who does that? I say, well, why you didn't tell them, Raymond? I did. I say, I didn't hear that on the news. Just as loud. Fake news is a part of it, too. The citizen should know voodoo economics. Taking money from designated for voodoo economics. And you do it. You do it, Pat, guys, too. Voodoo economics. Whenever you start with that fund, it's something evil. It's something corruption going on here. But you've got the right one. Don't go to my three minutes. All right. All of a sudden, you're going to get them. Now I can talk. I've got three more minutes. Thank you, Mr. Blackmore. Thank you, Mr. Blackmore. Thank you, Mr. Blackmore. Ladies and gentlemen, that concludes the public comment portion of our meeting. The first order of business is approval of the July 2025 monthly report, which all members of the committee should have received via the shared drive. Are there any questions or comments from the committee members regarding the report? Seeing none, Alderman Lopez recommends approval of the 2025 monthly report by the same roll call that was applied to the term quorum. Hearing no objections, so ordered. At this time, I'd like to invite special service area commissioner appointees that are present to come up in front and take a seat. If your name is called, please indicate your presence to be acknowledged. Claudia Rodriguez, Hugo Avila, Rosa Haraf, Pamela Flowers-Thomas. Here. Perfect. All right. Items one through four on the agenda are appointments or re-appointments to the following special service areas. The following individuals are being considered before the committee. Re-appointment of Claudia Rodriguez as member of special service area number 25, Little Village Commission. Appointment of Hugo Avila as a member of the special service area number 25, Little Village Commission. Appointment of Rosa Haraf as member of the special service area number 34, Uptown Commission. And the appointment of Pamela Flowers-Thomas as a member of the special service area number 81, 87th Street Business Corridor Commission. At this time, Mark Roshan, the deputy commissioner for the Department of Planning and Development, is available to answer any questions on these appointments and re-appointments. Are there any questions for Mr. Mark Roshan and the members? All right. Seeing none, the ECTD committee has confirmed the support or non-objection for the following council members with appointments and re-appointments within their respective wards. Alderwoman Clay, Alderwoman Hall, Alderwoman Mona Hoppenworth, Alderwoman Martin, Alderwoman Mosley, Alderwoman Rodriguez, Alderwoman Scott, Alderwoman Cecil Lopez. Please let the record reflect that the special service area number 87 in our agenda had a mistake. It was not 12, it was 21. And so Alderwoman Mosley is in fact in support or has no objection for his SSA appointee. The appointees that are present, would you like to make a statement at this time? So you had a statement then. All right. Anyone online have a statement? Chairman of Lagos is Alderwoman Napolitano. I'd just like to be recorded as present. Thank you, Alderwoman Napolitano. The record will reflect that. All right. At this time, would any of the members of the committees or council members strike that? Are there any questions from the Alderman for the appointees and reappointees? All right. Seeing none, may have a motion to recommend approval of the appointments and reappointments by the same roll call vote that was applied to determine quorum. Alderwoman Lee, so moves here, no objections, so order to do pass recommendation for the appointments and reappointments will be reported out at the next city council meeting. Appointees, congratulations on your confirmation. In partnership with the city of Chicago, we look forward to working with you. Thank you. Item five on the agenda is an ordinance that amends 2025 budget and service provider agreement for special service area number 47, Cottage Grove. Mark Roshan, the deputy commissioner for the Department of Planning and Development is here to present and support the item and will be available to answer any questions. Mr. Roshan, please begin the presentation when you are ready. Good afternoon. Good afternoon, Chairman, Villegas, and members of the committee. My name is Mark Roshan. I'm an assistant commissioner for the Department of Planning and Development. The item before you is a budget amendment for SSA number 47. It's located in the 4th and the 20th Ward and it is for an $80,000 increase in the TIF rebate portion of their 2025 budget. The reason we are coming to you as a separate amendment is because in March the Comptroller received additional TIF rebate funds specifically for this SSA. The SSA has plans to use those extra funds as part of their Streetscape project which is being completed this summer and this fall and they need the funds expedited so that they can create an artist initiative, public art initiative that complements the installation of the Streetscape. So with that, we've requested an increase in the TIF rebate authorization portion of their 2025 budget and if there are no questions, we appreciate your favorable recommendation of this ordinance. Thank you, Deputy Commissioner Roshan. Alderman Robinson has provided a letter of support for this item. Are there any questions or comments from the members of the committee? All right. Seeing none, Alderman Wagesback makes a motion to recommend pass this ordinance by the same roll call vote that was applied to establish quorum. Hearing no objections, so ordered to do pass recommendation will be poured out at the next city council meeting. Item 6 through 8 on the agenda are direct introduction ordinances dealing with public hearings for various special service areas. Public hearings Hearings for SSA No. 17, Central Lakeview, terminating original SSA 17, creating a new SSA 17-2025 for a 15-year term from 2025 to 2039 in Wards 44 and 46. Public hearing for SSA No. 27, West Lakeview, an enlargement of a special service area, No. 27, change in special services, imposition of annual service tax at 0.25%, extension of original levy period from 2025 through 2039 in Wards 32, 44, 46, and 47. No. 8, public hearing regarding SSA No. 72, a change in special services, imposition of annual service tax at 1.75%, an extension of an original levy period from 2025 through 2039 in Wards 28 and 37. Mark Roshan, the Deputy Commissioner of the Department of Planning and Development, is here to present in support of these items and will be available to answer any questions. Mr. Roshan, please begin the presentation when you are ready. Thank you, Commissioner, Chairman Villegas, and members of the committee. My name, again, is Mark Roshan, Assistant Commissioner at the Department of Planning and Development. Before you are three direct introductions for public hearing authorization. These three ordinances are required in order to set a date for a public hearing for each of the three SSAs that are going through their renewal for the upcoming year. If no action is taken, these SSAs will expire. And so this ordinance will authorize the selection of the designation of a public hearing date to be held in October. The three SSAs are SSA No. 17-2025 for a 15-year reconstitution in the Central Lakeview and Wrigleyville area. The second ordinance is for SSA 27 in West Lakeview along Belmont Avenue and Southport Corridors. And the third ordinance is for SSA 72, the Chicago Cultural Corridor in the Austin community. We have letters of support from all of the affected alders, and we look for your favorable support. Again, these ordinances are not to approve the actual proposed SSAs, but are just to allow for the selection of a date for a public hearing. Thank you. Thank you, Deputy Commissioner Roshan. Are there any questions for members of the committee? Alderman Wagesbeck? Thank you, Chairman. Commissioner Roshan, could you just explain to us, and I do support the one for Lakeview. You know, we actually watched as they went out and got the signatures they needed for the reconstitution. Could you just explain to the public about the annual service tax and how that works, and also the type of cap, if any, there is on what an SSA is allowed to do there? And then where that funding would go right back into. So just the annual service tax, are they allowed to increase it by a certain amount every year, every reconstitution, and maybe what impact it would have for one versus another? So if you look at number eight, that annual service tax is 1.75, and then ours up in Lakeview is just a one-quarter. Sure. Just as a general discussion question. Okay. So SSAs are taxing agencies, just like the Board of Education, and appear on the tax bills as an additional layer of tax. There are caps on the levy rate that SSAs can charge. The state statute limits that to a 3%. To put that in context, the average tax load in Chicago for any given property is about 7%. So you're adding on top of that 7%. In the city, our SSAs range from a low of 0.25% to a high of 2.36%. The value of the properties, basically the EAV of each SSA varies greatly. So, you know, doing the math, the higher the EAV, the lower the rate that is needed to raise the same budget amount. So for that reason, the levy rates do vary from SSA to SSA, depending on their collective value of their EAV for their particular SSA. In terms of the funding, there are prescribed uses for SSA funds. They must benefit the public to provide some kind of benefit above and beyond what the city of Chicago is able to provide on a citywide basis. Excellent. Thank you very much. Thank you, Alderman Westbeck. First, let me acknowledge Alderman Dow for not purposes of quorum, but she's a non-member Alderman Dow. Can we get the Alderman to mic? Then followed by Alderman Lopez. Thank you, Mark. Just a quick question. When the EAV goes up and we see property values increasing on a commercial corridor, what's the process by which you can increase what you can get to go to the SSA? How does that happen? So the levy request that goes to the county with these budgets is actually a dollar amount. It's not a rate. And so if an SSA requests $100,000 for their budget for 2026, the county will note that. When it comes time to send out the second installment of the tax bill next year, there will be a final EAV that's determined for that particular SSA. And at that last minute before the bills are sent out, the appropriate rate is assigned to that EAV to come up with the exact $100,000 for their budget. So the taxpayers are not assessed based on if the property values rise in an area. That doesn't mean automatically that the SSA budgets rise accordingly with that. So an SSA can ask for more money in their budget. They can request an increase in their levy as long as it doesn't exceed their levy rate cap. Thank you. I'd like to also acknowledge Vice Chair Mosey for purposes of quorum, Alderman Lopez. Thank you, Chairman, and good afternoon, members of the committee. Item number six, you stated that all of these were to have hearings so that we avoid expiration. But item number six, what's the expiration date of SSA 17? SSA 17 will expire at the end of 2027. I'm sorry, 2026. There technically is one year left. We preemptively, based on the protocol of our law department, we preemptively renew SSAs before they expire. Because if they expire even for a momentary lapse at the end of the year, it's considered it triggers a hard, what we call a hard stop. And that way, that would require a break in their funding sources. So by renewing before the expiration, that allows us to continue the steady collection and distribution of tax collections going into the new term of an SSA. So to be clear, this wasn't one of the unexpiring SSAs, correct? This SSA, there's a couple of factors that go into when an SSA must reconstitute. If any pins, properties are taken out of an SSA, that requires a new SSA entity to be established. And so that's the reason that this one is SSA 17-2025 and not SSA 17. In this case, there were about three residential blocks of properties that were no longer to be included in this SSA. Instead, the SSA is using the CTA red line as a way to continue the contiguity necessary to be compliant with the SSA program. Can you expand on that? What does that mean? So all SSAs must be contiguous. And so for the existence of SSA 17 has included some residential blocks in order to maintain that contiguity to serve all the businesses in the area. Through this process, we determined that certain residential properties were no longer necessary to be in the SSA. And so those SSA, upon request of the service provider, those SSA properties were removed from SSA 17. Those residential properties. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Alderman Lopez. Any other questions from members of the committee? All right. Seeing none, I may have a motion to recommend passing this item by the same roll call vote that was applied to the established quorum. Vice Chair Moseley, so moves. Hearing no objections, so order. The due pass recommendation will be reported out at the next city council meeting. Item nine on the agenda is a Class 6B tax incentive for property at 1400 West 46th Street and redevelopment agreement with Bubbly Dynamics LLC. Aaron Fogel, financial planning analyst for the Department of Planning and Development, is here to present in support of the item and be available to answer any questions. We also have members of the development team available to answer any questions. Mr. Fogel, when you're prepared, please begin your presentation. Thank you. Good afternoon, Chairman Villegas and members of the Committee on Economic Capital and Technology Development. For the record, my name is Aaron Fogel, financial planning analyst in the Department of Planning and Development. I'm also joined today by John Adel, representing the applicant. I'm here today to request the approval of an ordinance supporting a Class 6B SER property tax incentive for Bubbly Dynamics for the purpose of providing sustainable economic relief for its facility at 1400 West 46th Street, known as The Plant, an approximately 100,000 square foot industrial property it has owned since 2010. The project site is located at 1400 West 46th Street in the 15th Ward, the new city community area, the Southwest Planning Region, the Stockyards Industrial Corridor, and the 47 Ashland Tiff District. Alderman Lopez has provided a letter of support for the project. Here's an aerial view of the site located in Canaryville at a dead end bordered by a rail line to the east, separating it from complementary industrial use. The plant is an approximately 100,000 square foot facility that houses a collaborative community of small food businesses committed to material reuse and closed-loop systems. It currently hosts more than 20 businesses, including indoor and outdoor farms, kombucha and beer breweries, a bakery, a cheese distributor, a coffee roaster, and other emerging food producers and distributors. The plant is a former meatpacking facility that closed in 2007. The marketability of the property to a traditional tenant user that would occupy the whole space is severely limited due to low-ceiling clearances, limited loading areas, a three-story design, and divided interiors. Much of the building is unimproved or only nominally improved from its prior use. It's simply been repurposed. The building includes severely degraded 1974-built concrete with significant efflorescence, rust corrosion, spalling, and cracking. Corrugated metal sheeting is required in some areas to contain the fallout of concrete ceilings. Seepage is constant, and drainage systems from the building's roof and city sewer will back up several feet in the basement during heavy rain. Bubbly Dynamics purchased the property in 2010 as an applying for a Class 6B SER property tax incentive. Bubbly Dynamics operates on a slow-money development model, emphasizing steady growth and resource efficiency and long-term value over rapid returns. It also operates as a social enterprise committed to keeping rents