Are we good to go with the streaming? Is anyone from tech support able to confirm we're good to go? Great. Thank you. Good afternoon, everybody. The Committee on Ethics and Government Oversight will now come to order. We have two items on today's agenda. First is a substitute ordinance amending Municipal Code Section 2-156 regarding ethical code of conduct for city council contractors, lobbyists, and candidates for city office. And second, re-referring a matter to the Committee on License and Consumer Protection. We will begin with a roll call to establish quorum. Please note that your yes or present response will be deemed a yes vote when this quorum call is used for a reference vote for later items. Chairman Martin is present, Vice Chair Haddon, Alderwoman Lee, Alderman O'Shea, Alderwoman Taylor, Alderwoman Tabarez, Alderman Talleyferro, Alderman Wagesback, Alderman Sposato, Alderwoman Nugent, Alderman Vasquez, Alderman Riley, Alderman Lawson. And I see Alderwoman Taylor just walked in acknowledging you for quorum. We have we have established that quorum. I don't believe anyone has signed up for virtual. So moving on. At this time, we will begin public comment. This period is set for 30 minutes out of respect for everyone's time. Each speaker is limited to three minutes of public comment. We have received one, two, five people signed up for public comment. First up is Bijan Tarani, followed by Peter Lata. Good afternoon, Alderman. My name is Bijan Tarani. I'm speaking today in my capacity as the Associate Director of Reform for Illinois, a nonpartisan pro-democracy advocacy organization. I'm sorry to interrupt. Is there a mic on or? Doesn't sound quite loud enough. Great. Thank you. Go ahead. I'm speaking today in my capacity as the Associate Director of Reform for Illinois, a nonpartisan pro-democracy advocacy organization concentrated on money and politics, to speak in favor of the ethics reform ordinance recommended by the Board of Ethics. Ethics reform is common sense. City council contractors being subject to ethics requirements. City employees not being coerced into making political contributions. Political advertisements that identify who is approving them. City property not being used for electioneering communications. Political committees not being able to escape fines by violating ethics requirements. None of these changes are matters of controversy. They are matters of common sense. The bigger question for this committee is how far are you willing to go? Ethics reform is a small step in a privately financed campaign system. The ethics reform ordinance will push us forward in creating a city government accountable to the public. But the deeper problem will still remain. The system. Private financing creates a system that incentivizes a donor relationship between large dollar contributors and public officials. A system where elections are increasingly expensive and candidates need every dollar they can get. A system where an official's mind is at times forced to be divided between fundraising and governing. Fortunately, there is a solution. The Fair Elections Ordinance. A public campaign finance program similar to programs administered in New York City and Washington, D.C. The Fair Elections Ordinance would create a new system. A system where you can knock on doors, host block parties, host cookouts, and talk to constituents, while simultaneously fundraising the money you need to run for office. A system where you do not need to worry about fundraising between cycles and can focus on governing. A system designed to build public trust in government by incentivizing stronger relationships between candidates and constituents. Reform for Illinois encourages city council to take the step of passing common sense ethics reform and to also consider the Fair Elections Ordinance as a bigger solution to a deeper problem. Thank you, Chair. I yield my time. Thank you. Recognizing Alderman Lee, Alderman Riley, and Alderman Vasquez for purposes of quorum. Next up, we'll hear from Peter Lotta, followed by Jessica Jackson. Good afternoon. Chicago Board of Ethics is among one of the worst boards I've ever seen. Proposals still in transit for over two years now. Now, when are the politicians going to start working for the people, representing the people, instead of a small group? Where are my taxpayers' tax money going? Where is it going? It's going to pay for the chairs, everything in this room, but yet, and it's paying for your salaries too, but nothing is being done here? Where are the investigations into political contributions made to the city? Recently found out there were gaps that were recently identified. Why isn't the system designed to prohibit contributions before investigative entities find them? There's more to what's happening than what's being discussed. Why are restaurants now paying higher fees for inspections, permits, and various other fees that the city wants to implement? You're making businesses fly away with not only all these extraordinarily high fees, taxes, various other elements. Why is there no investigation into Mayor Johnson's recent DEI decision with businesses that want to partner up with the city? Why does race need to be a factor to work with the government? If you can get the job done, why does race need to be discussed? Why do you need to involve that? For what, another distraction? So the right people don't start waking up and speaking up on it? This is a shame. It mind boggles me that this is the biggest city in the Midwest, one of the biggest in the entire nation, and we're witnessing the turmoil like this? This is a clown show. This isn't even politics. This is like watching a reality TV show. It's unbelievable. Many Chicagoans are just sick and tired of this. When is