and thank you for joining us for this Committee on Health and Human Relations meeting. I am Chair Rosana Rodriguez-Sanchez. It is 11.39 a.m. on July 22, 2025, and this meeting is now called to order. On today's agenda, we will review two resolutions calling for subject matter hearings, R-2025-0017564, introduced by me and Alderman Quezada, calling for hearings on the Department of Health Plans for Public Health Education and Pursuit of Federal Public Health Grants. And R-2024-0014414, introduced by Alderman Haddon, calling for hearings on the allocation of HIV-AIDS grant funding. We also have a planned subject matter hearing with the Chicago Department of Public Health regarding their strategic plan focusing on areas of maternal health and infectious disease, where they will also provide information as requested by the above resolutions. Thank you to all our guests for joining us today. Before we begin, I will call the roll to establish quorum. Vice Chair Ramirez, Alderman Robinson, Alderman Yancey, Alderman Gutierrez, Alderman Lopez, Alderman Ciccio Lopez, Alderman Fuentes, Alderman Cruz, Alderman Castada, Alderman Lawson, Alderman Manah Hoppenworth, Alderman Haddon, Chairwoman Rodriguez-Sanchez is here. We have eight members present and we have a quorum. We have a request for remote participation citing Rule 59 from Alderman Robinson. Is he here? I am here, Chairwoman. Thank you. Good morning, Alderman. Can I get a motion to approve the remote participation of Alderman Robinson? So move by Alderman Manah Hoppenworth. All those in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. Opposed. In the opinion of the Chair, where the eyes have it, Alderman Robinson, your accountant Towers the Rule. We will begin our meeting with time for public comment. The period is limited to 30 minutes and each speaker is limited to three minutes. We have two speakers and there are no virtual public speakers. We have George Blakemore as our first speaker. Go ahead, Mr. George Blakemore. This is this grace to have a committee meeting and you only have one public, two public speakers and the seats are all empty. No one is here and you're dealing with subject matter as committee on health and human relation, mental health, physical health and how man relates to man when it comes to human relations with this so-called illegal immigrant and how the other people that are legal, how do they relate to this and especially black people that voted for something that they shouldn't have. Voting for illegal immigrants to come to the city of Chicago and get jobs, goods, contracts, medical care, health care and we're not getting it. And so I'm looking now, I'm using my eyes and I don't see anybody. I see but one person of color. I think that's Mr. Yancey over there. I'm looking at and I see you. I don't think you embrace your blackness. Anyway, it's very important for me to come to these meetings. Look at the empty seats and what political parties? The Democrats. Well, why do you come and wear that red hat? The Democrats. The revenge. Oh my, flip, go red. Flip red. On my way to blackness. But both of these parties have a lot to do with whatever happened to our people enslaved in America. So that's why it's very important for a man of my caliber to attend these meetings. And out here with my Facebook friends, can you see the empty seats? You deserve the government you get. And you get the government you deserve. All Democrats. Oh, Mr. Blasmore, don't use those kind of terms. Sixty-nine each other. Woo! That's not very good for a man of your caliber to talk like this. I'm keeping it real. I'm keeping it real. Human relations. Health is wealth. And how man relates to man. Now, remember, his statics are saying somebody's putting graffiti. Thank you, Mr. Blakemore. Thank you for your comments. Our next speaker is Crayola Hampton. Thank you and good morning. It is still morning. Many of us are familiar with the adage that the definition of insanity is doing the same thing over again and expecting different results. Essentially, funding for HIV and AIDS has historically, and when I say historically, we're referencing funding from the Chicago Department of Public Health and the Illinois Department of Public Health for more than the last three decades primarily has been granted to organizations that are headquartered and provide services in communities that are comprised primarily of white residents. However, the rates of HIV historically and continue to be much higher, inequitably higher among African-Americans. African-Americans are only 14% of the population in Illinois, but more than 50% of new cases. African-Americans are 28% of the population in Chicago, but comprise 48% of new HIV cases and 52% of existing cases. Funding still continues to go to organizations that are on the north side that are led by white, primarily white-led organizations versus going to those that are culturally competent that are on the west and south sides. As long as funding continues to go to communities where there is a high incidence of HIV among other communities when the degree of HIV and AIDS is higher among African-Americans, we will continue to see rates of HIV go down in the city but not go down among African-Americans. Today, we stand with at least 12 organizations across the city of Chicago. We stood with 19 organizations yesterday from across the entire state of Chicago. Illinois to demand that funding follow the illness. We've seen the incidents with COVID. We see it with black maternal health and mental illness. It is happening with HIV. But because of the stigma, we rarely hear about it. HIV and AIDS, the fame has been flaming among African-Americans. Black women are eight times, there are 14 times, I'm sorry, more black women who are HIV positive than white women in the city of Chicago. Eight times more black men. This is not just specific to gender. HIV and AIDS has to be addressed. And the only way it's going to be addressed if it's funding is equitably applied to black-led organizations. Thank you. Thank you for your comments. There being no further speakers, we conclude the public comment period. We received one written comment that was sent to our committee and shared with members via email. This comment relates to item number two on the agenda. Our first item of business is the approval of the Rule 45 report. Can I get a motion to approve the May 2025 Rule 45 report? Alderman Gutierrez, so move. All those in favor of approving the May 2025 Rule 45 report, respond by saying aye. Opposed, say nay. In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. We will now move on to the matters before the committee. Could I ask that our first guests move to the microphone? Are you already there? You will see that our agenda has a few presentations. To make this work, I'm going to ask you that you write your questions until we complete the presentation of all materials, as the presentations are going to be related to each other. CDPH will present last and take questions following their presentation. Following each set of presentations by our guest speakers, there will be a brief Q&A. I ask that your questions to our guests be directly related to their remarks. If your question is directed to CDPH, please hold it. We will address it at the end of their presentation. Item one on the agenda is R-2025-0017564, which was introduced by Alderman Quezada and me, calling for hearings on the Chicago Department of Public Health Plans for Public Health Education and Pursuit of Federal Public Health Grants. To begin, can I get a motion for the acceptance of item three? Item R-2025-0017564? Other person Fuentes, so move. All those in favor, signify by saying aye. Opposed, say nay. In the opinion of the share, the ayes have it. Yeah, I want to acknowledge other woman Gutierrez, other woman Fuentes. Anybody else came in? Okay. Yes, and you. We'll be counted towards the wrong. I'm going to start with some remarks about the item that Alderman Quezada and I introduced, and then I will pass it to Alderman Quezada to open, and then we will start listening to our guests. Good morning, everybody. Today, we convene to address a matter of urgent and profound importance, the current state of public health in the United States, and more specifically, the escalated challenges that we face at the local level due to alarming shifts in federal public health policy. For decades, public health has been a cornerstone of our society, quietly working to prevent disease, promote wellness, and protect our communities from myriad threats. This work relies on robust scientific consensus, evidence-based practices, and consistent, adequate funding. However, in recent times, we have witnessed a disturbing departure from these fundamental principles at the highest levels of our federal government. The guidance emanating from the current Secretary of Health and Human Services, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., has created an unprecedented level of chaos and uncertainty. His public statements and policy directives frequently contradict established scientific consensus and the expert guidance of our nation's leading public health professionals. This is not merely a difference of opinion. It is a direct assault on the very foundation of public health that puts the lives and well-being of our constituents at risk. We are seeing concerning reports of proposed or actual cuts to essential public health programs that are vital for protecting vulnerable populations and advancing medical science. Programs dedicated to HIV prevention, critical cancer research, widespread vaccination initiatives that have eradicated diseases and save countless lives, and essential gender-affirming care are all facing threats. These are not abstract policy debates. These are life-saving services and research efforts that directly impact our families, friends, and neighbors. Undermining these programs based on unscientific claims is irresponsible and dangerous. Here in Chicago, our Department of Public Health has a proud history of serving our communities, often doing so with remarkable dedication despite significant constraints. Historically, the Chicago Department of Public Health has been underfunded, operating with limited resources while tackling complex health disparities and challenges. This historical underinvestment now places us in an even more precarious position. As a city, we must be prepared to protect our communities from the potential wave of anti-science policies and funding cuts originating from the federal level. To do so, it's imperative that we provide the Chicago Department of Public Health with the resources it needs not only maintaining but strengthening its vital services. We must empower our local experts to continue their evidence-based work, ensuring that Chicago remains a beacon of public health grounded in science and dedicated to the well-being of all its residents. Today, we will hear from experts, advocates, and officials who can shed light on these critical issues and help us chart a path forward. Our goal is clear, to safeguard the health of our city, uphold the integrity of public health and science, and ensure that every Chicagoan has access to the care and protection they deserve. Thank you. Now we pass it to Alderman Quesada for some remarks, and we will move on. Thank you, Chair, and thank you to the members of the committee and the public for being here today. We call for this hearing because we're seeing two things at the same time. A rise in public health misinformation coming straight from the federal level, and a war against science from Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert Kennedy, and a rollback of critical funding that cities like ours depend on to keep people healthy. Let's start with the disinformation. Secretary Kennedy has repeatedly pushed conspiracy theories, things like vaccines causing autism or fluoride in drinking water causing cancer. These aren't harmless opinions. These are claims that have been thoroughly disproven by the scientific and medical community. But when they come from someone in charge of national health policy, they start to influence local decisions and erode public trust in science. We've already seen Florida rollback fluoride in its water supply. We've seen rising vaccine hesitancy, especially around COVID and childhood immunizations. That's left our communities more vulnerable to preventable diseases like measles. And in black and brown communities, these false claims carry added weight when they're wrapped in racist pseudoscience, like Kennedy's repeated suggestion that black people have different immune systems and need different treatment. That kind of thinking has a long and harmful history that has no place in public health. At the same time, federal funding for cities is being threatened. The loss of funding for our public health departments hurts real people. It means fewer resources for mental health clinics, fewer mobile health units, fewer neighborhood based outreach workers who can answer questions, offer vaccines and build trust. Our city cannot wait for things to get worse. Our city and our department of public health has to act now. We need to stay grounded in evidence-based public health policy, actively combat misinformation and disinformation, and build strong relationships with our state and county to secure funding from every possible source. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Alderman. Now we are going to move to introductions from our guests. So I would like to ask each of you to introduce yourself and then at the end of introductions, you can start doing your presentations in order. Good morning, everyone. My name is Mayra Diaz. I'm the Senior Policy Analyst at Health and Medicine Policy Research Group. Good morning, all. My name is Dr. Lee Francis and I'm the CEO of Erie Family Health Center, a community health center serving the Chicago metro area. Can you introduce yourself? Oh, you're with the second item. Thank you. All right, you can start. Okay. Good morning, Chairwoman Rodriguez Sanchez and members of the committee and city council. Thank you for the opportunity to speak today on this urgent topic. My name is Mayra Diaz, and I am the Senior Policy Analyst at Health and Medicine Policy Research Group. I'm here to discuss the critical need for policies that protect and strengthen our public health system, especially now as we face both an erosion of trust and underinvestment in public health at the federal level. We are living in a moment when federal-level misinformation, and quite frankly disinformation, are actively undermining public health, putting the safety and well-being of all Chicagoans at risk. Misinformation and disinformation do not just mislead or deny people access to credible, accurate health information. They are deadly forces that cost lives in our very own neighborhoods here in Chicago. We witnessed the detrimental harm of misinformation on our communities during the COVID-19 pandemic. False information regarding coronavirus and vaccines flooded the news cycle and social media networks, in great part by the actions of the current Secretary of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. This false information led some to mistrust and not get vaccinated against the potentially deadly coronavirus. Research by the Center for Countering Digital Hate from 2021 found that 65 percent of anti-vaccine content online was led by just 12 individuals known as the disinformation dozen, with Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. being among them. Efforts to intentionally mislead the public leave communities, particularly historically excluded communities, susceptible to dangerous health advice. In fact, research shows that black and brown communities are specifically targeted with disinformation, exploiting the historical injustices these communities have suffered by the medical system and perpetuating ongoing distrust and fears around health services that can help keep communities healthy, including vaccines, chronic disease prevention services, substance use interventions, and mental health support. Let's be clear, this is not by accident. Disinformation campaigns thrive in environments where people have historically been mistreated and feel unheard by the system. Here in Chicago, disinformation threatens to exacerbate long-standing health inequities, namely the life expectancy gap of over 11 years between black and other Chicagoans. Chicago's life expectancy gap is not merely a statistic. It is a daily lived reality for many communities and a direct result of systemic failures to protect health as a fundamental right. These inequities are made worse when false claims discourage people from seeking care, accessing vaccines, or trusting health information, leaving communities vulnerable to preventable illness and death. At the same time, underfunding of the Chicago Department of Public Health weakens our ability to respond with the accurate, culturally relevant guidance our communities need to make informed choices. With federal COVID-19 funds expiring at the end of this year and cuts to Medicaid and SNAP already enacted at the federal level, the City of Chicago must be responsive to these gaps. Without an increase in local funding, CDPH will lose critical capacity, leaving us unable to respond effectively to emerging threats and to the onslaught of misinformation with consistent, trusted local health guidance. Increased investment in our public health department will ensure that we are able to deliver an alternative to federal information sources to ensure access to credible evidence-based education on urgent public health issues, including chronic diseases, maternal and child health disparities, communicable diseases, the opioid crisis, mental health, and more. Fund and expand community health workers, the trusted messengers in our communities who help to engage residents, deliver accurate information, and help community members navigate health and social services. Strengthen our epidemiology and emergency preparedness capacity so that we can detect, communicate, and respond to new health threats before they escalate. And support trauma-informed policies and practices across city services, ensuring that residents who have been harmed by misinformation and disinformation, as well as health inequities, can engage with public health systems without fear. And much, much more. Chicago needs a public health department that is capable of countering misinformation, not only with research and facts, but also in close collaboration with other public health agencies, health providers, community-based organizations, and residents. To do this work well, CDPH needs adequate funding, staffing, and resources. Health and Medicine thanks Alderwoman Rodriguez-Sanchez, Alderman Anthony Quezada, for introducing the resolution under discussion today, and to the committee for elevating these important issues. We urge City Council to build on today's resolution by committing to protecting and expanding Chicago's public health infrastructure so that every resident, regardless of their background or what neighborhood they live in, has equitable access to accurate information and the care they need to live a healthy life. Thank you. Thank you for your statement, Dr. Francis. Thank you very much. And thank you, Chair Rodriguez-Sanchez, for inviting Erie to testify and for your recent visit to Erie Helping Hands in the mighty 33rd Ward. And shout out to Vice Chair Ramirez and, of course, Alder Fuentes, where we have a large penetration of patients in the mighty 26th. I am Dr. Lee Francis, and I'm very proud to represent Erie Family Health Centers today. We are a federally qualified health center, also known as a community health center. I've been the president and CEO at Erie since 2007 and a practicing physician there since 1991, which some people say was before penicillin was invented. As I said, Erie is a community health center. We serve and we are required to serve everybody, regardless of their insurance status, regardless of their ability to pay for services, and regardless of who they are. We believe that health care is a human right. Erie Family Health Centers is just one of 22 other federally qualified health centers in Chicago. And together with our peers, we operate more than 150 health centers located throughout the city in many of the wards. And an incredible statistic is that one out of every four Chicagoans gets their care at a community health center like