affordable for small and emerging businesses. Tax saving from the incentive to the applicant are estimated to be about $1 million over 12 years, while total taxes are estimated to be nearly $3 million. The applicant has indicated that it will no longer be able to operate the plant without this incentive. The applicant notes that it does not currently have a significant construction project in the immediate pipeline, but that it will be able to initiate rehab work as cash flow permits. It also has identified planned property improvements, but projects have remained on hold due to the upfront costs of construction and infrastructure. Bubbly Dynamics was established in 2002 and first renovated the former Lowe Brothers Paint Warehouse in 2007 before purchasing the subject property at the plant in 2010. Recent improvements they have implemented at the plant include a new roof installed in 2015 and 2016, tuck-pointing exteriors, new windows, three interior loading docks, new concrete and metal railings, new glass enclosures, updated electrical conduit, and wiring throughout the majority of the structure, some limited build-outs for office and flex use, and a freight elevator monitorization, all totaling about $1.4 million. The plant is home to 17 industrial businesses listed here that use over 70,000 square feet of industrial square footage. The plant's economic hardship is outlined here, including significant property obsolescence and deferred maintenance, sharply increased property taxes since the acquisition, and full reoccupation of the property, a near doubling of operating expenses, resulting in net operating losses for several past years recently. As noted earlier, we estimate the value of the tax abatement to the applicant to be about $1 million over 12 years, or $753,000 on a net present value basis. Additionally, we estimate this incentive to provide an $858,000 12-year net benefit to all taxing districts, or $605,000 on a net present value basis. While this incentive would not be tied to specific investment, the applicant has identified and planned for a couple of significant property improvement projects that it will undertake as cash flow permits. One is called Southside Cellars, costing $233,000, which proposes to turn 4,500 square feet of vacant basement space into a facility to support the aggregation, processing, and distribution of local foods. The other is called Energy Capture Plus Reuse System, at a cost of $783,000, which, in collaboration with the SPARC Center at DePaul, would replace outdated HVAC and refrigeration equipment with a centralized thermal network that captures waste heat from on-site food production and redistributes it where needed. DPD is in support of this project that demonstrates qualification for the 6B-SER program, providing economic relief to a long-term industrial owner. DPD allows for job retention among its diverse and 100% Chicago-based workforce, and is estimated to provide a net benefit to all taxing districts. Thank you for your favorable consideration of this request. I, as well as the applicant, are happy to answer questions you may have. Thank you, Mr. Fogel. As you indicated, Alderman Lopez has provided a letter of support. Alderman, would you like to make some remarks on this item? Thank you, Chairman. Actually, I would ask if John Edel would care to say anything or just smile from the background. Okay, he will smile from the background, but he's back there. Yes, I'm happy to make remarks. That was probably the most vanilla and bland description of what goes on in one of the most tasteful and colorful buildings on the southwest side. It's truly amazing for any of you who have not yet been to the plant to see what a fully repurposed and closed-loop system looks like in the back-of-the-yards community. No offense to Canaryville, but this is a back-of-the-yards baby. And as we've seen, this location repurposed something from our historic era and turned it into something quite literally, no pun intended, John, dynamic when it comes to creating business opportunities for women, for minorities, and for everyone who literally has the grit and determination to make something of themselves in a space that they can call their own. You know, I'm reminded as I looked at like the south side cellars that – is that the location where you used to have the shrimp ponds or the tilapia? Okay. So this same building could go top to bottom with grains. Actually, I think the very top is bioengineered – is the – was or is the bioengineered printed foods, the meat, the shrimp, the $10,000 produced shrimp, all the way down to a system that recycles itself in the basement with shrimp, tilapia, and throughout the walls to help create – to turn algae into fuel. That twice in this room we've had discussions about anaerobic digestion now here, yesterday and today. But more specifically, creates well over 100 jobs at its peak and provided for many of the restaurants with microgreens, cheese, mushrooms, fish, things of that nature, to many of Chicago's restaurants. This is a model that should be duplicated, replicated, and incentivized in all our communities. And gladly welcome all of you to join us there to see what we have to offer. I believe, Lenny, you were actually there not too long ago. But also, aside from all of those opportunities, it has a – Wonderful tap room with the Southwest Side's own brewery, Wiener Brewery. So hard-pressed not to see or do anything in one day. And welcome all of your support for this and an open invitation to see live and in person. Thank you. Thank you, Alderman Lopez. Alderman Lee. Thank you, Chair. And thanks, Ray, for that great description of the project. I am familiar with Bubbly Dynamics, as they also operate in the 11th Ward in Bridgeport. So I am in full support of this tax incentive for Bubbly Dynamics at the plant to continue their work. Can't say enough great things. We need more organizations like Bubbly Dynamics. Social enterprise is kind of like a weird term that I think not enough people are familiar with. But the work that you do is so valuable, and I wish you all the best. I will come over and take a tour of the new plant. I know you've been wanting me to, so I will make sure that I get over there now. Well, I'll make sure that Ray buys me a beer. Thanks a lot. Thank you, Alderman Lee. Are there any other questions from members of the committee? All right. Seeing no questions from the committee vice chair, Mosey makes a motion to recommend pass of this item by the same roll call vote that was applied to establish quorum. Here are no objections, so ordered. The due pass recommendation will be reported out at the next city council meeting. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Item 10 on the agenda is a class 6B tax incentive for the property at 501 North Sacramento Boulevard. William Grams, financial planning analyst for the Department of Planning and Development, is here to present and support this item. Be available to answer any questions. We also have members of the development team available to answer any questions. Mr. Grams, please begin the presentation when you are ready. Thank you. Good afternoon, Chairman Villegas and members of the committee on economic capital and technology development. For the record, my name is William Grams, financial planning analyst in the Department of Planning and Development. I'm also joined today by Greg Diamantopoulos, counsel for the developer, Alex Theakos from the development team, and Todd Osman, Stephen Pokorski, and Lisa Carlson from Goose Island Beer Company. I'm here today to request the approval of an ordinance supporting the renewal of a class 6B property tax incentive for Market Properties LLC to support their business at 501 North Sacramento Boulevard. The project is located at 501 North Sacramento Boulevard, which is in the 27th Ward, the Humble Park community area, and the West Planning Region. While the seat is currently vacant, former Alderman Walter Burnett previously provided a letter of support for the project. Here is an aerial view of the site, which is located at the northeast corner of North Sacramento Boulevard and West Ferdinand Street. Here is an exterior view of the nearly 500,000-square-foot building, which was renovated between 2010 and 2013 as part of the initial class 6B incentive application. Here is an interior view of the facility, which holds two tenants, DWF Food and Paper Redistributors, Inc., which is a family-owned food service distributor servicing Chicagoland since 1958, and Fulton Street Brewery, LLC, a craft brewer doing business as Goose Island Beer Company. The applicant and property owner, Market Properties LLC, is seeking renewal of the class 6B property tax incentive for its 493,554-square-foot facility. The original project cost was $4.1 million, and more than $8 million has been invested in total during the initial incentive period. The facility is fully occupied with two tenants, DWF Food and Paper Redistributors, Inc., which is an owner-related entity of the applicant, and Fulton Street Brewery, LLC. Across both tenants are 32 full-time and two part-time employees. The estimated tax savings to the applicant during the renewal period is $6,114,779. While there is not a clearly defined new project associated with the renewal, the ownership intends to make future investments during the renewal period, including adding additional temperature-controlled freezer space, new security systems, and energy efficiency improvements. The estimated 12-year tax savings to the applicant over the renewal period is $6,114,779, of which the city's share is $1,415,048. The property will pay an estimated $5,591,522 in taxes over the same period. DPD is in support of the class 6B renewal for Market Properties LLC. Taxes have risen nearly 4x throughout the initial incentive period, starting at less than $100,000 and increasing to $365,532 in the most recent certified tax year. With the triennial reassessment and phase-out of the initial incentive, full taxes would be nearly $1 million annually. Most of the taxes are passed through to the tenants. The Goose Island lease expires in 2030 and would be challenging to renew with a further tripling of the taxes. With renewal of the incentive, ownership will be able to continue to invest in the site. Thank you for your favorable consideration of this request. I, as well as members of the development team, are happy to answer any questions the committee may have. Thank you. Are there any questions from members of the committee? A couple of things. In your presentation, your last slide talks about, you can bring that back up. So you continue in investment with the renewal of the incentive. Ownership will be able to continue to invest in the site, including building modernizations, new schemes. Are those capital projects already underway? Are they future projects? What does that mean? Good afternoon, Chairman. This is Greg Diamantopoulos, the counsel for the developer. Nothing's been, nothing's, you know, planned currently, but the incentive started in 2014. At that time, you know, the full roof was replaced. We do anticipate, you know, with another, you know, 10 to 12-year period that the roof would potentially be replacing. The building, you know, is 84, 85 years old. It's built in 1939. So there's always tuck pointing. We expect seal coating for a two-acre asphalt and concrete, you know, parking that will be necessary, you know, as well as, you know, painting. So some of the general maintenance items, there are additional things that are kind of listed up there. You know, some freezer space was added back after the incentive started back in 2017, and the ownership, the developer, the Thiakos family, had bought the mechanicals, but for their space has not done installation. If, you know, there was some additional growth, the installation, it's my understanding it's about a $2 million investment to do all the things that need to be done to install that type of freezer. So there are things that we anticipate, as well as, you know, security systems is kind of an issue that was one of those things when the building was first purchased, you know, it was, you know, the prior ownership had gone into bankruptcy. There were things, you know, getting stolen out of the building. So there was a lot of investment done at that time. Some investment done, security systems was done when they initially invested money. You know, you know, we have the ownership's, you know, business there, but there's also the Goose Island space, which hosts, you know, an event space. Their, you know, crime and homelessness is kind of an issue that's coming up. So we do anticipate, you know, potentially some additional security upgrades. But, you know, the short answer is there's nothing planned at this time, but those are things that we do expect. So usually we give and usually we have incentives and there's capital projects that are tied to it, job creation, et cetera. So with this incentive, you're basically, you're not creating any new jobs. You're not making investments. You're just stating that your taxes have gone up and you're seeking the incentive in order to provide it on to your clients or to your tenants, rather. Is that what my question is, why are we giving you an incentive if you have no capital projects that are listed and then also no new job creation? Yeah. So this is a project that, you know, took a vacant and abandoned site and put it into productive use. And these are the tenants that have been there since that time in 2014. Ownership came in and took 190,000 square feet. Goose Island came in and took about 145,000 to start in January 2024, and then has made two expansions up to about 303,000 square feet. So they brought additional jobs. Ownership brought their jobs from the existing, the previous location. So these are tenants that have been there long term, and we're trying to keep those tenants in place to keep those existing jobs. So we do anticipate, and part of what Mr. Graham said presented, is that additional investment on top of what was initially planned was put into the building, and we have been a good steward of that building and intend to put projects forth. There's just nothing that's come up yet at this exact time when we are asking for the renewal of the incentive. But it is – And this is – I want to read the record to reflect this is a renewal, correct? Correct. The incentive that was initially put actually allowed you to make these investments in order to get to where you're at now. It did, absolutely. So usually when we have a renewal, it's usually to increase jobs, increase capital. There's no renewal – I'm sorry, the renewal is not talking about any job creation. It's not talking about any capital. The initial incentive did exactly what it's supposed to do. It provided an opportunity for you to have relief in that tax so that way you could make these investments, create jobs, et cetera, which was successful. But right now what I'm seeing is there's – you're just asking for the incentive because your taxes have gone up. And there's no capital projects have been identified, nor have there any job creation here. So that's why I'm having a hard time understanding why we're talking about providing an incentive in a case where it already – the incentive worked. And you're not bringing on any additional work. There's no specific capital projects that you can point to to say, hey, this is why we need this incentive in order to pay for these capital projects. So a renewal, your taxes have gone up. That's basically what I'm hearing. Sir, you raised your hand. Hello, Chairman. My name is Alex Thiagos. I'm with the development team of the property. I would say one of the biggest issues we're having is the security issue. Goose Island Beer Company is present today, a few of the representatives. And they do have an event center directly in front of 14 homeless tents that has deterred a lot of weddings and different kind of events for the following year. And due to this, once 2030 comes at the end of their