Good morning, everyone. Happy Monday. Go Bulls. Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. The Committee on Finance is called to order. Today, we'll be holding a TEFRA public hearing for the O'Hare Aeroterm Project for which the city will issue special facility revenue bonds. TEFRA, for those of you who have asked, means Tax Equity and Fiscal Responsibility Act. We will now have roll call to establish quorum. Vice Chair Conway, Alderman Laspata, Alderman Hopkins, Alderman Hall, Alderman Mitchell, Alderman Harris, Alderman Beal, Alderman Lee, Alderman Ramirez, Alderman Quinn, Alderman Lopez, Alderman Moore, Alderman Curtis, Alderman O'Shea, Alderman Taylor, Alderman Mosley, scratch that, Alderman Rodriguez, Alderman Scott, Alderman Ciccio Lopez, Alderman Burnett, Alderman Irvin, Alderman Talia Farrell, Alderman Cardona, Alderman Wagesback, Alderman Rodriguez-Sanchez, Alderman Cazada, Alderman Villegas, Alderman Ciccio Lopez, Alderman Mah oversimert, Alderman Madras Tades, Alderman Males Alderman Martins, Aldermanttar Ulerman, Alderman Ciccio Lopez, Aldermanaal Rise Major Zoting speculative Thanks, Mike. Alderman Sposato, Alderman Mitz, Alderman Mitz, Alderman Vasquez, Alderman Riley, Alderman Knudsen, Alderman Martin, Alderman Silverstein, Chairman Dowell's here. We have a quorum. We have 21 members. Alderman Mosley has requested remote participation for reasons stated under the provision of Rule 59. We have a meeting going on. Can I have a motion to allow Alderman Mosley? So moved by Alderman Casada. All those in favor, signify by saying aye. You've been baptized. All those opposed? In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it and the motion carries. I want to confirm. Alderman Mosley, are you with us? I also see Alderman Harris has also requested remote participation under Rule 59. Can I get a motion to allow Alderman Harris? So moved by Alderman Laspata. All those in favor, signify by saying aye. Opposed? In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. And Alderman Harris, are you with us? Yes, I am. Yes, I am. Good morning. Good morning. Alderman Cicho Lopez, we see you and are counting you towards quorum. Did I miss anyone? Oh, Alderman Wagaspak, see you and we will count you towards quorum. Let the record reflect that this is a public hearing that is being held pursuant to the requirements of Section 147F of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 as amended. Notice of this public hearing was published on April 2, 2025, on the website of the Office of the City Clerk of the City of Chicago. Let the reporter mark the screenshot of such notice as Committee Exhibit No. 1 for identification. This is a hearing regarding a plan to issue, excuse me, okay, this is a hearing regarding a plan of finance to issue Chicago O'Hare International Airport Senior Special Facilities Revenue Bonds, TRIPs Obligated Group Series 2025, and a principal amount not to receive $50 million. We will refer to these as the Series 2025 Bonds. The proceeds of the Series 2025 Bonds will be loaned to Arrow Chicago 2, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company. We will refer to them as the O'Hare Arrow Term Borrower, and we will be used to finance one the acquisition, finance or refinance the acquisition, construction, equipping, and or improvement of an integrated project consisting of air cargo facilities and other related facilities located in the Chicago O'Hare International Airport O'Hare, more fully described below. and two, fund a deposit to the debt service reserve funds for the bonds, and three, pay the cost of issuance of the Series 2025 Bonds, the Arrow Term, O'Hare Arrow Term Project. The project facilities are located at Chicago O'Hare International Airport, Chicago, Illinois, 11601 West Tui Avenue, Chicago, Illinois, 60666. Building 838 and consists of a long-term leasehold interest in a track of land containing an approximate amount of square footage at 320,000 square feet for air cargo facility and ramp parking area for air cargo facility and ramp parking area. Arrow Term Management, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, will be the initial manager of the project facilities. The city will issue the Series 2025 Bonds pursuant to its powers as a home rule unit of government under the 1970 Constitution of the State of Illinois and an ordinance adopted by the City Council of the City. The Series 2025 Bonds will not be a general obligation of the City, the State of Illinois, or any political subdivision thereof, but will be a limited special obligation of the City. The principle of premium, if any, and interest on the Series 2025 Bonds will be payable solely out of the revenue of the O'Hare Arrow Term Project, and other funds pledged and assigned for their payment by the O'Hare Arrow Term Borrower, in accordance with a loan agreement between the City and the O'Hare Arrow Term Borrower. The Series 2025 Bonds will not constitute an indebtedness or an obligation of the City, the State of Illinois, or any political subdivision of the State of Illinois within the purview of any constitutional limitation or legal provision. No holder of the Series 2025 Bonds will have the right to compel any exercise of the taxing body of the City, the State of Illinois, and the United States of America, or any political subdivision of any of them, to pay the principle of premium, if any, or interest on the Series 2025 Bonds. Written comments related to the plan to issue these bonds must have been submitted by email to the Committee on Finance no later than 10 a.m. Friday, April 11, 2025. Let the record reflect that no written comments were submitted on this project. Ladies and gentlemen, if any resident, taxpayer, or other interested person attending this hearing desires an opportunity to express their views for or against the proposed issuance of the Series 2025 Bonds, please do one of the following. Attend this hearing in person. Please come up to the microphone in the aisle when your name is called, or two for those who have called in on the toll-free phone number. Please enter star 9 on your phone to notify the host of the call-in number, and once you are called upon to provide your comments, please enter star 6 to unmute your phone. Each speaker will be limited to three minutes. Let the record reflect there have been no response or no response to the question proposed by the chair. Ladies and gentlemen, this concludes the public hearing on the proposed plan for the City of Chicago to issue the not-to-exceed-$50 million principal amount Chicago O'Hare International Airport Seniors Specials Facilities Revenue Bonds, TRIPs Obligated Group, Series 2025 for the O'Hare Aeroterm Project. Let the record reflect that the public hearing on this matter was concluded at 10-15 a.m. April 14, 2025. This concludes the TEFRA hearing. Ladies and gentlemen, the Committee on Finance is called to order once again. Today, we will be holding a TEFRA public hearing for the 111 West Monroe Project, for which the city will issue multifamily housing debt. The meeting has come to order. We will now have a roll call to establish a forum. Vice Chair Conway, Alderman Laspata, Alderman Hopkins, Alderman Hall, Alderman Mitchell, Alderman Harris has joined us remotely. Alderman Beal, Alderman Lee, Alderman Ramirez, Alderman Quinn, Alderman Lopez, Alderman Moore, Alderman Curtis, Alderman O'Shea, Alderman Taylor, Alderman Rodriguez, Alderman Scott, Alderman Scott, Alderman Cicho Lopez, Alderman Burnett, Alderman Irvin, Alderman Talley Farrell, Alderman Cardona, Alderman Wagesback, Alderman Rodriguez-Sanchez, Alderman Cazada, Alderman Villegas, Alderman Mitz, Alderman Sposato, Alderman Sposato, Alderman Vasquez, Alderman Riley, Alderman Knudsen, Alderman Martin, Alderman Silverstein. Chair Dowell is here. We have a quorum. We have 25 present in this meeting. Can I get a motion to allow Alderman... excuse me alderman mosley and alderman harris uh to participate remotely because of rule 59 so moved by alderman kazada again you're on a roll huh um all those in favor signify by saying i opposed in the opinion of the chair the eyes have it alderman harris here alderman mosley present this is a hearing regarding a plan to finance to issue multifamily housing revenue bonds series 2025 one for 111 west monroe project and a principal amount not to exceed 40 million dollars we will refer to these as the 111 west monroe bonds the proceeds of the 111 west monroe bonds will be loaned to 111 monroe affordable lp and illinois limited partnership we will refer to them as the 111 west monroe borrower to finance a portion of the cost for the development of an affordable housing project which we are calling the 111 west monroe project the 111 west monroe project consists of the following one the acquisition and adaptive reuse of a subdivided portion of a 24-story building located on a portion of the ground floor a portion of floor 11 and portion of floors 12 through 24 thereof including an allocable portion of the real estate acquisition costs thereof such building being located at 111 west monroe street chicago illinois and to the construction and a rehabilitation of a residential rental project consisting of 104 housing units of which 100 percent will be affordable for households earning no more than 80 percent of the area median income and at least 40 percent of which are expected to be leased to persons excuse me to individuals or families whose annual income does not exceed 60 percent of the area median income as well as an allocable portion of residential amenities for the tenants thereof the 111 west monroe borrower will be the initial owner operator of the 111 west monroe project 111 west monroe one 11 monroe ah gp llc and illinois limited liability company is the general partner of the 111 west monroe borrower the city will issue the 111 west monroe bonds pursuant to its powers as a home rule unit of government under the 1970 constitution of the state of illinois and an ordinance adopted by the city council of the city the 111 west monroe bonds will not be a general obligation of the city the state of illinois or any political subdivision thereof but will be a limited special obligation of the city the principle of premium if any an interest on the 111 west monroe bonds will be payable solely out of the revenue of the 111 west monroe project and other funds pledged in the sign for their payment by the 111 west monroe borrower in accordance with the loan agreement between the city and the 111 west monroe borrower the 111 west monroe borrower will not constitute excuse me the 111 west monroe bonds will not constitute an indebtedness to or an obligation of the city the state of illinois or any political subdivision of the state of illinois within the purview of any constitutional limitation or legal provision no holder of the 111 west monroe bonds will have the right to compel any exercise of the taxing power of the city the state of illinois the united united states of america or any political subdivision of any of them to pay the principle of premium if any or interest on the 111 west monroe bonds written comments related to this plan to issue the 111 west monroe bonds must have been submitted by email to the committee on finance no later than 10 a.m friday april 11th 2025 let the record reflect that no written comments were submitted on this project ladies and gentlemen if any resident taxpayer or other interested person attending this hearing desires an opportunity to express their views for or against the proposed issuance of the 111 west monroe bonds please do one of the following for those attending this hearing in person please come up to the microphone in the aisle when your name is called or two for