Erie. Of the 13 Erie locations that you see, the purple Monopoly pieces on the screen here that are operated by Erie, we serve at health centers from North Lawndale to Humboldt Park up to Albany Park on the northwest side, operating 11 health centers in the city of Chicago, plus one serving Evanston Skokie and one in Waukegan. And I just want to point out the purple-yellow star on the far left, which will be Erie Family Health Center at the Sankofa Village Wellness Center, opening in early 2026 in West Garfield Park. And we're very proud of the partnership there on the west side. We serve 95,000 people in total. That's about four United centers. Nearly 15,000 of our patients live in or near the 33rd Ward, for example, and we have a heavy penetration in the 26th Ward and other wards around the city. Community health centers like Erie are primary health care homes that provide full-service, comprehensive, integrated health care. Under one roof, we've got medical services, dental services, mental health services, and social services. Again, under one roof, all stages of life from infants, children, pregnant people, teens, adults, seniors, regardless of ability to pay, and as I said before, who they are. And I want to thank various partners like the city of Chicago and the Chicago Department of Health because we are able to collaborate and to provide or connect our patients with various levels of behavioral health services from brief consultations under our roof when the primary care provider identifies that the patient has a mental issue, mental health issue, and provide a warm handoff to deeper care with substance use disorder treatment and psychiatry services. We are also proud to have the first teen health center in Humboldt Park dedicated to caring for young adults up to the age of 21, and that's right across from the 26th Ward office, so that's a great thing, too. And we do this all really well because Erie is ranked in the top 10% of community health centers nationally for the quality of our care, and in general, studies show that quality care, the quality of our care, care that health centers deliver is as good or even better than what patients might experience visiting a private practice. Yet the range of services is more broad and found under one roof, and it's also affordable for everyone. We trace our roots back to the civil rights movement. Some of the first community health centers in the country were here in Chicago, Miles Square Health Center, for example, on the west side. We are beyond disappointed in the federal government's extreme gutting of Medicaid now signed into law. While we remain committed to caring for all our patients regardless of their ability to pay, we are deeply concerned that this new law will result in many of our patients losing their health care coverage even though they may qualify. For Erie and community health centers across the country who care for 32.5 million people, one in nine people in Illinois, the loss of Medicaid income could strain our budgets, impact our ability to provide the breadth of services I just described, and put at risk our ability to serve future patients, including the influx of newly uninsured patients as a result of the bill in Washington. When whole groups of people in our communities lose coverage, they may turn to community health centers like Erie for care. And in fact, even Secretary Kennedy has cited community health centers as a fallback for people without insurance. However, we lose over $200 on every uninsured patient visit, and we don't get any new funding when we see more uninsured patients. And community health centers save Medicaid some $2 billion annually nationally. And the health system as a whole, $3 billion in annual savings. And that's because of prevention, prevention of unnecessary hospitalizations and emergency room visits, and preventing disease. While caring for people regardless of their insurance status is our mission, community health centers were not designed to see a massive influx of uninsured patients all at once. The more uncompensated services we provide, the more difficult decisions community health centers have to make. And we will need to make difficult decisions to ensure that we continue to care for as many patients as possible. We also know that insurance is much better for patients. Patients feel prouder. Patients with health insurance have more control over their health care. And people with insurance are much more likely to seek critical preventive services. For example, one in 10 Erie patients has diabetes. With Erie's help, 75% are successfully managing their diabetes. One in eight Erie patients has hypertension. With Erie's help, 77% are successful in managing their hypertension. Erie delivered one out of every 41 babies in Illinois last year. That's amazing. But access to affordable prenatal care is so important. And that is because 93% of our prenatal patients are insured by Medicaid, and cuts could affect that. In addition to any reductions to Title 10 family planning funding or federal Ryan White HIV-AIDS funding, both of which are at risk, this would have significant impact to Erie and community health centers, health departments, and the millions of people that we serve. In short, people's health will suffer because of these budget cuts. Emergency rooms will be saturated with people who do not need to be there with ambulatory sensitive conditions that can be easily taken care of for a fraction of the cost at the community level. Infectious diseases will spread more quickly, and health disparities will grow. Simultaneously, we're concerned that confusing and misleading rhetoric and scientifically unproven claims will have a similar detrimental impact on health outcomes. One example is vaccines. We are paying very close attention to changes to the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices, also known as ACIP. This group develops recommendations on the use of vaccines. In turn, these recommendations determine whether the federal government pays for vaccines made available through programs like Vaccines for Children program. The Vaccines for Children program makes life-saving vaccines available to more than half of the children in the United States. Erie's providers are aligned with all of our our professional medical organizations, including the American Academy of Pediatrics and the American Academy of Family Physicians, for example. We believe that vaccine safety is based in strong scientific evidence and has been proven by rigorous testing. Vaccination is one of the most highly effective tools that we have to prevent children and adults against serious illness and sometimes death from vaccine-preventable illness. Rolling back vaccine mandates may lead to a resurgence in a vaccine-preventable diseases like measles, as we have seen in other areas of the country and Illinois in past years, and polio. Polio. Lower vaccination rates could result in increased healthcare utilization as preventable diseases rise, and that would place place a strain on all health providers. The relationship between a patient and their healthcare provider must be built on trust. When confusing, sometimes intentionally misleading messaging is delivered from social media posts, from the highest levels of our government, it threatens this critical trust. A person who hears a message questioning vaccine safety from their governmental leaders may choose to skip that vaccine, regardless of whether or not the actual scientific proof exists. Similarly, an immigrant or a person from a mixed status family who feels a real or even perceived threat to their safety or the safety of their family may avoid unnecessary healthcare, or they may avoid enrolling in programs or services to which they are entitled, not to mention this increased fear and sustained anxiety can lead to both mental and physical problems. A combination of limited access to healthcare services and misinformation together will impact our whole healthcare system, including our hospitals and emergency rooms. When fewer people receive primary care, the more our emergency rooms will be saturated, leading to delayed emergency room services and higher healthcare costs for everyone. On behalf of Erie Family Health Centers, I call on our city's leadership to continue to provide public health recommendations rooted in clear scientific evidence and to continue to support initiatives that aim to reduce health disparities and improve the health of all Chicagoans. Thank you. Thank you so much, Dr. Francis, for your presentation. We are going to take questions now. I encourage you all to think about the community health centers that you have in your own words and your fears about what's going to happen with those institutions, the people that they serve. And Erie is a really valuable organization, but it is one of many federally qualified health centers that we have in the city of Chicago that are at risk of losing the ability to care for as many people as they do. So I do want you to think about your own communities and ask questions based on that. I would like to first ask Dr. Francis, I am very concerned because I have a really big undocumented population in my community and there is a risk risk that many of my neighbors are not going to be able to access care. Can you talk a little bit more about the threat to federally qualified health centers to their ability to be able to see undocumented people? You mentioned some aspects of it, but I think that there is more as I was having a conversation with the staff at the clinic. And then how does that impact the overall public health of the rest of the public when people decide that they are not able to access services? because they're scared or because there is just no no capacity thank you chair uh well first of all we believe that health care is a human right and that means health care for all and erie and i think all community health centers in the city and the state and the country we understand the intent the intent of executive orders we understand the intent of the health and human services rule which to which you're referring to which basically says that immigrants undocumented immigrants and other immigrants in our communities that you cannot use federal funds to provide services to those populations however these rules and executive orders have been issued without regulatory guidance and so without specific regulatory guidance we do not understand what change is being asked for in the rules and we cannot implement anything the health center program across the country the 32.5 million people the 1400 health centers across the country with over 7 000 delivery sites and i mentioned the stats for chicago the health center program which is funded by health and human services under which erie receives fund is dictated by federal statute it requires that health centers care for all patients that seek care within our service area and so we believe health care is a human right and we are grounded in the federal statute that requires care be delivered for all patients that seek care in our service areas and so ultimately that's where the conflict lies and that's where we're planting our flag in the sand and you're saying also that the capacity might become limited because a lot of people are going to seek care and there might not be capacity to see everybody correct when the for example when um health care and family services springfield state of illinois announced that the health benefits for immigrant adults program was ending well that was 2 000 patients that are that are ours but it's some thousands tens of thousands of patients across the state and uh we are still dedicated to serving those patients they will be on our sliding fee scale and they are welcome and at the same time the department of health care and family services says if you are losing your insurance you can please seek care at your local community health center well that's additional thousands of patients that would be new patients to us which would could be overwhelming depending on the capacity of the individual health center and that is um that is something that um we will be keeping a close eye on so when it comes to outreach to people that are losing the ability to get services elsewhere um do you feel like federally qualified health centers are equipped with the ability to do outreach or do you think that it won't be needed because people will just gravitate towards it we are well equipped uh to do outreach to 95 000 patients and their families uh for example um we use technology to reach our patients um almost all of our patients we've surveyed them they have smartphones and we use technology reaching out not only to say to our patients you're due for your flu shot or you haven't had your mammogram yet we need to see you or your diabetes is out of control we haven't seen you for six months please come in those would be text-based messages or phone calls we utilize technology such as my chart which is a technology that leverages our electronic health record for example we can also deliver other messages to our patients using technology depending on the need and the particular message that we need to deliver and that is immediate and the penetration of being able to deliver text messages to our patients is very high thank you my last question for now um i'm very concerned about the vaccination um situation right now and the fear of an outbreak if people follow the guidance that there is right now um what is at risk um what would happen if we end up with a measles epidemic uh nationwide do you have thoughts on how to go about that well again in in particular some of the vaccine preventable illnesses such as measles uh measles is extremely contagious much more contagious than even covid uh is was and is um measles requires a high percentage of the population to be vaccinated otherwise the disease can spread and uh we feel and i feel that uh patients and their families trust the information they receive within the four walls of community health centers that that that we are trusted providers and that although they may hear and see on the news um misinformation uh they are welcome to ask us and they do ask us that said there is a fair fairly significant degree of what we call vaccine hesitancy in the community and that means reluctance upon by the adult patient or the parent or guardian on behalf of the child to receive a vaccine and that is a constant struggle that we had before we were in this situation and so honestly we don't need it to be made worse by misinformation that's out there we are dedicated to delivering science-based public health-based information to our patients and to help them make the choices that they need to make thank you dr francis i'm going to pass it to my vice chair ramirez good afternoon good afternoon thank you so much for sharing your expertise you know i'm really grateful in my neighborhoods um places like esperanza health uic health um which is pretty neat they're actually located within one of my elementary schools and so they were they're able to service like the young people and the parents directly from that school um now that we're going to be going into budget season if there was one thing that we could prioritize through the department of public health you know what would be that one thing that you are now sitting in front of alders the second thing is wondering on a very local level what's something that we can do for better partnership um as alder alder woman rosana said um what's the best way to do outreach um because you know it's going to be a long three and a half years ahead so wondering what different ways that we can approach this um so i'll take a stab at that thank you very much and um i can't think of a better partner than esperanza health centers they are amazing and continue to be wonderful partners for all community health centers i think uh in terms of what can be done and priority areas especially for the department of health is number one uh continue the amazing um synergy that we have with mental health services in the community building upon the resources that we have for mental health services and multiplying those out at the multiple community health center sites around the city there is synergy there and there there are real real important services being delivered there the second thing is uh vaccines vaccines for children as it comes under um as vaccine information comes under attack from uh from outside the city i think the city department of health can continue to be a loud voice on uh um saying approaches and scientific approaches to vaccine and um for uh vaccine programs that are passing through the city uh from the state and the federal government to uh continue to advocate for those programs like vaccines for children but also other vaccine programs that provide free vaccines to adults and um so i will just concentrate on those things too the the last thing i will say is um title 10 family planning uh is something that the city should uh the city department of health should be supporting and fighting for uh so that the funding streams can continue out of wash and in D.C. that is under attack. And lastly, provision of HIV-AIDS services at the community level, some of which passes through the city Department of Health. It's extremely important to protect those very valuable resources that are federal pass-throughs through the Department of Health. Can I add something as well regarding the budget? I really want to emphasize that we know that at the end of this year, a significant portion of the Chicago Department of Public Health funding will go away due to the COVID-19 grants expiring. So we're talking about 41% of CDPH's grant dollars are coming from those COVID grants. In addition, 42% of CDPH's additional grant dollars are under threat given the federal administration's cuts to public health. So CDPH is in a pretty dire situation. And if we don't act quickly, you know, it can potentially be catastrophic for the health department. So in terms of what I would like to ask of the city council is health and medicine leads the fund public health campaign here in Chicago. And what we're asking for is for the budget to include an increase of $52 million. This is just a starting point. This by no means will fix everything, but it's just what we're asking for right now. And I think in terms of the second part of the question, which was around outreach, there's so many critical ways that the Chicago Department of Public Health can support that outreach and education. We need these additional funds in order to be able to maintain and expand our community health worker workforce so that they can provide that accurate information. Other programs such as nurse home visiting programs for new parents so that can receive the support and how to, how to, you know, care for their children in the first months of life. You know, education on communicable diseases, STIs, vaccinations, so many different things. And so we really, really just want to advocate and push for that additional funding. Amazing. Thank you guys for advocating for that. So heard you loud and clear. Thank you. Allerman Lawson. Thank you, Chair. And thank you, everyone, for being here. Just on my colleague's question, $52 million, would that be an increase over the 2025 budget, keeping all federal funds stable, even though we know we're going to be short there too? Yes. So we're requesting $52 million increase as compared to 2025. All right. That was just a, I have a couple of just other general questions. What vaccines are mandated right now? Is there anything you need? I'm not a parent. Is there anything you need to go to school? For example, for, to a public school, if you are going into the military, if you're going into healthcare work, is there any federal or state mandate for a vaccine currently? There is, there are about 10 childhood vaccines that are recommended by, by a certain age and we, we track those. So those are, those are mandated vaccines. They must be shown on school forms and filled out. And the rush is now for school physicals and all those forms are getting filled out. Yeah. So if someone does not have, so can I go to kindergarten without a measles vaccine? I believe there are, there believe there are ways to get waivers. So are people who are foregoing the vaccine, actually getting the waivers? And this may be for CDPH, you guys are here. Um, are they getting the waivers or are they just blowing it off and kids are