Mic check. Mic check one, two. Mic check three, four. Mic check in the mic. Mic one, mic two, mic three, mic four. City of Chicago City Council Rules of Conduct for Public Meetings 2023 to 2027. Pursuant to Rule 58 of the Chicago City Council Rules of Order and Procedure, the Sergeant at Arms sets forth the following rules of conduct for members of the public. These rules shall be in effect at all times that a viewing gallery or room is open for a meeting of the City Council or any of its committees. All individuals and their belongings are subject to search at entry or upon request. Individuals must remain seated at all times except, one, when entering or exiting the gallery. Two, when providing public comment during the portion of a meeting, set aside for that purpose. Or three, when asked to rise and be acknowledged by a member of the City Council. Profane, threatening, harassing, abusive, or defamatory behavior or speech, which in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the sergeant at arms may lead to a breach of the peace or disrupt the orderly conduct of the meeting, is not permitted. Disruptive or distracting actions, such as the stomping of feet, waving of arms, throwing any item, whistling, booing, shouting, or other loud utterances, are not permitted when in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the sergeant at arms, such actions are disrupting or impeding the orderly conduct of the meeting. Any item that poses a potential safety hazards, as determined by the sergeant at arms, is prohibited in the gallery. Such items include, but are not limited to, 1. Any pointed objects, including knives of any kind. 2. Banners, flyers, or other forms of signage. 3. Food and beverages, including in glass or metal canisters. 4. Backpacks, large bags, and sealed packages. Clear bags, not tinted in color, that do not exceed 12 inches by 6 inches by 12, are permitted and subject to search. And 5. Firearms, ammunition, fireworks, laser pointers, stun guns, tasers, mace pepper spray, and toy weapons. 5. Cell phones and other small handheld recording devices must be placed in silent mode, can only be used while seated, and can only be used in a manner that does not interfere with the ability other individuals to view or hear the proceedings. Individuals or groups failing to adhere to these rules will be subject to removal from the remainder of the meeting by the sergeant at arms. All right. City of Chicago City Council Rules of Conduct for Public Meetings, 2023-2027 Pursuant to Rule 58 of the Chicago City Council Rules of Order and Procedure, the Sergeant-at-Arms sets forth the following rules of conduct for members of the public. These rules shall be in effect at all times that a viewing gallery or room is open for a meeting of the City Council or any of its committees. All individuals and their belongings are subject to search at entry or upon request. Individuals must remain seated at all times except, one, when entering or exiting the gallery, two, when providing public comment during the portion of a meeting set aside for that purpose, or three, when asked to rise and be acknowledged by a member of the City Council. Propane, threatening, harassing, abusive, or defamatory behavior, or speech, which in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the Sergeant-at-Arms may lead to a breach of the peace or disrupt the orderly conduct of the meeting, is not permitted. Disruptive or distracting actions, such as the stomping of feet, waving of arms, throwing any item, whistling, booing, shouting, or other loud utterances, are not permitted when in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the Sergeant-at-Arms, such actions are disrupting or impeding the orderly conduct of the meeting. Any item that poses a potential safety hazards, as determined by the Sergeant-at-Arms, is prohibited in the gallery. Such items include, but are not limited to, 1. Any pointed objects, including knives of any kind. 2. Banners, flyers, or other forms of signage. 3. Food and beverages, including in glass or metal canisters. 4. Backpacks, large bags, and sealed packages. Clear bags, not tinted in color, that do not exceed 12 inches by 6 inches by 12. 5. Firearms, ammunition, fireworks, laser pointers, stun guns, tasers, mace pepper spray, and toy weapons. Cell phones and other small handheld recording devices must be placed in silent mode, can only be used while seated, and can only be used in a manner that does not interfere with the ability other individuals to view or hear the proceedings. Individuals or groups failing to adhere to these rules will be subject to removal from the remainder of the meeting by the Sergeant-at-Arms. And we got our people in the box, Mary. All right, one more? Waiting for Yancey. Committee on Workforce Development will now come to order. Today we have one item on our agenda, 02026-0027470, an amendment of Municipal Code Chapter 292, 2-92, by adding new Section 2-92-4, establishing bid incentives for Chicago Jobs Plan Commitment. Before we begin, I'll conduct a roll call to establish quorum. Alderwoman Clay, working backwards. Alderperson Vasquez. Alderperson Vasquez is present. Alderman Spasado. Alderman Spasado is present. Alderman Quesada. Alderman Quesada is present. Alderman Taliaferro. Chair Rodriguez is present. Alderman Curtis. Alderman Coleman. Alderperson Vice Chair Gutierrez is present. Alderman