those who have called in on the toll-free phone line please enter star 9 on your phone to notify the host of the call-in number and once you're called upon to provide your comments please enter star 6 to unmute your phone each speaker will be limited to three minutes if they let the record reflect that there have been no response to this question posed by the chair ladies and gentlemen this concludes the public hearing on the proposed plan for the city of chicago to issue the not to exceed 40 million dollar principal amount multi-family housing revenue bond series 2025 111 west monroe project for the 111 west monroe project let the record reflect that the public hearing on this matter was concluded before i conclude the public record here i will acknowledge alderman vasquez and alderman mitchell said he was already here um let the record reflect that the public hearing on this matter was concluded at 10 21 a.m april 14 2025 this concludes the teffra hearing one more y'all good morning ladies and gentlemen the committee on finance meeting is called to order today we'll be holding a teffra public hearing for the 208 south la sal project for which the city will issue multi-family housing debt we will have a roll call to establish quorum vice chair conway alderman lasbada alderman hopkins alderman hall alderman mitchell alderman harris uh alderman alderman alderman beal alderman lee alderman alberman ramirez alderman quinn alderman lopez alderman moore alderman curtis Alderman o'Shea alderman taylor alderman rodriguez alderman scott alderman cicho lopez alderman brunette alderman urban alderman talia farrell alderman cardona alderman wagasback alderman rodriguez sanchez alderman cazada alderman viegas alderman mitts alderman spazato alderman vasquez alderman riley alderman knudson alderman martin alderman silverstein chair dowell is here we have a quorum we have 28 members present with us in the room we have two aldermen alderman harris and mosley who have requested remote participation under the provision of rule 59 can i get a motion so move by alderman lee all those in favor signify by saying aye aye opposed in the opinion of the chairs the ayes have it and the motion carries confirming alderman harris and alderman mosley here present thank you this is a hearing regarding a plan to finance to issue multi-family housing revenue bond series 2025 208 south lasalle project in a principal amount not to exceed 25 million dollars we will refer to these as the 208 south lasalle bonds the proceeds of the 208 208 south lasalle bonds will be loaned to 208 lasalle affordable lp and illinois limited partnership will refer to them as the 208 south lasalle borrower to finance a portion of the cost for the re for the development of an affordable housing project which we are calling the 208 south lasalle project the 208 south lasalle project consists of the following one the acquisition and adaptive reuse of a subdivided portion of a 21-story building located on a portion of the ground floor and portions of floor 13 through 16 thereof including an allocable portion of the real estate acquisition cost thereof such a building being located at 208 south lasalle street in chicago illinois and to the construction and a rehabilitation of a residential rental project consisting of 51 units of which 100 will be affordable for households earning no more than 80 percent of the area median income and at least 40 percent of which are expected to be leased to individuals or families whose annual income does not exceed 60 percent of the area median income as well as an allocable portion of residential amenities for the tenants thereof the 208 south lasalle borrower will be the initial owner operator right of the 208 South LaSalle project. 208 LaSalle AHGP LLC, an Illinois limited liability company is the general partner of the 208 South LaSalle borrower. The city will issue the 208 South LaSalle bonds pursuant to its powers as a home rule unit of government under the 1970 constitution of the state of Illinois and an ordinance adopted by the city council of the city. The 208 South LaSalle bonds will not be a general obligation of the city, the state of Illinois, or any political subdivision thereof, but will be a limited special obligation of the city. The principle of premium, if any, and interest on the 208 South LaSalle bonds will be payable solely out of the revenue of the 208 South LaSalle project and other funds pledged and assigned for their payment by the 208 South LaSalle borrower in accordance with the loan agreement between the city and the 208 South LaSalle borrower. The 208 South LaSalle bonds will not constitute an indebtedness or an obligation to this other city, the state of Illinois, or any political subdivision of the state of Illinois within the purview of any constitutional limitation or legal provision. No holder of the 208 South LaSalle bonds will have the right to compel any exercise of the taxing power of the city, the state of Illinois, the United States of America, or any political subdivision of any of them to pay the principle of premium, if any, or interest on the 208 South LaSalle bonds. Written comments related to the plan to issue the 208 South LaSalle bonds must have been submitted by email to the Committee on Finance no later than 10 a.m. Friday, April 11. Let the record reflect that no written comments were submitted on this project. Ladies and gentlemen, if any resident or taxpayer or other interested person attending this hearing desires an opportunity to express their views for or against the proposed issuance of the 208 South LaSalle bonds, please do one of the following. For those attending this hearing in person, please come up to the microphone in the aisle when your name is called or two for those who have called in on the toll-free phone line. Please enter star 9 on your phone to notify the host of the call-in number. And once you are called upon to provide your comments, please enter star 6 to on mute your phone. Each speaker will be limited to three minutes. Is there any member of the public taxpayer interested person who wishes to make a statement with respect to this matter? Let the record reflect that there have been no response to this question posed by the chair. Ladies and gentlemen, this concludes the public hearing on the proposed plan for the city of Chicago to issue the not to exceed 25 million principal amount multifamily housing revenue bond series 2025 for the 208 South LaSalle project. Let the record reflect that the public hearing on this matter was concluded at 10 29 a.m. April 14, 2025. This concludes the TAFRA hearing and this concludes the Finance Committee meeting for this part. The Committee on Finance is called to order. We will now have a roll call to establish forum. Vice Chair Conway, Alderman Laspata, Alderman Hopkins, Alderman Hall, Alderman Mitchell, Alderman Beal, Alderman Lee, Alderman Ramirez, Alderman Quinn, Alderman Lopez, Alderman Moore, Alderman Curtis, Alderman O'Shea, Alderman Taylor, Alderman Rodriguez, Alderman Scott, Alderman Cicho Lopez, Alderman Burnett, Alderman Irvin, Alderman Talia Farrell, Alderman Cardona, Alderman Wagesback, Alderman Rodriguez Sanchez, Alderman AldermanLAUGHTER. Alderman Alderman Mitz, Alderman in the room alderman hall we will count you we still have a quorum we have 30 can i get a motion to allow alderman mosley and alderman harris to participate remotely so moved by alderman kazada all those in favor signify by saying i opposed in the opinion of the chair the eyes have it and we will confirm alderman mosley and alderman harris here present gotcha at this time we'll begin the public comment period the public comment period will be limited to 30 minutes out of respect for everyone's time each speaker is limited to three minutes we have no callers by remote participation today so we have one person that signed up to speak in person and that is taiwan sims good morning good morning committee good morning um so finance and whatnot i was thinking about george blakemore but i was also thinking about how old he is 80 some years old and how much time he spent here possibly coming up here speaking the same way i am even though i come speaking and trying to get help with housing and whatnot but when you think about the things that brandon john said he says that we are investing in our working people however chicago's most pressing financial obligation since 2022 that's when the new arrivals came has been the escalating prince pension obligation liabilities the city's contribution to four major pension funds municipal employees annuity and benefits labor and retirement employees annuity and benefits firemen and chicago policemen however as of 2022 these funds had a combined unfunded liability of approximately 33.9 billion with assets covering only 24 percent making them amongst the nation's most unfunded pension system wow but man the man said he is investing in the working class chicago's pension obligation continues to exert significant pressure on chicago's financing the city's 2005 budget allocates approximately only 2.9 billion to this underfunded municipals labor police firemen all these annuities this the money that they should be getting but we are investing in our working class people as of january the what global rating for the city has failed but in the news you only hear junk you only hear degrading all of this in finance for us but i'm still the homeless man in the room after you all spent 98 what nine what nine nine million now what's the number so extravagant nine nine nine nine that's the shortfall we suffer this year 928 million nearly a billion dollars spent on individuals who have not contribute who have not paid anything in and yet i'm the 44 year old chicagoan homeless still who comes here every day almost i'm losing my mind but you all said or the great collaborator says that he is investing in chicagoans investing in the working class and yet this unfunded thank you mr sims that concludes our public comment period we have a total of three items on the agenda this morning item number one is from the department of finance and the department of aviation it's an ordinance approving the authority to issue chicago o'hare international airport senior special facility revenue bond series 2025 in an amount not to exceed 50 million dollars we're joined this morning by brendan white assistant commissioner from the department of finance amber ritter managing deputy commissioner from the department of aviation and bernie williams assistant commissioner from the department of aviation we also have present with us today representatives from the deal team who are also available to answer any questions that might come up from the committee. We'll turn this over to Brendan Wright. Thank you, Chairman. Good morning, Alderman. I'd like to just start off by outlining what exactly this ordinance request would authorize. This would authorize the issuance of senior special facilities revenue bonds at O'Hare in the amount not to exceed $50 million and a term not to exceed 35 years. These bonds would be issued on behalf of Realtorm to reimburse project costs incurred in the construction of the Northeast Cargo Center, which was completed in 2023 and which Amber will describe in the following slides. Realtorm currently has an existing construction loan with JPMorgan Chase that will be paid off with these bond proceeds. The important thing I want to emphasize is that these bonds will be limited obligations of the city and all costs associated with the bonds will be paid by the borrower, which is Realtorm, not by the city or CDA. It would not constitute an indebtedness of the city, does not add to our outstanding debt, and has no effect on