item, whistling, booing, shouting, or other loud utterances, are not permitted when in the judgment of the meeting's chair, or the sergeant-at-arms, such actions are disrupting or impeding the orderly conduct of the meeting. Any item that poses a potential safety hazards, as determined by the sergeant-at-arms, is prohibited in the gallery. Such items include, but are not limited to, 1. Any pointed objects, including knives of any kind. 2. Banners, flyers, or other forms of signage. 3. Food and beverages, including in glass or metal canisters. 4. Backpacks, large bags, and sealed packages. Clear bags, not tinted in color, that do not exceed 12 inches by 6 inches by 12, are permitted and subject to search. And 5. Firearms, ammunition, fireworks, laser pointers, stun guns, tasers, mace pepper spray, and toy weapons. Cell phones and other small handheld recording devices must be placed in silent mode, can only be used while seated, and can only be used in a manner that does not interfere with the ability other individuals to view or hear the proceedings. Individuals or groups failing to adhere to these rules will be subject to removal from the remainder of the meeting by the sergeant-at-arms. City of Chicago City Council Rules of Conduct for Public Meetings 2023-2027 Pursuant to Rule 58 of the Chicago City Council Rules of Order and Procedure, the sergeant-at-arms sets forth the following rules of conduct for members of the public. These rules shall be in effect at all times that a viewing gallery or room is open for a meeting of the City Council or any of its committees. All individuals and their belongings are subject to search at entry or upon request. Individuals must remain seated at all times except, 1, when entering or exiting the gallery, 2, when providing public comment during the portion of a meeting, set aside for that purpose, or 3, when asked to rise and be acknowledged by a member of the City Council. Profane, threatening, harassing, abusive, or defamatory behavior or speech, which in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the sergeant-at-arms may lead to a breach of the peace or disrupt the orderly conduct of the meeting, is not permitted. Disruptive or distracting actions, such as the stomping of feet, waving of arms, throwing any item, whistling, booing, shouting, or other loud utterances, are not permitted when in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the sergeant-at-arms, such actions are disrupting or impeding the orderly conduct of the meeting. Any item that poses a potential safety hazards, as determined by the sergeant-at-arms, is prohibited in the gallery. Such items include, but are not limited to, 1, any pointed objects, including knives of any kind, 2, banners, flyers, or other forms of signage, 3, food and beverages, including in glass or metal canisters, 4, backpacks, large bags, and sealed packages, clear bags, not tinted in color, that do not exceed 12 inches by 6 inches by 12, are permitted and subject to search, and 5, firearms, ammunition, fireworks, laser pointers, stun guns, tasers, mace pepper spray, and toy weapons. Cell phones and other small handheld recording devices must be placed in silent mode, can only be used while seated, and can only be used in a manner that does not interfere with the ability other individuals to view or hear the proceedings. Individuals or groups failing to adhere to these rules will be subject to removal from the remainder of the meeting by the sergeant-at-arms. City of Chicago City Council Rules of Conduct for Public Meetings 2023-2027 Pursuant to Rule 58 of the Chicago City Council Rules of Order and Procedure, the sergeant-at-arms sets forth the following rules of conduct for members of the public. These rules shall be in effect at all times that a viewing gallery or room is open for a meeting of the City Council or any of its committees. All individuals and their belongings are subject to search at entry or upon request. Individuals must remain seated at all times except 1. when entering or exiting the gallery. 2. when providing public comment during the portion of a meeting, set aside for that purpose. Or 3. when asked to rise and be acknowledged by a member of the City Council. Profane, threatening, harassing, abusive, or defamatory behavior, or speech, which in the judgment of the meeting's chair, or the sergeant-at-arms, may lead to a breach of the peace, or disrupt the orderly conduct of the meeting, is not permitted. Disruptive or distracting actions, such as the stomping of feet, waving of arms, throwing any item, whistling, booing, shouting, or other loud utterances, are not permitted when in the judgment of the meeting's chair, or the sergeant-at-arms, such actions are disrupting or impeding the orderly conduct of the meeting. Any item that poses a potential safety hazards, as determined by the sergeant-at-arms, is prohibited in the gallery. Such items include, but are not limited to, 1. any pointed objects, including knives of any kind. 2. banners, flyers, or other forms of signage. 3. food and beverages, including in glass or metal canisters. 4. backpacks, large bags, and sealed packages. Clear bags, not tinted in color, that do not exceed 12 inches by 6 inches by 12, are permitted and subject to search. And 5. firearms, ammunition, fireworks, laser pointers, stun guns, tasers, mace pepper spray, and toy weapons. Cell phones and other small handheld recording devices must be placed in silent mode, can only be used while seated, and can only be used in a manner that does not interfere with the ability other individuals to view or hear the proceedings. Individuals or groups failing to adhere to these rules will be subject to removal from the remainder of the meeting by the sergeant-at-arms. City of Chicago City Council Rules of Conduct for Public Meetings 2023-2027 Pursuant to Rule 58 of the Chicago City Council Rules of Order and Procedure, the sergeant-at-arms sets forth the following rules of conduct for members of the public. These rules shall be in effect at all times that a viewing gallery or room is open for a meeting of the City Council or any of its committees. All individuals and their belongings are subject to search at entry or upon request. Individuals must remain seated at all times except 1. when entering or exiting the gallery, 2. when providing public comment during the portion of a meeting set aside for that purpose, or 3. when asked to rise and be acknowledged by a member of the City Council. Profane, threatening, harassing, abusive, or defamatory behavior or speech, which in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the sergeant-at-arms may lead to a breach of the peace or disrupt the orderly conduct of the meeting, is not permitted. Disruptive or distracting actions, such as the stomping of feet, waving of arms, throwing any item, whistling, booing, shouting, or other loud utterances, are not permitted when in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the sergeant-at-arms, such actions are disrupting or impeding the orderly conduct of the meeting. Any item that poses a potential safety hazards, as determined by the sergeant-at-arms, is prohibited in the gallery. Such items include, but are not limited to, 1. any pointed objects, including knives of any kind, 2. banners, flyers, or other forms of signage, 3. food and beverages, including in glass or metal canisters, 4. backpacks, large bags, and sealed packages, clear bags, not tinted in color, that do not exceed 12 inches by 6 inches by 12, are permitted and subject to search, and 5. firearms, ammunition, fireworks, laser pointers, stun guns, tasers, mace pepper spray, and toy weapons. Cell phones and other small handheld recording devices must be placed in silent mode, can only be used while seated, and can only be used in a manner that does not interfere with the ability other individuals to view or hear the proceedings. Individuals or groups failing to adhere to these rules will be subject to removal from the remainder of the meeting by the sergeant-at-arms. City of Chicago City Council Rules of Conduct for Public Meetings, 2023-2027 Pursuant to Rule 58 of the Chicago City Council Rules of Order and Procedure, the Sergeant-at-Arms sets forth the following rules of conduct for members of the public. These rules shall be in effect at all times that a viewing gallery or room is open for a meeting of the City Council or any of its committees. All individuals and their belongings are subject to search at entry or upon request. Individuals must remain seated at all times except, one, when entering or exiting the gallery, two, when providing public comment during the portion of a meeting set aside for that purpose, or three, when asked to rise and be acknowledged by a member of the City Council. Propane, threatening, harassing, abusive, or defamatory behavior or speech, which in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the Sergeant-at-Arms may lead to a breach of the peace or disrupt the orderly conduct of the meeting, is not permitted. Disruptive or distracting actions, such as the stomping of feet, waving of arms, throwing any item, whistling, booing, shouting, or other loud utterances, are not permitted when in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the Sergeant-at-Arms, such actions are disrupting or impeding the orderly conduct of the meeting. Any item that poses a potential safety hazards, as determined by the Sergeant-at-Arms, is prohibited in the gallery. Such items include, but are not limited to, 1. Any pointed objects, including knives of any kind. 2. Banners, flyers, or other forms of signage. 3. Food and beverages, including in glass or metal canisters. 4. Backpacks, large bags, and sealed packages. Clear bags, not tinted in color, that do not exceed 12 inches by 6 inches by 12, are permitted and subject to search. And 5. Firearms, ammunition, fireworks, laser pointers, stun guns, tasers, mace pepper spray, and toy weapons. Cell phones and other small handheld recording devices must be placed in silent mode, can only be used while seated, and can only be used in a manner that does not interfere with the ability other individuals to view or hear the proceedings. Individuals or groups failing to adhere to these rules will be subject to removal from the remainder of the meeting by the Sergeant-at-Arms. City of Chicago City Council Rules of Conduct for Public Meetings, 2023-2027 Pursuant to Rule 58 of the Chicago City Council Rules of Order and Procedure, the Sergeant-at-Arms sets forth the following rules of conduct for members of the public. These rules shall be in effect at all times that a viewing gallery or room is open for a meeting of the City Council or any of its committees. All individuals and their belongings are subject to search at entry or upon request. Individuals must remain seated at all times except, 1. When entering or exiting the gallery. 2. When providing public comment during the portion of a meeting, set aside for that purpose. Or 3. When asked to rise and be acknowledged by a member of the City Council. Profane, threatening, harassing, abusive, or defamatory behavior or speech, which in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the Sergeant-at-Arms may lead to a breach of the peace or disrupt the orderly conduct of the meeting, is not permitted. 4. Disruptive or distracting actions, such as the stomping of feet, waving of arms, throwing any item, whistling, booing, shouting, or other loud utterances, are not permitted when in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the Sergeant-at-Arms, such actions are disrupting or impeding the orderly conduct of the meeting. 5. Any item that poses a potential safety hazards, as determined by the Sergeant-at-Arms, is prohibited in the gallery. Such items include, but are not limited to, 1. Any pointed objects, including knives of any kind. 2. Banners, flyers, or other forms of signage. 3. Food and beverages, including in glass or metal canisters. 4. Backpacks, large bags, and sealed packages. 4. Clear bags, not tinted in color, that do not exceed 12 inches by 6 inches by 12, are permitted and subject to search. 5. Firearms, ammunition, fireworks, laser pointers, stun guns, tasers, mace pepper spray, and toy weapons. Cell phones and other small handheld recording devices must be placed in silent mode, can only be used while seated, and can only be used in a manner that does not interfere with the ability other individuals to view or hear the proceedings. Individuals or groups failing to adhere to these rules will be subject to removal from the remainder of the meeting by the Sergeant-at-Arms. City of Chicago, City Council, Rules of Conduct for Public Meetings, 2023-2027 Pursuant to Rule 58 of the Chicago City Council Rules of Order and Procedure, the Sergeant-at-Arms sets forth the following rules of conduct for members of the public. These rules shall be in effect at all times that a viewing gallery or room is open for a meeting of the City Council or any of its committees. All individuals and their belongings are subject to search at entry or upon request. Individuals must remain seated at all times except 1. When entering or exiting the gallery 2. When providing public comment during the portion of a meeting, set aside for that purpose or 3. When asked to rise and be acknowledged by a member of the City Council. Profane, threatening, harassing, abusive, or defamatory behavior, or speech, which in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the Sergeant-at-Arms may lead to a breach of the peace or disrupt the orderly conduct of the meeting, is not permitted. Disruptive or distracting actions, such as the stomping of feet, waving of arms, throwing any item, whistling, booing, shouting, or other loud utterances, are not permitted when in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the Sergeant-at-Arms. Such actions are disrupting or impeding the orderly conduct of the meeting. Any item that poses a potential safety hazards. Good morning, good morning, please. If you could, um, if you can please find your seats. I want to welcome everyone to the September meeting of the Committee on Housing and Real Estate of the Chicago City Council. The time is 12-14 and the meeting is called to order. Today, we have 15 items on the agenda. We will now start with a roll call to establish quorum. Vice Chair Mitchell. Vice Chair Mitchell present. Alderman Dowell. Present. Alderman Robinson. Not present. Alderman Harris. Present. Alderman Quinn. Present. Alderman Moore. Alderman Moore present. Alderman Tavares. Present. Alderman Scott. Present. Alderman Fuentes. Present. Alderman Burnett. Present. Alderman Rodriguez Sanchez. Presente. Alderman Quesada. Presente. Alderman Villegas. Presente, right. Alderman Mitts. Alderman Mitts is a present. Alderman Clay. Alderman Clay. Present. Alderman Happenworth. Present. And Alderman Manhattan. Present. That gave us 15 members, including the chair. We have quorum. We have a Rule 59 request from all the persons like Spada and Taylor. Can I, to participate remotely, can I get a motion to allow them to be added to the quorum? So moved by Alderman Casada. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All the opposed, say nay. In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. Now, do we have Alderman Lespada? Can you hear us? Yep. Yep. And Alderman Jenna Taylor? Can you hear us? Here. Your chairman. Thank you. So we have a few members that will be added for the purpose of the quorum. We have Alderman Conway and pro-temperial elder person Nugent. Go ahead. Thank you, Chairman. Pursuant to my role as president pro-temp under Rule 36, I intend to participate and vote on matters as an ex-officio member. Thank you, Alderman, that you'll be added as well. We have today, we have actually quite a bit of speakers. We have a full hand. I want to welcome everyone for joining us. We're listening to all the people involved in this, so we appreciate, and I think it's always good for the City of Chicago to have healthy participation. I thank you all for coming. We have 42 speakers today for public comment. As you know, the average attendance usually is 10 members, and it's three minutes each. With so many speakers, usually we allow everyone to speak. However, today it will be hard to do it with so many speakers, so for the sake of fairness, what we're going to do is double the amount of speakers, 20 speakers, at a minute and a half. That's the best we can do so that everybody can participate or as many people can participate, and we're going to do it via lottery. So we're going to have a box where everybody who signed up during the time is going to be chosen randomly. So 20 speakers are going to be chosen randomly, a minute and a half each. That's the least amount of time that we can allow so that you can have a clear statement. So we're going to start with, these are the first three names that came out. Lovenia Hood? Lovenia Hood? All right. And yes, and then so that we allow time so that we, the next one is John Kozlowski. John Kozlowski will be followed after Lovenia Hood. So maybe, John, you can make your way. Good morning. Good morning. My name is Lovenia Hood. I'm the Executive Director of Mothers Opposed to Violence Everywhere. I stand before you today to speak on the Senior Bill of Rights Ordinance, which has been delivered to the Aldermatics offices and given it to their assistant. This is a bill that specifically targets our senior citizens who live in senior citizens' homes or senior citizens' buildings. Please, I am begging each of you that's here. I know you know about the bill, and there's a lot of other people who know about the bill, and you've been staggering with this bill. You have a senior citizen person in your family. And senior citizens deserve to live a quality life no matter if they are rich or poor. And I want to say this to each and every last one of you who's holding up this bill. First of all, I'm going to say, get your heart in order. That's your brains. Think about what you all are doing holding up this bill. It is premeditated murder if you all allow these senior buildings to close. And seniors out on the street, think about what you're doing. Thank you. Thank you. Next, we have John Kozlowski. John? Followed by Michael Glaser. Good morning. My name is John Kozlowski, and I'm from the Chicagoland Apartment Association. I want to speak plainly. Even with recent amendments, Mayor Johnson's Protecting Renters Ordinance remains a rent increase ordinance. For years, providers and developers have warned of overregulation and unintended consequences, and they have been dismissed. We are now in a desperate supply shortage, and our warnings are still being dismissed. Propile's new requirements, costly legal risks, and unnecessary red tape on housing providers, driving up the cost of providing rental housing. When operating costs rise, rents rise. Renters feel that impact first and most directly. And you cannot say with a straight face that reshuffling fees to rent will help with affordability. If Chicago is serious about adding more housing, we cannot villainize the people who operate it. The mayor cannot champion new construction in one breath and then treat operators as adversaries in the next. That contradiction is immediately obvious to the very people who we rely on to build more housing. When the long-term operating environment becomes unstable and unworkable, some buildings will simply not get built. Developers will continue avoiding this market. Chicago is tens of thousands of units short of what residents need. Large, professionally financed multifamily buildings are essential to closing that gap. Other cities are demonstrating that when supply grows, rents stabilize and renters gain more choices. Affordability comes from more homes, more investment, and more options, not more hurdles. Pro moves in the opposite direction. I respectfully urge a no on the rent spiking. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Next we have. Thank you. Let's please. Please let's hear each other out. Michael Glaser followed by. LaKeisha Lowry. So Michael Glaser followed by LaKeisha Lowry. Go ahead, Michael. Good morning, everyone. My name is Michael Glaser. I'm president of the Neighborhood Building Owners Alliance. We have 12 organizations that are neighborhood landlord based throughout Chicago and Cook County. Our owners represent the naturally occurring affordable housing, and we are mostly folks that live in our neighborhoods, and we provide housing. We care about our tenants, we care about our tenants, we are directly involved in taking care of their situations. If they have problems in their apartment turnover, we work with them and talk with them. Many of us have day jobs, and we put everything we have into owning our buildings responsibly and providing for the needs of our tenants and our own futures, as these buildings do represent a massive investment for us, we're an important component of the housing market in Chicago, and I'm very concerned that this ordinance, by adding 100 or so new rules and regulations and burdens, is going to be too much for so many of our owners, and the temptation will be to sell. And there's one entity out there, a group of folks who are interested in buying our units, and they're not local. They're from New York. They're hedge funds. We have many of our members today who get weekly calls from these folks who really don't care. They're looking at the numbers and not the people involved. There is nothing in this ordinance that makes rents more affordable. Thank you. Next. Thank you. Next. We have Takesha Lowry, followed by Tracy Randolph. So Takesha. She passed. She passed. Okay. So we can bring another speaker. Tracy Randolph. Yep. Followed by Mecca Thompson. Good morning, everybody. My name is Tracy Randolph. I am a veteran, and I'm also a person that is very keen to the streets of Chicago. I grew up in the 100s, 154 South Aberdeen. My brother and sister were murdered here in Chicago. And for my family, real estate was a way for us to get out of the hood, get out of poverty. My mom was on Section 8. My mom had a link. My mom participated in every one of these public housing properties. She did all of it. But for us to get out, real estate was the way that we got out. Got my first building. And next thing you know, we're loaded with all of these different fees. How are we going to survive it? For anybody that's trying to make it out of the hood to get better and to stand on their own and not depend on the government system, you guys are making it extremely hard. And then we have no choice but to add it to our tenants. We can't afford it. There's an economy that we're all ignoring. There's an economy of real estate that is not just the building owners. It affects Home Depot. It affects them and who they can hire. It affects every sector of this industry, and we're crippling the economy of Chicago. Thank you. I want to recognize Alder Person Meets and Alderman Robinson as members and also Alderman Beal as a non-member for the quorum. We have Mika Thompson followed by Shania O'Sullivan. Hello. My name is Mika Thompson, and I am the housing chair for the west side branch of the NAACP. I am here today because I am very concerned with regards to the changes that are being proposed with the PRO and the fair amendments to the residential landlord housing ordinance. The NAACP today stands for now. Now is the time. We'll see you next time. We'll see you next time. to make affordability a priority in Chicago. Now is the time to make accountability a priority in Chicago. Now is the time to make constitutional rights our priority in Chicago. And we need to be concerned about protecting Chicago citizens from discrimination, bad actors, and overregulation. And right now, I'm very concerned that the proposals here are not addressing those things. It does not matter how many rental inspections you do. If you're not willing to hold those landlords accountable, those rental inspections are a waste of time and a waste of money. And we can go any day and look at the court dockets here in Chicago and see a number of households and housing units that have those inspections, have the evidence of slum lures or rat infest. Yes. Thank you. Yeah. We got your information. We got your contact information in the slip. Next, we have... Yeah, let's listen to one another. Next, we have Shania O'Sullivan followed by Stephen Rich. Let's listen to one another. Go ahead. Good afternoon, everyone. My name is Shania O'Sullivan, and I'm a youth housing organizer from Palenka LS&A, a lifelong Chicago resident and a neighbor from the 30th Ward. Today, I'm here to ask you, older people, to please support PRO. I'm in college, and I'm terrified for the world that I'm graduating into. I want dignity in my housing. I don't want to be subjected to the whims of my landlord. My grandparents are landlords, and they are deeply good people. I want them to be uplifted, and PRO can do that. PRO makes housing significantly more accessible for me. The Realtors Association claims in their critique of the ordinance that the current manifestation of the RLTO reflects a, quote, balance between the rights and responsibilities of both landlords and tenants. I strongly disagree. PRO doesn't solve our problems on its own. We need more abundant and dense housing. We need to uplift mom-and-pop landlords. However, these truths can all be held together. This isn't a zero-sum game. Landlords are housing providers, and PRO holds them accountable to doing just that, providing housing. I urge the Committee on Housing and Real Estate to advance the Protecting Renters' Ordinance to the full city council, ensuring stability for all Chicagoans, whether they own or they rent. Thank you. Next, we have a Stephen Rich, followed by Julie Dwerking. Stephen Rich, followed by Julie Dwerking. Hello. Thank you. I am a housing provider on the south side of Chicago. I was born and raised in the city of Chicago. My parents are from here. I believe, honestly, that this PRO ordinance is not going to hit the goal that I stated, which is to make housing more affordable and to make wealth easier built from, you know, to make a regular person easier to build wealth, right? I do think that there are solutions with that. We have a lot of vacant housing, a lot of vacant properties in the city of Chicago. I do think that there is bad landlords and bad tenants, but I don't think that making housing more expensive for providers to operate is the way to make it more accessible or more affordable for the average tenant. I think that most landlords that I know, because I'm also the president of the Southside Community Investors Association, most landlords that I know are very good and they are looking to make sure that they're, I mean, it's not across the board, right? But the landlords that I know are very good and they are looking to make housing clean, safe, and affordable for their residents. And if, okay. So I just would like to say that I think that we all should be able to come together. This is not, like somebody says, not a zero sum game. We should all be on the same side of the table looking at the issue. If the issue is to make housing more affordable, I think landlords, tenants, and city council should be in meetings, having conversations on how to hit that goal. Thank you. Next, we have Julie Dworkin. Julie Dworkin followed by Jonah Karsh. Julie, Julie Dworkin? No, Dworkin. Dworkin. Julie. Julie, Albany, Albany Street, 2445 North Albany. And next is Jonah Karsh. After that, Jonah Karsh. Good afternoon. I'm Julie Dworkin with Institute for the Public Good. There's an idea floating around right now that the deck is stacked against landlords when it comes to tenant rights and that landlords are struggling to survive in the current market. Here are the facts. Rents have increased nine and a half percent since 2023, the highest increase in the country. Average rent increase in the Chicago region, at least renewal, is $107. One second, please, please. We're all listening to one another. Everybody who had an opportunity to speak spoke. We don't want a shouting in between comments. I'm okay with you saying something right after, but let's hear to one another. I'm hearing everybody wants to hear to one another. Let's allow her to speak. My apologies. Go ahead. Nearly double what it was in 2023. Ninety percent of tenants lack legal representation in eviction court, which leads to three times the eviction rate than when they have representation. There are currently no limits to what a landlord can charge a tenant to move in or move out of a unit. Ownership of large apartment buildings by LLCs is nearly quadrupled, leaving tenants with scarce information on who to contact when things go wrong. You have before you a set of common sense reforms that will create transparency in building ownership, rain and runaway fees, create real infrastructure to enforce tenant protections, and ensure tenants have due process when they go to eviction court. The competing proposal fair, which will come before a committee tomorrow, is not a compromise. It is a rollback of 40-year-old tenant protections combined with essentially no reform. It will not provide legal support. It will not ban move-in fees. It will not provide full transparency and ownership of properties. It creates an aspirational office of rental housing in an already overburdened apartment, creates no funding mechanism, and makes it subject to appropriation. I urge you to vote yes on pro. Thank you. Jonah Karsh. Good afternoon. My name is Jonah Karsh. I'm a community organizer with the Metropolitan Tenants Organization. We are Chicago's largest citywide tenants rights organization, and we respond to thousands of calls a year on Chicago's only citywide tenants rights hotline. And it is with that experience in mind, we have a better vision than perhaps anyone into the issues that tenants face in Chicago. And those issues are not having access to attorneys in eviction court. Those issues are not being able to have their rights enforced by a city agency and being left to sue their landlords when there's an issue. Those issues are not being able to figure out who their landlord is because there's a whole web of corporate LLCs and registries and shell corporations. And another issue is junk fees. All four of those issues are addressed in the Protecting Renters Ordinance. We are also fighting for just cause for eviction, but that's a fight for another day. Right now, we're focused on passing pro. We've compromised, and we would love to see what will be a big transformative win for the tenants of Chicago. And before I close, I just have to say about Alderman Villegas' fair ordinance. He looked me in the eye when we met last month, and he said that he wasn't going to take away rights from tenants. Unfortunately, the new draft that he has socialized still takes away rights from tenants. It still takes away tenants' rights when they lack heat and essential services. It still narrows the definition of a lockout. It still doesn't allow, doesn't require CPD to respond to lockouts as they're required to do now. And so I think we have to look at what is actually proven, and that's what's in pro. It's what's been socialized for months, and I hope we vote for it. Thank you. Next, we have Chris Abbott. Chris Abbott, followed by Demetrius Bonner. Chris Abbott, followed by Demetrius Bonner. Good afternoon. I'm Chris Abbott. I am representing the 44th Ward Action. While I am, thankfully, at this point in my life, a homeowner, I am a powerful, loud supporter of pro. I have spent many years of my life. I'm also a 23-year veteran of the Air Force. All of that time was as a renter, and I know what it's like to be taken advantage of. Here in Chicago, I worked through the process of my daughter, who attended Loyola University, of figuring out rent in the North Shore part of the city and the challenges with that. Pro provides accountability for landlords. You should not be afraid of accountability. If you're a great landlord, like we've heard, you should be able to participate and provide the minimal level of protections that we're seeing with pro. And I would close with the thought, as I know our alderman is not here in the room, but we see very clearly. On the Illinois Sunshine website, it's the guys in the suits and ties here today who have paid for access to an alderman like Lawson in a ward where over 60 percent of the residents are renters. And we're going to make sure those renters are voters in February if we do not see pro pass. Thank you. And Mr. Bonner, Demetrius Bonner, followed by Ron Abrams. Mr. Bonner, followed by Ron Abrams. Good afternoon, everybody. Good afternoon, committee. Good afternoon, colleagues. I'm here about a very important issue about holding landlords accountable. There's properties that's being shut down. No fault of the tenant, but the owners for lack of completing work orders and things like that. This one particular property that I'm talking about was closed and shut down by a judge because the owner wouldn't repair the boiler. Now, it's not just that simple. The boiler had been in disrepair for over 20 years. This falls on the back of this city council. This falls on the back of the city inspectors. How many inspectors been out there to that property in the last 20 years? How many times have these people been cited and the city has done nothing about it? So now you're victimizing the victim. You put those folks out on one of the coldest days of the year, and then there was no accountability for the owner of the property. Come to find out, he lives in another country. So now let's talk about this. There needs to be a citizens oversight committee on these types of issues because when I call the city and ask them about the inspectors, oh, we don't have enough inspectors, then hire enough. Then what we need to do is have trying to build a better relationship with our city officials is to bridge the gap by having the tenants who live. Thank you, Mr. Bonner. Next we have Ron Abrams followed by Mr. George Blakemore. Hi, everyone. My name is Ron Abrams. I am an owner-manager. We manage about 2,000 units. I am wearing a sport coat as a sign of respect to the city council. I am not a corporate owner. I'm not an LLC. I'm a human being. My company, Silver Property Group, tries to treat our tenants the best we can. I am telling you today not as a threat, as an actual fact, that if this ordinance passes, rents will go up. Absolutely 100%. Yes, it will. And the reason is, much like property taxes, when our expenses go up, we pass them on to the tenants. Now, the cost to comply and the cost of capping fees, you know what's going to happen with those? Those are going to be passed on to the tenant as well. Why don't we, while we're at it, why don't we cap prices on gas, on eggs? I don't think it's even going to be legal, but, you know, why don't we hit Starbucks, too, while we're at it? There's no way the city has the technology to handle this ordinance. There's no way the city has the budget to handle this ordinance. The city can't get property tax bills out on time. How are they going to manage a 700,000-unit registry? Look, we don't need more government. We don't need more bureaucracy. We don't need no more patronage. We, this is a parking meter moment. Thank you. Next, next we have, thank you, thank you. Thank you. Next we have Mr. George Blakemore, followed by Anthony Stepter. Thank you. Mr. Blakemore, follow Anthony Stepter. I have been a property owner, and I have been a renter, so I know both. But what is happening here is that a non-functional government, a non-functional city council, non-functional, that will give or bring another people over, illegal over, to get housing. They pay for their housing. Then, Mr. Blakemore is playing the race card, and you have that card. With the NAACP, nothing that Rose Joshua is doing. Nothing. So I'm using my name to try to unite black people. You come together and advocate ownership. God lets you tell they got his own. Now, the federal government has now got out of the business of housing, especially housing black people. Play the race card. You black ones, play the race card. So we got everything we need. We just need to help each other and unite and advocate for ownership. God blesses the child that God is on. So the government has gotten out of housing, public housing, with the staff of Mick's house. Thank you, Mr. Blakemore. Anthony Stepter, followed by Patricia Rowe Easley. Anthony Stepter, Anthony Stepter, followed by Patricia Rowe Easley. Hi, my name is Anthony Stepter. I've lived in Chicago for 16 years, but all for the last four of those months, I was a renter. My wife and I recently had, even though I'm not a renter currently, many, if not most, of my neighbors are renters, and I love my neighbors. My wife and I recently had our first child, and we spent the first year of his life looking for a place to live that we could afford. We finally found a place that we love so much on the near west side and the 28th Ward. And in the four months that we've lived there, we've already had one family on our block forced to move after less than a year in their apartment. This was incredibly stressful for them, and we lost part of our community. So I'm here in support of PRO because I love my neighbors, and I want them to stay. I'm also here because I moved to Chicago 16 years ago because I had a lifelong dream of working in the arts. It was the best decision I've ever made. We don't talk about it a lot, but arts workers and artists are mostly working class. There's a recent study that says most of them make less than $40,000 a year, and stable housing is a lifeline for them. I've had the opportunity to teach art students at UIC, School of the Art Institute, and when I moved here 16 years ago, we had affordable housing and good renter protections, and I see some of that changing right now. Stable housing is a lifeline for them, and I urge you to pass PRO so that we don't lose the amazing creative workers who help drive the culture, tourism, and so much more in this city. Thank you for your time. Thank you. Ms. Patricia. Ms. Patricia Rowe-Easley. Followed by Alan Smith. Good afternoon, City Council. My name is Patricia Rowe-Easley, P. Rowe-Easley. I'm standing here as a Westsider. Every time I come down here, this is to discuss Westside business. I live in a home that my grandparents bought in 1972, and that's my mother's side, and we own the building on my father's side that my other grandmother bought in 1972, and me and all my cousins are on the deeds. I am standing here before you all today to change the subject just a little bit. We need the city council to amend the community block grant that we got from HUD in 2024. The city of Chicago requested $429 million of flood repair, but there was no money, zero dollars, zero dollars allocated to the homeowners, which means that now the mold is in the furnaces, it's in the HVACs, the windows are going to be closed in the wintertime, and we're going to be in another mold box. People lost everything during the floods because, again, we've been packing this stuff since the 70s. It is very essential that you all please talk to the Office of Management and Budget and ask them to pretty please amend the grant. This is so simple to do. It's a file on somebody's computer. All you got to do is open it, redo it, have the community meetings, send it back to Washington, and learn how to play nice. This is a tough city. The whole country knows that we're tough. We don't have to keep fighting the federal government, okay? Everybody loses when that happens, and we are going to go through another winter of being choked by black mold if we do not amend this grant. Please, please, please amend the grant. Thank you. Next, we have Alan Smith, followed by Rod Wilson. Alan Smith? Alan Smith? Otherwise, Rod Wilson. No, Alan Smith? He left, okay. All right, Mr. Wilson. So, in the city of Chicago, black constituents are disproportionately represented in eviction court. The pilot program provided to counsel shows that 95% of the people who wanted to stay in their home had a chance to stay there. This shows that the program is effective and will help black constituencies of this particular city. We know we lost over 400,000 people, black people, let me be clear, over the last 30, 40 years. We used to be 52 percent, now we're 28. We need to do all we can to make sure we stay in our homes. With the third and fourth wards being two of the highest wards that were in that program, we also know in our community we disproportionately have absentee landlords and landlords that don't live up to the standards and have violations. Having a rental registry and a rental protection bureau will allow the city to address this to make sure we're living in the conditions we need to live in. And for landlords that are saying it's going to cost them, it's only one fee. At the most, $60 annually, that's if you're a big landlord, to pay for the registration fee. So until we address rent control, we can't stop them from price gouging us. That's what's been happening. So they're going to raise the rents where they want to go. But they can't say that this is causing them to raise rents. All we ask them to do is what they're supposed to do. They're providing a right to us, a commodity, just like electricity and everything and water and gas. It needs to be regulated because we haven't been getting what we deserve. And the only. Thank you. Next, we have Eric Schwab. Eric Schwab, followed by Donna Smith. Eric Schwab, followed by Donna Smith. No, sir. Good morning, Mr. Chairman and the members of the committee. Thank you for the opportunity to speak for you today. My name is Eric Schwab. I'm here representing the Chicago Association of Realtors and our nearly 16 members, 16,000 members. I'm also a small housing provider here in Chicago, investing in the neighborhood I live in and the city I was proudly raised in. I understand firsthand what it takes to provide rental housing in this city. I also stand personally the small margins that are left over after the mortgage is paid, the property taxes are paid, after the trash and water are paid. Recently, I had a tenant whose lease was not renewed. Knowing the challenges of everyone relocating these days, whether you're a renter or a homeowner, I chose to provide them more notice than was legally required. After receiving the notice, the tenant stopped paying the rent for the balance of the notice period. And once we were in the unit, the cost of making it rentable again and repairing the damage was nearly $20,000 and took five months. This is for a unit that costs less than $2,500 a month. I share that story not to talk about the costs and the risks, because when we talk about housing, it can all seem theoretical. For small housing providers like me, it isn't theoretical. There's been a lot of discussion about pro-exempting small housing providers. That's misleading. It's only if you're only occupied. You could own one unit and be treated like a corporate conglomerate. Chicago already has a residential landlord-tenant ordinance with extensive protections and remedies for tenants. Housing providers have far fewer options when there are significant challenges like the ones I just described. We don't have portfolios to absorb a $20,000 loss. Those costs come out of our pocket. Much like the rise is insurance, maintenance, and undoubtedly the increase in property taxes to balance the city budget. Those costs have to go somewhere, and they end up with the tenants. Thank you. Next, we've got Dana Smith, followed by Leola Lewis. Dana Smith. Dana, thank you. My name is Dana Smith. I've been a renter in Chicago since 2010. I'm urging the committee to advance the Protecting Renters Ordinance to the full city council. I currently live in the 32nd Ward, but I lived in the 35th Ward for 15 years. I'm an elementary school teacher. I live check to check. My landlord for 15 years said I was a part of their family. I did so much for them. I managed the building for them. There were four of us tenants total. March of last year, they gave us all a lease non-renewal. We had to be out in 120 days. It was unjust. Our landlord admitted it was cruel, but they sold to a demolisher from Michigan, and our house sits vacant today as a multimillion-dollar single-family unit house is slowly being built. The only reason I was able to survive this excruciating ordeal while being a full-time teacher in CPS was because of the renter's protections we already have and the pilot program that gave us a right to free council. There is no way that the other tenants and myself, the four of us, could have afforded an attorney without these protections. We were able to get 30 extra days and $4,000 per person to help us move. That was spent on movers and a deposit for our next apartment, so please, please protect PRO. Please expand renter's protections. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Next, we have Leo LaLuis. Leo. Leo LaLuis. Is that right? 460 East 41st Street for the Senior Bill of Rights. And next, and the last speaker will be Jonathan Smith from MTO. Hello. My name is Leo LaLuis. Here we go again. I am here for the Senior Bill of Rights. A lot of things that you have in your PRO bill is also directed towards the Senior Bill of Rights. We, you know what we want because we know what we want. We are asking you to pass this bill to please for the Department of Aging. We would like them to be reinstated. It is time to vote. And seniors vote the most. And I am telling you, we will never give up on this bill. And like they say, you tell them whoever wins, like Paul Revere, the seniors are coming. And we will not, we will not let this go because part of your bill and your real estate bill is also pertaining to our Senior Bill of Rights. So we will keep on coming and asking you again. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Last speaker is Jonathan Smith. Jonathan Smith from MTO. How y'all doing? My name is Jonathan Smith. I'm a volunteer with Metropolitan's Tennis Organization. I spoke here on June 29th in that box about the ordeal that I've been going through with my property management. Two and a half months. Nothing has taken place as far as rent, as them trying to steady raise it. Nothing as far as the work orders. I still have mold in there. I had to pay for my own inspection that costed me $500. And they wondering why I ain't paying rent. I want to say something, but I'm going to be respectful. But my thing is this, to those who own properties and are landlords, I feel for y'all because I truly don't understand how protecting the renters' rights and expanding them turned into a financial situation. How the hell did that happen? Please tell me how that happened. You get what I'm saying? Like, it's just crazy. Like, it's not about money. It's about protecting the renters. Everything boils down to money. Why? Why? It's kind of crazy. Like, I'm a stellar tenant. Like, I help my neighbors. I take care of my unit. But I'm being punished for what? Because y'all allow anybody to rule? Anybody? Like, come on, bro. Thank you. Thank you very much. This concludes our public comment. The committee also received 31 written public comments. The written comments were emailed out and included in your packets today. We appreciate everybody who came for public comment. They did not have the opportunity to speak today. We do encourage you to reach out to the committee. We have continued to have town halls and conversations. We will continue to do so. So we'll encourage you, if you did not have the opportunity to speak today, we will continue to engage with communities. We encourage you to reach out to the committee. We want to make sure that we hear you. I also want to recognize Alderman Moore for the purpose of the quorum, a thing that we had you before, but just in case. Our first order of business is the Rule 45 report. From July 8th and July 14th, 2026, which was emailed and handed out to committee members. Can I get a motion to recommend approval of this report? So move out the president, Rosanna Rodriguez-Sanchez. All those in favor, say aye. All those opposed, say nay. In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. The Rule 45 report has been approved. Now we will move on to the items before the committee. We will begin today's meeting with two appointments to the Chicago Housing Authority Board of Commissioners, Ms. Ramona Westbrook and Mr. John Barlett. They will have two minutes to introduce themselves and provide a short summary on their interests in serving as a CHA commissioner. After all the appointees have spoken, we'll have the Q&A from the committee members, and we take a vote on the appointments at the end. So, do you want to please get settled? Welcome, both. You got any particular order you want to start? You want to start, Ms. Westbrook? All right. So we're going to start with Ms. Westbrook. Again, two minutes each, and then we have the Q&A. Welcome. Fantastic. Good afternoon, everyone. Thank you for allowing me to come before you this afternoon. I'm honored to be considered for the Chicago Housing Authority Board. Please allow me to introduce myself. My name is Ramona Westbrook. I am a proud Chicagoan, a Lindblom Eagle, an accomplished architect, a successful business owner, and an optimistic overcomer. I was born on the south side of Chicago and raised on both the south and west sides of the city. Both of my parents were civil servants, my dad, a 35-year veteran of the Chicago Police Department, and my mom, a public school teacher, for 35 years as well. Ironically, after retirement, my father worked for the CHA police training officers. My mother lived in public housing when she moved here from Mississippi. It is a full-circle moment for me to be here, as they both instilled in me the belief that when we work together, the human spirit will prevail. They loved serving the city. As a teacher, my mom used the city as her classroom. She took her students on field trips to the museums in what was then the tallest building in the world, the Prudential Building, Buckingham Fountain, and Wrigley Building. She also recruited me to help renovate our 1920s Chicago bungalow, where I learned to hang windows, wallpaper, and install flooring. Consequently, I fell in love with architecture and have been practicing for 40 years. In 1992, I became one of the first African American women licensed to practice architecture in the state of Illinois. My approach to architecture has always been simple and direct. I appreciate the beauty of the Wrigley Building and the practicality of the Chicago bungalow. The most successful buildings adhere to the tenant that form follows function. I'm a lead accredited professional because sustainable buildings not only enhance the environment, they also enhance the people who interface with them. Designing energy-efficient, durable buildings is a smart thing to do. When we build sustainably, we're not spending more. We're spending smarter, and we're protecting the investment for the next generation. Taking lessons from my parents, my practice is set up to design buildings where people can thrive, specifically places where people live, learn, work, and play. Our process begins with listening because when we listen, we respect and we honor and we celebrate the human spirit. Housing is not just about shelter. It's about dignity, stability, and providing a foundation where people can build their lives. I want to serve as commissioner because I believe I can help provide the foundational and fundamental need of housing. Without it, the city suffers. I want to see this city thrive, and I know that a strong, well-housed populace is the foundation of a strong city. That's where my foundation as an entrepreneur thrives. I have had to be resourceful, stretching budgets, managing risk, building teams, and delivering results even when circumstances were challenging. I understand what it takes to turn a limited budget into an enduring asset because I've had to do exactly that for my clients and for my business. Practical, ground-level judgment has served my company well for the past three decades, and I would like to offer that knowledge and governance to the authority. Making Chicago the safest and most affordable big city in America is an enormous goal, but it's worthy of pursuit. I've always been drawn to challenges that seem impossible at first, but they're the ones that yield the greatest reward. My experience as both an architect and a business owner gives me a rare, practical understanding of housing, sustainable development, and governance. I would be proud to put that experience to work for this authority and for the people of Chicago. Thank you. Thank you, Ms. Westbrook. John. Good afternoon, everyone and members of the committee. I, too, want to thank you for the opportunity today to talk to you about serving on the CHA Board of Commissioners. My name is John Bartlett, and I'm the former director of the Metropolitan Tenants Organization. I have been working on, I have worked on rental housing issues for almost 40 years, and ever since retiring from MTO, I have been looking for a volunteer opportunity to put my knowledge and skills to beneficial use. When a colleague of mine suggested that I apply to be a board member on CHA, I immediately thought this would be a great fit for me. I want to begin by stating that I am totally supportive of CHA's mandate to provide safe, decent, and affordable housing and to its vision of creating a thriving Chicago where every neighborhood has quality, affordable housing, and everyone feels welcome. I am passionate about affordable housing. So, you may ask what skills and vision I will be bringing to the board. There are many, but perhaps most importantly, I will bring a tenant-centered perspective. I am familiar with the laws governing CHA, and in fact, the laws governing most all rental housing, and I have general knowledge about many of the affordable housing programs in the city of Chicago. Throughout the years, I have answered countless questions from residents, and I know that the starting point for resolving any conflicts is to listen. And by listening, we hear the participants' concerns, and you get a good understanding of what tenants' expectations are of CHA, and thus can help the board and CHA leadership to prioritize expectations as we move into the future. I believe in tenant organizations and have years of experience collaborating with them. I believe that when tenant associations and management work together, we can create change and be successful. Community building is a partnership, and I look forward to encouraging that spirit of partnership and collaboration as a member of the CHA board. Health and housing also go hand-in-hand, and my experience in this area can only help CHA better serve its residents and improve their health. CHA could be a leader in ensuring that healthy housing is the norm. As the largest provider of affordable housing in Chicago, my hope would be to center CHA as a leader in the affordable housing to foster relationships with tenants, community organizations, and other interested parties throughout the city with the goal of solving the affordable housing crisis. Finally, as a former executive director, I am familiar with budgets, the budgeting process, being fiscally responsible, dealing with the day-to-day challenges of a nonprofit organization, and the flexibility required to prioritize programs, and the tremendous need that we have for affordable housing. I am familiar with the workings of boards, and look forward to bringing this experience and expertise to the CHA board of commissioners. I am a team player and strive to create a sense of teamwork where everybody can see themselves in the agency. In closing, I would be honored to have your support and to continue to play a role in ensuring that everyone in Chicago has access to decent, safe, and affordable housing. I look forward to any questions that you may have. Thank you. Thank you, John. Are there any questions by committee members? Please raise your hand so that we can answer any questions that you may have. No questions? Oh, Alderman Dowell, followed by Alderman Villegas. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'd like to know what positions you're taking on – whose positions are you taking on the CHA board? Whose term – whose expired term are you stepping into? I'll be replacing James Matanke. And I'll be replacing Matthew Brewer. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Alumada. Alderman Villegas. Mr. Chair, could you provide a list of the expired terms on CHA, starting from oldest to most recent, to the body, so that way we can kind of see what terms – what's there? No doubt it. Yeah, we'll be happy to provide. And then also, I guess to the board members. So obviously there's been a lot of contention around CHA and the new CEO that was approved and selected by the board. And the CEO has had a difficult time trying to recruit talent, given the fact that there's been a lot of pressure by board members to potentially replace them. Do you have any intention of replacing the CEO that was selected by a nationwide search? I don't know and have not had the opportunity to even meet with the CEO yet. So I don't see how I could possibly answer that. I have no intention to do that without. So you have no intention of replacing the CEO? No, I haven't met him yet, so I don't know. I would say pretty much the same thing. I wasn't there for that procedure. Oh, can you not hear me? Oh, there's better. Yeah, a little closer to the mic. So a lot of that has happened prior to us joining or being a part of that, so I wouldn't have any intention around that. So were there any questions posed to you during your interview process or your vetting process as to whether or not you would remove the CEO because of the fact that the administration feels a different way about the new CEO? That was never a part of my interview process. So no one in the administration said, hey, we want to point you there. We want to make sure that one of the first – not first, but one of the actions that you'll support is the removing the CEO? No, I've never been told to do that. So I would ask that as board members, if you do get confirmed, that this is an agency that really should not – politics shouldn't be played with. We're talking about people's lives. And as a former CHA resident when I was a child, this is housing that's much needed. And this is a department, an agency, unfortunately, that, in my opinion, needs to do a better job. And so if we can get politics out of it, letting professionals that have worked in other housing agencies throughout the country that was selected by a nationwide search have an opportunity to perform, I think the residents will win here. So I would hope that, if confirmed, that you would do that and not participate in the political show that's going on here because there was a CEO that was selected over the objection of an administration, even though the board made that selection and made it in a transparent way. Certainly my reason for being on the board is to serve their penance in CHA, and that's the highest priority. Thank you. Thank you. Alderwood Manhattan followed by Alderperson Nugent. Oh, do you want to point a clarification? That's the folks in the box. The mic's not in front of him. You can't hear him. Oh, sorry. We're going to – a little bit closer to the mic. Sure. Thank you. Thank you. Alderwood Manhattan. Great. And if you – just bend it towards you. If you bend it to be right in front of your mouth, you'll be good, too. Yeah, a little closer, yeah. There you go. There you go. Okay. We deal with this equipment all the time. Thank you, Chair. I'm in a similar vein. So I'm looking forward to supporting your appointments. And I know in some passing conversations – I don't think I have it with you, Ramona – but I had similar concerns. So the decision about who runs our CHA and that search for a CEO is tumultuous, I think, would be maybe the most diplomatic word I could use. But I know that the mayor had different intentions. I know that there were legal restrictions. We could not get the permissions from HUD. And then I know that while it might not be conventional or maybe the way it should have been done, the board did move, and they made a decision through a search, and they picked a qualified candidate. I've had the opportunity to meet with the CHA CEO, and he's in a pretty untenable place, right, because political things are happening, and it is making it difficult for him to do his job. So coming from the constituents of the 49th Ward and not just CHA residents but everyone, we need this agency to have stability, and we need a competent, professional, experienced person running this agency. I believe we have one now, right? I think we have one right now. And once you're on the board, as you guys are acclimating and working, obviously you'll have the authority to carry out new searches. I ask that you keep Chicagoans in mind. Absolutely. That you center the most impacted people and the business of the agency over the will of elected officials like myself or the mayor. Right? In making your decisions. We're in a place in lots of our institutions where we are, there's instability. Instability means that people aren't getting the services that they need. When it comes to management and executive management, it means people are leaving their jobs because they don't know if they're going to have one. It means that we're losing out on talent, and it means that people aren't making important decisions that they need in order to move forward. We are also under the scrutiny and in the context of a very unfavorable, I would say hostile, federal administration that is looking for every reason to diminish our city and to take things away from our residents. We don't need, right, middle school politics getting in the way and creating an opportunity for the federal government to come and take over the CHA or to appoint a receiver that they want. And work with the team that we have. Please use good, independent judgment and thinking to evaluate people. Don't let us down. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Alderman Harris. Thank you. I want to get some clarity about the other positions on the board that are empty. Could someone give me that? That's really important to me. I'm understanding that there are several people whose term have expired. And if I had my wish on this, I'm going to make a friendly motion to amend the Mantanki with Angela Herlock, to replace Angela Herlock, whose term has expired, and to remove Mantanki, who has an expired term also. Yeah. We'll be happy to share with you those vacancies and terms. And then, of course, and do... I just made a motion. So you want to make a motion on replacing the person who is... The vacant position with who? With Angela Herlock. Okay. So... If not, then I'll have a secondary motion to hold this appointment. They're expired. Because these are not the vacant... Right. Because they're not substituting Ms. Herlock. That is a different vacancy. So, not so sure. The motion is... I'm making a substitution of the expired term of Mantanki to be substituted with Herlock. Okay. So there's a... So there's a motion on the floor. One second, just to check on the... So we need a... So have you... Have you... Do you have... Do you have any... Anything... You can amend it on the face and we can get the paperwork later. That's not a big issue. Right. Can we take a five-minute recess so that we can send the official motion and then we'll reconvene? Five-minute recess. Six-minute recess. Six-minute Vinayra. Six-minuteslash. Six-minute recess. Six-minute recess. Sim- pattiness. we're going to resume our housing and real estate committee please if you can go back to your seats we're trying to figure out this with the law department so we're going to leave this item towards the end I think all the women Harris agrees to work a little bit so that we have the the right procedure thank you so much next we have item item 3 this is a substitute ordinance 2026.0026554 amendment of municipal code chapter 512 regarding the residential landlord and tenant ordinance the protecting renters ordinance we will hear a presentation from commissioner Marlene Hopkins of the department of buildings commissioner Lissette Castaneda department of housing and Young Young chief of policy for the mayor's office we can hold briefings this week to inform others of the changes in in in this ordinance and the copies of the substitute as per the briefing have been emailed and handed out to committee members in your packets before I proceed with the presentation can I get a motion to accept the substitute so move by all the person Rosanna Rodriguez Sanchez all those in favor say aye all those opposed in name in the opinion of the chair the ayes have it the substitute is before us I will hand off our guests to start us off with a presentation and explain the specifics of the substitute ordinance and then we also we have members in the panel for the Q&A we have Matt Stern deputy mayor deputy commissioner of DOH Edwin Ortiz Reyes director of policy and planning and legislative affairs of DOH and Donovan Harvey director of housing and Natalia Sorrilla director of through a policy for the mayor's office. So now we can start with the presentation. Thank you, Commissioner. Thank you so much. And please, we can be close to the mic. Thank you. Good afternoon, members of the committee and chairman. Thank you very much. Here today, we are excited to present an amended Protecting Renters Ordinance to bring more transparency and more affordability to our rental market in this city. In the 40 years since the Residential Landlord-Tenant Ordinance was first passed by Mayor Harold Washington, Chicago's rental market has changed dramatically. Growing numbers of out-of-state landlords target vulnerable communities, eviction rates have surpassed pre-pandemic highs, and non-refundable junk fees that would have been unthinkable a few years ago are now commonplace. The RLTO has not kept pace. And so to ensure that all Chicagoans have access to safe and stable housing, we've introduced the Protecting Renters Ordinance, or PRO for short. Since introduction, we've been listening to tenants, small landlords, large landlords, and alders to better understand how to strengthen this policy. And we look forward to sharing those amendments today and answering any questions you may have. So first, to go over the summary of what's been changed, our goal remains building the safest, most affordable big city and to make life more affordable for working people. That means protecting the majority of Chicagoans who are renters. In service of that ultimate goal, we have made the decision to amend the Protecting Renters Ordinance and remove the Just Cause provisions while maintaining the core pillars in the rest of the ordinance. We're committed to continuing to listening and working to make that policy stronger as we continue to get feedback from all stakeholders on all sides. Additional changes include adding an annual unit production report requiring the Department of Buildings to share annually on how many housing units are produced. We've added a question to the rental registry so that registrants must attest to the healthy and safe conditions of each registered unit. We're addressing a growing problem around ratio utility billing systems, or RUVS, increasing the notice periods required for a change in the billing system from 30 days to 90 days so that tenants have an opportunity both to understand the formula is being used and make the necessary budgeting required to afford the fluctuating payments, as well as numerous drafting clarifications which have been shared in a memo to all of council. So to zoom out, why do we need the Protecting Renters Ordinance? There are over 622,000 renter households in the city. 54 percent of Chicagoans are renters. We've seen a 35 percent increase in rent since the before the pandemic. We're looking at a $2,300 annual or average rent monthly. That means you need to make $93,000 every year to afford rent. We know that most Chicagoans are not making that. So what that means is that 48 percent of renters are cost-burdened, spending more than 30 percent of their monthly income on rent and utilities. We're also seeing surging levels of LLC ownership as an increasingly common way to own property. And holding property in an LLC is not inherently bad, but what this allows is for bad actors to hide behind numerous LLCs, and it makes it very difficult for the city to understand who are the owners and to track these patterns of negligence across the city. What that has led to, for one example, is the hundreds of properties on the south and west sides that were loaded with RAT-related ticket debt, and it was really difficult for a long time for the city to figure out that these were all owned by a common person. And if we had a rental registry and clear ownership database, we would have been able to intervene much sooner. Chicagoans are also facing a wave of junk fees that push the true cost of renting far above the base rent. These include application fees, credit check fees, move-in fees, move-out fees, property tax fees. Just this past week, we were at a listening session, and a tenant came up to me afterwards and said she was planning on moving. She showed me the application, and on the front page, it just says a $50 application fee. But when you go to apply, there's a $400 administrative fee, unexplained. It is time that we rein these in. Rent should be rent. It should be transparent, clear, and predictable. The Sun Times found that in a lot of bills, additional junk fees are increasing rent nearly 50 percent above the listed base rent. This is making housing and renting unaffordable in our city. Evictions are also back to pre-pandemic highs. 