Mic check. One, two, one, two, one, two. Is it good now? All right. I'm going to hear it. One, two, one, two, one, two. Mic check. Mic check. Okay. Now, yeah. Now. Now. Okay. Very good. So I got a little excited. Thank you. The Committee on Immigrant and Refugee Rights will now come to order. Today, we have three items on the agenda, a subject matter hearing on each of the next items. One, the investigation process for DHS violations in Chicago and operationalization of DHS-related mayoral executive orders. Number two, Chicago Police Department enforcement of street vendor violations and related detainments and deportations. Number three, Omni Air International, DHS, and ISIS Deportation Airlines, whose parent company, Stone Peak Partners, want to purchase the Chicago parking meters. Votes will not be taken on any items. We will begin with a roll call to establish quorum. Alderwoman Dow, Alderwoman Gutierrez, Alderperson Knudsen, Alderperson Rodríguez, Alderperson Fuentes, Alderman Taliaferro. Alderwoman Cruz, Alderwoman Cardona, Alderwoman Rodriguez Sanchez, Alderwoman Quesada, Alderwoman Manal Hoppenworth, Alderwoman Haddon, Vice Chair Taylor, and myself. That is, I know the number, y'all. That is seven members present. We have a quorum. There are no non-members present. Alderpersons Rodríguez Sanchez, Dow, Taliaferro have requested a virtual option for committee hearing attendance in accordance with Rule 59 of the City Council Rules of Order. Can I get a motion to allow them to attend this hearing virtually? So moved by Alderwoman Gutierrez. Hearing no objections, so ordered. For the record, Alderperson Sichel Lopez, a non-member, is present. At this time, we will begin the public comment period. The period is limited to 30 minutes. Out of respect for everyone's time, each speaker is limited to three minutes. Remote speakers will comment first, followed by those in person. As of 10.15 a.m. on Wednesday, July 16th, 2026, zero callers have requested to speak today, so we will move on to in-person speakers. Our first speaker will be Kelly Howe. I live in Chicago. In May, I sat in a courtroom listening to the judge's decision in relation to the petition for a special prosecutor to hold ICE accountable for their crimes and human rights abuses during Operation Midway Blitz. The judge said no special prosecutor could be appointed because CPD claimed that up until the date that a Freedom of Information Act request had been filed for the petition, zero reports had been made to CPD about ICE. The judge argued that if the police aren't turning over evidence to the state's attorney, you can't say that the state's attorney has been derelict. CPD claims they received no reports or complaints about ICE until that point. They themselves knew crimes were being committed. There are videos and articles everywhere, and the police were present in it in many moments. Claiming that they did nothing because of a lack of a report from an ordinary Chicagoan is absurd, even if there were such a lack of reports. If a CPD officer walks down the street and sees someone beating someone up in broad daylight in, let's say, Lincoln Park, nine times out of ten, most of them are probably not going to say, I'm going to stand here and watch this crime being committed in this affluent neighborhood because no civilian has reported it to me. And then later, they failed to seriously investigate ICE causing the incident in Albany Park, among so many others. For example, according to Illinois HB 1312, you're not allowed to make a civil immigration arrest within 1,000 feet of a courthouse, and the police know very well about all of those. Where is the action? We're watching, we will make the reports, and we expect the city council and CPD to do all they can to hold ICE accountable, rather than hand them an engraved invitation to spray babies with tear gas. As far as city's parking meters, how is it even possible that it is being considered that Chicago residents and tourists would have to put money in meters that would then go to the parent company of Omni International, an airline whose human rights abuses flying ICE kidnapping flights are beyond chilling? If one can hear what that airline does and their stomach doesn't revolt, they need to look deep inside themselves. According to the investigative journalism of Gillian Brockel, among other journalists, Quote, Omni specializes in doing the ICE flights so craven that a lot of the other airlines that do ICE kidnappings won't do them. Stop this sale. Thank you. Thank you very much. Our next speaker is Wendy Siegel, followed by Noelle Clennan. So I'm responding to enforcement of the executive order ICE on notice. My name is Wendy Siegel. I'm here today representing Indivisible Lincoln Square, Indivisible's an all-volunteer organization concerned about strengthening the underpinnings of democracy and the rule of law. Particularly since Midway Blitz, we have become increasingly concerned about ICE's aggressive immigration enforcement and Chicago Police Department's apparent willingness to turn a blind eye, putting the lives of immigrant residents and citizens alike at risk. An example, it is simply beyond our comprehension that the shooting of Marimar Martinez in Chicago, a Chicago resident and citizen, has not been investigated. And, of course, there are many others. Let me say as well that we do not buy the argument that the Supremacy Clause prohibits CPD from charging and investigating. In our reading, the Supremacy Clause merely offers those federal officers a defense so long as they plead and provide that their actions were authorized by federal law and were necessary and proper. And while the mayor issued the ICE on notice executive order in January, which directs CPD to investigate, document, and refer federal immigration agents for criminal prosecution if they violate state laws, we have yet to see the required guidance and procedures for implementing that order. Furthermore, we see little evidence that anything has changed. So we have several specific questions we would like answered today. Has CPD written the new policies to address the order? If so, will they share the document? I guess I was expecting some representation. How is CPD monitoring implementation of the executive order? Who specifically is responsible for monitoring the implementation? It has been 10 months since Midway Bliss and six months since the executive order was issued. Can we see reports on actions taken? How can we, how have you communicated with trained and trained officers on these new policies and have ICE officers been investigated? How about CPD officers for noncompliance? We value CPD and want to believe that officers are indeed here to serve and protect our communities, but it is long past time for accountability to the public. In addition, we would like to see actions to protect us from other departments, which we had hoped would be represented here today. For example, emergency management and communications and the law department. What have those agencies or departments done to build the scaffolding that supports due process and humane treatment for members of the Chicago community? Thank you. Thank you very much. Our next speaker is Noelle Clennan, followed by Micaela Caden-Garido. Good morning. My name is Noelle Clennan. I'm a member of Indivisible Lincoln Square and a founder of Illinois Fighters Against Fascist Overreach, a group organized to demand bolder and more creative action by Illinois state and local officials to prosecute crimes committed by federal agents and minimally. We demand that they do the jobs they were hired or elected to do. Last October, CBP agent Charles Exum shot Marimar Martinez five times and then brought false criminal charges against her. And our law enforcement and local prosecutors appear to have done nothing in the more than nine months since Marimar was shot. Just to be clear for everyone, a U.S. citizen and Chicago resident was shot by her own government and our police department has not investigated. Why not? Marimar has testified in front of Congress twice, so we cannot pretend that she's not going to be cooperative. CPD can interview her, Anthony Ruiz. They can review the evidence from the failed federal prosecution of Ms. Martinez that was released by the FBI. It is literally CPD's job to investigate violations of Illinois law, even when the perpetrator is a federal agent and even when he does not want to cooperate. Last month, ICE rammed their vehicle into a car stopped at a traffic light not much more than a mile from my house. They did this to cut off a possible escape route for a man they were pursuing. CPD supposedly investigated and found no evidence of wrongdoing. Serving as a federal agent is not licensed to do whatever you want, wreck havoc, and sow chaos, damage private property, and endanger the lives of innocent bystanders. It doesn't give anyone immunity to shoot first and ask questions later. CPD's failure to investigate an ongoing preferential treatment for federal agents will only embolden those federal agents to target and assault more Chicago residents. In fact, it seems quite clear that across the country, this lack of consequences and accountability for their lawlessness has emboldened them. ICE has shot two people this month and killed them. My request is that CPD please do their job and immediately open an investigation into Charles Exum, at a minimum, as a starting point, and that they please rethink and report back on what changes they will make in response to Mayor Johnson's executive order to how they investigate crimes committed by federal agents in order to help keep Chicagoans safe from their dangerous and lawful behavior. Thank you. Thank you very much. Next speaker is Michaela Cayton-Garrido, followed by Mary McCarthy. Good morning. I am Michaela Cayton-Garrido. I am a staff attorney with Ascend Justice. I am here together with Angelica Gonzalez-Lopez, interim ED for Ascend Justice. We are here today to express our profound concern about ICE activity in and around courthouses in Cook County, including 555 West Harrison. The mission of Ascend Justice is to empower people impacted by gender-based violence or the child welfare system. And we help immigrants who have been victims of crimes, abuse, and trafficking apply for asylum, green cards, visas, and other U.S. immigration status. We also provide technical assistance and community outreach about the intersection of immigration and domestic violence to other agencies and community stakeholders. And at our walk-in clinic at the Cook County Domestic Violence Courthouse at 555 West Harrison, we help people every day get orders of protection from their abusers. So we have seen firsthand the chilling impact on the willingness of both victims and witnesses of crimes to come to the courthouse where federal agents lie in wait. We are deeply concerned about ICE activity in and around courthouses in Cook County. These include not just blatant ICE activities, such as the illegal warrantless arrests last month in the Bridgeview Courthouse, but also surreptitious activity of ICE agents intercepting individuals en route to or from the courthouses, including 555, in the Blue Line, on city streets, what have you. ICE agents coming to the courthouse and staying on the premises, including at 555, they scare people away, including the very people who need help the most, like Ascend Justice clients. ICE enforcement is deadly, not just due to the condition in ICE detention centers, but also with ICE activity in communities, as the nation has yet again had heartbreakingly witnessed this past week with the deaths of two innocent individuals in Maine and Texas. I'm not even talking about the third one this week. We need to find a way to prevent ICE's deadly illegal activity in the city of Chicago. We call upon the city and the committee to remind law enforcement officials, among other ways, that we can be innovative, to have this responsibility to ensure the courthouses and the city streets and people in their homes remain safe zones for all, to refrain from aiding and abetting ICE activity, and to keep people in the city safe. Thank you. Thank you very much. Our next speaker is Mary McCarthy, followed by Noah Basis. You're going to pass? Okay. Next speaker is Noah Basis, followed by Ileon Baena. Good morning, members of the committee. My name is Noah Basis. I am the legislative strategist for the Institute for Justice Clinic on Entrepreneurship, based out of the University of Chicago Law School. We've been working with mom-and-pop businesses free of charge for the last 25 years, and we worked directly with the street vendors for over 15 years to get the original street vendor's license passed. Essentially, Chicago's street vending rules are not intuitive, especially for people who did not grow up here. The distinctions between vending license types and what is permitted under each one is a source of ongoing confusion, and it has been a source of ongoing confusion for years. When rules are unclear, enforcement becomes dangerously subjective. An officer might ticket a vendor one day for something that went unremarked the day before, leaving vendors guessing about where and when they can sell. Now, the city did recently release vending maps showing where folks can and cannot be, and they are genuinely helpful. But, again, a tool only works if people know that it exists, and many vendors have no idea to go looking for it. Moreover, every time that they do try to get one of these licenses to legitimize themselves in their practice and being on the street, essentially they run into so many delays, expensive lengths of time, impenetrable bureaucracy. It's very, very difficult for folks to comply, and they want to comply overwhelmingly. Before we charge someone with a misdemeanor that threatens their ability to stay in this country, we should first make compliance sensible, comprehensible, and manageable. Punishment and the threat of deportation shouldn't come before clarity and accessibility. Thank you. Thank you very much. Our next speaker is CCPSA 10th District Counselor Eliane Baena. Good morning, Counselor. Good morning. Good morning. My name is Eliane Baena. I'm a member of the 10th District Council, and I'm also part of the District Council Immigration Working Group. And we want to express our disappointment with the continued delay in implementing the guidance required under the executive order ISON notice. The Community Commission for Public Safety and Accountability communicated just last night that the Chicago Police Department reported that the final guidance still remains under the review of the mayor's office. Months have passed, yet our communities are still waiting for clear direction. We're tired of excuses and finger-pointing across our city. In my neighborhood of Little Village and others like mine, immigrant families continue to experience fear and trauma as federal immigration enforcement continues. We have also seen CPD target street vendors, many whom are among our most vulnerable yet hardest-working residents. These actions undermine the trust and raise serious concerns about how our welcoming city policies are being implemented in practice. If this executive order is going to be meaningful, it has to be accompanied by clear accountability measures. As members of the Immigration Working Group, we are calling for the following. First, CPD should establish a dedicated task force whenever ICE activity reaches a level that significantly impacts our community. Second, CPD should initiate investigations whenever there is credible evidence of criminal misconduct by federal immigration agents. Third, those investigations should have a clear deadline so communities are not left waiting indefinitely for answers like we have for the past year. Finally, these findings of these investigations should be made public. Transparacy is essential to accountability and rebuilding that trust across our community through all our departments in the city. Our residents deserve clear policies, timely action, and confidence that our city and our institutions will respond to them. Thank you. Thank you. Our next speaker is Maria Lourdes Ochoa, followed by Juan Gama. Sorry. No, primero, Maria Lourdes. First, Maria Lourdes. Buenas tardes. Mi nombre es Maria Lourdes Ochoa, Secretaria de la Asociación de Vendedores Ambulantes, siglas SBAC. Abuso a los vendedores. Hay tres tipos de abuso que estamos sufriendo. El abuso de poder, las autoridades, los inspectores. Al principio nosotros entendíamos que hay lugares donde no se puede vender y no se debe. Está prohibido y nos queda claro que varios concejales trabajan en sus áreas para hacer zonas prohibidas. Mi pregunta es, ¿dónde vamos a vender en los terrenos baldíos el abuso del racismo en Chicago? ¿Es una ciudad santuario? No lo creo. Cualquiera viene, discrimina y nadie hace nada. Tenemos en nuestros zapatos familia que mantener. No nos gusta robar. Solamente queremos trabajar y han crecido un enorme racismo hacia nuestros vendedores ambulantes. El abuso también es silencio. Muchos de ustedes, los que tienen el poder, que pasan leyes, prometieron luchar por su gente de sus barrios, gente trabajadora, hoy guardan silencio ante todos. Solo miran y no nos apoyan. Nosotros necesitamos una oportunidad para regularizar nuestros vendedores ambulantes. ¿Nos pueden apoyar? Por favor. Good morning. My name is María Lourdes Ochoa. I'm from the Street Vendors Association. The abuse of power by authorities and inspectors at first, we understand that there are places where selling is prohibited, and that is clear to us. But several council members are working in areas to create prohibited zones. My question is, where are we supposed to sell? On vacant lands? The abuse of racism. Is Chicago a century city? I don't think so. Anyone can come and discriminate, and nobody says anything. Okay, I'm trying to walk in our shoes. We have families to support. I don't like to steal. I just want to work. And there has been a huge race of racism towards our street vendors. The abuse of silence. Many of you, those in power, those who pass laws, those who promise to fight for our people, our neighborhoods, our working people, today you remain silent. You just watch and don't support us. We need the opportunity to regulate our street vendors. Thank you. Thank you very much. Our next speaker is Juan Gama, followed by Clara Barrios. Buenos días. Mi nombre es Juan José Gama. Soy presidente de Street Vendors. Estamos aquí porque queremos alzar nuestra voz y hablar con ustedes porque en los últimos días, las cosas están complicando con nuestros vendedores ambulantes afuera, en el centro, en el sur y en el norte. En los últimos tres años, nos hemos dado a la tarea de tocar puerta de concejales, mandando correos, visitando sus oficinas, y tocando la puerta de la oficina del alcalde y del comisionado del BACP. Nos hemos encontrado con gente de buen corazón y también con gente que aún no nos quiere escuchar. Pedimos nosotros que tenga que haber un tipo de regulación para los vendedores ambulantes, ¿verdad? Porque nosotros queremos enriquecer con nuestra cultura, nuestra gastronomía a la ciudad de Chicago, preparando frente al cliente nuestros ricos elotes, vasos de fruta, nuestros tamales, aguas frescas, etc. Nos comprometemos que si esto es posible, trabajar con el departamento de BACP, el departamento de salud, con los diferentes concejales y con la oficina del alcalde, si esto es posible. Son muchos años batallando, más de 30. Alguien tiene que ayudarnos ya a legalizarnos. Amamos la ciudad de Chicago. Aquí hemos echado raíces y queremos que la ciudad de Chicago sea un ejemplo a seguir para las demás ciudades en cuanto a cómo apoyar a sus trabajadores informales. Muchas gracias. Good morning. Good morning. My name is Juan Gama. I'm the president of the Street Vendors Association. I'm here today because the past week has been very critical for our street vendors. In the past three years, we have made it our mission to knock doors of the city councils, send emails, visit their offices, and knock the doors of the mayor's office and be BACP commissioner. We have encountered kind people and also people who still doesn't listen to us. We request that the current license for packaged food be modified so that we can enrich the city of Chicago with our culture, gastronomy, and prepare our delicious corns, food cups, tamales, aguas frescas, and more rice for our customers, for our street vendors. We are committed to working with BACP, the Department of Health, various city council members, the mayors of the office, if possible. We have been struggling over 30 years. Someone has to help us legalize our business now. We love the city of Chicago. We have put down our roots here. We want the city of Chicago to be an example for other cities that support our street vendors. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Our next speaker is Clara Barrios, followed by Salvador Salas. Yes, my name is Clara Barrios. First of all, thank you very much for the opportunity. I am one of the most of the vendors of the Millennium Park, in which we are here today to raise our voice. Thank you very much. We are tired of having to hurry up to the police, because we want to grab ourselves for so many hours, with cold weather, with cold weather, just because we are working, not we are robbing. We have a job in which we see a lot of people visit the park and enjoy eating our fruits, which are in very good state. We offer fruits that are fresh, we offer products good, of good quality. In any moment, we have been accused of that someone has been intoxicated, someone has had no effect secondary, because we have given us some fruit in bad conditions. No, al contrario. We have been accused of that. Why? Because we have love to what we do. We have passion to what we really are working. Por eso es que hoy en día, queremos que sinceramente nos apoyen y nos den los permisos correspondientes para poder trabajar dignamente y tener la capacidad de tener nuestro trabajo honradamente. Muchísimas gracias por su apoyo. Hello, and thank you for the opportunity. I am one of the vendors and sincerely want the opportunity to work where I'm at and not face the fear of having to run away from the authorities and from the city. I feel like we sometimes face abusive situations. We see people enjoy our food that we offer at the park. We offer fresh and good fruit. Never have we really had problems with food poisoning, no secondary symptoms. And all we ask is for us to keep working our passion and that we just want the ability to ask and be able to work in the places that we vend. Thank you very much. Our next speaker is Salvador Salas, followed by Guillermo Flores. Hello, buenos días a todos. Mi nombre es Salvador Salas y estoy aquí para contarles una historia. En los 90, en el 2000, vendedores, ambulantes eran violentados, eran abusados. Hay tanto racismo que nos sentimos completamente mal. En esos tiempos, nos tiraban las cosas a la basura, nos quitaban los carritos, nos daban tiques, nos daban cortes, tiques de 70 dólares hasta 1,500 dólares. Nos daban cortes. Hubo muchos detenidos. Es que por eso que nació esta organización, para defendernos. En la actualidad estamos luchando por una ordenanza que nos está ofreciendo el alcalde. Queremos pedirle a los concejales que nos ayuden, que empujen para que nos den una nueva ordenanza, que nos apoye, una ordenanza que nos dé un permiso para vender, una ordenanza que necesitamos para poder trabajar dentro de la ley, para que podamos pagar nuestros impuestos, para que igualmente la ciudad pueda regular a los vendedores que habemos. Eso es todo. Muchas gracias. Good morning. My name is Salvador Salas. I'm a street vendor. I'm part of the Street Vendor Association. I'm going to tell you a story from the 90s to the 2000s. The street vendors were criminalized and also facing a lot of racism back then. And until today, that is still happening and that breaks my heart. Back then, street vendors were still facing getting tickets, throwing their items away, their food. Tickets are up to $70 to $1,500 and going to court. Today, we ask you that we want the others to support, to help us pass a policy that would allow street vendors to sell. And we hope that the city will support us in regulating a policy that would allow more vendors to continue selling. Thank you. Muchas gracias. Thank you. And our final speaker is Guillermo Flores. Hello, what's up to all? I'm Guillermo Flores. I'm a vendedor of fruit and elots for the area of Gage Park for 15 years. Why did I become a vendedor ambulant? Well, what happens is that I was injured in the back, I was injured in the back, I was injured in the back, I was injured in the back, I was injured in the back. I was injured in the back, I was injured in the back. I was injured in the back, I was injured in the back, I was injured in the back, I was injured in the back. But, lamentablemente, llegan los inspectors and me dicen que yo no puedo estar ahí, que me retire, sabiendo que en las calles, vendiendo en las calles hay mucho peligro. Por eso, yo pido a la gente, a las personas que nos den permiso para vender nuestros productos, nosotros tratamos de vender nuestros productos todo fresco, porque nosotros también comemos de ahí, nos alimentamos de ahí. Y para rentar un local, los precios de la renta son muy altos, porque hay que pagar renta, luz, agua, gas. Por eso, les pido a todos mis compañeros ambulantes que nos, les pido por todos ellos que nos dejen trabajar. Gracias a todos y que Dios los bendiga. Hello, my name is Guillermo Flores. I am a vendor of fruit and corn over at the Gage Park area for 15 years. Why do I do this? I had to have a back surgery after an injury, and no one has wanted to hire me in companies, so this is my next best option. Currently, right now, delinquency is bad, and I would say today it is worse. I would just want to be able to stay in one place. I've been able to ask for permission from an owner of their space to vend outside, but inspectors keep coming in and telling me that I have to leave. Currently, in the streets, it's pretty dangerous right now. All we want is permission to vend our products. We do our products. We have them fresh. We also eat from our own products. We rely on them. Rent is really high right now to be able to rent from a building, and I'm just asking for you all to allow us to have permission. Thank you, and God bless. Thank you very much. Thank you to all of our speakers today. I would like to note that this committee received four written public comments. There being no more speakers, the public comment period is concluded. The first item on the agenda before our committee is to approve the June 2026 Rule 45 report. Can I have a motion to approve? Alderman Cardona, so moves. Hearing no objections, so ordered. Before we move forward with our items, I want to briefly discuss why I wanted to bring these three matters up today. So the first item related to the CPD enforcement of the ICE on notice executive order. Mayor Johnson signed the executive order on January 31st directing CPD to investigate wrongdoing and pursue prosecution of federal agents. Since then, we have not seen any investigations open into the conduct of federal agents, even though there have been plenty of misconduct incidents on our streets. In June, a federal agent crashed into a bystander's vehicle and CPD closed it as a traffic incident instead of pursuing a fuller investigation that we know of, and we have yet to get answers on how that occurred. ICE has shot and killed two people within the last week, Lorenzo Salgado Arajo and Joan Sebastián Guerrero. Afterward, they blamed them for their own deaths by telling the same lies they told when they killed our neighbor, Silverio Villegas Gonzalez. Their recklessness also led directly to the death of a third person this week who was killed by a semi-truck while fleeing. It is past time that we have a clear process for how to investigate and hold accountable the people who are murdering our neighbors without consequence is a question I have and we'll discuss during the hearing about what happened in the time between the executive order being announced at the end of January and now related not only to investigations of activity, but policy implementation. And so we look forward to those conversations. The second item, as you all heard some of the speakers, is related to street vendor enforcement. As we've seen recently, CPD has been enforcing laws on street vendors, arresting as many as 18 vendors in one day. At least one of those vendors, Norma Salazar Perdomo, has been deported as a result of those actions in the going court where they were abducted by ICE. Laws on the books are only good if they are being followed. We need answers to why CPD is neglecting to pursue investigations of the agents that terrorize our communities while at the same time targeting street vendors who are just trying to make a living. And then finally, we'll be discussing the proposed parking meter deal with Stone Peak. As we all know, we're in the middle of those conversations as a city council. And in finding out that Stone Peak has ties to OmniAir, which contracts with ICE for deportation flights, a number of city council members have concerns. Omni has a record of human rights abuses, including shackling people for over 24 hours and stranding over 100 detainees at a New Hampshire airport in a blizzard while shackled and without giving them food or water. Chicago has been a sanctuary city for over 40 years, but we cannot continue to call ourselves that if we aren't protecting our communities when they are being terrorized. And if we allow companies that profit off of human rights abuses to profit off of our streets, it's not a reputation we want to continue as a city of Chicago if that's the direction we're going in. So we'll be doing questions at the end of each item or each of today's items for the testimony. The first item is a subject matter hearing on the operational operationalization of immigration enforcement related mayoral executive orders. I would call on the folks providing opening statements on this item, but please introduce the team you have brought to the box today as well. We have Jill Stevens, deputy chief of the Chicago Police Department, Beatriz Ponce de Leon, deputy mayor for the mayor's office of immigrant, migrant, and refugee rights, and Sheila Betty, chief strategy officer and counsel to the mayor. Deputy chief, deputy chief, if you'd like to begin. Yes, thank you. Good morning. Morning. My name is Jill Stevens. I'm a deputy chief with the Chicago Police Department. In accordance with the Welcoming City Ordinance and the Trust Act, the Chicago Police Department does not assist federal immigration authorities with enforcement action based solely on immigration status. These laws prohibit us from participating in civil immigration enforcement operations or assist in the civil enforcement of immigration law. Additionally, CPD does not request or document immigration status and does not share information with federal authorities. In collaboration with the mayor's office and the Department of Law, we are happy to report that we have issued a revised responding to incidents involving citizenship status policy. However, while this policy was being revised, it is important to know that the Chicago Police Department's current policy does allow for the reporting of incidents from community members' interactions with ICE agents, the documentation of these incidents on our body-worn cameras, as well as rendering aid to injured persons. This revised policy is important to know that the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of provides additional reporting requirements to ensure documented apparent violations of the law by members of the federal immigration or other federal law enforcement agencies are tracked and investigated consistent with the expectations of the ICE on notice executive order. These additional guidelines build on the existing policy to ensure all incidents involving federal immigration enforcement are thoroughly reported, documented, and tracked. The policy also ensures CPD's response to these incidents are adequately supervised at a higher level. And before we head into questions, I want to again reiterate that in accordance to the City of Chicago Municipal Code, the Chicago Police Department does not assist or intervene in civil immigration enforcement. Thank you. I'd like to introduce the members. Okay. So again, my name is Jill Stevens. I'm a deputy chief in the Bureau of Patrol. To my left is Commander Pat Kenney. He is the commander in the Bureau of Detectives. To my right is Captain Mike Kapistanik. He is in our policy division. Next to him is Commander Seamus Mannion. He's the commander of the 1st District Patrol. And behind him is our general counsel, Scott Spears, who's here as well to help talk about policy and legalities. Thank you very much. Next, Beatriz, Deputy Mayor. Yes, good evening. Muy buenos dias. Good morning. I'm Beatriz Ponce de Leon. I'm the deputy mayor for immigrant, migrant, and refugee rights for the city of Chicago. And I'm joined by Sheila Betty, our chief of strategy and legal counsel to the mayor. We will present an overview of the Protecting Chicago initiative and the executive orders that have been issued to date. I'm going to start by just sharing more about Protecting Chicago. Thank you. You know, this initiative was launched as a result of the mayor's commitment to protect all Chicagoans, to make sure that our communities have well-being and safety at the center, and that our city was prepared to uphold our laws, our values, and to fight back against the federal actions and inactions that have really brought danger and have threatened our communities. And as all of us have experienced over the last year and a half, we know that some of these federal threats have resulted in increased militarized immigration enforcement, which is reckless and dangerous. It includes aggressive rollbacks of our social services. We saw the changes to SNAP impact our communities. It also includes these targeted attacks on racial equity and on our civil rights. And then finally, cuts to federal funding. And there are other things that we have seen our federal government put forth that are really threatening the well-being and the safety of our communities. So the Protecting Chicago initiative was launched with the purpose of fighting back against those harms. And the framework that we are operating under is really encapsulated by these six strategies. So at the top, we know that knowledge and information is power, and we want our Chicagoans to have access to resources and information that they can use to make tough decisions about how to keep their families safe. So we have information campaigns. I'll share a little more detail on the next slide. We are also focused on community safety. We continue to be focused on community safety. It's been at the heart of the mayor's agenda, and we really look at it in a comprehensive way. We have leveraged wide-scale messaging and communication. And at the top of that is Mayor Johnson's bold and very clear messaging about what Chicago stands for and what we're doing. But we work with our press office. We work with our coalition partners and others to get information out to the public. We've seen that in order to combat what is happening at the federal level, we've also had to create some new supportive services. And an example is, for example, with SNAP, when that was cut, we helped to organize some emergency food distribution and worked with our community partners. But across departments and agencies, we've had to look differently at how we provide support to immigrant families and to other Chicagoans that are being impacted by federal problems. Legal and policy. You know, our Department of Law has really leaned into using litigation as a way to defend Chicago. We continue to do that on a regular basis. We've joined over 40 lawsuits, have worked with other cities, with states, to push back on some of this federal overreach. But also internally, updating our policies, guidelines, and protocols so that departments and agencies know how to respond and have access to resources in responding to immigration enforcement and to other federal issues. And certainly in this area of litigation and legislation, we also have executive authority, and we have used that power to issue executive orders, which Sheila Betty will go into more detail about. And then finally, I want to name the coalition building and convening. You know, our administration has centered co-governance and being rooted in community, working with groups across the city to really advance the work and to protect Chicago from these federal harmful policies. I'm going to give a little bit more detail about our Office of Immigrant, Migrant, and Refugee Rights and just some of the scale at which we have been engaging with our community members and really doing some of the advocacy work that is important to this Protecting Chicago initiative. We host a weekly community briefing that at times it's every week, sometimes it's every two weeks, depending on activity. But since October, when the first executive order launched the Protecting Chicago initiative, we've held 25 of these briefings. About 1,200 members have joined them over time. And it is really a way to distribute city information and for community partners to share information with each other. Our team is a part of canvassing events in different neighborhoods, tabling events. We participate in a wide range of community activities, including cultural celebrations, educational events, and advocacy events, reaching thousands of people over the last year and a half. On the policy and advocacy work, as the Office of Immigrant, Migrant, and Refugee Rights, we really provide leadership for our city, but also at a national scale, we have been called to testify and participate in national and international convenings around migration. Most recently at the United Nations, part of the International Migration Review Forum, where we were able to talk about Chicago's welcoming city ordinance, Chicago's response to the federal overreach, and also our migrant mission. We have commented on federal and state legislation, public comment, and we are a leader in the Cities for Action Network, which is a network of over 200 cities and counties that work on immigration affairs. Chicago is a co-chair of that network, and it is a place where we are able to not only share what the city is doing, but also learn from other cities. And then we always are working closely with our departments and sister agencies around a variety of programs. You know, when we first launched the executive orders, the one that started Protecting Chicago initiative, we saw that there was great support for them and lots of momentum, and we have since launched several that Sheila will go into more detail. I'm just going to touch quickly on the first executive order, in which we did three things very clearly. One was to reject federal militarization of immigration enforcement. We came out strongly against the National Guard being here and any other type of militarization, and that laid the groundwork for other cities to speak and challenge that as well. We clarified the role of police officers and CPD, just affirming the Welcoming City Ordinance, restating that CPD does not coordinate or collaborate with ICE and other enforcement. And we called on making sure that our officers were always in uniform, so it was clear that it was CPD and not other law enforcement. And we urged the federal agents that were here to also be in uniform and to be identified. And so that first Protecting Chicago executive order launched the work that we have been a part of now over the last year and a half. And you will hear more about the details of the other executive orders from my colleague, Sheila Betty. Thank you. Thank you very much. Officer Betty. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. My name is Sheila Betty, and I am counsel to the mayor and chief strategy officer. Before I start my remarks, I also want to express appreciation and gratitude to the members of the public who spoke today. Your voices matter, your experiences inform our work, and your courage inspires us. So thank you. I'm going to pick up where the deputy mayor ended and start my remarks on the right to protest executive order. And so I'll take us back to almost a year ago in September 2025. And that's when we saw in Los Angeles and Portland, federal officials using extreme violence against individuals who are protesting in the streets of these cities. We saw them using projectiles and tear gas, shields, uses of force. On the right to success. Whoa. And one of the main skirmishes that we saw occurred on September 1st in Portland, and that was just a few weeks before the mayor signed this executive order. At this time, here close to home, Broadview, the holding facility, began to become a flashpoint as Midway Blitz was gathering speed and people were getting detained at record levels. And so the mayor began to understand that the harm that the federal agents posed to our city wasn't just focused on immigration enforcement, that it was also going to be focused on individuals, including many members of council who were leading rapid response teams, who were showing up and protesting, who were standing up for their neighbors. And there was significant fear that the same tactics that were being reported widely across the country were going to be used here in Chicago. And so the mayor signed the Defending Right to Protest executive order on May 16th, and within just a few days, it became clear that this harm wasn't hypothetical because one of the largest skirmishes at Broadview broke out there where we saw members of our community, members of the faith community, pelted with projectiles. They were used tear gas. They slammed people down on the ground. I know many of you heard complaints from your residents about what happened at Broadview. And the purpose of this order was to provide very clear direction should federal officials attempt to interfere with protests on the streets of the city of Chicago. And it was also to make clear that the presence of federal officials does not suspend the First Amendment. Next slide. So the order does three main things. First, it formalized pre-protest planning with members of our communities. And that helps to ensure that in these rapidly escalating situations that there is a plan in place with CPD, the mayor's office, and the community groups who are engaging in protest. Second, it establishes a process through which CPD and the mayor's office would be communicating with these groups on the scene should federal officials attempt to interfere with protests. One of the things that we saw in some of the other cities is that federal authorities were using the power that they have to police the areas immediately outside of federally run buildings. So there was a concern that protests could happen at the federal courthouse. The feds could try to assert authority outside of the courthouse, outside of the immediate sidewalk. And so what this order did is provide some direction that should that happen, should the federal officials attempt to stop protected First Amendment activity, the Chicago Police Department would work with those who are organizing it to try to find an alternative location. And that was critically important, again, because of the disruption that we had seen across the country. The other reason why this was so important is because of the extensive footprint that the federal government has in the city of Chicago. We all know that the federal courthouse is just a few blocks away. But according to the General Service Administration, there are 17 federally owned buildings in the city of Chicago, 32 federally owned lease buildings in the city of Chicago. And that's not all of the buildings that the feds control here. So this issue of what would happen outside of a federally owned building was one we were really concerned about based on what we saw happening across the country and the reality of what the federal government's control here inside the city. The the other this this order also came about in close collaboration with our community groups who were involved in so many of the large protests. That, again, I know so many of you participated in, including no kings, including the incredibly large action that happened immediately after Midway Blitz was was announced. Next slide. So I'll now move on to the the third executive order relating to ice free zones and the same forward looking response that animated the right to protest or order also was present here. What we saw was that while Midway Blitz was getting ramped up, federal officials were using city property to stage and to engage in in immigration enforcement that included some property outside of police station that included vacant lots and in some of your your wards that also included areas, park district land, some CPS parking lots. And so there was this question of whether the city was going to permit federal agents to use land and property that was paid for by taxpayers to engage in this campaign against residents of the city of Chicago. And Mayor Johnson's answer to that question was was absolutely not. And so we tried to find the the legal ways that we could try to assert control over the city's property. And that's what's really important here. The point of this order was not to try to control federal agents because there are some supremacy issues there, but it was try to assert control over the city's property. And that's what this order did. What this order what this order does is prohibit city owned parking lots or garages or vacant lots, other nonpublic property from being used by the feds during immigration enforcement. And it communicates to the federal government that consent is not given, that the city does not consent to this property being used for immigration enforcement. Next slide. So, again, these these signs have really two purposes. The first is to ensure the feds are clear. The city has not given consent for enforcement on on city property, nonpublic city property. And there's also a public education component here, and that has spread far beyond city property. You'll see in this slide there are two signs. The first one makes it clear that that property is city owned and that there's no consent for immigration enforcement on it. The second sign you'll see up there, the private area no trespassing sign, is a sign that we distributed to over 20,000 of our partners. That includes private businesses, faith institutions, community based organizations. And what happened there is that these private entities were able to designate their nonpublic and their public areas. So their nonpublic areas are areas where federal officials cannot enter without a warrant. And this was really part of a national movement to try to educate the public around the contours of the Fourth Amendment and to ensure that people understood that when we're talking about nonpublic areas, whether it's government owned or private owned, the feds can't enter without a warrant. And the consequence of this is ensuring that members of the public in Chicago and, again, across the country are educated about one of our most important constitutional rights. And that is the right to ask, do you have a warrant? And in the context of immigration enforcement, it's critical that that warrant be signed by a judge as opposed to an administrative warrant. All right. Let's go. Let's go. Let's go back one. And so the other thing about this order that's important is that these signs weren't just signs that were put up for purposes, for symbolic