still going to school? I can't say that I'm an expert on CPS policy on, but that would be Chicago public school policy about what kind of waivers, uh, for, you know, there might be a medical reason for not receiving a vaccine or there might be an allergy, uh, or there might be hesitancy to receive the vaccine. Those could be reasons. So, um, that kind of takes me to my next question where we say vaccine hesitancy as opposed to being anti-vax, right? Are we being too nice? Um, should we, should CDPH, should our local organizations be pushing back specifically on the things, uh, Kennedy is saying that are, have no basis in science? I mean, we, we will always be pro vaccine as a public health entity, right? As are your organizations. But when he says something ridiculous, should we address his statement head on or does that cause more problems? Um, do you think? We, in my opinion, we, we should address, uh, scientific, we should address, um, statements from public officials that are not scientifically sound with, uh, a response that says what the science is. That's a proven science and we should just be relentless in responding to that. And, uh, we should also explain the science in language that people can understand at their level of understanding, which I think is something that we could do better. So from the standpoint of government, uh, explaining, and this is something that health departments do very well is they take complex information and they put it on a poster in the CTA bus or on the L and that's something that people can understand, or they use short videos on social media or things like that, that it's cool to get your vaccine and things like that. We had a little bit of that during COVID, for example. I love that stuff. Um, I was part of the crystal breaks campaign 20 years ago to talk about the dangers of crystal meth in the LGBT community. And Alderman, the longer the needle, the cooler it is. Yeah. Yeah. Right. There you go. There you go. Um, uh, let me, uh, just, oh, do we consider disinformation as a barrier, as a barrier to healthcare? Does that, has that become, you know, in addition to being housed or insured or all the other factors that go in, do we consider disinformation to be one of those factors, those barriers? Yes. Misinformation is a barrier to healthcare and misinformation can be publicly stated. It also could be beliefs in certain communities or cultural beliefs, which, uh, we respect cultural beliefs and cultural, um, historical, cultural values. And so sometimes we, we work with those as well. And I think in the community level, we're used to, uh, approaching our patients and our, our neighbors in that way. Great. And then I think my last question, you know, thinking about the FQHCs that serve, um, our neighborhoods, um, I have the Howard Brown flagship right on Halstead, uh, in my ward. And, uh, several times over the last few years, we have had outbreaks, whether that was meningitis or MPOX, who knows what may come next. It was specific to, uh, LGBT folks, gay men. Um, we had a rapid response of vaccines, uh, meningitis is a lot faster than MPOX certainly, but, um, that all come, that's all directed and controlled by the federal government. That's my understanding. If, if we're, if we're having an outbreak that, that, that vaccine access and, and correct me if I'm wrong on that, but then the second part is, are we concerned about having that same kind of response? If we have another outbreak of any kind in any community that requires vaccine? I think that, um, underfunded health departments could lose their ability to do rapid responses. It is the role of public health departments to respond rapidly to outbreaks of infectious disease. That would mean city and county health departments and state health departments with the support of agencies like the CDC. And so when there are outbreaks, uh, if staff is understaffed, if, uh, health departments are underfunded, uh, then the response could be slower. Uh, the supplies, uh, vaccines could be more limited and, um, that could lead to higher risk of vaccine preventable illnesses spreading. So just to follow up and we're not seeing though, that we're like, they're not, uh, decreasing the stockpile of certain vaccines. They haven't started to do that yet. As far as I know, no, as far as we know, no, right. Thank you both very much for everything that you do. Erie does amazing work. The, uh, the, the, the, what we have seen is that, um, certain vaccines would no longer be officially recommended by the advisory council on immunization practices, ACIP, and then insurance plans would be less likely to cover those vaccines. And then that at the end of the vaccine chain or food chain, whatever you want to call it, then, uh, people might be less likely to elect to receive a vaccine because it's not covered by their insurance. So the, the ACIP, the, uh, um, um, immunization practices, um, uh, council that I described earlier, it's extremely important to have that official seal of approval so that insurance companies follow that. Great. Thank you again. And for all the work that you're, you're, you're doing with Erie and, and, and the research, um, I think we saw in January right away that people are going to. sicker. And that started with HIV prevention, and it's moved into, obviously, the draconian cuts that are happening to health care coverage. So, again, thank you for everything you do. We've got a long road ahead. Thanks. Thank you, Vice Chair. Do I have any more questions from members? No? Okay. Thank you, both of you, for being here with us today. I really appreciate your expertise and the information that you have provided. A reminder that CDPH is going to be presenting last, and that we can ask them questions about any of the items that we are discussing at the end of their presentations. Thank you. Thank you for your help. We are now going to move to item number two on the agenda. Do we have word from Alderwoman Haddon? She's not. She's not coming. Hi. Good afternoon. Alderwoman Haddon got called to jury duty today. Okay. So, let me present the item, and then I'm going to pass it to you. Okay. Item two on the agenda is R-2024-0014414, which was introduced by Alderwoman Haddon, calling for hearings on the allocation of HIV-AIDS grants funding. To begin, there was a substitute to this resolution discussed through the evening, and Leslie Perkins from Alderperson Haddon's office is here to outline the substance of the changes, which I understand to primarily update statistics used. Thank you, Leslie, for being here. You can speak on the changes, and then we will accept the substitute. Thank you, Chairwoman. Yeah. So, as Chairwoman Rodriguez-Sanchez said, the substitute before you updates many of the statistics to more recent data. And then in the final paragraph, we also changed some of the language to reflect that funding be allocated to high-impacted community areas where the rate of infection is 21.9 per 100,000 individuals. And that is just to ensure that the most impacted communities receive, you know, proportionate funding. And then if you want to pass that, or I can hold off on reading the statement from Alderwoman. Yeah, give me one second. We're going to accept the substitute, and then you can read the opening statement. Can I get a motion to accept the substitute for R 2024-001-4414? Alderperson Casada so moves. All those in favor say aye. Opposed say nay. In the opinion of the Chair, the ayes have it. And the substitute is on the floor. Leslie, take it away. Thanks so much, Chairwoman. Good afternoon. Thank you to Commissioner Dr. Ige, the Black Coalition, and members of the Committee on Health and Human Relation for attending today's committee meeting. I'd also like to give a special thank you to Alderman Robinson for his partnership and collaboration as a co-sponsor on this resolution. Chicago's Black communities continue to be disproportionately impacted by HIV and AIDS. This preventable and treatable disease remains one of the top five drivers in the nearly nine-year life expectancy gap between Black and white residents identified in the Healthy Chicago 2025 assessment. In 2020 alone, Black Chicagoans, who make up less than 30% of our population, accounted for over half of the all-new HIV diagnoses, AIDS diagnoses, and late-stage HIV infections. In response, CDPH committed to prioritizing racial equity and investing in culturally competent care. Yet, between 2019 and 2024, only 4.46% less than $2 million of the department's $40 million in HIV and AIDS budget went to Black-led organizations. This is unacceptable. We cannot address a public health crisis in Black communities without resourcing Black-led community-based organizations. We cannot make progress on closing the racial life expectancy gap if we continue to underfund the very communities facing the greatest burden. I would like to acknowledge that this hearing takes place during a critical juncture for our communities. Local health departments are under attack from an antagonistic federal administration determined to roll back and defund public health initiatives. This is exacerbated by sweeping executive orders issued by Trump targeting diversity, equity, and inclusion. Today, we will hear testimony on how the historic allocation of these funds has led to systemic failures that have resulted in the life expectancy gap between Black and white communities. We will also hear testimony about how the federal government clawing back critical funds meant to prevent disease and keep our communities healthy. With this, we are left asking how we can toe the line of meeting federal guidelines while closing racial health disparities. Under this Trump regime, we unfortunately cannot address the issues of funding equity without examining how federal DEI rollbacks have hindered HIV and AIDS responses. With all that, we cannot allow a repressive federal government to define the future of Chicago's health. The decisions on how we allocate funding have a cascading effect, which is why it is incumbent upon this body to explore creative solutions to ensure equitable funding. Thank you, Leslie, and my gratitude to Chairwoman Havan for bringing this item to us. Now, we are going to have our guests introduce themselves and do their presentation. Good morning, Counsel. My name is Vance White. I'm the Executive Director of the School of Opulence. Okay. I want to first say that today I'm showing up as a Black man first, and then second, I'm showing up as a Black gay man. That's important to what I have to say. My name is Vance White. I am the Executive Director of the School of Opulence, newly located at 1817 East 71st Street in the 7th Ward. Our alderman is Gregory Mitchell. With the privilege of sharing Alderman Desmond Yancey right across the street in 6th Ward, and a proud member of Black, the Black Leadership Advocacy Coalition for Healthcare Equity. And I'm standing here today because I'm tired while I'm sitting, but I'm still tired. Tired of watching the city of Chicago through CDPH maintain a status quo that systemically excludes Black-led organizations from equitable funding. Tired of seeing our communities underfunded, overlooked, and extracted from, all while our labor, trust, and cultural currency keep entire systems afloat. For decades, Black-led HIV-AIDS service organizations have been doing the work on the ground, in the streets, at kitchen tables, in our living rooms, in churches, shelters, duty salons, and even on sidewalks. We serve the most impacted people in the most impacted communities with the least amount of support. And yet, when it comes to public dollars, we are treated as an afterthought, or even worse, a checkbox. Let me give you just one example. The recent HOPWA RFP from CDPH, in the scoring breakdown, community reach, the very thing that defines whether an organization has deep ties and trust in a community, was giving zero points. Zero. Meanwhile, organizational infrastructure was giving 30. When we talk about systemically racial funding practice, this is the evidence of that. That says a clear message. It's not about who knows the community or who's been showing up. It's about who has the back office and bandwidth to manage bureaucracy. That's how systemic disinvestments get hidden behind technical language. This is how CDPH has been operating, elevating institutions that already have wealth and access, historical access that Black-led organizations have not had, while leaving Black-led orgs to fight for scraps. And it's not just about HOPWA. It's about a pattern across HIV-AIDS grants where the same few players receive funding cycle after cycle, even when they don't reflect the people they serve, while newer community embedded orgs are denied the chance to scale, like the School of Opulence, and like many organizations with the Black Leadership Advocacy Coalition for Healthcare Equity. All of this is happening while federal government is actively slashing DEI and has launched a war against Black Americans and equity protections. So here in Chicago, we should be doubling down on our commitments to racial equity, not using unscored sections and vague promises as substitutes for accountability. We know what equity looks like because we've lived without it. It looks like assigning value to community first. It looks like scoring community reach the same way you score infrastructure. It looks like hiring from within, paying fairly, and funding those who are closest to the pain and the solutions. I'm not here asking for charity. I'm here demanding justice. Our communities deserve better, and we will not be silent while CDPH continues to build systems that reward privilege and punish proximity. We are not going to fix racial health disparities by ignoring the very people who have been holding up this city. It's time to fund Black-led HIV AIDS service organizations, not just because it's fair, but because it's effective and it's long overdue. Let me be clear. This isn't about whether the people at CDPH care, because I personally, deeply in my heart, believe. Many of them do. I know it for a fact. But intentions don't correct systems. Policies do. And policy without enforcement is just decoration. If equity is truly a guiding principle, then it must guide the money. And when the dollars don't follow the communities most impacted, that's not a gap. That's a strategy. You cannot measure equity by the presence of a few questions in the grant application. You measure equity by who gets funded, how often and how sustainably. And if we are to lay the data bare, we'd see that black led HIV AIDS organizations are still treated as marginal players in a crisis crisis. We've disproportionately born. Many of us work and live the lion's share of us work and live in the communities that are affected the most. The HIV epidemic is in Chicago has always had a racial dimension. Black people make up less than a third of the city's population, but account for nearly half of the new HIV diagnosis. We are still dying faster, living sicker, getting less support to address the root causes. Yet we're expected to partner with institutions that have historically received funding to serve us without us. That's not collaboration. That's appropriation. Some of us call that sharecropping. Let's talk about what it feels like on the ground. You write a grant for 60 plus hours, pulling staff away, volunteer hours for organizations that can afford grant writers. Who need housing, meds and mental health support. You submit it. Then you're told your agency lacks infrastructure that your narrative didn't show enough innovation. Meanwhile, organizations with no history of serving our neighborhoods are what are six figure contracts. They get the check. We get the burden because they just spend the block and come back to us and say, hey, we want to subcontract you for a lesser amount. And it's not just about dollars is about dignity. Every time our applications are rejected without feedback, every time we're left out of strategic planning tables, which that is often the case, every time the metrics ignore what community trust looks like, we lose people. We lose time. We lose lives. This isn't theoretical. This is real harm. We don't need more task forces or listening sessions. We know what the issues are. We've had many of those over the years. We need action. We need a reallocation of trust and resources. CDPH has the power to restructure its funding processes so that lived experience matters as much as a 501c3 status. Community reach should not be a formality. It should be the foundation. Imagine what we could do if black-led organizations were truly invested in, not just included. Imagine if our labor was met with funding, our trauma with healing and our vision with resources. We also deserve sustainable careers. We also deserve job security. We also deserve health care benefits. We deserve those things. We also deserve to retire from doing this hard work with something that can support our lives after the work. We are not here to decorate your equity reports. We are here to demand a seat, a say, and our share. To every council member here today, I ask you not to just hear us, but to act. Call for a racial equity audit of CDPH funding practices, require transparency in who gets funded and why, demand scoring systems that reflect lived impact, that sit at the intersection of equity, not just back-end capacity, and ensure black-led organizations are no longer a lifeline for saving funds. Chicago cannot afford to continue funding inequality under the guise of public health. Our people deserve more, and I will continue to stand in the gap until that more becomes reality. Thank you again for your time, your ears, and hopefully for your courage. Good afternoon, chair and committee members. My name is Vanessa Smith, and I serve as the executive director of Southside Help Center, a black-led organization founded by my late mother, Betty Smith. I've been the executive director since 2008, but I've worked there since I was a wee child. Just kidding. But, you know, we have been on the forefront of this HIV and AIDS crisis since 1987, and we have a wide variety of programs at Southside Help Center. We're a Ryan White provider, and probably the largest African-American-led ASO, AIDS service organization in the city of Chicago. And, unfortunately, we are also only maybe two of all the 20 organizations funded through the Chicago Department of Public Health. Only two black organizations, I want to say, are funded through the Chicago Department of Public Health to provide Ryan White services, and we are one. We have a fleet of mobile units on the south side of Chicago that provides at least 4,000 tests annually. And so, despite our deep roots, trusted presence, and proven impact, we have been consistently underfunded. The black coalition's analysis shows that only 4% of CDPH's $40 million goes to black-led organizations. It's just not a number. It is a reflection of a painful, ongoing pattern that we all know too well as black-led organizations. That underinvestment is not accidental. It is structural. It is systemic. It is racism. For decades, black-led organizations have had to do more with less, while larger, white-led institutions receive the bulk of the funding, even when they serve the same populations as we do, often without the same cultural insight or community trust. You know, we're not just asking for charity. We're asking for equity. And we raise these concerns at a time when diversity, equity, and inclusion efforts are being rolled back across the country. That rollback isn't just happening in an abstract policy. It is showing up in real ways. Funding applications are being scrubbed for DEI language. Longstanding equity frameworks are being quietly retired. The result is a chilling effect. Organizations like ours are once again left to wonder if we will be left behind, despite being the ones closest to the work and the communities most affected. Southside Health Center has been around for a very long time. And through every wave of the epidemic, because our communities need us, we didn't wait for permission. We didn't stop when the headlines did. We've done the work faithfully, but without equitable funding. We are operating at a disadvantage that no amount of passion can overcome. This resolution is a necessary step to acknowledge and begin correcting that injustice. It speaks truthfully about the disparities. It restores crucial language that validates the experience of black-led CBOs, and it affirms the principle