22,300 evictions were filed in 2024, and this is directly connected to unstable communities. And a University of Chicago study found that for every 1 percent increase in evictions, in that same census tract, you see an increase of 2.66 shootings. Evictions really break up communities, and they force people to move. You lose your neighbors, you might lose your school, you lose your support system and base. And so by keeping people housed, we really seek to strengthen our communities and make them safer. And with that, I will pass it to Commissioner Castaneda to go over the rest of the ordinance. Thank you. Good afternoon. As Jung has said, PRO has been updated after many conversations with various stakeholders. And so I'm just quickly going to ground us in the remaining four pillars of PRO. So the four pillars, just to name them, are the rental registry, the Bureau of Rental Housing Services, the codification of the eviction council program, and RLTO reform and tenants' rights. The first fundamental tenant now of PRO is the citywide rental registry. As a reminder, this will be the first time that the city has a centralized database that will collect information on landlord identity, ownership, compliance history, and rental data. Chicago is behind in that New York City and LA both have this, and other municipalities here in Illinois like Aurora and Juliet also have rental registries. This will enable the city to make data-driven decisions to track absentee landlords. And the tiered registration fees, which are going to be a one-time annual registration requirement, will help to fund the new Bureau within the Department of Housing of Rental Housing Services, and with DOB inspectors, DOL staff, and 311. The annual fee structure is based on building size, because we want to make sure that there is not an outsized impact on small landlords. Anyone that has one to four units will pay $20 per unit. Five to 49 units is $40 a unit, and 50-plus units will be $60 a unit. We have exempted all owner-occupied units, all owner-occupied buildings that are six units or less, and have exempted all subsidized affordable housing. We know that there's lots of concerns and lots of questions that people are bringing up. On the screen, you'll just see some basic examples. If a small landlord who owns a three-flat is asking, how does this help me, and how does this affect me? One of the things that we know is that with the rental registry, we will be able to hold absentee landlords accountable. We know that that will even the playing field, so that good landlords are not competing against bad landlords that cannot be taken to task for being bad owners. It will also help us develop targeted programs for the community. The new Bureau of Rental Housing Services that will be housed within the Department of Housing will provide compliance support and guidance to small landlords. These are the kinds of services that are often only found now through lawyers that cost a lot of money. This will be an opportunity for small landlords to also gain access to guidance through the city. If you live in your three-flat, you won't have to pay anything, and if you don't live in the three-flat, it'll be $60 in total otherwise. Once a year, folks will have to complete a short form with basic details about their property and their contact information. Personal information like owner addresses and contact information will be kept private. What will be public will be information about the property, such as units, bedrooms, amenities, maintenance, leasing information, things that are generally public anyway when someone enlist their unit for rent? And one of the concerns is, of course, what if I'm late registering? Part of the commitment that we have made is that during the first year, we will be about education and making sure that folks understand what the new responsibilities are. We do not plan on imposing penalties. Part of the commitment that we have made is that of the things that we need to have a lot of that first year. In the second year, a notice will come to the landlord to let them know and remind them that the registration is due. So the Bureau of Rental Housing Services will have benefits for renters, for landlords, and for all dramatic offices and community organizations. For all of these entities, it will be one intake point for all complaints, whether it's habitability, lockouts, fees, and retaliation if you are a tenant, whether you are concerned about having to navigate multiple systems as a landlord because maybe you're facing fines or something else that is out of compliance. The Bureau will be coordinating inspection and enforcement with DOB, DOL, and the Department of Administrative Hearings through 311 referrals. It will also provide for tenants free legal information and referrals and enforcement records to track repeat violators across buildings. Landlords will also get support with dispute resolution, which means that it's less time in eviction court and stronger landlord-tenant relationships. This kind of predictability will also be applied consistently, giving landlords the opportunity to not have to spend so much time trying to enforce and simply being able to have a good relationship and good outcomes with their tenants. For the aldermanic offices, you will be able to direct constituent calls to support, for support to the Bureau, and you will have real-time data on problem properties in the ward. Ultimately, it will make sure that we have one agency that is accountable for these outcomes citywide. The eviction council program is currently a pilot operating as a right-to-counsel program. Since July of 2022, reporting has found that for every dollar that the city has invested in the program, it has realized $2.75 to $3.35 in fiscal benefits. The program provides legal representation for all income-eligible tenants with an eviction defense. And as you can see from the map, there is not a single ward in which a tenant has not been able to use this program. And then finally, RLTO reform in the Tenant Bill of Rights. We are banning junk fees. It bans move-in fees, move-out fees, and other non-refundable junk fees. You can still charge certain fees, but a landlord will have to provide a written itemized documentation before charging this fee. There is the Tenant Bill of Rights, which just ensures that all tenants have the same base level of protections under the law. One of the things that we heard from industry partners in the couple of years that we've been building up to this has been the request for cure windows. So we have instituted cure windows that give landlord time to correct a violation before fines are issued. The windows can range anywhere from 1 to 14 days. And it generally just makes the RLTO more clear and accessible to landlords and tenants so that it can be understood by all without a lawyer. I'll turn it back over to John. Thank you, Commissioner. So we are planning and projecting a three-year phased-in implementation plan. When this is fully up and running, we will have 28 full-time employees able to support and enforce the RLTO. That is spread across the Department of Housing, Department of Law, Department of Buildings, and DTI. This will be fully paid for by the rental registry fee, which we project bringing in $22 million annually. And the first year, again, will be about foundation, education, that grace period, really making sure we're building systems and policies and workflows, hiring that initial core staff, and launching the rental registry program following the standard procurement process. We'll be establishing 3-1-1 routing and complaint intake lanes and data agreements to make sure our different departments' systems are talking to each other. This is a real issue currently, is that we do not have the data infrastructure in order to streamline our work. And so that is very frustrating. It leads to slow inspections, slow responses, not knowing how to get help. By speeding it up and making sure that all of these things are talking together, we're going to be better positioned to respond to constituents with concerns, whether you're a landlord or a tenant. Phase two, the second year, is really about ramping up. We'll be able to use that citywide data, focus on compliance. We'll be building the registry revenue and completing the available staffing throughout that. Then we'll be able to continue and expand our outreach, scale our intake and investigations and inspections process, hire any additional staff, and begin those complaint-based investigations. Again, the RLTO complaints will be handled by the Bureau of Rental Housing Services at the Department of Housing. Building construction code complaints will be handled by the Department of Buildings. Phase three, we're looking at full enforcement and optimization. This is when we'll start to institute penalties if there is still a failure to register after the grace period and ample compliance support and education. We'll look at coordinated enforcement between the Department of Buildings, Department of Law, and Department of Housing, and continue to use data-driven targeting and compliance monitoring, tracking any patterns we're seeing across the city. All in all, the Protecting Renters Ordinance benefits everyone, whether you're a renter, a landlord, or a homeowner. For renters, we're going to have no more junk fees, one place to find information, to file RLTO complaints, to get help and understand your rights, faster resolution of habitability issues, lockouts, and lease disputes, and connection to legal representation for qualified tenants with an eviction defense. For landlords, free compliance guidance, one streamlined intake channel instead of navigating six different departments. Faster dispute resolutions means less time in court or avoiding court altogether. This will help us level the playing field so that small landlords get the same access to city resources as large property managers, and those that are doing right, which we know there are many good landlords out there, will not have to be competing against those who are undercutting and cutting corners. For all of Chicago, we're going to be building safer communities with lower crime and safer neighborhoods. The centralized data will help us track building ownership and property information, again, bringing Chicago in line with other major comparable cities across the country, and streamline our coordination and enforcement of building violations as well as tenants' rights violations resulting in faster service delivery. Thank you. Thank you. Are there any questions by committee members? I expect there will be. All right. Alderman Quinn, followed by Alderman Harris. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. A hypothetical question. So, if using the one example with the three flat, so if you live in that three flat, you don't have to pay the $60 fee. How about a city of Chicago resident that owns a three flat but doesn't live in it? Does that city of Chicago resident have to pay the $60 fee? Yes. The rental registry is $20 per unit per year. Okay. But there is no carve-out for city of Chicago residents that own three flats that don't live in them? That is correct. Okay. The total cost of the Bureau of Rental Housing Services is $22 million, 22.4? The 22.4 is our projected revenue from the rental registry. That's going to support not just the Bureau of Rental Housing Services, but also additional inspectors for our Department of Buildings, Department of Law, and DTI support. So, there's 28 new employees we're going to be onboarding here in the course of three years. Four of the Department of Housing employees are existing employees, so we'll be able to move them off the corporate fund onto the rental registry fund. And then, so that leaves 12 new employees for net new for Department of Housing. And those four housing employees from the building department? From the Department of Housing. Department of Housing. Okay. And what happens when we fall short of the budget? Do those employees, do they get offloaded onto the city's budget? So, that is why we have a three-year phase ramp-up, and all of this will be subject to appropriation. And we'll do the annual, we'll follow the annual budget process, you know, hiring those appropriate staff when the revenue is available. I guess what I'm getting to is that it was reported earlier this month that our gap is about $800 million. I don't know if we should be in the business of taking on more employees when we're facing a shortcoming. So, I understand the three-year phase end. So I suppose it remains to be seen. We haven't been the best of collecting fees, fines, that sort of thing. So it's just a hepsom pause about that. Thank you, Alderman. We also share your concern about our budget gap. And I think one thing that's very exciting is by instituting a rental registry, we're going to have an additional revenue source to help address that gap. Can you speak to the just cause? And am I correct in this no longer, this pro no longer has the relocation fee? Is that accurate? That is correct. The just cause provisions and the associated relocation fees have all been removed. And why was that removed? You know, over the past several months, we have been listening to tenants, landlords, big and small, alders, housing advocates, community organizations to get feedback on that policy. And we're listening. We understand that there are still some concerns of unintended impacts. And while we fundamentally believe that tenants should not be displaced due to no fault of their own, we understand we have more work to do to strengthen that policy proposal before bringing it back to this body. Therefore, in alignment with the coalition of organizations who have been fighting for these policies for decades, we've made the decision together to remove this piece of the policy so that the other pillars can move forward. Thank you, Alderman Quinn, Alderman Quinn did have several of my questions, including the how much we anticipate this will generate. Could you tell me that how much we anticipate this registry generating? Just over $22 million annually. $22.4 million. $22.4 million. Okay. And I kind of wanted to go through, you're saying you're only hiring 12 new people for, and we're going to phase it in. Where are we getting the rest of the DOL, the DOB, and the DIT? Are they already existing? Those would be additional staff, again, funded by that rental registry. So there wouldn't be additional pressures on our corporate fund. So we are hiring more than the 12 that are going to DOH. So we're actually getting to the 28 number that we'll be actually hiring. That would be minus the four. That would be 24 people that we're going to actually hire. 24 net new. That includes beyond Department of Housing, four additional attorneys at our Department of Law, seven additional inspectors at their compliance bureau, the Department of Buildings, and support at our Department of Technology and Innovation. Okay. And if you could walk me through this, and I think you have, but the $20 is a one through four flat. If I don't live in it, I'm going to pay $20 per unit. Four through 49, I'm going to pay $40 per unit. And then if I have $50 and over, I'm going to pay $60 per unit. Okay. Annually. This is annually. Does this include senior buildings? It includes all rentals except for any affordable housing, income-restricted, nonprofit affordable housing, CHA, bills. HUD? HUD. Okay. All right. Those buildings would need to register, but they would be exempt from the fee. All right. Thank you. That's it. Thank you. Alderman Moore? Yes. Thanks, Chairman. So you said they still can charge certain fees based on expenses. Are those fees identified or are they just fees? Yes. So the Protecting Renters Ordinance adopts an allowable fee approach following the best practices of this type of policy across the country. And so what we do is create a list of specified allowable fees prohibiting anything beyond that. So the allowable fees include background check application fee capped at $20. It includes a pet fee, a parking fee if that is optional, things like any tenant-incurred costs like key replacements is allowable, and then everything else would be considered a junk fee and banned. Everything else would be considered a junk fee. So you're saying junk fees are included? No, we're prohibiting any junk fees except for the allowable fees. Okay. That's what I'm saying. So I just wanted to know the fees that were, and those fees are clearly spelled out. Yes, they are spelled out in the ordinance. Okay. And then there was something about a notice or something before you implement these fees I heard during the presentation. So help me understand that. So if there's a, you're saying the key fee or any of the pet fee and all that has to be noticed up at the time of lease, or if it wasn't there before, you have to have, what, how many days or something to do it? Thank you, Alderman. So I think there is a, the notice we're saying in terms of, like, grace is the rental registry fee, because that's going to take us time to educate people and that they know what their responsibilities are. As it relates to allowable fees, I'm happy to pass it to our Director of Housing, Donovan Harvey, to answer some more granular questions of how that rollout will look. How am I on now? Oh, yes, I am. And for the record, Donovan Harvey, Director of Housing in the Mayor's Office. So to your question, Alderman, at the beginning of the presentation, we talked about a change in the required notice period for a certain category of fees. That was the ratio utility billing services. So under state law, the requirement is 30 days. We've increased that to 90 based on what we've been hearing from folks, especially on the south and west sides, about the damage that ratio utility billing is doing in some of those communities. So what we've done is increased the required notice that a landlord has to provide a tenant if they're going to switch from individual to ratio utility billing or tenant paid to landlord paid or any kind of change in the billing system. Now they're required to give 90 days of notice as opposed to 30, which is the requirement under state law. Okay, so besides the rubs, I think is what we call it, besides that, are there any other fees that require any change of notice besides the utility fee? You're not changing any other notice periods. Okay, so all the fees that, the allowable fees that you're talking about, say I didn't have a pet fee like at the start of the lease, right? Then all of a sudden I add a pet fee. I can add a pet fee at any time. I don't have to, it don't have to be any notice period or anything like that? I think the lease would, I'll pass it to Donovan. That would be, so under state law that will take effect at the beginning of next year, that would be prohibited. Any mandatory fees would need to be included in the lease up front and that's state law? Until that, until that lease is up. Yeah. That's, that's correct. So once that lease up, then if I, if they wanted to renew that lease and then I included the pet fee, I don't, I don't, is there a certain, I don't have to give them any type of notice. It's just, okay, you're getting a new lease. Now it includes its pet fee when it did before. That's correct. It would just be included in the new lease. All right. All right. Thanks. I'll do with my mitts. Thank you. Um, what happens if a tenant or a landlord refused to pay the registration fee? What's the repercussion for that? So again, the first year will be, um, a grace period in education. We're not looking to penalize people. We're looking to support them, uh, in registering. It's critical for the city to have this information, just like we register every other business in our city. A nail salon is far more regulated than a rental unit currently. And so we want to make sure that as we are instituting this new process, first and foremost, they have someone to help guide them on what is required. We're going to make it very simple to fill out a form as a way to make this very easy for landlords. In terms of any penalties, again, our intention is not to be punitive, but to encourage compliance. We would issue a notice that they need to register and give them a time period by. which to do so. If after that they still are not in compliance, they would be fined or be subject to a fine issued under our code. And what's the fine? And what's your code? I'll give you that one second. Between $100 and $500, depending on the severity of the violation. Now we're talking about they couldn't pay a $20 or whatever registration fee. And now we got a fine attached to that. So how do we have that? Yeah, we would, again, issue a notice period to come into compliance. It's not that the moment they fail to register, we would send them a $100 fine. We would send them a letter. Hey, we noticed you didn't register. Please register. Here's the form to fill out. Again, it's for landlords who are doing right by the city and right by their tenants. This will never be... Is there problems being put in there for hardship or any emergency or something people are experiencing? Is there anything there? No? Yes, we can. That is obviously at the discretion of the commissioner. So yes, we can do that. We're looking at just to vote on something. Now, first of all, let me say how I feel about this is because we just got a briefing yesterday evening at 4 o'clock with some changes that's been made. And the changes have been made consistently through the ordinance being introduced. Several meetings in my community totally opposed the ordinance and we're trying to get there. But you made changes yesterday evening, which I haven't had a chance to go back and even share. So what are we doing here? Is this something we can... Are we looking at the whole list and have further discussions? I can answer that. So the briefings that we had were in line with a lot of the conversations that we have had in communities. You all are having a conversation. I could go back and ask now who's the organization that are having these conversations. Yes. Because they're not all of Chicago and that's all I know. Right. We are having conversations and the conversations will continue. The amendment that you got in the last briefing, we have had briefings on the previous version as well. You just took out the just calls when I just heard it yesterday that that came out. Is that correct? That is correct. It has been removed and we, you know, did that in response to the feedback we heard at your community meeting and others that we have heard and we appreciate the continued feedback and dialogue. Can we continue the dialogue? Absolutely. Because it seems like there's a need for some more dialogue here. Absolutely. We are absolutely committed to continue dialogue. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Alderman. Alderman Manahapenworth followed by Alderman Beal. Thank you, Chair. I have had a lot of conversations in my ward as well, Edgewater and Uptown in the 48th Ward. We are mostly renters, higher than the Chicago average. And so we also have a lot of small landlords that not only own, but they live in our neighborhoods. So we've had a lot of conversations. And my priority is to keep communities intact, including my own, where we're struggling to keep our naturally affordable housing intact, like our SROs. We've been struggling with that, as you know. So I appreciate this conversation. I wanted to ask several questions. And when electricity is not available to a tenant and they can't access their appliances for weeks and they call repeatedly to 311 and report, and they don't get an answer. And then they come to us and the management or the landlord doesn't respond. Who is actually responsible? Who in the city is responsible for helping to resolve this issue? And then, yes, tell me that. As a freshman Alder, you know, most of our inquiries have to do with housing. Good afternoon, Alderwoman Hoppenworth. So those 311 calls do come into the building department electrical bureau. The bureau does research the 311s that come in each day when we find that a tenant is stating that they do not have electrical service. The inspectors do go out. The code does require property owners to have an individual responding to those immediately, but we have found in many instances they don't. And so it then results in us having to do the outreach while on site to get someone there to basically reset the circuit breaker so that that tenant's power can be restored. So those calls do currently come into 311. Thank you. And you have been very helpful in many instances. I also want to ask what, how would PRO help in a situation like this? What would be different? So I think part of the coordination between buildings and housing is that they can also call over regarding the violation of the RTLO as well. So it would be a two-tiered approach, whereas we're looking at it from the electrical system to ensure that there are no violations with this system. But at the same time, because of the lack of responsiveness from the property owner, the RTLO provisions would allow housing to follow up on that aspect of that. So it would be two-tiered responses from both buildings, from the building code standpoint for a potential violation of the electrical code, but as well as housing for potential violation of the RTLO. And is this different than what is happening today? Yes, because currently the responsibility is with buildings. And when we don't find that there is a violation of the building code, we're not citing that. But in fact, that is a violation of the RTLO. And that would enable housing then to have some input in that as well with the property owner. Okay. If I may add on, Alderwoman, a few additional things will happen. Currently, the RLTO is only enforced by the courts. And so it is very challenging for a tenant facing an issue like you're raising to get that addressed. Additionally, we do understand while Commissioner Hopkins' teams are incredible and very fast and responsive and doing the best they can, they still could use more capacity. And so by establishing the rental registry, we're going to be able to increase the number of inspectors out there so that we can be even more responsive to these types of complaints. And we also look forward to having the Bureau of Rental Housing Services because we'll be able to have earlier awareness of these issues, ideally before they turn into a real crisis as a preventative holistic plan. Thank you. And then even before that, how right now, how am I as the alter person supposed to find out who owns or manages or who is responsible for following up to resolve issues such as this right now? And then how would PRO help? So right now, we know it is very difficult to understand who the right contact person is, who the actual owner is of buildings sometimes. So the rental registry would give you that clear access and contact information to make sure that that can be addressed. Thank you. And then in the case where someone has been reporting these issues and has not gotten any response from the response from the management, and then they find that they have been locked out of their building, how would PRO help address situations like this so the landlord can remedy it earlier? How could this help? Yeah. Thank you for the question. So in general, what will happen with the Bureau of Rental Housing Services is that the Bureau within DOH will be able to investigate any complaint related to the RLTO. And if there is a violation that it finds credible, then it'll be able to issue a compliance notice. And then the compliance notice will have a cure period, it'll have like all the remedies. And then if that doesn't happen, then part of the coordination that the Bureau will be able to do is to work with the Department of Law to then escalate that up all the way through the Department of Administrative Hearings if necessary. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. I bring all these questions up because this isn't a hypothetical person. This actually is a person who lives in the 48th Ward. This happened to Vanessa, and she rented an apartment for $1,995 a month. She paid $4,750 before she even got keys, and then she moved into an unfinished apartment. They had serious electrical problems. This is during our heat wave where we had wildfires, and they did not have any utilities, and it was extremely hot. She called 311 multiple times. She called our office, and she couldn't get any meaningful help. We are going to pursue this through the courts, so we are trying to not have something like this happen where people have to suffer through weeks and feel like they're not getting any support from the city. I share it to say that I, again, I have listened to so many stories from both tenants and landlords in the 48th Ward, and as a renter myself and as a mother of young adults who are trying to find affordable rentals in the city, it's very challenging. I feel like the rental registry very basically will help us to hold bad landlords accountable, not to punish small landlords, but to hold bad landlords accountable for small violations, for large violations, to help us keep communities intact. Also, the Bureau of Rental Housing Services will be that place where we could point my staff to get the help that we need to help resolve problems before we need to refer these issues to court. So I do support the pro-ordinates, and I hope that my colleagues will join me today. Thank you. Thank you. Alderman Beal. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Good morning, everyone. Good afternoon. Good afternoon. A couple of quick questions I have. We talked about the coordination of all these different departments. How is that going to work? So the coordination will work through the Bureau of Rental Housing Services. And so there will be dedicated staff whose job it will be to coordinate with the Department of Law, with the Department of Buildings, and anyone else that needs to be coordinated in the effort of enforcing the RLTO. Okay. Now we're going to look to hire around 12 people, and how many is coming from the Department of Housing? So the total new hires is 24 people as of right now. 12 would be for the Department of Housing. Four of the total 16 that the department plans on having for this effort are already on staff. Okay. And so we're going to add to their workload already? It would be a switching over of some of their work, and some of the work that they are doing is already part of the work that is contained within PRO. Okay. So if they're switching over, who's going to assume the workload that's being switched over? Where's that workload going to? Yeah. So some of the work that is already happening, for example, right now is the management of the right-to-counsel contract, which is contained within PRO. It will also be the work of equity officers who do the work of community outreach and engagement, which will also be part of the work of PRO. Okay. Let's talk about where Alderman Mintz was headed. If these people don't pay any fees whatsoever, say, four or five years, I don't pay any fees, what's the consequences? Are you referring to the rental register? Yeah, the rental register. If they decide, I'm not going to pay anything, and you send them a warning, you send them another warning, you send them a demand letter, you send them this, you send them that, and they still say, I'm not paying anything, what happens? Yep, so again, the penalty is $100 to $500, and that would accumulate daily, so it would be far easier for them to just register. Okay, so you say $100 to $500 daily? That's right, to encourage compliance. Wow. Like I said, if I can't afford $20, I sure can't afford $100 daily. Okay. So, again. Please, please, please, please, please, please, please, please, please, please. I'd just like to add, Alderman, again, we're instituting a cure window. The goal is not that the moment you fail to register, you're hit with a fine. It is to, again, remind you, please come into the claim. I laid the question, I'd say, five years down the road. I understand you're, you know, we want to encourage people. I get that, but that's why I laid with my question about if I don't pay anything and it accumulates four to five years, what happens? What's the enforcement at the end of that four or five years that I haven't paid a dime? The Department of Law would pursue legal action as it does for any other code violations for our municipal code. Okay, so that will probably add to our billion-dollar-year deficit money that we have not been collecting, but yet we're going to hire additional people. We're going to move people from housing over here, and we're going to create this whole new department. Basically, right now, we'll be totally unfunded because we don't have any of this money coming in, and it's going to fall back on the people of the city of Chicago. It's going to fall back on the taxpayers, and we're going to bloat our budget even further because I guarantee you, if people aren't paying their property taxes, they're not paying their tickets, fines, and fees, why would I pay a registration fee? Thank you, Alderman. Staffing would be contingent on the rental registry revenue coming in. You know, we've seen this model be successfully stood up in many, many, many other jurisdictions across the country, and we are looking to best practices to ensure that it is easy. Again, we've heard a lot of stories of good landlords who are doing the right thing, who want to comply, and we expect them to be in compliance with this modest fee. Well, I'm just, again, I am just looking at the past history of our budget being bloated because we're not collecting fees and fines across the city, but yet we continue to hire and do these different things, so I get that. Now, how are we going to hire these people, and we're currently under a hiring freeze because we have an $884 million deficit? How are we going to hire people? So, again, hiring would be contingent on the rental registry revenue coming in and would be put forward in the standard budget process. So if we have a hiring freeze, you're telling me you're going to hire people regardless if there's a hiring freeze? The first year, again, is, you know, we're not hiring right away. We are going to be phasing that in. It's not that, you know, 28 people are going to come on board tomorrow, and the hiring freezes for this existing year, that's not something we have currently proposed for next year. Okay, that did answer my question. If there's a hiring freeze, how are you going to fill these positions? So, again, the hiring freeze is for fiscal year 26. We are not looking to make any hires until at least fiscal year 27, of which we have not yet discussed if there will or will not be a hiring freeze. We're saying that we still have an $884 million deficit right now. There's probably going to be another hiring freeze next year because we can't afford to keep onboarding people, and we don't have the money. Now, that leads me to my last and final question. We have a very capable and appointed commissioner of the Department of Housing. Can you explain to me what the director of housing out of the mayor's office do? What the director of housing in the mayor's office does? Yeah, what does the director of housing in the mayor's office do that our commissioner is not doing? I would love to let the director of housing respond to that. Thank you for the question, Alderman. So, in the role as director of housing on the mayor's office business and neighborhood development team, my role entails coordinating between the mayor's office, Department of Housing, and CHA, as well as assisting in developing housing-related policy priorities, as well as housing-related matters unrelated to policy. Okay, so are you going to be the one coordinating all this? Principally, this would be housed within the Department of Housing, Department of Buildings, and the other departments that have been listed on the slides previously. All right. I'm done. Thank you. Aldo Person Fuentes. Thank you, Chairman. I want to help articulate this maybe in a different way. You know, the data that the Department of Housing and the mayor's office presented, you know, I can respect it. I want to talk to you a little bit about what happens in the 26th work. And this is particularly for folks that may not be supporting PRO in this moment, both my colleagues in the room, as well as folks in the gallery. One in 10 constituents in my office have a housing problem. This year alone, over 300 cases. A third of those cases, evictions, or a violation of the housing code. I want to give you a particular case. I have a constituent. She has two sons. She's living with an immense amount of roach infestation. Her son was in the emergency room for about two months because roaches had laid eggs in his ears. We cannot get a hold of the landlord because it's hidden behind multiple LLCs. The average housing case in my office, we house for about six months because of how difficult it is to get property owners to come out, to fix the problem, to get a hold of the people hiding behind LLCs. I have tenants that are living with immense mold. Young people, as we know, I represent a community that has had families that's been living there for 30, 40 years, renting, right? And they pay their rent. And the landlords expect their rent. And yet we have a hard time getting these folks out to ensure that their tenants can live in dignified conditions. Now, I also have fantastic landlords in my ward who go out of their way to make sure that their tenants live with dignity, who provide affordable housing. When there's a small issue, they show up. This is not for them. You see, 60% of my ward is renters. And a majority of those small landlords are also homeowner occupied. So they're not paying this fee, right? But we still have an obligation to make sure that we do a couple of things. That the tenants who live in our communities can live in dignified conditions, and it does not take us six to seven months to fix the problem. Now, I don't, you know, Marlene Hopkins, our Department of Buildings Commissioner, she's fantastic. I mean, Commissioner, I thank you for every time you pick up my phone call. I do. She picks up the call, and sometimes she personally, as the commissioner, is going out of her way to find out who is the owner behind the property, to put together a group of inspectors who can help us solve the problem. And even then, with the resources and her power behind it, we still hold on to cases sometimes for months because we don't have transparent data. And this is going to allow us to do that. Now, I understand the concerns of, like, the cost burden. Can our landlords afford it? It's why homeowner exemption, homeowners don't have to pay it. It's why we worked really hard to make sure that we looked at the ordinance and we took out the pieces that folks are really concerned about. Now, I personally have seen dozens of eviction cases in my office of tenants who have not done anything wrong. They did not violate their lease. And landlords, you know, want the right to rent to someone else or to flip that apartment around to increase the rent that they know maybe a tenant cannot absorb, and I get that. And on the other side of that, there's a tenant that's life is completely disrupted. They have 30 days to move somewhere. Maybe to come up with another security deposit to move their things. Right? So I know that right now we're thinking about landlords, and I do every single day. Look, I have lots of conversations with my small landlords, and we support them trying to get the city to support them. And I also have to think about my renters, who are teachers in our classrooms, who work at our grocery stores, who work at the small cafe on our commercial corridors. These are people who keep our economy running, who keep our communities going. And I want to make sure that they also feel protected by government. Because I know right now I have over 300 cases, housing cases, in my office, and we don't have answers for them. We don't have answers for them because we don't have a system right now that says that we have the transparent data to hold their landlords accountable who are keeping them in deplorable conditions. And the last piece I'll say is this. Every single one of our tenants deserve to have heat in the winter and air conditioning in the summer. We have had some of the hottest days that we have seen as a city. And I have a lot of residents right now that don't have air conditioning. And they don't have heat. And we have to make sure that if they're paying their rent, that the landlord is also meeting their needs. And that's basic. And I want to make sure that I can go back to the 300 individuals right now who have open cases in the 26th Ward and to tell them that we're going to make sure that when they pay their rent, they can live in dignified conditions. And that is both the spirit, the mission, and the data-centered approach that this policy takes. And I think that we've done a lot to make sure that small landlords are accounted for in this policy by all of the things that were removed. And so I thank you all for the time. I love the debate. Look, we're not always going to agree on the issues, and I'm not going to sit here and say that people don't care about tenants. I think we all do. I also think we see the situation differently. In this case, I think PRO right now is meeting the needs of every constituent that deserves our attention. Thank you. Alda person, Rosanna Rodriguez-Sanchez. And Alda woman, Scott. I want to echo what my colleague from the 26th just said, because we have exactly the same problem in the 33rd Ward. I don't have to repeat everything that she said, so I'm going to say that the only way that we are going to get a different result is trying something different, something that we haven't done. And I do understand that changing things and bringing in new ideas can be scary, and people can have a lot of questions. But the reality is that this has worked in other jurisdictions, and we have the blueprint to do it. The other thing I would say is that the coalition that has been fighting for this for years and years and years, these people are the people that I call when I get people in my office that are facing eviction. They are the people that take these cases to court. They are the people that counsel them so that they can have the resources, the necessary resources to defend themselves against predatory landlords. I have a landlord in my ward that also had buildings in my colleague's 35th Ward that had 70-something buildings all outside of code. He was a slumlord. He had a phone number that people could call from 8 to 8, 30 a.m. That was his management plan. We had to take all of his buildings to court, all of them, because he just simply could not bring himself to give his tenants decent living conditions. And the people who live in these apartments are the people who are the most vulnerable, are the poorest. And I think that we have an opportunity to be able to right these wrongs for people. So I hope that we are going to stand with the tenants. I hope that we are going to stand with small landlords and support them, because they also deserve that. But this is an incredible opportunity that we have to move forward protections for renters. And we should take it very seriously, and we should absolutely support this ordinance. Thank you so much for all the work that everybody has done to get this here. Thank you, Chair, and I move to pass. Thank you, Alder Person. Dr. Sanchez, we have a few more Alder Persons. Alder Person, Scott, followed by Alderman Quezada. Thank you, Chair. For the 24th Ward, there are several concrete reasons I have concerns about PRO, and it's particularly because a ward like mine has older buildings, small property owners, and vacant properties. Please be respectful. Thank you. And this is, you know, so I look at this is about collecting data. And even if you have a larger property owner that has 20 plus properties, I don't think $60 would really matter. But what we find it hard for those same owners to get them to cut their grass right now. And we have some of that information. And the fees are never collected from those particular owners. So I don't see how this is going to really make a huge difference. And this is not about shifting from the tenant to the owner. My dad owned our building in which we lived in, 10-unit building. And he was an amazing landlord with not being a rich man, but trying to make sure that he provided for people within the 24th Warden. Some of their rents were probably only $500. So we have a lot of landlords that rent out property because they do care. And, again, this is not about shifting power from one side to the other. You know, good tenants should be protected and good landlords should be protected. And this is always a hard fight when you are trying to protect both sides. And, you know, my real issue is about the data that will be collected that we typically have now that we are – it's hard for us to enforce with the staff that we do have. And when you live in a community like mine, you hear a lot of tenants say, hey, I don't know what to do with my residents. They're tearing up my property. What do we do? I have residents that say, hey, I have mold in my apartment. What do we do? There's a scuffle on both sides. And we do have laws that are in place for tenant rights right now and the landlord. And we have to come up with a better compromise because I just don't think $60 is going to move the – right, it's not going to move the needle. This is more so of we got to figure out a different way because that $60 is not going to affect the tenant nor the resident. And I want to see people in my ward, how you build a stronger community is having great people that live in your ward and having viable small businesses – well, they're small business owners because they own two, three