lease, it's not – to my knowledge, it's not looking too favorable that they love that space to hold events. So I'm not too sure how the renewal of their lease looks like. So with 300,000 square feet empty and a family-owned business of 190,000 square feet and the tax bill potentially 3X-ing to a million dollars, that's not very good for us. Who initially in 2010 took on the project at the heat of the financial crisis and poured lots of money into it. And it just kind of feels like that would kind of be a kick in the – or a punch in the gut to us for taking on that risk initially to then, for the future, get held with a million-dollar tax bill. No, and again, the incentive was sought after you provided the incentive for 12 years and you made the investments. The reduction in tax – your tax bill allowed for that to help offset that. So we were partners in that. And it accomplished what it was supposed to accomplish. You have a full place, a facility that's full, and it's back on a property tax roll, and so the incentive did its job. What I'm hearing here is that you have folks that are intense, that if you talk to CPD, they can help you with that, or Department of Family Support Services can help you with that. I'm just having a hard time without having an exact project to look at capital investment or saying, hey, we're creating 100 jobs. I'm just having a hard time seeing how an incentive of this magnitude is justified. So I'm just having a hard time. Alderman Lopez? Thank you, Chairman, and good afternoon again, members of the committee. First off, I want to say, Chairman, I appreciate your questions because I think that this sets us on a very interesting precedent when it comes to tax incentives to offset – not create jobs, but to offset bad policies by the city of Chicago. So – and it's a kick in the nuts, I think this is the phrase you were looking for. Thank you. I appreciate it. Thank you. The incentives are designed – you're asking because Goose Island – who is here? Who are they? Yeah, so we have – Would you like to come join us because I have a question for you? We do have three representatives from Goose Island. Mr. Gramps did introduce them, Todd Osman, who's the president of Goose Island, Stephen Pekorski, financial controller at Goose Island, and Lisa Carlson, the brewery experience coordinator. I'll step back so that they can answer any of your questions. And then the members of Goose Island, you can have one representative and just introduce your team. Sure. So my name is Todd Osman, president of Goose Island. I have our controller, Steve Pekorski, with me and our event coordinator from the event space at the location, Lisa Carlson. Thank you. And for the record, you have not provided any free samples to the committee, so we're free to – Or else it would have passed already, so – I'm just – someone's going to accuse us. I'm just going to get it out there. I would like to say, for the record, we did teach Brian at Weiner Beer how to make beer. I know. And he worked at our facility. So we're beyond that subject right now. But, yes, thank you for teaching, Brian. It was stated that you have a contract for events based on 2030. Yes? Correct. And it was also stated that there are multiple homeless – is it tents or encampments? Or all of the above? Yeah, all of the above. They moved from a viaduct about a block away once they did work, and they brought them right in front of the event center. So they can speak on it more if they would like, but it is – If you would. It is challenging for them to book space for the following year. So that we can all get an idea of what you're dealing with as a business. Sure. We – so we're very proud of the neighborhood and the location. Consider ourselves stewards of Chicago throughout the world now as we have pubs everywhere. But we are hosting a lot of events five days a week, everything from weddings to corporate meetings to birthday parties. And these are booked about six months out in advance. And we've had security problems. We had a break-in over the weekend, and we have – we've hired additional security to – 24-7 to monitor the facility. And the homeless are just on the parkway, on the street? What's – Parkway. In a row. Approximately how many would you say are there? I would say about 15 – 10 to 15 tenths, roughly. Okay. My concern is this, Chairman. And as much as I like to support people and keep business here, this is not the right way to do it. Addressing the homeless issue would be the right way to do it. But as we've seen time and time again, this administration refuses – absolutely refuses – to address homelessness, actually setting a new policy unrelated to this that allows Chicago Park Districts to now be places for homeless encampments at the expense of the community. All the while, the one system initiative started by this administration has been hijacked by the ever-evolving migrant crisis, thereby forcing individuals to live in tents, in parks, on streets, in viaducts, and in front of businesses who, presumably, given the chance, would leave. If you could leave today, would you, if that issue was unresolved? Reluctantly, yes. So I say that – I ask that not because I'm trying to beat up the building – the people who invested or the people who are leasing space, but I think it's incumbent on all of us to hear it loudly from business people that we are creating a city that no one wants to stay a part of. Everything that we're doing to try to attract business is getting bit in the ass by all the social policies that do us no favors. I don't know how, Chairman, we move forward, as you've stated. The objectives have been met. There's no additional criteria that are being proposed under the extension. But at the same time, it pains me to think that now we have to not only supplement the homeless system, the failed homeless system of this administration, but its impact on businesses as well. So… I don't know. So… I really don't know how we move forward from this point because what concerns me is that once one business starts asking for tax incentives because of the negative impact of bad policies, this will be the day that the 6B has evolved as opposed to being a job creator to a job maintainer regardless of impact simply because we have to offset the negatives of the failed policies of this building. Thank you. Thank you, Alderman Lopez. Alderman Manahapenworth. Thank you. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you for your presentation. I'm a small business owner too. And I have a very small business, not comparing to you, but in Andersonville. And so I represent the 48th Ward in Edgewater. And we are not immune to our housing crisis, which is happening all over the city of Chicago, in every neighborhood, including in yours, in front of your business, and in mine as well. And I just wanted to express my also frustration with those that need help, that people should not be living in tents. And we're doing all that we can with the departments that have been doing this, who are tasked to do it, DFSS, with parks, with streets and sand, with the police, everybody working together with the Chambers of Commerce. Because it's not just a tax incentive that's going to fix homelessness. It's not. So I just want to express my empathy and also get us back on task to the job of approving or disproving this tax incentive. And I understand, but I understand what you're saying. It's very difficult to be a small business owner right now. It's very difficult to develop neighborhoods right now because people are suffering. But we also have to address all the things that we need to do to build more housing, to build more affordability, and it's slow. And it's not easy to house people. It's expensive, like $30,000, to house a person who's living in a tent right now. And that takes a lot of coordination, and we're doing the best we can. We in Edgewater have already housed 60 people since I've been in office, and that's no small feat. It requires a lot of coordination. And us, you know, me going out to talk to people, to ask them for their name, to make sure that they're in the 311 system, it's, you know, it's a personal, it's a trust thing, too. I understand your difficulties trying to, you know, make sure that you are able to sustain your business and to make sure that Chicago is a destination for all the milestones that are really important to people. And Goose Island is part of that experience. And so I just wanted to express that. It's very difficult, and we're doing all that we can, but it takes time, it takes trust, and it takes relationship building. Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Alderman Lee. Thank you, Chair. Typically, we would hear from an older person, which you currently don't have. I want to echo a lot of the sentiments here. I'm not sure that this is necessarily addressing the actual issue. I would like to make a motion to hold this in committee until we have a newly appointed older person that you could work with to try to sort through some of these issues. And then you all can regroup as to whether or not the 6B is actually necessary. But I would like to hear from the older person that's going to be taking over. I'd also like to – sorry. Please identify yourself and – Jeff Cohen, Deputy Commissioner, Department of Planning and Development. I wanted to directly address Chairman Villegas' question about the rationale for this tax incentive here. We are seeing a supremely increasing tax environment here that could potentially be detrimental to this particular business. In 2030, when this lease expires, if we are not able to address the occupancy costs for this particular user, they are most likely going to vacate, which is going to put an undue burden on the existing ownership, which is a family-run business. In order to make sure that we can either attract a new tenant or keep this tenant here, along with the 32 jobs, DVD's recommendation was to renew this, particularly for those reasons. If we're not here – if we come around and not do this renewal, we most likely will be back here in five years, having already lost a tenant, maybe potentially putting a family business under, and likely having a vacant building for 12 months that we would have to come back and get a new 6B4. So here, I understand. I understand. But the precedence here around incentives has always been that the incentive would be for job creation, capital improvements, et cetera. On a renewal, it would be an expansion of additional capital, more jobs created, et cetera. That's what this is about. I understand that property taxes have gone up. I understand that. And I appreciate the investment in the city of Chicago, and I appreciate Goose Island being in that facility. But we've got to be careful about the precedence that we're setting here because every incentive that I've seen has created a job or has – have capital projects tied to it. And so what I'm going to do is I'm going to hold this in committee, and then I want DPD to work with the owners of the property to figure out what jobs are going to be created as well as what type of capital improvements are going to be done and when the work is going to actually get started because what I've heard is that you're going to do future projects. I need concrete. What does that mean? We're talking about a million dollars or more of a tax break, and I don't mind. I've supported almost every tax incentive. I have because businesses need that relief as well as we're making these investments. But to have no projects identified and no job creation and ask for an extension I think goes against the spirit of what the incentive is because the spirit of the incentive worked. It applied 12 years ago. The facility was remodeled. It's full. Perfect. Now you need an extension. What are we getting in the form of jobs and investments as well for this incentive? And you have been unable to explain that to me. And so as a result of that, we're going to hold it, allow DPD to do further work to figure out and justify what the incentive is so that way we're not setting a precedence here where any company that feels that their tax bill is too high can just come back and say, hey, we want an incentive. And then depending on who is putting it forward, we'll get it or not. Now, I don't want to I don't want to be in the business of picking winners and losers. We want to make sure that the incentive, the spirit of the incentive is to allow for job creation and capital investments. That's all we're looking for. So we need to be consistent because I'm not going to set a precedence here where we're picking winners and losers. We want every business to succeed in Chicago. And we're going to provide the incentives to make sure that that happens when applicable. And in this case here, I think you guys have had a hard time explaining it. That's why I'm going to allow for DPD to go back, talk to the owners to figure out on a concrete plan as to how the incentive will be used. I understand it'll be passed to the owner. No problem. We do that. We do that here, but it's not enough to justify that renew at this time. So go back, work with the developer and the properties owner to figure out how we're going to how we're going to put forward a better product. So we're going to hold this right now. I mean, Lopez, and then we'll hold it. Thank you, Chairman. Actually, since DPD, since you're up here, as I'm looking at the Cook County's tax incentive schedules, the incentives for special properties, there's a dozen, half dozen. Which one of them deals with security concerns? Sorry, can you clarify the question? No. Which public safety incentive deals with security concerns? Public safety incentive. Yeah. I am not aware of that at the moment. There's none, right? Yeah. Which one deals with homeless encampment? Where's the homeless encampment incentive in the Cook County's tax incentive program? I don't believe there isn't one. There isn't one. So you are, as a department, trying to manipulate the 6B to compensate and address what they've brought to your attention. Because what they've brought to us today, what they've articulated very clearly is that because of public safety failures and a homeless policy failure, we are now trying to manipulate this. And I don't want to belabor the point because I think the chairman and others have said it well. But it is highly offensive that a department would try to do this at a time when it is clear what those tax incentives are. Sure. And I hope that it's not as sure. And stop smacking your lips because it's very disrespectful to this body. You are insulting all of us. with this answer and i hope you understand the severity of that because your commissioner should be ashamed of herself for having you here representing that mentality here today and hopefully when you arrive before the next committee if it's you who arrives you come with a very more respectful attitude on this subject thank you chairman all right on on that note i'm going to go ahead and hold it in committee uh and allow dpd to do additional work in order to provide a better product for the committee to for consideration all right um so we're gonna we're gonna hold that okay all right item 11 on the agenda is a class 7b tax incentive for property at 1210 west 59th street and execution of agreement with rage economic upliftment project llc for redevelopment into commercial space robert bumpers financial planning analyst for the department of planning and development is here to present in support of the item and will be available to answer any questions we also have members of the development team available to answer any questions uh mr bumpers please begin the presentation when you are ready good afternoon commissioner vegas and members of the committee on economic capital and technology development for the record my name is robert bumpers financial planning analyst in the department of planning and development i'm here today to request your approval of a redevelopment agreement between the city of chicago and the resident association of greater