that where the impact is the greatest, the investment should follow. I want to thank the committee for their time and leadership, Representative Lamont Robinson, if you can hear me. Well, Alderman Robinson. Thank you so much for helping to build the resolution, as well as our fearless leader, Cruella Hampton, the leader of the Black Coalition, for helping to pull together this resolution, because it's definitely required at a time like these. Big shout-out to Alderman Haddon, too. She sponsored it. Absolutely, absolutely really appreciated it. It was support that was needed, that we were fighting for, especially after Alderman Sawyer. It was just to be able to pick it up and to bring it forth and to continue that work on, because so many lives depend upon it, yeah. Thank you both for your testimony. I want you to know that this is a very friendly space to you, that we want to work with you, that I think that this is being discussed at a very important moment, because we're about to go into budget, and we need to be having these conversations about equity, particularly in this moment that we're witnessing. And your statements were brilliant. We really like that here. I have a couple of questions for both of you. I am shocked to hear that bigger organizations get grants, and then they subcontract some of your organizations to deliver the work. And I would like to learn more about that. Can you give me maybe an example of money distribution on a grant where it goes to the big organization, and they come to you to deliver the work? What is the percentage, right? Like if there is, I don't know, like a $100,000 grant that this organization got, how much are they giving you for the work that you are delivering? Either of you have, like? Well, first of all, I would like to say that we were just in a room yesterday, me and my colleagues, we were just in a room yesterday. And thank you. Thank you. Because the state is allocating funding specifically for black-led HIV service providers, A service providers, but the city of Chicago has allocated zero. So we were dealing with this issue on different levels, right? We're dealing with the state and locally. An example of that is larger institutions have a larger overhead. Majority of the money that comes from these grants go to administrative costs, right? It feels that way. So that if there's $100,000, in our particular situation, we're a smaller organization. We just opened up a new office in South Shore. We have a satellite site in Kankakee. $100,000 to us is the world. It's the difference between some of our staff paying their bills or not. However, if that same $100,000 is given to a larger organization, they're going to take a chop off of it. They're going to take a chop for their administrative costs, right? And what seems to happen is and what has happened historically is some organizations are taking a larger administrative cost from the funds than they allow the subgrantees to do. So an organization may take 15%. For example, an organization may take 15% just for administrative costs, right? But then when they subcontract us, they will only allow us to take 7% to 10% for administrative costs. So that means that we have less money to pay light bill, gas bill, lease. That means that we have less money to pay for supervision or administration of the grant, right? To add to that, because of this cutting this money, because they cut this money off, we can't pay livable wages all the time, right? We can't afford the health care that we sit in these rooms and say that everybody deserves. We can't, and that is important. I'm sitting here right now, and I can't afford health care in my own organization. We can't afford the employment taxes. And the reality of the situation is that we're currently left out as black-led organizations. Thank you. So I do want to just say that, you know, systemically, over the course of the 40 years, nearly 40 years, that Southside Health Center has been funded by the health department, public health. We have seen funds from $50,000 in direct grant allocations to maybe $150,000, and then back down to $95,000. But all the while, you know, we were receiving, you know, $100,000, you know, the other organizations are receiving a half million dollars. This particular last round of funding to Southside Health Center, we were awarded a pretty decent amount of funding, but we were instructed that we had to, you know, self-contract. And, unfortunately, the self-contract arrangement probably only allowed us to give the organization $50,000, okay? And so that's what we're talking about. I mean, that's not really enough to hire a full-time person to do the work and or to, you know, an outreach worker, you know, to go out and provide HIV-AIDS education. We do receive pass-through funding from several larger organizations. And, again, those pass-through dollars are usually under $100,000. And, you know, with the rate of salaries and minimum wage, that's really just enough to cover one employee and services. So that's usually what it's like. Now, don't get me wrong, we're also funded by the Department of Family Supported Services, and those grants are very small, too. Got it. One more question on that same vein. And if you don't have this number, I can work with you and with the department to try to figure it out because I think it's important. Go ahead. Thank you so much. Do you have a sense of what percent of the work that is supposed to be done by the bigger organizations is actually subcontracted to smaller black-led organizations? Do you have a sense of how much of that work you take on? That's easy. We take on all of it. So, no, I mean, just it is. So they get the largest part of it is the trust. Howard Brown, I think that to your last question, Howard Brown and Central Halstead were awarded more than $3 million, and they subcontracted $100,000 to five or six black-led CBOs to do the work, right? So when you subcontract to smaller organizations to do the work, we are doing the work. You got the money, and you hired us to do the work. That is – and what it is is it's saying that you are good enough to toil, but you are not good enough to reap. You know what I'm saying? That's not true investment. We don't get to invest into our organizations. We only get enough to simply pay our workers something that, you know, us as a city, we've taken the position as a city that the median average – the median average income is about $72,000 a year. We've taken the position that it requires about $65,000 to live comfortably in the city, and we're okay with paying the people who do this hard work with community, dealing with mental health every day, dealing with health issues, dealing with homelessness, dealing with food insecurity. We've made it okay to say that it's okay to only pay them $42,000 a year, $46,000 a year. So, yes, they get the money, and we have to then do the work and figure out the rest. Well, the key issue is that the money is just not going into the black communities, right? And that's problematic. You know, the larger white-led organizations are getting the money, and then there's some trickle-down economics that are happening with these funds. You know, we're not getting enough to really address the issue. And, you know, just recently with these potential, you know, Medicaid cuts, you know, we're going to see an increase. We're going to see an increase in STIs. We're going to probably see an increase in HIV and AIDS infections. There may be even an outbreak, another outbreak of inbox, right? And so we're – but we're not ready. We're not equipped because we're not receiving our fair share of the funding. Again, remember, only 4% of $40 million – what is that, like $1.5 million – that went to black-led organizations throughout the city of Chicago. Thank you so much. Do I have questions for members? Lawson? You know I always have questions, Madam Chair. Actually, I just have two quick ones. Most of mine are for CDPH. But if for some reason I don't ask CDPH, can we get a full list of all of the grantees in that $40 million through the chair? Yes, that can be provided through the chair. Because I know a lot of that is Ryan White money, right? And so it's federal money that's coming to us and that we're distributing, and that's all on the table, unfortunately, is the fear here. But the only other question I had is, is there a definition of a black-led organization? Is there, like, sort of an agreed-upon definition that you can share? So the state has a definition of a black-led organization, which is not the position that we have as the Black Leadership Advocacy Coalition for Healthcare Equity. The state's definition of a black-led organization is 51% of your board has to be, you know, African-American. That's the state's definition. Is it anything else? Yes. And the leadership of the organization is – Not the leadership. No. It's a black-led. Well – 51% of your board must be black-led. You must operate in a predominantly black community. And – I'm sorry. Good question. Operate in a predominantly black community. And there is one other qualifier. It's slipping me right now. But the reality of it is the city of Chicago doesn't have its own definition of what a black-led organization is. And that is something that we need to establish. One second, ma'am. One second. She can use the mic. Oh, can she? Yes. Oh, yes, yes, yes. Yes, please, if you want to come to the mic over here to the middle. Yeah. Perfect. Oh, sorry, Jonathan was coming. Thank you. Yes, the – the Illinois Department of Public Health – Can you please identify yourself? Oh, I'm sorry. My name is Criola Kizart-Hampton. I am the chair of Black – it is the Black Leadership Advocacy Coalition for Healthcare Equity in Illinois. We comprise approximately 23 African-American-led organizations across the state of Illinois, 19 of them which are in Chicago. So there is legislation that was passed, a law called the African-American HIV AIDS Response Law that was passed in 2006 by the Illinois Department of Public Health that is funded by the state of Illinois through GRF funding. It is the only one of its kind that exists in the entire United States that specifically identifies what an African-American-led organization is and specifically has funding that goes to African-American-led organizations. And the criteria is one is that they have a board that is more than 50 percent African-American. This will be a board that is more than 50 percent ethnic groups withafegilism on the armed community and so on 거야. And two is that their headquarters is located in a community where the residents identify, the majority of the residents identify as being African-American. And then three, the other criteria is that the majority of the clients that they serve identify as being African-American. And then, of course, that they have GATA certification and are approved as a nonprofit organization by the state of Illinois. So Chicago Department of Public Health has been the head of Dr. Ige, she is working with, and like Allison Arwadi. So previous predecessors were working with CDPH and Dave Kern, who is head of the Syndemic Disease Department, which houses the HIV-AIDS division under CDPH. Also work with the Illinois Department of Public Health, Dr. Vorhar and others, in terms of interfacing to ensure that the definitions are pretty consistent. Yeah, I just want to add, you know, because, again, Southside Health Center has been funded since 1995 from the Centers for Disease Control. And so I just want to add this particular definition. Part of, in the 1990s, CDC tried to address this inequity, this funding inequity, right? And part of the definition that we came up with back then was also not only all three of those, but the other fourth component was that the leadership of the organization had to be 50% African-American. The executive leadership, the executive leadership, not just the board, but also the employees in executive leadership positions. And I just want to make sure that we also perhaps consider that as well in the future. Let me add one other thing. It should be noted, again, there is a law. And during the last funding legislation period for the state of Illinois, GRF funding was allocated directly to the African-American HIV Response Act, the law. And what we are asking for is that type of law be instituted here in the city of Chicago to mirror the dedication of funding allocation. Because other than that, there are zero funds from the city of Chicago that are allocated to African-American-led organizations. And to fortify those two statements, what the pattern that we're starting to see is that historically white-led organizations who've historically had a board that comprised, that the lion's share of the board was white and sometimes didn't have any black people. So it seems like there is some strategy to maneuver the board in the position of being 51% African-American to be able to shield themselves with that, to be able to apply for funds that are intended, that the legislators are intending to go to black historically. You know, at its core, you know, at its core, black-led organizations, black-founded, black executive directors, 51% of the board is black, communities that are served as 51% or more are black. And those things, those are important as we, you know, begin to talk about what the definition of it is for Chicago. Thank you. Go ahead. That's very, very helpful. I was on an aid service organization board many years ago, and I think all of them are intentionally trying to diversify their boards because they're trying to diversify their boards. I'm not sure that it's funding related, but they want to look like the population that they serve better and get away from the white gay guys, which there's plenty of. I won't say too many, but I know that's been a goal, to better be able to serve the populations where they are and to get off of the North Lakefront and get into the neighborhoods all over the city. So I'm glad to hear that there's still partnerships. It sounds like they need to be a little more equal and that, you know, once you are doing the work under this grant, the next year makes sense to me that you would be the grantee. Has that happened at all? No. Okay. So, you know, back then we used to call it Chasing the Dollars. Give me one second because I want to correct something. Carola, would you like to join them in the box? Because I see you, you have a lot to say, and I'm not sure why we didn't put you on the speaker box, but you're completely welcome to sit with them in the box so you can answer the questions. Yeah, so I did just want to say that people were chasing the dollars, organizations were chasing the dollars. And during a time when they saw that the epidemic was shifting to more communities in the African-American neighborhoods, white organizations started to open up shop in those communities without even so much as reaching out to the organizations that were in those communities to collaborate. And it was only until, like, forced collaboration in the, you know, recently that those, that happened. Otherwise, they would, you know, come, set up shop in, say, the Roseland neighborhood or South Shore neighborhood without reaching out to some of the local organizations in those neighborhoods. There's a lot of fiefdoms in this work, though, too, I know. Right. But I, but, but I could definitely appreciate that. I'm sorry, you're going to add. No, primarily what I wanted to add to your point about what we are trying to ensure is that the organizations that are doing the work are directly funded versus indirectly funded, because then, again, what happens is this sharecropping practice. So we have organizations, so you may or may not be aware is that, okay, the, for CDPH, typically, historically, approximately 25% of the funding from CDPH goes to AIDS Foundation of Chicago across the board. And then AFC, which gets between 12 to 13 million dollars of the funding, then subcontracts, 12 to 19 black-led organizations totaling $2 million of the $12 million that they get. This is information that they provided us with to do a lot of the work in African-American communities. So you have 12 to 15 organizations splitting $2 million. Now, they do, when they get subcontracted, they do not get in their subcontract funds for administration. It's direct care only, understanding what you were saying. And so if AFC gets $12 million, they may get $2 million of that to use for administration so that they can pay staff benefits and operational dollars. But the organizations that are doing the work, when they get the grants, there is no funding in there for them to provide employees with health care insurance or other things that they need or with operational dollars. They have to use it specifically for direct services. So when they hire a person, they will have to pay that person $40,000, whereas if somebody at AFC or the other organizations like Howard Brown, Center on Halstead, they can hire someone and pay them $60,000 to do the same amount, the same work. And the same happens on the side of the state. So, again, this is not just about funding. It is about equitable funding to African-American-led organizations. That's the crux. Yeah. My recommendation is that we increase the budget of about $15 million. And so especially, you know, funding that comes directly from the city, not necessarily the federal dollars, but, you know, the money that comes from the city of Chicago. And so that that money can be earmarked to African-American-led organizations. That's my recommendation. For sure. Similarly to what's done on the state level. If there is an allocation, we have a law. Again, it's passed in 2006. So if there is an allocation that is set so that funding is separate, that goes directly to African-American-led organizations because of the high rate, just look at the cost of the height rate and the high death rate that's going on in our communities, is that it's justifiable based on the incidents and based on the budget. So even if the budget is decreased, it's still percentage-wise. If the percentage is allocated based on the percentage of the rate and the incidence of disease, that is what we're asking. And let's be clear, CDPH, I heard, you know, doctors say earlier that CDPH would be losing or the lady CDPH would be losing a certain amount of money, a large part of its budget. I greatly doubt that that loss from CDPH will affect black-led organizations anyway because we don't receive the funds that would be affected by that, right? See you next time. And it's so what the biggest disheartening part of it is, is that we always have to couple our issues as black people. We always have to couple our issues with other issues to get visibility. We have been meeting with CDPH AFC state for two years. Like we've been in this fight for for for equity and funding. We've been going back and forth to Springfield. We've been, you know, engaging community and bringing them along. But, you know, this is an issue that should be handled separately. It shouldn't have to be coupled with other issues. Now that we have this funding situation, the administration is attacking poor people, launching war on, you know, the LGBT community, completely targeting trans people, trans experience. We shouldn't have to couple these issues all the time to get some type of effect. We've been here fighting. We've been here with, you know, surviving through inequity. I do feel like because of the funding cuts federally, that it may place us in a position again to where people are saying, hey, we need to solve for everybody again. But we've been standing here for decades saying, hey, we still ain't got it yet. We hear you. Yeah. Like I said, I've been we've been around for 40 years and I've never seen any funding equity. In the last 40 years of receiving Chicago Department of Public Health, I really do believe that it's time for us to make a change. Creola said earlier, you know, insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results. And if we are ever to get down to zero, to get zero new infections, then we have to make an investment in the black community, in the black, historically black community based organizations. Do you have something else? I 100 percent agree. And I want to thank you for all the important work you're doing every day. That's it, Chair. Alderman Casada. Thank you, Chairwoman. I just have a couple of questions. I wonder if the chair may know. Do we know the amount of annual funding that CDPH has towards