for real solutions. Important stuff to change that. Thank you. Thank you for your comment. Let me recognize Alderman David Moore and Alderman Stephanie Coleman for the purpose of a quorum. And also we have Rosanna Rarilla-Sanchez, non-member. And Chairman, you have Alderman Gardner on as well via Zoom. Chairman, you have Alderman Mitchell as well. So we have Alderman Gardner and Alderman Mitchell. So with Rule 59, can we get a motion to accept so moved by Alderman Taylor? All in favor, signify by saying aye. Opposed and depending on the chairs, the ayes have it. Thank you. Thank you. Also joining us now for the purpose of the quorum is Alderman Chris Talaferro. Next speaker is Wendy Pollack. Good afternoon. My name is Wendy Pollack. I'm a former union carpenter and a founding member of Chicago Women Carpenters, which evolved into Chicago Women in Trades as more women enter the various construction industry trades. Today, I'm asking you for your support for the Chicago Construction Workforce Equity Ordinance. This ordinance will go a long way in countering the federal government's evisceration of the rights and opportunities that all women and black and brown workers have relied on for decades to obtain and retain high-wage jobs in the construction industry. It cannot be overestimated the vital role of the federal executive order 11246 and its implementing rules and goals and the monitoring and enforcement by the Federal Office of Contract Compliance Programs have played since 1965 in ensuring that women and people of color have a fair shot at being hired and retained in the construction industry. I know from my own experience as a tradeswoman, I would not have been hired, let alone retained, if it were not for those federal mandates and vigorous enforcement. Unfortunately, this remains true for many of those actively pursuing careers in the construction industry today. But the federal government has rescinded the executive order and its implementing rules and goals, terminated the federal employees whose job it was to monitor and enforce compliance, and has dismantled the Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs. We cannot allow the construction industry in Chicago to go backwards in terms of hiring and retention of women and black and brown workers. And we cannot rely on just the McLaughlin Ordinance. I was part of the coalition that advocated for and won the McLaughlin Ordinance. The McLaughlin Ordinance offers financial incentives to construction contractors for hiring women and people of color. However, the ordinance has never lived up to our hopes and expectations, and without more, is unlikely to do so in the future. If enacted, the Chicago Construction Workforce Equity Ordinance can play an essential role in making sure Chicago not just falls behind, but moves forward in its hiring and retention practices in the construction industry. Please support this ordinance. Thank you. Thank you very much for your comment. Next speaker, Karen Freeman Wilson. Good afternoon, Madam Chair and members of the committee. I appreciate the opportunity to address you on the Chicago Workforce Equity Ordinance on behalf of the Chicago Urban League. For the last 110 years, the Chicago Urban League has been engaged in helping black people and other underserved communities find a place in this community. Part and parcel of finding a place is to be gainfully employed, to have a career that will allow you to raise a family, to also gain housing and sometimes own a home, and to build a business in this community. This ordinance speaks to all of those opportunities, but it also speaks to what we have seen over the last 110 years, that the opportunity in the building trades is not always accessible to women, and particularly black women. Through this ordinance, there is an opportunity not only to ensure that access, but also to track what needs to be done when that access is not granted. And so we stand in full support of this and also offer our support and help into making what is written and promised on paper a reality in the practice as we are out here building this community for everyone to enjoy. Thank you for the opportunity. Thank you. Thank you for your comment. Our next speaker is Mr. George Blakemore. Mr. Blakemore speaks very eloquently. Illegal immigrants coming to America, we know nothing about them. No background check. If you bring a fish from Asia, Asian car, agriculture will not allow them to come in here to compete with the native fish in Lake Michigan. You can't bring a plant in, but I'm going through immigration and naturalization. Something is wrong here. And this committee, they have only 3% of the contracts in the midst went to black people. I'm talking about American black people, enslaved in America. How could you do this, you black altamines, to vote for another person, another people, illegal, to come in and to compete with you for jobs, your people, service, contracts, and jobs? How could you do that, Emma Mitch? And they're going to gentrify you out of your ward. They're placing most of these illegal immigrants into the black wards. How could you? Why would you do this, Tala Farah? Jeanette, why would you do this, Ms. Taylor and Mr. Moore? Why, when we only get 3% of the contracts, blacks, three American blacks born here and saved here, why would you do this? What motivated you to do this? Perhaps it was money, honey. Perhaps it was money, honey. And all of you are Democrats, are one-party sisters. Why would you do this? And you black people only receive 3% of the contract. Why are you worried about this? For we need this money, honey. We need this money, honey. Only 3%, 3% of the contract go to black Americans enslaved in this country. Something is evil here. Something is un-American here. And big-head Trump is not here. Big-head Trump is not here. It's something evil here. Only black Americans here in the city of Chicago only got 3% of the contracts. And you advocating for other people to come get jobs, goods, and contracts that your people have not received. The Urban League, the NAACP put... Mr. Blackmore, you're talking with food in your mouth. Slow down. It's something evil and wrong with black leadership. No leadership! No leadership! Thank you for your comments. Next speaker is Carrie Shaw. My name is Carrie Shaw. I'm a union laborer, and I'm a part of Chicago Women in Trade. Looking for a job is a full-time job in itself. Women are willing to work, qualified to work, and ready to work. But too often, we are not getting the same opportunities to get through the door. I am asking the city of Chicago to do more than set goals on paper. I am asking the city to look at who is actually getting the jobs and contracts, who is being given opportunities to participate, and where women, particularly women of color, are still being left out. And the city... I mean, if the city is serious about workforce equity, then we need accountability. We need measurable results and real opportunities for women to enter, work, and advance in Chicago's construction industry. We should not have to work twice as hard just to be given an opportunity to work. Thank you very much. Great comment. The next speaker is Noelle Clennan. Hi, thank you. My name is Noelle Clennan. I'm a resident of the 47th Ward, the Secretary of Indivisible Lincoln Square. And a member of Illinois Fighters Against Fascist Overreach. And I'm here to ask for your support for the Immigration Enforcement Disclosure Ordinance. If we are to truly call ourselves a welcoming city, we should know, we should demand, transparency and accountability from everyone who is a part of city government, including our contractors. If we are to be a welcoming city and to truly be one, not just call ourselves one, we should avoid patronizing businesses that are doing ICE and Border Patrol's bidding when we have other options. If we are truly to be a welcoming city, we should avoid giving access to city systems and data to contractors who also work with ICE and Border Patrol. And I recognize that there are rules against them accessing that information and sharing it. But these days, I don't know that those rules make me feel particularly confident that that's not going to happen. I also just want to make one comment about the language in the existing ordinance and a request that the chief procurement officer, should this ordinance get approved and enforced, that the chief procurement officer create rules to define what we mean by related to civil immigration enforcement. I think saying that the contractors only need to disclose contracts that are related to civil immigration enforcement creates a huge opportunity for a major loophole. It creates the opportunity to say, oh, well, I was just providing telecommunications services. I wasn't doing civil immigration enforcement. That's not what the contract was. I was only providing access to data. I wasn't doing civil immigration enforcement. I was only providing access to AI that helps you use all the data you bought from everybody else to target people. I wasn't doing civil immigration enforcement. So my request