Quinn. Alderwoman Ramirez on her way. Alderman Chico. Alderman Beal. Alderman Hall. Alderman Yancey. Alderman Yancey is present. And we do have President Pro Temp Alderwoman Nugent in the House. And she is present. And with that, we have a quorum. We have eight members present. We have quorum. The following alders have requested Rule 59 participation. And that would be Alders Hall and Chico. Can I get a motion to accept them into the meeting? So moved by Alder Vasquez. All those in favor signify by saying aye. Any opposed? Any opinion to chair? The ayes have it. With the lone exception of the colleague of the North. At this time, we will begin public comment period. I want to note that written comments received prior to the deadline have been presented to all committee members. We will limit public comments to 30 minutes or less. It will be less today. We have three public speakers. First up, only three minutes, please. We have Zoe Lee. I didn't get to speak at the zoning for pro and fair and fair and pro is going to advance in city council. The purpose of me fighting for my family was because the city of Chicago unlawfully demolished a private property without a court order. The buildings department and some alderman, Greg Mitchell, he says that the aldermen have police powers to demolish buildings in their ward. And the buildings department has said that they just they know all the violations. The inspectors will go out and, hey, they may be a corrupt inspector and get paid off and walk the other way. While they while some of these buildings don't get torn down at all, especially the ones who make sure that you guys have money in your campaign accounts. Prime example is the seventh war with the 75th South Shore building. You guys knew all of those violations. You guys knew the people that were living in those as well. Greg Mitchell did. But because Greg Mitchell was getting kickbacks from those developers, all of a sudden you guys were able to save that building. But a small business owner like my godfather who had his building in that TIFF zone. And was playing into that TIFF zone since 1998. Y'all happened to demolish that building. So both of the ordinance are terrible. And if constituents you are paying attention to me and my personal story and Chicago Flips Red, I would call up the aldermen and anyone that votes yes to that or is OK with that rental registry because they're going to continue to look at it. I would vote them out. I would vote them out. I would go look whoever is voting who's running against them. I would reach out to them. I would talk to them because it's about their personal interests and not the homeowners, the property owners. This is progressive versus moderate. This is socialism and communism versus the daily regimen. Regimen, they do not care about the real Chicagoans. It's their ego. And we're paying for it. Thank you. Next up is George Blakemore. Thank you. I think the chairman is also leaving the council. I think this is wonderful. We should have term limitations. Two years, two years, four years, two terms for four years, that's eight years. It's not an institution for 15 or 20 years. New York has 50. Chicago has 50. New York have 25. You're not needed here. Why would you want to stay here? And guess what, Mr. Blakemore, with that hundred and something thousand dollars they receive, it's a part-time job. What? Maybe we need to have a manager, like some of the city have city managers. And I don't have the answer, but I know what's not the answer is to have these same old political hacks. In place. I know that that's not the answer. And it's sad. And I believe that some of them are resigning and say enough is enough because probably maybe some of them might be indicted. Mm-hmm. And guess what else, Mr. Blakemore? What? With your old crazy chef all painted up. They're all Democrats. Well, Trump's a racist. Trump's not here with his non-functional government. His non-functional government dealing with the workforce. They have an agenda of an illegal workforce, an illegal workforce. And these black, all the white, all the Mexican, Chinese, they voted for illegal. And on these union jobs, when they get to buildings, they're talking about bidding. They have union workers and illegal workers. And Fred Winkle said that you got to give them comprehensive health care. And you have to tell chef, doc, don't send them back when they've borne out. Now, do you think that these countries are sending their best people over here? They're sending their rejects here because these people in Mexico who are clashing, they wouldn't wait across the Rio Grande with their little babies and everything. And you see them sucking their titties all out in public. No, they wouldn't do that. They sent their untouchables here. So they're greeting. And Mr. Blakemore, some of these husbands here are the one that's greeting. He used the truth. You look in that wall. And it takes one more. Order, please. Thank you. Go ahead, ma'am. Hey, good afternoon. Good afternoon. Could y'all hear me? We can hear you. Oh, okay. My name is Kushana Harris, and I'm a candidate for the Aldermity for the Third Ward. And today I just want to talk about policy reviews and policy provision reviews and city guidelines. I feel like things are not coming to line with the two, and we do need to do a policy review before we keep on introducing new audience and things