level properties. And it's a struggle. We had a 130% increase on property taxes this year. And my residents are struggling. I mean, if it wasn't for the grace of the Staines Foundation who paid $2 million to 588 residents in my ward to get their property taxes on track, I don't know what some of them would have done because they bought into the affordable housing. And once their taxes were raised, there were no more affordable housing because those taxes made that mortgage go up. And what do they do? Pass that on to the residents. And I'm just – I'm in a lingo. You know, some of my concerns with the junk bond, what is considered the junk fee bond, what is considered the fees that are acceptable, that you all consider acceptable, and what is not. Because if I am a homeowner, if I'm a landlord, I'm going to protect my property because you see so many people leave these properties and tear them up and don't have a care. But what I've been doing for the 24th Ward, if you build more homeowners, then people, they'll care a little bit more about the properties as well. That home ownership means a lot to me in the 24th Ward in trying to grow my community. I'm not taken away from tenants. I just know that home ownership is important, and having those properties are important in a neighborhood like mine has been dilapidated for decades. This is decades of disinvestment. So this is hard for me because I care about both. I was raised to live in a 10-unit building, so I have respect for my tenants. I live in a home now, so it's a difference, but I just saw the struggle of my father fixing the boiler, fixing the hot water tank, and just being, that's a struggle. You're not, people think that you're rich, but you're taking care of a, it's like you're taking care of a whole family and still trying to maintain a building so that you can have equitable investments in a community. So, you know, for the tenants out there, my empathy is with you all. For the landlords, my empathy is with them. We have to find a common ground that really works. I don't know if taking the names down and saying, hey, this is Joe Blow, I don't know if that works because we have that now, and weeds and porches falling down, and we're staffed and we're not staffed. And so, for me, it's about revenue as well when you think about the budget. Where's this coming from when we're building these departments and we say that we have an $800 million deficit? Where's this money going to come from? Thank you so much, Alderwoman. I think a lot of what I'm hearing you describe are a lot of the same concerns that we all have. And I think ultimately when we look at PRO, it is a revenue-neutral way to bring more services for tenants and for landlords, right? I hear you describe a good landlord who's trying to do right and might still be struggling. The Bureau of Rental Housing Services within the Department of Housing, it's not going to be a separate department, will be a place for that, right? For tenants who struggle, this will also be a place for that. And our hope is that with the weight of the city behind this, right, with the ability to do enforcement, we will be able to get landlords to be responsive and to be responsible tenants. And, again, happy to continue the conversation with you. We have Alderman Quezada followed by Alderman Villegas. Thank you, Chairman. I want to thank all the organizations that have done the work in not only protecting renters and working-class residents across the city of Chicago, but also in making sure that we are modernizing our TLO, you know, regulations. Last time that this regulation was first put in place, Ronald Reagan was the president. I mean, it's kind of embarrassing that we're the third largest city in the United States and we have not modernized our housing legislation. You know, in my time as a lifelong renter, now as an Alderman, you know, I knock the doors. I talk to my residents all the time. And over this past year, I think I've really seen something incredibly quite frustrating. You know, I spoke with the resident Avondale just last month who had a tree growing out of her stairway. I had a number of tenants in one other two-flat whose entire property was infested with rats. They told me that they had been calling their landlord to no avail. We don't have that information for the landlords. There's no accountability. So when I look at these amendments, like the addition of the rental registry attestion that registrants must attest to healthy and safe conditions of each registered unit, that's amazing because right now with the housing conditions that some of our residents are living in, it's the Wild West. They have peeling paint. They have mold. They have cockroaches. They have rats. Yet they're paying their rent. A rent is a contract. And when you pay your money, you should have healthy, dignified housing conditions. So not only do we have a housing affordability crisis, we have a dignified housing crisis. We have senior citizens. The majority of the people who come into my office, just like my colleague was saying, are senior citizens. Senior citizens who are on fixed incomes. Senior citizens who are working minimum wage jobs or looking to pick up more minimum wage jobs. Or senior citizens who are actually looking for roommates because they can't keep up either with their property taxes or their rent. And I think it's truly devastating to think that we are turning a blind eye to the conditions of our residents. And I think that this legislation is seeking to address that. I also want to address that strengthening tenant rights and fighting for dignity for people living in their homes is not in conflict to building more housing. We can do both. We must do both. We can't talk about building housing without talking about protecting the people who are going to live in them. So these things don't have to be in conflict with one another. And I really encourage my colleagues to look at this as a good faith piece of legislation, to listen to the people of our communities, the most impacted people, poor and working class people. So I urge a yes vote on this item. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you. Alderman Villegas. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I have a few questions. I'll make a comment. As relates to just to get clarification. So some of the guidance that will be provided by the Rental Bureau. Are we held harmless if with any advice we provide? Because obviously, when there's a situation that occurs, the courts are usually the entity that makes the decision. But now we're inserting ourselves as an agency that's going to provide some advice. I wanted just to make sure. that as that advice is being provided, that we're not opening ourselves up to any type of lawsuits. Excellent question. We will be working closely with the Department of Law to ensure that anything we're putting forward is fully vetted. So the question is the guidance that's being provided by the city. If that guidance has a negative impact on either the renter or the landlord, is the city held harmless? The guidance is not legal guidance, right? It is understanding, for instance, I'm a landlord and I want to call the Bureau of Rental Housing Services. I'm not sure, say, what are the tenants' responsibilities. The Bureau of Rental Housing Services would be able to walk you through the tenant responsibilities. But there's also going to be the opportunity for tenants to call on landlords to say, hey, I have issues with roaches, structural, et cetera. Is the department then going to – what type of advice or what is the department going to do there with that? So in a roaches or rats example or maybe a building, a structural concern, we would route that to the Department of Buildings to send out an appropriate inspector, and they would follow the standard procedures before pursuing any type of legal action. I can pass it to Commissioner Hopkins to talk about that process if that's helpful. There you go. Good afternoon, Chairman. Yes, we would do our inspection to determine the extent of the violations as it would be related to a structural deficiency enrolled in infestation or any of the provisions of the Chicago construction codes that we are responsible for enforcing. They would refer it to us, and we would then continue with our current process of conducting the inspection and taking the appropriate enforcement action against the property owner. Okay, and just so I'm clear, there's nothing prohibiting someone from doing that today, correct? No, and then – I mean, actually, that is the way it goes today. But oftentimes, we receive complaints that when we go out, they're really not a building code violation. It is, in some instances, a violation of the RLTO, and we don't have the – there's no enforcement arm or any agency internal within the city to really address that properly. Cool. And then, Ms. Yoon, you mentioned yesterday during the briefing that the $20 million a year for the departments, but then you also mentioned something about an additional $8 to $10 million in other fees that potentially could come to the general revenue fund – or the corporate fund, rather? Yeah, our budget office did some projections based on typical compliance and projected some potential fine revenue that might come in. Again, a little bit of that is to be determined because this is – we don't have years of data to look back on. Should that come in, yeah, that would go towards our general fund. Okay. All right. So, thank you for answering those questions, and thank you for your presentation. So, Mr. Chairman and my colleagues, I think it's important to first put the premise aside that our colleagues don't want to protect renters. And unfortunately, Mr. Chairman, please, it's unfortunate that it seems like it's becoming more and more political. And the reality is that you have an ordinance that was crafted with a couple years' worth of meetings with tenant organizations, with housing providers, and it's good because that allows you a lot of opportunity. Unfortunately, members of the council were not involved in these, nor were we briefed along the way. And then all of a sudden, the ordinance was dropped, and we heard – and I'm glad that the mayor and the administration decided to pull out just cause of relocation fees at this time because we know that those types of unfunded mandates ultimately end up costs – end up being an extra charge for renters. We know that. It's simple economics. And so, we're glad that that occurred. That being said, the speed that you're trying to move this, given the fact that there are a lot of similarities between the ordinances and a lot of concerns from my colleagues, just says, is there an opportunity to continue dialogue so that way we can get to a point where we can get an agreed-upon ordinance? So, that's that. That. We also need to begin to deal with the issue around building in the city of Chicago. Chicago's last as a big city, and Illinois' second worst in the country, behind Alaska, as it relates to bringing new housing. So, yes, we have a housing deficit. We have a housing shortage, and that's ultimately what's going to help bring down rents and housing costs because we see that it's worked in Phoenix, Nashville, as well as in Austin. So, the more housing that we can provide and the quicker we can get it online, I think that benefits all of us because now we're reducing rents, but at the same time creating new revenue for the city that the city needs, given that we have over 150,000 units that we need to put online in order to meet the demand. So, I would love to see if we can continue dialogue. Obviously, you'll vote pro today. You'll pass it today, and then tomorrow we'll have a zoning committee. And my intent is to pass fair to continue having a dialogue. But if you're going to play politics and try to put myself and my colleagues in a position that if we don't support pro, that somehow we're anti-renters, that we're against the renters, that's not what this is about. It should be about making sure that we have a balance. There is an ecosystem that exists in the city of Chicago. We have renters, but we don't have renters without housing. We don't have housing without renters. And guess what? We don't have housing without any investors as well that want to build here. And because those other markets are saturated, Chicago is in a great position to attract those investments. But they're on the sidelines. The pension funds and the private equity firms out of New York that help fund these projects are on the sidelines because they're waiting to see what types of policies are going to make it more difficult to rent and at some point make a return on investment. Again, this is economics that we're talking about. You look no further than the Fulton market where the Department of Zoning and the Plan Commission has approved thousands of units. They're entitled. There's no funding. Why? Because of the unpredictability of what the city is going to mandate on these folks that want to make these investments. So I would urge the administration to continue having dialogue. You've took out two of the main things that our ordinance never had in there because we know that unfunded mandates ultimately end up costing renters. So we agree on that now, which is great. There are other things in here I think that we can get to a situation where, for once, maybe we can collaborate and figure out how to get something done that ultimately helps the people of Chicago, that we all want to help, attract investors and businesses here and buildings here so we can help ourselves with as it relates to creating new revenue and addressing the housing shortage. We're close. So if there's an opportunity to work together, I would love to see it. But if you're going to pass Pearl today, then we'll pass ours tomorrow. And hopefully then that will force more conversation. But listen, we only had a couple of months. You had two years. So we met with tenant organizations, housing providers, and investors to kind of get a sense as to what the landscape looks like. Unfortunately, we were put in a position where we had to craft something a lot quicker than we would have wanted to because we would have wanted more feedback, and similar to what you guys did. So that being said, I hope that at some point we can continue dialogue. At this time, I can't support it, only because there's still more work to be done. And I would love for us to at some point get to a point where we can collaborate and have a lot more of an ordinance that takes into account everybody's consideration. So thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Chairman. Please, please, please, please, please, please, we're hearing one another here. Please. Thank you, Chairman. I appreciate, you know, we are very proud of what we've been able to put forward after years of dialogue, dialogue, as you mentioned, and we are absolutely committed to continuing to work with you and collaborate with you in the full member body of full, the full body of city council. Just like we were pleased to collaborate on the legalization of additional dwelling units and cut the tape and green social housing. We are committed to a comprehensive solutions for housing. One ordinance will never solve every single thing we have. One ordinance will not solve the financial markets. One ordinance won't... help homeowners, you know, like we have to have all of all of this together to bring forward the safest, most affordable city. And we are committed to continuing that dialogue with you. I want to just echo what Jung has said. Again, I think that particularly as a Department of Housing, we've been really proud to do a lot of the work, a lot of the work we've done with you. And I want to highlight, right, that so much of what we have here today, right, is the result of listening, a lot of listening to landlords, listening to tenants and trying to put forth the very best version of this that we could for everybody. I talk a lot about the Bureau of Rental Housing Services, because I think this is going to be really incredible work, both for the tenants, for the older people who hear a lot of these stories in their offices. And in order to ensure that we can move forward, we're really just proud to have brought forth this option that, again, is revenue neutral. It's not an unfunded mandate. And that ultimately will allow us to bring more services for both tenants and landlords. Sure. Yeah. When I was talking about unfunded mandates, I was speaking specifically about the relocation fees that would have been in the tens of thousands of dollars. So that's the unfunded mandate I was talking about. Thank you. Thank you for clarifying, Alderman. We have Alderwomen Tavares, followed by Alderwomen Dowell and Haddon. Just to point clarification, I'm looking at this handout here. And on the bottom here on the right, it says $22.1 million in revenue that the city will be receiving. Can you just clarify, help me understand the breakdown of how much of the $22.1 million is going to be appropriated toward to? How much of that's going to salaries? How much is that going to, and so forth? I'd be happy to follow you through the chair to get you a complete breakdown. Again, that is just a projection of the revenue we seek to come in. The staffing, this is again also our projection of the need based on what we currently understand. That is always subject to change as we launch this and understand what the needs are. Maybe we need more inspectors in buildings instead of housing. We'll be able to be responsive with the revenue coming in. So that is really just a projection of the revenue. It's not a budget proposal. And you talk about the buildings, one to four units, five, and the fees associated. Where does church rectories fall into or like that sort of thing? Is there a category for that or are they, does that count towards this or no? Church rectories? Like a rectory, like a church. Any non-profit affordable housing is exempt would be exempt from paying the fee. Just wanted to clarify on that. Thank you. Thank you, Alderman Tavares. Alderman Dowell, follow by Alderman Haddon. You know, I've been thinking about this pro-fair thing. And to me, this is like just a feel-good ordinance because it doesn't really address, I think, the issues that we really see out in our communities. I mean, leaving HUD buildings out, they're some of the worst buildings. And I think that you need to spend more time trying to deal with the building courts, the judges to really move the needle on getting these and what to do with these slum landlords because they don't care anything about this ordinance. And we're not able to impact that. The people that are living in with the roaches in the ear that Alderman Fuentes was talking about. What's going on with that building owner? There's nothing. So I really think that this is just a piece, and I understand you talked about a comprehensive approach, but this is just a piece of the problem. And you're not even thinking about how to coordinate. I mean, that should be the guy that's in the mayor's office. That's what he should be doing. So I just wanted to lift that up. I think that HUD should be included. HUD buildings should be included. And just correct me if I'm wrong. You said that HUD buildings are excluded from this ordinance? They are excluded from paying the fees. Any subsidized housing is. However, HUD buildings and any other subsidized building are still subject to the ordinance. So they're still subject to enforcement actions. I know that Commissioner Hopkins shop will often work with those situations as well. And generally, the ordinance will give the city the ability to go after slumlords for RLTO violations for the first time. Right now, the only enforcement ability that the city has is through like the Chicago construction code through Commissioner Marlene's work. So walk me through, Commissioner, what this ordinance will do differently for a slumlord. So in a case like, again, so there's a slumlord, someone who has been unresponsive, right? Very often in the most extreme cases, which Commissioner Hopkinson talked about, we end up in receivership. And it is often over violation of the construction code, violation of like the physical situation of the building. Part of what the RLTO revisions will open up will be the ability to go after someone for also RLTO violations. So any place where you are violating the rights of tenants, the ability to go after that as well will, so that it doesn't escalate. The problem that happens right now, which again, Commissioner Hopkins can attest to, is that by the time that we are able to intervene, it is a really dire situation. And Commissioner Hopkins, I don't know if you want to add anything to that. Hi, Chairman. So as Commissioner Castaneda stated, our enforcement action in circuit court is against the building code violations. And as you referenced, we have had some challenges in the court proceedings with our bench, with the judges on the bench actually supporting the city's ask for receivers to be appointed. We've had some changes in the courthouse. We have some new judges. And these new judges seem to have a different perspective where they are committed to holding building owners accountable. And without going into too much detail, there was recently a property that was in violation of the cooling ordinance. And when we went into court, we asked for a receiver to be appointed, and the judge actually appointed the receiver. And it got the attention of the building owner. It motivated the building owner to do the right thing, because of course, he didn't want any liens filed against his property for any work that the receiver was going to do to restore the cooling system. And so there is a renewed hope that I have with our judges in the courtroom. We have three new ones, and they all seem to be very attentive to the request that the city is currently making for receivers to be appointed. So I'm optimistic that we will start to see a much different outcome for those cases that we are filing for the building code violations. And as Commissioner Castaneda referenced, the RLTO really has not had any enforcement action taken by the city. And I know that through this, or through an ordinance that is passed, that this will enable us, enable them rather, to be able to move forward with it. So the only times that we've seen the lockout provisions where we've had to work with the law department to help us notify the police department, when a landlord has locked out a tenant, and not maybe not lock out of their unit, but lock out through turning off utilities, the police has worked very closely to, in some instances, arrest those landlords for doing so, for violating that provision of the RLTO. But this gives the city the ability to take that enforcement action as well. Thank you. Thank you, Alderwoman. We have Alderwoman Haddon. Thank you, Chair. I just want to echo the thanks to our department representatives, to our community partners who have helped to work and form this ordinance, and to everybody in the chamber who's contributed to the debate. And I know we've got more discussion to move forward. You know, I'll echo