HIV AIDS? As I see here, they the in the resolution language, it says that there's 40.4 million dollars in HIV AIDS budgets that annual. Or is that over the past 20 or between 2019 and 2024? Do we know that? Go ahead. Let's think that's annual. That that that that is a that is an annual figure. So annually, it's 40 million dollars. Yes. The entire city. 40.4 million, 40.4 million dollars. The I believe that, though, the majority, the majority of that, it does come from the federal federal versus the state and versus and versus the city. So and and and of that 40 million, there is a portion of it that is mandated to go to like a that for for drug for drug assistance and some of it to go specifically for medical medical care. So some of it is already, you know, dictated as to how it is is allocated. And then there is a certain portion of it. I believe it's about 25 million that ends up then going to community based organizations. Got it. So I guess my my first question that I'm trying to clarify or the information I'm trying to clarify is in the substitute resolution. One, two, three, four, five. Yeah, the fifth clause, it talks about, you know, according to research from the coalition in 2019 through 2024, the Chicago Department of Public Health allocated a total of one point eight million dollars to African-American and black led community based organizations of its 40.4 million dollar HIV AIDS budget. So you're saying that the 40.4 million dollars is annual, right? Yes. So between 20, 20, 20, 2019 and 2024, has that been 40 million dollars each of those years or has it increased or decreased over those past six years? There has been, to my knowledge, little, little fluctuation in the allocation. As a matter of fact, I think. I think there have been some years that it went up to like forty three million dollars, a little bit inched up a little bit. And but again, at this point, we based on what's happening in Washington, we're expecting, you know, their fiscal year typically is June to June. We're looking at, you know, we're looking at, you know, we're looking at, you know, we're looking at, again, dramatically. Well, I could, let me tell you, as a grantee, for 2025, there has been a decrease in funding. And that's possibly due to, again, the rollbacks that Trump is doing. So we have been getting contracts in pieces. So we've gotten a contract for, you know, our original grant was about three hundred thousand dollars. And so for this year, we received only twenty five percent of that in a contract. So about sixty, sixty five thousand. Got it. So thank you. And I guess I'm still just trying to make sure I land on this properly. So if between that period of twenty nineteen and twenty twenty four, that would mean somewhere north of two hundred million dollars that the city of Chicago had for HIV that spent for HIV and AIDS budgeting. So you're saying in between that two hundred million dollar plus six year period, you all only received one point eight million dollars totally or one point eight million dollars each year. Each year. Each year. OK, thank you. OK, so I'm just trying to clarify. So each year you receive one point eight million dollars of that forty million dollars. Got it. OK, so I know they are all representing different organizations here. Can you tell me which year your organizations were established? Mine was 1987. We were officially established in February of twenty twenty two. I was I'm looking at a list of the organizations. Some of them you may know my name, task force prevention and community services. It is on the west side and they were established. They are celebrating their thirty fifth year anniversary. As a matter of fact, they were one of the leaders of the pride parade this year. It was the first time that in the fifty five year history of the pride parades that a community based organization was actually chosen to lead. And task force, which provides services for black LGBTQ youth. Again, I know they're celebrating their thirty fifth year anniversary. TCA health, which is located in Altgear Gardens. They were established 15 years ago. Transforming reentry services, which was formerly called men and women in prison ministries. They have been around for at least 30, at least 30 years. Universal Family Connections, which was established by Dr. Lorraine Brorles. It was established in 1985. Lighthouse Foundation of Chicago. It was just established five years ago. Jamie Frazier. Life is work. It was just it is a transgender led organization on the west side of Chicago. It was just established, I think, three years ago. Brave Space Alliance. It's it's chair Shannon Lynn Parker. And it was established, I believe, like seven, seven years ago. Community Supportive Living Systems, which was established in 1983 by Herschel Gamble. They had multiple grants for HOPWA. That's housing for people living with housing for people living with AIDS. Proactive Community Services. They are on the far south side of south suburbs. And they were established, I think, you look, you established by Eula Burge in 1987 as well. Project Vida, they are led by an African, Jerome Montgomery is the chair, and they were established in the mid-1980s. So we have a variety of organizations that were established, many of them in the 1980s and 1990s, and then some that have been established within the last five to seven years. Thank you very much. I appreciate you reading that into the record. So I guess this is going to be this is a little bit too much of a going into the weeds, but I was just wondering how many patients, you know, each of you all, your organization serve. But maybe we could just get that through through the chair. And the reason why I'm asking these questions is to uplift, you know, I think, a message that we're talking about here with equity. I mean, it is very disappointing that, you know, of all those organizations that you named, that only $1.8 million went to each of those or to that coalition of organizations each year. That's just recently. I can't even imagine what that number was previously. This is definitely a real bad situation we're uncovering here. I think this whereas clause really highlights the impact of the lack of equity that we're talking about here, which was that African-Americans make up 42% of new HIV diagnoses, 49% of A diagnoses, and 37% of late HIV diagnoses, despite comprising only 28.8% of Chicago's overall population. I mean, I think our funding should reflect these numbers, these percentages, not the other way around. One of the one of the rationales that we have been continuing to get from those with CDPH is that white led organizations also serve black people. And and as long as we have and as long as organizations like Howard Brown and Center on Halstead and Chicago House and Erie are being funded, that it shouldn't matter which organizations are funded as long as organizations are funded to provide the care. However, we know and understand that these are organizations, as I was mentioning, many of them established in the 1980s, 1990s and later. But these are organizations that are established within the black community. They are indigenous to the black community. They have staff that live and work. Many of them are HIV positive people, so they are peer navigators and leaders. And so we understand that all studies, you know, show that when you fund culturally competent care, when you fund organizations with not only the leadership, but also those who are in the rank and file, who reflect the demographic that they are serving, that care is more effective. And so that's why, again, we see when people are diagnosed with HIV, they move actually the communities where they're primarily white led organizations so that they can get the care. But the but the communities themselves that have the highest rate of new diagnoses are those that are in the black community where those organizations are not being funded. And, of course, there are the correlations of the socioeconomics of that situation where, yes, the people who are most impacted are sometimes the people who are most disadvantaged and actually don't have the ability to move to those other communities where they're priced out. And, you know, I can speak, you know, to this situation from experience as well as as a queer man, you know, who sought, you know, sexual health resources at a very young age as a working class Latino. I remember getting on the bus to go to Howard Brown and how long that took so I can imagine what it's like for poor or lower income black communities that don't have the ability to take to go up north or to take the train or to take the bus. So that cultural competency tied with its geographical relation to the community is so important. It's so important. And the Department of Public Health needs to understand that they need to understand that we need to invest in the communities of the people who are most directly impacted right in their neighborhoods so that they can walk to their clinic and not take the train to a clinic. And they need to they need to be sensitive to that. So what are some of the examples that CDPH has given to you in regard to denying funding? What are some of those reasons that you all were referencing earlier? The inability to spend the funding that they, you know, infrastructure is is is something that we but again, they don't they don't provide funding to the organization so that they can build infrastructure. How can you get a grant that includes funding to cover your operational costs and administrative costs? But when you sub grant an organization, you don't include it. So that is why we're pushing again for direct funding. So infrastructure, of course, is is continually to has continually been one of the reasons why they have denied it. But then the other thing has been capacity and what do we say capacity is capacity is the ability to. Well, if you gave us more funding, we could serve more people. Every organization is serving as many as they possibly can based on the funding that they are getting. So those have been the two major complaints. And the other thing relative to what Mr. White was just alluding to is the RFPs themselves, the applications are have systemic barriers in terms of even how organizations are chosen. So the the the last set of grants that came out, it gave zero points for having community reach. So you give 30 they gave 30 points for infrastructure, but zero points for having community reach. Well, if you have an organization that is in the community doing community reach, they get no points on their application for being part of the community. But they're supposed to have 30 points for infrastructure. So you have infrastructure on the north side. So you get so you get points. You have zero points for community reach. So you end up getting granted the you get up being being awarded the grant because you're not in the community. You don't have community relativity, but you have infrastructure. So the way that the RFPs have been written intrinsically and system systemically negate black led organizations being funded. If I don't say this, I'm going to set a flame. So if I so to fortify that thing and the last thing is, is that this is the systemic racial piece is hidden behind those type of things to suggest that an organization needs to have the infrastructure infrastructure, and that infrastructure only could have been built during a time to where there was racism, right? We talk about organizations that had access. There was a time when black people didn't have access to anything, right? And there is no way possible that we could have built that infrastructure, that the same infrastructure of the AIDS Foundation Chicago. There's no way possible because when that infrastructure was being established, when that capacity was being stretched to be able to do this work, it was done at a time to where we didn't have access to the same tools. So we couldn't have built the same way. So that is important. That is what makes it systemically racial, right? Not taking into account the journey, not taking into account the historical facts that put black led organizations at a disadvantage today. And I just wanted to say that, and I also want to emphasize, if it's the last thing that I say today, that, again, we are not here fighting to provide services in anyone else's community. We are here fighting for resources to provide services in our own. I want to just say one thing to answer your question relative to, you know, what could be some of the issues. So, and again, like in 1995, the Chicago Department of Public Health reached out to Southside Health Center and asked us to apply for funding. We were not great grant writers at that time. The majority of the organizations today that probably did not receive funding is because they did not present a good, strong enough application. Yes, there probably are some of those other issues, but for the most part, they were things that should not have impacted their ability to be selected as grantees, such as, you know, a poorly written work plan. Those things could be helped developed with the help of the Chicago Department of Public Health. I just think that they have put up a lot of barriers to prevent black-led organizations from getting the funding, something that they had not done in the past. You know, like I said, we've had a long history, and we've seen the systemic barriers being put up decade after decade. Thank you. Yeah, unfortunately, the tale of two cities has too many chapters in it. And so, you know, I'm very interested in having deeper conversations with the Department of Public Health to better understand, you know, what are these barriers, you know, to providing funding for more of our black-led organizations and to figure out efficiencies and ways to help support you all. Because I think as we started this conversation earlier, one of the great risks and threats that currently exist right now is, you know, the war that the federal government is waging on science, on public health, on black communities, on working-class communities. And so now, more than ever, your organizations, but most importantly, the communities that you represent are at risk. That means we need to evolve our strategies to better assist organizations and communities at most risk. And that means we need to get smart and make sure that we have strategic funding, you know, mechanisms, more strategic conversations with your organizations year-round to figure out how we can best support that infrastructure. But then also, for those organizations that are, you know, what kind of partnerships can they engage in to, I think, relinquish some of the privilege that they've had in these conversations and in these funding, you know, struggles. And at the end of the day, we also need to firm our analysis that we're still all dealing with scraps. Some of us just have bigger crumbs than others, but some of us have much greater need than others. So, you know, we need to couple this conversation in the short term, you know, with analysis, but also in the long term, because we need to make sure that we survive these next couple of years under this horrible administration, but then have the political courage and clarity to fight to, you know, transform our public. health system nationally so that we can, you know, really move towards, you know, Medicare for all systems and make sure that we have equitable funding across our nation for all people. Thank you very much. Thank you, Alderman Quezada. I don't see any other hands, so I think that we're at the end of this hearing. I want to thank you so much for coming to us and bringing this matter to our attention, for the conversation, for the expertise, for the work that you do in the community and you have our commitment that we are going to be fighting alongside you so that there can be equity in the distribution of funding. This is also a matter of autonomy and when we think about colonial systems, this is a perfect example of how colonialism shows up in the way in which we resource our communities and you have the right to lead your own work. You have the right to have a vision to execute. You have a right to be researched to be able to deliver the services in a manner that is adequate for the community that you live in and that you work in. So I am committed to working with you on this. Before you leave, please leave your cell phone numbers with Jonathan here because we will be in touch with you to continue this conversation, okay? Thank you so much. We just finally want to say thank you for allowing the word hearing to be heard is astronomically valuable. We have been pushing for this actually for the last 12 years. So sorry it took so long to bring you. No, it's not your fault. No, I know it's not my fault, but I am sorry that that's what happened. We appreciate that this administration and this body and this group allow a resolution to be able to be submitted and for a hearing to be set to be heard and acknowledged because you can't address the issue if you haven't heard about it. Absolutely. Thank you for the hearing. Absolutely. Thank you so much. We appreciate it. Sure. I'm going to take a minute recess to take a picture with our guests. Here, a picture. A picture. Please. I was going to beg for a picture. And we are back from recess. If members can take their seats again, we are on our last item of this hearing, item number three. Where's my committee? Committee? Don't go. So item number three on the agenda is a planned subject matter hearing with the Chicago Department of Public Health regarding the strategic plan focusing on areas of maternal health and infectious disease, where they will also respond to the resolutions we previously heard presentations about. Thank you, Commissioner Ige, for being with us today and for continuing to partner with our committee to provide these important updates to our city at a critical time. I, again, ask that questions will be held to the end so that we can keep the presentation moving forward. Now, Commissioner Ige, you can get us started. Members of the committee, thank you again for another opportunity to share with you what we have been doing to keep Chicago safe. There is a lot going on, so I will go real quick so that you can have some time for questions and answers. So we can be for you to share our strategic plan and say these are the plans that we have to help address the issues that are killing Chicago prematurely. And so we'll show you the progress we're making where there's still room for work and then address some of the emerging topics that you wanted us to share with you. So the Healthy Chicago 2025 Progress Report is an obligatory community health improvement plan that we must submit to the state and also to keep us accountable to the communities that we serve. So our goal for the last five years has been to close the life expectancy gap in Chicago among different groups in Chicago. So the reason why we have been doing this is that, you know, some demographics in Chicago are living up to 80 years and older, but the black community has been averaging around 72 years. And today, I'm happy to tell you the last time we were here, we were looking at the 2022 data, which showed that the life expectancy gap had increased to 12.4. When we started this journey, it was 8 point something and then increased to over 12. And we are very glad to tell you that post-pandemic, the gap has closed to 10.4 since the last time we were here because we now have the 2023 data. So we are very excited to share that we are making progress and that our goal to close life expectancy, now we have proof of concept that the gap can close. This is the first time in a very long time that we are seeing the gap shrinking. Now, this is the trajectory since 2010 when we have been using Healthy Chicago. So the first iteration of this was Healthy Chicago, then Healthy Chicago 2.0. So you will see there that when we started Healthy Chicago 2.0, nothing had changed. Then it continued, the gap continued to increase. And then we went to Healthy Chicago 2025. And the gap continued to increase. So last year, we decided to pivot and do something different, which is let us focus on the communities that are most impacted and let us focus on a few areas and see if we can begin to see some success there. And so we have started to see the downward trajectory there. So we are very hopeful. Now, the things that are driving this gap, the reasons why people are dying early, the number one, the light blue, is heart disease or chronic diseases. And you will see how that has ebbed and flowed over time. And the promising trend here is that from 4.8 has come down to 4.7. The green, which is homicide, the second reason why people are dying young, has also reduced. Then opioid overdose. And we will share with you why we decided to focus on homicide and opioid overdose is because of these drivers. And then the notable thing here is if you look at 2022 and 2023, there is a color that is missing, as it's a color pink. That is COVID-19. In 2022, COVID-19 contributed to the premature mortality. In 2023, COVID was zeroed out. COVID is no longer the primary cause of death in Chicago. Again, this is a testament to the power of immunization and vaccination. And so we are using this lesson to guide the work that we're doing this year as we go into the last year of the Healthy Chicago 2025. Now, this is the good news. I want to celebrate with you, and I want to thank you for your partnership addressing opioid-related overdoses. The last time I was here, I shared with you that in 2024, the decrease in mortality and opioid overdoses in Chicago exceeded the national average. And that was because of your partnership. This year is even better this year. We've already seen a decrease in opioid overdoses by 24 percent. Most aldermanic offices are partnering with us. Alders are distributing Narcan. We are trying to expand Narcan through all of our public library, other opportunities, vending machine. And we have achieved our goal of saturating Chicago with Narcan. There is no reason why anybody should die of an overdose in Chicago. And we want to thank you for your partnership. This is what working together can do. But you will notice in the slide that in June, we still saw an uptick in opioid overdoses that exceeded last year. So we are doubling down there. We have identified to the block where this is happening. And so we want to work with you all again to take the services to the streets, door to door, block by block, so that we can prevent these diseases and overdoses and mortality from happening. But we are very excited. Now, look at the numbers. In 2023, it was 5,000 overdoses. That's dropped to 4,200 in 2023 and 2024. And now we are 3,000. 