like that because it just doesn't align. But we talk about workforce development. We talk about connecting Chicago residents with employment opportunities. We have job fairs throughout the year consistently, possibly once a month, offering a variety of city jobs, workforce, I mean, warehouse jobs, et cetera. But I have to ask, how are we truly going to build a strong workforce if people cannot maintain stable housing? We cannot continue to address employment and housing as if they are two completely separate issues. A person can have a job and still be at risk for eviction. A person can be working and still be in unaffordable housing in the communities where they live. Chicago residents should not have to choose between remaining housed and remaining in workforce. We need to look at housing stability as a part of economic development when residents are protected from the unnecessary displacements and the realistic of opportunities to remain in their communities. There are very strong positions to work and provide families with, to provide their families in these particular neighborhoods and contribute to Chicago's economic, economy. But where do that come to line with the residents here in Chicago? The value, our taxes, everything, the commercial taxes, none of it lines up. And we need to do a serious provision review on these policies with a lot of the city services that we have to offer here in Chicago, especially with the guidelines that we have to meet. We talk about all these unnecessary things when this is... It's a simple fix. I feel like as an all-dominant, the position should be if you care that much, you should go to these organizations and request certain documentation that cannot be found online and things like that just to get these things in order because it's just we're not a commonwealth state. We're not a commonwealth city. This is a city. This is Chicago. We shouldn't be exempt from certain things because we're suffering as a collaborative unit. Our residents are suffering. Our workers are suffering. Our taxpayers are suffering tremendously, and our city is in debt. So we have to tear it down to rebuild it, and I feel like that's the best suit if we want to push forward with opening up things that were taken from us, like the trauma hospitals and things like that, how we get more grants and more budgeting operations if we have debt that we're still playing with, piggybacking off of when it's not rocket science. It's not that hard. We have developers that are coming in our city because it's like a gold map. But what about the residents? We're not the gold to be digging up on. And that goes up. Thank you. Thank you, ma'am. As there are no further speakers, we will now move on to our agenda item 02026-0027470, an amendment of Municipal Code Chapter 2-92 by adding new Section 2-92-4, establishing bid incentives for Chicago Jobs Plan commitment. Before we begin, with our expert witnesses, we do have a substitute ordinance that was emailed to all committee members before the meeting. Can I get a motion to accept these substitutes? So moved by Alderwoman Vice Chair Gutierrez. All those in favor signify by saying aye. Any opposed? Any opinion? The chair of the ayes have it. The substitute is now before us. Lovely. Today we have with us, as expert witnesses from the Midwest, from, forgive me, from Jobs to Move America, the Midwest Director, Casey Beyer, and from the Chicago Federation of Labor, we have Director Nick Desideri. I was going to say from the CFL, we got Nick D. We also have Chief Procurement Officer, Assistant Corporation Counsel Ray Phillips-Santos from the Department of Law, General Counsel Managing Procurement Officer, Courtney Delgaitis. We have with us, as well, the Chief Sponsor of this effort, our amazing Vice Chair, Helu Gutierrez, Alderwoman. Why don't you take the floor? Thank you so much, Chairman. Good afternoon, and thank you to all my colleagues here in the Workforce Development Committee for joining us in consideration for this ordinance here today. Chicago, as we all know, it's a pro-worker city. We know that good jobs with high wages help working people support their families and communities. It's in that spirit that I'm putting forward the Chicago Jobs Plan Ordinance, which encourages the procurement of quality goods manufactured by employers with high labor standards. The Chicago Jobs Plan Ordinance creates up to 5% bid incentive for the evaluation of price of the contract. To be clear, this ordinance only applies to manufactured goods. It does not include contracts for construction, installation, or professional services. Possible contracts based on the city buying plan include major investments of city dollars in manufactured goods like water meters, water mains, and motor vehicles. Companies that commit to creating more jobs, pay higher wages, and offer better benefits in training receive a higher share of the bid incentive and are more likely to win the contract. A bidder's job plan becomes part of its binding contract with the city. Those commitments are made public and are monitored annually during the contract. This ordinance helps reverse the race to the bottom of workers' wages and benefits in manufacturing and reverses course by rewarding manufacturers that provide good wages, benefits, and training. It also advantages manufacturers located in places with higher workforce standards, like