would simply be that we make sure that it is very clear what we mean because if the contractors use that somewhat vague and ambiguous language as a loophole, we will never know. We will never know. Because all we can do is try to do research, but for the most part, these contracts are not public information and not things we can find out on our own that is the whole purpose of this ordinance. And if we leave this loophole in there, we will not be accomplishing what we want to with this ordinance. Thank you for your time. Thank you. Thank you very much. Our last and final speaker is Wendy Siegel. Good afternoon. My name is Wendy Siegel. I am here representing Indivisible Lincoln Square, which is also affiliated with chapters all around the city that have been working on this issue. We're here today to ask this committee to vote for the Immigration Enforcement Disclosure Ordinance and to vote it out of committee and send it to the full council for passage. We believe companies that do business with Chicago should disclose any contracts that they have to conduct or support ICE enforcement activities. Working with Indivisible Chapters across the city, we have focused and will continue to focus our advocacy on passing laws that strengthen Chicago's ability to collect and analyze data on ICE and DHS immigration enforcement activities across all departments. This matters because so far, too little has been done to rein in ICE's disruptive, aggressive, and inhumane actions against members of our community. One reason is that reliable data has been difficult to obtain and analysis of enforcement trends has been lacking. The mayor has issued several executive orders intended to address ICE activity, but the city council must ensure those orders are fully implemented and that reliable information is available to support sound decision-making. Passing the Immigration Enforcement Disclosure Ordinance would be an important first step. Please vote yes today and send the ordinance to the full council. Thank you. Thank you. There be no further speakers. The public comment period is closed. I'd like to thank everyone who addressed the committee today and for all of those who came down. I'd like to add Auderman Basquez as non-member for participation. First item on the agenda today is the approval of the committee monthly rule 45 report for May, June, July, and August 2026. Can I get a motion? So moved by Vice Chair Laspato. All in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. And you know the chairs, the ayes have it. We're going to go out of order of business for one minute. We'll go to Auderman Laspato until we get Auderman Villegas over. Auderman Laspato has an ordinance. Item number 02025-0021-035, an amendment of the Municipal Code Chapter 2-92 by adding a new Section 2-92-587 entitled Immigration Enforcement. Before we accept this item, we have a substitute ordinance that's before us. Can I get a motion to accept the substitute ordinance so moved by Auderman Irving and also adding Auderman Irving for the purpose of a quorum? Yeah. Thank you. The chair now recognizes Auderman Vaischer Laspato. Thank you very much, Chairwoman Mitz. I'm grateful for the room here. I'm grateful for our residents who very righteously have pressed the point on this. I'm really grateful for DPS, for the law department, for working through the issues and helping us come forward with a substitute that both in word and letter and spirit lives into the issue that we're talking about today. There's not more that I can say that hasn't been said about the impact of ICE on the city of Chicago. And I believe at the end of the day that disclosure leads to transparency. Transparency leads to accountability. And that is what is at the heart of the ordinance that we're talking about today. It doesn't void contracts. It doesn't void the issue of the city of Chicago. It doesn't void the issue of the city of Chicago. It doesn't void the issue of the city of Chicago. It doesn't void the issue of the city of Chicago. It doesn't void the issue of the city of Chicago. Thank you. It doesn't cancel contracts. It doesn't restrict them. Whether it should is a conversation for another day. What it does do is require those who are contracting with the city of Chicago to provide an affidavit showing how in the present or past they have also contracted with agencies doing civil immigration enforcement. It allows counsel to be more informed because these affidavits will then be publicly accessible to the public. It allows you to be informed, to hold us accountable, to hold those agencies and contractors accountable. It is cost neutral and information positive. And so on these grounds, I'm glad for questions from my colleagues, but I would ask favorable consideration. Honorable Spotted, just give us a little summary of the change from the original to the substitute, will you please? Great question, Chair. So it allows for some very specific, and I would say niche carve-outs as asked by the administration. So, for instance, if there are emergency orders need to be placed in a crisis, it allows that affidavit not to be waived, but to be provided within 120 days of the issuance of the contract. Similarly, for the small orders process, contracts under $250,000, it allows those affidavits to be provided within 30 days of the contract. It also allows, in cases where the federal government says this information cannot be disclosed or is confidential, the contractor can say this information is confidential or we have been asked to disclose it. How that is then read by the public and by counsel is another matter, but it does allow, as requested by the Department of Law, for the reasons for that confidentiality to be listed in the affidavit. Right. Thank you. We wanted to welcome, who is it, came in? Oh, Alderman Ramirez, Julie. Julie Ramirez for the purpose of QWAM and Chairman Villegas as well. Now, let me go back once again to accept the substitute ordinance. All in favor of accepting the substitute? Aye. Aye. We got a motion by Laspato. Laspato, so move. Now, all in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. Opposed? And you may be chair as the ayes have it. Are there any other questions for committee members on this particular item? No questions? It's a good sign. All right. Let's get a motion then. There's no question. Can I get a motion to approve? So move by Alderman Taylor. All in favor? Signify by saying aye. Aye. Opposed? In the opinion of the chair as the ayes have it. But congratulations, Alderman Laspato. Just like that. Our next item will be item number 02026-0024839, directing the Commissioner of the Department of Planning and Development and Department of Housing to engage, encourage a goal of 3% veteran-owned business. Alderman's enterprise participating in each city financing discretionary approval that include MBE, WBE participation goal, Alderman Villegas. The chair recognizes Alderman Villegas. Thank you, Madam Chair and members of the committee. Before you, you also have a substitute ordinance. Yes, ma'am. So before we go into, can I get a, we have a substitute? Don't move. Alderman Teller-Ferro moves that we accept the substitute. All in favor? Signify by saying aye. Opposed? And the opinion of the chairs, the ayes have it. Now the substitute ordinance is before us. Alderman Villegas. Thank you, Madam Chair and members of the committee. This is an ordinance that continues to build upon the actions that this city council has been working on for over seven years. We provided two types of pilot programs, each lasting three years, and then this year we were able to finally codify it into the city law that there would be 3% VBE goals on projects. However, what we saw throughout the passage is that it did not require the 3% goal to be assigned to Department of Housing as well as Department of Planning projects. And so what this ordinance does is just expand it into the Department of Housing, Department of Planning to ensure that veteran-owned businesses have an opportunity to participate on procurement projects and open for questions and would seek approval on this matter. Dr. Alderman Talaferro. Thank you, Madam Chair. Chairman Villegas, I just want to take this opportunity to just say thank you for the continued push and work that you do on behalf of the veterans. And I have really seen over the last several years that you're having a concentrated effort on making sure our veterans in the city of Chicago are represented, not only in contracting efforts, but in equity and resources. So keep up the great work, and I certainly support this ordinance. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Alderman Maris. Talk about true multitasking. We have the chairperson of the zoning committee that is currently happening. So thank you so much for joining us. And then I just want to reiterate with what Alderman Talaferro said. You know, when I have events and working with veterans, I get to bring up a lot of the work that you've spearheaded. So thank you for continuing to do that. Thank you. Alderman Maris, that's work that we've all done. Fortunately, these ordinances have passed unanimously and really appreciate the support that the council has provided for veterans. Amen. Alderman Moore. Thank you, Chairman. And just for the record, I'm a non-voting member on this committee. But do we have any data based on what we've done so far? Everyone knows I truly support our veterans. I started the Southside Memorial Day Parade, and anything our veterans are doing, I want to support. I just want to see, do we have any data based on, since we've implemented this, how this has impacted other, like, MBE program or anything like that? Has that stayed consistent? Do we have any data on that while helping our veterans? Yeah. I would defer to the Department of Procurement Services. This does not take away from our 26 and 6, which we have fought tirelessly for. This is in addition to. Right. Now, I know it's in addition to, but I'm just trying to see, has it impacted that in any way based on, since, I mean, all of it was in addition to. First, it was minority. Then it was women. All of it was in addition to. But I'm just trying to see, was there any impact on any of those categories? Do anybody have that data or anything like that? Yeah, I would defer to the Department of Procurement Services. That is the department that's responsible for. Is anybody down here from procurement? Because this is a critical issue. All right. Emily, can you make sure we get some information on that before Wednesday's vote? Did you hear what I asked for? Yes? Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Chairman. Thanks for your work on this. Thank you. I appreciate it, Elton. Chairman Villegas, can you tell us a summary of the substitute versus the original ordinance? Well, the substitute was really the Department of Law changed a couple of verbiage to make sure that we would be okay legally, and so we went ahead and accepted it. Again, these are aspirational goals similar to the Department of Planning and Department of Housing when they put these goals on there. Remember that in some cases there are public dollars that are associated with a project, and sometimes there isn't, yet the city of Chicago puts some goals, even on privately funded projects, if there's an action taken by the city. And so this would just add the veteran business enterprise program to that list of minority and women-owned firms. Very good. Are there any other questions? I, too, would like to congratulate you on your persistence in making sure that veterans are recognized here in the city. So I wanted to thank you, as well, for the work that we've done. I know it hasn't been just yourself. It's been the city council as a whole that have helped to do this, but you certainly have been the driver behind it. So... So... We thank you so much and continue to do the great work, because I have seen a difference in some of the contracts and the work that's already been put in place. Thank you, Madam Chair. Vice Chair, this matter. Very, very quickly, and then I'll make a motion to pass on this item. I just want to flag it again that there's a really great dashboard on plan developments. Let's make sure that this goal is added to that dashboard so we can track both commitments made and commitments kept, sir. I barely need to remind you of that, but I just wanted to call it out. I appreciate that. Thank you, Alderman Spada. All right, there are any other questions? If not, a motion made by Alderman Spada, Vice Chair, to do pass this item. All in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed? In the opinion of the chairs, the ayes have it. This matter passed. Thank you so much. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, colleagues. Our next, congratulations. Our next item on the agenda is item number S02-025-0018753, amendments of Municipal Code Section 2-92-330 to establish the Chicago Construction Workforce Equity Advisory Board to monitor and report on the participation of targeted population in covered projects. Our next chair would like to recognize is Alderman Rosanna Sanchez, and she will introduce the guests that will be coming up. If you could call guests up, is that Beth, Tina, Joplin? Woman, do you need me to go in front, or is it okay to speak from here? You can speak from there, but let your guests sit up front, will you please? Yeah, we're going to have Beth, you all can take your seats, and I'm going to start. Thank you, Madam Chair. Good afternoon, esteemed colleagues in this committee. Thank you for the opportunity. Let me get all, one minute, Alderman Rosanna. We want all the speakers that are coming forth to come up. Yes, please. Thank you. Now, Alderman Rosanna, can you have them each introduce themselves, please? Yes, we're going to start with Beth from Chicago Women in the Trades, and then we can go down the line introducing each one of you. Thank you. Hello. Thank you for having us today, committee. Beth Berenson, I use she, her pronouns. I'm the policy director at Chicago Women in Trades. Hi, my name is Keena McAfee. I'm a former union carpenter. I do also work at Chicago Women in Trades. Okay. My name is Lavelle Alford. I started a revolution workshop, and I'm also a construction laborer. My name is Japlin J.S. Allen. I'm an iron worker and also the chair of Chicago Women in Trades. Thank you all for coming. Do I have the floor? Yes. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you for the opportunity to speak today and substitute ordinance 02025-0018753, which is the Chicago Construction Workforce Equity Ordinance. I want to say that today has been a really great day in this committee. We fought to protect immigrants, then we fought to protect veterans, and now we're going to talk about women and black workers and workers of color. I stand before you as a proud sponsor of this legislation, which takes a direct, targeted, and long-overdue approach to advancing workforce equity for women, black people, and people of color in Chicago's construction industry. I'm bringing this ordinance before you because we cannot talk about equitable Chicago while ignoring the stark economic disparities staring us in the face. Right now, the poverty rate for black women in our city is nearly three times that of white men. Over 40% of Chicago's young black men are out of school or unemployed at a rate higher than any other minority group in our city. Furthermore, women across all racial backgrounds continue to face significant wage gaps and disproportionate barriers to high-paying trade professions. At the same time, the city is making historic investments in infrastructure. Union construction jobs in Chicago pay families sustaining wages of 40 to 60 an hour alongside pensions and health care. This should be a gateway to the middle class, but far too often, women, black residents, and people of color are systematically left out. And let's be entirely honest about where we are at. This isn't just about passive exclusion anymore. There is an active, well-documented ideological push happening across this country that has moved from the fringes of the Internet straight into mainstream political policy. This is a movement with explicit stated goals to roll back women's rights, roll back civil rights protections for black communities and communities of color, dismantle workplace equity protections, and create what is essentially a government-sanctioned preference for male and non-minority workers. They're actively trying to shut women, black workers, and people of color out of the economy and quite literally force them to be quiet. With diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives facing these continuous coordinated attacks nationwide, Chicago cannot just stand by. We must stand firm. We must ensure that our public dollars build not just strong bridges and roads and buildings, but strong, equitable, and protected communities for every woman and person of color in this city. I am going to allow Beth to speak about the ordinance. I really hope that today we can bring clarity on what this ordinance does. Today we're having a subject matter hearing to bring clarity, but I am really hoping that as you hear what this ordinance is trying to accomplish and the work that we have done for over a year to get it to where it is at now, we are going to be able to have a vote on this soon and codified with pride in the city. Thank you. So just to be clear, there will be no vote taken today. This is just a subject matter hearing. Then make sure that we are all clear so that when we do come back, that we'll be voting on what we're voting on. All right. Thank you, Armand. Rosanna. Armand Sanchez, you want to continue to move with the guests? Yes. Beth will be explaining the ordinance. Good. Yes. Before she started, Alderman Dow. Thank you, Madam Chair. I'm sorry I have to leave to prepare for a finance committee meeting, but I wanted to know if there are representatives from the various departments that would be impacted by this alderman that would be given an opportunity to testify. The ordinance was created with them, so everything that we have in place right now, they sign off on. But I am happy