3,000 is still too many. 3,000 is still too many. So we still have a lot of work to do there. At the last hearing, we talked to you about our plans for violence prevention and how we want to increase coverage. And again, we have good news. Here, all cause homicides and non-fatal shootings are down by 33% compared to 2024. This is a collective impact, interdepartmental collaboration, Mayor's Office of Community Safety. Our role in this is in the prevention space, where we are supporting street outreach. We're supporting the peacemaker initiatives. We're supporting gun locks and education. We are supporting hospital-based violence prevention programs so that those who have survived don't get re-victimized. And so, again, the numbers here, lower than 2024, and we are on track to meet the mayor's goal of keeping homicides below 500. We are now at 188, which is, again, too many. But we are on the right track, and things are trending in the right direction. So, again, we want to say thank you for your partnership, distributing gun locks, conducting gun safety workshops in your ward, helping to educate and helping to expand the reach of the street outreach. Now, what I didn't share with you the last time is our heart health campaign. So, we went back and did a bit more math and queried our data a little more to see where we can do a little more in terms of preventing heart disease and chronic disease. And this is what we found. The chart at the bottom shows the blue line is men. The red line is women. Heart disease is going down among women. Again, mortality related to heart disease is going on among women, but not as fast among men. Twenty to sixty percent of heart attacks have no symptoms. People don't know that they even have this disease, and boom, they have a heart attack and they die. So, this is where we are going to be concentrating. We are doing a partnership with UIC to get to 21 community areas with a focus on men's health and how we can encourage men to start screening for high blood pressure, screening for diabetes, and getting connected to a primary care provider. So, this is an event that we have later this month to have a heart health community conversation. So, that is a quick overview of the work that we have presented to you and how it's going. Now, we want to talk to you about maternal and infant mortality, our plans, what we have learned, what is working well, and where we need your support. All of the work that we do, it is to help ensure we're serving Chicagoans. But we want to also let you know that this year we're up for reaccreditation by the Public Health Accreditation Board. We have submitted over 150 documents to document that we are responsive to the Community Health Improvement Plan, and we are now scheduled for a site visit before the end of the year. So, the work that we're doing is not just that we are saying we're doing a good job. It's also that the National Accreditation Board is going to come and validate the work that we're doing, and we hope to report back on you that we have been accredited. This happens every five years. We have not had an accreditation in the last seven years because of COVID. So, we are very excited to ensure that every T and every I is dotted, and we have a lot of success stories already. So, I am going to hand over to our Deputy Commissioner and Chief Program Officer, Jen Vides, to talk about the work we have been doing in infant and maternal mortality prevention. In our life expectancy chart, infant mortality contributes a reduction, a gap of our 0.5 years. So, it is the next area that we will be presenting our plans for how to address this to you. Jen? Thank you, Dr. Ige. I'm Jennifer Vides, Deputy Commissioner and Chief Program Officer, and I support all the work of the Bureau of Maternal, Infant, Child, and Adolescent Health Chair and Alders. I'm pleased to provide this update about some of the work that we are doing, some of our action plan that's focused on preventing infant and maternal mortality. And we'll begin with a bit of the data analysis that's informed our strategy. So, infant mortality is defined as the death of a baby before their first birthday. And while infant mortality has declined by 39% overall in the last two decades, black infant mortality has declined more slowly than white infant mortality. As a result, the gap between black and non-black infants has widened. For a little more context, infant death is still relatively rare. There were 530 infant deaths in 2000 and 173 out of 27,400 births in 2022. But any death, obviously, a death of an infant, particularly when it's preventable, is unacceptable. There are three consistent leading causes of infant mortality. Preterm-related causes for babies born before 37 weeks of gestation, congenital disorders and birth defects, and then sudden unexpected infant deaths. Across all three causes, black infants experience the highest rates of deaths. However, sudden unexpected infant death rates, also known as SUID, has the widest gap between black and non-black infants. Notably, over 95% of these deaths occurred when an infant is in an unsafe sleep environment. So we know with education resources and support, many of these losses can be prevented. Next slide. Infant mortality is influenced by exposures and services that occurred before, during, and after pregnancy. In this data, we see there are protective factors like receiving early and adequate prenatal care and also accessing WIC services, nutrition services, and counseling and support during pregnancy for families who are eligible. Risk factors include no prenatal care during pregnancy. This is the biggest risk to mortality. And exposures to harmful substances, including alcohol and tobacco. I would note that only 2% of Chicagoans receive no prenatal care, but this accounts for 10% of infant deaths. So there are many things we can do to bolster protective factors and mitigate these risks to improve health outcomes. To fully understand and develop our responses to infant mortality, we need to understand maternal mortality because the health of the mom and the baby are so intimately linked. What we know about maternal mortality is learned through deep investigation of each death. This is done at the state level by the state's Maternal Mortality Review Committee. In Chicago, for all maternal deaths from 2015 to 2020, the leading causes were substance use disorder, pre-existing chronic conditions like diabetes, hypertension, autoimmune conditions. But they were different for Black Chicagoans. Non-substance use disorders are driving mortality. So with sepsis and pre-existing conditions and embolism as the leading causes. Notably, 84% of these deaths were preventable had there been adequate support in the clinical, social, or community areas, you know, including getting early and adequate prenatal care. And I'd note also that 58% of pregnancy-related deaths occur one week after delivery. Hence, we need to pay attention to the postpartum period as well as the prenatal period. Pregnant people and infants live in the context of their communities. And what you see here are a couple of maps that show you rates of severe maternal morbidity, which are critical and near-death experiences that happen during delivery, which can have potentially lifelong health consequences. And a map that shows you infant mortality as well. And the rates of maternal morbidity and infant mortality are highest on the south and west sides of the city of Chicago. By understanding this geography, we can focus our resources on the people and places most at risk. A little bit more of a dive into that geography and how it's informing our Healthy Chicago 2025 Action Plan. If you look at a number of metrics across the five priority community areas, you'll see that we have disparities in those community areas when compared to the rest of the city of Chicago. And that data... along with some of the other drivers that I've shared with you, really points us to an action plan that at a high level includes a focus on promoting safe sleep practices and access to safe sleep resources, expanding outreach and education related to the importance of early and adequate prenatal care, growing enrollment in our WIC programs, and increasing participation in Family Connect Chicago, which is our postpartum nurse home visiting program. In addition to the Healthy Chicago five priority community areas, we've added five additional community areas of focus based on a birth inequity score. So we looked at a variety of measures, including prenatal care utilization, maternal hypertension, pre-teen birth, and many other measures and came up with an index. And based on that, we've added Greater Grand Causing, South Shore, Roseland, West Pullman, and South Deering to our list of priority community areas. So we're focusing today with an update on Family Connects and what we're doing to improve participation in this important program. Family Connects is actually a national program model that has a strong evidence base. It's widely disseminating across the country. It's a universal postpartum system solution to improving health and well-being of moms, newborns, and their families. It consists of three interlocking components, a nurse home visit, data and monitoring, and community alignment. Its many strengths include that it is universal, which allows us to assess all birthing persons, their families, and not miss folks who fall through the gaps. It helps us respond to immediate needs in the home through brief interventions, education, and support. It also sets us up to respond to longer-term needs via referrals and warm handoffs by our nurses. And it yields a lot of data. And through community engagement, we're using that data to improve not just the performance of the program, but how we build a system of care and support for all moms and babies in the city of Chicago. So a little bit about how this works because it's relevant to our action plan. These, as I said, are postpartum visits. They're in the home, ideally, with a registered nurse. I think we all know that in the prenatal period when people are accessing care, there are lots of doctor's appointments, a lot of attention to the health of the mom and the baby up to and through delivery. But after that, when families leave a hospital, that careful monitoring and support tends to fall off. And while it's a really joyous time, it can also be a time of isolation and anxiety. I know I was anxious. And this is true whether it's a first baby or a fourth. This visit then is timed to bridge the gap, timed in a way to bridge that gap in care and make sure that we're checking on families during a particularly vulnerable time. And again, I'd note that 58% of maternal deaths occur in this postpartum period. We try our best during the prenatal period to make sure that all families are aware of Family Connects and know that an opportunity for a visit is coming. If you're a Chicagoan delivering at one of our 11 participating hospitals, a visit is offered either at the bedside or shortly after discharge. These visits can happen early if there are circumstances that warrant it, like there's additional need for breastfeeding support or there's concerns about blood pressure and hypertension. So some visits happen within 72 hours. But generally speaking, the visits happen within two to three weeks postpartum, mostly in the home. That is the gold standard. But we can offer visits via telehealth if the family prefers it. And there are many reasons why families may select that option. It's an unusual health care encounter. It lasts one and a half to two hours, which is much longer than most doctor's visits are. And a lot happens in the visit. There are checks, important health checks for blood pressure, wound care. There are assessments for postpartum depression and mood disorders. The baby's weight is checked and growth is checked. There's breastfeeding support. They're checking out sleeping issues as well as ensuring there's a safe sleep environment for the baby. We also screen for substance use and interpersonal violence. And then a whole range of other factors are discussed, like needs for child care, need for economic support, housing instability, concerns about violence, et cetera. And then the nurse does the work of figuring out which supports and services in our communities are available and making a warm connection to those services for the family. And then there's typically follow-up phone calls with families to determine if they'll be able to access those services. And then after 60 days, we do what we call a post-visit connection call, where it's a little bit of customer service, customer service satisfaction, but also a final check on whether referrals were made. And I shared with you, I know you guys all have access to these slides so you can read at your leisure, but you know, every family is unique and the program is really helping us meet families exactly where there are. And we've shared here some nurse stories. There's no two stories that are the same. In some cases, our nurses are stepping into homes and dialing 911 because we've come across emergent situations. But here we're sharing stories of a grieving family that experienced sort of unspeakable violence just before the baby was born and the ways in which this nurse was able to connect them to the support that they need. Another is an example of an intervention where there's a low weight gain among an infant and the need for additional services to get that baby's weight back on track. And then finally, an example of how a nurse is supporting a mother that was managing really complex health needs and high-risk conditions to make sure that she was connected to care and able to meet all of her doctor's appointments. So Family Connects just celebrated its fifth birthday. And over the five years, we've been able to complete 13,000 home visits. In our data, we're reaching 83% of the families who are saying yes to our visits and completing them are Latin A or non-Latin A Black families. 80% of these families live in low or very low opportunity areas based on the Childhood Opportunity Index. So we know we're going where the need is greatest. 97% of families express satisfaction and tell us that Family Connects really feels like a lifeline. And 76% of the families we're serving are also on Medicare. I'll just note that, you know, last year we made over 8,000 referrals to the families that we saw for everything from essential services like diapers to connections to child care, health care, mental health care, and other. We've shared a map with you of a couple of years of visits by ward. Happy to, you know, provide more information to any of you about the details behind this map. And then here's our progress to date. So a major goal has been for us to increase the number of families that we are reaching in priority community areas. And this slide is showing you what our quarter one 2025 outcomes look like. So on average, our reach has increased from 43% in these areas in 2024 to 51% in 2025, the first quarter of 2025. What you're looking at the blue bars represent that 2024 baseline data by community area. And that's the percentage of families, eligible families, who received and completed a Family Connects visit. The green bar shows you where we're at as of the first quarter of this year. And the red dash line mark marks our goal that we've set of 50% across all community areas. So this is signaling a strong start to the year. We know some of our work is making a difference, including North Lawndale, South Deering, and Roseland, where we've seen notable gains. And five communities are now exceeding our 50% goal. It also tells us where we need to do more work. And Englewood, West Garfield, and East Garfield Park are important community areas where we need to just double and triple down on the focus that we have on reaching families in those community areas. We see these really as opportunities to strengthen our engagement and start to close the gap in upcoming quarters. Some of the things that we're doing to improve our reach and to improve the number of visits is we're focusing a lot on scheduling practices. We know that we have decent scheduling rates. People will say yes initially and set up an appointment. But where we see some fall off is in getting folks to complete the appointment. And really, until there's widespread awareness of Family Connects and that every family really expects this as, you know, part of the way we care for people in Chicago, we have worked to improve our reach. So lots of work ensuring that visits are offered. strike s s s and scheduled at the bedside. We're setting new standards for best practices, for making these follow-up calls, trying to differentiate based on the families that we're serving and what things might be of concern to them in terms of opening the door. We're working on updating our messaging and really, you know, what gets monitored gets done. And we have set specific goals for all of our nurses and all of our hospitals. And we are strengthening our routines for regular review of that data, for lifting up strategies that work, sharing them, testing them out, and coming back around to see if it made a difference. We're also doing work at a hyper-local community area to really promote awareness of our program. And that includes leveraging our many, many partners in our community alignment system who are helping spread the word. And then we've got plans for some additional hyper-local marketing and outreach campaigns. And as always, grateful for the support we've received from Council and the Mayor for Family Connect Chicago. We continue to seek your support in helping us really normalize the Family Connects visit. So, you know, asking you to help us spread the word, encourage families to participate, to say yes, invite us to events in your ward so that we can share the word, and help us identify local services and resources that we can get families connected to. Thank you. Yes. Thank you very much, Jen. So, that is our plan for improving the reach of Family Connects. And now we will turn to infectious disease prevention. This is the report of our respiratory virus immunization report for last year. And that is Dr. Alex Loboda, our medical director. All