Chicago, so high road companies are not being undercut by competitors who do not invest in safety and quality workforces. This idea is not new. And there is a proven track record behind the Chicago Jobs Plan policy framework in Chicago and across the country. The Chicago Transit Authority has incorporated a jobs plan in its contracts for over a decade. As a city, we should demand nothing less. We have worked hard to get this ordinance right and get it into this point. I would like to thank the CFL, the Chicago Federation of Labor, and Jobs to Move America to trusting in me on leading this ordinance. From the start, we have been in conversations with the Department of Procurement Services and Chief Procurement Roberts to ensure that this ordinance will be additive to their efforts and the implementation transition will be soon. We have collaborated and incorporated feedback from the city and labor partners to ensure this ordinance is a win-win for the city, Chicago's residents, and Chicago workers. And with that, I would like to ask my colleagues to vote in favor. Thank you. Thank you very much, Vice Chair. We'll have a couple of minutes from each of our expert witnesses, and we'll start with Director Nick Desideri. You have the floor, sir. Sure. Good afternoon, everyone. As the chair noted, my name is Nick Desideri. I'm the political director of the Chicago Federation of Labor. I want to echo the points made by our sponsor after all of her work, and it's been wonderful to work with throughout this process. This ordinance is a sensible proposal that will help working people in Chicago and beyond. Chicago is the birthplace of the American labor movement, and we understand both the moral and communal value of treating workers with dignity and respect. The Chicago Jobs Plan Ordinance is an extension of those values, which will offer a bid incentive for manufacturers who demonstrate a continuing commitment to high labor standards. As discussed, bidders must outline to the city the number of jobs created and retained and where, wages and benefits across job classes, what training is provided to their workforce, and partnerships to stimulate community hiring. And my colleague Cassie will also go into more detail on that during her testimony to really go over the nuts and bolts. This framework has a strong track record of creating opportunities to win strong agreements for communities and workers. Jobs to Move America Labor Partners includes SMART, IBW, IUECWA, USW, as well as labor federations like my own, the CFL. United Auto Workers, another supporter of this proposal, is also supporting it due to the positive impact a bid incentive would have on workers in the manufacturing sectors across Chicago area and for the city of Chicago itself. This is also, to the sponsor's point, not new. In 2016, the CFL worked with the CTA to include similar jobs plan language to advance good jobs in manufacturing, which helped lead to a Chicago manufacturing facility where IBW Local 134 electricians and SMART Local 73 sheet metal workers built the CTA 700 series rail cars. Jobs plan language was also included in the Northern Illinois Transit Authority Act passed last year, which was heavily supported by the Illinois AFL-CIO, as well as the Chicago Federation of Labor. The CFL, for our part, shared this ordinance with our affiliates for their input. We worked with operating engineers, Local 150, to incorporate their feedback, and we have been at the table with Alderwoman Gutierrez, Jobs to Move America, and city departments to get this ordinance to a place where every stakeholder feels comfortable moving forward. This ordinance is one way we can support workers in our city's procurement of manufacturing goods. And as such, the CFL supports this ordinance and its passage out of committee today. Thank you. Thank you, Director. Up next, we have Midwest Director Casey Beyer of Jobs to Move America. Go ahead, Director. Thank you. I am Cassie Beyer. I am the Midwest Director for Jobs to Move America. We are a national organization working in community and labor coalitions to win hydro procurement policy and also secure community benefits across the country. I'm here to share context on... Director, would you mind moving the mic closer to you? I can. Thank you so much. Thank you. Thank you. I'm here to share context on the policy and a little bit of how the proposed evaluation mechanism will work. Chicago has historically set high standards for pro-worker, pro-community procurement policies. We should all be proud of this. Chicago and its Department of Procurement Services have led the way in advancing high-road manufacturing policy by leveraging the city's purchasing power to incentivize bids that manufacture goods within the city and promote diversity and equity among suppliers. Recent pro-worker, pro-community procurement policy adopted by Chicago include a city-based manufacturer bid incentive from 2012, a local business preference bid incentive in 2012, and a diverse management and workforce incentive in 2022. When combined, these three past ordinances paint a clear and powerful picture. Chicago is a city that rewards local businesses, prioritize bidders who employ Chicagoans, and empower the hiring of disadvantaged workers through our public purchasing. But there is one missing component, and that is good jobs, job quality. How many good jobs do these contracts create? What