this board going to do something? Because people are waking up, and also the mayor, the administration, and the city is lying. We need a full audit on what's happening. He's lying with everyone else. Get away with it. I want to recognize Alderwoman Tabaris for purposes of quorum, as well as non-committee members Moore and Kezada. Next up is Jessica Jackson, followed by Brian Zerou. So the fact that this gentleman here came and talked about fair elections. Fair elections do not occur in the state of Illinois, the city of Chicago and Cook County. They do not occur. What we have is a completely corrupt system that they have literally put the people of Chicago, Cook County, and Illinois in what I call a political headlock. They've made it where it's impossible for us to do anything because J.B. Prister is paying for everybody's seat. He's paying for everybody's seat, including you all's, that you all are running unopposed. You can't get you all out of these seats because you all are paid. So if anybody gets in your seats, you all are terrified that if someone gets in your seat that's not as corrupt as you are, that you stand a chance of being reported and going to jail. So therefore, J.B. Prister is saying to it that every last one of you all continue to sit in your seats. We're corrupt judges, corrupt public administrators. I'm encouraging the city of Chicago citizens, the citizens of the state of Illinois, the citizens of Cook County, do not participate in voting. Let the federal government come and lock these people. So do not let these crooks, these criminals, these thingies get into seats again because J.B. Prister is making it that they can't be ran against. Brandon Johnson is a criminal. Brandon Johnson is incompetent. Brandon Johnson should have been impeached a long time ago. Him and J.B. Prister, and the fact that you all do not have anything to recall, these politicians, is insane. So you all are actually forcing us to go back to the polls to vote for a bunch of losers? Then they have people like Jeanette Taylor and Desmond Yancey to be the jump out commercials? The ones who gave us up on the South Shore? The ones who gave us up on the South Shore? And now y'all want to act like y'all was against that Obama center being there? How insulting. And then get J.B. Pristock to cover you all. The feds are coming in here. Chicago don't vote for these crooks. The only people we're voting for is Danielle Carter and Christian Maxwell because they don't come with a bunch of garbage losers. Next up is Brian Zeru, followed by our last public speaker, George Blakemore. Good morning, Chairman Martin and the members of the committee. My name is Brian Zeru. I'm the vice president of policy at the Better Government Association. The BGA supports this ordinance. The remaining provisions, including extending ethics rules to city council, independent contractors, adding to stand by or add transparency standards, and clarifying restrictions on the political use of city insignia, are thoughtful and meaningful updates to the city's ethics code. However, we are disappointed by the removal of the provision, closing the contribution loophole for city contractors and business owners. While current law caps entities doing business with the city at $1,500 in annual political contributions, owners, officers, and partners remain able to contribute beyond that limit individually. Treating businesses and their principal owners as a single entity under the $1,500 cap, as peer cities like New York and Los Angeles already do, is a reasonable step toward ensuring a level playing field and strengthening public confidence. While voting for this ordinance moves several good policies forward, passing it without addressing the loophole ultimately leaves a significant gap in our ethics framework. Removing this provision will not instill confidence in city government. We respectfully encourage the committee to reconsider restoring this contribution limit and future reform efforts to ensure Chicago adopts the strongest possible protections against pay-to-play politics. Thank you. Recognizing Vice Chair Haddon for purposes of quorum, our last speaker is George Blakemore. Ethics. Marlon. What is ethical? And you all are part-time employees. So some of you have other business. And what the previous speakers have spoke about, they can't get, you can't vote them out. You can't vote them out. And they're all are Democrats. The black ones, the white ones, the Hispanic, the Asian, All of them are one party system, like a communist or fascist system. No check and balance. All of them. And Mr. Blakemore, do you predict it's going to be a change? No. No. They're going to all be back in their office. And if it's not them, it's going to be a carbon copy of people just like them. Well, what about big head Trump, that big head white man? He don't have a thing to do with this. They're all Democratic. Well, well, well, is Trump a racist? He's a big head white man. He's a big head white man. And he's Mexican. And he's Chinese. He's blacks. They're all is terrible. And the young lady said, Danielle, Danielle's not going to be no mayor. Uh-uh. Uh-uh. The whole system is broken. It is a non-fuck. It's a non-fuck. No store, no nothing. No nothing. Bad school. Children. Oh, they say. They say. Some black people are calling these books. Thank you. What are your houses? Leave me alone. Leave me alone. It was worth it. That concludes our public comment portion. Our first order of business is the Rule 45 report from July 2026, which was distributed to the committee via email. Can I have a motion to approve the Rule 45 report? Alderman Vasquez, so moves. All those in favor, signify by saying aye. All those opposed, in the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. We