Good afternoon. The Committee on Workforce Development will now come to order. Today we have two items on the agenda. First, the approval of the July Rule 45 report. Second, 02023-0004210, the Heat Illness Prevention in Outdoor Places of Employment Ordinance. Before we begin, I will conduct a roll call to establish forum. Alderman Yancey is online. Alderman Hall. Alderman Beal is online. Alderman Chico. Alderman Chico is present. Alderman Ramirez. Alderman Ramirez is present. Alderman Quinn. Alderman Quinn is present. Alder Person Gutierrez vice chair. Vice chair Gutierrez presence. Alderman Coleman. Alderman Curtis. Chair Rodriguez is presence. Alderman Talley Ferrell. That is way. Alderman Quesada. Alderman Quesada is presente. Alderman Spasaro. Nick Sposato is here Alderperson Vasquez Alderperson Vasquez is present Alderwoman Clay is online We have a quorum We have eight members present with Tally Ferre on the way By Rule 59 Alderman Yancey Alderman Beal Alderwoman Clay have requested to attend the meeting By remote means Alright Alderperson Beal We will bring him in Since the other two aren't online Yep, I'm here So moved by Vice Chair Gutierrez Permitting Alder Beal To attend remotely To the motion, please respond by saying aye Hearing no oppose The ayes have it Alder Beal is allowed to Attend this meeting by remote means We have Alders Riley And Haddon As non-committee members Presence At this time We will begin the public comment period The public comment period is 30 minutes Out of respect for everyone's time Each speaker is limited to three minutes The first speaker You got that up Is Richard Juarez Many of you have come to know me I'm a proud Chicago Ride Share driver My name is Richard Juarez One of many who have spent countless hours And thousands of rides Fighting for what's right A fair and transparent And safe system For both drivers and passengers In our city We the drivers Created the foundation For the Ride Share Living Wage Ordinance We came together Organized and lobbied We did this voluntarily No one paid us No one told us to We did it because we care About fairness And about safety And about the people of Chicago This ordinance was built On three pillars A transparent fare system Based on time and distance Not manipulated algorithms Fair and consistent pay for drivers Who work hard And deserve stability Meaningful safety measures That protect both passengers And drivers But in June This ordinance Our work Our movement was carjacked Large organizations Like SEIU Local One And IU OE 150 Stepped in Not to support us But to serve their own interests They saw the traction We had built And they took over Pushing drivers The original authors Of this effort To the sidelines We also trusted an alderman To help guide this fight But that trust May have been misplaced Instead of standing With the workers They stood with those Who had their own agendas What's worse A public document Tied to this ordinance Has never been made public How can an elected official Support something Hidden from the very people It's supposed to serve Transparency matters Let me be clear This is not a new fight It is a continuing one And we are not fighting For drivers We're fighting For every passenger Every citizen Who deserves a safe Honest and fair Transportation system We ask the workforce Committee To do what's right Alright See you next time bring the fair share ordinance to a vote let the city council do its job and represent the people not corporations hold over and lift account for putting for putting profits over people we don't want charity we want justice we want every dollar earned in the cities to stay in the city not be funneled off to wall street we want the economy to work for us the people who live here work here and raise families here this is about chicago values integrity hard work and community we cannot allow corporate giants and self-serving organizations to speak for us let the voices of actual drivers be heard i've given over 48 000 rides i'm a veteran i know what it means to serve and to fight and like many others in this room the shitty the chicago drivers initiative will not give up on this fight not for myself not for our fellow drivers and not for the people of chicago we will see it through win or lose if we lose this fight it will not be because we gave up win or lose we the chicago drivers initiative will have done all that we can if scru or 150 are of noble intentions and truly stand for the worker they will not oppose the passing of the fair share ordinance thank you mr juarez next up is emily casajay i forgive me if i got that wrong it's okay it's emily casajay uh good afternoon uh my name is emily casajay and i just wanted to speak off of what rich juarez said i am a writer of uber and lyft and basically i wanted to give my story i work at united center and it's very hard coming out after work at like 12 a.m because of concerts and games and events that we host and it's hard going on the red line and the green line at such like a dangerous time so i have to take an uber and a lyft but it's so expensive and it's very hard to to get an uber especially us having the uber zone at united center and uh yeah so i have to like walk down madison street or walk down in the dark all the way to the green line just for it to be less expensive and uh just for me to have the safest option just to go home to my apartment and uh even uber and lyft can even be safer by showing us a bigger picture of the driver and uh yeah i just wanted to give my piece about safety thank you thank you thank you emily cosijay thank you got that um next up mr george blakemore workforce workforce workforce the workforce in the city of chicago is changing the faces are changing a lot of the the police that's part of our workforce they are mostly hispanics now and they say the blacks don't want to be police all right so the workforce and and the money that's been spent with other people not even legal citizens coming over spending this money the workforce is changing but the egregious act is that why would you have two meetings at the same time why would you do that and they're all democrats and they they have so so out the streets and i predict the new when this new election come guess what they're gonna all be democrats again maybe some of the old ones they get rid of and urshel a new group in i've advocated for trump to come here and clean up this swamp and on this hat it says make america uh uh uh great again and i painted out some gold paint great again my hat say make america great make america great make her great by letting her appreciate and serve her black constituent that was not refugees that got over here through slavery force work force force labor that's the difference between black and white and hispanic and asian we're the only group that was forced to work in the workforce and we made america great our feet our labor our blood our sweat and our tears we made her great black white wealth of black labor made it not hispanic not asian but black labor so we are entitled to all the jobs the goods contracts and services that they have in the america united states of america and they have and president who you can see now washington lazy man he has slaves slave labor so again that's why it's very important to have a man uh mr blakemore chap thank you sir next up is chris anderson good afternoon chairman ladies and gentlemen of the committee my name is christopher j anderson director of government affairs for united airlines joined by my colleague here rachel dame of american airlines the two hub carriers operating at o'hare today are here to provide comment as members of the trade association airlines for america better known as a4a members of a4a include united american southwest and delta all of which operated either of chicago's two airports the heat ordinance is well intentioned but we ask for both more time that allow you to improve it better an exemption for the airline industries and its vendors are must while i cannot guarantee much what i can guarantee is the months of january february there will be no heat related illness injuries in chicago i want to thank the sponsor for her time she's given much time on this issue and i know she's passionate about it we thank her for the back and forth in the dialogue we've had uh however as i expressed to her earlier