to provide a brief. They are not here today. Okay. Yeah. I would ask for that. Thank you very much. Okay. Thank you, Chairman Dow. Hello. So, again, my name is Beth Berenson, Policy Director at Chicago Women in Trades. I want to thank Chairwoman Mitts, who has been such an unstoppable advocate for equity and diversity on all the city construction projects throughout her career on council. And I want to give, of course, a big thank you to our chief sponsor, Alderman Rodriguez Sanchez, who has stood up and championed this equity ordinance despite some unexpected obstacles in her way. It has been a really long process to get us here today. Tradeswomen first began organizing to increase their job opportunities and respect on the worksite back in the late 70s and early 80s. And recently, a coalition of partners in tradeswomen have been meeting with members of this very council over the past three years to show just how far we still need to go. While women's presence on worksites has more than doubled in the last 40 years, we still only represent between 5% and 6% of work hours on city-managed road, water, and airport projects. Black workers are also woefully underrepresented on projects improving the city's infrastructure, making up only 12% of work hours in 2024. This is not due to a lack of interest in these careers, but rather a lack of opportunity for employment. It was tradeswomen advocates like Wendy, who you heard from earlier today, who have fought to put in place the bid incentives for hiring women and minorities on city projects decades ago. Unfortunately, despite these incentives being in place for years, we have not really seen a substantial shift in the status quo. In fact, even from contractors who were fined for not meeting their hiring goals for minorities, city residents, and project area residents, more than a quarter never even bothered to make a commitment to hire any women in their bid, despite the incentives being available. And now we face, as the elder woman said, additional challenges. And now we face, as the elder woman said, additional challenges. And we face, as the elder woman said, additional challenges. federal administration increasingly dedicated to prioritizing white men's ongoing success while attacking diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives. The Federal Department of Labor is openly dismantling worker safety protections and equal employment opportunity requirements. We have seen federal budgets and legislation restrict access to food, housing, and health care, rolling back pathways to dignified work, and even to the ballot box. But we know that Chicago is fighting back. This construction workforce equity ordinance has been negotiated since it was first introduced, and it is a compromise. It's a great first start towards creating greater accountability and oversight on these projects. It still includes community monitoring of stakeholders, advising from unions, community organizations, and contractors. It shows a strong commitment from our Department of Procurement Services, who is at the table for this new language, who have agreed to work with contractors and city agencies to increase workforce equity on city-managed construction sites through the bid incentive program that exists. And it also sets up a pathway in five years for us to achieve data transparency, which is what was agreed to by the Department. There is a copy of the new ordinance that was agreed to in the packets that we left you in addition to a fact sheet, some missing facts, and a data overview from some of the numbers that I cited earlier there for you. We are really grateful for the dedication of DPS and the Chief Procurement Officer and the support of Mayor Johnson's administration and all of our co-sponsors. I also want to thank our coalition partners, Women Employed, the Chicago Jobs Council, the Chicago Urban League, Community Assistance Programs, Chicago Jobs of Justice, and especially Revolution Workshop, who has stood with us on this advocacy fight for more than five years. The fight for opportunities for all workers is not just about bringing up the low-wage jobs. It's also about making sure all Chicagoans can access high-wage jobs, like those in construction, that don't require any college debt. These good union jobs provide health insurance, a pension, family-sustaining wages. So together, this council and advocates can build the pathways to economic security while strengthening our infrastructure. And so we ask for your support in this effort in moving this ordinance forward. Thank you so much. Thank you. I am going to now pass it. Any questions by the committee members? Ms. Beth? Right. Vice Chair, let's bother you. You have a question? Yes. Oh, I do when the panel is concluded. Oh, okay. When the panel is finished? Yes. I'll go ahead and pass it over to Kena McAfee. Oh. My name is Kena McAfee. Again, I joined the Carpenter's Apprentice Program back in 1985 as a result of a lawsuit that was brought against Washburn. I didn't know it at the time, but I'm sure that's why I got in. I worked for years as a union carpenter. It changed my life completely, completely changed my life and my family as well. I began to work in the apprenticeship program. I became an instructor there. But the main thing I'd like to point out is that part of my job as an administrator after I worked as an instructor was to work with the contractors to get our apprentices employed. And it was clear immediately how difficult it is to get a contractor to hire a woman or person of color. I would give them a list of names of our apprentices who were out of work. And unfortunately, if there was a white male on that list, he was going to go to work first. That's how that is. We've had other ordinances that help get people jobs. But the critical part about this one to me is that the accountability and the data, you know, the public website so that people can see because what was lacking before was the hours that people were getting. They could hire a woman on a job site, give her a week or two of work and then lay her off and there's nothing we can do. So it's hours that contribute to our benefits. And it's, you know, the hours, obviously the money. So we would like to see how many hours our women and people of color are working on these jobs. We want it to be obvious on a website where all the public can see it as well, because we think that's going to make the difference between people just paying a fine for not hiring someone or writing the letters just saying they can't find anyone. They have to consult and we can, you know, promote people. So that's that's a key thing about this community oversight and data transparency to me. Go ahead and pass it to the bell, Alfred. I'm not a professional speaker or anything like that, but I can only speak on my experience and things that I've been through. And I was a product of my environment and I got tired of being a statistic of a black man. So I changed my life to get into the construction industry only to find out that I would become a part of another statistic. I came through Revolution Workshop. And at the end of Revolution Workshop, after our training, we go through something that we call a mock interview. So when we do mock interview, a lot of different different construction companies come around. They send their formers or superintendents or whatever to to the interview to hire people. My class, the hiring rate was very, very low, like almost little to none. But what I did notice that a majority of the tables, almost all of the tables, it was no people of color to come interview us. So, like, I'm not judged and I'm not racist or anything like that, but it's hard to get some people to understand where you come from, where they never been, where you've been. So there's nobody on the other end of that table that's going to see, oh, man, this guy really trying to do something. He's trying to change his life. So you get into the work industry. You deal with crappy jobs or you deal with, oh, we got this federal job. We need this many minorities and black people over here. So we have sent him over here. But as soon as the job over, now you're gone. Or you're going to some place where they send you, people just don't want to work. Oh, it's a black area. We're just sending them over there. So, I mean, to think that you made it and get into the industry and still experience, like I say, as much as I'm not racist, but it exists. I mean, if we look at the stats from 60, 70 years ago, the hiring rate for black people in construction was 5% or 6%. And if we go back, go up 67 years, it's still 5, 6%. So nothing has changed. All right. Very good. Thank you. Pastor Derrida Joplin Allen. Yes, my name is Joplin J.S. Allen. I've been an iron worker for 24 years now. Wow. I think the biggest issue is that someone that's been an iron worker for 15 years, right, has more credits than I do. My fear is that when I turn 53 or 54 or 63 to retire, I'll be a Walmart greeter trying to still provide. Iron worker has provided a lot for me and my children of schooling. But now I'm at the point