will now discuss the first substantive item on the agenda today, Substitute Ordinance 2024-0007359. Can I have a motion to accept the Substitute Ordinance? Alderman Woman had and so moves. Hearing no objections, so ordered. The Substitute is now before the committee. Bear with us for just a second as we get things set up with a very short PowerPoint presentation. And yes, as we're doing so, we have joining us today Board of Ethics Acting Chair Ryan Cortazar and Acting Executive Director Carissa Flores, whom we will be hearing from shortly. Okay. Great. So if we could go to the next slide for this short presentation. As context, towards the beginning of every term, the Board of Ethics suggests various changes to the city's governmental ethics ordinance based on the board's experiences from the prior term and especially the preceding election. Today's Substitute Ordinance features five of the recommended changes that we received from the board earlier this term. The first involves city council contractors. The proposal would provide that the independent contractors for city council would be subject to the same ethics requirements as city officials and employees, what they must follow already. And this ranges from a fiduciary duty to the city, as well as avoiding conflicts of interest, improper gifts, improper use of confidential information that is used or that is received during city work, as well as other things. This is important in part to ensure that city council independent contractors remain accountable to the city and to the public, just as their employees and official peers are, and also that we're taking steps to continue bolstering public confidence in city council and the people who work on its behalf. Next slide. Second involves coercive electioneering communications. At the moment, no city employee or official can force city employees to make or solicit political contributions. However, there's a loophole that exists unintentionally involving political fundraising committees associated with those city officials. This proposal seeks to close that loophole so that the fundraising committees can be held accountable should misconduct occur. And, again, why this is important, ensuring that the city is taking steps to ensure that its employees are not pressured into donating for fear of losing their job or other retribution. Next slide. Third is a stand by your ad requirement. It provides that in any print, web-based, radio, or TV ad, that a candidate would be required to state that they've personally viewed and approved the communication, something that, as many people know, is in line with federal election law. The board has proposed this to help ensure that candidates do not avoid accountability from electioneering communications that their political committees send that are improper, coercive, or involve misconduct in some other way. Fourth is something involving city uniforms, badges, and other insignia. Currently, city officials, employees, and candidates can't use or allow the use of city property in unauthorized ways, including unauthorized political activity. In recent cycles, including the most recent one, the board had issued clarification saying that uniforms, badges, badges, and other insignia qualify as city property, and this seeks to codify this guidance that the board has been providing. And part of why that's important is that candidates shouldn't be allowed to give the impression that any city department or person in their official capacity endorses that candidate's campaign. The next and final provision involves insolvent and dissolved political committees. It proposes that the city could hold a successor committee liable for any fines for ethics or campaign financing violations. And a successor committee can include a political committee formed to support that same individual for election to any public office within the four subsequent years. And this one I think is pretty obvious. Committees shouldn't be able to avoid accountability by either closing or keeping their balance sheet at zero and then simultaneously opening up a new committee. Those are the five key pillars of these changes to the governmental ethics ordinance. I'll now invite Ryan Cortazar and Carissa Flores from the board to provide brief comment before we open things up to questions from committee and non-committee members. Ryan, let's start with you. Thank you, Chair Martin and members of the committee. Can you hear me? Is the green light on? Maybe I need to hold it down. Yeah, that sounds good. Thank you, Chair Martin and members of the committee for the opportunity to address you and for considering these amendments to the city's ethics ordinance. These proposals will strengthen the ordinance and will resolve certain ambiguities that the Board of Ethics members and staff have confronted over the last several years. To give you a little bit of background of our work and the determinations that the board makes, we're guided by three guideposts. First and foremost is the text of the ethics ordinance that the city council has enacted. Second, we apply our board precedent interpreting the ordinance to the dozens of cases that come our way. And third, we consider basic fairness and try to do justice to the parties in front of us to enforce the law as enacted. In applying the ordinance and having discussions with the persons who come before us, we're mindful that certain ambiguities in the ordinance can present challenges for guiding city officials, employees, contractors, and even candidates for public office. And in our work, we often look for ways to resolve those ambiguities and to strengthen the ordinance so that its meaning is clearer for the people that we serve and to improve the government. These