purposes. They also were used in a federal lawsuit that was filed against the federal government by the state of Illinois and the city of Chicago, making the argument that the city, that the feds were essentially co-opting city property for purposes of immigration enforcement. So this executive order provided the basis for enforcement that's currently happening in federal court. This case is still pending, but it provided a really important basis for us to go in and make the constitutional argument that the feds are ignoring the power and the sovereignty of the city of Chicago with its enforcement tactics. All right. Next slide. So the last executive order that I'll talk about has to do with the ICE on notice. And this order happened after the tragedies that we saw in Minneapolis. And it also happened after the tragedy that we saw happening here in the city of Chicago, which includes, of course, the tragic shooting in Brighton, Brighton Park. It also included reports of pepper spray and projectiles and assaults the federal officials committed on our residents. And it was clear that there needed to be some framework for accountability. And I want to take one moment just to emphasize how unprecedented the situation was. We had federal troops on the city on the streets of the city of Chicago and regular reports that those federal officers were assaulting our residents. And not just our residents, but members of the Chicago Police Department got tear gassed. So this is a completely unprecedented situation in terms of how a local government can respond. And the mayor asked for us to find a way to develop a framework for accountability, recognizing that there are limits here in terms of what can actually happen at the scene. Federal authorities also have a significant amount of authority, but it's not unlimited. The immunity that they have when they commit crimes is not absolute. And that's why a framework for collecting information, for investigating these allegations, is so critically important. Next slide. So this what this executive order, the ICE, I know this executive order does, is focus on four really essential responsibilities. The first is is directing. Chicago Police Department that they must provide medical care. The second is that they must confirm the credentials of the federal officials on the field. The third is to document and report what is happening in the field. And then the second is to take complaints from members of the public and, when appropriate, when evidentiary bars are met, refer to the Cook County State's Attorney's Office. Now, this executive order did not invent CPD's authority to do these things, but what it did is answer clearly that some of the existing policies that CPD has in terms of documentation, in terms of investigation, applied with full force to this situation of federal officials on the streets of Chicago. There were a lot of questions from members of the community. We heard this morning that some of those questions persist. And what this order served to do, was to provide an answer to those questions and some guidance about the policy priority of investigating these federal agents that inflicted so much harm in our city. So taken together, these orders established a really coherent progression. The right to protest order is about the public's ability to witness, criticize, and oppose the action from the federal government. The ice-free zones order protects city property and educates residents about the constitutional limits of federal presence. And ISA notice provides a path to accountability for these federal agents. And next slide. And ultimately, these orders are about more than Chicago. They've demonstrated that cities around the country have had a need to look deep into their toolbox to come up with strategies. And today, jurisdictions representing nearly 10 percent of the United States have adopted executive orders based on those authored by Mayor Johnson and signed here in the city of Chicago. And that is the legacy of these orders, showing that local government can lead with courage to use every lawful authority to protect the people it serves. Thank you. Thank you very much for your remarks. I have a number of questions, then I'll open up to members and might have follow-ups after. Could you go to slides 13 and 14? I want to make sure that what we're focused on is that specific executive order, the ISA notice. So first question, because I don't have time to ask every single question, we did submit a number of questions directly. Sorry, this is for Deputy Chief Stevens. We had submitted a number of questions about the executive order and process. What we'd like is a through-the-chair response and writing to the questions that we sent. Have you all sent that, or can you commit to sending it? We can commit to sending it. I don't believe we sent that. Okay. Yes, sir. Thank you very much. So I'm a bit confused as to where I'll start. On the one hand, what I'm hearing is that this is unprecedented, that we've never seen anything like this. I mean, I would say that's what it feels like to me. But in the other, the same conversation, we're saying there's pre-existing policy to deal with situations like this. That, to me, doesn't really jibe. So could you kind of walk through that? Yes, of course. I'm going to introduce Captain Mike Capistanic, who wrote our policy. Yep. Captain Mike Capistanic, CPD Research and Development. When the executive order was issued, there wasn't a barrier for CPD or community members to act within the scope of that executive order. CPD's current policies were allowed, provided for rendering a body camera footage, and it allowed for community members who had complaints or allegations of criminal conduct against federal law enforcement or ICE agents, just like they would report any crime, could report crimes to CPD. CPD will always have the ability to report crimes. Sorry, for clarity there. So you've got pre-existing policy in case anybody reports a crime, body camera footage, all this stuff. But is there anything that has been specifically about federal agents that was already there? No, there wasn't anything specifically about federal agents, and that's where the new policy comes into play. It gives us the opportunity to provide a higher level of supervision to those reports when our officers get called to incidents where community members do make allegations against federal law enforcement or ICE agents. It gives us a better way to report the data. The executive order also requires us to report the aggregate data that specifically identifies ICE officers. The new policy allows us to do that. It also builds the tracking mechanisms and report numbers so that members of the community can track their incidents. And it also allows for incidents that might not rise to the level of a criminal case report in the existing policies, but it would allow, the new policy allows CPD to still gather evidence in that. So if in the future, or if there are trends or patterns or additional information comes about, we document the original incident, we're able to capture that evidence, and we're able to continue to investigate if it does eventually rise to the level of a case report for criminal conduct. Those additional mechanisms, we were working with the mayor's office and the Department of Law in a collaborative effort to identify those challenges on the existing CPD policies and to make sure in this new policy, those standards were clear. Okay, as part of that conversation, are there any documents related to tracking the existing policies that all fall under that scope? Right? So I don't mean to paraphrase, paraphrase, I apologize, but there's things that would already work if anybody committed a crime, right? What this does is it allows for what's already on the books, plus a tracking system to get aggregate data and figure it out so that you can have that information to be able to access body-worn camera in the situation? It's also CPD seeking to get the identities of any federal agents who are on site as well? Yeah, what it also identifies is it identifies, per the executive order, the requirement for CPD members to identify the supervisor on site, and then it also provides mechanisms that when it does rise to that criminal case report that we'll be documenting to route that through our Bureau of Detectives for investigation as well. Got it. Yep. You got a follow-up or point information? Yeah, point information. Got you. I have a question. When was this implemented? Because there's existing, you're saying new policy was implemented. What day, when was this policy implemented? The existing policy has been in policy for a while. The new policy that provides for the better tracking mechanisms and the reporting was finalized and issued today. Yeah, the hearing helped, I think. So I guess the question I've got related to all of that is, like I'm a six-year-old, if you've got one category and column that says, here's the pre-existing law or policy related to these incidents that are federal, right? Here's the new one being proposed, and this is what the complete one is. I'd like to see that through the chair. Because in absence of that, I think it's, it could be easy to say you got pre-existing, right? Hey, there's shoplifting laws in the books. If a federal agent is shoplifting, we have the law in place. It doesn't mean that necessarily that there's any training or any protocol involved in specific incidents like what we see occurring, right? What we see occurring is a federal agent taking over a street, sometimes tear gas, corralling people. And so I think I'm hard-pressed to think that there's pre-existing policy that deals with that kind of situation because it is unprecedented. So how do you square that with, unless you tell me different, that's a completely new scenario, isn't it? Yes. So when we first started seeing these incidents take place, do you want to talk a little about the street deputy order and how we added that extra level of supervision? So we did, you can talk more about, we did review that policy and we added that extra level of response. So if you want to talk a little bit about that. Yeah. What we also did is that in response to earlier incidents, we, not only in this policy that was just issued, that we heightened the level of those individual incidents for reporting. Prior to that, we escalated the response, the supervisory response to those incidents. So if there was an interaction during a civil immigration enforcement effort with ICE or other federal agents, those responding officers would contact their supervisor. And then we increased that to both, to also include their watch operational lieutenant, who's kind of the officer in charge at that time. And the street deputy, who's a deputy, exempt deputy chief level would also respond to take control and be the incident commander of that incident. And that incident commander, then once the incident was over, there's also an after action reporting mechanism that we put into place so that we can identify the observations, the incidents, what our actions were what we observed, the actions of the ICE officers, and then any steps in furtherance or best practices to move forward within that. So that was already implemented. And just to your point on the preexisting policy versus the new policy. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, the pre-existing policy, what you would have to do is you have to look at that policy, and there were no barriers to it, but it wasn't specific to federal law enforcement. There were pathways to do all those actions. What this new policy does is it takes all those pathways and puts it into this policy so that while we did have existing body-worn camera policy, this new policy references that provides clarity on what the responsibility is during those ICE enforcement efforts for our officers for body-worn cameras. So that's what this policy does. It takes those existing policies and frameworks and specifically identifies it for those ICE officer incidents. So related to the incidents, when you all said, like, we start seeing it happen, we decided to change some of the policy related to supervisor, around what time would you say that occurred? Mr. Chairman, may I just add one quick point of clarification? The goal of the executive order was to ensure that if a federal official committed an act of murder that individual would be investigated just like anybody else who committed an act of murder. And so when we're talking about the fact that there were existing policies that apply, that's what we're talking about is the fact that CPD has policies and that those apply with full force. They applied at the point of the order. They still apply now. Those haven't changed. That I understand. To say, and also for federal agents, it doesn't take five months. So that's why I'm trying to get a better understanding. If it's already on the books and all you're saying is you added also for federal agents, it shouldn't take five months for that to be completed. So I'm sorry. I want to go back to data tracking. That was it. That also doesn't take five months. Please let me ask a question. Sorry. So, OK, when was that communicated related to the incident? Right. Because those were unprecedented. So there was a communication within CPD of like, hey, we need a change of strategy. Make sure our supervisors know around when was that? That change in policy was September of last year. We're going to increase supervision for the key pre supervision. And then after action reporting was September of last year that we had the street deputy start responding to those things. How is that communicated? Does that conversation? Is that training? Is that emails? Anytime we issue a new policy, it's announced via an administrative message, which goes out to all department members. It's front and center on our internal website, our intranet site. Additionally, that message provides that unit commanding officers provide that information at roll call for seven days. So there's roll call kind of individual supervisory interaction with officers to announce the revision to the directive. And then also once a month, our officers are required to take an electronic and e-learning curriculum of all the policies that were revised the month prior. And that policy change was included within that e-learning. Got it. So related to that, and I'm glad you guys got legal here. Are you at liberty to share that information as far as when you got those trainings and communications out? Yeah, if you want to get on, Mike. Good morning, everyone. Scott Spears, general counsel, CPD. Those conversations are privileged conversations with the law department. It reflects our deliberative process between DOL, the mayor's office, and how we were able to put this together. I know that it's easy to look at this and say, yeah, it's just a portal, but this was a process we put together to make sure we did it right. We're collecting information from residents who are going to be coming to us with ring camera video, their phone, their camera phone video, whatever they have as evidence. We're encouraging them to bring that to us, but we also want to make sure that we can accurately inventory that and track it. We want to make sure that there is a review that gets done to make sure that these very serious crimes can be put in a position to best be presented to the state's attorney in the event that we are able to bring felony charges. Yeah, no, I appreciate that, and especially when I've been watching the back and forth between the city and state's attorney's office where it's like, hey, state's attorney, you're not moving forward to prosecute, and they're saying, well, we haven't gotten anything to prosecute. I want to know why it's happening there, but I got more questions related to that. This is more specific about what protocol looks like in training officers because to preface all of it, right, it is not my baseline assumption that officers are doing wrong. It is my baseline assumption that this is unprecedented and officers may not know what guidelines are, period, because of the situation. And so in absence of clear guidelines, when it is this unprecedented, you're making decisions that you may not exactly know what the right thing to do is because these are chaotic situations. And so I'm more concerned and not concerned, but want to be informed as to what's being communicated to officers when they're being trained and what that looks like to make sure they know what to do responsibly, right? And there are things that are in the books already, right, the body camera policy and protocol. But this is a different situation when you have federal agents coming in, blocking a street as if they own it, and everything's moving in flux. You've got rapid responders on site. You've got people being abducted. You've got a level of assault and battery by federal agents potentially that anybody, officer or not, right, is going to walk into something brand new and not necessarily know how to act. So knowing that what the communications look like is important, I do understand that there's a lot of it that's internal, but even an understanding that that has happened is something that I think is in the public interest. So is there anything that you're able to share related to any of that kind of communication? I think that we can, you know, certainly share the directive. We can share guidance that we're putting out to our officers, and we can provide that through the share. Okay, and then to your second point related to the tracking, when I say the portal part, it's because, as with a lot of things in government, compared to anything else outside of government, it just moves slow as hell. I don't think that's a technical term, but I think it's accurate. But I would imagine if you already have body camera protocol, it would serve the same way, right? You track it, there's an incident, it's somewhere located on a folder somewhere, a drive, and then you have to create a separate one for federal agent incidents? Actually, what we're concerned about is the evidence that residents would be bringing to us and making sure that we could track and inventory that just as accurately as we do our body-worn camera video. Okay, so, and I don't know if you have anybody from the team, but if through the chair, if possible, even that would be something as far as creating somewhere where someone could submit a request, you put in the complaint, you upload footage, and then that would be somewhere where it's reviewed. Am I missing something there? Am I fine? No, absolutely. Like I said, I'm asking a question just to get an understanding. So, Patrick Kinney, commander with the Bureau of Detectives. So, our biggest concern is making sure that any evidence that is brought to us can be introduced in the court. So, chain of custody is extremely important for us, right? So, if we take it without having that proper policy and that technology behind it, it could get thrown out in court, right? So, if we do try to bring charges against an individual and that evidence was given to us or mishandled by us and it gets thrown out in court, that could potentially ruin the case. So, that's where we have to be very careful to make sure that any evidence we are taking into our custody can be introduced. So, it's kind of similar, right? In this conversation of pre-existing policy and new policy here, is there not that already in place for any other incident where a neighbor might be able to provide – I mean, I would imagine so, right? Camera footage from the home, that kind of stuff? Yeah, absolutely there is. But now that we are tracking it related to federal officers, we had to have a mechanism there to touch back to the reporting side of it being a federal officer. So, every incident where something is reported to us related to a federal officer involvement is not going to rise to the lever of a case report if it's not criminal activity. Without having a case report, we were unable to inventory evidence that could be potentially introduced later. We now have corrected that through technology, and now we can inventory any evidence related to any information that's brought to us related to a federal officer. Got it. Thank you. Something for reference, just for my understanding, is when CPD first started using body cameras, I imagine all of this had to get built, right? The established systems in place you're talking about. How long did that take from, hey, the CPD is deciding we're going to use body cameras to then having the same kind of mechanisms we're talking about right now? I was not part of that process, so I'm unsure. I know we do use vendors for that as well. Yeah, and if we could get that through the chair, I just want to get a sense of, like, how long that took compared to what it means to kind of upgrade or improve some of what's already existing. Yeah. With the body-worn camera, all I do know is that it was district by district by district, so it wasn't a overall everybody get trained right now on this. It was a pilot program. It would start with this district, then it would roll into this district, and then once they covered patrol, it went to the detectives, and it went to counterterrorism. So it was more of a rollout by area where this is going to be a mass rollout to everyone. Right. And actually, thank you very much for that context because I think that would take much longer, right? You're going, trialing it out. You're spreading it out. Once you've kind of built that infrastructure, now you're, in essence, kind of, like, upgrading it. And so I'm trying to get a sense of, based on how long that took and how long this is taking or has taken now that we're hearing about the announcement today, just to get a better understanding of that. So I've got questions related specifically to the June incident because I think the questions I had initially were kind of more general. I guess before that, since January 31st. we are now on July 17th. How many incidents have been reported? How much evidence has been gathered? How much ice stuff has occurred? How much body camera? What does that look like in about five months time? So that was the issue we're having. We could not track it. So because it would go into the general reports, we were unable to track what was done at the time, what's been inventoried. But now moving forward with this new system, we will be able to track specifically these incidents. Sure. And so prior to the tracking system, again, I'm going to sound like a sixth grader, is there no way to search any of those reports by keywords, ice, for example? This is Mike Capistanic from CPD. There are challenges in terms of doing those kinds of queries with narratives or making sure the data is accurate on that. But those case reports that were generated even in the prior policies, those case reports and those criminal case reports went through our existing process. So they would go, the patrol officers would document that. It would go to our Bureau of Detectives Case Management Office. So we continually go through the existing processes. The challenge we had was identifying with accuracy. Because if you, once you start doing keyword searches and other things, a bunch of other data gets put into that. This allows us, this new process allows us to extract that data very specifically and document it very specifically so that we're providing accurate data. Got it. Yeah, yeah. I appreciate that. I think for me, trying to figure out zero to everything that's happening and let's wait for it to update. That's all. So an example is like catalytic converter thefts, right? We used to try to track that. It would be, people would categorize it like damage to vehicle or a theft to auto. And so we had to really zoom in on what we were trying to track because there was no way to get exact numbers. So that's what we did here. We're trying to zoom in so we can