today we're asking for a little more time to make the case why airlines need a special exemption and i want to thank you all members of the committee for indulging us for many phone calls and text messages both ua and american airlines have a very unionized workforce more than 83 percent of our workers are represented by a union and those cbas discuss in detail the work conditions also for those you all may not know your partners in government at the state level also tried to uh uh pass the extreme weather for workers uh uh bill earlier this year but held it out of abundance of caution because it was too sweeping and too broad it needed improvement we think the same is true here the air carriers seek a simple exemption that it says this shall not apply to employees of an air carrier as defined in and regulated under the federal aviation act of 1958 as amended nor does it apply to vendors nor contractors performing services for an air carrier this provision will hurt our operation remember that more than 50 percent of the traffic that comes through o'hare is actually not local is connecting traffic and flights not leaving on time out o'hare have a disastrous disastrous effect throughout the country and not to be hyperbolic hyperbolic but throughout the world seeing that chicago serves as many cities and destinations around the world a letter was sent to you all by a4a and today i sent out a report about united airlines in particular emailed to each of you and i have caught hard copies for you today to discuss our environmental injuries i don't want to go into too much detail but out of the last four years we've had 50 injuries at o'hare of which only nine were related to heat or cold the others were due to slips and falls and trips um our airlines operate worldwide and throughout the united states and worldwide in places like phoenix houston and las vegas many of those places have longer summers and much hotter summers than we do and have no such ordinance uh i'm gonna turn it over to my colleague rachel who wants to address some things as well you know what we'll do mr anderson you're at time so i'll consider this as a separate testimony at this point because you have you have also signed up on a pink form so let's restart at three minutes and then we'll go with rachel dame and your time should begin when you speak thank you okay perfect thank you so much so as mentioned my name is rachel dame american airlines i want to say we've been operating at o'hare for over a hundred years this is actually our hundredth year here we have some logistical concerns around the ordinance i want to speak to how would you add shade coverage you have people walking the wings they're all the way out on the tarmac what is that going to look like with a tent next to a jet engine how are you going to take preemptive breaks on the tarmac how would that work what does the climatization look like when you're trying to have somebody push a plane off a gate but they're acclimatizing to the weather outside you know one of the things we talk about is we have these collective bargaining agreements agreements and our collective bargaining agreements you make sure that our employees stay safe, but that we can still run our operation effectively. I would argue that airlines are an essential workforce. We are carrying people on life's journey, and we have workers that are safe. And at O'Hare in the past three years, we've only had two heat-related incidents, but we also need to make sure that our operation is running smoothly. So this ordinance, there's logistical concerns, and we're also fixing a problem that doesn't exist, and the data shows that. So we need to make sure that O'Hare continues to be one of the greatest airports in the country, but to do that, we need to not create another burden for our workforce. So I really urge you to obviously talk to the Chicago Department of Aviation, talk to the airlines. We have these collective bargaining agreements that protect our workforce and also make sure that we can run our operation smoothly. So thank you. Thank you. Next up is Mary Kay Mahoggan. Good afternoon, Chairman Rodriguez and members of the committee. I'm Mary Kay Mahoggan, and I'm here on behalf of the Women Construction Owners and Executives, as well as the Association of Subcontractors and Affiliates. WCOE represents women-owned construction firms that work primarily in the city of Chicago. ASA represents over 300 construction companies. Many of these companies work outdoors, including work on city construction projects like roads, water mains, and sewers. For years, construction contractors have followed OSHA worker protections that currently address heat illness. This morning, you received an email with a link to the employer responsibilities that we are obligated to under the OSHA laws. Also, as an additional protection, construction workers are covered by collective bargaining agreements, all of which have language as it relates to worker call-off. If an individual is not feeling well, too much heat, too much cold, they have the opportunity to call-off under their bargaining agreement. This ordinance doesn't really add any new protections, and at the end of the day, you're asking for additional people to be coming on a secure construction site, which poses all sorts of other concerns from a standpoint of safety. We just heard six days of testimony at the budget's mid-year budget hearings and suggestions that there'll be three to five percent across-the-board cuts to meet the budget hole that we're facing. Is adopting a measure that provides the same worker protections that are already being provided by OSHA and Chicago's fine trade unions really the best use of the city's extremely limited resources? At the same time, women and minority contractors are facing elimination of critical MW and DBE programs that ensure we have a place at the table. To add to this burden, many construction contractors are experiencing significant cost increases as a result of the tariffs imposed by the president. With all that is happening in Washington, it's understandable that people might worry about what OSHA is going to do with relation to worker safety. However, EPA has published rules to strengthen safety for outdoor workers in extreme heat conditions. I included a fact sheet for you in that email that identifies what those provisions are, and at this point in time, I expect there to be final comments are due on the end of the end of the month. I expect that the EPA will come out with those recommendations before our next summer heat season here in Chicago. So we very much urge you to hold this matter in committee until the rulemaking process at OSHA can proceed and the comment period is closed and we have an actual final rule. If at that point things aren't working and protections aren't there, then by all means we'd be happy to come back to the table to come up with new regulations. Thank you. Thank you. Next up is Jack Lavin. Good afternoon, Chair Rodriguez and members of the committee. Thank you for the opportunity to provide comments. My name is Jack Lavin, President and CEO of the Chicagoland Chamber of Commerce, which represents over a thousand members across all sizes and sectors. I'm here today to express our strong opposition to the heat ordinance before this committee. As you're all aware, the chamber has serious concerns regarding its unclear language, lack of feasibility, unduly burdensome mandates, punishment and fees far beyond reasonable enforcement action, increased costs to the city's budget that we are in absolutely no position to afford, and all without clear evidence of need or improved safety outcomes. This would be the most far-reaching, wide-ranging, impunitive heat ordinance in the country at a time where small businesses are dealing with inflation, tariffs, and skyrocketing property taxes. In fact, three violations in a 12-month period could lead to license revocation, which could put a company out of business. While these issues are serious, they disproportionately impact small businesses, which have fewer administrative resources to meet the ordinance's extensive requirements. However, while our concerns regarding the ordinance policies are significant, the problems with the ordinance run deeper, because even on its own terms, this ordinance is not ready. No ordinance