our credit rating. Only revenue collected by Realtorm from tenant rents will be used to pay the bonds. Some of their cargo tenants at O'Hare include global firms like DHL, AGI, WFS, SwissPorse, and Azaz. Part of the reason why we want to do this is the project generates fees for the city, and that includes ground rent at the facilities, net rent participation, increased landing fee revenue from increased cargo traffic, financing fees, and other fees. So there's the base rent that we get from the facility. That's approximately $7 million per year. Over the course of the term of the lease, that equals about $245 million to the airport. And for the bond issuance itself, we're charging a quarter of a percent financing fee for serving as the conduit issuer, and that amount is approximately $70,000. Now to talk a little bit more about the project and the facility, turn it over to Amber. Thank you, Brendan, and thank you, Alderman Council, for your attention this morning. In 2008, the city issued an RFP for the development of the cargo facility on the northeast side of the airfield at O'Hare. Previous to this, it had been a military installation, so the idea was to redevelop it into a cargo facility that would be developed by a tenant, and then the cargo operations sublet to subtenants. So the RFP was issued in 2008, and Realtorm, the company Realtorm, was the winning bidder. At the time, they were known as Aeroterm. You sometimes see that word, those terms used interchangeably, but now they've changed their legal name to Realtorm. So the project was split into three phases over time that required three separate leases plus an additional lease for a fuel farm. So the leases for phases one and two in the fuel farm were approved by city council in 2012. Development started right away, and they were operational in 2016. And then the phase three, which is the final phase, we came to council with that lease in 2020 and 2021. It was approved in January of 2021, and then it went into construction, and then the facility was fully operational in 2023. These are 35-year leases, and they all now expire in 2058. We did come to the city council to the aviation committee last September to make the expiration of all of these leases coterminous so that they weren't staggered. So now they do all expire at the same time in 2058. So looking at a little bit about just an illustration of kind of what we're looking at, this is the northeast corner of the airfield at O'Hare. You can see the blue and the orange buildings in the schematic are the cargo facilities that we're talking about. So phase two is actually the northmost blue rectangle. That opened in 2017. It's about 240,000 square feet of cargo space, and its primary tenants are Maestro and Swissport, which are, you know, cargo handlers. Phase one is the largest phase, and that is the darker blue rectangle to the south of that. It opened in 2016, 540,000 square feet of cargo space, and its primary tenants are AGI, TAS, and DHL. And then the phase three portion, which is the most recent portion that we're here to talk about today in connection with these bonds, is that diagonal sort of orange portion that's highlighted on this map. That's phase three, opened in 2023. It's 125,000 square feet of cargo space, and its primary tenant is WFS. So again, this is a 65-acre campus overall, one of the four airside cargo campuses that we have at O'Hare. The total facility space is about 900,000 square feet of space. It's got positions for 13 of the largest B747-8 freighter aircraft. So it's a very significant cargo facility within O'Hare's footprint. I'll talk a little bit more in a moment about how it fits into the footprint of O'Hare and the importance of the facility. Phase three, like I said, did open in 2023. We had a ribbon cutting, and you can see some nice photos of this. But the important thing, and I think the thing that we're most proud about from an airport perspective with this project, in addition to its role in our cargo operations, is the fact that it's historical. It was the first major cargo facility in the United States that was built by an African-American-owned prime contractor. So this is a huge project that was undertaken by BOA Construction, which of course is a Chicago-based construction company. They were the prime contractor. So this is a great opportunity for them and for the subs that they retained. So this project, in addition to that kind of historical accolade, also reached, you know, way exceeded its MBE-WBE goals. Its goals were 25 and 5, and the end result was 45 and 10, so significantly higher. That breaks down to 45% MBE participation, and of that it's 20% African-American-owned subcontractors, 18% Hispanic-owned subcontractors, and 7% Asian-owned subcontractors. And then in addition to that, we have 10% women-owned businesses that participated in this contract. So it's a huge victory for the airport, for the city, and for the region in getting this construction project off the ground and completed. It is now closed out. In addition to that, there are significant financial and revenue-related benefits to the airport that are direct, and then there's more sort of indirect benefits as well, which I'll touch on in a minute. The direct benefits are that at the end of the term of the lease, we will, the city, the airport will take free and clear the ownership of these facilities that Realtorm is constructing on their dime. So Phases 1, 2, 3 in the fuel farm to date, again, it's fully constructed and operational. To date, Realtorm has invested approximately $175 million in the construction of this facility. So that consists, of course, of the cost for structures, ramps, utilities, drainage improvements, roadways, and environmental improvements. Massive improvements to the area that are all funded by Realtorm that will be the ownership of the city at the end of the term. In addition to that, of course, we get rent every year. So as Brendan mentioned, that rent consists of different factors. The first is a base rent, which is a square footage rent. That amount goes up periodically in connection with the PPI or the CPI. Essentially, it's based on inflation. So it does, it is adjusted by inflation. And then in addition to that, we get a proceeds rent, a 3% proceeds rent, which is essentially 3% of the gross revenues that the tenant, Realtorm, is getting from its subtenants. So to date, that has resulted in about $7 million a year in rent to the airport from these facilities. And that, of course, is in today's dollars. So with the 35 years of the lease, and again, the base rent is adjusted by inflation, it will go up, but that's in, you know, $20, $25. So the entire 35 years of the lease, we expect approximately $245 million in rent from the facility to the airport system. And again, that's in $20, $25. So in the end, that would probably be a larger number. In addition, as Brendan mentioned, we do get, based on the lease, a quarter of a percentage financing fee for serving as a condo and bond issuer, which equals approximately $70,000. And I just want to take a moment to talk about the importance of cargo operations to O'Hare and to the city and to the region. You know, we talk a lot about our passenger capabilities at O'Hare, but I want to make sure everybody is fully aware of our extremely important cargo capabilities and the role that we play in the national cargo system. In 2023, O'Hare processed over 1.9 million metric tons of freight. That ranked us 13th in the world as far as the largest cargo airports in the world and sixth in the United States for volume and tonnage. But importantly, that same year in 2023, we were number one in the United States for value. That means that the stuff that we're bringing in, the goods we're bringing in and getting out are not just the, you know, the cheapest stuff that's kind of coming through. These are valuable, you know, commodities that are coming through. We buy vehicles, pharmaceuticals, electronics. These are high value items that we tend to be seeing at O'Hare. Number one in the country in 2023. And the exciting thing about that to me is that that's not just about airports. That's all ports. So only 1% of the global... songs, you know. So I'm going to talk about the listen to me in a good way that we should address this for a whole bunch of people. I guess that, in a good way, can we just get to go. And I think that, you know, getting the money is going to go. I think that with. So, I think that, in a different way, you know, there's going to find out what I was going to call it. So I think that it's going to be active in. And I'm going to get to cargo trade is air freight. Mostly it's trains and mostly it's shipping and containers, et cetera. So in 2023, we beat even the port of LA, which is a shipping port for value of commodities coming in. So this is an enormous benefit to the city of Chicago and to O'Hare, certainly into the region. Of course, we've been a key port during the COVID pandemic for the supply chain for pharmaceuticals. We got some of the first vaccines coming in. That was a great day for us to be able to watch that as airport employees. We have real estate and jobs that support this world-class cargo hub. And again, major benefits to the Chicago community and to the region. We have about 2 million square feet of airside cargo buildings and another 2 million square feet of landside cargo buildings. That equals about 40 parking positions for jumbo freighters at the same time. So again, that's a very significant cargo facility. We can handle the largest 747-8F cargo aircraft. And importantly, as Alderman, of course, remember, we are now at the end of our OMP, our O'Hare modernization program, which modernized our runways. That was a 20-year, over 20-year program. The result of that for cargo is that we now have two extra-wide runways, which is 10-center and 9-center, that can handle these largest aircraft. Many airports do not have that. So we've got capabilities to handle the largest aircraft in addition to our cargo capabilities for loading and unloading. And then you can imagine that this supports jobs. It supports about 5,000 cargo jobs daily. That's our whole cargo system, with another 10,000 cargo jobs within about a mile of the airport, because the economy around the airport, around O'Hare, has really risen to this logistics and freighting economy. So with that, I'm going to hand it back to Brendan to talk more about the bond itself. Thank you, Amber. So to talk about the actual bonds that we're contemplating issuing, I want to emphasize again right at the top that the city is not going to be responsible for paying debt service or fees associated with these bonds. The only revenues that are pledged towards the repayment of the bonds is revenue derived from real terms group of 86 cargo properties across the U.S. So that includes not only the Chicago facility, but also the New York's facilities at New York City, Louisville, Cincinnati, Miami. That cargo group is rated triple B plus by S&P. And the proceeds of bonds are going to be used to reimburse the cargo facility projects, funded debt service reserve fund, and to pay the cost of issuance. The deal team that was selected by real term is led by JPMorgan Chase, which, as I mentioned earlier, they hold the construction loan that initially funded this project. Their co-senior is Loop Capital Markets, which is a local African-American owned firm that we use on our own bond deals, rounding out the underwriters as Goldman Sachs. And then their legal team includes Greenberg Traurig, Mayor Brown, Chico Nunez, and Charity & Associates. All those are firms that we use in our own bond deal. Chico Nunez is a Hispanic owned firm and Charity & Associates is a Black owned firm. Now, I'll just turn it back over to Amber to conclude why we're doing this. Yeah, thank you, Brendan. And again, just to reiterate the high points here, major benefits to the city with this cargo development. The first, of course, is that we get the ownership of these buildings and the infrastructure at the end of the 35-year lease. We also get rent each year, as I mentioned, approximately $7 million a year in today's dollars, which will approximately, you know, equal about $245 million total over the course of the lease, again, in today's dollars, plus the $70,000 financing fee, in addition to all of the great, you know, cargo benefits to the city of Chicago that these facilities give. And then, as Brendan mentioned, again, this is not city debt. The city is not responsible for paying the cost of financing, nor is the city responsible for paying debt service, and the bonds do not increase the city's outstanding debt. With that, I think we'll conclude, Chairman. Thank you, Amber, and thank you, Brendan. I'd like to start with Aviation Chairman O'Shea. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you for that presentation, Amber. This is pretty simple. This is about supporting not just Chicago, the metro area, but the entire region. This is about significant revenue for the city of Chicago, and thousands and thousands of jobs continuing that moving forward. This is a credit to Commissioner Rhee, who will finish her term here as Commissioner of Aviation tomorrow, to put us in a place to make sure this next generation is successful. Thank you. Thank you, Chairman. Vice Chair Conway? Just want to make sure I understand. So they're going to pay the debt, and the rent is in addition to the debt payments? Yeah, so they're paying the debt service payments, and then the rent is separate. So they get paid by their subtenants, and they pay us the rent. Okay, and then, but then they pay the debt in addition to that. Yeah. Right. The amortization schedule, that's chosen by them or us? That was chosen by them. Right. Blind a couple years to ramp up, if it matters. We have some members of the real-term team who can answer sort of fine, detailed questions like that to vamp for time for them to come up to the microphone to potentially answer that. I would say that they're structuring this debt in, they're doing this concurrently with another New York City bond issue. There are 86 cargo facilities that are sort of backing up these bonds. So I assume that they're structured in some sort of way with other debt that they have outstanding to fit their overall desired debt structure. I didn't know if it was, knowing it's still already constructed, I didn't know, is it not already filled, or is it already filled, the facility? Oh, it's filled and fully operational, yeah. Okay, that's all I have to say. Okay. That's all I have, Madam Chairwoman. Thank you. Okay, thank you. Any other questions on this Alderman Lee? Thank you, Chair. Thank you for the great presentation. Just for general information, I understand how cargo works, having worked at an airline and really see the value. Cargo really saved, I think, everybody during COVID. But just to refresh everybody's memory, can you talk about how Chicago benefits from having additional cargo capacity? Absolutely. Thank you, Alderman. There's so many ways. Let me list the highlights. The first, of course, is just from looking at just the airport itself, and then we'll kind of move outward from that, I think. From the airport itself's perspective, when, in addition to, again, you know, the rent, et cetera, that we're getting from this property, each of those cargo airplanes that land pay us a landing fee. So, of course, you know, many, I'm sure most council members here are fully understanding kind of how the airport funds itself. It is, of course, an enterprise fund. The way the operations of the airport work are that we charge the airlines who land landing fees. We also charge them terminal space rent. And then that money together, essentially, in addition to, you know, some federal grants, goes to fund the operation of the airport. So, no city dollars, again, you know, come in to fund the operation of the airport at all. This is solely funded by the airlines. So, when cargo, you know, when we have a robust cargo operation, each of those planes that are landing are paying us money and offsetting the, you know, the overall fees for everyone, including the passenger airlines that we need to stay, you know, competitive. We want our passenger airlines to be able to give the best possible fares, you know, to our consumers here in Chicago. We want them to be competitive. We want them, we want to attract more. And so, that's one way is that the increased cargo capabilities, you know, increase our landing fees and our revenue. So, again, the revenue we talked about already with the rent, but in addition to that, there's just the volume revenue of them coming in. So, that's one very specific way. When you start moving out, though, I think the most important thing from the city's perspective is that, you know, we are right in the middle of the country, as we know. Chicago has traditionally been a transportation hub. We were started, frankly, because of our location, you know, with a portage between Lake Michigan and the Mississippi River back, you know, so many centuries ago. And so, we continue, and then we have the train system, which was robust here in Chicago. We continue to have that robust transportation hub feature, and that is really one of our key features here in Chicago. We have so many great things, but one of them is transportation. So, having this cargo capability and being able to grow along with demand and, you know, technology and innovation allows us to stay competitive on the global front. That means we can get products in here quickly. That means we can get them cheaply. We can continue getting our deliveries quickly. Our industry is able to get goods coming through without the, you know, additional freight, freightage shipping to get, you know, to come in and then, you know, take a truck to, you know, Tennessee or whatever it might be. So, we are really at the hub of getting things in and out of the global trade and the domestic trade. I think that's very important. And then, also, there's, you know, jobs. So, the freighting industry around O'Hare, as I mentioned, has, you know, supports at least 10,000 jobs a day in the region. We like to say Chicago is, I think it's within one 24-hour trucking drive of a third of the population of the country. So, we're really, you know, this is a hub that allows us to kind of spread out. And that's all jobs, of course, that these things are coming in. So, I think, you know, I mean, I could go on and on. And, of course, but I think those are the kind of moving in, you know, from the airport to the city to the region. It's cargo is incredibly important to just the, you know, keeping our society going and keeping our economy going. Yeah. And absolutely. The increased capacity means just more landing fees, fuel surcharges and all the like. Thanks for the answer to the question. I agree with Chairman O'Shea. This seems like a no brainer, especially because we're going to get ownership of this at the end of the term. So great job. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Alderman Lee. Alderman Irvin. Thank you, Madam Chair. I think this project has done what we need it to do. Ultimately, we are the bonding is to reimburse the developer for their cost to build the facility and put it on some long term arbitration schedule, essentially, is what we're doing here. Yes. Yeah. OK. All right. Built, done, met everything, did everything, no issues, no problems, no concerns. Yeah. Could you repeat that question? I just want to make sure I understand this. Just make sure this is ultimately this is built. We have no issues, no problems, nothing outstanding, no concerns to be worried about. We're just essentially swapping out all of the costs that have been done for this project and putting it on a long term fixed debt repayment schedule. That's right. The project is completely closed out. I'll just take this opportunity to mention, you know, something that that has come to our attention recently. The the let me just let's say this, but the way that the financing for this works is that real term, of course, is the developer and the tenant. They pay the the primary contractor and then which is BOA. And then, of course, you know, BOA is responsible for paying the subs. And so all of all of that money has been put out. The project has been closed. It's fully operational. And real term has paid all money owed to BOA construction. It's my understanding that there might be a few subcontractors who have not picked up their checks, but the check is waiting for them at the title company and has been for some time. That is a business decision that they've made. But that business decision is between them and the general contractor. Real term has paid out all money and those checks are waiting just for a few a few subcontractors. But the vast majority of some contractors have certainly accepted their checks and are pleased with the result. OK. All right. Thank you very much. Thank you. OK. Thank you, Alderman Irvin. Alderman O'Shea moves to pass on this item. Item number one, all those in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. Opposed. In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. And the motion carries. We will report the due pass recommendation at the next city council meeting on the 16th. Thank you, Amber and Brendan. Item number two is from the Department of Housing. It's an ordinance concerning the issuance of financial assistance to 111 Monroe Affordable LP and 111 Monroe Market Landlord LLC for the acquisition, construction, rehabilitation and equipping of affordable and market rate housing projects at 111 West Monroe Street in the 34th Ward, an amount not to exceed $40 million. We are joined today by Ryan Slattery, financial planning analyst from the Department of Housing, and Cindy Rubick, deputy commissioner in the Department of Planning and Development. We also have representatives from the development team. Ryan. Thank you, Chair Dow. Good morning, members of the Finance Committee. For the record, my name is Ryan Slattery, and I'm a financial planning analyst for the Department of Housing. I'm here today to present 111 West Monroe, also known as the Monroe Residences, which is one of the Office to Residential Conversion Projects in the LaSalle Central Redevelopment Project area. The project is located at 111 West Monroe Street in Alderman Conway's 34th Ward. Both Alderman Conway and Alderman Riley have provided letters of support for this project. Today's requested action before you is to approve and refer 111 West Monroe transactions to the City Council for the approval of the following. Authorize the execution of a TIF redevelopment agreement with LaSalle Development Partners, NFP, 111 West Monroe Affordable LP, and 111 West Monroe Market Landlord LLC, the use of $40 million in TIF, and to authorize the issuance of multifamily revenue bonds in the amount not to exceed $40 million. Before I jump into the presentation, Cindy Rubick is going to present a very brief overview of the Loop Revalidation Initiative. Thank you, Ryan, for the record. My name is Cindy Chan Rubick. I'm Deputy Commissioner with the Department of Planning and Development. So the COVID pandemic in spring 2020, as you all know, significantly exacerbated already high office and retail vacancies, challenged by aging, older structures, the rise of e-commerce, and work from home. The City initially convened over 150 