get exact numbers on these incidents. Like creating a specific tag for a specific incident. Correct. And then everybody does it the same way. Okay. Got it. So in the Albany Park incident, our understanding in conversations was that what occurred there, which appeared to be, I guess, an ICE incident, like what we've seen happen plenty of times, was categorized as a traffic crash. And then a CPD at that point declined to investigate the incident for further criminality. From what you know, how did that play out where it got marked as, Hey, this is, this is more of a traffic incident than something else? Pat Kinney, Bureau detectives commander. I'll take that question. So we did not decline to investigate it. That's not the right characterization of that case. So it was documented as both a non-criminal, other non-criminal offense. And then there was also another case report generated by the officers and the supervisors that responded to the scene for a traffic crash property damage hit and run. Just for a little bit of context before I go into what happened with that case. So the Chicago Police Department handles around 35,000 hit and runs every year. Of those 150 approximately are fatals, which require a deeper or more in-depth investigation. And then of those 35,000, around 500 are what we call serious personal injury. Serious personal injuries are, could be catastrophic, somebody with a broken arm, broken leg, things of those nature, right? So those are very in-depth investigations. The rest of them are around 30,000 of them are hit and runs with no personal injury. So that was a vehicle on vehicle or maybe a vehicle against an object where nobody was injured. We, due to the sheer volume, we have to triage those cases as they come in. What will happen is a officer on the street will report that, pull a case report number or what we call an RD number, a records division number. That number based on the UCR code, so the Uniform Crime Reporting Code, will then be funneled up to our major accidents investigation unit that handles all serious personal injuries, fatalities, and hit and runs related to traffic accidents. They will do an initial triage. Usually, typically, they reach out to the victim. They see if that victim has any additional information that will aid in our investigation or if there's any additional evidence that that victim has. If there's nothing additional at that point, we will take that case and we will put it in what's called a suspended status. It is not closed out. It's in a suspended status. And if anybody, a witness, a victim, wants to bring us additional information that could help us in our investigation, we then quickly change that from a suspended to an open status and continue on with our investigation. So with this case that you're talking about on June 2nd, that is currently sitting in a suspended status. And when we previously talked, if the victim of that, because that is the reporting party, wishes to come to us with additional information or any factors that can help us identify who the offender or the person that struck their vehicle is, we would be more than willing to open up that case. Another just little point about that. So hit and runs with no injuries are considered class A misdemeanor. So they are not felonies. Got it. Um, so related to this one specifically, uh, if the victim were abducted, who else would be able to file a report? So anybody, any witness, anybody on scene there. And again, that's why, you know, we encourage people to call us, the Chicago police department to respond to that scene, because we do have our body worn cameras that can help document the scene. And we are going to, especially with our new policy over-report on what is being told to us. That's why we have a couple mechanisms in there. Information report, case reports, we're going to over-report on what is being told to us by witnesses or complaining, uh, complaining witnesses. Okay. Um, that's it. If I could just add, I know, um, we've heard that there are some, um, people that don't want to come into the police station to make a report. We have a, um, a 3-1-1 phone call and that number, the other side of that number are police officers. And those officers can take those reports by phone. So they do not witness. If they're, um, unsure of coming into the police station, they can call 3-1-1 or they can call 9-1-1. And those phone, those reports can be taken over the phone as well. Sure. So in, um, incidents like this without a report, whether it's a witness or someone else on site, does that preclude CPD to get like, um, LPR footage or pod camera footage or any other footage from local businesses or anything that would have occurred in an incident? Does, if you don't get a report, does that mean you don't do that? Or is there a protocol of like actually gathering information? Because in this particular instance, there would have been footage from like the Sun-Times, bystanders, nearby businesses, police observation, device cameras, traffic cameras, body cameras, all of that. So if we're talking about the specific incident, it's, again, there's a victim of this. So we have to work at the victim's wishes, right? What the victim wants us to do. If the victim wants us to pursue the case report that was generated or doesn't. In this one, I don't have that one, uh, that, that personal knowledge about what the victim said in this incident. Um, but that's just generally what would have to happen. Okay. Um, is there a specific, I know there's preexisting protocol. There's the incident now, um, in an incident that most folks in Chicago, I think would identify as an abduction. Is that not something that could be filed under as opposed to a traffic incident? So with, with our current policy that we just issued today, absolutely. They can document, they can notify us of anything and we will document everything, right? So, so we are not going to make that determination. What we didn't want to do is have that police officer on the scene with limited information, uh, make a determination if something was criminal or not criminal. So we erred again on the side of just over reporting. So now we're directing our officers that any information about federal agents that is brought to you and you're unsure if it's criminal or not criminal document. And we will then have supervisor oversight for that. Okay. So I know when the executive order dropped on, uh, January 31st, uh, that's what we were told, right? If there's an incident officers will go on site, they're going to interview all the witnesses to gather data and evidence when some of this occurs. Did that occur in June? Yes. There's case reports generated and there's information in those cases. There's interviews from witnesses who might've corroborated said something happened and none of them, none of them took it a step further to say, I want to file a report. The report was filed, sir. Meaning, meaning more than a traffic crash. Like here's, here's the reason why I'm asking that in most incidents. And I think in Chicago, we know in Albany park, if something like this goes down, you're going to see neighbors all come out and all try their best to protect as many people as possible. They're watching this go down. If they're all being interviewed, I'm hard pressed to think that none of them would have said, yeah, we need to file a report. This looks like somebody got abducted. Let's go put this in because I guess what I'm hearing is that nobody said that. That's not correct, sir. So that is documented in the reports. But that doesn't, that wouldn't trigger unsuspending it if somebody said that and wanted further investigation. Can you repeat your question again? Yeah, I'm going off of what you said. So pardon me if I got it wrong. You said we saw a traffic incident occur, didn't see any broken arms, legs or anything that would trigger something higher. So because of that and no further kind of report mechanism or no one saying it was something more, it went into suspension. The traffic accident. Correct. Yes. I guess in interviewing. OK, in interviewing people on site, is there another investigation still open related to someone else saying talking about something else that wasn't a traffic incident? Currently, no, there's not. So that's my question. You talk to all these people on site. They all view it as an abduction. They're showing up. They got whistles like crazy. None of them said, hey, this is a problem needs to be investigated further than a traffic incident. They didn't request us to investigate. No, they they told us what they saw. And it was documented by the patrol officers that showed up on that scene. But because no one made a specific request to go further. And and I'm not trying to put you in the spot. I think for me, it's good for the public to understand the clarity, to ask that question if that's the case. Gotcha. So so we we we base our investigations off what victims tell us. Right. Right. So if there's a victim to a crime and they are reporting it or somebody is reporting on their behalf, like a family member or something like that, we will generate a case report for that victim and then follow it up. It will be brought initially through patrol and then moved up to the detective division based on where it occurred and what type of crime it was. OK, thank you. I'll go to my colleagues. Felix, you had questions or just a point of information? OK, I'm excited. Thank you, chairman. Thank you to everyone who's here. You know, I think what we're talking about clearly is extremely important for the time that we're in in our nation's history. The the ability for us to keep record of this moment is going to be very important for future, the present and the future of our of our city and of our nation. It's important that we keep track of the the constitutional, civil and human rights abuses that are taking place in our communities. It's important that we hold each other accountable. There are so many different contradictions that we are all navigating at once. But our principles and the upholding of the law must remain true. And that's a responsibility that we all have. And I'm very grateful to everyone who has done the work of protecting our communities in these very violent and scary times. As we work to build the movement necessary to abolish ICE in this agency, our ability to track and keep record of everything that's taken place is going to be very important in our effort to prosecute the abuses that have taken place. So, again, I want to thank everyone for all their work in in these efforts. So I just want to better understand. So right now, is CPD trained to begin recording all federal enforcement activity? So if there is a call to 9-1-1 and residents are saying there is federal enforcement activity happening in the area right now, or if officers see that happening, are they trained to begin recording immediately? Yes, sir. By our body-worn camera policy, which was a policy that we already had produced, anytime they respond to a 9-1-1 call, they activate their body-worn cameras prior to arriving on scene. Same with a hand waver. If they're driving down the street and somebody waves them down for assistance, they will activate that body camera. So anytime they use any kind of police official duties, they do activate those body cameras, and they are all trained on that, yes? Excellent. And then what are the steps that take place after that? Like, what are the reporting mechanisms that CPD officers engage in? Because, imagine, there is a whole wide variety of circumstances that take place during federal enforcement activity. Sometimes there is the great fortune that we have rapid responders available who are also engaging in recording activities. Sometimes somebody is kidnapped and abducted by themselves, and sometimes there are only other vulnerable people who are there or other people who have not been trained, other residents that don't know what to do in that moment. So that's why there needs to be, you know, more education for the broader community as a whole. But when it comes to CPD officers who have reported to a scene where an incident has taken place and they have recorded what they could, what are the reporting mechanisms after that? Okay, thank you. That's a great question. So they report to the scene with their body cameras activated. If an individual needs aid, they ensure aid is rendered by calling for fire over their department radio. As soon as aid is rendered, they ensure the scene is secure and witnesses and any victims are identified. At that time, also a sergeant will be responding as well as the watch operations lieutenant, and the watch operations lieutenant is the lieutenant that's in charge of that watch in that district, as well as, we spoke earlier, the street deputy. So 24 hours a day, there's a street deputy that's on duty that responds to these incidents. The street deputy will respond and become the incident commander of that incident. It is their responsibility to, or if there's only a lieutenant at the time, identify as best they can who the ICE officials that were out there and document that all of this information will be documented in the information report. That is why we really needed that extra technology part, because if they do have video evidence, we can now attach that to that information report number. So now information reports will have numbers associated with them in order to track, and the victim or the complainant, the witnesses, will be given that information number in order to follow up. Excellent. And then can you possibly walk me through any investigative work that is done by CPD when an incident has taken place? So, for example, unfortunately, you know, I have been a witness to incidents where people have been taken from their cars, from the middle of the street, and all that's left is their belongings, and sometimes running cars, like keys in the ignition in the middle of the street, and someone has literally been abducted and stolen from their vehicle, from our community, and all that is left is their personal property. Sometimes there are residents there to respond. Sometimes it's too late. What work does CPD do to better find out who has been taken? Is that something that you all have done in the past? So, generally speaking, I don't have a specific incident, but generally speaking, yes, if there was a vehicle there, we would absolutely run the license plate of that vehicle in order to determine whose vehicle it was and then try to make contact with family members. I don't have any specific incidents to refer back to, though. Yeah. And, yeah, literally there have been times where I've had to help move vehicles out of the public way, and I know that a lot of rapid responders have done the same. I'm literally getting shaken up because it's just bringing up so many different things that we've had to navigate in our communities. But I just want to make sure that, like, if you can speak to, you know, if any of these vehicles do have to get towed, you know, making sure that that comes at no cost, the families, do you have any protocols around that that I should be aware of? No, Mike Capistanic Research and Development CPD. If a vehicle was found on the public way like that unattended, like the commander said, we would try to identify the owner or family members to be able to take control of that vehicle. If they're unable to take control of that vehicle, we have to follow our normal protocols to remove it from the public way. So it would be our normal process. Got it. Well, I think we should just take note of that because we should make sure that, you know, that comes at no financial costs or burden to impacted families. Okay, so when an incident has taken place, and I believe some of these questions may have been asked already, but I just want to resurface them or answer it already. I just want to resurface them. An incident has taken place. Residents have evidence. You all have evidence. What kind of evidence can residents provide? Can it be, you know, videos or pictures from their phone, ring cameras? What can people provide and what kind of formats? Yeah, so great question. Pat Kinney, Bureau Detectives Commander. Video evidence is great for us, right? That is going to be that silent witness that helps us. It's objective, and it's going to kind of show us what happened there because most of the times we're not going to be there. Actual eyewitnesses also. We need to be able to talk to people and understand what they observed and what they saw. Any type of physical evidence that a witness may have seen fall off a car or happen during the incident that they can direct us to is also a great help. Usually some video evidence will help us direct us to that physical evidence, but witnesses can do that as well. And now – I'm sorry, may I add Jill Stevens, Patrol. It does not have to be immediate. So if they find video, someone comes up to them and says, hey, I have a video of something that I saw happen to you, they can at any time come in and get that inventory. So it does not have to be immediate. If it's after the fact, a week later, two weeks later, they can bring that in, and it could be attached to that information report. Got it. And then proactively, can and will CPD also utilize pod cameras, OEMC assets to help corroborate evidence? So we will follow up on crimes that are reported to us. So that is definitely a tool we utilize day in, day out in the Bureau of Detectives, our license plate readers, our pod cameras, police observation devices to follow up on cases. So absolutely, if it is moved up to the level of a case report, that is one of the steps we will take. Got it. Got it. The next question I have is around data protection. So what kind of data protection is there for residents who submit this information? Is that subject to federal search and seizure? You know, I want to make sure that our residents can provide this information in confidence and not be prosecuted for potential. you know nonsense charges by the federal government what kind of protections we have there good afternoon scott spears from second legal affairs um we absolutely have protection for that information that is submitted to cpd that becomes part of our investigative file system we will hold that we will protect that can the federal government acquire people's names information uh for evidence that they've submitted to the city we don't provide victim and witness information can you say sorry can you speak a little bit closer to the mic we don't provide victim and witness information okay but is that something that can be acquired there is probably a universe in which that happens i think that we saw that up in minnesota with the uh the case involving um the federal agent who fled to texas where a resolution of that minnesota litigation was an exchange of information between the hennepin county attorney and the federal government but that was an extreme situation um that was negotiated as part of the resolution of a lawsuit um you know as far as you're asking would we willingly give that up no we would not do that and then um how long uh you know is our kind of um inventory for data like this um scheduled for you know is there kind of like a release of data how long will we hold on to this uh any evidence that's been submitted to the city it would be held indefinitely sir excellent and yeah that goes back to the original point that i made you know we're not in a universe now where we can prosecute ice officials but i hope that we get to that point and i hope that the data and the information and the efforts that we do here today help contribute to that case so that we can reaffirm our uh principles of life liberty and justice for all thank you so much thank you very much um also as a follow to your line of questioning uh alderman casada we actually introduced uh a ordinance uh related to towing obligations costs and everything because of everything we're seeing so it's currently sitting in license and consumer uh for license and consumer protection committee so we can follow up on that as well yeah happy to the co-sponsor all right next up uh alderman sixo lopez thank you chairman and um uh thank you for all the people who came to this important hearing as well as chicago police department representatives and the mayor's office um i want to follow up uh alderman quesada's follow a chain of uh questioning especially around chain of command gathering of evidence and how investigations must happen um i know the chairman referred to the incident on june so i'm going to go to another incident that happened um last year in the brighton park neighborhood i was present in this incident where one of our constituents one of our neighbors marimar martinez was shot at five times um i want to understand why was it that the chicago police department issue a statement condemning anybody who shot at these ice mercenaries when it was evident that such evidence did not exist i want to understand what is the chain of command to first of all gather video footage evidence testimony before we make a determination what is the chain of command and let me let me start with that question to cpd what is the chain of command for the police department to gather evidence testimony video footage before a statement or uh launching of an investigation happens so peckney commander bureau detectives uh specifically to that incident is currently being investigated by the federal bureau of investigations and not the chicago police department okay so the federal bureau investigation is investigating itself because you see the problem here is that federal agents launch an attack on residents and also police officers that day they tear gas elected officials neighbors including chicago police department officers so is this something that we truly believe is going to be investigated by the same agency that perpetrated this in my opinion attack on residents including cpd officers so the fbi is a different agency than ice um and they are the ones currently investigating so we know for a fact that this is being investigated is there any information the chicago police department provides to the fbi how do we know that they're actually investigating that is my question my understanding they showed up on scene and were the ones investigating the shooting is there any collaboration between the federal uh bureau of investigation and the chicago police department on a regular basis like i mean if it's like federal you know immigration or there's any other issues is there like a regular communication is this something that you can verify that because to this day this is the first time i hear that is actually being investigated so that shooting was always uh initially investigated by the fbi we will have to get it through the chair about the current status if they're willing to provide that to us thank you i do think that it's critical that we provide such information because i do think that there are serious irregularities in this first you know uh and i'm and i i i um i think marie martinez is fortunate to be alive because she could have been uh just as we have seen parents these are not criminals this is a neighbor who was just alerting their neighbors within her right of presence of ice mercenaries who were coming to terrorize our neighborhood i think that it is imperative that the chicago police department uh and i will go to my second line of questioning that that we provide all the necessary evidence that we provide testimonies that we provide video footage before we validate the false narrative that the federal government is providing criminalizing neighbors criminalizing parents criminalizing street vendors and neighbors who are making uh in our city or city an economic engine as it should be so i do think and through the chair i hope that we can get the information and verification that indeed they are investigating this because they're