should move forward when it contains fundamental gaps on key items such as clearly establishing who is subject to the ordinance or objective standards for compliance. Case in point, the ordinance itself opens by establishing its scope as workers performing work in an outdoor environment where outdoor heat index exceeds 80 degrees. As currently written, this ordinance has no standard for measuring the heat index for the outdoor working environment. As we all know, temperatures and humidity levels across Chicagoland vary widely at any given time. Having no objective basis for compliance creates serious regulatory confusion for employers, employees, regulators, and anyone involved. But it also creates a situation that is ripe for abuse and frivolous litigation. Let's be clear, what I'm speaking to isn't an obscure clause, but this ordinance's foundational scope. And the issues go on from there. This ordinance is not ready. Far from it. Especially when there is no reason to run this now with summer behind us. We need more time to get this right. We all must do better for our constituents and our city. Companies have more choices than ever as to where they can locate. And this wide ranging and overly punitive ordinance just adds to the narrative of how difficult it can be to do business in Chicago. It makes Chicago an outlier and will hurt job creation and retention. While I encourage a no vote along with a coalition of business groups, at minimum, I ask those who may support the policy to hold on taking action to allow the time needed to address these foundational issues and also to get the ordinance out there so it's transparent and people can see what's in the ordinance, which we have not yet publicly. So please consider these comments and hold this a no vote or hold this for further consideration. Thank you. Thank you. Next up is Aaron. I'm going to just say G from Urban Kayaks. And if you please would state your last thing for the record. My apologies. Yes. Hi. Good afternoon, Chairman Rodriguez and members of the committee. My name is Aaron Gershenson, owner and manager of Urban Kayaks, a small business we started 15 years ago on the Chicago Riverwalk. We run kayaking and paddleboarding tours, rentals, lessons, camps, lifeguards for the Chicago River swim yesterday that just happened, all on the Chicago River and Lake Michigan. I'm here to oppose the proposed heat ordinance, not only for my business, but for small businesses across all 77 of Chicago's communities. The truth is there's no way for a business like mine to comply with this ordinance and stay open. We don't have the resources to hire staff to handle its requirements. And even if we did, the rules don't fit how we actually operate. Most importantly, they don't make us any safer. Worker safety has always been our top priority. We're a small, tight-knit team that spends long hours outdoors kayaking the river, showcasing our beautiful city. And we already have safety measures tailored to our environment. In 15 years, we've never had a single heat-related incident. What's also troubling is the process. I only found out about this ordinance two days ago by chance. Many other small businesses never even had the chance to weigh in. I urge this community, please take more time, engage with the small business community, and work with us to create policies that keep workers safe without putting small businesses out of business. This ordinance is not ready, and I respectfully encourage a no vote. Thank you. Thank you. As there's no more individuals signed up for public comment, we will move on. Our first order of business – well, before I do that, I'd like to recognize Alders, Tally Farrell, and Hall for the quorum, and also non-committee members Cardona and Tabares. Online, we have Alders, Nancy, and Clay that are on the committee and have filed – sorry, Alderman Reilly. I thought I caught you earlier. Forgive me. I actually did catch you earlier. Again, online committee members are Yancey and Clay who have filed Rule 59s. I'll take a motion from Alder Casada to allow them for remote participation. All those in favor, signify by saying aye. Any opposed? Hearing no oppositions, the ayes have have it. Also, Alder Vasquez has requested a Rule 59. I'll assign that to the previous motion without any objections. Seeing none, so moved. We have Alderman Coleman, who is a committee member for the quorum. Got it. All right. Our first order of business is the approval of the Rule 45 report from July 2025. I remember the committee should have received a copy in her email. Can I have a motion to approve the Rule 45 report? I'll take Alder Spisato on that motion. All those in favor, signify by saying aye. Any opposed? Any opinions, share? The ayes have it. All right. Second item before the committee, 02023-0004210, the heat illness prevention and outdoor places of employment ordinance. Following Alderwoman Haddon, we'll have in the box with us today Commissioner Ivan Cappofalli from BACP, First Deputy Melissa Pagan, Chief of Policy Jung Yeun, Director of OLS Miguel Campos. But first up, we have sponsor of this initiative, Alderwoman Haddon, for your remarks. Thank you, Chair. And good afternoon, everybody. Thank you guys for being here for today and for hearing this item. So we introduced this. I know some of you came to the briefings that we had last week. We introduced this legislation in 2023. While, I'll say, through the work that we've done and many hours meeting with the Chicagoland Chamber, a lot of our other partners in transportation industries, and of course with the city, there are kind of two ways that I feel a lot of us come to legislation. Sometimes we intro legislation because something is going wrong and we need to fix it. Sometimes we intro legislation as a preventative measure, not because there's a lot of problems with it. So I will say from some of the public comment, I would agree. When we think about what we've seen at the airports and we think about the logged numbers of kind of heat-related illnesses causing sickness on the job, numbers are low. But we are also in a space where we don't need to wait for a changing climate, extended heat seasons. You know, September, almost October, the AC is still intermittently on at my house. We don't have to wait for something to be a problem in order for us to set reasonable standards and expectations, especially when it comes to worker health and safety. So it's within that spirit that we introduced this in 2023. And we looked to other cities and other states for their models. And then we paused because under the Biden administration, OSHA actually took this up, working on guidelines for heat protections for not just outdoor workers, but also indoor workers. Those warehouse workers, right, people in other spaces that we know are suffering, our constituents. In June of 2024, OSHA actually released some of their initial recommendations from that deep work that they had been doing. And you'll see the basis of their recommendations is what we built this ordinance around. So what you see before you today, what was presented before you last week, we've made some changes. And those changes have actually been at the request of some of our partners in business and our partners in labor. We proudly work on this with the support of the full SEIU State Council and support from the Chicago Federation of Labor. Our trades, you'll notice in this, our trades asked for some language to give some exemptions around construction workers. We worked with the city to put in reasonable limitations and exemptions for emergency work. So both from departments like OEMC, CFD, CPD, OPSA, but also language that considers emergency situations that other industries face. And construction work outside of the city, including like our telecom companies, right, AT&T, Verizon. We've got utility companies that have to do construction work and also have to respond in emergency manners. And so we've included language and definitions that also make exceptions for them. We started with, again, guidelines from OSHA about, you know, the kind of breaks that you might need to give employees during high heat conditions and reasonable things like making sure there's access to water. We, I think at the core of this ordinance, the city will be going through a rulemaking process to lay out really helpful