inglewood rage if you will for the purpose of authorizing an initial property tax incentive a six sorry 7b property tax incentive i am joined here today by asia butler co-founder and ceo of rage and valerie batiste she is the uh owner's rep from allied innovation group the subject property is located at 1210 west 59th street within the inglewood community area in the 16th ward it's the south planning region alderwoman coleman is supportive of the incentive property is located on the northwest corner of west 59th street and south racine avenue as you can see here it's a building exterior current condition interior current condition again the project team is led by asia butler co-founder and ceo of rage the team also includes general contractor national builders construction group beehive architects and allied innovation acting as the owner's rep rage is the resident-led neighborhood association focused on community revitalization within the greater inglewood area the proposed project the 1210 west 59th street will rehabilitate the 8 000 square foot building into a retail development containing a second majani's restaurant a training facility for e-class security and offices for rage total project cost is 6.4 million dollars the project will be financed with combination of equity debt and the requested 2.5 million dollars in nof grant estimated tax abatement to the applicant is 209 000 this is an npv of 155 000 city share is 48 000 with an npv of 36 000 this is a rendering of the completed project overall dpd is highly supportive of the proposed project the incentive will aid the community in the creation of creation of jobs activation of a vacant building increasing property taxes and providing much-needed retail in the area thank you for your favorable consideration of this request i'm joined here today again by asia butler and valerie batiste we're happy to answer any questions you may have thank you uh mr bumpers uh alderman coleman has provided a letter of support for this item to the committee are there any questions uh from the members of the committee alderman lopez yes thank you chairman i promise i'll be nice this time it's my plea um on behalf of all of the anglewood alderman i've been texting them to see um we are all very excited to see this project finally take off um actually i know that uh the resident association of greater anglewood started about almost a decade ago 15 years we're celebrating is it 15 years yes november 15th you will be getting an invitation to our celebration so looking forward to that look and all the great things that we've done together in the community um i just do have one question the uh display showed a two and a half million dollar neighborhood opportunity fund award has that been given already it has not we have just did a committee meeting last week for it to be approved at i think it was a budget committee committee finance yes we were there um yeah it was approved at the finance okay okay i just wanted to make sure because i know sometimes those things don't move in tandem and it tends to add more costs that organizations cannot handle so i'm glad to hear with my finance chair to my right that both are moving simultaneously in the same direction so congratulations and look forward to the new addition on racine thank you chairman and move to pass if no other questions thank you alderman lopez any other questions from members um there was a request uh asia if there were any more of these three more okay um so you guys know we were doing a capital campaign and so we have this for some of our marketing so i have three more um and then the slide that you have is a update we gave to at our village meeting last week and so i just he just kind of talked a little bit about where we were um i didn't update it for this meeting but um we're still working trying to work through some permit issues so you're going to see permits are stuck in zoning right now but we're working through that but yeah i do have three more okay if you if you wouldn't mind providing that to my staff so that some of the members were asking for that yes all right um any other question from members all right seeing seeing seeing no other questions on lopez has made a recommendation uh for passage of this item by the same roll call that was applied to establish quorum hearing no objections so order to do pass recommendation would be reported out the next city council meeting um thank you congratulations item 12 on the agenda is our subject matter hearing to examine uses and projected short and long-term impacts of the 830 million general obligations bond uh did want to state um according to the rules of order and procedure for city council for this for this term the economic capital technology development quote shall have jurisdiction over the consideration identification goals plan and approach to the annual and five-year capital improvement programs um we want to make sure that departments that are in charge of capital are actually hearing from the members as to relates to what is what is it that are some of their priorities as well my understanding is that um the departments that receive capital dollars make requests uh to the budget office and then into the finance uh cfo as well and then those dollars are totaled and then uh a request for bond authorization is uh put forward that being said the part that's missing in my opinion is what are the members priorities uh because ultimately we're the ones who have to to vote for uh the funding of the bond as well as the associated uh appropriations needed to pay back that bond and so it's important that we have these discussions prior so that we can know what your thoughts are around capital and more importantly what our thoughts around capital uh to make sure that there's um some synergy there um i opened i opened this subject matter hearing by welcoming representatives from our city departments we have the following department's officials uh in place fleet facility management deputy commissioner uh merrick wisniewski deputy commissioner mark chumplis chipotlis my staff wrote it wrong so i apologize uh department of water management uh deputy commissioner hans krueger seed out assistant commissioner william higgins department of finance department of finance assistant commissioner brendan white um and members should have received the 2025 capital bond preliminary budget slide deck in the share drive um so with that if we can have these members present so you guys can put forward your your slide deck and we can talk about the uh the hearing um so so everyone should have a copy of the uh the slide deck that was proposed for the or not strike that not proposed rather that was passed or not strike that was passed by the uh the uh the uh the uh the uh the uh the uh the uh the uh the uh the uh the uh the uh the uh the uh the uh the uh the uh the uh the uh the uh the uh the uh the uh uh the uh the uh the uh uh the uh uh uh the uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh Thank you. around the capital bond 2025 budget. This is an effort to talk about where we're at, ultimately what's going to be required for 26, 27, et cetera. So I'll start off with some questions, and then we'll have the appropriate departments go ahead and respond. So on slide number one, the slide starts off with the purpose of bond offering, and the use of proceeds states that the approved capital projects from 24 to 28 capital improvement plan. And so my question is, who picks the projects during this four-year or five-year period? Good afternoon, Chairman. Good afternoon. And members of the committee, from 2FM's side of things for capital improvement projects associated with our facilities, we work in tandem with our end-user departments to understand their goals and their needs, as well as our facility operations team engineers and our trades to understand the deficiencies that would most impact the functionality of these buildings and basically prevent them from operating as intended and providing the services to the communities which they are in. So the end-users provide what the request is for upkeep and for capital? It's a combination of discussions with the end-user departments to understand their needs, but also we work with our facility operations team who basically maintain and operate the buildings to understand the most significant impacts that failed systems would have, per se, roofing, mechanical, masonry, things like that. So we prioritize things based on warm, safe, dry, and making sure that the facilities can continue to stay operational for the public. So along that note, what type of data do we use in order to categorize, or at least like asset management, our infrastructure, so that way we know when the life of something is coming to an end, so that way we can put forward recommendations for capital requests? That's correct, sir, yes. There's a work order system, which the facilities team operates and uses. They generate those work orders, and then we analyze those and basically identify priority needs and move those to the priority list. Gotcha. What about CDOT? Bill Higgins from CDOT. Yeah, a large portion is through the menu program, so it's selected by the alderman and your colleagues. In addition to that, we have a lot of programs that are based off of conversations with aldermen, 311 data, assessment of the roadway to figure out what projects need to be prioritized for maintenance. So you said you started off by saying the menu. Right. Right. So what's that dollar amount? The entire menu program is $108 million. $75 million is the direct menu that is selected, $1.5 per ward. And what's your total budget for capital improvements? Sorry, I don't have the total in front of me. Would you say it's north of half a billion? Yes. Would you say it's a billion? It could be, I don't, yeah. So we'll split it there. Sure. It's not a billion, maybe a billion, maybe half a billion. Let's say $750 for easy math. Yeah. $750 million. So 10% of that is actual menu where we have a say in the projects. Is that accurate? Yes, that's correct. Okay. So then the other 90%, who makes the decision as to where those dollars are going? CDOT staff in coordination with the aldermen on various projects. So we have almost $100 million going towards the bridge and viaduct program alone. Bridges are quite expensive. Sure. I'm saying nearly $100 million to the bridge and viaduct program alone. As I was saying, bridges are quite expensive to maintain and replace when needed. And that's, you know, reviewed by bridge engineers that under state and federal requirements that we... So do we receive federal and state dollars to help with construction of bridges? In some cases, I don't know the exact number. Are there cases where we pay for the full bridge replacement out of our capital fund? Yes. We are advancing right now in this budget, eight bridge rehab reconstructions and repair to eight additional bridges, $2 million to $5 million each. What's that total cost for those 16 projects? You said eight new and eight rehab? $98 million. $98 million? Yeah. Okay. Do we take a look as it relates to viaducts? Do we talk to the railroad industries as well as Surface Transportation Board to figure out what funds they provide in order to help with viaduct upkeep since it's their equipment that goes over that viaduct? Yeah, we do. There is specific elements to the viaduct and bridge that are the railroad's responsibilities, and we parcel that out. Right now in this budget, we have $825,000 for two underpasses for viaduct rehabilitation. There are more projects than that being done in the city right now through projects that are funded through other means. So you said that CDOT staff determines what projects need funding, and you said there's some coordination with aldermen. Sure. How does that work? How does that communication? Because I've never had any discussions except for the CIP and how I'm going to spend my menu. But anything above my menu is basically there's no discussion, and so I want to find out how I'm able to tap into that other 90% of funds that are going towards capital and making sure that we're able to address some of the issues of capital within our wards. Because when this capital bill was passed and it originated out of this committee, it was intended to help put people to work, but at the same time coupled with what was occurring at the state and their $45 billion capital plan and also at the federal government with their $1.2 trillion capital plan. And what we've seen is that the capital dollars are easy bucket to tap into when you're pursuing the state and federal dollars, and if you're not successful, then you come back into the state dollars and into the city capital program. And the reason why we put forward this capital program was really to address the bread and butter issues that we get calls on, whether it's sidewalks, curbs, lighting, alleys, resurfacing. And what we're seeing is that what I've seen over the last couple of years is that it's being used for larger, very expensive projects, which in turn really diminishes the return on investments in the wards because $98 million in the wards goes a long way versus $98 million for a bridge. Now, I'm not going to say that we scrap not fixing the bridges, but what I'm saying is there's money at the federal and state level, and that we need to make sure we're doing our best in order to capture those revenue because, again, the dollar at the local level goes a lot further for us, and people can see that infrastructure. So I want to make sure that CDOT is doing everything possible to pursue those state and federal dollars because the 90% of funding that we're not being able to – I shouldn't say not being able to. We haven't had discussions around. I want us to have discussions around what projects are priorities to us because we know what your priorities are, and you have access to them, and you're making those decisions. But as an appropriator, I want to make sure that I have some decisions in there as well because, ultimately, these bonds are paid back by property taxes. And so if I'm going to my property owners saying, hey, we're raising property taxes in order to pay for infrastructure projects, and they're asking me, hey, why is my street not resurfaced, and why is my sidewalks cracked, then there's a disconnect there. And so we need to do a better job of having communications with capital requests from not just the departments but also with the aldermen to find out what our priorities are. Okay, okay. Okay. Okay. I would just add that the – we do have a lot of street resurfacing, $102 million, just going to street resurfacing out of the bond. We have – that includes the Green Alley program. There's also supplemental arterial resurfacing programs. And I just wanted to bring that up because with the arterial resurfacing and the collector street resurfacing, we do larger projects that are longer, and that is to get more out of our dollar, too. So to get more done over a longer period of – a longer project will result in more for the money. Yeah. Okay. Water department. We – essentially, we pick our projects. We just rely on – and the science behind it. So if I were to expand on our water main replacement program, we go with, you know, the oldest water mains, locations where we have the most repair history, things of that nature. And then if we need to coordinate with, you know, another agency, we'll review, you know, our projects. Same thing on the sewer side. You know, if we have aging infrastructure, sewer collapses, we'll rely on the data from, you know, flooded basement reports, any hydraulic modeling that can be done. So we're looking at the science behind it to pick our projects. The science. So we're just looking at, you know, so if I were to, for example, if I look at a particular block of water main, we have a water main that's 100 plus years old. It has a, you know, a fair amount of repair history in a particular valve section. We're going to go ahead and replace it. It doesn't make sense to, you know, keep