stakeholders and identified 90 action items in the Central City Recovery Roadmap. These recommendations included repositioning the Loop and its historic financial core to be more vibrant, equitable, and a mixed-use environment. DPD then sponsored additional studies which recommended that the City provide financial assistance for mixed-income housing. The City then announced an invitation for proposals in the fall of 2022 for proposed conversions of underutilized office space into residential uses. And for the consideration of City financial assistance, a minimum of 30 percent of the units had to be affordable households averaging 60 percent AMI. After evaluating the proposals, the City continued with the underwriting process for, to date, five adaptive reuse projects. Each of these will need to be reviewed by City Council before the closing and construction can begin. In addition to the adaptive reuse component of the initiative, the City also is providing small business improvement grants for the first time in the Loop to address unprecedented high levels of retail vacancies. And then last year, the City also engaged the public on LaSalle's revisioning process to gather feedback to help to improve the public realm along this historically significant corridor. Following the engagement, the visioning study was completed and published online earlier this year. Thank you, Ryan. Thank you. So jumping back in, I'd like to share a few details about the existing structure, as you see here. Thank you. The East Tower exemplifies mid-century modernism with its steel frame and glass curtain wall. Despite these different styles, the two buildings are visually and structurally integrated. The landmark designation will protect the historic exteriors of these buildings and the bronze line sculptures as well. The development team is a joint venture between Prime Group and Capri Investments. Prime Group was founded in 1982 and has developed over $12 billion in real estate. Capri Investments was created in 1992 and has completed more than $14 billion in real estate investment transactions. The joint venture is also working on redevelopment of the Thompson Center, which is to convert the former state of Illinois facility into office space for Google. Prime is also working on two-way selfless sale office residential conversion that you'll hear about later this morning. The architect for this project is Stantec, a global leader in sustainable engineering, architecture, and environmental consulting. The general contractor, syndicator, and property management have yet to be determined. The construction and permanent lender for the project is Merchant's Capital, and the attorney is Applegate and Thorne Thompson. 1-11-Must Monroe is an adaptive reuse project that results in the conversion of approximately 315,000 square feet, containing 345 residential units on a portion of floors 11, floors 12 through 24, a fitness center, swimming pool, private roof deck, parking, and club room. Of the 345 residential units, 104, or 30%, will be affordable to households earning an average of 60% area median income. The remaining units will be rented to unrestricted households. Unit sizes will range from studios to two bedrooms, with square footage averaging 477 square feet for studios, 707 square feet for one bedrooms, and 1109 square feet for two bedrooms. The project will provide 104 rental units that will consist of a total of 19 units at 40% AMI, 46 at 50% AMI, and 39 at 80% AMI. The table, as you see in the bottom, outlines the additional unit details, including estimated initial rents for the 4 billion units. The rents for the 4 billion unit studios will range from $727 to $1570. One bedrooms will range from $767 to $1608, and two bedrooms will range from $919 to $1928. The rents for the 4 billion units will be significantly lower than the unrestricted market rates. The rents for the 4 billion units, rental rates for Class A. Buildings in the loop are roughly $2,260 for studios, nearly $2,800 for one-bedrooms, and about $4,100 for two-bedroom units. So the structure and the city requirements that we have for those projects, the TIF disbursement schedule is $12 million upon expenditures of 30% construction, $12 million upon expenditures of 60% construction, $12 million upon 90% construction, and then the remaining $4 million upon issuance of a certificate of completion. The city's construction compliance requirements include prevailing wage, 26 MBE, 6% WBE, and 50% city residency. The mixed-income rental housing development has a total development cost of $179,200,000. The developers plan to use the FHA HUD 221D4 loan in the amounts of $86 million, or 48% of the total development costs. 22.3% of the project, or $40 million, will be the TIF grant. The applicant is leveraging LIHTC and historic tax credits that will generate a combined $36.6 million in equity, approximately 16% of the total development costs. Development also anticipates using owner equity and deferred developer fee for the remaining sources. In all, the pre-unit costs sits at $519,420. For a pre-unit breakdown, studios are $371,000, one-bedrooms are $540,000, and two-bedrooms are $866,000. A closer look at the uses, roughly $48 million is an acquisition, $91 million in hard costs, $22.6 million in soft costs, and $8.5 million in developer fee. I'd like to point out there are several factors that drive up the cost for these types of adaptive reuse projects. The conversion costs, so costs to convert these projects are similar to new construction projects due to extensive mechanical equipment and plumbing, HVAC, and other code requirement modifications. The floorplates, these, the office buildings, former office buildings, have larger, deeper floorplates that are more inefficient in terms of rentable and non-rentable spaces. This reduces the feasibility. The building size, similar, office buildings are often too big for a fully convert to residential, resulting in costly building modifications. The financing costs, interest rates are still fairly high, making financial more expensive and reducing the feasibility of the project. The structural challenges, the office building has many structural obstacles, windows, column placements, excessive elevators, sprinklers, means of egress, and then also the affordable requirements. 3% affordability requirements lower the rental income, creating a financial complexity. Also, we have the historic preservation, so the conversion of a historic building requires higher standards of care and specialized expertise. So, the building occupies the southwest corner of West Monroe and Clark Street. Serious photos of the exterior of the building. Here we have the breakout of the building showcasing the 345 residential units in the upper floors, mainly floors 11 through 22. And then we have a future 327 key hotel as anticipated main lane floors 3 through 10. Here's the renderings of the building once it's complete. So, now we get to the public benefits, which include converting unregulized space. This will help increase the property taxes. Housing production in the loop community area. 104 affordable units will be created in households earning 40 to 80% AMI. All of the affordable units will be type A accessible. And then also for the historic preservation, they are requesting landmark status. And we'll be leveraging historic tax credits. For environmental sustainability, the adaptive reuse will be energy efficient with upgrades. And then academic impacts and job creation. There's about 200 construction jobs. As I said previously, 26% MBE and 6% WBE. The project timing, both closing and construction start date, is anticipated to be September of 2025, with construction completion at December of 2027. As I stated earlier, today's request action to the Finance Committee is to prove and infer 111 West Monroe change transaction to City Council for the approval of the following. Authorized execution of a TIF redevelopment agreement with LaSalle Development Partners NFP, 111 West Monroe Affordable LP, and 111 West Monroe Market Landlord LLC for the use of $40 million in TIF and to authorize the issuance of multifamily housing revenue bonds in the amount not to exceed $40 million. Thank you for your time today. We also, with us today, we have from the Prime Group, Mike Ruski and Jeff Breeden. Unfortunately, Quentin Primo was unable to attend to his sickness. He is sick this morning. But we're happy to answer any questions. Thank you, Ryan. I wanted to ask a question regarding the 104 affordable units. You say here that it would be affordable to house, 30% would be affordable to households earning an average of 60% of the area median income. And I noticed on page 7, you speak to 40% AMI and 50% AMI. I'm wondering how you, can you tell me how you're going to secure the 40% and 50% AMI? How is that going to be done? So after City Council, we started drafts for the Inclusionary Housing Agreement. And within the Inclusionary Housing Agreement, we'll have those parameters based off the ARO requirements. So we'll have within, they call it the IHA, they will have the 40, 50, and 80% requirements within there that are required. And does that get attached to the RDA? It's a separate document to it, but it puts the lien on the property as well. So it's also reported, but it's separate to the RDA. All right. Thank you. Any questions before I have, you want to close? Okay. So we'll start with Alderman Villegas. Thank you, Madam Chair. I see reference to MBE and WBE, which is great. Is there any VBE goals on these projects? There's no federal dollars, so it's just WBE and MBE. Does it work? It doesn't, a VBE is not a federal program. V as in Victor. Oh, V. Sorry, I thought you said D. I'm sorry. Apologies. Not that I'm aware of. Okay. Can you tell me why there isn't a goal on there? It's a city ordinance we passed. I'm not sure, actually. Which ordinance was it? Apologies. Veteran Business Enterprise Ordinance. Okay. I'm not familiar. I'm sorry. Can you check with that? We can check with that. Yeah. And I'd like to see that incorporated. I mean, that's an ordinance that we passed unanimously from the body a couple years, a few years ago. And then great to see this project repurposing. My question, my other question is, how many of these, how many more are left in the queue? Do you want to talk? Sure. We have one that was already approved by City Council last fall, 79 West Monroe. And we have this one on the agenda today, as well as one 208 South LaSalle, which you'll hear next. And then we have two more projects that we're still working with the development team on, 30 North LaSalle, which is Kitty Corner to City Hall. So, you know, and 135 South LaSalle, which is the landmarked field building. So we're going to do a total of five of these? Okay. Cool. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Alderman Villegas. Alderman LaSpada, followed by Alderman Lopez. Thank you very much, Chair. I know this has been in the working for a long time. I deeply support it. I appreciate the income grading of the units. I'm particularly curious, and I was hoping you could share, when we talk about energy efficiency standards in the building, what does that look like? Can you elaborate on that? Oh, sure. Yes, sir. The Department of Planning, we have a sustainability matrix, as you know. I imagine that was where you were going. Yes. And so for new construction, it's, you know, 100 points with a menu of options. For major rehabilitation, it's 50 points. So they would have to comply with that as part of the redevelopment agreement. But really, when you adaptively reuse a building, the reason why the points are lower is because there's just an inherent carbon savings by, you know, reusing a building, and especially a historic one, because then you're required to keep more of the historic components. I mean, to say nothing of bringing it up to date with the existing energy code and the building code. But do – have they stated to us the 50 points that they intend to apply against for the sustainable development policy? Well, there's a requirement to meet the 50 points, and then when they submit the permit, that's when we vet which points they're targeting. I hear that, and at the same time, usually, like if we were at the plan commission, we don't wait until the building permit to, like, understand what points they're at least intending. Correct. It's just out in the air? They do identify which ones they're targeting. Targeting when it's when it's a PD, we can we can do that as well. Yeah, I think I think the development team can speak to what they anticipate if that works for you. Sure. Mr. Reschke. Good morning. Yes. In terms of sustainability, I think we're well over 50 points. I don't know offhand, but I know we've submitted the specifics. I think we're in the 60 range. The exact items out of the list. I don't recall offhand, but I know we've finalized that and it should be in the city's possession. That's fine. Would you mind just providing that to the chair? The chair. Thank you so much. Thank you, sir. Thanks, chair. Thank you, Alderman Laspata. Thank you, Mr. Reschke. Alderman Lopez, followed by Alderman Mitchell. Thank you, chairman. And good morning, members of the committee. First, I want to say that I fully support the idea of helping to revitalize downtown and putting to use some of the vacancy that we've seen. The question that I actually have is for whomever would like to answer it, because it's great to see projects move with lightning speed in areas that we want them to happen, right? We saw the sale reimagined or whatever it's called within the last year and a half to create now five projects, correct? And then you have a community like Back of the Yards, where you all have sat on your hands since 2022 on an affordable project that would actually create and activate a vacant storefront parcel on 4630 South Ashland, which is basically going dead, which is basically going dead because you all refuse to move. We see this time and time again in neighborhoods where the stagnation of the departments are either killing projects or driving costs up while something like this in downtown moves with breakneck speed, right? That's a question. I mean, so this project started back in 2023, so it's, yeah, I mean, it's quick, but... And last time I checked, LaSalle Street is not blighted compared to some neighborhoods in our communities, correct? I'll try to answer your question. I think it's, every project is definitely complicated, has its own set of complex issues. I think financing has been difficult for all projects. And I think the ones that you're talking about, we have tried to advance as many as we can when we have the financing secured. So if there's a higher affordability component, it requires competitive financing applications through the Department of Housing. Actually, I'm directly referring to, like, TIF support that's promised and never acted upon. So, for example, in this instance, we are talking about a $40 million TIF infusion for this project, correct? So in other projects, again, Back of the Yards, for example, which was promised $15 million and an additional $8 million by the previous administration, a $23 million total TIF infusion to help make that happen in 2022, how is it? We're not talking about financing. We're not talking about anything other than the city writing the check. And in this instance, the loop for this project is moving, again, breakneck speed, but there are plenty of TIF issues, TIF-based projects waiting for the city to take action. Where's the holdup? And what makes this so much more of a priority than what's going on in our neighborhoods? I mean, I don't know your particular project, and I'm not sure. We can bring it up to our senior staff and find out. It's 4650 North South Ashland, you said. That's the address. Madam Chairman, I'm going to follow up with the departments offline, but I think that all of us deserve a better answer because I think all of us have projects where we've seen issues and where we are seeing now this happening for the loop, which, again, I fully support everyone getting the help that they need. I want a vibrant downtown, but I also don't want the blank, dumb stare from the departments when our neighborhoods are asking us what we're doing. Thank you. Thank you, Alderman Lopez. Alderman Mitchell. Thank you, Madam Chairman. I would like to know what activities or efforts have taken place to date with respect to the 26th and 6th floor MB participation. And I would like to know what type of activity related to the prime GCs, joint ventures, to get to that number. Who can speak to that? What has been so far? What kind of efforts, activities? On their soft costs so far. That would be not a question for you guys, but Mr. Reschke? Yes, you know, we fully intend to meet or exceed the 26th and 6th requirement, but we have not awarded any subs yet. We have not even selected a general contractor. We're in negotiations with the two general contractors. But I think we have a pretty good track record in the city of Chicago over the last four decades of meeting the city residency and the MBE, WBE rules, and we will continue to do so. Who are you in discussion with for the GC? If you don't mind, can we keep that confidential? I'm happy to discuss it with you offline. Are they MBEs? They're committed to meet a minimum of 26.6. Yes. His joint venture is? The general contractors that we're discussing are not MBE, but the subcontractors will meet that requirement. So neither of the people you referenced for the general contractor role are MBEs? I'm sorry. I didn't hear your question. Neither of the general – neither of the companies that you're in discussion with for the general contractor role are the MBEs? No. I will say it's a joint venture, and unfortunately, Quentin Primo wasn't able to be here today. He was sick. But he's an MBE. On the developments, on the developer side. Mr. Rushdie, on the soft cost side, have you – do you have any MBE – you were asking about MBE, WBE numbers on what you've spent so far on the soft cost side? Well, that's only been, I would suspect, $2 million in architectural engineering fees, and I don't know what percentage has been 20 – falls in the MBE, WBE category, but it's a very small part of the $179 million of the total cost. So most of the MBE, WBE awards will be, you know, with hard-cost subcontractors, not necessarily on the soft cost side. Thank you for your response. Thank you. Is that it, Alderman Mitchell? Alderman Irvin. Thank you, Madam Chair. I think Alderman Mitchell kind of was looking at the point that I was, and I really want to know what the black participation looked like on this job. Unfortunately, I don't think – I'm going to vote on this without getting some kind of clarity and understanding of what the participation looks like. We say 26-6. I understand that. To date, you spent $3 million, and you can't tell me how much you spent with MBE contractors. I got a problem with that. So until we can get some clarity and some finite nature as to where the money is going on this project, I don't think that it's something I'll be able to support. Thank you, Alderman Irvin. Vice Chair Conway, this is your project. Thank you very much, Madam Chair. One, this project as well as the next project are hugely important projects for the city of Chicago. As we – every city in the world has to rethink its central business district after a global pandemic. It can't just be a place where people work. They have to be able to live and eat and shop in that area. And especially in this case, we are talking about an iconic building that perhaps difficult for adaptive reuse. Nonetheless, the developer and DPD have come together to find out a way to keep this iconic building intact and engage in adaptive reuse to build housing here downtown. I don't need to tell any of you about the housing shortage we have, not only downtown, but across the city of Chicago. In fact, we're going to spend a lot of time later today talking about it. So this is hugely important. Thank you very much. This is especially well-timed as it's coming on the heels of the Google project, which is going to create thousands of jobs nearby. And with regard to the TIF amount, $40 million, a lot of money. I'm not going to sugarcoat that. But I want you all to put that in the context of the rest of the capital stack in this project, a project where the per-unit costs actually seem relatively economical relative to other projects. But nonetheless, this is part of a $179 million project, of which we are 20-ish percent of it, less than between 20% and 25% of it. So based on that and based on the importance of this for our city's economy, our city's property tax revenue, as well as housing units for workforce housing for all the jobs that Google will be creating, I will ask my colleagues to support this. Thank you. Thank you. Alderman Moore. Thank you, Chairman. I don't think no one wants to stop this project. I think it's a good project and one that's needed. But I am concerned about the question that my colleague, Chairman Jason Irvin, raised. And my whole thing with any projects and anything that we're doing as Alderman is getting that information. And if that information is not obtained, it becomes difficult for us to make the right decision. And so if he asks for that information, and that's important information, I know to a lot of members of the Black Caucus, it's important information to me. I make a motion to hold this item until he receives that information. I don't want to get into this situation and vote no on this and it fails or anything like that. But I think let's get that information so we can move forward on this. Can I make another suggestion, Alderman Moore, if you would be willing to do this? I would say if we pass this item, that I would make a commitment to hold it in committee until we receive the information. We might receive it tomorrow. And then we have city council on Wednesday. I would still like to move forward with this. So, yes, Alderman Villegas. Madam Chair, what information are you asking for? What I'm hearing from the committee is that they want, one, knowledge about what the MBE-WBE numbers look like for money that has already been spent on this project. And, two, what is the current thinking around the MBE-WBE projections, perhaps, for the construction side of it? So while that information is being gathered, I also heard that it was specific around Black participation. So if that's the case, I'd like to see what the Hispanic participation is. All right, I agree with that. So all of the categories. Alderman, Vice Chair Conway? I would only say in response here that the part of this is very early in putting together the capital stack of this project, in the sense that it only seems like there's been a limited amount of architectural as well as engineering costs that have been expended. I mean, not only has the developer in this case come forward, and we can also recall who the other person in the joint venture is, but the developer has come forward and committed himself to exceed the participation requirements of this project like they have in every case. And I would also point out that we're not dealing with just some, you know, out-of-nowhere developer. Mr. Reschke and Mr. Primo have been developing in this town for four decades, and to hold back such a hugely important project is the early process. We're