guidelines based on federal standards, based on OSHA for heat illness prevention. There will be a training that employers and employees can take every year. And as a representative of the 49th Ward, where a full 90% of my businesses are very small businesses, we actually wrote this ordinance in mind of small businesses as well as large ones so that there would be no additional cost. You don't have to hire people to do this. You don't have to hire equipment. The National Weather Service is the standard that tells us what temperature it is. Everyone can access that on their phone. The Office of Emergency Management sends out updates and guidelines based on those same standards. So questions of putting this into practice, we've thought through. We've put in language with the consideration of small businesses that don't have supervisory teams. Maybe you're a five-person shop, right? You don't have a supervisor on every shift. Maybe you're a restaurant, like a lot in my ward, where you've got a cook and a server. This also works for you as well as working for a United or an American Airlines. We were pleased to find that, especially for our big partners, they have practices that already meet the standards we're proposing in this ordinance, from cooling stations to heat illness awareness to hydration stations. And so with the ordinance that's before you today, we are putting our stake in the ground here in Chicago for workers' health and safety. We are under a different federal administration. The guidelines here, this is what OSHA 2024 came out with, right? What is OSHA 2027 going to come out with? We know that worker protections are under assault at the federal government, and so is climate science. We are being told climate change isn't real. So as we work to be smart and just lay the groundwork for basic health and safety protections, again, that are not burdensome for us to do, not only are we making a benefit to Chicagoans when this would take effect in 2027, but we're also setting standards for future uncertainty under this current federal administration. We do understand the realities of federal guidelines and rules, and so there is language here that especially for some of our big partners like railroads, airlines, and organizations that fall under federal guidelines, there is language that we have included here to not put us or them in conflict with any federal rules that should come out, right? Should OSHA pass something that is in conflict with what we have here? Should, you know, the FAA, should the FCC pass something that's in conflict with what we're putting here? The language that we have included in this legislation would make sure that that company is not out of compliance with the city code, understanding that the federal guidelines will supersede what we have here at the city. So with that, just to say, this isn't a cost prohibitive ordinance. This is something thoughtfully prepared. It's been in the works for a couple of years. We've been sharing versions of this with you all for a few weeks now and have worked in good faith with partners like the Chicagoland Chamber. I think we've spent about six hours talking to them. And look forward to more discussions, because as I say, one big change from our initial introduction is also that this is going to take effect in January of 2027. And that is largely with respect to wanting to see what may come from the federal government in January 2026 and making sure that we're giving sufficient time for our Office of Labor Standards to come up with the information for the trainings and the heat emergency plans that we will be providing so that businesses, especially small businesses, don't have to try and hire somebody to create those themselves. So with that, I would ask for, of course, any questions, but the favorable consideration of my colleagues in supporting this. Thank you, Chair. Okay. I'm aware of some changes at the behest of the CFL, so we're going to recess for about five minutes and get those packets out, and then we'll be back here right at 122. Thank you so much. Be right back. Thank you. The item 02023-0004210, everyone should have received the copy of the substitute. The substitute has also been emailed to all committee members. Can I get a motion to accept the substitute? So moved by Vice Chair Gutierrez. All those in favor, signify by saying aye. Any opposed? In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. We now have the substitute before us. Alderman Hannon, anything else? If you'd mind, I'll just share what changed in the version that you have before you that was recently handed out. So this is actually language that was in a previous version that we... had some back and forth on as we're trying to make sure that we are dealing fairly with the complexities of existing collective bargaining agreements. We've had a lot of back and forth with the city, with private businesses, and of course, with our partners in labor. And we had a, so this is language that's not new. It actually had been previously circulated to you all and is what we had covered in the briefings. There is a small change that takes out a date. And so under section 6-140-075, the application to collective bargaining agreements, sections, subsections B and C are what were added. And this just says that requirements of the chapter may be waived in a bona fide collective bargaining agreement, but only if the waiver is set forth explicitly in such agreement in clear and unambiguous terms. And that other than a collective bargaining agreement, any agreement to waive rights granted under this chapter is void and against public policy. So this is standard language. Again, we had some questions about not wanting to have some members in a CBA who weren't granted the same rights. We didn't want to end up with a bargain for employees that had fewer protections than non-bargained employees, but got some clarification in the language so that that was not an issue. Thank you, Chair. Excellent. And again, I'd like to note, before we move to Aldermanic questions, that in the box we have Commissioner Ivan Capifali from BACP, First Deputy of Labor, Melitza Pagan, Chief of Policy, Zhang Yun, Director of the Office of Labor Standards, Miguel Campos. And we will now move to questions from Alders, first from committee members and then to others. I'd like to keep it to five minutes if that's possible. Absolutely. Alders Posado on the point of information. I see the commissioners from BACP is here. He has nothing to say to us about this or? Would you like to chime in? I'll take that as a question. He'd love to know your response. Is he just here to answer questions? I would guess he has something to say. The man with the great haircut. Good afternoon, everyone. Ivan Capifali, Commissioner of BACP. I just want to, for the record, I want to thank the chairperson for working with us, for being available, for giving us that runway in 2026 so that we can prepare and get ready for launching in 2027. 2026 is going to be a time where we're going to use for education and outreach campaign. One thing that I have to say, come 2027, we have to be very cognizant and recognize that we will be fiscally responsible with this in a way that, you know, if we want this implemented the right way and enforced the right way and we continue going into 2027 with the education and information to our businesses, that we have the necessary resources for that. So when it comes to that point, we will then go back to the table and have more discussions. But thank you, Alderman, Haddon, for being so flexible and for working with us. Alderman, anything else? I'll be raising my hand when I'm ready to speak, I guess. There's only three of us here, I guess, so I don't know. There's six, seven, eight, nine, ten. Okay. All right. Person for online. Alderman Hall. Well, thank you so much. My question is the when we, you know, look at the implementation of this, right, and in goodwill, good faith, definitely, again, the work conditions are important. It is what it is. As we, you know, want to weed out the bad guys. But we do have good guys in this work already. And so one of the, some of the good players are in what we see that's happening in the airport and outside festivals and so forth and so on. So I do want to deal with the outside group that works, which I think this