right. Thank you, Dr. Ige. I'm Dr. Alex Loboda, medical director of immunizations and emergency preparedness for the Chicago Department of Public Health. In the next couple of slides, I just want to take you through the last few years of viral respiratory illnesses, particularly COVID and flu, to see where we're at now compared to four or five years ago. These graphs are from our dashboards that are publicly available online as well. So, all this can be found on our websites and several different metrics. On this graph, we're looking at emergency department visits and hospital admissions, the percentage that's contributed to, in this case, COVID-19. So, you can see in the first couple years, 2020, 2021, and 22, the first few years of the COVID-19 pandemic, it had a very severe impact on society and our healthcare system with a significant number of ED visits, hospitalizations. But because of immunization, vaccination efforts against COVID-19, as well as other public health interventions and mitigation tactics, we are in a much better place now compared to just a few years ago in terms of COVID-19, thankfully. But it's still important to be aware that COVID-19 is still with us. People still get sick from it. They still end up in the ER, in the hospital, and people are still dying from COVID-19 this year as well. So, that is why it's really important to continue to promote COVID-19 vaccination. Just some context about COVID-19 vaccination. I'm sure you're all aware that there's the initial COVID-19 vaccine that came out. That was either one or two doses, and then there was several boosters. But last season and this past season, there are now updated COVID-19 vaccines, in which they've updated the formula because we know that COVID-19 is always changing. It's always mutating. There are often new strains every few months. So, it's important for people to stay up to date on their COVID-19 vaccine to stay protected. Next slide. This is looking at flu. And something to note is in 2021 and 2022, during the COVID-19 pandemic, at the heights of that, those mitigation techniques and public health interventions for COVID also helped prevent flu as well, which is great. But now that we're out of the COVID-19 pandemic, we are starting to see flu surges again in the winter. And this past winter was quite severe in terms of flu, which can be prevented through vaccination. And I just wanted to briefly touch on another viral respiratory illness, a virus that is getting some more awareness, is often tracked with COVID and flu called RSV. That's respiratory syncytial virus. For those that don't know, this is a very common virus. It's been around for a long time. A lot of people will get it and they'll just get the sniffles or the head cold and they won't even know they have RSV and they'll be on their way. But it can really severely impact older adults and very young infants. So, I'll touch on some immunization efforts there towards the end of this presentation. Next slide. All right. This is looking at COVID-19 vaccination coverage in Chicago from this past viral respiratory season of 24-25. And this is the updated 24-25 COVID-19 vaccine. We're now turning COVID-19 vaccine is now kind of like a seasonal vaccine where you should be getting updated vaccine every season, just like you do usually with flu. As you can see, the coverage across Chicago this past season was only 13.4%. But this is also a national problem as well. This is slightly lower than the last updated COVID vaccine that we had in 23-24, which was 16.6% coverage. Our coverage is slightly better than the overall coverage for the state of Illinois. And if you look at national data, we are quite a bit ahead of the national average in most other states as well. So, this is really a national problem of having lower coverage rates for COVID-19 vaccine. Thankfully, a lot of Chicagoans did get the initial couple COVID vaccines. Around 80% of Chicagoans got at least one dose since 2020. Around 70% got the first series. But like I've stated, COVID-19 is changing. People need to stay up to date on their COVID-19 vaccine so they don't get infected and ill. Next slide. This is looking at flu vaccination coverage. Obviously, we've had flu vaccine, seasonal flu vaccine for quite a while now. And for this past season, it was about 28.1%. So, just about where we were at the season before. We were off to a bit of a slow start, but we eventually were able to catch up. This is pretty much on par with the overall state of Illinois as well at 28.5%. Again, both Illinois and Chicago are usually quite a bit ahead of the national average for these coverage rates, as well as most other states as well. But there's definitely room for growth. All right. And so, in terms of our immunization efforts this past season, we did a lot of work. So, this is data from September 1st of 2024 to April 30th of 2025, just a couple months ago, which is what we refer to as our viral respiratory season. We did over 400 vaccine events for COVID and flu. Here's a breakdown. Just over a quarter of them were our own caravan direct service team going out into the community doing vaccine events. We also had 200 events in congregate settings, which include shelters, Chicago Housing Authority, and senior housing facilities. We also do have special programming with faith-based events. We had 31 specific events in faith-based settings. Also, 30 specific events at DFSS Senior Centers, who've been a partner with us for a long time. We also have big Saturday weekend family flu clinics at city colleges, seven of those as well. Overall, in terms of vaccines during our vaccine events with ourselves and our partners that we work with, we did just over 10,000 flu doses and just over 9,000 COVID-19 doses through these operations. And I just included a map on the right of our just, this is just events by our caravan team during the first quarter of this year during the season. So January, February, March, just to illustrate the variety of sites that our caravan goes to and throughout the city of Chicago. I also want to talk about a specific project we had this past season as well as part of our Healthy Chicago 2025 strategic plan. It was to, in addition to our city-wide efforts, also give some special focus to communities that are most impacted by COVID-19. been in flu and have had lowest vaccination rates. So our great vaccine-preventable disease team, epidemiologists that do the surveillance, looked at all the data from the past couple of years, including COVID hospitalizations, flu ICU admissions, and identified five community areas that were either majority Black or majority Latine in Chicago that we would specifically do additional outreach, partnerships, events in this season. So that included West Garfield Park, West Englewood, Burnside, Hermosa, and McKinley Park. Here's kind of some results from those efforts. Overall, just over 100 vaccine events were specifically for or around those focused community areas of priority. So 31 events for West Garfield Park, 28 for West Englewood, 16 for Burnside, 15 for Hermosa, and 17 for McKinley Park. On the right is a map that shows the amount of events per a community area. Important to note, sometimes we would do an event for a specific community area, but might not be physically in that community area. But we would do outreach engagement with the community area, such as Burnside, which is a smaller community area. But we would do a lot of outreach engagement in that area for events that may be nearby in Roseland, similar with Englewood, West Englewood, as well as West Garfield Park, East Garfield Park, and the surrounding community areas. All right, and this is just a couple pictures from some COVID vaccine community meetings that we hosted with our community partners this season. We really wanted to reset on COVID vaccine and what the community was thinking about COVID, COVID vaccination. Later on, we will talk about misinformation around vaccines as well. So we wanted to get direct feedback from community members on what their thoughts were and how we can improve our efforts. We also did surveys as well. So these are some pictures from Garfield Park in the Fieldhouse, the Golden Dome, as well as a community church in Burnside, where we talked to community members. There's obviously a lot of concerns around COVID vaccine misinformation and trying to address those issues, as well as different social and economic issues these communities are facing as well that can be barriers to vaccination that we can help them overcome. So a lot of important direct feedback. And as always, we can get furthest with people with direct communication with people, talking to people one-on-one, answering their concerns about vaccines. But obviously, that's most resource and staff intensive. I also wanted to share some success in terms of RSV this season, particularly for infants. So RSV is actually the number one cause of hospitalization for infants in the United States. So this is a very significant problem. But thankfully, there is immunization, an RSV antibody, that is 90% effective in preventing this RSV hospitalization, which is great. This works a bit different than a vaccine. Instead of someone getting a vaccine, which causes the body to create antibodies, the infant receives antibodies already preformed. And we're excited to announce that 58% of Chicago infants that were born between April 1st, 2024, March 31st, 2025, received this RSV immunization. And this was improved from 17% the season before. This is a new antibody prevention treatment. So obviously, it's going to increase every season. But this was a pretty significant gain that we're excited about. CDPH also already enrolled six out of 15 Chicago birthing hospitals in our Vaccines for Children program so that they can receive this immunization at the birthing hospital before they leave. Because once they leave, they can get infected with RSV or they may not get the immunization from their pediatrician or primary care doctor within the seven days. And so through the Vaccines for Children program, they can get no cost, nircivumab, RSV antibodies. This covers uninsured, underinsured, publicly insured, and anybody who's just not covered by their insurance. All right. All right. And we just want to thank you all for your continued engagement and support in our vaccine immunization efforts. We just want, again, continued to have your support and help in promoting the importance of staying up to date on seasonal vaccines, particularly flu and COVID-19, obviously there's a lot of misinformation and confusion around vaccines these days. So it's really important for you to help support our message in providing science-based, evidence-based, accurate information around vaccines to the people that you're serving, which we will continue to provide, along with other partners, such as IDPH, American Academy of Pediatrics, as trusted sources. We're already working on setting up our events and schedules for this upcoming vial respiratory season. So we want, it would be great to continue to get your support in connecting your residents with our CDPH vaccination events. So once those are planned, we'll definitely share those with you so you can, we can work with you to help promote those vaccine events in or nearby your, your wards. And we would love to continue to collaborate with you. And it's also important, reach out to local providers and pharmacies in your wards that you can also work with to host additional vaccine events in your areas. Thank you. Thank you, Dr. Sloboda. And those are our programmatic updates. And now we want to talk about some of the issues that you have asked us to address, including mitigating threats to public health, starting with misinformation. So misinformation is inadvertent spread of false information without the intent to harm. So it is a mistake, an error. Disinformation, however, is false information designed to mislead others and is deliberately spread with the intent to cause confusion between facts and fiction. So these are big concerns to us because misinformation and misinformation can create fear and confusion. They can lead to wrong health decisions. Now people are opting out of taking the COVID vaccines because they are afraid. Yet COVID vaccination has saved many people from death and hospitalization. People delay care seeking due to distrust of health care and public health. We have seen maternal mortality. A lot of this is preventable. 84% of those who have died from maternal and infant causes are all preventable with care. Impede efforts to safeguard health and well-being. So we are very concerned in public health because our work is in preventing. So we have been tracking misinformation data since August 2024. And there has been 10,000 plus social media interactions that have been flagged as misinformation. It is just about 0.2% of citywide discussion. So we have a surveillance, a sentient surveillance system that helps us track when wrong information is circulating on social media. The sources of this information are usually from residents or community groups, 91% of them. But there is 9% of misinformation in the city of Chicago that is coming from official channels. That is local government agency and officials who are saying things that are not also accurate. So we want to encourage that as government, we want to ensure trusted messaging. And part of the reason for that is that we are seeing that social media perception of public health information has been trending in the wrong direction. In 2023, about 6% of interactions were positive. And in 2024, we saw a little more positive interactions. But by 2024, look at the negative, the jump in negative sentiments for public health. So that is a concern for us. We are seeing people rejecting home visit. We're seeing people rejecting vaccination. We're seeing people rejecting care, outreach, or mental health services because they are afraid. And so this is a concern for us. If we invest in all these city resources and services and people are not saying yes, then how do we keep Chicago and safe? So this is a concern for us. And the trust in the local government, in the public sector, is also a concern. We've been tracking this since 2022. We do an annual Healthy Chicago survey. And we ask people, do you trust the local government, the city of Chicago, to do what is right for your community? And these are the responses for those who said, yes, we trust the government to a great extent or somewhat. And this hovers around 40%. So only about 40% of Chicagoans feel like we are working in their best interest. So that is also a concern because if we bring services and people. So that idea that we are looking for people. don't trust the government, then how do we engage with our residents? And then we ask people, if we were to provide information, what are the best conduits? Where is it that you go as an adult for information on health? Number one is the medical providers. So that is useful information to us and how we have a health alert network where we are constantly updating providers with real-time information. Medicine requires continuing medical education. What you knew last year might have changed. So we have the responsibility of making sure that our providers are up to date. I have heard someone say to me, my doctor said I don't need the vaccine. I said, connect me to your doctor because I am the one sitting here looking at the number of deaths every day. So if your doctor doesn't believe you need vaccine, I need to talk to that doctor. So updating medical providers is important. Now, the other thing that is important here is friends and family. Before we get to CDPH, people are going to their friends and their family for information. So how do we better engage the community as trusted voices is another issue. We are glad that CDPH remains the top three options for people for health information, information. But we have seen a reduction there from 65% to 60% in 2024. So we want to do a better job of working with our community and providers to ensure that good information, accurate information is everywhere that people prefer to go for their information. And this is what we do. We are always tracking media to track sentiment, to see what is happening so that we can better prepare. We have the health alert network. This is to provide information to healthcare providers and proactive engagement. We are stopping, you know, from asking people to come to us. We will go to them. And you see that in our vaccination, we're going to the communities. You see that in our maternal family connects, we're going to home visits, we're going to churches. So we want to take information to people so that it is easier for them. And communication saturation, we want every platform, television, social media, news, print, we even do bench signs to get information closer to people. I went to a community meeting, and they were like, we don't listen to the news. We don't listen to traditional news. So how do we get information to people? So we are also increasing our network of community health workers, so that regardless of where people go for information, they can get information. And then partner with trusted messengers. And that's why we are cultivating relationship with our elders, saying, how can we partner with you to get information? People come to you about city resources. These are the resources we have. These are the services that we have. These are the challenges we are having. And now I want to give you an example of how we are responding. We found that from that survey that family and friends are trusted sort of information. And this is an example. This is a youth-led social media campaign. Student creators created this campaign, and it is a campaign me and Nick broke up. This is a campaign that has received national recognition, 6.5 million campaign impressions. TikTok blew up because of this campaign, because it was designed by youth for youth. And these are the young people who are creating the visual and the snack breakup kiosk. And what we wanted to do is get used to make a pledge to be vape-free. And we're very proud that more than 2,500 young people took a pledge to break up with Nick or to not start vaping at all. So these are examples of putting the message into the mouth of trusted messenger that is working for us. Now, we are also tracking how people are engaging with CDPH. And we are continuously improving how we share information. CDPH main website is here, and the QR code can help you, you know, scan and see the page. But we have more than 245 pages, press releases, media briefs. There's a lot of information. And then we looked at the total views. We have more than 1 million views in 2024 on CDPH website. So we know that we have to keep that updated. It's where people go to for information. And we had more than 600,000 unique views. So Chicagoans still trust CDPH as a source of information. So making sure that our website is updated all the time is now another priority. And what is important and exciting to us is that the top pages that people are seeking information about, number one is immunization clinics, more than 100,000. And then our CDPH homepage so that people see the services and programs that we have, STI and HIV testing and treatment services, Noturing You, that is our postpartum Medicaid coverage page, and then get the fax measles. So we are very proud that people are still coming to CDPH for information. And so we want to make sure that our information is accurate and updated all the time. So we want you to know that our website is always available. And so that if you are seeing any misinformation, you can flag it for us and we can address that and follow up with our community. But what we want to do is become a trusted partner. This is why we share with you all the slides and we share with you all the sources of the data. And we put together a progress report so that you are always aware of the work we're doing and rebuild trust in Chicagoans that we are looking out for their health. And we are always tracking the data to see if it's working or not. Now, HIV funding, this is an area where our community has been challenging us for a long time. I have had several meetings and I know that people want additional information. What are you doing? How are you keeping Chicago and safe? And this is where we are. Last year, we had a big program with the governor to renew our commitment to getting to zero by 2030. Getting to zero means that we want to get to zero new HIV cases. And we want to ensure that everyone who has HIV is connected to care and has viral suppression. If your viral suppression is low, you cannot transmit HIV. And if you are taking your pre-exposure prophylaxis, you cannot transmit HIV. So these are two areas of priority for us. Now, this is where we are. This is the national dashboard. The black line is new HIV cases over time. From 2012, we have been seeing a steady decline in new HIV cases until COVID-19. 