amendments in large part reflect the board and its staff's recommendations based on our day-to-day work, providing guidance about the ordinance's meaning and exercising our enforcement powers. They reflect our best judgment about how to create a more ethical and fair playing field across the city, to make sure city resources are used ethically and not for political advantage, and to make sure the people who are entrusted with the city's work are all held to the same standards, regardless of their position or station. Right now is an excellent time to address these concerns before the next municipal election. We know from experience in the previous election that these issues become more salient and more contested in the crucible of the campaign. So the need for refining and clarifying the ethics ordinance is of particular importance now so that officials, candidates, campaign committees, lobbies, contractors, and employees all have strong guidance about their ethical obligations. And the particular issues in these amendments are some of the most familiar problems that the board confronts. Using city properties such as the Chicago Police or Fire Department insignia in electioneering communications, ethics violations committed by political committees that may dissolve and become moot and unenforceful because the committees themselves become insolvent or dissolve, and potentially coercive actions by political campaign committees towards city employees. And finally, the until now lack of a standby or ad provision will close the gap in the ordinance and bring it in line with campaign rules throughout the country. The bottom line and the common goal here is good government. That's the spirit behind these proposals, and it's why the board is recommending that you adopt them today. Thank you. Next, we'll hear from Acting Executive Director Carissa Flores. Good afternoon. Can you hear me? No. Thanks. Does this work? Okay. Sounds better. Oh, no? Okay, perfect. Good afternoon. Can you speak into the mic a little bit more? Good afternoon, Chair Martin, members of the committee. I want to thank, first of all, Chair Martin and his staff for all the work that you have done in bringing this ordinance forward. I'm here today to recommend the passage of these proposed amendments and not to repeat what Chair Martin said or the words of the vice chair here for the board. I would just like to reiterate that these amendments are something specific, are a response to something specific and documented that the board of review has encountered in its enforcement work. This is what the board is supposed to do, is to identify real gaps and bring them to you to close. And with that, I'm happy to answer any questions that the committee might have. Thank you, Director. With that, we'll open up questions first to committee members and non-committee members. I want to recognize Alderperson Fuentes as a non-committee member. Thank you for joining us. Alderman Riley. Thank you, Chairman. And I appreciate all the hard work you've done on this ordinance and the spirit of collaboration that you've brought to the process. I had just one question that I was speaking about with my colleagues this morning. I just wanted to raise to get some clarification, specifically Section 2-156-090. Would this ordinance prohibit city council or a committee from engaging a subject matter expert or attorney to advise city council or a committee on a particular matter if that person is a registered lobbyist on a totally unrelated matter? The reason I ask is that the city council contractors would become subject to the prohibition on representation of other persons, e.g., no lobbying the city. The concern here would be that a person who is a registered lobbyist that city council wants to engage as a contractor for their specific expertise, like data work in connection with a map, a lawyer engaged to advise city council on a specific transaction, et cetera. Under this ordinance, the way I read it, it could be prohibited. So I just wanted to get some clarity for legislative intent and how that might be actually applied by the Board of Ethics. Thank you for that question. I'd like to turn it over to Acting Executive Director Flores, if that's something you would be able to respond to. Sure. Thank you. And can you please... This is 4 of 9, 2-156-090, towards the very bottom of page 4. Sure. And I just want to make sure that I have your question correctly. Are you asking whether a lobbyist that is hired by a council member as an independent contractor on a specific issue would now, under the amendment, be prohibited from doing that? Or be prohibited from lobbying. So if you're going to be engaged by a council committee to help us with a very specific issue, does that mean then you are no longer able to be a registered lobbyist at the City of Chicago? Well, I don't think that it's a complete blanket exclusion of having that dual role. However, now that the independent contractors would be under the fiduciary duty, also the representation of other persons, I think that now that there is an eye for a conflict of interest, just as any, you know, employee would have. So if there is, they may be precluded depending on what they're lobbying on, and depending on what is very fact-specific, what they're working for you on. If there is now that they are under the umbrella of a conflict of interest, and that could be, you know, working on the exact same related material. So the way that the ordinance reads is an independent contractor can have, do other work for the city. And I would argue that may include lobbying. However, it has to be wholly unrelated to the work that they're doing as an independent contractor. So if it was the same type of work or the same issue, let's