are the wages being paid? What are the benefits being offered? And what's the training provided? This reason for the missing piece wasn't Chicago's choice. It was because of, until very recently, federal law did not allow the city's public purchasing to incentivize job creation, higher wages, better benefits, and strong training programs. Fortunately, Chicago once again led the way for workers. In 2024, Chicago's mayor and many older people, including several in this room, joined our coalition's national effort to update the federal permissions at the Office of Management and Budget to empower cities like Chicago to incentivize high road manufacturing practices. The OMB's uniform guidance had remained largely unchanged since the 1980s and severely restricted cities and states from enacting procurement policies that prioritized workers. I'm happy to share, in no small part because of Chicago's advocacy, we won new permissions in the federal grant rules. That's how we arrived at the Chicago Jobs Plan Ordinance. Chicago has the opportunity to take advantage of these new federal permissions and get the most public good from our public goods. I now want to share just a little about how the Chicago Jobs Plan will work. To qualify for the 5% bid incentive, bidders must outline their jobs plan, detailing the number of jobs created or retained, minimum wages paid to non-supervisory employees, benefits, and workforce training plans. DPS, alongside other criteria, will evaluate a bidder's jobs plan and assign a total dollar value to the bidder. The bidder's total dollar value commitments will be ranked. The bidder with the highest total dollar value commitment receives the full 5% bid incentive. Other bidders are evaluated against the highest bidder and receive a proportional amount. To make this more concrete, the highest bidder bidder will be eligible for the 5% incentive. The second highest bidder, let's say they have committed to a 50% less good plan, will receive a 2.5% incentive. The specific evaluation criteria and scoring mechanism for this incentive is in line with the city's pre-existing bid incentives and has been agreed upon by DPS and city leadership. The contractor will submit annual reports to DPS to ensure compliance. It's important to note that the bid incentive does not change the overall price of the contract to the city. Rather, it allows the city to consider a bidder's workforce investments and reward them for doing right by workers. The Chicago Jobs Plan is one important tool in the city's toolbox to make sure we are supporting workers both locally and nationally. The Jobs Plan makes sure Chicago is investing its public dollars into businesses that take the high road. Bidders who prioritize wages, training, and benefits for its workforce are rewarded via the bid incentive. It's hard out here for working people, as we all know, and this is one action Chicago can take to help workers in this moment of weakened protections and also the rising cost of living crisis. We can also make sure that our public money is supporting quality jobs and not just getting stuck at the top with shareholders and CEOs. I appreciate your leadership on this issue and look forward to working closely with DPS to implement this policy to support working people. Thank you. Thank you. I will now open the floor to questions or comments from committee members. Any questions? No? Lovely. Well, I will... All the women? Chair, I think it wasn't mentioned. We're planning for it to pass and start being considered January 1st of 2027. Wonderful. I want to... Is that a question or is that a statement? Sure. A statement. Okay. Chair Vasquez. Thank you. I just want to commend Alderwoman Gutierrez's work along with the partners as well. Given all the changes that we've seen at different levels of government and the lack of emphasis on making sure that people have an equal opportunity, I appreciate the thoughtfulness in looking at the legislation to address what's clearly a need. So I want to thank you as well as the chairman and all the partners here. Thank you very much. Thank you. The CFL and Jobs from America have been leaders throughout the country in so many different aspects of improving our workforce conditions, pay for working class people. And I think this is yet again another example of that amazing track record. With that said, I will ask for a motion to pass from Alder Vasquez. All those in favor of do pass, please respond by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed? Aye. Say again? Ah. Before... Aye. Aye. Yes. Absolutely. Yes. Thank you. Aye for Coleman. Thank you. So with that, SO2026-0027470 has passed out of committee and will be reported out at the next city council as do pass by unanimous vote. Thank you so much for those in the chair, in the table there. We also want to recognize Alderman Stephanie Coleman for the quorum. Can I get a motion to include her as a row 59? So moved by Alderman Nancy. All those in favor say aye. Any opposed? We got one. Independent chairs, the ayes have it. She will be reflected in the roll call for this meeting. Without any further business, may I have a motion to adjourn from Alderman Spasado. All those in favor signify saying aye. And with no opposed, the meeting is now adjourned. The, yeah, the committee, the committee on workforce development is now adjourned. Thank you so very much. Thank you so much.