covers. We want to zero in. And when we look at what's happening with the airport being built, there's outside workers there. And then we actually have airport workers. How much when it comes zeroing into the actual industry with the passengers and the workers, will this become a burdensome to them? Or have you, you know, seen this as problematic in other cities that may have introduced something similar to the point where we see backing up in addition to that, now, more costs for, have you, like, added that into the equation? Or is there something that, you know, we see as a safety third rail to prevent? Sure, no, thank you for that question, Alderman Hall. I'll say that it's certainly for, right, passenger experience, for making sure that we are, remain a world-class city for transportation and our airports. I know when I travel through O'Hare and Midway, I like things to be timely, right? Right? I like things to be timely. So both as a Chicagoan and as a passenger and user of our airports, certainly into considerations. That's actually why we made a lot of changes at recommendations of the airlines. So the intention of our ordinance hasn't changed. But, for instance, like, we started off with things like, hey, when it's really hot, you've got to provide some shade or shade structures. And, you know, several people came back, but the airports especially, they're like, we can't just build things on. It's like, oh, my gosh, you're right. And even, I'll say, at the 80-degree heat index piece where that's the level where OSHA recommends you start looking out for heat illness and where it's important for people to be aware. We originally went for some of the strongest recommendations, which we took from the state of California, to say that, hey, there should be an optional 10-minute break if somebody requests it. That's kind of the gold standard. We listened to both the city and some of our private partners, especially when it comes to some of the airlines and the difficulty of scheduling breaks, especially when you are working on a schedule. And we actually removed that, right? So now there's education and kind of awareness piece. So where we're at when it comes to the scheduling, at this point, isn't burdensome. A 15-minute break every two hours, that can coincide with whatever is already bargained for in your CBA. This is something that is in the OSHA recommendations. And we know that it's not going to cause huge delays. It's not going to impact customer experience and is already in line with a lot of practices that we heard from companies that they are doing, including our city departments. Our city departments actually had some of the best practices for taking care of workers. So it's something that we should be proud of. And once we move forward with this ordinance, this is something that we can lift up in Chicago as a standard in our public space and our private space. Thank you for that. If I can just piggyback off what Alderwoman had in the 49th Ward. I want to introduce yourself, please. Hi, everyone. Leslie Perkins, Chief of Staff to Alderwoman Haddon of the 49th Ward. Yeah, in addition to some of the flexibility that we built into the ordinance, if you look under the 6140-015 scope and application and the substitute ordinance, subsection D also puts in a provision that if there are existing federal laws or regulations that come into conflict with this ordinance, that deference will be given to those federal regulations. So we know that a lot of our airport workers are regulated by the FAA and TSA. Those will take precedence over this ordinance if there is any conflict there. Thank you so much for that. Thank you, Alder. Alder Quesada. Thank you very much, Chairman. I want to thank Alderwoman Maria Haddon for her leadership on this ordinance. She's exactly right. I mean, this isn't a matter of if we will ever need to implement ordinance like this. It's a matter of when. This is very forward thinking. Unfortunately, the forward march of climate change means that there is going to be enormous threats to workers, vulnerable people. And we're just talking about the workforce. We're not even talking about tenants or people experiencing homelessness. Everything is on the line here. So this forward thinking piece of legislation, I think, is very great. Our workers are not expendable, and they should not be treated as such. So I think that this is common sense legislation. I also want to recognize the letters of support that we received from Arise Chicago and the SEIU Illinois State Council in support of this ordinance. So, yeah, no, I don't have any questions at this time. I thought the briefing was very informative. So I urge my colleagues to vote yes on this. Thank you. Chair, Tally Farrell. Thank you, Chairman. I understand this. The ordinance would be applicable to every business that has outside or outdoor employment. If that's the case, how do we assess or was it difficult to assess the cost that would be incurred by an individual company? Is it accurate to say that we can't ascertain that? I think it's accurate to say that we as the city can't game that out for each individual company. And what's the status of the proposal that OSHA has put forward? forward. And I'm trying to understand whether or not the proposals that OSHA has put forward are in the process becoming rules and regulations, or is it just recommendations that they're looking? Because when I did look at it, it looks like there had been a few hearings with another hearing scheduled for October. And so are they looking to present guidelines that will be looked at across the country? Or are these hearings just informative? I'll say we're hopeful that that is the case. And prior to the change in administration, that is the track they were on. So the OSHA recommendations that make up this ordinance were in the process of becoming rules and regulations for the entire country, which was one of the reasons why we paused initially, because they were working on this and what they released in June of 2024 was based on that work that was going to be recommendations for both indoor and outdoor workers. We had started just working on outdoor workers. There is some thinking from D.C. that they might be picking this back up with the hearing that they have and that we might see something released in January. Our concern is it could be the work that they had already been doing. But a lot of that, of course, was based on science and health data and worker protections. And that's not tended to be what we've seen from this administration. So some concern there. But also, before they had this hearing scheduled in October, we decided to pick this back up and that we in the city of Chicago can continue that work. We can take these, you know, well thought out recommendations, we can put them into action and continue to be a leader and a beacon for workers' rights. Now, we're setting an effective date for January, 2027. And of course, should the federal government come out with something, the federal government supersedes, right, what we can do here in the city. But we're hopeful that they're going to continue with the work they started and that that would be the rules that they would implement. And I just really want to say I appreciate your efforts and the chairman's efforts in bringing this legislation so that our workers in the city can be protected. Being that we are on the end of our summer season where it's not very likely that we're going to get temperatures that rise that far are above 80 degrees. We may have one or two days. I don't know. But I believe that we're on the end of our summer with our higher temperature days. Is there an immediate need to move forward with this prior to OSHA's determinations or what OSHA decides to do with regard to rules and regulations? Would there be a harm, in other words, prior to next summer, if we held back on this until such time as OSHA is able to definitively tell us that these are the rules and regulations that we're putting into place or we're not going to put, we're going to leave it up to different jurisdictions to come up with their own sets of rules and regulations? So I'm just basically asking, is there harm to wait on this? or is this something we want to get into place going into next summer? So this is, I'll say, personal opinion, right, in my response? Absolutely. I