not holding it back. We said that we would pass it today, and I would hold it in committee pending some information that the committee is asking for. I think it's a lot to ask the developer to be able to obtain that, obtain information on a $180 million project between now and 48 hours from now on that. Well, it came here without any information. We see projects all the time that have identified contractors and who the architects are and all of that. Not a lot of $180 million projects when we're talking about $40 million of the capital stack, though. I think it's unfair to ask the developer or that based on his track record. All right. Thank you, Mr. Conway. Just for the record, based on your comment, I withdraw my motion to hold. Based on my comment to hold. Alderman Lopez. Thank you, Chairman. Chairman, respectfully, this is the first of five, correct? Second. Second. Okay. How many millions of dollars are we committing to this project? It's $40 million. To the overall. Oh, the overall. Yeah, roughly. For all five, it's $249 million. $249 million, and we are trying to get specifics on what, at bare minimum, 26.6, 26 and 6 looks like. Bare minimum. Yes, but the TIF funds would not be reimbursed to the developer without proof that they're complying with the. Thank you. My point is this, and I think it's one of those rare moments that brings all of us together concerning our ability to ensure that we are all actively seeing our communities reflective in this deal. There's an urgency. We have to walk. Can we have other conversations or just? We have an urgency here. I understand that. We have a ward that wants to move and a developer that wants to go. But we also have seen time and time again, and I'm sure each of my colleagues can attest to our own specific situations where we are the afterthought in these deals. Whether it's companies that come to us for tax breaks, who've done all the work, and then say, oh, by the way, we forgot about MW minority participation. Or we're going to focus on waivers because we didn't have a plan to come up with it. You could be brand new. You could be 100 years in the business. I don't care. There's nothing wrong with this body saying we want to know what the plan is to ensure that women, that minorities, that veterans, that all of those people we claim to care about are part of this bill, are part of this building. And moving forward with the next one, because I'm pretty sure the same questions that we're going to have for this, we're going to have again in about 10 minutes. So I appreciate, Chairman, your offer in holding and getting some answers. I don't think that for such a big project it should be difficult to get answers because, as you're right, as you stated, you are right. They should have came in with it. They should have been prepared to answer that question. That is not a new question in this room. So I think we can, you can, if it passes, hold it, get some answers, and make sure that we are all prepared, especially from the city side, because I have to say it's quite revealing that the department didn't even realize we had a veteran's preference that had to be incorporated in this as well or included in that discussion. So thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Alderman Lopez. Alderman Riley, I thought I saw your hand up, followed by Alderman Mitchell. And then Mr. Reske will give you a chance to speak to the body. Alderman Riley. Thank you, Madam Chair. And I just wanted to speak up generally about the TIP request for the Central Business District. I agree with everything Alderman Conway said. But just wanted to provide a friendly reminder to folks that it's not just the 34th and 42nd wards that depend on these projects being successful. We have a central business district that is sucking wind, and we have a collapsing tax base here. We have obsolete buildings that were built, frankly, to be fortresses over a century ago. And because of that fact, these are bank buildings we're talking about generally. These are difficult projects for adaptive reuse. These are clearly historic structures. They're beautiful, majestic. They should be on a walking tour for sure. But otherwise, these massive buildings with millions of square feet have been rendered essentially obsolete. Class A buildings are eating the lunch of buildings like these. And I think that the commercial real estate community has accepted that fact. And unfortunately, in order to facilitate an adaptive reuse of these dated structures that were built with, you know, many feet thick concrete walls to prevent people from robbing banks, you do need a little extra assistance, especially when you put a premium on delivering affordable housing. housing units. And everyone's kind of losing that here in the conversation. This project is more expensive because we're trying to provide affordable housing stock in the central business district closest to where working families are employed. That's a benefit to the entire city. For Alderman Conway and myself, our residents already live here. Our voters are here. But we can't afford to have all of these buildings in millions of square feet in the central business district on LaSalle Street sit fallow. That will be a slow death for the central business district. And I'll remind folks that when we go through our annual exercise during budget to bail out the Chicago public schools, seemingly every single year, we surplus heavily the downtown TIFs. In fact, we've done that routinely through a few administrations now. So you don't see a lot of these TIF awards being given out as frequently or consistently as you do in the neighborhood awards. And I would argue that Alderman Conway and I have been very judicious in how these funds are used. And during my 18 years here, we've only approved a handful of TIF funded projects out of this particular TIF district. Because I really felt that if we're going to make these kinds of commitments, these big financial commitments, it really has to pass an extraordinary but-for test. And I can tell you that none of these properties we're talking about on LaSalle Street could be financed and repurposed to deliver what the city is asking for. People have to remember, we framed the redevelopment plan here as the city government and then asked developers to come participate, not the other way around. And so it's not as if these developers all are being opportunistic and saying, just give us this money and we'll do X, Y, and Z. No, the city actually laid out the plan here. And it was up to the developers to decide voluntarily whether or not they wanted to participate. And many did and others didn't. And so again, the central business district's tax base is what allows us to fund most of our citywide programs. This is the tax base that pays the city's bills, whether you represent the 50th ward or the first ward. So let's not get too regional about this. Let's think about this as a whole for the city. I think that the information that's been requested by Alderman Moore and Alderman Lopez is reasonable. And I think that we should have passed this out of committee and I hope we will with the other projects as well. But this is an important investment in the central business district. And again, we've been very sparing in the TIF awards we've made here over the last two decades. This is one of those special circumstances, I think, where we need to make these investments. Alderman Riley, I think that there's no argument with what you just said. I think people here want to support this project and support it. I think they're just looking for some additional information since this is a large amount of money on how diverse companies get to participate in this project. Well, and Madam Chair, I'm... And you said you agreed. I 100%. So I would urge the department and the developer to get that information as quickly as possible. I would just hate to see the timeline for these projects disrupted because of it. But yes, we should all have transparency. My goal is to approve it today. I wanted to respond to Alderman Villegas. The Department of Housing is informing me that there is a 10% veterans preference in the affordable units, the ARO units in this development. Madam Chair, I appreciate that. On the construction side, there's also a VBE goal as well. Right. I understood that point that you're making. I just wanted to put on the record because the question you asked, the first question, was on the veteran preference. Thank you, Madam Chair. Alderman Mitchell, followed by Alderman Irvin, followed by Alderman Vice Mayor Burnett. Thank you, Madam Chair. Alderman Conway made reference to the developer's history. I am not familiar with the developer's history, so I request to the chair that some brief history of MBE, making those MBE numbers. And I tried to go on the website to see the projects. None of that's listed. So I request to the chair that kind of information with respect to MBEW participational projects. Thank you. Alderman Irvin? Thank you, Madam Chair. I guess to reiterate your point, not against what's happening. I'm just against the brothers not getting a cut. That's all. So the only thing I'm asking for is that for our communities to participate. That's the only thing that we're looking for. And I don't get the sense from the conversation that that's even really at the forefront. I mean, you want to have these conversations. Let's have these conversations on the front end. And you're saying you're early on in the process of this project, but we're just not seeing what the participation is going to look like. I'm sorry. I mean, again, I would like to see, hell, my first bank account came out of that building. So I'm familiar and understand that it's going to require a lot to make happen. But again, we've got to make sure that we are looking at all of Chicago. This is not, it's a downtown project, but yeah, black folks go downtown too. And we want to make sure that we participate and what's going on a hundred and some odd million dollars and no plan on black participation. I'm sorry. I won't move on that. And if I'm, if you want to hang me for not making sure that black folks participating, go ahead. I'm okay with that. I just want to make sure that our people are participating in this project, period, point blank, not against the project. I think it's a great project. Affordability downtown is great. Out of all these millions of dollars that's going on, we just want to make sure that black folks get a cut of the action, period. Thank you, Chair Urban. Vice Mayor Burnett. Thank you very much, Madam Chairman. I concur with my colleague. I know this developer, worked with him for years. He's a very inclusive developer. Matter of fact, coincidentally, he's doing the state of Illinois building. He has a black partner. Him and the African-American developer are doing it together. He's very inclusive. So I would anticipate that he would make sure that it would have some diversity involved with this project. But also, I wanted to say this. I want to commend both of my colleagues, Alderman Rowley and Alderman Conway. And Alderman, I mean, that's a very compelling argument that you had about having affordable housing down there. That same argument can go toward green social housing that we just talked about the other day. Because we need, right now, we will not be able to get developments done in this city if we don't have government involved. Because of the economy, because of what's happening in Washington, D.C., we need help to continue to have development in this city. I was blessed to be on the task force to come up with the ideas for the reimagined LaSalle Street. Matter of fact, I was one of the ones who interjected that we need to have, we should use affordable housing to help to save some of these buildings downtown. I don't get the credit for it, and that's fine. But I understand this because I know in the 80s, in the 80s, guys, there are several buildings downtown, even presidential towers that used to be in my ward wouldn't have been able to have been built if government didn't give them money. There's a lot of buildings in our city, especially in the downtown area, on Ontario, on Dearborn, on LaSalle Street, on Clark Street, had an 80-20 deal with the federal government that Roskinkowski helped to get money for in order for those developers to be able to build those buildings back then. That's when we had a bad market, and those developers and those construction companies were able to sustain themselves. But at the same time, people were able to get affordable housing and live downtown. And folks don't even know that they got an affordable unit. They live downtown with everyone else. My dad actually used to live in one, 750 North Dearborn, right, is one. 1212 North Michigan, right? 