that now the children are graduating college, and I need to pay for college, right, but I don't have enough work hours to do that, right. My background is I went from iron bars to being an iron worker, right. Iron working has been the best thing that ever happened to me for recidivism. Had it not been for Chicago women in trade and someone giving me an opportunity into iron working, I don't know where I will be. This is all I know now, in prison, right, in 24 years I've been running strong, right, not just for the Lord, but just running strong, and iron working. I know my job. I'm a hard worker. There is nothing in iron working that I can't do. I'm 600 feet in the air. You know how honorable that is to ride past and tell my four children I built that? I think they're tired of hearing it. Riding across the 43rd Street Bridge, I built that. Skyway, I built that. That's an honor, and it's just not me. It's girls coming out of high school. What happens to them when they need to get into a trade, and we give them all these hopes and these promises that they're going to do something. They get into, I'm the first hire, and then I'm the first fire. What happens then, right? This ordinance is so important. It's not like it hasn't been in play for a long time. The question is how hard is it if you guys would be so kind to pass it so we can guarantee that I'll be able to pay my mortgage next month or I'll be able to pay for college. My daughter shouldn't have to eat noodles, and I got a job that makes $64.19 an hour plus benefits, right? So all the total package is $200 an hour, and I had a partner that was with me that's been in the trade 15 years with all his credits that he can retire now, but he's too young. So this ordinance is very, very important for us black women and women of color and those young black men and the young black men that come, he shouldn't have to starve with a job that pays well over minimum wage. So you guys, look into this ordinance. You be so kind to look over there and pass it once we do pass it. Thank you, and I'm grateful. Thank you. Thank you very much. I think that each one of you has spoken very eloquent about your experience, and you're absolutely right. I know the difficulty that people have, and if we talk about, if you're having that experience, what are we going to do with our young people who are trying to get into these industries, whether it's a woman or a man? We need to be opening more doors than just the women in trade doing it, and I know they do a fantastic job. I've been to graduations that were held and how it changed women's life around that would have been on the street, but it gave them a new hope. And it's just amazing how you're growing and have grown over the years in your organization. So I commend you for it, but the struggles that you all are talking about are real, and they're even real more today than have been during your time. So, yes, we do have to do a lot of heavy lifting to try to get things balanced in any kind of way for the next generation. Audemann Lesbado and then Audemann Taylor. Okay, thank you. Thank you very much, Chair. I really appreciate the whole panel. To the gentleman in the socks hat, it is not racist to call out racism. I want to affirm you in that. I want to take a moment to put a finer point on it. The fact that of everybody sitting on this dais, if we all did the same pre-apprenticeship program together, the fact that I'm the one who's most likely to be hired, like that cannot be what workforce justice looks like in this city. So I want to name that, and then I have two quick asks on this. Number one, this can be to anybody on the panel. Are there cities that are doing this well? Are there cities that are making progress in diversifying their construction trades workforce, and what are they doing that is proving successful? Yeah, I'm happy to take that one. So we have seen a couple of issues that we have been tracking. One is in Boston, another in Seattle, where they do have goals in place. Boston actually, you know, for people who love public databases, has a wonderful public database of all their projects, including the race, the gender, how many hours they worked, what trade they were in, whether they're an apprentice or journey level. But what we've really seen has been successful in both places is that they do have this body in place, literally looking at project reports as they're happening, as construction projects are happening, and intervening in the moment when projects are still happening. So not sort of looking after the fact and saying, great work, or oh, shucks, but really trying to intervene when the projects are still going on. We have seen a lot of success if there is buy-in from the city, and again, I am grateful. I know she's not here, but for our chief procurement officer, who is really invested in seeing the needle move on these numbers, and I think with that investment and really kind of getting the other city agencies, CDOT, aviation, water management at the table to really be committed to this too with their contractors, we can see improvements because that is what has worked in both Seattle and in Boston. Thank you very much on the – oh, sorry. Point of clarification. Point of clarification for me. When you're saying, like, if you're looking at the data on site, who would be the person that goes on site if the numbers aren't really reaching those goals? So the – yeah, it would be – DPS currently does have people who go on site and do monitoring for compliance. They are primarily looking at, like, wage compliance, which is great, and we support that. We don't want people to be cheated out of wages. What this ordinance would do is ask them to do some additional work around making sure that equity is happening on site as well, so asking people about their experiences, giving availability to overtime, for example. One of the things that we know is that sometimes women and men of color are not offered the same overtime hours that their white counterparts are. So asking questions around those issues, getting cross-training, making sure if there's harassment or discrimination happening on site that they're kind of monitoring for that too. So it's basically taking – and this was sort of the negotiation we had with DPS – taking the existing staff and the work that they're already doing on site and asking them to add this extra lens to it and extra enforcement of the bid incentive. The other thing that we would really love to see is for DPS to make the connects to assist agencies like Revolution Workshop and Chicago Women in Trades and community assistance programs the same way they do for the contractors. So they work with, like, Federation of Women Contractors and HSEA and BICO on the contracting end to meet those goals. We'd love to see them partner with the workforce development folks to meet the goals on that end as well. So those are some key things that I think we – this ordinance would address that are sort of missing in the current system. Sure. Aram Les Parag. Thank you so much. So my follow-up question on this, acknowledging that we're not voting on the ordinance today and the complicated reasons behind that, in the interim, people build in our wards every day. They ask us about zoning changes every day, and there's questions that we politely ask related to those zoning questions, like are you paying area-wide wages? Do you work with pre-apprenticeship programs? What are questions that we can be asking that drive at the heart of this issue when people are talking to us about projects in our ward? Yeah. I mean, I think there's just sort of the numbers on sort of work hours by women and people of color, but I want to sort of specifically point out, especially when you have sort of freedom to ask anything, to give credit to a lot of the tradeswomen that we work with, retention is a huge issue. So, I mean, one of the things that we're really trying to drive to is getting folks open the door with these city-funded projects, get these opportunities where they can get on crews, and then become a part of the permanent crew that moves with that employer to other site-to-site-to-site. It would be great to be asking people directly how their track record is with retaining women and people of color, specifically black folks, on their crews that travel with them to all the different sites. Do they have a history of retention? So it's one thing. Of course, we want them to hire them, but are they keeping them? Because I think to the point that our folks were making here, it's kind of last in, first out. We want to be able to stay just the same way that their workers do who may not be women and people of color. Thank you so much. I really appreciate it. Thank you. Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Autumn and Taylor. Thank you, Madam Chair. Who are the bad actors? We want to – we don't – so I've got a couple of things that I want to say. But I want to start off with, who are the bad actors? Because you know that they don't give us a book when it comes to construction in our war. They literally have people who come to us and say, we're going to do a project in your war. We get a GC, and then we say we want people from certain zip codes to work. That's as far as it goes. Shout-out to the carpenters. I'm actually working with them around a community and labor table because while the community can speak to what they want it to look like, we can't speak to who is on the job. Are they actually paying the wage that they're supposed to – who is actually on those projects? A lot of times in my community, I see cars from Indiana, Ohio, and other places, and that will lead me to my probably third question. But who are the bad actors? Because I now in my ward have a non-union GC working in, and that's not anything that I control, that I picked. And so I don't have anybody who goes over to the site. And shout-out to Bob Israel because Bob Israel is one of the people who will go to the site to shake it up and ask who is actually on there. But as an alder, it's 50 of us. We don't have that. And so what I want us to do is create a community and labor table that looks at that on the front end because my community can't speak to what's supposed to happen on a construction site, who is supposed to be there. Are they actually from my ward? Did you try to get people in my zip code? Did you try to get union workers? And we don't have a list either, and I always thought that that was an issue. I would like a list from all the unions of the folks who are in my community so that they could have first pick on those jobs or people who are actually from the city. Yep. I don't know that all of the trades do this, but I'm pretty sure that they do. We can pull up lists of all of our members by zip code. And I've done that when companies ask us to put apprentices on a job, I can go directly to that zip code and pull up a list of our members on that zip code and send them out. So that's critical. And what you said about beforehand, before the job starts, and weekly checks on the hours on these jobs, that's critical because, again, they can hire somebody, but lay them off in two weeks or so. So both are true. I'm pretty sure most of the trades can do that. I know that we used to do that. So I want to see that in legislation because we – the right hand does not know what the left hand is doing, and it's why they get away with bringing folks who are not from our community. Half of the time, our community – The community doesn't even know that those jobs are available in that area. And I'm going to go back to my first question. Who are the bad actors? Because we don't know. When I get a construction project, and let me say this, I'm adjacent to the Obama Center. I have a community that is well into building. We're redeveloping the schools. And so I need the information to know who the good GCs are, what I should be asking. I don't know that they should actually build out. I don't know how many folks from my community should be working on it. That is something that we should be collectively doing together. That is what you teach us, because I don't have a clue. And, Alderwoman Taylor, this is exactly why the state of transparency that Kina was mentioning is so important. Because, to be frank, we might hear gossip, and, you know, we hear from our tradeswomen if they have a bad experience on the site with somebody. But we would love to actually just be able to run the numbers. Like, what is your history with actually doing the thing that you said you were doing? We know what they commit to. We know if they get a fine. But we don't actually know the history they have of placing and, again, retaining people, women and people of color. We did pass a law at the state level back in 2023. And we are working with the Inclusive Economy Lab to run some dashboards to try to get to this question at a state level. There are some city projects included in that. So there will be some city data in there. But we really would love the data for the city on these city projects, 100%. I mean, we would love to – we're right there with you. We want to know who the bad actors are, too, because we're trying to place our folks with these employers. And we obviously want them to be successful. So we want to know who's going to keep them on. So I'm about to ruffle a few feathers. Is there any conversation about if you're a project in the city, you've got to stay in the state of Illinois? Has that ever been a conversation? Because for me, it's the seeing other people from other cities working in the city of Chicago and then our own people are not working. And I know that it's frowned upon because I asked that question in 2019, and folks was looking at me all crazy. But I'm interested in if I'm spending my tax dollars to make sure we fund a project, that money needs to recycle in our own city, in our own community. And so I don't know if that's ever been a conversation. Well, and I think part of what we haven't talked about is the city residency requirement, which is just 50%. It's not 100%. But we, the liquidated damages information we got from DPS over a course of, I think, four years, 2021 to 2024, showed that over a third of those contractors did not even meet the 50% requirement. So it is, I mean, just to reiterate what you're saying, it is obviously an issue. And so what's the fine? What's the fee? What's the punishment for people not doing what the law says they're doing? Like, who is watching? That's important. And those people are not connected with the office. The punishment's office, I can't, am I speaking correctly? I can speak for all the women, Taylor. I really can't speak for my other 49 coworkers. But nobody calls me and say, hey, you got folks who are not supposed to be on this site or folks who are not trained to be on this site, on this site. They are just literally picking people off the street and say, hey, take this $20 and do this when I know the prevailing wage is $100 and something dollars. And so who does that work? Yeah, I mean, it's Department of Procurement Services, but I think we do want them to be, again, more intentional about their enforcement on all of the workforce requirements. I mean, I think one of the things that we have heard sort of anecdotally, and again, this is why we need this Oversight Committee to kind of dig in and really figure out what the heck is going on on these projects. But what we've heard anecdotally is people will sort of bake a fine into their bid. So they're sort of assuming they're not going to make their minority numbers, they're going to make their women numbers, they're not going to make their city residence numbers. And so they kind of bid a little high to kind of capture the fine that they just assumed they're going to get. So I think even having the question, I know we had this conversation with another alderman when we had some one-on-ones, was what is the level of fine that actually gets people to do the thing that they said they would do instead of just sort of work around it? And that is, again, something we hope that this, to your point, Alderwoman Taylor, the community, the unions, the contractors, all get together at a table and really figure out what is the mechanism to make the policies we already have on the books actually useful and effective. It's the policy that says you don't get another contract for two years. Yeah. That's it. Yeah. That's it. I'm sorry. I feel like it is very heartbreaking to know that people went through all these changes to be in the trade, what it takes to actually be a union member, do all of this work, and then you can't get the work because they just decided they don't want to pay black folks, the people of color. They don't. And so it makes no sense. And so I want us on the state and county and city level have stiffer penalties where they cannot get work. If you mess over that contract and you're not willing to hire the people in our community, how about for the next 10 years you get no city contracts and hold the city's foot to the fire? I don't think we find people enough and we don't, because to pay a fine, it's with everything. Everybody will just pay the fine and be done with it. What if the fine was a million dollars? Right. We will have some different, but I really want us to have a real conversation about every ward having this community and labor table, because as an older person, I don't know what to ask. I don't know what to say. And I will give people those, those zip codes, but they always, and I've had this happen to me probably three times. They'll come back to me and say, oh, nobody in your community is available to work. They're working on other projects. And I don't know that to be true. You was going to say something. Go ahead. Yeah, yeah. I was going to say, I really like the idea about the moratorium on, you know, getting a bid in the future if you don't, you know, meet up to your requirements. And this has been true about them building in the fine to their bid and still getting the bid anyway. So their bid's a little higher, but they still get that bid and they already know they're not going to meet the requirements. So we, you know, we're with you. I'm