Alderwoman Dowell's frustration. You've heard the stories, right? I think all of the elders here have had examples, experiences, like what some of our colleagues have shared. And when you're really working to serve your constituents, it can be incredibly frustrating to run into limits on our power. You know, Commissioner Hopkins knows we've had our fair share of really creative problem solving of trying to use her department and the building code to bring safe and secure. conditions, not just to the tenants in a particular building, but to people in the entire block, right? Like, because when you've got a bad building, a bad landlord or unsafe conditions, it's not just doing harm to those tenants, it's doing harm to your entire community. And even with all of her efforts and her team's attentions, I'd say we get middling responses on some of them, because it's to the extent of what we are able to do. So I share those frustrations. And I want to move us forward. This is going to help. So I move to pass. I think that the, thank you, Alderman Haddon. Vice Chair Mitchell wanted to add something. Yeah. Yeah. Thank you, Chairman. I share the frustrations of Alderman Dow. She and I have a lot of conversations around that. But I want to touch on something that is not present in either of the ordinance, the pro or fair. And that is a, and that is direct language specifically addressing the unique neighbor to neighbor dynamics of single family homes that are rented in our neighborhoods. I have four distinct communities, all of which, three of which are predominantly homeowner. Historic, that's home ownership. And over the years, due to various reasons, the single family homes are now owned by, they're owned by investors. And they're being rented out. So there, there is, it has been a huge, huge challenge with getting the investors to, when they do rehab the properties to do, to do just the standard level of basic rehab, the care and the skills that they employ in developing these properties are absolutely horrible. And then they put tenants in. Then on the other side, I have tenants who, who are nowhere near the best. So I have bad owners. I have bad tenants. They don't follow the rules of the neighborhoods. Don't own it. I have absentee landlords. I have more than you're allowed it number of people living in these homes. It is just, it is a dynamic that, that for as long as I've been on this council has been ignored. And, and, and, and, and commission knows, we've had conversation about the dynamics of my single family homes and how I feel about it. Um, so both of these ordinances that I've gone through, um, like any, any language is very silent to that dynamic. And then just to piggyback on one of the points that Autumn and Dow may, uh, we're, we're letting our owners of buildings appear to just exist owning vacant properties in our, in our neighborhoods. I have an abundance of beautiful, vacant buildings that I bet that are in the court system that these, these, these owners are just, they, they, they just allowing to exist and it has destabilized, um, my, my communities. And we, we, we have not done, I won't say anything, but I, I think that the, the change in that dynamic, we have not kept up with legislation, legislation has not kept up with that. So when we, when we, when we, we're looking to at a, a, a bureau of tenants, right? Well, I, I can argue that we need a more focus on, uh, um, staff provision and policy within the department of buildings, uh, simultaneously, quite honestly, um, to do that, to address those, to address those needs. Um, again, I have problem tenants. I have problem owners. I have buildings with deferred maintenance. I have buildings that are that, that, that, that are vacant. And I won't even get on how with the influx of the, the migrants that most of these buildings were able to just be occupied by, by that dynamic that, and that just, that just further, just exacerbated the problem. Um, I, I can go on and on. I think you, everybody here get, get, get what I'm saying. I, whatever we do, we have to include the, really consider all the dynamics of, of, of, of what, the city of Chicago is going through and not just, uh, the, the, the, the, the tenants, which I'm going to say the good tenants. Um, so with that said, I'll, I'll, I'll, I'll get off the mic, but I think we need, we, we need to, we need to really, um, consider the dynamics that we have not addressed in, in, in either of these ordinance, the fair and pro. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Vice Chair. Um, we have the, uh, okay, okay, okay. Yes, please, please. Um, any other, all the, uh, one more question on other personal limits? Um, in the, in the handout, on page 10, you have a city-wide rental registry, but I see 4928 West Chicago Avenue, Westside Health Authority. What is that for? It's just a screenshot of an example of what a potential registry could look like. Out of all this, do the people's, okay, well, let me take you to page five. Uh, hundreds of south and west side properties for sale, a mere legal fight against city's worst landlord. Who put that draft up? A load of rat-related ticket debts. And then I see Austin community. I want to know why. It's the only community got rats? What is this? Uh, older woman, um, that is certainly, I, I do apologize for, um, I see what you're saying. Um, the example is, uh, when folks try to put my ward down any different than any other ward, I know good and well this shouldn't be here. So, uh, and that was not to highlight any concerns with your ward. It was just more sensitive when you're doing this then. Understood. I apologize. Thank you. Thank you. I'll do a person. Um, I know that we have a motion by all the person, um, hadn't to move on this item. Um, can I have then a, um, a motion on the floor from all the woman, hadn't all those in favor, say aye. All those opposed to a name or roll call. So we got, um, a roll call request by all the person Quinn. So we'll, we're gonna, um, start a roll call. Yeah, I can finish. Uh, vice chair Mitchell. No. Uh, all the persons, Las Pada. All the persons, Spada. Yes. Yes. And I, yes. All the women Dow. No. All the men Robinson. Yes. All the women Harris. No. All the men Quinn. All the men Moore. All the women Taylor. Yes. All the women Tavares. All the women Scott. All the person Fuentes. All the men Burnett. All the women Rodriguez. All the men Quesada. All the women Villegas. All the women Mitz. All the women Clay. All the women Nugent. No. And chairman. Francisco Lopez votes yes. Does 12 affirmative, 9 against it, the pro-ordinance passes. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. Please, please, please. Okay, please. Please, thank you very much, everybody. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Read this and then take a brief piece of stuff. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, everybody, for participating. Yeah, I think, thank you so much. The DUPAS recommendation of these ordinance will be reported out at the next City Council meeting, which will be held on September 23, 2026. I do encourage, I know, I know Council members both, you know, I do encourage all of us. It's been 40 years we updated this RLTO, so looking forward to continue the conversation. Especially I want to encourage Alderman Villegas and I to work together because we don't want contradictions on these ordinance as well. So I do look forward to working together, and I'm really looking forward to address all the issues on affordability, property taxes, as well as the issues that small homeowners and tenants both face with rising housing costs. So thank you, everybody, and we will move on to the next item on the agenda. Yeah, so we're going to take a small recess so that we can go back to the appointments. So we're going to take a few minutes, and then we come back. Thank you. We'll resume the meeting of housing and real estate. We have received a Rule 59 request by Alderman Burnett and Alderman Robinson. Can I get a motion to allow them to participate every moment? So move by Alderman Harris. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed say nay. In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. Do we have now Alderman Robinson and Alderman Burnett? I think they're just logging in. But when they log, okay, they are waiting on the list. So we'll welcome in as soon as they come in. Now we're going to go back to the appointments. So today we had Ms. Ramona Westbrook and Mr. John Barlett for those two appointments. So we have a substitute. So the substitute has been received. Can I get a motion to accept the substitute? Second by Alderman Mids. Oh, there are two substitutes. There are two substitutes. You should just accept them. Chair Sancho Lopez, this is Alderman Nugent. I'd like to be recognized for Rule 59. Oh, thank you. Thank you. Yes, you'll be recognized. Thank you, Alderman Nugent. Can I have a Rule 59? So we got a motion. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed say aye. So we have now officially recognized Alderman Nugent as part of the quorum. So we have two substitutes because they're two separate substitutes. Can I get a motion to accept the substitutes? So move Alderman Nugent. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed say aye. In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. The substitutes are now in front of committee for review. So you move to Ramona Westbrook as commissioner of Chicago Housing Authority for a term effective immediately and expiring July 7, 2031 to succeed Matthew Brewer for his term has expired. So all those in favor say aye. All those opposed say aye. In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. The due pass recommendation of this item will be reported out of the next city council meeting on September 23rd. Can we have the next one, Alderman? Alderman Harris, I move appointment of John Bartlett as commissioner of Chicago Housing Authority for a term effective immediately and expiring July 7, 2031 to succeed Angela Herlock, whose term has expired. Thank you, Alderman Harris. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed say aye. In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. The due pass recommendation of this appointment will be reported out at the next city council meeting on September 23rd, 2026. And congratulations to both. We look forward to working with both of you as commissioners on the Chicago Housing Authority. Thank you. Thank you both. Next, we have item number four, ordinance 2026-0027-400, lease agreement with Neighbor Space, Inc. for use of vacant city-owned property at $5,900. $5,900. to 5910 North Lincoln Avenue as Community Garden in the 50th Ward. Mayor Solis from the Department of Fleet and Facility Management is present to testify on behalf of these ordinance. Good afternoon, Chairman and members of the committee. For the record, my name is Mayor Solis on behalf of the Department of Fleet and Facility Management. The department is requesting authorization to enter into a lease agreement with NeighborSpace, which is an Illinois and not-for-profit organization for the continued use of the city-owned lot located at 5900 through 5910 North Lincoln Avenue to be used as a community garden. Joining us today are NeighborSpace representatives who are also prepared to answer any questions that the committee may have specific to the organization and the community garden operations. The city-owned property is located in the 50th Ward, and Alderman Silverstein is in full support. The lot consists of approximately a third of an acre, roughly 15,000 square feet. The initial term of this lease will be for 10 years, and the base rent will be in the amount of $1 for the entire term. Under the proposed lease terms, NeighborSpace will be fully responsible for supplying and paying for all utilities that's associated with the site. That includes water, sewer, any additional utilities required for the safe and effective operations of the garden. The community garden was established under a previous lease and subsequent right-of-entry agreements. Beginning in 2023, it transitioned to being a 100% community-led, ran entirely by volunteers and neighborhood residents. Today, the garden contains 118 individual raised beds, measuring 4 by 8 feet. In 2022, 95 families actively gardened a plot, demonstrating strong and consistent neighborhood engagement. The garden sits in a unique location, nestled between single-family homes, multi-unit condos, schools, parks, and local businesses. It is fully organic, with no chemical pesticides or herbicides allowed on site. A number of scholarship plots are held in reserve each season to ensure access for residents and organizations in need, helping to maintain the space as a community asset. In addition to individual gardening, the group hosts communal activities, such as potlucks, meals, volunteer workdays, summer evening musical performances by neighborhood musicians, and educational sessions led by master gardeners. A major feature of the site is the Grow to Give program, where volunteers maintain long, V-shaped beds that are specifically dedicated to producing fresh vegetables for donation. Produce is delivered weekly to Inspiration Cafe, which supports people experiencing homelessness and those living in shelters across Chicago's north side. The garden has proven to be a catalyst for positive neighborhood development, an adjacent property at 5918 North Lincoln, which had been a previous junkyard for many years, was developed into condos shortly after the garden was established. And the residents credit the garden with improving the area's attractiveness and community identity. The garden group is now seeking a formal lease with the city to ensure long-term stability, maintain the space, and continue delivering these social, educational, and charitable benefits. And I respectfully seek your support for the approval of this lease so that the garden can continue serving the community. And that concludes my presentation on this item, and I'd be glad to take any questions. Thank you, Mary. Any questions from the committee members? Otherwise, can I get a motion to move? So move by the other person, Scott. All those in favor, say aye. All opposed, and aye. In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. The do pass recommendation of these ordinance will be reported out at the next City Council meeting on September 23rd, 2026. Thank you. Thank you, Mary. We have a substitute ordinance for the next item. There are two substantive changes made. The amount of the City Chicago Recovery Financing Plan, the CRP grant for permanent supportive housing was increased, and the environmental provision summary in Exhibit C has been added. Copies of the substitute have been emailed and handed out to committee members in your packets. Item 5 is a substitute ordinance 2026-0027320, issuance of multifamily program funds and other financial assistance to the Regenerator LLC for residential housing project at 6206 South Racine Avenue in the 16th Ward. Can I get a motion to accept the substitute? So move by all the person, by Bastian Mitchell. All those in favor, say aye. All those opposed, and aye. In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. The substitute is before us. Ryan Slattery from the Department of Housing is here to present this ordinance. Thank you, Ryan. Thank you, Chair. Good afternoon, Chair. Secretary Lopez and members of the Committee of Housing and Real Estate. For record, my name is Ryan Slattery, and I'm a financial planning analyst for the Department of Housing. Here's presents the Regenerator. Today's requested action is to approve and refer the Regenerator to City Council for the following, issuance of up to $7,773,157 in multifamily program loan funds, issuance of up to $10,992,687 in CRP permanent supportive housing grant funds, and then issuance of $1,982,000 in 9% LIHTC tax credits, and then disposition of the Chicago Public School property for the developer for $1. I can move that. Apologies. The project is located at 6206 South Racine Avenue in the West Englewood Community Area. It sits within the 16th Ward, represented by All Our Women's Stephanie Coleman, who did provide a letter of support for this project. The project proposed for the site and the Regenerator is an adaptive reuse of the former Granville T. Woods Academy, a Chicago public school building that was closed in 2013. The developer will acquire and rehab the approximate 83,000 square feet of former school space into 48 one- and two-bedroom units of permanent supportive housing for formerly incarcerated individuals, restricted to households earning no more than 60% area medium income. The project integrates three components, a robust health and wellness ecosystem, permanent supportive housing, and workforce development opportunities to assist reentry citizens. The project cost is approximately $40,204,900, with the city fund requests at $8,725,844. Construction is expected to commence at the end of this year and will reach completion in the beginning of 2028. The development team is a partnership between Gourmet and Companies, who holds 49% stake of the project, and then Go Green Development Group, who has 51%. Go Green is a Wisconsin-based affordable housing developer found in 1984 that specializes in downtown revitalization, the preservation of affordable public, rural, and workforce housing, and adaptive reuse of historically significant properties. Go Green Development Group is a community-driven partnership centered on 63rd and Racine that brings together Iman, Team Englewood, Rage, and E.J. Wood around shared community and economic development strategies, including affordable housing and commercial development along East and West Englewood. The architect is Nia Architects. The general contractor is Ujama. Applicate Thorne Thompson will serve as legal counsel. And then for the financing partners, IFF, who is a CDFI, will serve as permanent lender, and CIBC will be the construction lender. Here's just the context of the sites. So it's located at 62nd and Racine. Shown here are current exterior images of the former Granville T. Woods Academy that has set vacant since 2013. And the next three slides are some renderings of the future, which will include a four-story to the school. There's also a park there. And then the last one. Total development costs, as I said, was $40,204,900 for the sources. The equity counts for about $18.2 million. The city multifamily program funds is $18.7 million. There will be... There will be... Senior debt, $548,000, and then the other sources are $2.67 million. For the use of the side, the hard costs are $32.2 million, which is almost 82% of the budget. And then there's professional fees at $2.4 million. Financing costs at $2.15 million. The developer fee at $2.5 million. And then other soft costs, including reserves and marketing, totaling a little over $1 million. This is the proposed unit mix, which will provide 48 one- and two-bedroom units, all restricted to households at or below 60% AMI. Of the 36 one-bedroom units, 12 will be reserved for households at 30% AMI, 6 households at 50% AMI, and 18 households at 60% AMI. For the 12 two-bedroom units, 6 will reserve at households at 30% AMI, 2 at 50%, and then 4 at 60%. To recap, the proposal transaction before you requested the Department of Housing to issue up to $7,733,157 in multifamily loan funds and up to $10,992,687 in CRP permanent supportive housing grant funds, issuance of $1.982,099% LIHTC tax credits, and the disposal of a CPS parcel to the developer for $40, and supported the redevelopment of the former Granville T. Woods Academy at 6206 South Racine into 48 units of permanent supportive housing for formerly incarcerated individuals. Along with me today is Gorman & Company and GoBring Development Group to address any of your questions. Thank you. The applicant is also here. If you want to, yeah, if you want to introduce yourself, Cecile, you can do it over there in the mic. Yeah, right there. Hi, everyone. My name is Cecile DeMello. I'm the Executive Director of Teamwork Inglewood. I'm also one of the partners in the Go Green On Development team. I'm also an Inglewood resident, and I proudly raised my family in Greater Inglewood. Good afternoon, everyone. My name is Sana Sayed. I'm the Chief Growth and Strategy Director for IMAN, and also one of the Go Green Development Group board members. Thank you. Alim Amor. Yes, thank you, Chairman. I just wanted to add, and I'm glad they stayed. I think Aisha Butler from RAGE, which we are all members of over in that Inglewood community, she was here and she left, but I appreciate Teamwork Inglewood and IMAN for sticking around. I want people to really take a look at them because they're just not people who just came up to develop some. These are people, residents who have lived in the community, have done the work, and I mean, I'm talking about real work, and making Inglewood a stronger community. And this is what we, these are the people we want the money to go to. People who have lived there, who have, didn't run away, and I'm telling you, could have gone anywhere, but they stayed and decided to make Inglewood work. And for us to have this opportunity for them is great. I just want to thank them for, and not only investing their time, but their commitment and the resources that they have to building up a great Inglewood. And so I move Dupas on this item, and I hope all of my colleagues fully support this item. Thank you. I'll do one more. All those in favor, say aye. All those opposed, say nay. In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. The Dupas recommendation of this ordinance will be reported out at the September 23rd meeting of 2026. Congratulations. This is a great project. Looking forward to see it. Thank you. The remaining items on today's agenda are from DPD. Item 6 will be skipped today. We will come back on this. We're going to move on on this item. Item number 7 is an ordinance 2026. Yes. Oh, yeah. Yeah, we're calling. We're calling. We're skipping because it passed already, this item. So, yeah, we're skipping this today. So we're going to move on to item 7. Ordinance 2026.0027312, sale of vacant city-owned property at 4442 South Calumet Avenue to Fargo Ventures, LLC, under Chai Block Builder in the Third Ward. Seth Thomas from the Department of Planning and Development is present to testify on behalf of these ordinance. Hi, yes. Good afternoon, Chairman Cinchero-Lopez and committee members. As stated, this is a market rate land sale that was applied for during the April 2025 Chai Block Builder round at 4442 South Calumet. The site is in the Third Ward in the Southwest region, and it's in the Grand Boulevard community area. For some context, the site is 50 feet by 137 feet for about 13,700 square feet. It's in the RM5 zoning district, and the market value of the lot is $168,000 and some change. So this is the site condition. We'll go over it in a little bit, but this is a 50-foot wide lot that's going to be divided into two 25-foot lots. This is a TSL-eligible lot both by bus off MLK Drive and the Green Line, which is situated directly behind the lots in question. So for just a brief overview, the applicant is George Sanchez of Fargo Group, LLC, and the summary is a new construction of two three-story residential buildings with three dwelling units each, so a total of six dwelling units. Again, the market value is $168,000, and some change in the total project cost is $1.3 million. As far as a budget, the applicant is paying for this property with 30% equity and 70% in loans, and of that, about 80% is hard costs, 8% is soft costs, and then 12% is the acquisition. This is the site plan and floor plan of how the floor plan and lots will be situated. Here is a rendering showing the elevations of both the front and rear of the property, as well as the side of the property. I also want to make note that the applicant agreed to extend the brick wrap an additional six feet from what was required as part of the original design ordinance. And here are the kind of renderings or mock-ups of what the buildings will look like. And that concludes my presentation. I'm open for any questions. Thank you. Thank you, Seth. Any questions by committee members? By the way, I have a motion to move on this item. So move by all the personal inquiries. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed say aye. In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. The do pass recommendation of this ordinance will be reported out at the next City Council meeting on September 23, 2026. Item 8, ordinance 2026-0027-298, sale of vacant city-owned property at 5022 and 5026 South Dr. Martin Luther King Drive to R&D Builders, LLC, under Chag Block Builder in the third ward. Thomas Bellino from DPD, here to request authorization for the sale of city-owned land at 5022 South Martin Luther King Jr. Drive. The address is in the third ward, and we have the support of Alderman Dowell. It's a Grand Boulevard community area in the southeast planning region. There are two city lots involved, and the total market value price is $352,500, which is what the applicant, Eric Dantzler, is offering. And there's a total development cost of about $3.36 million. So this is the existing site context. You can see there's nothing on the properties currently. And the properties are near the 51st Street Green Line Station, as well as Washington Park. There will be a zoning change required from RS1 to RM5. You can see here a rendering of the project and some overview details. The applicant is proposing construction of three four-unit buildings and parking for nine cars. And the architects are listed there. This is a detailed project budget. It is funded entirely through, I'm sorry, 10% through equity and 75% through loans. This is a site plan with King Drive on the east and the parking in the back. These are elevations of the proposed buildings. Those are the front and rear. These are the side elevations. These are the floor plans for two of the buildings. And the floor plan for the other one is just flipped. These are just some additional renderings of the proposal. Let's see the front angles and the rear. So I'm happy to go back and answer any questions. And the applicant, Mr. Dantzler, is here if there are any questions that I'm unable to answer. Are there any other women now? I just wanted to say, since Mr. Dantzler has spent his whole afternoon here, thank you so much for staying. We look forward to seeing. The construction that you're bringing into the community, he is a developer who has been in our community and has done housing in the area, so we know the quality that he brings. And so I ask for my colleagues to support this land sale. Thank you. So move to pass by Alderwomen Mitts. All those in favor, say aye. Those who oppose a name, in the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. The do pass recommendation of this item will be reported out at the next City Council meeting on September 23rd, 2026. Congratulations and thank you for your patience. Only just a little more. The next one is him, too. Item number eight, Ordinance 2026-00-27302, sale of vacant city-owned property at 5316 South Martin Luther King Drive to R&D Builders, also under Chai Block Builder in the third ward. Again, Thomas, to present on this item. Thank you. Again, for the record, this is Tom Bellino of DPD requesting authorization for the sale of city-owned land at 5316 South Martin Luther King Jr. Drive. It's very close to the previous one, so a lot of the details are the same. Also in Grand Boulevard, Southeast Planning Region. This is just one city parcel, and the value is $160,000, which is what the applicant is offering, with a total development cost of almost $3 million. So you can see the site context here. It is between two existing buildings. It's directly across the street from Washington Park and within two blocks of the Garfield Green Line Station. The zoning is already RM5, so there is no change necessary. The applicant is proposing construction of a 12-unit multifamily rental building and a parking pad with five parking spaces. Again, this is R&D Builders, which is represented by Eric Dantzler. There's a project budget here. You can see about 13% funded by equity and the rest through bank loans and other financing. The total project cost is almost $3 million. This is a site plan here with King Drive on the right and the parking in the back. This is an elevation of the front and rear. This is the south elevation and the north elevation. And this is just another rendering from another angle. And these are the floor plans that would be the same for each floor of the building. There would be two three-bedroom units and one two-bedroom unit per floor. And there's four floors. So happy to answer any questions. And once again, Mr. Dantzler is here if there should be any questions that I can't answer. Are there any questions? Can I have a motion to move on this item as well? So move by Alderwim and Manahappenworth. All those in favor, say aye. All those opposed, say aye. In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. The due pass recommendation of this item will be reported out at the next City Council meeting on September 23, 2026. Thank you, Thomas. Thank you. Item 10 is Ordinance 2026-0027390, Sale of City-Owned Property at 1054 North Avers Avenue to JT Alternatives LLC under Chike Block Builder in the 37th Ward. Thomas Bellino again from DPD to present on this item. Hello, again, for the record, this is Tom Bellino from DPD requesting authorization for the sale of City-Owned Land at 1054 North Avers Avenue. This one is located in the 37th Ward, and we do have a support letter from Alderwim and Mitts. It is in the Humboldt Park community area in the West Plain region. There is one city-owned lot or one parcel, and the applicant is offering the market value price, which is $24,653, and the developer is GT Alternatives, represented by Kali Kakiani, who is in attendance today. Total development cost is about $343,000. This is the existing site here. You can see it's on a corner. It is on the corner of Avers and Thomas. The zoning is RS3, but because it is such a big lot, he was able to do setbacks big enough so that he can propose construction of a two-unit residential building and garage for three cars. The architect is Stern Architects. This is just a front elevation here. This is a detailed budget here. You can see it's funded entirely through equity. And this is the site plan here with that very generous side yard. These are the front and south elevations, as well as the north and rear elevations. This is the floor plan for the lower unit, which is four bedrooms and takes up the ground level, as well as a basement, and the second unit, which is two bedrooms on the second floor. That's all I've got for this one, so happy to answer any questions. And again, the developer is here. Should there be any questions, I can't answer. Are there any questions? No. Move to pass by Alderman Dowell. All those in favor, say aye. All those opposed, say nay. In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. The do pass recommendation of this item will be reported out on the September 23rd meeting in City Council. Thank you so much. Thank you for your patience and congratulations. Item 11 is Ordinance 2026-0027315, Sale of Vacant City-Owned Property at 3609 and 3611 South Dr. Martin Luther King Drive to New House of Flowers, LLC, under Chike Block Builder in the Fourth Ward. Ernest Bellamy from the Department of Planning is here to present on this item. Thank you, Ernest. Thank you, Chairman Sancho Lopez, and thank you, members of the committee, for the record. Thank God. Look at that. No time for it. Alderman. Absolutely. That's where we're going. We got it. I don't think he hears. Oh, there you go. Okay. Sorry, Ernest. No worries. For the record, my name is Ernest Bellamy. I'm a development land sales city planner in the Department of Planning and Development. I bring forward to you today a request for disposition of one city parcel at 3609 through 11 South Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Drive. The developer, Zyra Flores, was present a little bit earlier but had to depart for a prior engagement. The location of the disposition is within the Fourth Ward, Alderman Lamont Robinson, in the Douglas Community Area of the Southeast Planning Region. The disposition consists of two city parcels under RM5 zoning. As an October 2025 Shye Block Builder applicant, the purchaser, New House of Flowers LLC, is a longstanding developer within the Douglas Community, husband and white duo, who's been doing a bit of rehab of different properties. On June 11th, Alderman Robinson provided a letter of support for the land disposition. As an overview, the purchaser is proposing to develop one new four-story, four-unit apartment building with two car parking pads in the rear. The applicant offered offer amount of $68,401 is equal to the market value sale price for the two combined city lots. Total project costs for the proposed development will be $1,946,401. With a construction timeline of 18 months to commence two months after closing, the city lot is located mid-block on the east side of the 3600 block of South Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Drive. The combined lot dimensions are roughly 24 feet wide by 124 feet long. The land disposition area is roughly 29,775 square feet. For greater site context of the parcel within the Douglas Community Area, the site is a transit-serve location located half a mile walking distance from the CTA 35th Bronzeville IIT Green Line Station. In addition, the site is served by multiple CTA-TSL bus lines along Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Drive. Furthermore, the parcel for disposition is centered within a block of predominantly multi-unit residential buildings. Transitioning to the street view of the site along South Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Drive, we can get a better sense of the parcel in context with the immediate surrounding residential developments. As seen in this rendered elevation, the proposal will span four floors as well as have a basement and contain a Natal S. two-car parking pad in the rear. As an October 2025 Chi Block Builder applicant, the purchaser has gone through DPD's review process for applicability, the zoning, and design standards for development. The overall site plan shows the layout of the residential building, which fronts South Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Drive. The two-car parking pad will be off the rear alleyway. Next are the floor plans, starting with the basement. The basement unit, as well as the upper floors units, as you'll see in the accompanying slides, are of a two-bed, two-bath layout. Transitioning to the first floor, you'll see the other two-bed, two-bath unit. And second floor, again, with the similar two-bed, two-bath unit layout. The third and fourth floor will be the owner-occupied unit, which, starting with the third floor, majority of the social space for that unit will be on this floor, as well as one bedroom and one bathroom. And then lastly, on the fourth floor, is the remaining balance of the bedrooms. On this floor is the primary bedroom, as well as two additional bedrooms for a total of four-bed, three-baths for this unit. Next, I'll progress through the elevations. Here is the front and rear elevation. Overall, the materiality of the facade of the building and the overall building will be brick masonry. The front facade will have a stone base. And then on the side elevations, we'll continue that brick masonry, where this stone base will wrap four feet onto the sides of the side, both the south elevation and north elevation. Here concludes my presentation. I'll hold here for any additional questions from the committee. Any questions from the committee members? So moved by Alderperson Scott. All those in favor say aye. Those opposed and in. Depending on the chair, the ayes have it. The due pass recommendation of this ordinance will be reported out at the next City Council meeting on September 23rd, 2026. Item 12 is Ordinance 2026-0027380. Sale of vacant city-owned property at 2341 West Erie Street to Walsh Apartments, LLC, under Chide Block Builder in the 36th Ward. Ernest Bellamy, again from DPD, to present on this item. Good afternoon once more. Thank you, Chairman Citro Lopez and members of the committee. For the record, once more, my name is Ernest Bellamy. I'm a development land sales city planner in the Department of Planning and Development. I bring forward to you today a request for disposition of one city parcel at 2341 West Erie Street. In attendance today is Sean Walsh of Walsh Apartments, LLC. The location of this disposition is within the 36th Ward, Alderman Gilbert Villegas, within the West Town community area of the West Planning Region. The disposition consists of one city lot under RS3 zoning. As an October 2025, Shide Block Builder applicant, the purchaser Walsh Apartments, LLC, is a long-time developer within the West Town community area. On June 30th, Alderman Villegas provided a letter of support for this land disposition. As an overview, the purchaser is proposing to develop five single-family homes with a three-car garage per building. The applicant's offer amount of $1.5 million was $60,900 above the market value sell price for the city lot of $1,439,100. Total project costs for the proposed development will be $5.9 million with a construction timeline of 18 months to commence one month after closing. The city lot is located mid-block along West Erie Street. The combined lot dimensions are roughly 123.25 feet long by 150 feet wide. The land disposition net area is 18,450 square feet. For greater site context of the parcel within the West Town community area, the site is a transit-served location located a quarter-mile walking distance from the Metro Western Ave Station, which is serviced by the Milwaukee District North, Milwaukee District West, and north-central service lines. In addition, this site is served by multiple CTA TSL bus lines within a three-block radius. Furthermore, the parcel for disposition is centered within a block of predominantly single-family to two flat residential buildings. Transitioning to the street view of the site along West Erie Street, we can get a better sense of the parcel in context with the immediate surrounding residential developments. As seen in this rendered elevation, the proposal will span two floors and have a basement and contain a three-car garage per home. As an October 2025 shy block builder applicant, the purchaser has gone through DPD's review process for applicability to zoning and design standards for this development. The overall site plan shows the layout of the residential building, the five residential buildings, in context with the adjacent properties, which front West Erie Street. Each single-family home will have a three-car parking garage, which will be accessible off of the rear alley. Next are the floor plans, starting with the basement, which contains a few social spaces for the home, rec room, as well as a bedroom and two bathrooms. Next, transitioning to the main floor of the home, the first floor contains the remaining social spaces for the house. Uh, consisting of the family room, kitchen, dining room, and living room. Then lastly, uh, the second floor, uh, uh, which will contain the majority of the bedrooms, uh, for the home. Uh, the primary bedroom, uh, as well as three additional bedrooms and three bathrooms. Uh, next I'll progress through the elevations, which, uh, will all be distinctive and maintain a variety along the street wall. Overall, the materiality of the, the, um, elevations will be, um, of the two you see here on screen, uh, uh, face brick and hardy board siding with asphalt singles, uh, progressing forward to the 2331 building, uh, hardy board siding, stone veneer base, and asphalt singles, shingles, pardon. Uh, and then, uh, 2335 will, uh, also have face brick hardy board siding and asphalt shingles. And lastly, the 2337 will have face brick, um, flat panel hardy board and asphalt singles, shingles. The side elevation, the side elevations will be all the same. Uh, the materiality of these elevations will be hardy board siding, asphalt shingles, and a brick base. Here's the east elevation and the west elevation. And then lastly, um, are the elevations of the three car garage. Uh, uh, all the garages will be, uh, typical, all the same. Uh, they will be clad in hardy board and they will have an accessible, uh, deck on its roof. And lastly, here's the, the plans quickly. If you want to see those of the garage, uh, here concludes my presentation. I'll hold here for any questions from the committee. Are there any questions by committee members? So let's have a motion to move. So moved by Alderman and Metz. All those in favor say aye. All those in favor say nay. In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. The due pass recommendation of this item will be reported out of the next city council meeting on September 23rd, 2026. Thanks. So Ordinance 2026-0027-324, Sale of City-Owned Property at 4144 South Calumet Avenue to Neighbor Space under Chai Block Builder in the 3rd Ward. Jim Michaels from DPD here to testify on this ordinance. Good afternoon, Chairman and members of the committee. This item is a sale of City-Owned Property at 4144 South Calumet Avenue to Neighbor Space under the Chai Block Builder Program. 4144 South Calumet is approximately 25 by 130 or 3,244 square feet, but expanding existing Bronzeville Farm by approximately a third. The farm manager, Rosalind Owens, has been with the farm since 2021 as part of the Advocates for Urban Agriculture Farmer to Farmer Program. Bronzeville Neighborhood Farm has become recognized as a value community known for social events and educational programs. Partners with the Center of New Horizons, Summer Youth Workers, University of Chicago, and the Boys and Girls Club. The budget is approximately $30,400, which includes new raised beds, soil, and fencing. The farm meets the criteria for urban agriculture category and will be sold for $1. Ben Halpin with Neighbor Space is here if you have any questions. That includes my presentation for this. I want to thank the department and especially Ros Owens for her stewardship of this garden, which has turned out to be, it's really a farm, which has turned out to be a really great gathering place for community and for people to buy fresh produce. And, you know, just have an oasis in the middle of the city. So I just ask my colleagues to support this. Thank you. Thank you, Chairwoman. Can we have a motion to move on this item by Chair Mitchell? All those in favor, aye. All those opposed, aye. In the opinion of the Chair, the ayes have it. The due pass recommendation of this item will be reported out at the next City Council meeting on September 23, 2026. Item 15, Ordinance 2026-0027. Oh, 14. See, 14. Yes. Sale of city, vacant city-owned property at 817, 821, and 823 North Harding Avenue to Neighbor Space, Inc. under Chicago Block Builder in the 37th Ward. Jim Michaels, again, from DPD, to present on this item. This item is a sale of vacant city-owned property at 817, 821, 823 North Harding Avenue to Neighbor Space, Inc. under Chicago Block Builder Program. The Garden and Harding at 817, 23 North Harding is approximately 75 by 125, or 9,453 square feet. It has been in operation for 10 years. Neighbor Space, on behalf of Garden and Harding, owns one of the four pins of their existing garden and wishes to acquire the other three. The Kelly Hall YMCA has been integrating its summer camp into the space, engaging children in mindful planting and sensory gardening since 2023. Monthly adult wellness events bring 10 to 20 volunteers to help with the garden cleanups, planting, and maintenance. Community members also lead seasonal events, including seeding and harvest festivals, which celebrate the agricultural cycle alongside yoga, chair aerobics, and community concert. 10% of the market value for the open space category is $2,835. The garden group has a budget of approximately $77,000 for new raised beds, a nature play area, path, and patio. Ben Helping, again, from Neighbor Space is here to answer any questions you may have. That concludes my presentation on this item. Thank you. Are there any questions for committee members? Let's move by Aldo Mandao. All those in favor, say aye. All those in favor, say nay. In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. The due pass recommendation of this ordinance will be reported out at the next City Council meeting on September 23rd, 2026. Last item. Thank you for indulging with us. This has been a long meeting. So everybody who stayed, thank you. Item 15 is Ordinance 2026-0027-36-8. Sale of bacon, city-owned property at 5645 West End Avenue to adjacent owner Tracy Blackwell under Chi-Block Builder in the 29th Ward. Jim Michaels here from DPD to present on this item. This is the sale of bacon, city-owned property at 5645 West End Avenue to adjacent owner Tracy Blackwell under Chi-Block Builder Program. The market rate is $33,982 and the sale price is $33,982. Lot dimensions are 50 by 170. Tracy Blackwell is the adjacent homeowner and wishes to purchase the lot. The site will be graded, fenced, and landscaped as a side yard. Tracy has demonstrated strong community support. Since the site does not fit the criteria under the side yard category, the sale price is ineligible for the 10% market value. Our budget for this is approximately $50,000. We have alderman support, and that concludes my presentation on this item. Thank you, Jim. Any questions on this item? Otherwise, I have a motion to move. By Alderman, it may not happen. With all those in favor, say aye. All those opposed, say nay. In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. The do pass recommendation of this item will be reported out at the next city council meeting on September 23, 2026. There being no further business in a committee, you can have a motion to adjourn. It's a move by Chair Mitchell. All those in favor, say aye. All opposed, say nay. In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. This concludes the Committee on Housing and Real Estate. It is officially adjourned. Thank you so much for staying with us all this time.