contradictions the chicago police department put a statement basically validating what the uh dhs have said now we know and marie martinez herself and i can tell you validating by elected officials who were present and she has testified in front in front of congress that she never shot at any police officer and i want to make sure that is on the record she never shot at anyone the cameras and testimonies validate that so certainly i would like to put it on the record that this should be investigated as a why these ice agents did not only lie to the public they lied to the chicago police department they lied to everybody who was present but not only that they conspired to shoot her there were text messages that showed that these individuals were conspiring to shoot an at a resident who committed no crime so i do appreciate that the chair can follow up with that yeah can you for clarification for the through the chair can you um kind of restate specifically what you want them to send yeah so uh i think that we're going to follow up with the bureau of federal investigation if indeed such investigation is happening or has continued and any updates that they have on this particular case on october 4th be communicated to the chicago council to the city council via the committee of immigration and refugee rights we will do that okay thank you very much uh next we have oh sorry no please go ahead i'm not done yet yes um so i do think that that is important because and this is my second this is my second question and i do appreciate that the street vendors and many people are here because i i i i believe that it's critical that these investigations happen because right now i think one of my concerns on that that's my second question to the mayor's office i understand that there's now a task force that is looking at or there's looking at these evidence or they will be forming to make sure that there's more uh a due process my biggest concern here is that if investigations are not happening by the chicago police department then the the attorney the state's attorney is saying that basically that if there's nothing submitted to her office that she's not going to investigate i do think that there has to be a process where through a task force in the mayor's office through the chicago police department and maybe through the through the city council um we can submit information to the state's attorney's office i think that um it is shameful that these instances have continued to pile incidents where we see street vendors being picked up by ice these these individuals are coming outside of our courts and picking up and terrorizing domestic violence victims imagine the level of criminality that we have here disregarding our laws disregarding the fact that we have in the state of illinois and in cook county mandated that ice agents should not be uh they should not be uh they should not be outside of the courts picking up domestic violence victims of innocent people who are just going to court that is a a problem that we see with the street vendors that have now been going to an unrelated issue and now have been instances being reporting being arrested outside of our courts so i do hope and maybe there's a there's something that come uh maybe through the mayor's office or the chicago police department what are we doing in terms of submitting evidence to the state's attorney so that they can and they should be investigating uh any kind of violation of city code and and violations of our state laws as well so and maybe there's a question maybe to the maybe to the mayor's office if what are the steps for this maybe task force to be completed how we can collaborate because i do not accept the state's attorney's answer we're seeing what happened in philadelphia and minneapolis these state's attorneys are conducting criminal investigations these agents if they have a badge that does not give them the right to execute with death squats neighbors you parents, innocent people who are just making ends meet? Thank you for that question, Mr. Chairman, and share both your outrage and concern over what it means if we act as if federal officials have complete immunity when they are engaging in this. And that's why it was so important that just this morning, the mayor and Superintendent Waller issued a statement providing clear direction to Chicago residents who want to report these crimes. As representatives of the Chicago Police Department said, people can report by going into a district and bringing their evidence with them. They can also report by using 311 and 911. And we think that statement, again, issued both by the mayor and the superintendent, provides a very clear direction to residents. We understand that part of the outrage here is that it has been widely reported, we've all seen it on our phones and in the news, what this violence has looked like during Midway Blitz, and that there's real frustration that enforcement action hasn't been taken. But what is needed in order to ensure that cases can be referred, our first-person accounts, our victims who are going to be willing to testify, to give further information to the Chicago Police Department. And that's why it is so important that people come forward and use these processes. We understand that for many reasons, people may be hesitant to come forward and to tell their stories. But accountability is going to require people coming forward using either 311, 911, or going into their district offices to ensure that CPD has access to to first-person accounts and any medical records, video, other types of evidence. Thank you. And last, I'd like to finish with, I know that StreetVendors.com, I know there's an organization that we have been working very closely. It is really heartbreaking. You know, I... My apologies. If you could reserve that for when we get into that item, I'd appreciate that. We have other members. Yeah. Yes. Thank you, Chairman. Sure. Alderwoman Cruz. Thank you, Chairman. And thank you to everybody who's here in the panel. Our lives have changed, how we live life, how do we protect our neighbors, and how do we legislate, and policies have changed as well. So I do want to say, again, I appreciate all of you being here and open to all these questions. I'm going to follow up with one of the questions that the Chairman asked, and it's about implementation. Like, ensuring, how will you all ensure that everyone, every single officer, every single department, district, I'd rather say, is receiving this information, and that everybody is following the order? So what, you know, throughout everything that you do in implementation, like how you will ensure that this, indeed, people want our understanding, and two, their following? Thank you, Alder, Alder person. So what we do is we have a directive, a department directive, which is a general order that all officers follow, and that is going to be uploaded in our e-learning system. I believe it already might be. It'll upload into our e-learning system, and every single officer has to go on and read these orders and mark that they have completed it and that they understand it. The second thing we do is we send out an administrative message center, and that goes department-wide. It's called an AMC, and it's on our department internal wire, where it pops up as soon as they log on their computer, and they can click on that, and it'll be on that AMC message right on their desktop of their computers or on their phones. The third thing we are doing in the Bureau of Patrol, we are creating what we call our BOPS, so a Bureau of Patrol operations. So what we do is we do a one-page notification on what is going on and what they need to know and what's new and what's different, and we publish that to all the commanders of the districts. Those commanders put it in what we call a CO book, which is our commanding officer's book, and it's left outside of the roll call room for the officers to read at any time. But on top of that, those lieutenants on every watch take that BOP, that we call it, and they present it to roll call seven days in a row. So officers that are RDO have their regular days off. Don't miss that training. So it'll be read in roll call by these lieutenants on all the watches in the districts so that they understand and they can have discussions and they can ask questions, and if there's any questions that they don't have answers to, they will run that up to me, and I will work with policy and things of that nature to ensure patrol is trained on this. Okay, perfect. Thank you for the detailed information. I'm going to go back also with something with license plates, and at times, you know, we find ourselves helping most of the time, making sure that we bring back those belongings to the family members of those who have been affected, whether calling toll trucks, everybody to help us to identify, again, how do we return their belongings. I have asked like, hey, can you run a license plate? So I have reached out to, you know, my police sister can say, can you write a, you know, run a license plate for me? Have we told no? Because of it, I think everybody's so concerned and worried, making sure that they're not doing something wrong, that they're going to get in trouble. How can we change it? Is that something that, as an older person, I can have access? So I'll take that, and then if General Counsel Spears wants to jump in here. So the license plate systems are ran by the Illinois Secretary of State and the state police. There are rules and regulations that the police have to follow in order to be able to run a license plate, okay? Victims of crime, if we have that, we could run it, or if there's a case report and it's related to an investigation, we can do it. We can't run license plates for people at their request. So in that incident that you're talking about, my suggestion, again, would be to have the Chicago Police Department come out, explain, or have somebody explain to us what happened so we can document it, and then at that point, it would be able to trigger us to be able to run it to gather further information. But somebody just contacting us and asking us to run the license plate, we absolutely cannot do that. Okay. Okay, good for clarification, because now we can have that. Eventually, we'll figure it out, right? But I just want to make sure that I have that ability to help those who are in need in that moment. The second thing is, when it comes to staging, I do want you to walk me through the process. So if CPD is informed of federal agents being staged at parking lots, what is the protocol? And I'll follow why am I asking this? So we call our police districts, they're notified that ICE agents are there. As a department, what do you do next? So if it's in our parking lots, we don't allow any staging in our police department parking lots, if that's your question. But we have had incidents where that exactly has happened, and nothing is done. I do have to say there was one, and I won't say the police district, because I am even worried for them, because they did the right thing. They actually said, went out to the individuals, to the ICE agents and says, you know, this is city property, you cannot be here. They actually were able to leave. So the community was really welcome and, you know, happy that they did that. But we have heard about other incidents when they're told, like, hey, they are in your parking lot, and nothing gets done. Can we make sure we notify those district commanders? It's important that those district commanders of those district stations are aware of it. So I know a lot of the aldermen do have good relationships with the commanders. If you can please just call that district commander and make that notification. And I have to say, I do have with my three, and that's why one of them was able to help. But there are situations at a, you know, bigger scale that I just, you know, they're not my commanders. But I just wanted to know, what is, again, the protocol and to ensure that, again, they leave those parking lots. Yes. And you said exactly what we would do. We would go into that parking lot. We'd ask them to leave and say, this is our property. This is city, city of Chicago property. So we know of anything not happening. Could we reach out to you, Deputy Chief? Absolutely. Absolutely. All right. The second, another question is, based on what we know, what we have seen, and what you have observed as well, do you believe that the police department has handled these situations appropriately? Yes, I do. So when the police gets there, you know, there's a very chaotic scene. Police gets there, addressing everybody who's there, you know, asking them to disperse, to leave, and not really addressing the ICE agents first to figure out what's going on, and rather pushing back those who are there. Do you believe that has been handled appropriately? So I believe, like the chairperson said earlier, it's a very chaotic scene, and this is unprecedented for us. So officers are responding to these scenes, and they are ensuring public safety. So they are responsible for ensuring the safety of the scene and the members and the community members that are on scene. But these agents are threatening, are those who are there, whether they're getting in their face, whether, you know, pointing tasters at them. And the first persons that get addressed are those who are there to protect those vulnerable, and rather than addressing those ICE agents? I'm not aware of those situations you're referring to. So you have not seen or heard anything like that? Well, we have de-escalated, and like was mentioned earlier, 20 of our officers were gassed in a situation like that, trying to de-escalate these situations. Yeah, I've seen that. And I know that, again, everybody has been impacted. Thank you. I just want to make sure that we have that on record. And we are giving clear guidance with this directive to our officers on what they should be doing when they respond to scenes. So this will be definitely a step in the right direction. Okay, perfect. Thank you. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you very much. Yeah, Alderman Gutierrez. Thank you. I just have a question. When there's an abduction and police was called, we wait until a constituent or someone, a family member reported or your officers are supposed to get in the description of the person, like getting like a report going, what they saw on site when they were called. So I'm not sure I understand the question. So when the officers respond and there's nobody on scene, they would just have to talk to the witnesses to get as much information about the incident as possible. And they do document that in a report. But again, a lot of unknowns, we'll document descriptions. So if we have a male, female, any descriptions, that'll be included in the report. But if they're on scene, they will take the reports from those witnesses. But then they're mandated to reporting back and saying, we realized someone was taking, it was a woman wearing this shirt. Like, is there a report that they're supposed to file when that happens? Sure. So thank you. With this new way to track, we'll be able to add additional information. So if the officer comes to the scene and there's nobody there except maybe one witness that said they saw this, and we take this information report, if a family member comes and says, my family member was here, we can add that information now with this tracking system to the report that was originally documented. So as we gather additional information and evidence, we can add it to that tracking number. Yeah, because there's been instances where they're looking for their family members. They saw that police was present at the time of the abduction. But then sometimes they say, did police took it or ICE took it, right? So how can we make sure where to find our family member? And if there's a report that then CPD could pull up, that would be really helpful for us to help the constituent navigate these really hard times in order for them to find their family members. And if they're concerned, if maybe it was an arrest versus that, they can always come into the police station and give that name. And we can find out if that name is in custody somewhere with us to help alleviate that as well. Okay. Thank you so much. Thank you very much. I've got some follow-ups. Probably not surprising, but thank you guys. So first, separate from the reporting, I had the same incident in, I'm not going to share what district either, where the agents actually used the parking lot at a police station. And ultimately, I had to show up to get them to get them out. How many times has DHS violated the executive order regarding staging or operating on city property? Good afternoon, Chair Scott Spears, CPD Legal Affairs. I'm not sure that we have that information documented. What we can do is take a look through our records and see if we can get you a response through the chair. Okay. Has it just never – and I know you don't know, has it ever been documented? Is that any part of policy or protocol related to, hey, if ICE shows up in a parking lot, we need to get a record of this? As I sit here, I'm not aware of that, so we'll have to get that through the chair. Yeah, if you could send that to the chair, greatly appreciate it. And then I'm curious if the same rules apply to O'Hare Airport, that city property, right? Mr. Chair, may I? Yeah, absolutely. Thank you. So there certainly have been instances where signs have been up and federal agents have gone in and they have ignored those signs and they've engaged in immigration enforcement. And most disturbingly, perhaps, what happened at the rideshare lots at O'Hare. And in that instance, the mayor's office, aviation, CPD worked together to get security out there 24-7 after the first raid that happened in those lots. And the federal agents just went right past that security officer. And because of that, because we realized that, unfortunately, these signs were not creating a protective shield, that's why the litigation is so important. And that's why the Department of Law is tracking all of these instances so we can go in before a federal judge and make the argument that the federal government is co-opting the city of Chicago's property. So the tracking that you're referencing in terms of when the signs have failed to provide their protective intent is critically important for the litigation process. And so we've worked with our departments. We have got a reporting process for them that's gone out to all of the departments. And that information is being used by the DOL to inform that lawsuit. Got it. So to my understanding, DOL is the one housing the tracking, if that would occur, because it could be CPD, it could be elsewhere at city property. So they're the ones who would have the tracking? The tracking is through the mayor's office, and then we hand that over to DOL. Okay. Do the chair, would you be willing to submit to the committee the number of incidents that have occurred and where they have occurred in the city? Just general widgets, not details. Of course. Okay. Thank you. Similarly related to kind of tracking and transparency, now that there is this tracking mechanism in place that got announced this morning, is that an internal tracking? Is that something that's public facing? What is that currently? Mike Kapistanic, CPD Research Development. The policy that was implemented today also provides for that data to be released to the public and presented to the public, the aggregate data from that reporting. So now that the policy is in place, the police department will work on mechanisms to provide that data to the public. Okay. So it's absolutely possible to do so per the policy. I guess my question is, how long would it take now that that's implemented to have a public facing dashboard showing the aggregate data? In terms of time frame, I would have to get that through the chair. We don't work on that research development. We can get that through the chair on how the progress of that dashboard would go. Okay. Also, if through the chair, unless you know now, the name of the vendor that has established the tracking system or public dashboard, who does that for the city to kind of know how they operate, what their regular timelines look like, all of the above? Do any of y'all know who the contractor vendor is for all of this? In terms of the mechanisms that we put in place with the policy today and the dashboard, that's all done internally within CPD. Got it. So it's a specific CPD team. Correct. There's a CPD unit that works on data, works on transparency dashboards, a CPD unit. They're the ones who create it all. Correct. Okay. Can I get a commitment to meet with that team so we can get a better understanding of how it's all being built and how long it takes? We can get that, yeah, through the chair. We can probably get a time. Yeah. And the reason why I say that as a meeting is I imagine there's information that might be shared that's internal Chicago information as far as what's getting done as opposed to full public. I'd like to get an understanding of it to then be able to discern, okay, this could be public and this is what this looks like compared to what isn't, right? Because I do understand that there's information protection that's involved with all of this. So thank you. Those are the questions I have. Oh, I guess one more. Sure. So my colleague, Audemars Cesar Lopez, referred to a task force that the city has related to looking at some of these incidents to try to figure out what could be moved forward to the state's attorney's office. Do I understand it correctly? It's my understanding that that was part of the chairman's question and that there's not a task force that's been officially announced. The first step, I think, towards moving in the direction was the announcement that happened this morning, making clear what the practice is for people to come forward and file their complaints and get their evidence to CPT. Got it. So there isn't a current task force in place. Let's get this system to kind of track it, get a task force, look at it, and keep moving forward. Exactly. Okay. No, thank you very much for that. And thank you all. Now we will move on to the second item. Yep. Yes. Oh, yes. Oh, sorry. To clarify, CPD, love you guys to death. We won't need you here for the second item as it relates to CPD policy and the street vendors. So I want to make sure that was clarified before we – yeah, still going to need y'all for a policy. Yeah. Yeah. Sorry. Yeah. We're just switching the subject. Got it. Y'all switch the seats. Totally cool. Thank you. And thank you all very much for the information on the last item. Okay. I'll move. Yeah, it was – I'll stay just okay. I don't know what I am. All right. Do you want to switch? Do you want to switch? So the second item today is a subject matter hearing on the criminalization of the street vendors. As we all have seen in recent news, there's – Incident in the city where there was enforcement of current laws in place. And I have a lot of questions related to what violations look like, tickets look like, because in the specific incident that we learned about, whatever ticket was issued led to them having to go to court. Then they went to court and ICE was there to subsequently abduct them upon leaving, entering court. And now they've been taken away and they're in a detention center somewhere. And so when we don't have laws in place currently to understand the current moment of our street vendors, we know that there's challenges. We know that sometimes they may be occupying spaces and you guys are getting calls from neighbors, alders to try to move forward just to get a better understanding of what policy needs to look like. And I believe needs to change to in order to not have folks who are out here just trying to earn a buck and do it in the most legal way possible. We