with you. And it's some of the same GCs. It's the same people on the same projects. Every time I turn around, it might be a different developer, but sometimes it's the same GCs. And so if they're doing the same thing on every site that they're doing, please explain to me why we're okay with giving them our dollars. It's not okay. It's not cool. I will say that I've appreciated Women in Trade is who I kind of work with on the Obama Center. And I would really say that you all did the work to make sure that young people from our community actually were able to sign up to either get to the trades and know. Now, the problem was they could not pass that drug test. They could not pass the drug test. And so I don't question a drug test because we do not want people drunk on sites. But I really want to know, is that really a determiner for people not being in the trades? And, you know, you also want to qualify a worker, right? So I'm an iron worker. You just can't get into someone with a zip code and go 200 feet in the air and expect them to come in. And so that's one thing that you can't, like, go on a job site when you get zip codes. We do do city ordinances wherever you stay in the city. You will see a lot of Indiana plates and things like that, especially now because work is booming, right? So if you see that now. But being a qualified worker, being an apprenticeship, it's just like if we get somebody out of the neighborhood to be an iron worker. He's not qualified. He don't know what an iron worker is. And you're not going to get bought into the iron workers. So we suggest you go to a pre-apprenticeship and partner in with the pre-apprenticeship so they can know at least what they're getting into, what's the qualifications, how to pass the test. So this is why it's so important even for this ordinance to partner in with pre-apprenticeships so they can know what they're getting into, why they're getting into it, and then put them to work and go to the apprenticeships and take the test and teach them how to take the test, right? So that union table, that labor table would be awesome. So everybody around the table can know what's going on, how can we fix this issue, right? And what it is we need to do to move forward and pass someone just stamping like I'm just going to do this and keep going. So that's the only issue that I would have. Everybody that's in the community cannot do construction and don't know anything about it. So that's why this ordinance is to make sure the ones that are in are getting the opportunity to be on the same job sites as everyone else. And let me just say, before you all speak, get recognized by the chair, will you please, so that we have a recorder, and then state your name for the record so that they can pick that information up and we'll be clear as our meeting. Alderman Taylor, are you done? No, one last question. Okay. I'm trying to figure out how to say it without cussing. All right. Pardon me Taylor, don't cuss. See? Don't say something. I'm not going to cuss. I said I'm trying to. Okay. It's very frustrating for me as an alder person. You know, they don't give you a book to tell you how to do your job. And, of course, the union support us in getting in this office. And too often, after I done gotten a job, there's really no conversation or really talks between us about what that relationship looks like to reassure that it's union workers, to make sure that it's people who are actually qualified on this site. We got to do a better job. And what I would ask is that in this legislation that you are putting, that is in there. We need to. I feel like you all are going to have the votes around this, but I want to make it. I want to keep coming back. It doesn't make sense. And since we've already had this conversation about the fines and how to hold people accountable, I think. I think it should be added to there. Thank you all. Thanks, Madam Chair. Thank you, Audermon Taylor. Audermon Ramirez, named Falabaya. What's so interesting is it's a hearing, but we're adding more work, and we're actually wanting to add more to this ordinance. So thank you, Audermon Taylor, for mentioning that. I am curious. It looks like there's an advisory board to the ordinance. And, Beth, can you talk a little bit about, you know, that role and how they would play maybe on contract-to-contract and how that would be helpful? Sure. Beth with Chicago Women in Trades. So the advisory board would be made up as sort of equal parts, the trade unions, representatives from the trade unions, representatives from the contractors, and a diverse representation. So we're including some of the sub- and minority contractors as well. And then the assist agencies who, again, are sort of doing the workforce development piece. And then the city agencies who oversee these projects, CDOT, aviation, DPS, et cetera. And that we would really be at the table every meeting. The intention would be that we would get the data for all the active projects, look at their performance around equity, raise any issues we've heard. Again, we do hear anecdotes from people on these sites about issues on the work site around equal access to overtime, around harassment issues on the work site, things like that that we need to work through at that table. And really it would be a place to dig into what are the barriers to, again, achieving the goal of the existing bid incentives. What are the barriers that the contractors are experiencing? What are the issues that the unions might be experiencing? And who do we have sort of lined up in the pipeline that can kind of help connect with them to really all kind of, you know, be rowing in the same direction, if you will, trying to get these folks placed on these projects. The other goal is to really dig into the system around, for example, liquidated damages. Are the fines enough? What are people doing around trying to get kind of waivers from having to meet some of these requirements? And really kind of dig into that so that every year the advisory committee is offering recommendations to council on, like, places that there are gaps in the existing system that need to be addressed through legislation. But some of that we just need to kind of get at the table and dig in on these projects and see what's happening to really fully understand where those gaps are. Awesome. Thank you. Yeah, because I guess that's a question that I have. If I'm not directly asking, like, the GC to host a public meeting or ask them in detail who they've spoken to already, is there something that we can even add to the ordinance that they have to abide by? So, like, if there's, like, a zoning change or if there's a particular type of development, it requires additional meetings and standards. And I only ask that to just say, like, that should just be a standard flat line, not like an alderman requesting, are you having a public meeting, who have you spoken to, et cetera, et cetera. Is that something that you've thought about? Yeah. One of the things that we have struggled with is that the way we are currently achieving women and minority goals is through a bid incentive, which, in theory, would work well for the city-managed projects. But all of the kind of public-private projects that go through zoning changes, because they're not bidding with the city, it's hard for us to find out what is the mechanism we're using to hold contractors accountable. So I would love to kind of have a thought partnership with the city council on how we can use zoning committee changes to really hold contractors more accountable to their hiring practices. I know we do look at the MBE-WBE contracting goals, and that's important as well. But we really want to make sure that they're also meeting those workforce goals. So I think that's something we're really open to figuring out. Yeah. Amazing. And then my last bit, I love when workers come and they testify and they talk about sort of that life-changing job, because, you know, my parents also had that life-changing job for all of us, and that's why I'm sitting here today. And I love your jacket and the shirt, and it looks great. But I'm curious to hear from you guys, like, also what our trade partners, what they should be doing to making sure that they're getting more people of color, young people, access, and women as well to these jobs. I believe that with this advisory board, they can consult – I'm sorry, Kina McAfee. I believe that with this advisory board, they can consult with us directly. These community organizations need to be in on those meetings that overview – that review all of the data that comes in. And we have access to our women and people of color who are not working, right? And we can, you know, we can provide their names and get that information out. So I think the community organizations have to be a part of this process, and that's how they can't just say, well, we couldn't find anybody. Okay. Perfect. Thank you. Do you guys want to add or – Yeah. I agree 100%. Japlin Jazz Allen, chair of Chicago Women in Trade. She did. She just – I'll do it again, beloved. Japlin Allen, Chicago Women