2020. And then we started to see an uptick in new HIV cases. And that uptick in HIV cases has become a concern. It is true that that yellow line is non-Hispanic black folks have the highest rates of HIV cases. But what is worrisome to us is between 2021 and 2023, the HIV cases among Hispanic Chicagoans has increased, has more than doubled. So we are keeping an eye on that to see where that is coming from, what we can do different. And the rate of HIV among black Chicagoans, it also increased slightly from 41.7 to 46.2. So our target right now is to get HIV cases below 451. We are now at 865. So we have some work to do, especially among black residents and Hispanic Latina residents. So to get to our goal of 54, we have some work to do. Now we have started again to look at where are we seeing changes? If we have 865 new HIV diagnoses in 2023, 81% of that is among men, 42% black, 44% Hispanic, 8% white. And this change in the demographic, we have to pay attention to it. And now new HIV diagnosis by location. Uptown, Edgewater, South Shore, Rogers Park, and Westridge and Loop are the areas where we have the most new HIV cases. So we need to investigate and do a better job there of what is going on. And then when we look at rates, that is comparing the number of new HIV cases to the population, Bunside emerges as the number one, then Uptown, Douglas, Woodlawn, and Edgewater. So we have some work to do there to bring these numbers down. And these are the trends when you look at overall how many people are living with HIV in Chicago. It's around 19,000. But we are also responsible for the Chicagoland area and eligible metropolitan area. So if we look at the Chicagoland area, it's almost 30,000 people living with HIV. But in Chicago alone is over 19,000 people. This is important because people need to stay connected to treatment for their viral suppression goal to be reached. So again, among those living with HIV, 83% are male, 47% black, 20% white, 24% Hispanic. So we have to do more to get those numbers down to pre-pandemic levels. And again, prevalence are in these areas of the city. These are the ways we work. We have prevention services for the city of Chicago and suburban Cook County. We're the ones responsible for all of that work. We have HIV housing services for the City of Chicago, Suburban, Cook County, DuPage, Will, Grundy, McHenry, and Kendall Counties. So we are responsible for a wide geographic area. HIV care and treatment services, City of Chicago, Suburban, Cook County, DeKalb, DuPage, Will, Grundy, McHenry, Lake Kane, and Kendall Counties. So we have a big responsibility of ensuring that HIV care and treatment services get to all of these counties, and also housing services cover all of these counties. So our work is not just Chicago. Prevention is also not just Chicago, but also Suburban, Cook County. So we have a lot of ground to cover. So some of the new things that we have been exploring is educational campaign led by CDPH, not just the work that's been done by our delegates. And we are starting a new program called the Queen's Initiative to help address the high prevalence of HIV, heart disease, stroke, cancer, diabetes, and maternal mortalities among black women. So instead of focusing on the disease, focus on the population and how can we address everything together at once by providing information and then screening people on site. So this is what that we are doing. 90% of those who attend our workshops up for HIV and STI screening. If we don't make it just HIV and STI and say this is just a screening opportunity and we can screen for several other things, then people are more willing to screen for HIV and STI. So these are some of the ways we're trying to reach our community. Now, funding. The biggest threat we have right now is the uncertainty in the HIV funding. We receive about $72 million for what we call syndemic illnesses, HIV, viral hepatitis, tuberculosis, and STIs. And again, remember that we cover a lot of counties for all of this work. Now, HIV housing services and HIV treatment is where the bulk of our money is. So we receive $27 million for HIV treatment service. That money goes to providers. Now, as part of that $72 million, the biggest chunk of the $72 million is HIV emergency relief project grants, which goes to providers. So health care institutions are the ones who receive this money. $27.8 million. So eligible providers are those who are health care providers. This funding is not available for community-based organizations. And then HOPWA is the next big one, which is about $14 million. This also goes for housing providers. So the rest of the money that we have for HIV prevention, that is $9 million. So the disparities in the funding allocation is because of how this funding is designated for different things. Now, federal funding. We have 79 delegates, HIV delegates in 2024, 79 different organizations. A lot of them are provider organizations. We awarded $31 million and more than 30,000 HIV tests provided to at-risk individuals and 8,300 people living with HIV received medical and supportive services. So we are, our funding is responsible for supporting almost half of all of those living with HIV in the city of Chicago. Now, look at this breakdown. Federal funding is the bulk of the money that we have, nearly 90%. The state gives us $123,000, so less than 1% of our funding comes from the state. And then the city provides about $8 million for HIV. And of that $8 million, $3 million is personnel and about $5 million is delegate. Federal is $41 million. Federal is $64 million. $64 million. State is $123,000. That's less than 1%. And city is 11% of our funding. That's $8 million. But the funding that is available for delegate is about $5 million outside of the staff. Now, this is why we are nervous. Our ability to put more money out to our communities is dependent on what we get from the federal government. As of now, based on the president's proposal, see all the red, red, red, red, the HIV Prevention and Surveillance Program, the proposal now is to eliminate that entire unit in CDC. So the $27 million that we have for treatment services is also under threat. So we don't know what we're going to have next year in terms of funding. And we are very, very anxious about some of the proposals to reduce or cut HIV funding. So it is why we are not certain how much we will be able to designate next year for funding or for community-based delegates until we know how much we're receiving. One example is the $27 million we typically receive. We have only received $4 million this year. So what we have been doing is engaging our federal delegates, our federal congressional leaders. These are some of the documents we prepared for them. This is where the funding comes from. This is how much we have received every year. This is how the money is being used. This is the number of individuals who are depending on us. We have more than 1,000 people depending on us for housing who are living on HIV. We have this Ryan White Part A funding that our community advocates have been concerned about. We receive a lot of money from this for treatment services, et cetera. 14,000 individuals receiving primary care services through this funding. What happens if the funding goes away? So we are doing a lot of education. This week, I and Dr. Joshi of the Cook County and Dr. Vora of IDPH co-authored an op-ed into the Tribune to say we are making progress. We don't want to stop now. We need the federal funding to continue to support us because, again, this is a lot of money, not just for Chicagoans, but for a big part of the state. Now, why are we not doing more for smaller organizations? This has been the area where we have been exploring. We have federal contract regulations that limits how we can use federal dollars. The big limitation that we have is the requirement for competitive grants. That when we receive federal funding is that all procurement transactions under a federal award must be conducted to ensure full and open competition. So we have to post these RFPs and make it open to all. Restricting it to only one group is a challenge. Now, we also have requirements for the Ryan White and other federal funding, which is a requirement for a local advisory council for HIV funding. So this is the Chicagoland Syndemic Advisory Committee. It is a community advisory group that informs how funding is allocated. The meetings are open. There are opportunities for people to participate in the subgroup, funding allocation subgroup. So it's called the CISAC, Chicagoland Syndemic Advisory Council. This is a requirement from the federal government for all HASA funding that we have a local advisory. So we have opportunity for community input. Now, the city of Chicago also requires that our delegate agency maintain a 501c3. So you have to be a nonprofit. You have to be in good financial standing with the city. And the big one, you have to be able to manage upfront costs while awaiting reimbursement. Do they mean monthly or? Monthly. Monthly. Thank you. So that is an opportunity. In addition to this, we have the LGBTQ forum that is also an open space where we receive feedback from our community partners about how well we are doing engaging the LGBTQ plus community and getting information out. It has been a wonderful forum and partnership for us. Now, I have commissioner's authority to approve contracts and delegate agency. But this is not a sole decision by CDPH. We have that committee. But we also have the city contracting policies as well, which also specify the principal requirement of the Municipal Purchasing Act is for all contracts greater than 10,000 to be let by free and open competitive bidding. And this is why on our website, at every time, there is a list of open requests for proposal. It has to be open to all. Everybody is invited to apply. We send this out on social media. We publish all of our RFPs so people know it is open. And we have put the QR code in there so that people know that these are open sources. Now, there are some times where we're able to do a sole source and say there is no other person who can provide this service. And we have to make the justification, including to the Department of Law, for why we are not making a... process open. And so these are some of the limitations we have. Now, when we have an RFP process, again, this is not a one-person decision-making process. It will be posted. It will go to the team's deputy for review. It will go to the CDPH Healthy Chicago Planning and Racial Equity Team for review. It will go to the Department of Law, the Office of Management and Budget for review. And these are all of the steps in the RFP review process. It is a two-month review process. So there is no single individual who makes decisions about funding. It is a participatory process that involves multiple departments in deciding who is awarded a grant. And so these are the areas where we want to make transparent. Now, what are we doing in CDPH to make the play-in field more equal? We have introduced what we call the CDPH guiding principles, including in our RFP template, we want people to demonstrate that they are using trauma prevention and trauma-informed services, ensuring that our services address trauma and healing. We have included a requirement for cultural responsiveness, ensuring that services are culturally and linguistically appropriate. They have to be able to make these services available in the language of the community. We have to request that the applicants demonstrate health equity in all communities, including how they are allocating resources or services to people and areas with the greatest need. And so these are the evaluation criteria that we've introduced. And from the feedback of our communities, we've also created a community reach component to our RFPs and included 10 points for alignment with CDPH principles and 10 points for community reach as a response to some of the calls from our community members to do better. So these are some of the ways that we are continuing to improve the system. What we will be able to do going forward in terms of funding depends on what we receive from the federal government. But we also want small organizations to be able to participate and providing education on how the RFP process works, encouraging organizations to come together as a coalition so that it's easier for them to, you know, manage the financial requirements. So that is as far as we've gone in terms of how can we make funding more equitable, how can we make funding more equitable? We will continue to work with the City Council on opportunities to make this more accessible to our communities. Our priority and our goal is to get to zero. When did you introduce the guiding principles, like the additional? This last year, with approval of our Board of Health. And the new RFP we posted, we got feedback from our communities when they said this RFP does not include community reach. So we pulled it down and said, we will include that as a component for the scoring. So these are new as of 2025 or 2020? Okay. So overall, our commitment is how do we get to zero? How do we bring this new HIV infections down? And, you know, our ability to do that, we're trying to learn from all the other programs where we're making progress in bringing numbers down to replicate the same model. So we remain accountable and we will continue to come before the Council to share with you the progress we're making. And then the final part of this is that is HIV funding, but overall, public health funding continues to be a challenge. We have shared this chart with you to demonstrate that a lot of CDPH funding comes from the federal government, government, which means our ability to continue to serve Chicagoans depends on funding from the federal government. Now, this is a lot of funding. This is over $560 million. And we know that the city cannot cover all of this. So advocacy at the federal level and making sure that it is visible how we are using this funding is really important. These are the threats. These are the agencies that fund CDPH, CDC, HRSA, HUD, and ASPR. This is where the funding for our work comes from. Now, these are the current proposals to reduce the budget of these agencies. If these agencies don't get money, we don't get money. So these are the areas where we are paying a lot of attention. There are cuts to critical agencies, which will then in turn impact our ability to provide, continue to do the work that we're doing. So we need your support in terms of elevating how important it is for Chicagoans to have this federal funding. We pay federal taxes, so we should get federal support. These are the areas that are at the most risk of cuts based on the proposals at the federal level. HIV, opioid epidemic response, including our ability to do naloxone distribution and overdose data. The public health infrastructure overall, our ability to do health assessments, disease outbreak response, and policy and regulatory capacity. Emergency preparedness and outbreak response. So laboratory capacity, our ability to do wastewater surveillance, all of that. And we have more than 200 staff on this grant. So this is a big concern for us. So we are monitoring the FY2026 budget appropriations that is underway at the federal level and the budget continuing resolution that must be passed by September 30. What we're able to do in 2026 or for the rest of the year is dependent on the decisions that are made. There are three subcommittees that we are watching very closely that have direct impact on CDPH funding, the Labor, Health, and Human Services and Education subcommittee, the Agriculture, Rural Development, Food and Drug Administration and related agencies, and then transportation, housing, and urban development. So we are cautiously optimistic, but the uncertainty around the FY26 budget is real. We are talking hundreds of millions here. So we are very, very worried. So what can we do if these changes come through? We have started the initial work of how can we partner better with the assets we have in Chicago to mitigate any potential harm. So we are beginning to prioritize evidence-based public health programs, documenting the impact, documenting the reach, having the data to support the work we're doing, and then partnership with the state and county. This is one example. We now have this gas government alliance for safe communities. It is an unprecedented collaboration between the state of Illinois, Cook County, and the city of Chicago to address violence. So that it's not just Chicago carrying the burden of keeping Chicago and safe. Whatever happens in Chicago is going to spread to the rest of the state. So how can we, you know, leverage all the resources and assets to better serve our communities? We're also working with the nonprofit philanthropic institution and relevant public-private partnership to help address service gaps. If they're not able to provide funding, can they provide services? So at least we're sharing the load and it's not just the city. So this is an example. And I know that you will love this because this is in the area of mental health crisis and behavioral health crisis. So this is the landscape. If you're in emergency 911, when there is need for immediate police, fire, or emergency medical response, that is one option. But we then have the city services that people can request through 311. And 988, which is a federal and state-funded initiative to address suicide and mental health crisis. So again, there are providers in that space covering Chicagoland. And then we have 211 Metro Chicago, which is, you know, collaboration with Cook County and us that lists all the resources available for the city of Chicago. Is 988 also at risk? The state has, through this last state budget, made provisions for a surcharge to keep 988 going. So if federal funding goes away, there is now a process at the state to keep it funded. And this is 211. We want everyone to know about 211 because 211 is where there is an inventory of state, county, and city resources. Not just the city, but what the county and the state can offer. And everything from child care, clothing, crisis services, disability services, some people don't know that they can get a home health aid through Medicaid. Some people don't know that they can get child care through the state or the county. Some folks don't know that there's legal assistance for eviction prevention through the county and through the city. So this website, this number provides a lot of information about the services available in health and social services across the city. We will be having a hearing on 211 on the 31st, and we're going to give everybody the information that you need in order to be able to use it effectively from your aldermanic offices. Awesome. So these are some of the ways that we are doing a better job of communicating what services are available. We continue to need your support to help build trust in public health, to help build trust in the local government, so that even the services we have, we can have better engagement. So this is all we have for you, Aldo, and Chair. Thank you. Dr. Ige, I am so impressed. You have run through so much information. today with your team. I am very grateful for all this information. I'm also very scared about, you know, the prospects that we face right now, given the cuts that are intended by the federal administration. And of course, we will continue to advocate with our delegation. Do I have any questions? I think that was very thorough. Would it be possible to get the deck the slide deck to share with the members of the committee and the rest? Okay. Well, so we have reached the end of our meeting today. Where am I? I don't know. I have like a mess of papers here now. Okay. With there being no further business before the committee, can I get a motion to adjourn? So moved by other woman Ramirez. Here, no objections. So order. And we are at the end of the hearing. This meeting is adjourned. This meeting is adjourned. Thank you. Thank you.