do think there's harm in waiting, which is why we picked this back up to move at the end of the summer season. And initially, we wanted it to be effective January 2026 to be ready for the next summer season. But again, what we're proposing now to give more time for our city departments to prepare is January 2027. This is an opportunity that we have, I think, to influence and affirm the standards that OSHA was putting forth previously. And I think that it's important for our city to do it, a city known for our leadership in labor rights, in civil rights, in climate work and research. Us moving forward with this now in advance of, I think, can also give some support and a signal to our federal employees who have already put forth these recommendations and may be feeling pressure from an unfavorable administration to backtrack on good work that they've already done. So that's personal opinion. That's why we're moving this now. That's why I think it is timely and important for us to do it now. And we know we have a million other things that we're always juggling. So this is also a good time before we get into a ton of budget things. And who knows what the next emergency is that is going to demand our attention. So those are kind of my thinking and, you know, my reasoning with the chairman here on bringing this now. If we know it's good, if we support it, if this is where OSHA was headed anyway, if we've got workers and employees in Chicago that we can protect, let's do it now. Let's give the city the lead up time, right? If we delay, then we're going to have to delay our implementation date again to give more lead up time for the city to actually work on the rules and create the materials. But again, who knows what awaits us after budget season and where our attentions will be turned. And lastly, Chairman, if I could ask a question of Ivan, how do we enforce? You know, I do understand that by ordinance, this won't go into effect until January of 27. Will there be a need for additional inspectors, additional employees, or is there proactive enforcement or more so a reaction from complaints being made? Thank you for that question. It will be a complaint-based approach. We're going to take the 2026 to actually create and to launch a very robust outreach and education campaign. We hope that that's going to lead to less complaints once this is established. We've talked to other departments that are going to be joining us in enforcing this. So it's going to be BACP on the lead, but we are working with other departments to also be on the books to be able to enforce if they witness a violation. Hopefully, that will minimize the amount of complaints that come our way. But a combination of outreach, education, and working with others, we think is going to be quite responsible. But yes, we will need and we have to consider other more resources in the years to come. Okay. Thank you. Chairman, thank you. And just a last comment. I am somewhat concerned. I do appreciate the ordinance and you have my support on it. But I am a little cautious about just an avenue of from an employee perspective or from the employer's perspective, rather, abuse and the potential for lawsuits. I worry about the employee that don't necessarily want to work, but will use this ordinance to their benefit to take extended breaks or take more breaks, because it's very difficult to actually determine whether a person is or is not suffering from heat exhaustion or heat stroke. I've had some experience with that while I served in the military. And so it was often an opportunity for those that didn't want to do something to say, I'm having an episode of heat exhaustion. And so I'm concerned from an employer perspective that we don't have anything in place that may assist our employers with abuse. And also that may subject some of them to litigation as a result of that. And then there's a wide vast, I mean, there's just such a whole big number of types of companies that actually go outside to include our park district that oftentimes have youth in the summertime working outside for a period of time. So I do support the measure because I believe in our workers' safety. And at the same time, I would love to see some provisions drafted in the future that would help prevent abuse from employees. That's all I have, Chair. Thank you so much. Thank you, Chair. If you would allow us, Chair, Chairman Taliaferro, we had some of those conversations and actually spent a lot of time on that. My chief of staff is going to speak a little bit to some of the guardrails that we put in the ordinance to, as best as possible, address that concern. Thank you, Alderwoman Haddon. And thanks for the question or the comments. I do think that this is one of the points that came up. Most consistently in engaging with our stakeholders is concerned that, you know, workers will kind of abuse the provision of a preventative cool down rest to, you know, not work. So in the original ordinance, we had that a worker could take a preventative cool down rest anytime that they felt that they needed to to protect themselves from overheating and that it would be a minimum of 10 minutes. And the updated version that's before you, that 10 minute minimum has been eliminated. So there's no minimum requirement just until their symptoms have abated. And then if it's 90 degrees or hotter and that 15 minute mandatory break is required every two hours for high heat practices, that worker initiated cool down rest can count towards that 15 minutes. Now I hear you of like, OK, if somebody takes a preventative cool down rest, comes back five minutes and then, you know, five minutes later, they're saying they need another one. And I think at that point, it's on the employer to say, hey, do you think it's time for you to seek medical assistance? Right. If you're feeling these symptoms and they're not mitigating, they're not getting any better. Maybe it's time that we, you know, dispatch emergency medical services or, you know, offer those kind of sort of things to, you know, kind of put those guardrails in effect of those provisions of the ordinance. And if they say no, I think, you know, at that point, they can determine what the best course of action is from there. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Chair. I think Aldous Posato, did you have questions? I have no other hands. I got questions. Please do. I got questions. I don't I don't know if I can get it in five minutes, but since the last guy got 10 minutes, hopefully I got to have 10 minutes. And I appreciate that. You have six minutes and 37 seconds. I don't know about that. But 38. Go ahead. Thank you. All right. But first of all, I don't mean to be critical, other woman here, but just some points that I'm witnessing here. Well, first of all, this is not something I could support. So I just want to say that. So I don't want to be disingenuous and act like maybe maybe I could support it. I maybe I can sometime, but not now. So I have some questions. I don't know. Maybe maybe some you can meet through a chair. Maybe somebody can answer right away. So the first thing is you mentioned the chamber. You know, you had meetings with them. You talked with them. Well, the president of the chamber there came up to me and said we talked, but they didn't feel anybody listened. So I don't know. You mentioned six hours. I don't know if that's enough. I know they represent a lot of big businesses, but they also represent small businesses. I'd hope things would get along better. You work things out better with that. Fifteen months away. I'm not really understanding why we're doing it now and implementing it 15 months away. I mean, why I know you've been working on this for a while. I'm not acting like you just willy nilly came up with this, you know, a week ago. But what's the hurry now to do it now if it's going to be implemented in 15 months? I'm a little having a hard time understanding that. Are those your two questions, Chairman? Oh, I got a lot of questions. We'll start with those two. I'll start with your second one. I did feel like I just answered that, but I'm happy to reiterate it. We've heard it take time. Our city departments, they need time to gather the information, to set up the trainings, and to make sure. So a lot of this extended time was really understanding our departments do a