putting money into repairs. It's just that that water mains, you know, hit the end of its useful life. So we're trying to replace the worst of the worst pipes in our system. All right. And then I guess, and then to add into that curveball, let's service line replacement. So now when we go ahead and replace the water main, we have to replace all the let's service lines along with that project. I'm glad you brought up let's service line. So I have a question for you around let's service lines. We had some hearings on it yesterday to talk about that. But one of the things that was brought to my attention afterwards was that that that the public building commission will take a partial undertaking. Requests from the city of Chicago let's service line replacement program. And that OBM, that the public building commission would get 750 million for let's service replacements. Is that accurate? You know about this? I don't. I can I can research that and get you an answer. I don't know if that has to do with them doing performing project management over a contract or anything like that. But if you'd like, I can I can do the researching and provide you an answer to the chair. That's deputy mayor. I saw you. I see you here. Good afternoon, Lori Lipson, deputy mayor infrastructure, the undertaking that the PBC for the lead service was for program management over 10 years. So it was just the undertaking. So they will have individual projects that they come up. So the public building commission will be project managing. They will help not only project manage, meaning get the procurement out, doing some of the compliance, the workforce initiatives and some of the things that the PBC is known for. But to help on. Hopefully we will get more money for lead service replacement so we can get out a robust program at the same time. And are these funds being used for through GO funds or how was this being? How's that 750 million over the 10 year period being funded? I think it will be a mix of the GO funds. It may be a little of TIFF. It may be a little mixing, a mixed bag of funding. However, no projects have been identified yet. But when they do, they'll report on that. And I can report back to this committee as well. Yeah, I would like to see what that looks like because the 750 million, typically a 750 million dollar fee is 10 percent of the total cost. So this would be a 7.5 billion dollar project. I see how you're looking at it. It would be I'm trying to think of something analogous would be. And this is for the people who have been here for a while. Modern School Across Chicago, when we did a big portfolio of new schools, there was a undertaking for almost, I don't know, 400 million dollars worth of work. And it was the initial thing for PBC to start. And then each undertaking took each project project by project. So it seems like a large amount. But as the program gets identified and detailed out, it will have to go to that board as well. And we can get that information to this committee as well. Yeah, we would. I would like to see that because if there's a mix, if it's city dollars that are being appropriated for capital, we want it to come through this committee so we can track it as well. Yes. And I'm sure you want the workplace and MB and WB numbers. Yeah, that's, you know, yeah. So we'll open it up for, I got some more questions, but I don't want to, it's not just my hearing, so I want to have members as well. Alderman Lopez, Alderman Wagesback, I'm sorry, Alderman Lopez, followed by Alderman Lee. Thank you again, Chairman and members of the committee. Thank you all for being here. Thank you all for being here. The committee on environmental protection and energy, we had a discussion about LSLRs. And the funding question came up and we were told that basically funding for lead service line replacement within the Department of Water Management comes in four different groups. CDBG funds, CDBG funds, which we are still waiting to have our through the chair responses provided to us. We learned of the federal loans, the WFIA loans, which we got in October 2023, totaling $325 million and set to expire and be used by 2026, of which we've only spent $75 million. We heard of water enterprise fund bonds as well as the general obligation bonds from last year, which I believe on this graph says on page, whatever this page is, the one that says 21 through 25 budget authority on bonds. It says here, $100.3 million, we learned yesterday that 72 million in general obligation bonds were executed of May of this year, of which only $5 million have been spent. And that in previous years, the 2023, 2024 budget general obligation bond execution of $60 million, which is listed here on this graph as well, $41.5 million out of $60 million that was executed has been spent. So my question to all of you is that, and is that a correct recapturing of what we discussed yesterday? Yeah. Thank you. So my concern, and my question to all of you is, when we have all of this bonding authority outstanding, and when we see graphs that show $1.4 billion, $1.8 billion, and in this year's budget, $831 million, how is it that we wind up executing bonding authority and not spending all of the money that we are actually borrowing? Most egregiously, the $72 million that we executed this year from our bonding authority, of which only $5 million was spent, and the remaining $67 million is just sitting unassigned in an account somewhere waiting to be spent, upon which we actually have debt service now for money that's not allocated towards anything. How do we wind up in that position? And is that something that is seen and visible in all of your respective bonding authority applications? We're still going to – this is Brendan White, Assistant Commissioner in the Department of Finance. The $72 million for – the $72 million for lead service line replacement that we bonded for in June represents – we're still going to get you the information for what projected period that applies to, but that was expected to fund all of the private side replacement work done through approximately January or February. But as we said, we don't have a list of those locations. It's just what's anticipated, correct? I talked to the Department of Water this morning about that. I believe we're – Well, he's right next to you. So – Yeah, I mean, we do have – it's all allocated. Can you assist them with the microphone? No, we can. If you're looking for a list of locations where we've completed private side-led service replacement, we can provide that information. No, that's not what I'm looking for. The question was, if you are executing $72 million in debt for the taxpayers of the city of Chicago, and in that example, and that's only the water department. I'm asking everybody because all of you access debt for your needs. If you are executing $72 million in general obligation bonds of which you've only identified $5 million in projects, why are you executing the full $72 million? I think – And yesterday, Mr. White, you told me it was to have cash on hand for future projects, correct? So the $5 million just represents money that has gone out the door. It does not represent the full list of projects that we've identified that we intend – that the Department of Water intends to – So you have $72 million in projects that you've identified for this ask? Yes. So you have a full list of projects, a full list of private-led service line replacement asks? Yeah. Well, there are several different programs. There are some of the sort of planned-ahead, block-by-block programs, and then there's also a substantial part that is sort of more of the reactive breaks and leaks program. So we need to be able to have funds on hand for private line replacement as unexpected breaks and leaks can happen, and then when that happens, we have to go in there. Okay. So I feel like we're going to go down this rabbit hole again, and I'm not trying to go down this rabbit hole. I prefer just simple answers. This program is for borrowing for lead service line replacement, not leaks and breaks, right? Not for water main replacement. That's not part of this program, correct? This is the general obligation bond, which covers solely the private connections for lead service line replacement, which is the only money that we can use to do this because we can't use enterprise funds. So do you have $72 million worth of connections set for this year? Yes. Great. Can you provide that list through the chair? Yes. Because I'd love to know how you've been able to get – what is the cost of all of those for a single lead service line replacement, and how many lead service line replacements does that mean from this private program for 2025 that you have confirmed applications for? Do you have that? And I say this, Chairman, because it's my concern that departments are borrowing money to have on hand, not necessarily with any project in hand as well. Well, yesterday we heard that we have a 30% non-response rate from the water department's lead service line replacement. So if we have a 30% non-response rate, but yet we are fully funding $72 million, that means likely you've overborrowed by 30% at this rate based on your own numbers. This assumption does include a certain amount of people who are not participating in private side replacement, and the total amount of replacements being done for the $100 million that were authorized is 7,945 private side replacements, and the amount, roughly comparable amount, that would be covered by the $72 million that we have already borrowed for is about 5,720. I still would like to see all these locations and addresses. Switching gears, Chairman, I want to go back to now CDOT and your request for the larger projects outside of the aldermanic venue. Mr. Higgins, can you describe to me what the CDOT matrix is that decides which streets have to be repaired and what that looks like? The matrix? Yes. As described in my office by your former commissioner and yourself when you were talking about how you assign streets that are not part of the aldermanic menu program, how you make determinations of which of the collector streets, arterial mains, sidewalks, and ADA ramps, what is the CDOT's formula for creating those? The street assessment that we present to you at the CIP briefing? No, I'm talking about the streets that my chairman was referring to when you're doing streets of your own choosing. What is the matrix, as it was referred to, that you guys use as a department to determine which streets and where are the ones that you are funding through the bond program that is housed within your department? I understand. The street quality assessment is one of those points of data that we look at. 311 complaints, complaints from the ward offices, discussions with the ward staff and aldermen, and an assessment of the length of the consistency of the street because, as I was saying to the chairman, we can get more for our money when we do a longer stretch. So that's why those types of projects are typically longer and span a few wards. So I want to add in here. So when you say that you're talking to the alderman and their staff around repaving, you're talking to us with menu money. You're not talking to us with the other 90 percent of capital dollars that this body has appropriated. Is that accurate? Because every time I have a discussion… We're always listening to you and we take… Oh, no. I don't want you to listen to me. I want you to actually spend some of that money, the other 90 percent, that is outside of the menu on some of the issues that people have. So when you say that you're talking to us or you're only talking to us about the menu money at the CIP briefings, and you're giving us recommendations on what it is that we should invest in based on the data from 311 or other sources, whether it's through asset management reports, whether it's old infrastructure, etc., you're not talking to us about anything above and beyond what the menu is. And that's why I requested this hearing is because the 90 percent of the dollars that are being spent on capital, there's not a fruitful discussion with the aldermen who are the appropriators of these funds. And so I'd like for us to have more discussions and action on what it is that the requests are within the neighborhoods. So when you're saying you're talking to us, you're only talking to us about the menu money. I mean, I think we are talking to you about all of it. It's a project that makes sense to be through the menu program, a single block of residential street. Yeah. We also listen to you when you're describing issues on an arterial street. And we look at that and take that into consideration when we're selecting arterial street resurfacing. Okay. Well, again, there's more questions, though. I'm sorry to hijack Alderman Lopez and then followed by Alderman Lee. Oh, of course. Yeah. Thanks. Just while we're on the subject of the when we have these CIP meetings, and I know, so, you know, Bill, you sat through the last couple that I've had. And it wasn't just, to be fair, it was not just menu that we talked about. You presented, CDOT presented its recommendations for capital improvement work that would be done in the world. I think what we're trying to get to is just how do you arrive at that? How does 311 information or 311 requests, service requests, play into how CDOT ultimately selects which projects it's going to take on? I mean, I think we can all agree, excuse me, there's more need than there are resources. At the end of the day, I think part of what we're trying to get to is just how those decisions are made. You know, I haven't necessarily disagreed with the ones that y'all have made for me necessarily in 11, but I also, you know, share some of the frustration about, you know, in my first meeting, when I was first appointed, there was a collector street that was supposed to be done. The work, I think, is supposed to start this year now, but that was three years ago. And when we issue bonds for different projects, this is back to water for a second, when we still have bonding authority from previous bonds, this is one of the things that I raised last year when the GEO bond was approved. I didn't support it because we had a billion dollars left in bond authority. You know, I would really love to understand what are the decision points? Brenda, maybe you can help with this. I mean, we want to get to keep it happening in our next place. I said, what was that? um as to when we use prior um bond authority that we have left versus new bond authority because all of this is debt we're taking out at whatever point it is um and i think that's i don't want to speak for you ray but i think that's what i'm taking away from what we're trying to just better understand yeah um uh i think that's a good point and i agree that um if it was just bonding authority then i agree we would have been no need to um come back and ask for further authorization given that we have already authorized bonding authority but the way that these ordinance are written is that they include both bonding authority and spending authority so um the so for the the projects that we're talking about here that make up the 830 million a lot of those projects need the spending authority for the various departments to start working on their contracting and procurement for those various projects and that will take there's a more of a lead time for when we um are actually going to issue the bonds to fund those because we we try to uh for most of our projects we um bond on a reimbursement basis so the city uh uh self-finances with available cash on hand for most of our general infrastructure projects um but because uh so a lot of that uh 1 billion that you mentioned in unused bonding authority a lot of that is tied to specific projects that are working their way through the procurement process and on the way to eventually spending and eventually being bonded for um the exception in this particular bond was that the lead service line replacement program where we just looked ahead for the next six months or