say that they are working for you on help on something very specific, some legislation or research, and now may they be prevented from lobbying the city or lobbying, you know, other organizations based on that, I would say that that would probably fall under the conflicts of interest. But I think it's really fact-specific. Okay, so you all will make a subjective determination on your own as to whether or not you think it poses a conflict and whether or not you think this person can remain a lobbyist. Is that fair to say? Well, yes. And that's generally how these conflict of interest come to us. It's either a question and saying, before I lobby or before I take on this client, these are the circumstances. I'm also an independent contractor. A call beforehand, we can provide based on the specific facts that they give us, where they stand in regards to the independent contractor role and the lobbying role. Okay. And just to be clear, I'm not... really asking this question as if an older person would hire this subject matter expert is typically committees and we go through a 10-year process of redrawing our political maps some of the people who've been retained to assist the city council with that effort also happen to be registered lobbyists they're clearly not lobbying us on the map right but they happen to be really really good at manipulating data and helping us draw correct boundaries we're just trying to make sure those folks aren't going to be told you're going to lose your career as a lobbyist by applying your subject matter expertise on something related to a map right and i i think it's the way it's defined so if it's um you know if their expertise is maps in general taking that raw data and making it into a map i think that is different than working on this specific map with this specific data now you know trying to lobby because there is information that they will obtain as their position as a independent contractor that will now be confidential um so if it's specific data well it's public data right none of it is hidden data it's all our data if there is anything um you know that they learn while working with this information possibly purpose or a policy um they would be covered with that but i would say it's not a blanket it's not a blanket um restriction on lobbying i think we would just have to look at um the subject matter that they are um uh want to lobby on okay um i'm not sure that that perfectly answers my question um so i'm sorry i i can i can rephrase that i would say that in general it would not be a um lobbying ban if independent contractors wanted to um also lobby it would not be an end of career it'd be a case-by-case scenario if if the work that they were doing as an independent contractor was uh very related so it's a close call and we would make that hopefully before any decision is made to take on a particular client and i fully appreciate you don't want to have a lobbyist helping us develop policy that they may then go and lobby for or against i completed that conflict of interest through and through it's these one-offs that i'm concerned about um thank you chairman thank you alderman other questions uh one thanks for your patience um asking a follow-up question on what alderman riley just mentioned if um someone is advising say the committee on committees and rules which is uh focused among other things at least in the past on the city's once in a decade map making process they hire independent contractors to advise on that process and one or more of those contractors separately lobby city council matters a city council on matters that do not pertain to map making lobbying how would the board assess whether and under what circumstances that lobbying can continue to happen um lobbyists aside from you know being an independent contractor and having um these uh new um provisions now applied to them from the ethics rules lobbyists also have a separate um more narrow um restrictions in regards to um what they can and cannot do um as lobbyists um you know this is something that the board has not contemplated before because independent contractors were not under this cloak of um fiduciary duty or um you know uh representation of others so i think the best policy would be um the board of review really looking at what possible one-offs can come to a situation where there's this dual um role as a lobbyist and an independent contractor and whether that would solely focus on the um specific uh work that the um lobbyist and contractor is doing and the work that they're doing as a lobbyist in order to frame a response that could incorporate all of sorry incorporate all of those potential one-offs that are there older woman happy um thank you chair uh i'm gonna i'm gonna say this in as plain to speak as i can and i'm thinking about the practical implications just for full clarification um and um and hello it's great to have you before us today so in practice i chair the committee on environmental protection and energy i am looking at having a body of work done that i need some support with and i decide to contract with uh abc firm and uh what i'm hearing is in practice if i know that abc firm also does some lobbying work um with the city then i should reach out to the board of ethics and i just said hey i'm planning on um i'd like to contract this group to do this discreet body of work and it's going to be related to uh lakeshore surveys um and i could just say hey board of ethics i'd like to hire them for this they're also lobbyists with the city and you guys could take a look at their filings and give me a determination on whether you think it would be a conflict and of course i would do my own research and i'd say hey they do lobbying work with the city but they're they're