lot of work. They want a little bit more time. This also, giving a runway, if you will, of course, is beneficial to our business community. So that's why on that. And so we can, if we delay a decision, it's just delaying the protections when they're going to be set up. So I don't imagine a decision next month or in two months or in three months. It's not going to mean that they have any less, they need less time. They're still going to need a runway. So we need to do something now so that in 15 months we can have it together. To your first question, we spent quite a lot of time with the Chicagoland Chamber. I enjoyed conversations. See Carl over there. Hey, Carl, we spoke this morning. I mean, I actually, you know, it's disappointing to hear the president of the Chicagoland Chamber tell me that they strongly oppose, even though they told me. You talked on for six hours. Yeah, I mean, over multiple meetings. I thought we were going steady at this point with as much conversation. But what I'll say is the things that they want, they want to remove private right to action. They want to remove any ability for an employee to have any legal pathway towards being made whole should they be in big violations. And that's not what Chicago does. We protect our workers. So just to say, that's not something we're going to bend on. Okay. All right. So not only do we protect our workers, we have to protect our businesses. So I am also worried about workers. I know there's a lot of bad actors out there, but there's also some good actors. So I'm also worried about the businesses because if the businesses aren't there, the employees aren't going to have jobs to go to. So we mentioned BACP. I'm just guessing. I'm just guessing that there's going to be a cost to BACP. You're going to have to create a department commissioner. So, commissioner, this question is for you. I mean, do you have any idea? Give me a short answer. We've got to start getting short answers here. Do you have any idea? I know it's way too early, but, I mean, how many employees, what the cost it might be, how long will it take you to get up and going with a department for this? I mean, so, Alderman, thank you for that question. I mean, like I said, we are going to take 2026 to prepare, but we're estimating that we're going to need about six full-time positions for this. Six employees. Okay. Thank you. There's in your packet, Alderman, there's actually a staffing analysis from Miguel Campos, and there's also, so you can see, about six employees will cost about $900,000 is their estimate. And then we also have in your packet an analysis from COFA that shows that our most conservative revenue estimate is also right around $900,000. So we've got some good information here that, you know, BACP needs more staffing for current labor enforcement, but another reason I'm giving enough time is so that we can really look at these revenue models, and this looks like it will pay for itself and benefit labor rights enforcement across the city outside of this ordinance. How did we come up with the 80 degrees? To me, 80 degrees is a pretty nice day. We just had some 80-degree day recently, which everybody was talking about what a great day it was. So can anybody explain how we came up with 80 degrees rather than 90 degrees because a whole different ballgame with 90 and 80? Oh, those are OSHA standards for workers. Standards, okay. I know people are asking to be exempt. I know certainly the airlines ask to be exempt. I think there will be many other people. So the airlines is supposed to have a, I'm just guessing, they're going to have to have a shade team come out there and out there on the runways or whatever they do, the plane stage and pop up tents and stuff like that? Is that what it is? No, absolutely not. They do not have to do that. As a matter of fact, our airlines already have designated cooling areas and the ordinance allows for existing structures like jet bridges that are already there creating shade to do it with the full understanding that they're not allowed to just put whatever up on the tarmac. So businesses period, let's just say it's ABC construction and there are roofers out there or ABC road paving. I mean, there's no place to go. You're out in the middle of nowhere. I'm guessing the strategy would have to be they'd have to bring cooling tents or at least shaded tents or something where employees could pop in there. I know one question was answered, cool down every two hours. So that would mean you get to cool down four times a day. Just to let everybody know, you know, you all know my condition. It's no secret that I have MS, but I just want to let you all know when my MS first manifested itself. It was 15 years ago. I was a fireman, back-to-back fires, 90-degree day on the roof, fire licking up my ass, you know, very hot. Second fire, I couldn't get off the roof. I was just a blob because the heat just knocked the heck out of me. So I know stuff does happen. You know, I worked in a restaurant as a cook. Back in the day, they didn't have air conditioning in there. I see fests. I see where you have a cook out there. You may have one cook. You got Joe, the hot dog guy. He's grilling hot dogs. And, of course, you have shade, you know, 99% of the time probably. You have one guy making hot dogs. You got 25 people in line. I got to say, sorry, got to stop, take a break now. Nobody gets a hot dog now because it's 80 degrees out. I just see a lot of problems. I just would, you know, maybe at some point I could support this. I just would encourage you to hold it a little longer maybe, try to work with some other people, the airlines, the chamber, the small business. At this point, I can't support it, but like I say, I'm not trying to be critical of what you're trying to do. I just think it's more of a job killer than it is of protecting workers. But thank you, Chairman. Chairman, thank you so much for giving me an opportunity to speak. And thanks for the extra time. You got it, Chair. Vice Chair Gutierrez wanted to chime in. Thank you, Chairman. Just wanted to ask, Chairwoman, if you can please expand about the telecommunications and broadband facilities. I know they're being considered as construction industries. Can you expand a little bit more about those efforts and what you landed with them? Yes, absolutely. So we appreciated the engagement with our telecommunications company. You know, many of them are operating even public utilities, things that are regulated as public utilities. utilities and the work that their employees are doing falls into our definition of construction by the city of Chicago. Therefore, as we've carved out construction employees there, they would be exempt from, those workers would be exempt from this ordinance. We understand that they have, you know, also federal regulations, which is why they're also covered under both our emergency work clauses, right, just like our departments are, right? So even departments that wouldn't be carved out normally for construction will be for emergency work and emergency conditions, as would our telecommunications companies. So they're covered in a few ways, but especially under the construction workers clause. Thank you. And also talking about construction, we know that especially construction companies that work with unions, they know about all these provisions and they do support their employees and they care, they do take care of them. But we know some smaller companies, right, sometimes doing this outreach, if this gets introduced, I think would also be important for labor standards also to work on being able to check if they're earning the right wages, the conditions are appropriate, because we've had some constituents calling to the office, right, that they had such and such company, you know, that they heard the workers are not even getting paid the minimum wage and stuff. So it would be a good opportunity for us now that we're introducing this to also try to enforce all of what we voted and ensure for employees at the same time. Absolutely. Thank you for that. Thank you. There's a real opportunity there to strengthen our office and what we're able to do in supporting workers' rights. Thank you. Also, we have Alder Ramirez. Well, first, I want to apologize. I did step away. So apologies if somebody did already ask this. But I want to start off by