so had all of our programs that we need knew we needed to get funds so we and we didn't need uh a lot of new procurement uh hoops to jump through so we decided to we're probably going to be funding most of the rest of the projects of the 830 million on a reimbursement basis but in order to have funds available for the lead service line replacement program specifically we decided to just do a look ahead for the next six months or so um just with that particular component so um we're continuing to use the the the unused bond authority is spending authority that's in the process of um actually spending um and we'll issue bonds when uh the money actually goes out the door so if we think of projects going like a bridge project let's say is going to take three years to complete in that first year you might you might issue bonds for whatever you think you're going to need just for that are you estimating then in that year i guess the way i want to ask this if the project you think is going to take 10 million dollars in funds over the course of three years you're asking for that three that 10 million in that year's bond bond authority yes uh yeah so for instance some of the the bridge bridge projects that are included in the bond that was approved in may some of those may not actually spend for another couple years but we also are not bonding for that until we get to the point where we spend so um we're always doing a little bit of catch-up so we did uh the bonds that we sold in june included the 72 million for roughly the next six months of lead service line replacement but it also included spending authority going back to 2020 2021 bonding authority 2023 bonding authority the chicago recovery plan like older bond ordinance authorities can you through the chair provide um a list of all outstanding bonding authority that we have remaining however old it is just by year i'm just curious as to what we've got left sitting out there um alderman lee let me get lopez to finish and then we'll get back to you oh yeah then after that alderman cruz sorry she's my neighbor i'm used to it it's okay um but great questions and actually to piggyback off where alderman lee left was and to where you left chairman the question about where all of the the non-menu cip direction comes from and when we met and discussed this because there were streets collectors and other things that were going on in my ward that c dot notified me of in one year and took away in the next at the direction of the administration or that we had a fight because they were irrelevant because of street condition because the streets were fine in one area and bad in another but it was a decision made to be more helpful potentially to my aldermanic neighbors as opposed to the actual residents so i think that's the question that we're all trying to get to and if you'd like me to refresh your memory you could look at the street where you're trying to do on 50th street which was perfectly fine and not in need of anything while streets and back of the yards which were on schedule were ignored those are the kinds of things that i think all of us have questions about which is when city council gives c dot the authority and the funding ability to do projects how are we not consulted for these larger scale projects that impact us we're leaving it up to the whim of the commissioner and the will of the administration where to do things in our city and it's creating a hodgepodge network of infrastructure replacements nowhere is there more evident chairman and if you look at western avenue just south of pershing where brand new lighting was installed with poles damn near on top of each other just so that we could get the mix in before 42nd street which at that time was the 15th ward you see this more and more and i'm not going to say this started with this administration but it hasn't ended with this administration either so i think that's what we're trying to figure out how that is possible when it comes to all of that additional c dot funding i also want to now turn to fleet and facilities management with regards to the equipment that we have particularly when it comes to non-cpd when we look at for example streets and sanitation under the previous administration we issued a one point something or other billion dollar infrastructure bond which was meant to upgrade our fleets and we ended up buying a lot of compressed natural gas trucks with window handles that people had to do manually which some people have never seen in their entire life where are we in terms of one upgrading our fleet two are we purchasing or leasing because my understanding is that we're doing more leasing than purchasing which is worrisome that we're borrowing to lease um three what is the maintenance schedule on all of our garbage trucks in particular our older trucks because we've known and seen what uh how cfd and we know that uh other departments are having equipment issues but we also know that streets and sand has its fair share when we have leaking seals and things of that nature that especially as we saw on the southwest side with the flooding as garbage was compressed i had that disgusting smell from western to harlem just because the trucks were squeezing all the water out so if you could talk to us as to is there a schedule for replacement repair what are we doing in terms of all of those other fleet vehicles sure and good i'm gonna add also for cpd we buy cpd vehicles all the time i'm very happy about that but i also hear that they get into one accident and we could literally have just bought them in a year and we're already scrapping them is that true as well and can you touch on that all right i'll start with the refuse trucks so we do have a plan together we have a five-year capital plan that we put in place and presented so we have a five-year capital plan that we have in place uh utilizing the money that we have designated for streets and sanitation and we try to buy um as many refuse trucks as we can without just taking that whole bond and throwing it for refuse um we try to do a recommendation based on other municipalities is what you know what their life cycle is i think a life cycle for a refuse truck right now typical replacement age is about 10 years on a refuse truck but our trucks really are getting a workout i'm not going to lie to that about 20 years old in some cases they are um so yes we are we are working to replace them we have gotten 30 30 new refuse trucks coming in this year we just received the three new electric refuse trucks it'll be that are out there um that we're going to be working with and hopefully moving towards some alternative uh means with the electric refuse trucks so we are we are working to replace them the best we can with the money we have i'd love to replace more of them but we're just going to trucks do we have in service you Actually, you know what, can you do me a favor? Can you just provide through the chair how many we have existing in service and what the scheduled replacement plan is? Sure, across all topics that I just asked about. No, absolutely. Thank you. So we are going to replace those. We do have a preventative maintenance program, which we go through every time the truck is reaching somewhere around 400 gallons of used fuel. We would like to schedule that truck in to get it in for maintenance. We're doing the best we can. We're getting that handled with the amount of services that Streets and Sand is out there providing. So, and now you asked about police vehicles. Yes, we do have a big number of police vehicles that have been purchased over the past few years, and you are correct. In some cases, a good hard hit on the front end of a vehicle can total out a vehicle. The cost of the repairs are just astronomical. As you know, these vehicles are designed to protect the passengers, okay? So all that energy that's absorbed in an impact is taken in on that front end or the back end of the vehicle, which causes extensive damage to the vehicle's computer systems. In the newer cases, the hybrid systems, frame rails that are damaged, and there's an extremely high cost. Unfortunately, in some cases, the cost to repair the vehicle outweighs the value of the vehicle at that point. Can you share with us, or through the chair, what the annual replacement costs or damage costs have been, or total losses, I guess we would call them, for the last three years have been from CPD and its vehicles? Sure. And we are self-insured, which means we own good, bad, or ugly, correct? You are correct. Okay. And the cost of a vehicle is going up, especially when we upfit it with everything that's in there. The cost is pretty substantial. The lighting, the prisoner partitions, the police officer's computer system or deck system. So that's pretty costly also. I have one other question, Chairman, for 2FM, if I may. Yes. And forgive me if it's not relevant, but I'm going to ask anyway. 2FM operates a solar plant past Grundy County, correct? I don't believe. Or finance? Finance, how did we build the solar plant? Unfortunately, I can't answer that question, Alderman. Perhaps our deputy mayor. Lori Lipson, deputy mayor of infrastructure. What we did, we partnered with them to make sure that we received their utilities from there. We didn't help build, per se. We're getting the benefit of the solar panels through our utility spend, if that makes sense. They being who? Black. Black diamond. Diamond. Thank you. Ah, so you are familiar. Okay. Oh. So my understanding is that this began under the previous administration. I vaguely remember a conversation at 9 o'clock at night during budget hearings about this. I also understand that this was a multi-million dollar venture out in the far suburbs. So if you could provide us what financial support or resources we spent out there, as well as whatever the agreement is, because I don't think most people fully understand that Chicago basically has its own solar farm out there with our partners. So we'd like to deal with that more and see if the funds, bonds, or however we built, whatever we built, has given us a ROI that is commensurate with what we thought we were going to get. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Alderman Lopez. Alderman Lee, followed by Alderman Wagesback. Oh, back to 11. I know. It's like ping-pong. Almost like we're back in the neighborhood, Ray. Let me get back to some of my questions. Can we talk about bridge and bidoc program for a second? I think I missed it earlier. Bill, how many bridges does the 68.1 million bridge replacement cover? We're covering eight bridges. And full bridge replacement, that's 68.1, and advanced, including their advanced design. Okay, so that's eight, and then it's eight for bridge repairs. Yes, and that's $30 million for bridge repair. Okay. And additional funds come from, does this include bridges like Western Avenue and Halstead that are getting TIF dollars as well? I am not 100% sure. I would have to double-check that. Okay. If you wouldn't mind, just through the chair providing that information, what I'd like to see is side-by-side. All of the bridge work, whether that's repairs or replacement, that CDOT is undertaking in the funding sources, whether it's bond money, TIF money, or federal or state dollars that are coming along with that. I know we've got, I'm sorry, $825,000 for underpass rehabilitations. That's rehabilitation work to two underpasses. Where are those two? I don't have that information. I can get that through the chair. Okay, I think there's going to be a bunch of through the chairs right now. Sorry. We've got a lot of underpasses in this city. Why are we only doing two? I'm going to read you all my questions here. Why are we only doing two? What are the railroads doing? And if they are doing any work, can you provide a list of the viaducts that they're working on? I know that, like, the Norfolk Southern has done some work in my ward that completed earlier in the spring. Ultimately, are you talking two underpasses, like the grade separations? I'm not sure what this is. So it says underpasses. So this is under bridge and viaduct work. So I'm just trying to understand what the 825 covers. So I wanted to know the locations. But because this is also the viaduct program, I wanted to know how many viaducts we're monitoring. The other question really is, how do we monitor that? I get lots of questions in the 11th Ward from constituents who get very worried walking through some of these viaducts where they can see through the uprights. It doesn't mean that it's not structurally sound. But, you know, if you're walking through and you can kind of see through some of the uprights, it doesn't feel really good. And I know that it's because it's we have a weird, not a weird division, but it's not solely the city's responsibility. Right. So I believe that the curbs, the sidewalks, and the roadway are ours, but the walls and the bridge itself are the responsibility of the railroads. And then sometimes you don't even realize that it's like it could be three or four separate bridges through one viaduct. So it would be helpful just to get a better understanding of how that tracks. I know it might not be you. I know just Streets and Sands does a lot of liaising with the railroads, but it is something that I think I know I would be interested in. I think some of my colleagues would be as well. Sure thing. I'll get the scope of those two projects as well as the location. But you're exactly right that the structure itself and the walls are typically the owner, which is the railroad. And the lights in the viaducts are ours as well. Right. See that. I don't know that we fully got this question answered earlier, so I'll just ask it again. How do 311 requests get incorporated into capital improvements? Is that part of the discussion when you're? Absolutely. We do extensive analysis of the 311 data. As I mentioned before, we are taking extensive notes. We have an internal request management system that we enter comments in when we're talking to the wards, when we're talking in public meetings with folks, and any opportunity that we get in addition to 311 to add to that data as well. I will mention, too, that as many of you know, we've transitioned from the terminology of word menu liaison to just a general CDOT liaison, and it's for that specific purpose that we can go beyond just the menu program and communicate better on all these issues. I just want to add that when we have our CIP meetings, most of the time that you see lights out or potholes, those are 311 requests that are inputted. So sometimes, like, and Alderman Moore is like, well, why isn't this coming up? I get a lot of calls on that. But we'll say, well, we got a lot of calls 311. Yeah. So when you get those maps, it includes all that data in one. The other thing that I just wanted to add is that we also have projects in development, and what we don't want to do is sometimes we'll say, why isn't this project happening along a thoroughfare, but we know there's a project coming. So it's no point in putting in new streets, and you're going to have a developer tear it back up as we build. So Department of Housing, DPD projects are also included in some of those majors as part of the projects that are coming on board. So I just wanted to make a holistic thought. On things that are coming on board. Sometimes you realize, like, why aren't they doing that? There's a project coming, but we don't want to do something and then have to they tear it up to do it again. Understood. Thank you. I think all my questions are covered for right now. Chairman, thank you. Thank you. I see that one more question. I got more, but this one more question. WPA streets. Yes. Where are we at with with those? Because those are supposed to be my understanding. It was two per ward. I'm not mistaken. It's part of the capital bill. And I have not seen those anywhere line item three or marked. I'll get that to the chair. I don't have that information in front of me. Are you familiar with the WPA streets? And I am. Yeah. Agreement. Yeah. OK. Yeah. I