have a lot to update here, but just to get a better understanding of what that can look like. So with us today to speak on this item first, we have Maria Orozco from the Street Vendors Association of Chicago. Maria, if you'd like to begin. Hello. Good afternoon. My name is Maria Orozco. I'm a proud daughter and granddaughter of street vendors. And on the weekends, I'm a vendor as well. I also work for the Street Vendors Association of Chicago. Today, we are here to represent the thousands of street vendors across the city of Chicago and the surrounding suburbs who are afraid to speak up. These are difficult times. For years, many vendors have felt unheard and unseen. Yet today, despite their fears, a handful of them stand here with us in solidarity, representing the many other vendors who cannot be here. Over the past years, our vendor community has endured hardship after hardship. While these events should never become normal, suddenly, sadly, they no longer surprise us. When Operation Midway Blitz began in Chicago, vendors started being detained while working in their stands. Alejandro Paricio was one of the first vendors detained by ICE despite not having a criminal record. Unable to endure the conditions inside the detention center, he felt forced to sign voluntarily deportation papers, a decision he regrets to this day. Alejandro Paricio is the same vendor who, three and a half years earlier, was robbed at gunpoint while working beside his son. During that robbery, his son was shot in the leg. Both incidents happened at the exact same location where he worked every day to provide for his family. Maria Lopez, a tamal vendor, a mother and a wife, was also detained and remains in immigration detention center today. Francisco, a seven-year-old vendor with serious heart conditions, made the heartbreaking decision to sign his removal order because of his declining health. Fausto's story gives us hope. After spending eight months at the detention center in Michigan, he was finally reunited with his family just a few weeks ago. During those eight months, his family worked tirelessly just to keep food on the table and pay the bills. These are only a few of the names behind the headlines. They are mothers, fathers, neighbors, people who wake up before sunrise to feed our communities and help make the city thrive. Every one of them has asked the same question. What about my family? Then, just as vendors began to recover and our neighborhoods once again filled with the energy that every Chicago summer brings, another crisis emerged. Three months ago, vendors in downtown Chicago began receiving citations from the Department of Business Affairs and Consumer Protection, BACP, followed by arrest by the Chicago Police Department. Instead of being sent to administrative hearing, many vendors received court dates at the Cook County Circuit Court on Florney Street, a courthouse that handles preliminary hearing for felony criminal cases. Our colleague, Juan, and our president at the organization worked tirelessly to connect vendors with organizations that could accompany them because ICE has been reportedly spotted outside the courthouse. Unfortunately, two of our vendors for those fears became reality. After a judge dismissed their cases and dropped every charge against them and told one of the officers, please stop sending me vendors here because they are working, they're a class working people. They walked outside and expected to go home to their families. Instead, ICE was waiting. Norma and Fabian were both detained immediately after leaving court. Norma is a young mother of a nine-year-old daughter and a four-year-old son. She sells food to support her family. Her children and husband waited for her to come home after what could have been a routine court appearance. She never came home. Norma remains in detention today. Fabian, also a father, has since been deported, leaving behind his wife and young son. What were the felony charges, you may ask? Silly mango and watermelon in downtown Chicago. Chicago proudly calls itself a sanctuary city, yet today many immigrant communities are terrified. We no longer know who we could trust. We are asking for accountability. We are asking for the communities between city departments. We are asking for communication between city departments for the families that are not separated, so that families are not separated because of preventable mistakes. A simple administrative error or sending someone to the wrong courthouse instead of an administrative hearing can change an entire family's life forever. Despite everything, we remain deeply grateful to every organization, attorney, volunteer, and community member who has stepped forward to support our vendors. Their solidarity has shown us what is possible when a community stands together. Beyond enforcement, vendors continue to face violence, harassment, and racial profiling. Last Saturday, just outside of Moles Cantina on Kedzie Street, a flower vendor was cornered against a fence by an intoxicated individual violently assaulted and thrown to the ground. Our vendors are yelled at, harassed, threatened, and attacked while simply trying to earn an honest living. We understand that some people have misconceptions about street vendors, and that is why we are here, to educate our community and help our vendors understand the laws that govern this work. We recognize that licensing matters. We understand that there are restricted areas and regulations that must be respected. But when the licensing processes can take up to six months, even after applicants have submitted everything required, it creates uncertainty barriers for hardworking families trying to do things the right way. We ask the city to work with us to improve that process. If creating a new ordinance is not possible today, then help us strengthen the ordinance that already exists. Help us create a system that works for everyone. Our organization has existed for more than a decade, fighting for dignity, fairness, and opportunity for street vendors. The children of vendors are no longer little. We are adults now. We have become the voices our parents wished that they had when they were too afraid to speak. Today, we sit in this room. Today, we sit in rooms we never imagined entering. We stand before leaders. We deeply respect. We advocate not only for our own families, but for the thousands of others. Chicago can once again become the city we know it can be, a city that protects families, values, honest work, and works, and welcomes those who contribute so much to its neighborhood. The work has been overwhelming. Every community leader standing beside us today understands that feeling. But the workload does not stop us. Every day, we continue reaching vendors where they are. We share resources, communicate urgent information, and do everything we can to keep communities informed and safe. We will continue fighting because this is our future. Street vendors are not asking for special treatment. We're asking for fairness. We're asking for dignity. We're asking for the opportunity to work honestly, provide for our families, and continue sharing the food, culture, traditions, and love that make Chicago stronger. We are a community asking for help. We will never stop showing up for our vendors, our family, and our city. Thank you. Thank you very much, Maria. My first question for you is, first, thank you so much for sharing all of your story. What recommendations would you have for the city to support increasing the diversity of small businesses in Chicago versus criminalizing them in the manner you described? I think talking to them, talking to us in the organization, if you guys have any questions. Like I mentioned, a lot of people have misconceptions of street vendors, and we are street vendors. We are small businesses. We pay taxes, maybe not as much as restaurant owners, but we do our share just like anyone else. And I hope people are able to understand that and just make us a part of the income of Chicago. Have there been any formal communications between the Street Vendor Association and the Chicago Police Department in relation to any? I know there's been conversations with BACP and the mayor's office. Has there been one with CPD related to kind of all of this protocol? Not at the moment, no. Okay. I'm sorry. I didn't get your name, officer. Good afternoon. Seamus Mannion, the commander of the 1st District of Chicago Police. Thank you, Commander. So I guess this was questions for you and CPD in general, and it's kind of just to establish based on... what the protocol is, right? You got street vendors out here. What are the things that you are most called to respond to? How does it typically play out when you're following up on a call? Great. Thank you for the opportunity. What makes, pardon me, what makes the first district unique is in the downtown area, in the central business district, whether you have a peddler's license or you don't, that is a restricted area. That's a prohibited area. And that's where a lot of our calls come from. The fact that it's easy to notice that there's someone selling something because regardless of who they are or what they're selling, it's prohibited. So we get phone calls from 911, from community meetings, the district council meetings, the community policing meetings, as well as outdoor roll calls, hand waivers, and a lot of calls for service from 911. So thank you for that. I have a bunch of questions related to this, even the first comment. So what is that clearly defined as far as the area you're referring to when you say central business district, what streets to what streets? We could provide through the chair the exact municipal code that lists it because there's other ones that are outside of the first district that I can't speak to. Okay. Yeah. So I think one, I would say if there is a central business district that is specifically defined, it should be something the public should know just generally. And I think even me asking, I think most Chicagoans would say, well, I know where downtown is, but I don't necessarily know what district you mean specifically. You mentioned that whether somebody has a license or not, they're prohibited completely from being in the area? In the central business district, in the first district, essentially the main area is by Wacker, as well as Michigan Avenue. That area is prohibited by municipal code for any types of vending, whether you have obviously a license or not. Okay. Yeah. The reason why I'm curious is in front of the bean, right? Like I see vendors there all the time by Art Institute. Is there, are they prohibited from being there? Correct. Correct. So like anybody selling t-shirts, anything at all? Yes, sir. I mean, they exist, they're there. So I'm trying to figure out if it's enforced to the level. Okay. First off, let me backtrack. Why are they all prohibited from being there? It's via municipal code. So just generally anybody selling anything, whether you have a license or not, you just, to your point, municipal code says you can't. Correct. All right. Well, we got some updates, folks. All right. I know as a Chicagoan, I go there regularly. I mean, we're City Hall, so we're passing downtown all the time. There's never been a moment I don't see somebody selling something. So the two things, one of two things should be true. Either it shouldn't be prohibited because people are out there actually doing it, or y'all would be arresting everybody trying to sell a t-shirt on Michigan Avenue. I don't, I haven't seen that occur. So how do you all determine where you're responding to? Or is it just, you're not getting calls about people with t-shirts, but if somebody's trying to sell fruits out here, it's suddenly a call? The main area that I receive phone calls for and 911 calls are along Michigan Avenue, as well as Museum Campus during events at Soldier Field in Norley Island. Those are the two main areas between Wacker Drive and Michigan Avenue, as well as Soldier Field Museum Campus. Those are the areas that I receive the most calls. Are you able to, as far as the tracking and reporting, not only know how many times you've gotten calls and reports or incidents, but be able to delineate whether somebody's selling t-shirts, bulls apparel, whatever, cubs, I mean, more bulls and cubs. But if you're selling anything like that on Michigan Avenue compared to fruits, you know, food, do you delineate? Are you able to classify that? Or is there categories to track any of that? But when we do the paperwork on it, it's just vending. In the narrative, it could get specific, but as far as tracking, it's not separate based on what they're selling. Could that be possible going forward? I would defer to Captain Kapistanek. Mike Kapistanek, Chicago Police Department. We would have to look at the Uniform Crime Reporting System. We are now bound by state guidelines and a national incident-based reporting system, which identifies specific reporting categories. We would have to look into that to see if that's possible. Is that similar to, like, the last item about, like, how we track all those kinds of reports and systems they already have in place? No, because this is a little bit different. This is about actually classifying criminal activity, breaking it down even further. The other concept that we were talking about was about identifying the federal involvement in that incident. So this is, this, we're bound by more rules with the state and federal reporting on crime statistics. You would have to look at that. Yeah, if you could do the chair, share any of that information related to state, federal, all these other laws in place. And the reason why I'm asking that to kind of get to it is what is unfortunate a reality here in the United States. Not everyone has the same laws applied. We know when we talk about cannabis prior to its legalization, everybody's smoking it, but only certain people get called and arrested for it. So if you've got multiple people out here selling different kinds of items, and the only ones that are getting calls happen to be black and brown folk who want to be selling fruits, vegetables, and food, I'm going to have a problem with that because that's not equal application of the law. And honestly, I don't think the law should be in place, period, first. But if you're going to then be called to enforce things, and they are not enforced equally, I'm going to have a problem with that. I think most Chicagoans would. And you guys get called about everything. This is something we bring up in council constantly since I've been in council, that y'all are overstretched. You're overworked. There's things that you could be working on that are more related to violent crime as opposed to somebody trying to sell a mango to someone. And so I have a lot of concern, not only in like the justice lens of the law in place, but also the misallocation of resource when we're concerned about violent crime, right? Those kind of things. So I, you look, you ready? You got something? Council? Good afternoon, Sheriff Scott's Fair is CPD Legal Affairs. I'm unfortunately about four questions behind you right now. But the prohibited districts for peddlers are set out in the municipal code at chapter 4-244-140. That identified, I'm sorry, go ahead, sir. Do you know when it was established? Before or after the Chicago fire, maybe? I'm curious. I'm going to say it was established after the Chicago fire. The description of the Central Business District is fairly extensive. It is in sub-B, sub-4. Sure. And I can start reading it and we'll probably be here at 1.30. Fair, fair. But it sets the boundaries for that. It also identifies other areas in the city where peddling is absolutely prohibited. And let me ask, as far as implementation of that, is that something that is led by aldermanic prerogative? It's an ordinance that was passed by the city council. Meaning the areas that are determined, is that because an alder person said, I don't want it here, as opposed to there being a blanket law saying these areas of the city of Chicago shouldn't? You know, I don't have that background. We could, you know, potentially ask the law department if they have that legislative history on where each of these prohibitions came from. I mean, there are prohibitions around Wrigley Field and areas like that. So whether that came from alderman or however it was introduced to the council, I think it would be a case-by-case evaluation. Yeah, and I guess for the mayor's office, do we have DOL here? No, Ray. Ray, how's it going, Ray? I'm going to guess the answer is through the chair because I probably got to do a lot of homework to get all that. Sorry, let me get in the mic. Yeah. Good afternoon, Ray Phillips-Santos on behalf of the city of Chicago's Department of Law. Mr. Spears is correct on the section that he quoted. The, as you know, you know, this is the municipal code. This particular section has been changed. The paragraph in small font is, you know, a couple, two or three inches long every single time that it's been changed. Whether that's because an alderman, one or more aldermen pushed for every section because, as Mr. Spears said, it's, you know, Wrigley Field, the Central District, and a myriad of other places throughout the city of Chicago. As you know, oftentimes aldermen say, yeah, in my neighborhood, I don't want it here. To be able to find out exactly, you know, these go back to 1992. Okay. So to be able to, you know, we don't have recordings of what the conversations were back in 1992. Gotcha. So how you would want to, you know, can we do some legal research, legislative research to find out when a particular section was put in place? Absolutely. It may not necessarily be material we're looking to do. I gotcha. Exactly. Yeah. Even the 1992 thing makes sense because the. I'm sorry, I'm going to sound real Chicago on this thing. We got the six rings after that. There were a bunch of T-shirts being sold everywhere in the city of Chicago, definitely downtown. I bet there weren't that many arrests related to it, I guess is my point. But thank you for that, Ray. I have questions to follow, but I'd like to pass it to my colleague, Alderman Casada. Thank you, Chairman. You know, like every major nation, every kind of nation, every major city around the world has vendors, street vendors. And it's no surprise that a lot of the street vendors that we're talking about today are of Latin American descent. They are our immigrant brothers, sisters and siblings who have carried on this industry, this line of work from their native countries to here. And they bring amazing food, and that's part of our culture, and it's part of the tapestry of our city. And we really need to find out what is the best pathway towards regulating it and making sure that folks who make a living off of this industry can do so in peace and with tranquility. I think that it's also incredibly courageous and unfortunate that people who are vendors, who are making their living, and many of whom are undocumented, still have to do the work. They have no choice. This is their job. And so protecting them is important now more than ever. So I want to just ask very pointedly to the representative from the Street Vendor Association. Can you remind me of your name again? Maria. Maria. Hola, Maria. Could you explain to me what are some of the clear policy reforms that the city should be pursuing right now to help street vendors? We do have two licenses at the moment, a peddler's license and the prepared license. So one of them is just packaged goods, basically. Basically, you're not tampering the product, so you could just sell as is packaged. And then the other one is you need a shared kitchen. But when you come to BACP for the process of obtaining a license, when you go to a shared kitchen, it has an expiration date, which is two years. But if a vendor takes, I want to say, 30, 50 days to go, but you're still in the time limit of those two years, BACP sends you back. They make you get a new card, a new letter of intent from the kitchen that is dated no more than 30 days, I believe, if that's correct. And once everything in process is set through, it's sent to the health department. And then there's like a two to three week delay where they send it back to BACP. And there's just a lot of back and forth where vendors don't have that time to wait. And we do wish that we can look into these licenses to better them for the vendors. And also, they're getting fined for putting toppings on their food. So you don't want to go to an elotero and get a elote with a lid on and packaged mayonnaise and packaged cheese. That's not the experience that we're looking for. And us as vendors, we don't want to give that to our clientele as well. So we wish that we can do something about that and expand the narrative of what we could do and what we should be able to do with still any regulations that you guys put at us that we could follow as well. Got it. Are you familiar with the nature of these shared kitchens? Are they privately owned shared kitchens? Are they publicly owned shared kitchens? I'm not familiar with the shared kitchens situation. Do you have some information, too? I know there's some shared kitchens that are nonprofits, I believe, if I'm not mistaken. There was one that was made by street vendors. So it's a cooperative. And you can go get your intent card. And I think it's $1,000 to $2,000 to get that for two years. And there's different ones that are privately owned. Got it. It might be interesting to pursue a publicly owned one to help subsidize that. The nonprofit cooperative is great, but the city should also be looking at how we can help out. So I heard some of the areas in which you're trying to explore helping regulate that. I think, you know, the other part of the subject matter is addressing the violations, but then it's also detainments and deportations. You know, the deportation thing is clearly a lot more holistic, and there needs to be community care and protections in regard to that. In regards to CPD enforcement and violations, are there any strong recommendations policy-wise that you have that we should know about? Well, we are talking amongst each other in the organization, and we do want some clarity as to if CPD and BACP are working together when they're finding our vendors. Because, like I mentioned in my letter, some are being sent to the Superior Court, which is an administrative hearing, while others are being sent to a different court, which is for criminals. And vendors aren't criminalized. We're not criminals. We are just vending to support our family. So we want to see if there's any policies that we can help pass or support where our vendors are being educated in the proper way, where we can get educated, so we can educate the vendors and do outreach and Canvas and get the word out there for our vendors as well. Got it. And so can you walk me through a scenario of, like, when violations are issued to vendors, what kind of, you know, how does that interaction look like? What is the actual violation? And then after, you know, some form of fine or ticket has been issued or a warning, what happens after that? Can the vendor continue selling, or are they supposed to cease and desist, or do they move somewhere else? Can you help elaborate what that looks like? To my understanding, when an inspector is sent out to a specific vendor is because someone called and they made a report. Sorry, you're saying inspectors at BACP or CPD or what are we looking at? So when a inspector sent from BACP is at a specific vendor is because someone made a report and they said, sorry, we got this report, sorry, we got this report and you have to, you have to leave, you have to pack up and leave. And then they give you a fine. It could be from not having the proper licensing, selling in a prohibited area, or it could be also having coolers. They don't allow coolers. And