representing a client that's working on you know i don't know street streets contracts and resurfacing or active transportation and that's completely unrelated to the work i'm hiring them for or would like to hire them for for the lakeshore study so i could make my case give it to you guys and you would make a determination and give it back to me yes yes so if you called and provided this is something preemptively something i'm thinking of doing um we would you know ask some information just everything that you said and we would look at it and give you an answer okay thank you thanks chair can you say more about how you would think about lobbying that is related versus unrelated to the work that's being done as an independent contractor because i i don't want i want to just i think get some clarification because i think this is important um if someone is lobbying on a matter that is unrelated to the work that they're doing as an independent contractor how would you if you've made the determination it is unrelated what what would this um substitute ordinance mean if anything right i think um you know once it's uh content that's unrelated and therefore they can work and it wouldn't only apply to lobbyists so if uh independent contractor wanted to bid on another contract with the city and another another department we that determination it's the same step is this something that's wholly unrelated um where it gets a little gray we can make that determination if you call us um the next step would be would this potential work as a lobbyist violate one of the um duties that now the uh amendment would um apply so fiduciary duty so if in the work as a independent contractor they have one position um they would always have a duty to the city before their own duty so they could not then lobby on something that is completely the opposite so if they're doing something for the city um on behalf of the city and that would benefit the city they cannot then lobby on the exact opposite i see so on a related matter to be clear yes taking the opposite side yes of the same position that they've been working on yes okay other questions from committee members alderman newgen uh first chair thank you for the work you did on this ordinance and you've made a lot of changes that i think a lot of colleagues are really happy with i i just keep going back to this one particular issue that alderman riley brought up um because i think it's important when it's important and i perhaps i want to just rephrase would a lobbyist engaged by a committee for a specific matter need to cease lobbying or deregister during the term of their contract because i am we do work as as a council particularly in the map process and we do engage lobbyists and i'm i'm very concerned if if we effectuate this ordinance then it falls under and this is no means of criticism to you or anybody but it falls under your subjective opinion of whether they can work with us what i'd what i'd like to be able to hear today is that no we can work with lobbyists on the map room and we can contemporaneously support this ordinance and continue to work that way so help me here uh yeah like i said before it's not a blanket restriction and i think where it's very clear that um you know lobbyists can continue to be employed as independent contractors for your um example in this map um however it would only be an issue if they were also separately lobbying for something that and this is probably a very very um rare occurrence, something that would be directly opposed to that, meaning that they would be then violating their fiduciary duty to the city. I think, you know, the work that you're describing data making into a map is something that's probably not going to incorporate these conflicts of interest that we have in some other areas. So this seems just like, you know, even if they're making a map for the city for this purpose and they work for an outside organization and use their data to also create a map, that would be fine. The only issue is, like I said, if they were doing work for the city and then doing the very opposite. So essentially, you know, going against what would be in the best interest of the city while also working for you as an independent contractor. So I think for the majority of things that you, it seems like the committee uses these independent lobbyists, contractors as lobbyists for, would not fall under the realm of limiting their employment with you. Okay. Thank you for that, Clarity. I appreciate that. Thank you, Alderwoman. Other questions? Seeing none, can I get a motion to pass the substitute ordinance? Alderman Vasquez, so moves. All those in favor signify by saying aye. All those opposed? In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. The motion passes. Thank you both for your time this afternoon. And thank you to the non-committee members who joined us this afternoon as well. Our next, and I promise very quick piece, is a re-referral item. That is Resolution 2026-0026043, which is a resolution calling for adoption of a small business bill of rights. This resolution was referred to this committee. However, it would appear that the Committee on License and Consumer Protection has more appropriate jurisdiction over the subject matter addressed by the resolution. Can I get a motion to refer this resolution to the Committee on License? Alderman O'Shea, so moves. All those in favor signify by saying aye. All those opposed? In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. And there being no further business before this committee, can I get a motion to adjourn? Alderwoman Lee, so moves. All those in favor signify by saying aye. All those opposed? In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. The meeting is adjourned. Thank you.