just I don't know the data and how much has been spent and how many have been done. OK. Thank you. Alderman Wagesbeck. Follow Alderman. Alderman Moore. Yeah, of course. Go ahead. Can you provide Alderman Moore microphone? I don't know if my staff have reached out, but if you can follow up on that 71st and Central Park to 74th, because we did the groundbreaking on there. The press was out there. When I say groundbreaking, it was verbal and they were supposed to start tearing it up that same week. And it didn't happen. And now we're almost in wintertime. And so I think Tom came out there, I think, a week before he retired. And I was out there the other day and my neighbors got in my behind good and said, you said this. They were going to get started on this within the week. And not nothing was torn up. And I got it. I can't ask. I got an answer to them. Alderman Moore. I understand. Go ahead. I have a update. That contract just passed at the PBC board meeting last month. So I'll make sure they get you an update on that as well. Thank you. Thank you, Tim. Thanks, Chairman. And I appreciate you doing this hearing because actually just listening, it's prompted a lot of other questions, but I'll save a lot of those for budget. Even as I was sitting here, people were sending me pictures of streets that were being torn up shortly after they've been repaved earlier this summer for other infrastructure to go in. And that is extremely frustrating for any constituent to see their tax dollars being wasted around the city. Actually, I'm glad people are watching, though. Just a couple of questions. You know, again, on the Metro stuff, on the Metro UP, we see persistent damage caused by Metro and UP rails and a lot of other rails throughout the city. And I kind of want to know, like, what kind of pressure do we put on them? Serious pressure to say, if the alderman has to repave the street three times under a Metro bridge, why aren't you guys asking for funding or pressuring them to pay for some of that? And it goes to the drainage in those, too, where the sewers are damaged, the roads are damaged, and people are saying, Alderman, you have to pay for it out of your menu, which is coming directly out of the bond money. So to the broader question, what conversations do you have in each department with other bonding authorities to tap into their funding for things like CPS asked? You know, we had that issue where we wanted the CPS phraseology removed from that bond deal because we weren't sure what was going to happen with those funds. But CHA, parks, Metro, and other jurisdictions, how do we approach them, and how aggressively do we approach them to start paying their fair share? Because, you know, people come to us, CPS, and I'm happy to do it, but CPS says, I want a new field. Parks say, I want a new field. The alderman are required to pay a third of that, essentially. Community group raises a third, and then CPS picks up a little bit of the bill, or parks. How are we pushing back now, especially now that we have, for instance, an elected school board that should be doing their own lift? I'll take the easiest one first. That was a lot of questions. Yeah, that's all right. I think our conversations with the railroad, we continue to try to have a conversation. Even before this administration, the railroads do what they want to do. They don't feel pressure. We have asked them for multiple things, whether it be safety, bidocs, lighting, and not to say it falls on empty ears, but we have been trying. Their usual answer is we're the railroad, and we have federal immunity, and they continue to do what they want to do. So that's the easiest we're trying. We don't have really a lot of leverage over the railroads. I know a couple alder people have had some success with talking to them, but often it is on ears that may not be acceptable to hear some things. Your second question about other municipal agencies, whether that be CPS and parks, I think with our renewed conversation about TIF has been helpful and really thoughtful about those projects and how we're doing things. I think as we move forward next year, we have a different conversation, because you are right. There's different pressure points from each. You might be getting information on one side, hearing from DPD from the other, and it may be all in the four-block radius as part of a larger development. And so I know Sierra Commissioner Boat Rights Team has really been working on that from a DPD perspective to make sure that we're looking at things holistically instead of in isolation. Sometimes those happen because there's different grants. They might get a DCO grant and they need to spend. They might get space that grows through MWRD and they need to spend that money quickly. So some of those things counteract each other and including state money, right? So we might get a list of all the bills that come out, and then we need to get on board and say, hey, we need to spend this money and time. So I know that didn't answer your question thoroughly. It's a complex, like, matrix of things that are in consideration. I hope that is helpful. Deputy Mayor, I would also ask if – I know that local government has a hard time with rails. However, they are regulated under the ICC, and so perhaps it warrants a discussion with our state legislative partners and then also under the Surface Transportation Board under the federal government. It may be an opportunity to speak to our Illinois delegation as well to see what type of investments. I know that the CREATE project, which is a PPP, it may be worth taking a look at how we address these VIDEX. Thanks. And, Chairman, just a quick speed round for each department, if you can. When it comes to warranties, so, you know, if my phone breaks, I can go back and try to get something out of my car or whatever it is. And I've heard over the years a little bit of, well, you know, we try to go back to, say, a private contractor who repaved a road. You know, if I spend $50,000 on a road and three months or six months or a year later, I start to see those huge dips where they didn't do it appropriately. Or a sewer or maybe a vehicle, you know, a sealer didn't work or something like that. How aggressive are each of your departments to go back after that to say, this is, you know, bond money that we spent on this and we want our money back? Or not our money back, but just warranty on those issues. Start with streets and sand. It's as simple as we take the vehicle back to the, you know, the purchasing agent. All right. Mark Chapoulos with fleet management. So what we do, we do work with all of our manufacturers, Ford, Freightliner, all the refuse, the company that builds the refuse box. We work with them within their time frame warranty. We do get warranty recovery from them if we don't have them do the warranty repairs themselves. Thank you. From a facility standpoint, we get a one-year warranty from the contractor, which we pursue. And then we receive warranties from the manufacturers, which are standard. We prepare closeout binders at the end of each project, which are delivered to our facility operations team. And we collaborate if there's any pending issues in the future to make sure we get satisfaction from those warranties. And it's just one year for your? For the contractor, general contractor warranty. Warranty is one year, but manufacturers' warranty vary, and different systems have different warranties. Roofing, you can purchase extended warranties, but generally one year is the general contractor's warranty. Wow, okay. I can speak to that to CDOT, too. We do extensive testing of our contractors' concrete, for instance, and on numerous occasions, if it hasn't come up to meet our standards, they have to go back out and on their own dime replace that. But also, trees, all the trees we plant are under a two-year warranty, so if they die, the tree provider will replace them. So we follow up on that quite a bit. Yeah, I think for viewers, trees fall under bonded funding, right? I mean, we basically borrow to pay for tree plantings. So, okay. How about water, if you don't mind? Yeah, for water, it's a one-year warranty. And we've had workmanship issues in the past with our private contractors, so we've hit them. They've gone out. They've done repairs at their cost. And there's been, whenever it gets into an argument and they refuse and it poses an emergency or a health risk or anything like that, we'll just send our crews out. We'll go ahead and take care of it ourselves, and we'll backcharge the contractor for that work. Okay. All right. Thank you very much. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Alderman. Welcome back. Alderman Cruz. Thank you, Chairman. I just want to also go back to Alderman Lopez' comment earlier regarding the criteria of the streets. When it comes to, like, how do you determine one of the collector's streets, for example, for capital improvement? I know you talked about different items, but one of them that it seems that we're having a hard time is you're saying with discussion with the alderman. And during one of my CIP briefings, we talked about some of the streets, and I'm like, how do you come out with these collective streets? Because the ones that have been recommended are not really in bad shape. I have really other bad streets, and I have given names. And I was told, you're not allowed to change them. And if you don't want this street, you will lose your street to get resurfaced, which I think that was really unfair to say, you either take what we give you or you get nothing at the end of the day. And we just went on with whatever was given to us. So I think that's where we're having a really hard time accepting that as an answer. And I do want to see what is that criteria, what happens when we give a different suggestion, because that's the answer that I received during one of my briefings. It may have been that the streets that you were concerned with didn't qualify as a collector's street. There's a specific definition. No, it was. It was just like, you just have to wait. We already gave you what we selected. You just have to wait. And if you don't want to get resurfaced, you won't get an extra one. You won't be able to change the plan. You just lose that collector's street that you're getting. And also, again, that street was not bad at all. I mean, it was for a condition compared to others. And we talked about the other one, and it is a collective street. But, again, I wasn't able to get it. And I think that it's really unfair. So we're talking about discussion with the aldermen. When that did happen, I did not get the support that I needed at that time. Okay, I'm not familiar with that particular case, but we can touch on that in the next CIP briefing. And, you know, I'm going to be coordinating that for this coming year. So we'll. Yeah. So I'm just, again, we're just asking for that information to be sent. Thank you. Alderman Cardona. Thank you, Chairman. This is for Fleet. You talked about electricity. Do we have any. Is Fleet looking into putting electric. You call it garbage. Garbage trucks out there. Or I know, did you guys invest in electric police cars as well or vehicles, period? All right. To answer your question, yes, we are looking at electric refuse trucks. We have purchased three of them. We just received them within the last two months. They're going to be in streets and sanitation. They're going to be utilizing those and providing feedback to us as to how, you know, how they're operating during a daily basis. So the answer to the electric refuse trucks is yes. We also looked at plug-in hybrid sweepers. We did get one of those. We are in the process of working with streets and sanitation and getting that out there to see how that operates to provide some efficiencies there. As for an electric police car, the answer is no at this time. Police vehicles are required 24-7 to be out there working in most cases. Unfortunately, with an electric vehicle, you know, you would need to have that vehicle down for recharging, you know, to build up the useful life of the vehicle. So when the technology or if there's something else out there for police vehicles, we will definitely be looking at that. And then let's see, facilities again. How about all the ward yards that are dismantling or our firehouses? I know we have to invest back into them because there's times when things are happening in the firehouses or in the police stations. It takes a while for them to get fixed. Have you kind of fixed the process of that to speed it up, or is it still the same? Thank you for the question. Yes, we are actively working on multiple firehouses in the portfolio right now. We're collaborating directly with their logistics and facilities management team to, again, prioritize those high-level key issues and address them at the forefront, while still going after the other issues that are needing to be addressed, such as mechanical items, envelopes, masonry, and roofing. Okay. And I also add that we did a lot pre-DNC, especially for the police stations, a lot of police hardening, and we're moving towards some OSHA requirements as well for police and fire, along with the ADA. Are we still trying to get new firetrucks, or are we still, like, fixing them because some firetrucks are breaking down? And we're asking if – I know the costs. Did you guys allocate costs for getting new firetrucks? Firetrucks? So, we have, what is it, 41 fire vehicles on order right now. Not all of them are firetrucks. We do have ladder trucks and pumpers on order. We have 20 ambulances that will be coming in soon. But the timeframe to get those is anywhere from 24 to 36 months based on the order. And the firetrucks that we utilize are built specifically for Chicago Fire Department spec. Okay. Chairman, I'm done. Thank you, Alderman Cardona. Alderman Lopez, what a point of information. What's the Chicago specification? Is it like a Chicago hot dog? Yeah, no ketchup on it. You know what? Chicago Fire Department, you know, they utilize certain volume pumps, and it's going to be specific to what they need for their uses. It could be pump size, gallon per minute flow. It can also be compartment sizes, ladder lengths, items like that, cabin, you know, cabin tiers. Okay. Thank you. Alderman, Mona Hoppenworth. Hi. Thank you, Chair. I just had a couple clarifying questions. Under Fleet and Equipment, it says $10.6 million for CFD bunker gear. I was curious, what does that entail? I've seen that on your presentation. That would have to be answered by CFD. That does not come through to FM. Okay. Go ahead. Usually, there's a space in the front where the fire people take on and off their gear, and there's exhaust and different things, you have to have a separation from where their sleeping quarters are. And so, some of the things that have to be upgraded, especially for our aging facilities, have to have that separation between sleeping headquarters and where their gear and the fumes are coming. And so, that's part of, I believe, the 10.6 for the CFD bumper gear. Thank you. And then the $7 million for public safety cameras, does that – can you speak on that also? Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Most of those cameras are through OPSA, which are through OEMC, CPD, and CFD. But all of those are typically what we want to be integrated in the OEMC system. Yeah, I just want to put a plug in for an upgrade of those pod cameras. I just don't, I am not convinced that they're helping our detectives actually do their job. So that's a good point. There's some pod cameras that only go in one direction. And so they're making it, what's the correct term, 360, available to be 360 instead of just a stagnant area. It's able to move. Some cameras are just old. Like, remember, we used to have CCTV, CCT. And as cameras, just like your phone, upgrade, we're trying to upgrade there. So there's some cameras that are aged out, let's call it. Okay. And then the, I had a question about, again, about the sweepers. I had a question, maybe you can answer. Are there sweepers specific to each ward? Does each ward have their own sweepers? There are 50 sweepers throughout the city. The sweepers, they're usually, I'm going to say down maybe four or five every day. So when the streets and sand comes out, sometimes they might have to do two wards instead of one. But those sweepers, there's not one quote unquote a sign, but there are 50 sweepers. Your ward soup usually puts in requests and lets your neighborhood know that this is when street sweeping occurs. What happens with the street sweepers, especially around this time, and Mark could give a little more explanation, the wet leaves in that sweet sweeper messes up the mechanics. So they're down all, up and down all the time. And if the pavement's wet, but I'm sure there's a more robust explanation than what I'm saying on the maintenance, on the maintenance. No, Deputy Mayor, you got it. You nailed it. And it is. A sweeper was basically designed to pick up light dust and debris, some light leaves, things that were along the curb, cleaning the gutters of a curb. But when we do get into a heavy fall or heavy leaf season, those wet leaves get up in there and clog the chutes, added water and debris. You know, as the water's mixed with the dirt, it turns to a mud and cake. And it affects all the mechanicals that are inside the sweeper. It affects the brooms, more wear and tear on the brooms than everything else. And then does every ward get their own bike lane sweeper also? That would have to be a CDOT question. Yeah, CDOT maintains the bike lane sweepers. I do not – I know we don't have 50 of them. No. I believe we only have 10 right now. Yeah, that's – We only have 10 right now for CDOT. Got it. And then do we have plans to extend street sweeping to later on in the year? Since it seems like the weather is getting warmer and stage warmer. If the weather permits. But what also happens, it's not only debris in the area. There's also rocks, dirt. And so the ward soup tries to make sure we do both. But we try not to go over that time because that's when our salt and snow program comes. We don't want to pull salt one day and then try to sweeper. It'll mess up the mechanics again. So once the seasons change, unfortunately, in Chicago, it might snow and then it might be summer the next day. But once the program in Streets and Sand tries to stick with the day that – before it turns winter, winter. I guess that's the best way to explain it. Okay. I had – through the chair because I don't – nothing is itemized. But I just want to be on top of the pedestrian hybrid beacon that my community has been asking for for 30 years. It's on Ridge and Wayne. And so I know it's got to be coordinated with IDOT, but I hope to see that in progress. I know that there has been a lot of movement in the ward, especially with the sewer replacement, the lead line replacement. That with DWM was a grand effort. And so I thank CDOT and DWM for working together to wrap that up. But I did have a question about – because I know the city has been under – charged with improving ADA accessibility, especially to and from the train stations and transit. And so is that factored into this budget here? Yes, it is. Oh, thank you. Well, that's – part of the automatic menu section, that $33 million that's for supplemental work, part of that goes to ADA as ADA issues come up. Also, the arterial street resurfacing program, which isn't always capital. It's also state funds and other funding, always replaces any ADA ramp that we touch that needs to be upgraded to be. Okay. And regarding the menu program, it looks like it was – I mean, from this – it looks like the budget was – it's cut. Is it not cut? It's – it's – in 23, 24, it was 216, and then 25, it's 108 for the automatic menu. That's just the difference between a two-year authorization and a one-year authorization. So for this particular bond authorization, we only ask for one year of projects. I think probably next time we come and ask for authorization, we'll go back to the two-year standard. Thank you. That's all I have. Thanks, Chair. Thanks, everyone. Thank you, Audra Manahopinworth. Do we have a list of all the deferred maintenance, what that total amount is, whether it's facilities, whether it's bridges, any deferred maintenance, what that cost is? You could provide that through the Chair. And then as it relates to facilities, if you could send through the Chair the number of vacant properties and their addresses, I'd be curious to see if there's an opportunity to leverage some of the buildings that are in, like, really good locations in order to monetize that. And then have we thought about also potentially leasing back? Is it cheaper to lease or to own our facility? Depends. We're laughing because we had a meeting about this this morning. I wasn't in the meeting. Yeah. Generally speaking, it's more cost-effective for us to own. What happens with leases, sometimes the landlord, we still have to do work because the landlord may not be improving that facility or maintaining that facility as we need them to. There are some facilities that we have brought back online and that we're looking at now for other departments that are expanding. And we're trying to co-locate some additional departments in some of our facilities instead of leasing because some of the leases, as you vote on them, are getting astronomical. The costs are getting... Even at a time where there's vacancies downtown and some of these commercial properties are vacant, they're still trying... Who would think? Okay. You would think. There's some places, but as staff contracts and expands, we don't want to be locked in leases that we don't have people there. And that has happened. We have facilities, like I said, that need work. And that's what we have a couple meetings on recently. And I think part of this budget exercise to make sure that we're using our useful space collectively, we're taking a look at all our big places. There's a couple of buildings, as you mentioned, that would be primed for us probably to purchase so we can get rid of more leases and just be housed under one. And so we're looking across the board as part of our budget thoughts, Fred, as budget comes into play. And I think that given the discounts that we're seeing throughout the city on properties that... This may be an opportunity to take a look at it. Second thing is, I think over a decade ago, BMO had did a triple P with acquiring properties and then leasebacks. Yeah, I think any private partnerships that we might be able to do or leverage those that weren't successful and maybe now that building has vacancy, we can do. And I think we have good, strong relationships, especially with Deputy Mayor Merritt and BOMA to work on those things. Gotcha. Thank you. And then finance, if you could provide through the chair a list of all the funding sources for capital. I think Lee had mentioned it. I just want to make sure. So whatever capital projects we're doing, how are we paying for them? I believe in the published CIP, there is a funding source identified for every individual project in the published CIP, including bond funded, whether geo or aviation, plus every other source of funding that is included in the capital improvement program. Okay. If you could just point my staff to it and then we'll send it through that. I appreciate it. Alderman Lopez. Thank you, Chairman. Just one quick, two quick things. One from CDOT, if you could provide through the chair the number of streets per ward as well as the amount of non-aldermanic dollars spent on street improvements per ward for years 2024 and as of 2025, today's program date. I'd appreciate it. I actually want to thank our Deputy Mayor for being here today. It's been a fun day of seeing you do the lightning round with us. But I wanted to ask you a question with regards to what I just asked CDOT for and your thoughts dealing with infrastructure for this administration. We all know, and I actually had a conversation with a group of young individuals this morning before coming here. We know that the aldermanic menu is 1.5 million times 50, but we also know that there are wards that have fewer streets versus more streets that need resurfacing repair and assistance. The fact that the 43rd ward has the same amount of money as, say, the 20th ward, which is basically two wards in one, would make it almost impossible to address the issues in some of these wards that are overpopulated in streets while being held back by the same amount of menu dollars for those issues. Do you have any thoughts on us looking at an equitable addition to the menu that would be able to say that you have a baseline operating menu of X? And then as we look at other wards that have higher needs but no other additional funding sources such as TIF or what have you, that we could actually borrow in addition four aldermanic equitable menu options. So, for example, Alderman Beal or Chico, who've got, you know, 500 miles of road that they're never going to get to in 100 years, that they would be able to tap into a select pool of funds beyond the aldermanic menu to try to help uplift some of those communities. No, I think, first of all, thank you for laying it out the way you did. I think that there's a couple of things that we've really been working through. Unfortunately, our budget has just been so tight. But in 2024, at the beginning of the year, CDOT, Warder came together and really looked at some of the things that we were doing. And like you said, looked at the projects, just looked at the map in general, not looking at ward, what all needs to be done. And that's what we try to do during CIP. Like, let's look at it holistically. I tell them put everything, throw everything on the map. That's why you see lines everywhere and try to explain to the electeds, hey, I understand this is bad. There's actually really bad ones right down the street. I know it's not in your ward, but we're going to try to make that happen has been more difficult to do. Our general funds, the 92% that you keep talking about, is our attempt to do that. There are really bad streets, and they may be concentrated in one ward, and it may be looked upon like, oh, my God, they're doing extra favors. But, no, they're really bad, or they had a lot of ward domain leaks, and all those streets are being resurfaced. So I think part of it is our ability to communicate that to you better. And I think, actually, this hearing was actually very hopeful to get a lot of those questions out. It would be helpful. However, it's difficult in our financial situation now. However, we try to do the best we can. The other thing we're looking at is our OUC, Office of Underground Utility, working better with people's gases, you know, working better with ComEd, working better to see what projects are in line so we don't do a lot of back and forth, and we know what's happening in the future. It's also helpful. But I'm certainly open to the idea of what you put forth. I think that other bucket of money will just be difficult to get in these times. However, looking at Chicago in general, I think is a great approach instead of saying, you know, as you said, Chico, Mosley have three times bigger wards. It's with the same amount of dedicated funds, and we try to look at it that way. And like I said, using DPD's data, Department of Housing, all those things come together as we try to make it more equitable. So you mentioned that you had come together and put a map with water and CDOT? That's your CIP. That's that big map. So what is the total cost of? Oh, Lord. How about this? Can you provide the citywide map, not the aldermanic one, the citywide map and the total cost of all repairs? Yeah, deferred maintenance. Yeah. All the city's maintenance, basically, for streets. Because I would say that the city of Chicago borrowed once already $1.4 billion, I think, under the Lightfoot Administration for Investment and Infrastructure. Chairman, correct me if I'm wrong. Bought a whole bunch of trees and a whole bunch of bad trucks. We've also, I think, talked about doing an infrastructure, or you may have just done one, if I'm not mistaken, under this administration. But I think it was the $800 and something million we just did. The $830. $830. But if we're looking at citywide issues to address those issues, I think the number one complaint that we hear is that we've heard it numerous times. None of us know what the big picture is. None of us have been able to connect the dots in a way that makes sense. And it's hard when you have, outside of today, an administration that doesn't tell you what the big picture is, to trust that the big picture is this. We know it would be cheaper if we focused on doing big things as opposed to one block here, one block here, one block here. But if we can't see it and we don't feel it, we're not going to believe it. So I think that being able to see what that looks like might be a way to do what we all do in a ward level, which is tell our voters, look, we see the picture for the ward. We just have to trust that we're managing as best we can. But now we have to figure that out on a citywide scale. So I think hopefully we can get that information and perhaps, Chairman, come back as a follow-up to see because I think that there's going to be billions of dollars in deferred action that needs to be happening. And I will also tie this in, and I'm sorry Chairman Dahl isn't here to hear it. We are making lawsuit settlements now, switching gears from CPD to CDOT and other departments because our maintenance of our streets, our sidewalks, our bike lanes are now causing lawyers to sue us a quarter of a million dollars at a time. So that's going to be the next major hit that we take if we don't come up with a citywide strategic plan. So love to have that conversation here, Chairman, so we could get on top of it and keep the citywide conversation moving in the right direction. Thank you. Thank you. Yeah, and I started off the hearing with reading the excerpt from our rules as it relates to what our committee is charged with. And so moving forward, I've talked to Chairwoman Dahl as well that as it relates to actually going to finance the bond things, that the – that the origination of the request comes from the capital program because the Economic Capital and Technology Committee, per our rules, we are the ones that decide in collaboration with our departments as to what the projects are, then it goes to finance to fund. It doesn't go to finance first and then we figure out what we need to fund. There needs to be input from the aldermen as it relates to capital. At the end of the day, we're the ones who are ultimately having to cast a vote to pay for capital and we want to make sure that we can go back to our residents and say how we're paying for this, you're actually seeing the improvements. So it's very important that we have that. So I really appreciate – I want to echo what my colleagues said around. Deputy Mayor, pleasure to see you here. It's always a pleasure to see you. But with that, if there are no more questions from the – Can I get a point of clarification from Alderman Lopez? What was the – through the chair you requested, number of streets per ward that were resurfaced? Oh, the length of streets? Okay. The total number of streets. Yeah, I've got that for you. I can get that. But then also the amount of money spent from non-aldermanic funds per ward on other infrastructure investments. Meaning non-menu? Non-menu. Cool. Thank you. I've seen no other questions. Okay. Since there's no further business, may – I'm sorry, strike that. This concludes the subject matter hearing. Thank you all for participating. We'll continue this dialogue. We want to make sure that we're helping one another. Since there's no further business, may have a motion to adjourn by the same rule call vote that was applied to the Attorney Quorum. Alderman Lopez, so moves, hearing no objections, so ordered. The meeting of the Committee on Economic Capital and Technology Development is adjourned. Thank you, everyone.