then they'll give you a fine. I think it starts at $250 to $1,000. And then over the course of 10 years, my mom has accumulated a total of $10,000 in fines that she's paid for the same reason that there's no proper licensing for what we're trying to do and what we want to do. And then after that, from the street vendors, we go with the vendors to the administrative hearing because there's no, there is translation, but they feel safer with us as the organization. So I go with them hand in hand, translate the paperwork, make sure they understand what their, their, their fine is and why they're being ticketed. Sometimes they get ticketed for not having license, but some do have license. That's what happened when, um, CPD started ticketing them in the downtown area. It does work a little different because, um, I am DACA, so I try to avoid that court. So from the people that volunteer to take our vendors, they, um, said that they go in there with them. But unfortunately, some of the, um, not unfortunately, sorry, but the judges were a little confused as to why the street vendors were being sent over there and not to administrative hearing as well. So that's the confusion that we all seem to have. And that's where we would like to understand if there's any communication being brought up from BACP and see, um, the Chicago police department, where we need that clarification to understand how we could proceed. And, um, um, on, in the other courthouse in Florida, um, Florida, um, Florida, um, Florida street, they do drop the cases. They drop the charges, they drop, um, they don't find them or anything, but administrative hearing, they still find them 200 to a thousand dollars and they have up to 30 days to pay. Got it. Um, turning to CPD, um, right now, um, I kind of just lost my question. Um, give me a second. Point of clarification. Absolutely. Uh, thank you, Maria, for, uh, cause that's actually one of my questions. So, uh, for CPD, there's different kinds of ticketing apparently that can occur. One that sends folks to administrative hearing, one that sends them to court. What's the difference in what's the protocol? When's that decided? How do you guys make the discretion? Seamus Mannion, first district. There's two different mechanisms that we can use for the enforcement. One is the citation is Maria reference. Uh, for us, it's called an ANOV administrative notice ordinance violation, or it could be the custodial arrest. ANOV, you have to have identification. We have to prove identity to document everything. And it would go to the hearing officer. Many times we try to start with that regard. So, and I'm sorry, I will get back to you, Anthony, my apologies. But so is, is the reason the decision is made is whether somebody has ID or not? That's one of them. And we'll, because again, in the central business district by say either Michigan Avenue or Wacker, because it's prohibited. And I think the reason, it's potentially targeted all... will the actions take place again so we're not keep going back and forth but many times we start with that a nov we just want to follow up with this one sorry and my please so one is hey you don't have an id so rather than an a nov we're going to issue one where now you got to go to court right that's one and is the other one that you're saying is hey we just want to see you here again so we're gonna send you to court we will not be able to continuously write a novs if the individual does not leave is there a limit to a novs you're saying you can't continually do it so i'm wondering if there's a limit you mean sir just if there's x amount after that we must do why is that what you yeah like for example there's not a limit to how many tickets i could get i just keep getting tickets nobody's taking me to court i if i can say something um personally from like i said my mom when she gets tickets over the course of 10 years that we received we've never been to a different um court but the administrative hearing and 99 of our vendors have not been to a different courthouse but that one until maybe a month two months ago when they started um arresting up to 20 vendors and one day in the downtown area got it okay i'm gonna come back to that because i feel like i'm interjecting a lot into my colleague so uh thank you very much yes uh do you have a response no mike capistana from cpd's research and development i just want to provide clarity there's in our policy there are certain criteria that members of the public have to meet in order to be eligible for that administrative notice of ordinance violation one is age they have to be 18 years of age second one is the id card they have to be able to prove the identity so that the ticket we're uh we are um confirming that the person is getting violated one of them is that there's a reasonable likelihood that the offense is going to continue i mean part of the enforcement action is to um end the activity that we were called there to do so there's a number of in our policy um exceptions to the anov citation so that it um our policy would then if any of those exceptions apply the member wouldn't be able our officer wouldn't be able to use the anov citation as the mechanism for enforcement to the chair if you could uh send us that policy to look at absolutely yes all right sorry uh alderman thank you chairman um who uh for cpd uh who mainly calls in complaints around vendors is it alder people is it residents is it businesses we can get you that through the chair for the entire city or for specifically downtown what is generally speaking yeah we can get you that through the chair all the calls for service got it um has cpd policy change in regard to enforce enforcement of violations to vendors in regard to um increased ice activity interactions between law enforcement and vendors has there been any sort of revisions to uh the policy and or interactions with street vendors yeah mike epistanic cpd no there haven't been any changes to the written policies on um enforcing either vendors or other municipal codes through the um administrative notice of ordinance violation policy got it are cpd officers equipped with know your rights materials at all do you all have do officers go out with know your rights materials and the reason why i'm asking is in in a situation where we're in when you have interactions with um street vendors many of whom could be undocumented i understand that you know you all are enforcing the municipal code but there might be an opportunity for you all to still provide people with information in the event that they do have interactions with ice so is that something that has happened and if not that's something to consider i think that would be good public policy yeah that's i don't think anyone here for is not from community policing we don't know if that information's available but we can we can find out and get that through the chair got it i would recommend that i mean i think that's a good thing if you are knowingly interacting with people who could be vulnerable populations it'd be good to provide them with information they need to be safe yes commander well again shameless manning one thing we have done numerous times because of the uniqueness of the central business districts as i keep stressing is we send officers up and down michigan on wacker at soldier field even even more when there's large events at grant park to educate them that it's you know basically it doesn't matter who what where why it's this location is why you you can't be here we bring and we try to i bring officers that speak the language of the individual selling to try to truly understand it that even if they get that license at this specific location it's not valid it's valid other everywhere but we we bring officers speaking english and other languages to really try to educate them that it's this specific location that's the issue at this point right is there written educational material that is provided to people the acp does have a flyer that we do hand out got it and we have handed them i apologize we've handed out flyers as well just trying to educate them that this location got it well i think it would be important to maybe talk to bacp somebody we should follow up with this chair that that written material should have legal resources for immigration services so in the event that someone is detained because a lot of times people are outselling with their family members so maybe one person's detained but not another person that person knows what to do in that incident to report any activity but then also be connected to legal resources we should be engaging in harm reduction in all of our services right now especially for our most vulnerable communities thank you chairman thank you alderman uh next up alderman fico lopez thank you uh thank you chairman and just following on the line of questioning of alderman quesada it seems like the issue is enforcement here and um with this delicate issue putting a lot of street vendors as i said it was very disheartening to me because you know we have a lot of our neighbors who depend on this that being attacked by the federal government being incarcerated continue to be incarcerated um so to me it's a matter of enforcement we're working with bacp to update a law that is being almost 11 years old so uh and with the sensitivity and everything that you described my question maybe for the maybe for the deputy mayor of immigration uh and refugee rights um in terms of like uh enforcement you know just maybe a little bit more clarity on um you know what we can do in the city council to help out i understand that your office because i know that we meet often we also have talked with the street vendors association but yet we see continue to see issues coming up like this right so what can we do i know that ordinance is still pending my concern is of course nice budget season it may take some time and this summer is usually when people come out when there's more events and we don't want anyone to be in this situation i tell you that people work so hard i got one of my neighbors three kids depend on that i see these these uh neighbor coming every night at 11 p.m i can hear the wheels of his car coming back home and i want to make sure that he comes back home safe i don't want to see another victim these are our neighbors right one of them was taken on damon and 21st you know and i tell you i did not i i lost my sleep over that until she was released so please you know what can we do together i mean maybe from the mayor's perspective and then maybe the cpd in terms of enforcement you know maybe there's an administrative order or something that can do and you know welcome also the comments from the street vendors thank you alderman and i i want to start by thanking the street vendor organization to be here and and really make very clear the harmful impact that that you're seeing because we are a city that takes pride in being a welcoming city where immigrants and refugees have opportunity and we have to look at ways to do that across the enterprise right at all of our departments and in in our policies as well as our practices um i will say that i and i also want to make clear that um the increased enforcement that has been seen recently is not coming from the mayor's office that is nothing that the mayor has asked for there's nothing that anyone on our team has called for um because i've been asked that before and it it is not um a directive that came from us we want to find the solutions thank you for the question and we have been working with the street vendors association in collaboration learning from them directly with our office of um bacp business as well as the bend office of economic and neighborhood development and um and several of you to look at the possibility of updating or creating a new ordinance we have very outdated street vendor laws in chicago and if you just look at new york or los angeles houston there are more options there for street vendors than we have in our city um it is time to revamp those you know the the looking at the no peddling zones could be a possibility but creating a new class of vending is a great opportunity and our that work came out of um the the work that the city is doing around food equity because creating a new opportunity for street vendors is for the benefit of street vendors but also for the benefit of our communities there are neighborhoods in chicago that don't have access to fresh you food. They don't have, you know, brick and mortar restaurants and great creating a new way for people to be able to bring food to different communities is also about expanding food equity. So I would say in terms of possible policy changes and ways that we can partner, we will need the support of city council to create a new ordinance, to update existing laws, to make them more fair for the street vendors, but also to bring greater access to other communities across Chicago. And I want to say one more thing, that this is not only an immigrant matter, right? Other people are selling things, as Chairman Vasquez noted. There are other communities where people are trying to feed their families and finding ways to make a living. And we could create our laws that are a little bit more friendly and make that easily accessible for folks. Thank you. I'm sure I need to talk about CPD and the street vendors. Yes. And I can give you, Marie, I can give you my point of contact. I don't have a business card on me today, but I'll give you my information. And we can definitely sit down and see if we can reach out to the commissioner of BACP and see if he's able as well to make sure everybody's on the same page. In Chicago, there is about 6,000 registered street vendors and our organization. We have three staffs. We have three people on staff. It's me, Juan, which is our president and Ochoa. We work very hard, but we have a group of volunteers. We have attorneys that help us, guide us, and lead us, and have led us to this moment. And I think it's very helpful as well if inspectors from BACP share resources to vendors that we can't reach. There's a lot of vendors. Last year, September 2025, we did a GoFundMe and raised $700,000 forestry vendors to give them a $500 relief fund for the same reason that they weren't going out to vend because of everything that was going on. So I think we finally opened the applications again, and a thousand other vendors reapplied that we had no idea about. Just that's the amount of magnitude of vendors that there is in the city that we can't reach. But with the help of everyone, we can inform them, educate them, and get them closer to us so we can help them with the process and obtaining the proper licensing and maybe keep working together so we can create a better ordinance or update the ones we have right now. So thank you. Thank you, Chairman. Yeah, I'm not going to be able to say to the next other part, but again, just my commitment to work with the vendors, the Streets Vendors Association. I want to thank you for all your efforts. I know that you put a lot of work, and I'm grateful to see the partnership to protect more of our neighbors. I mean, these are hardworking people experiencing a lot of fear. I think there's a lot of courage in this and coming out and trying to provide for the families. So our commitment to try to pass this would be ACP. But in the meantime, I appreciate the mayor's perspective and efforts as well as CPD to prevent any family separation, any harm. I mean, it's heartbreaking what's happening in our country, and I do appreciate that we're living in a city where we respect each other's human rights and constitutional rights. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much. Alderperson Gutierrez has requested a virtual option for committee hearing attendance in accordance with Rule 59 of the City Council Rules of Order. Can I get a motion to allow her to attend this hearing virtually? So moved. So moved by Alderman Quesada. Hearing no objections. So ordered. I'd like to follow back up. I appreciate – I'll just ask the question. Sorry. Okay. In the incident on May 5th, I want to go specific to that. What initiated the enforcement that day in the business district? I'm just seeking clarification on May 5th. Yeah. That was the sweep or the incident that then led to somebody going to court and being then taken to a detention center. So what initiated that level of enforcement then? I, at this time, do not have any documentation on May 5th, but you're saying that's the one that led to – Yes. I can cut to the chase. If somebody called you guys to go down there and force it, who did that? Was it the Alderperson of the ward? For that specific date, I would have to look back. I wouldn't know at this time who called on May 5th. We get calls every day, but we could get it through the chair. Sure. And I guess my question, because there were more of the ANOVs prior to a month ago, right, per Mr. Roscoe's testifying that it was about a month ago it started becoming more of these arrests and actually going to court as opposed to 99% of them, according to what was testified, being ANOVs. What changed a month ago? The one thing is a call for service, the sheer volume, and the proliferation of the vending along Michigan Avenue, which then in turn calls for service increase even more. Through the chair, would you be able to share what calls for service you were getting in comparison to what calls you might have been getting from the ward office? Is there a way to discern that? We could get through the chair that's called for service. Yeah. I just want to get a handle on what that ultimately led. If it was a... When I first got elected, I was able to learn a lot from a sergeant in the police department, which made me appreciate the fact that some people sometimes attribute a lot of bias to the police department, when in reality, they're getting calls from people that have their own biases and are informing someone who doesn't even know what they're walking into as a public servant. And so trying to get an understanding on where those calls initiated, right? Who's making those calls? Because if you're just following orders and doing your job and someone's telling you, you need to go out there because of this situation and they're making it appear that somebody just trying to earn a buck is being more of a criminal. Again, you're doing your job following up on the enforcement. I got questions related to some of the decision making, but you're doing what you're being called to do. So I'm more curious as to who called y'all to do it. And so I think that's the nature of it. So if through the chair, you could provide what calls you were getting, whether it's from neighbors or from city in and of itself. Like I absolutely take the mayor's office at their word. They're not the ones pushing this forward to make sure this kind of enforcement. I want to know who else in city government might be. Thank you. So, and I apologize if I asked this before. It's already been a long session. Did I ask the amount or tracking related to the ANOVs compared to other ones? You know, the ones that send people to court. Can we get tracking on that? Is that, I may have asked it before. I apologize if I did, but yeah. Mike Epistanic, CPD. Yeah, we can provide ANOV data through the chair as well. If there's, specific data you're looking for. Yeah, I'm looking for just the amounts of like what's being called in or how many, how many times that determination is being made in the business district related to this kind of activity, right? I, I think I'm almost thinking through the municipal code, changing some of the criteria related to what makes you say you can't use an ANOV in order to make it easier for officers to just do that issue ticket, keep it moving for something that's actually a danger, right? As opposed to the protocol itself telling officers to go, well, you can't do an ANOV here. Here's what you need to do. Even that small adjustment, I think changes the impact of really what we're seeing happen to the lives of people just trying to sell stuff and earn a dollar who are being told by the federal government, there's no other, you should get, do it legally and they're doing their best as possible to survive out here. So if it's just a change that we need to make that's that small, that's what I'm willing to explore. And so I just trying to get a sense of that would be helpful. Okay. Just, just to clarify. So ANOV citation data in a central business district for vending violations. Yes. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you for clarifying that for me. I really, I do appreciate it. I, my colleague left, but I had a, I appreciate my colleague, we have a little bit of a difference of opinion. So in talking about the street vendor ordinance, he stated that the reason it's not moving is because of budget season. I don't know that that's a criteria or reason not to move legislation forward. And if it was, we wouldn't have a protecting runners ordinance. So clearly, if we're willing to make changes that are independent of a budget process, this should be one of them. So I just want to make sure that we're engaging in conversations that lead to better solutions. And so I appreciate that y'all are willing to meet with Maria. I want to make sure that we're there along with BACP and the mayor's office to get the changes done because y'all got so much more important work to do. We are celebrating the fact that we have a lower crime rate than we have in 60 years. And we all know it ain't low enough. And so we want to make sure that you're not getting spread thin, doing things that might be BACP inspectors just issuing tickets, rather than you all and our officers who are risking their lives every day, going out here issuing a type of ticket that can then get somebody deported. I don't think that anybody in CPD that I've talked to would take any level of price. in that activity. And that's not what y'all do. And so I think making sure that the city more clearly identifies what should and shouldn't be your job related to this, I think is in the interest of everybody involved. Because every officer I talk to is overworked, is burned out. And with all the events happening in the city, especially during the summer, even more so. So that really is my interest. I want to thank you all for the information and your participation. I want to thank the Street Vendors Association for your work, for your patience, for your courage. And I want to make sure that you partner to get something moving, whether it's adjustments to just figuring out getting more ANOVs as opposed to these larger tickets, but more largely just rehauling all this system. We have so much that's a resource and a commodity in this city that other cities don't. I've been to towns where you can't get food. You're screwed. We have so much that y'all I'll bring to the table that I want to make sure we do that. I also want to work on having proactive zones where you can and should sell. Because we already have so many telling you where not to go. We should have some that are welcoming in that manner. I know we got Ainsley Arts Plaza in the 40th Ward and other areas where we're more than happy. We'd celebrate it. And as we've seen, because of ICE, places like Little Village have lost some of their luster because we want to see the vendors out there. So yeah, again, thank you for all the context and understanding. I look forward to partnering with all of you all so we can do something that moves us forward to gather the city. Thank you very much. We're then going to go to the next item if that's okay. Thank you. Just one more. This will be quick. We don't like the perky meter deal, right? No. All right. So then we can get the ball rolling and no one's rushing y'all out. So I'm going to go real slow when I talk about third item. Thank you all for your service. All right. So the third item is related to everybody's favorite deal in the city of Chicago, the parking meter deal. It's subject matter hearing on Omni Air International, who runs the Trump administration's ICE deportation flights. As a reminder, they are owned and operated by Stone Peak Partners, who are interested in purchasing Chicago's parking meters. With us today to speak on this item is Gillian Brockle, a journalist and author of ICE deportation flights are getting longer and crueler, featured in Mother Jones. Gillian, are you able to present? Can you hear us? Yes, I'm here. I wasn't able to turn my camera on earlier. Let me see if I can now. It says, unable to start video. Tech support. Disabled by the host. Yeah. Huh? Like you're good on your end, you're saying? I'm sorry? I can see it. Yeah. But it's very low as far as the volume. Are you able to raise volume on your end, Gillian? I can turn up the volume. Sure, yeah. Is that better? Is that any better? Testing, testing? Yes. Yes. Okay, great. Absolutely. So, yeah, if you're able to present, you can take it away. Thank you so much. Sure. I still don't have my video on. I guess that doesn't matter. All right. Thank you so much to the committee for allowing me to speak today. My name is Gillian Brockle. I wrote the recent Mother Jones investigation. Can you hear me? My apologies, Gillian. I'm sorry. We're getting a presentation loaded up for you, is my understanding. No. No. I'm just speaking. Yeah. Okay. Gotcha. No worries. Thank you. Yeah. Great. I wrote the recent Mother Jones investigation titled Ice Flights Are Getting Longer and Crueler, which is all about OmniAir International since its purchase by Stone Peak. Before my ice flight reporting, I was a staff reporter at the Washington Post where I worked for a decade and I hold a master's degree in business journalism from Medill, just from up the road from y'all. Before journalism, I was a flight attendant. So I'm uniquely qualified to speak on this topic. My top line today is that if the only way for the council to reject this deal with legal cover is due to the poor reputation of the potential buyer, I believe the information that I have about Stone Peak and Omni more than meets that criteria. In my Mother Jones story, I reported that since Stone Peak bought Omni in mid-April 2025, the number of ice flights they've done have nearly quadrupled. At the June 25th Finance Committee hearing, Stone Peak's Representative James Wiper told the committee he, quote, did not believe that to be accurate. My evidence is based on public flight data for all of Omni's aircraft between mid-April 2025 when Stone Peak took over and December 31st, 2025, and the same period in 2024 for comparison. I only included flights that exhibited all of the known criteria for ice flights, which I can tell you more about later if you care. Many of these flights have been confirmed by other major media outlets, not just me, and I cross-checked my data with Human Rights First and Witness at the Border, which puts out monthly reports about all ice flights. In fact, my data is pretty conservative. There may very well have been more Omni ice flights that I didn't include because they didn't meet all of the known criteria, and I also didn't include any stops that may have been fuel stops, even though they were that were fuel stops, even though they may have been deportation stops as well. Now let's look at Mr. Wiper's evidence for his claim to the council that he did not believe this to be accurate. As far as I know, he hasn't provided any. Next in the story, I report that under Stone Peak, the flights were getting longer and because of that crueler, and that during one Omni ice trip, passengers were shackled for at least 82 hours. Mr. Wiper said he, quote, couldn't speak to the claim of increased cruelty, and that Stone Peak had investigated the 82-hour claim, and quote, found no evidence of that. So again, my claim these flights were getting longer under Stone Peak is based on public flight data, counting the number of hours between takeoff from an ice deportation hub to arrival at its final deportation stop for the same periods in 2025 and 2024, and seeing how many lasted longer than 24 hours. You'll see the chart that Mother Jones included based on that data in your packets. The claim in the packets that I hope you were provided, the claim the length of these flights has increased their cruelty came from speaking with Judy Melanick, a medical doctor and forensic pathologist who is an expert on shackling. Nearly all adult passengers and some children on ice flights are shackled in leg irons and handcuffs attached to a chain around their waist for the duration of the trip. This has been widely reported. There are thousands of photos of this, and Ice Air Operations says it in their own handbook. Melanick told me prolonged shackling can cause excruciating pain, permanent nerve damage, cuts and bruising, mental injury, and a dramatically increased risk of developing blood clots, which can become deadly days or weeks after people have been deported. She called it torture, and she compared it to the boxcars the Nazis put Jews in to take them to the concentration camps. Mr. Wiper may not be able to speak to that, but Dr. Melanick sure could. So could Melissa Tran, a 45-year-old mother of four who was shackled for two days on an Omni plane while being deported to Vietnam. She told me I was aching all over. I felt like I was less than an animal. Omni is the only large jet charter willing to do deportations of this length. It has been this way for a long time, and they are getting worse. Now, where did I get 82 hours? This was based on flight data counting the hours that passed between when an Omni ice flight trip began in El Paso on the evening of December 14th and when it finally finished in the Vietnam four days later. I confirmed the passengers were shackled the whole time with an immigration attorney for some of the Vietnamese passengers. They were too afraid to speak to me, but their attorney showed me text messages where they described their inhumane treatment. And after the Mother Jones story published, I spoke with a former Omni flight attendant who was on that trip who also confirmed it. Now let's look at the basis for Mr. Wiper's claim that Stone Peak investigated and found no evidence of this. As far as I know, he has not provided the counsel with any basis for his claim. My Mother Jones story also mentioned in Omni ice trip lasting 75 hours, which was confirmed by flight data and a passenger on the trip who said at least 20 elderly passengers were so weakened from being shackled for days on end that they had to be carried off the plane when they arrived at their countries of origin. In 2026, I've recorded 21 more Omni ice trips that lasted longer than 24 hours, including trips lasting 48 hours, 51 hours, 59 hours, and 68 hours. Those are minimum times that the passengers were shackled. Several passengers and now three former Omni flight attendants have told me that Omni's flights take about four hours to board and that passengers are shackled that whole time too. Now, I would like to direct your attention to this statement from Stone Peak to the council quoted in Crane's Business Chicago saying, quote, Omni personnel do not interact with passengers as ICE agents handle all passenger interactions. This statement is simply not true. While it is true that on all ICE flights, flight attendants have little interaction with the passengers, the bulk of it is done not by ICE agents, but by ICE contracted prison guards. This has been widely reported by outlets like ProPublica, not just me. On Omni's ICE flights, this is generally 30 to 40 guards from the GEO group, which also runs two dozen ICE detention centers. All of the passengers and crew on Omni ICE flights that I spoke with told me that, like the private prisons where ICE detainees are held, the lights are kept on and the planes are kept freezing cold the entire length of the trip. They also said that while some of the guards are, quote, nice, others clearly enjoy controlling and dehumanizing the migrant passengers. They all reported hearing guards threaten the passengers for supposed infractions, like asking to stand up and stretch because they were in immense pain or asking to speak to their attorney. And some reported guards using racial slurs and not allowing passengers to use the restroom to the point that they soiled themselves. All of the flight attendants I talked to said that this was a regular occurrence. The flight attendants who had done ICE flights to Africa reported guards wrapping some passengers in a full body straitjacket known as the wrap device for supposed infractions, like asking for their heart medication. They also said that the guards and federal agents constantly told them not to feel bad for the passengers because they were all rapists and murderers. They also said that the guards frequently refused to comply with flight attendants' safety instructions, including screaming at and threatening the flight attendants, and that when they would report this to their supervisors, their supervisors would say, just make the client happy, we need the money. To be clear, I don't know why Stone Peak failed to mention the presence of dozens of prison guards on all of their ICE flights, but it is notable to me that they failed to mention it. He also said he'd been assured none of their, Wiper also said he'd been assured none of, quote, their people had done, quote, the behaviors. But they are happening on their planes, and their employees are being subjected to the moral injury of witnessing it and not being able to do anything about it. All three former Omni flight attendants told me that when they've asked their supervisors how they are supposed to evacuate 200 shackled people within 90 seconds, which is what all flight attendants are federally mandated to know how to do, no one will answer them. They have received no training on this, which is a violation of federal aviation regulations under Part 121. And when they get an answer, the answer is just save yourselves, let the immigrants die. Now let's talk about third country deportations, where immigrants are being sent to countries where they have no ties, and in many cases have never even been to the countries where they are being dumped. These removals may violate both U.S. and international law and are being challenged in courts both here and abroad. Omni has been a significant accomplice in carrying these out. They've done at least 30 confirmed third country deportation missions of hundreds, perhaps thousands of people, as recently as June 16th, when they took 12 non-Sierra Leoneans to Sierra Leone and eight non-Aquatogunaians to Equatorial Guinea, which is one of the most corrupt countries on the planet, where both citizens and non-citizens have in the past have been subjected to torture and disappeared. I also included in the packets that I hope you got stories about two women, Adriana Zapata and Rabiatu Kuyate. Ms. Zapata came to the U.S. as a legal asylum seeker from Colombia, where she'd been sexually tortured by the national police. On April 16th, she was put on an Omni plane with two dozen other South Americans and flown to the Democratic Republic of Congo. Adriana and the others were sent to a cockroach-infested motel by the airport and told they had to go back to their countries of origin, even though all of them had won protections in U.S. court from deportation due to harms they faced in those countries. Ms. Zapata has diabetes and other complex medical conditions that require care. Within a day or two, the Congolese government told the U.S. they didn't have the ability to care for her. Trump's State Department ignored them. Then a federal judge ordered Ms. Zapata be returned to the U.S. Trump's DOJ said, sorry, we can't take her back. There's an Ebola outbreak there, so it's not safe. She's still there along with others. Her lawyer told the Guardian she's not doing well and she worries she's going to die. Ms. Kuyate is a nurse and a grandmother, and she lived in Maryland for more than 30 years. She'd won legal protections in federal court barring deportation to her native Sierra Leone because she'd been a victim of torture. No criminal record, but ICE didn't care. They snatched her up and put her on an omniplane to Ghana, a country she'd never been to, last November. She told Reuters on the flight that the guards put a man in the wrap and put him upside down on the floor for 16 hours. Then they threatened her and everyone else on the plane that if they didn't behave, they were going to get the wrap too. I talked to a flight attendant on that flight. They said the man was screaming, I'm already a dead man. I'm already a dead man, over and over. In Ghana, Rabiatu was imprisoned in a hotel for a few days and then beaten and forced into a van and taken back to Sierra Leone. Pardon me. She fled to a neighboring country and has been in hiding for the last eight months. Her son, her grandkids and her parents, all American citizens, now live in the house Rabiatu owns but can't go home to. Omni Understone Peak has also done at least four deportations to Mauritania, sending asylum seekers back into the racialized chattel slavery that still exists there that they were escaping. Here are some incidents I have heard about but have not been able to prove. I have asked Omni and Stone Peak about them. They have a tendency to not reply to me. One Omni flight attendant that told told me that on an ICE flight to Colombia on September 24th, an immigrant may have killed himself using medication given to him by the guards. ICE gives people a week's worth of their meds as they get off the plane when they're being deported but the guards on this flight handed out the meds while the plane was descending into Bogota and as soon as no one was looking, he took all of them. This flight attendant told me a flight medic started to panic, telling the ICE agents we have to get him off the plane and into an ambulance as soon as possible or he's going to die. But the ICE guys and the guards, they didn't seem that concerned, they slow walked it, they kept doing their paperwork. And later on the next flight to Brazil, the flight medic was just sitting there in shock saying there's no way that guy lived. Let me be clear, I do not know if this is true. I have not been able to prove it. Stone Peak and Omni and ICE have not responded to my request for comment. They probably know if it's true. All three of the Omni flight attendants I talked to had heard about another flight to Colombia where immigrant passengers refused to get off the plane, so they were tear gassed inside the Omni plane to get them to come out. Again, I don't know if this is true, but everyone at the company has heard it. And so apparently have members of this council, they asked about it in the finance committee on June 25th, and I want to be clear that they didn't hear that from me. They have heard that from somewhere else. That's how widespread this story is. And that's the point here. Omni's reputation was already bad. Under Stone Peak's ownership, it has gotten much, much worse. And the poor reputation is well deserved. Mr. Wiper told the council they want to sell Omni but provided no evidence of that. And frankly, even if they do, that won't get the stink off of them or the profits from that cruelty out of their coffers. So on one side, you have mountains of flight data, dozens of stories from major outlets, stories from former passengers and former employees who all say the same thing. On the other, you have a company who wants to profit off of your meters saying none of that is true and providing no evidence. Now, from what I hear, Chicago Parking Meters LLC hasn't been great to deal with under its current owners. I would like to suggest that a company that is willing to either lie or look the other way in the face of such cruelty is probably not going to do a much better job as the owners. Thank you for letting me speak today. I welcome your questions. Thank you very much, Gillian, for all the work in the reporting and in hearing the atrocities, atrocities, even your willingness to speak to it. I know how challenging it is. So I will try to keep my questions short, but I need your help on some of this. So some of the activity you're describing. I know, obviously, we're in a moment where things have occurred more recently, but when Stone Peak sought to buy or bought Omni, was that activity occurring? Yes, not as much, not as frequently, but it was. So there was, I think, probably the most famous Omni incident before this happened in 2017 in December. There was a deportation to Somalia. It got stuck for crew timing, legal reasons, in Senegal for more than 24 hours. The passengers there remained shackled, they went out of food, the labs became full, and the guards started beating them. So, eventually the plane had to turn around and fly back to Miami. So they were shackled for a total of about 48 hours. It was national news. I mean, you can check any news site, and they've got stories about it. Most of them don't say it was an Omni plane, but it was Omni Aircraft N-225AX. And there were subsequent court cases about this. Two of the passengers were beaten so badly that they required surgery. Most of them were able to win protections, but not all of them. There's a book written about it called Shackled by a law professor named Rebecca Sharpless. When I told her that people were being shackled for longer than 48 hours as a matter of course these days, and not because of some accidental circumstance, she was shocked. So Omni, you know, like I said, they've been doing this for a while. No, I appreciate that, and I wish you could work for the city with a level of specificity on all these. Thank you for that. The reason I ask that is when I spoke to Mr. Wiper at the Finance Committee hearing, he suddenly found a moment of change of heart, felt so horrible about it. And my main question was that, did you feel that horrible about it when you bought it? And so I just wanted to confirm that that kind of activity was happening prior and upon purchase. Yeah. Okay. I can't speak to how well of a job he did vetting ATSG, which is the parent company, and Omni's activities before they bought it, but that was well known. Yeah. I know. In that Finance Committee hearing, he asserted he's doing everything possible to sell it. Mm-hmm. As far as I know, he has provided no evidence. Yes. No, it was a promise, I guess. But the reason why that's important to me is him articulating how challenging it might be to sell when it didn't seem so challenging to buy it when the activity was still happening is important. And so the following questions I have are, I will admit, just to get conjecture from you more than anything. All right. Try my best. Yeah, and I appreciate that you kind of spoke to it first. What do you think a company that would buy a company like that, what kind of reputation would you say they have? How would that impact their reputation to purchase a company like Omni? A word that I can use in a public hearing? Yeah. Extremely bad. I mean, the thing that I would say is dog poop. I appreciate the G rating. Yes. So that is not a good reputation. And the reason I ask that is when we look at the ordinance and we're voting on a transition of a parking meter deal, there are different criteria we can look at related to how we make those decisions, reputation being one. So I'll ask this further. If the city of Chicago engaged in supporting the transition of a contract with a company that has a dog poop reputation based on the activity they're doing, what kind of reputation would that bring to the city of Chicago, would you say, is somebody observing? I mean, I know of some Chicagoans who have said, wow, I didn't think that the parking meter deal that Mayor Daley did could get any worse, but apparently it can. You know, referring to the sale to this horrible company that is profiting massively off of these ice flights. That sounds like something I say daily once I find out. And I just want to put out there, too, that there's also possible legal exposure. You know, if rule of law returns to this land, if we get to the stage of a Truth and Reconciliation Commission, a pilot in command of a vessel is always in charge and legally responsible and has final authority for what happens on their aircraft, no matter what kind of contract they have, including with the federal government. They always have final authority and legal responsibility. So I believe that the pilots, at the very least, and perhaps Omni and Stone Peak, could be held legally responsible along with the federal government for crimes that occurred on their aircraft. Thank you for the clarification. The last question I've got, how much money do you think it would take to clean up the reputation, forget about the activity, make up for it in a way that wouldn't clean up the reputation as tarnished as what we're describing right now? Is there a cost? Is there a dollar amount? I don't know the dollar amount. I mean, I would be more interested in actions. You know, the dollar amount would be at least, you know, treble damages of what they have made off of these flights, which is in the hundreds of millions. I would be more interested in reparations for the people who have been victimized on these aircraft with returned to the United States if they'll have us or safe passage to some other country where they will be safe. No, thank you for that. I appreciate that, and I think that is a very graceful answer because I think in legal terms, as far as reparations, that makes sense. What I think, do I as a Chicagoan who has the privilege and honor of serving as a member of city council, believe there's a price tag to being able to clean up a reputation like that if we were to move forward with a contract? Nope. Nope. I don't know the amount of money that would make it right. So I appreciate your responses on it, but I just want to make sure on the record as we talk about it, that's where my stance is. Autumn McSada? Thank you, Chairman. Thank you. Is it Jillian or Gillian? Gillian with a hard G. Excellent. Gillian, what was the name of that article that you wrote? Ice flights are getting longer and crueler. Excellent. I don't have any questions. I do want to thank you for the work that you did. I think that's very informative. I want to share. I don't know if that's been sent to our colleagues' email list. Yeah, we can send it through. We also had a webinar where we shared the information as well, but we're happy to make sure a member of the council has it. I think we should send it to all members of the council. I've also sent the spreadsheets with all of my data and some links to a couple other stories that other outlets have done. Excellent. I think that's all helpful context. The only comment that I want to make just for the public record is this is why we need to move away from these neoliberal policies of selling off our public assets to corporations that do anything that they want. The public land, public property should remain in the public domain. When we sell off our public land and our public property, we come across these contradictions in a for-profit economic model that is now helping facilitate and fast-track fascist policies. So anything that we can do to move public resources and assets back into the public domain is something that we should be doing. That's all I got, Chairman. Thank you. My apologies. Thank you very much. Now, having heard from all our speakers, one, I want to thank everyone involved. So much work was done here on all the agenda items, and I hope that we're all learning from them and have next steps. So with that, I will ask if any of our colleagues – I'll move to adjourn. Yeah, so moved. Second. All right. Thank you. So moved with no objections. So ordered. The Committee of Immigrant and Refugee Rights hearing is now adjourned. Thank you very much.