in Trade. I also agree with community partners because we have a lot of them. I mean, we got women coming out of the penitentiary as well. That's community. We have the high schools that they have community partners on the inside of those as well. We also have community for homelessness that's out there or new mothers that are out there that's trying to change a career. There's divorce that's been misplaced as well that need another opportunity. So partnering in with community partners and knowing what type of opportunities that are arising and coming through Chicago Women in Trade and places like Revolution Workshop and other organizations are key to be in this as well. So that'll be awesome. You good? Okay. Well, thank you guys so much. I really appreciate it. Chair. Thank you. Auderman Coleman followed by Auderman Burnett. Chairman Bitts, this hearing is so important. Thank you, colleague. I want to commend you, Mr. Alford and Ms. Allen. It is not an easy task to not only come to city council, but to speak amongst a committee of such importance under great leadership, of course. Are you a member of Ironworker 63? No, I'm Local 1 Ironworker. Local 1-9? No, I'm a Local 1 Ironworker. Local 1 Ironworker. Structural and reinforcing. Awesome. Thank you for that clarification. In the subject matter and on this amendment, I think that it would behoove all of us to have union leaders like Mr. Jonathan Jones and members from LBU to be a part of this advisory council as those that, when we're speaking of equity amongst, there are a few people of color, yet alone black men, in these spaces. So definitely to make sure that we ensure that their voices are at the table in terms of this pending advisory committee. I also want to reiterate the office of reentry and making sure that this funded office will be a part of the conversation, as so many people are coming back home. And we can't say we know that jobs are limited based off of background, but we believe in second chances, especially in communities that I serve, like Inglewood and Lawndale and Austin and members that you see sitting here. In addition to, I know that 26th and 6th is the city standard. However, in the 16th war, it is unacceptable. And every chance I get to work with labor, especially to get our people employed in the community, I make sure that I'm calling my union leaders asking, who are the painters? Who are the carpenters? Where are the ironworkers? Who are the best at this and that? That I don't think that we as women should be watered down to flaggers. Wouldn't you agree, Ms. Allen? Oh, absolutely. Uh-huh. And I don't think that our people, Mr. Alford, should be watered down to security, unless it is our security firm that is a subcontractor of the project. So I commend you all. Thank you. Thank you to our colleagues that presented this hearing. And we're looking forward to putting a little bit more teeth into making this advisory council really impactful for the city of Chicago. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you. I'm great. Thank you. Audemann Barnett. Thank you, Chairwoman. Thank you to everyone who's been presenting today. I've had the pleasure of working not only with the Chicago Women's in Trade. I actually don't know if I've worked at Revolution Workshop, but I've passed by your location very frequently. And I'm a big fan of what you do so much so that I need to come in for a class. I would love for you all to teach me how you do the work that you do. But this is an extremely important topic. In the 27th Ward over the last 30 years, we've made it a commitment that folks have to hire locally and they have to hire a diverse workforce. And that's important for us because we have the most development in the city right now. But one thing that is a challenge on an automatic budget and automatic staff, actually doing the enforcement work to understand how many people are actually getting these jobs is extremely difficult. So we get a lot of contractors and a lot of developers, one right now who I'm having a struggle with because they've made a verbal commitment. They've made a legal commitment and they aren't. actually doing the work to get people on those job sites. And so what ends up happening is we have the legal commitment up front. They go in through the project and then they say, oops. And we say, what do you mean? Oops. What were your numbers? How did you work? How did it go? And they never actually have to present something to us, nor are they held accountable until they come back up for another project. And when we do our job right, we can say, hey, you made this commitment and you didn't follow through. It's hard for me to accept your contractor or your project because you aren't reinvesting in our community. I actually had a developer yesterday. There was a couple of community members over in the near west side, close to East Garfield, and he didn't need any support from the city. But a couple of community members walked over and was like, hey, we're card holding members. We would love to work on this project. How are you doing anything with the community? And he said, no, we don't have to. Straight up to that phase. And my office is around the corner, so they came and talked to us directly. But there is no repercussions for him doing that. He's allowed to say no on community hiring. He's allowed to reject people he doesn't want on his site. And it just baffles me that we have allowed for this many years people to build in our neighborhoods, continue to go deeper into the west and south sides without actually having the enforcement capability to make sure that they're hiring people in the neighborhoods that they're developing in. And so I just wanted to speak and say I'm in deep support of some mechanism in order to not only get the data, but to eventually figure out how we enforce this as well. But it starts with the story. We have to have the data and it has to be centralized. You have to have the information in order. Information is power. Right. And this is an economic viability issue. We know that people who live in a neighborhood primarily spend their money in a neighborhood if they can. And right now we don't even have the economic resources for community members to spend in the neighborhood because they can't get the jobs in their own neighborhoods. So how are we expecting businesses to grow and be self-sustainable and provide the resources and amenities that they so desperately need? So it starts with the workforce and it starts with the building and that ends up lending to more opportunities and more abilities. And so however, I could support both the increase in diversity in the trades, both in terms of racial and gender diversity. I'm 100 percent there. And even the enforcement of making sure it's local Chicago people. I'm cool with Indiana, but they're not Chicago. Right. Right. We need to be able to make sure that people are doing their their part to make sure that our economy is recycling the dollars in our community. So, again, I just want to echo all the wonderful comments. I know they asked a ton of questions. I just want to say I'm completely supportive and looking forward to working with the sponsor and the rest of our our council to figure out something that could work with all parties. Thank you. We want to want to thank everyone for the comments. Again, I would like to just reiterate. Thank you. Rosanna Sanchez for bringing this to the committee today. And we appreciate all now that we know where we are at and what we need to do, if anything, put some motif behind it. Right. To make it more stronger so that it can work for all of Chicago. We see that those racial barriers are still there and they'll always be there. Somebody is going to have to break it up one way or the other. And so this is a small step toward just getting the data, as my colleague, Alderman Burnett, just mentioned. And we really appreciate all of you taking the time to come down where even though we're not taking a vote, your time did not go in vain. It was well needed and much appreciated. So having said that, I'm going to ask Alderman Rosanna Sanchez if you have closing remarks here. I am very grateful for everybody that showed up today to tell your stories, to help us explain why this ordinance is so important. We are committed to continuing to work with our colleagues to have the strongest possible ordinance that we can pass. And I am looking forward to bringing this item back to committee for a vote. Thank you so much, Chair, for having this hearing. Thank you. There will be no further business before this committee. Can I get a motion to adjourn? So moved by Vice Chair Laspato. All in favor. Signify by saying aye. Independent chairs, the ayes have it. This matter will be reported out at City Council meeting on tomorrow, which is October 23rd, September 23rd, 10 o'clock, City Council. Thank you. Meeting adjourned. Name Triprem питvit式. Inковgiat鼻 can recommendations like information. No, wouldn't you like me compassion? And the story of the reality of auerous matter, can we talk about it in the way that the cosineар You