saying, Alderwoman Haddon, you are a great leader. And I always look up to you. And I really love that you're sort of like looking ahead, as Alderman Quesada had mentioned, and just thinking about the summer that we had actually this year, and just sort of the heat index. So thank you for putting this up. I did have a couple questions. I have one that's, you know, pretty specific in regards to O'Hare Airport, and as has been mentioned, the work that's ahead for the next eight years. So construction workers at O'Hare will be exposed to outdoor heat more than airline employees. So I had a question around the exemption. So construction workers operating under a CBA at O'Hare Airport will receive an exemption, but not airline employees. Can you explain the discrepancy? Thank you so much for the question. So I mentioned we built this ordinance, right, based on OSHA standards, and then with engagement through our labor partners and private partners and public partners. And what I'll say is, that was in discussion with our labor partners that a lot of our trades and those representing those construction bargaining units liked this language and want to approach it in a slightly different way. And so with trust in our labor partners and working for employees, that's what we agreed to. We did not get a similar request from the labor unions that represent the workers at the airports, right? Those labor unions did not say, hey, you know what, we're doing good. We don't need this. So I will leave it at that. Got it. Thank you so much, Alderwoman. And then this is actually for Ivan at BACP. I know, Ivan, you brought up like a 2026 educational campaign. I would like to just kind of know, is there a specific cost to that? And then ultimately what the cost is moving forward? So we're estimating that this initiative is going to take about six new positions added to BACP. So I don't know if John wants to talk a little bit more about it. Thank you, Commissioner, for the record, Jung Yoon. So again, as stated earlier, BACP will need six full-time positions to enforce this ordinance. And the projected annual cost is $900,000. increasing, of course, every year with COLA costs. And then the cost that we estimate to entertain the six FTEs plus the 15-minute break every two hours for all non-exempted city employees would bring a total cost to the city to $4.3 million. Thank you so much. And then Ivan, just curious about this educational campaign, because this is just like the most pivotal part, right? Just making sure that especially our small businesses are aware. How do you develop that? Or how are you going to present that to us moving forward to 2026? So I'm going to pass it on to Miguel to give you a quick specific on how we're going to implement, create and implement the outreach and education for 2026. Thank you. Miguel Campos. I'm the director for the Office of Labor Standards. Thank you for your question, Alderwoman Ramirez. So I'd like to thank Chairperson Haddon for allowing us a longer plane in order to get this off the ground. So our goal is for 2026, using our current staff, that we would build out this outreach and education campaign. So it's going to be educating employers and outdoor workers on their responsibilities and their rights. We're supposed to publish a required public notice. We're going to work with our Department of Technology and Innovation to have a dedicated landing page and website that will contain templates for heat-related illness prevention plans so that that doesn't fall on a small business operator to develop. We'll have approved training programs, which are being mandated by the ordinance. Again, provide guidance and redirect individuals to the federal government websites that detail how outdoor temperatures and outdoor heat index are going to be calculated in the city. And then perhaps most importantly, engage in a robust rulemaking process. So crafting proposed rules, publishing them, having a public comment period, reviewing comments, and then promulgating a final set of rules so that workers and employers are aware of like the nitty-gritty details that are necessary to properly enforce this. The additional full-time positions would kick in in 2027 in order to have a field enforcement component. Thank you so much, Miguel. That's all my questions. Thank you, Alderman. Very good. Alder Quesada wants to move to pass. Before we do that, Alder Chico has requested a Rule 59, although he is not here. So I'll take that up if he gets back. She's not here either. All right. So Alder Quesada. Thank you. One more question as we were talking about costs. How are we planning to incorporate or what's the policy we're thinking about in terms of overtime? I mean, I know that we've been a little bit more stringent on overtime considerations. I'm wondering if there's any considerations that you can elaborate on, Commissioner? So we're hoping that this initiative won't require overtime. Right now, the outreach and education component is going to be based on existing resources. And then when we move to 2027, that's where we'll be making our ask for six new positions. One other thing. Oh, Alderman. Sorry, I can direct the overtime question specifically. So we looked back at the number of days above 90 degrees, you know, within the county for the heat index. Yes. And that accounts for, on average, about 41 days a year or 11 percent of our days. And so if you take that and then do a FTE to account for the 15 minute break every two hours, that overtime cost is included in the estimate, the budget estimate of $4.3 million, $900,000 of that being the staff for BACP, and the rest is overtime. Thank you. And I'll add to that. We appreciate, right, the estimates we've been given. Some of it doesn't necessarily straight account for overlapping schedules. But another thing that, just to lift up, the break requirement piece is based on what OSHA is likely putting forth anyway. All right. I have a motion to pass, Chairman. There was a question from Alder Sposado. Go ahead. Thank you, Chairman. Another question for BACP. More of a statement, Commissioner. So if you think it's going to take six people to run this new and added apartment, we just recently had something in license yesterday about... a department for vgt's running them i mean that would have to be four or five times the amount of people as this so you're going to have to start asking for some more money because you're going to have to add about 25 30 people to your department so that was just more of a more of a statement about you know um adding all these employees on for business affairs um so really not a question but thanks for letting me make that statement out of his his department is going to really grow so uh um you know once again big difference between 80 and 95 out there um work my three jobs previously all remember all hot jobs um it was all pre uh pre-water bottles and everything so i know we are worried about people are employed we also have to worry about businesses also too um so that's it there's some i'm just i'm just definitely a no on this one but thank you alderman quesada has moved to approve item two on the agenda uh we will go to a uh roll call on the item uh alderman yancey yes yes to the substitute alderman hall alderman beale no alderman chico alderwoman ramirez alderman quinn alder person gutierrez vice chair alderman coleman alderman colman alderman curtis chair rodriguez is an eye alderman tallie farrell is a yes alderman casada is a yes alderman spasado alder person vasquez alder woman clay go back alder person vasquez alder woman clay uh one minute folks see if they come back in who's that uh vasquez vasquez and i that would be eight yes one two three four five six seven eight uh eight yes two nays the item passes sorry chair person uh just a little late clay but uh we've got eight yays and two nays so it passes i'm literally standing next to vasquez all right i will go here man go here man no no no no it's fine we're a2 that's it all right uh i will report this vote as a recommendation to pass at the next city council meeting on thursday september 25th uh with there being no further business before the committee can i have a motion to adjourn move by alder uh quesada to adjourn although hearing no objections so ordered the meeting of the committee and workforce will now be adjourned