1212, no, 1212 South Michigan, 1212 North LaSalle Street. I can name several of those buildings that has Section 8 affordable housing because of these deals. So this is a great deal, just like green social housing is a great deal to be able to help to sustain the city and keep construction going in the city of Chicago. I support this 100 percent, and I agree with everything Alderman Riley said about it. Thank you. Thank you, Vice Mayor. Alderman Conway, do you want to let Mr. Reschie speak before, and you can close? I was actually just going to ask a point of information, then I'll show up. Are the TIF payments dependent on them making the WBE and MBE requirements? Yes, that's correct. Okay, so they will be paid out once they approve and they can be making it? Yeah, they have to. Point of information, Alderman Mitchell? As the project progresses, it is not always accurate. NBWB participation is not always accurate as reflected at those intervals. So how would you guys work to make sure those numbers are adequately reflected? So there is a monitoring compliance that reviews all of their contract or sworn statements and verifies that NBWB is met. So in order for them to get a CFC, that has to be included so they wouldn't be able to get the remaining payment, but we also can go after them for the previous payments as well. One more question. You said they attest that basically these numbers are being met. Are supporting documentation? They review monitoring clients who go on. Okay, thank you, Alderman Mitchell. Mr. Reschie? Just to clarify a few items, I think the point's already been made, and I thank my aldermen here today who are in support of the project. But just from a timing standpoint, we cannot identify specific MBE, WBE, or veteran contractors at this time until we go to the market and start awarding contracts on a real project that has all the approvals and the capital stack is complete. That's when we go to the market and bid the project, review and scope all the bids, and then make decisions of what awards to make to what contractors. That probably won't be for at least 60, 75 days from today until we actually would have a list of the early awards. But just to give you an example, letting a job of this size, like the Google project, we're still awarding contracts. We started 18 months ago on the Google project. We're still awarding contracts as we go. It's not like I can give a list to this committee and say, here's all the subs and here's the percentages of MBE and WBE. We will provide that to the city as they monitor our progress. And, of course, the most important point is the receipt of the TIF funds is subject to our compliance of that. Now, having said all of that, I do have a 40-year track record in this city. My 50% partner is a dear friend of mine. We've been doing business for 30 years. He's African-American. If there's nobody that's more passionate about inclusivity in this city is Quentin Primo and myself working together. So if there's any development team that anybody would question, I think, on this issue, I'm surprised that they would question our team about our ability to meet these goals. We're committed to meet these goals, and we will. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Reschke. Seeing no other questions, Alderman Curtis, we will count you towards quorum. Motion made by Vice Mayor Burnett to move, do pass on this. All those in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye, opposed. Alderman Lopez, Alderman Mitchell. Okay. The do pass recommendation will be reported out at the next city council meeting, pending information that had been requested by Alderman Mitchell. Heard you, Mr. Reschke, about what you can't do in the future. But to their past participation that the Alderman requested. Thank you. Moving on to the last item on our agenda, which is also from the Department of Housing, concerning the issuance of financial assistance to 208 LaSalle Affordable, LLP, and 208 LaSalle Market Landlord, LLC, for the acquisition, construction, rehabilitation, and equipping of affordable and market-rate housing projects at 208 South LaSalle, in an amount not to exceed $25 million, excuse me, $26 million in TIF. We are joined by Dina Wayne, financial planning analyst at the Department of Housing, and Ryan Slattery from the Department of Housing as well. Dina? Thank you, Chair Dowell. So this project will have a lot of similarities to the one you just heard about at 111 South LaSalle. This is an Alderman Riley's ward, and it is also requesting financing through TIF and bonds. We're asking for authority to issue multifamily revenue bonds in an amount not to exceed $25 million, and the use of up to $26 million in TIF. The development team is made up for this project just of Prime, and the architect Lamar Johnson Collaborative, AOR Lucien Lagrange Studio, and design architect, and again, the attorney Applegate and Thorne Thompson. The general contractor in this deal is W.E. O'Neill, and again, they hope to fund this through a HUD 221-D4 loan through Merchants Capital. This is also a building where a portion of it is being rehabbed, in this case the ground floor, and a portion of floors 13 through 16. There will be 168 units, including studios, one and two bedrooms, of which 51 will be affordable, and 117 will have unrestricted rents. All of the units will be affordable between 40% and 80% AMI, and as with 111 Westman Row, the ARO laws will prevail, which ensures that a third of the units will be 50% AMI or below, and then of those, a sixth of them will be at 40% AMI or below, and there will be 80% affordable units as well. You can see that the unit sizes for the studios average 424 feet, the one-bedroom's 606 feet, and the two-bedroom's 1,027 feet. Here's a more precise breakdown of the unit mix, and you can see the studios range in size. So the average is 424. There is a small is 340 square feet up to 508 square feet. One-bedroom's 419 square feet to 705 square feet, and the two-bedroom's 894 square feet to 1,231 square feet. The 40% rents for the studios, $785, for the one-bedroom's 841, and for the two-bedroom's 1,009. That goes up to the market rate rents. You can see they vary a lot, too, with the highest rents being the two-bedroom market rate at $5,113. In terms of the sources and uses, they are getting the private loan, TIF, up to $26 million. They're getting historic tax credit equity because of the landmark nature of the building, low-income housing tax credits as well. The low-income housing tax credits will be generated by between $21 and $25 million, depending on what they need in the bonds. They're using the deferred developer fee as a source, $3.6 million. The total sources, the total project cost, $100 million, and a per-unit cost of $595,238. You can see the 208 South LaSalle Street building in green there, and then this map also shows the other projected LaSalle reimagined projects. A picture of the exterior, like 111. It's also a classically styled building, limestone cladding, and, again, hard to reuse. This is a building that shows the breakout of all of the uses in the building right now. Floors 1 through 12 are currently a Marriott Hotel, completed in 2010. That has 610 rooms. Upper floors, floors 18 to 21, completed in 2022, has 232 rooms. And then it's that middle section in blue, what they're going to call the LaSalle residences, that are the portion of floors 13 through 16, where this project will be located. In terms of the public rent benefits, including 168 new residential units, 51 of which will be affordable. I think maybe the most important thing, and we've heard so already today, reactivating LaSalle Street through the conversion of empty office space into residential units, simply bringing people downtown to live, bringing people onto the street. In terms of the environmental features, so like Cindy said in the earlier presentation, they're required to get their points. I don't know which – I know what the – the ways they're going to get those points. I don't know how many points per feature, but it's through their proximity to transit service. They get points for that, reducing indoor water use by 25%, providing bike parking and CTA digital displays. They get points for that as well. and diverting waste by 80%. So that's how they're going to get their environmental points for this project. They're going to create an estimated 10 full-time jobs. Obviously, housing is great when it creates jobs. That's not primarily what it's about, but there will be 10 full-time jobs, most likely building management, building engineering, and building operating-type jobs, and then 60 full-time temporary construction jobs. In terms of the timeline, obviously, we hope to get through Finance Committee today. It looks like we'll be approved by council, close the deal in July, construction starts in July, and then go through and complete the project within two years. And again, they ask a reminder that it's up to $25 million in bonds and $26 million in TIF. That concludes my presentation, and I'm happy to take any questions. Thank you. Any questions from members of the committee before I have Alderman Riley close, since this is in his ward? Alderman Lopez? Thank you, Chairman. I just want to reiterate all the same concerns I had with regards to neighborhood TIF, neighborhood after the other neighborhoods being afterthoughts. But I do have one other question. What happened? You used to be such a bubbly, happy... I'm worn down. I'm worn down. Still bubbly and happy. I was actually quite excited to see how you were going to present this today. So thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Alderman Lopez. It says, don't let Dina fool you, right? Alderman Irvin. Thank you, Madam Chair. I raised a similar question as it relates to this, and we want to see what the path looks like on participation as well. Thank you. Alderman Riley. Thank you, Chairman. Chairman, you know, I think everything that was talked about in the first project before the committee applies here as well, as we all know, this is part of a broader initiative to bring 1,000 new residential units, including over 300 affordable units for households with an average income of 60% AMI. And this project anticipates using about $26 million or so in TIF funds from the South Central TIF. You know, again, this is a little bit smaller price tag than the $40 million request in the last project, but this will deliver affordable housing units and repurpose a beautiful building and make it competitive moving forward. And so for that, I would appreciate my colleague's support for the project. Thank you, Chair. Thank you. Any other comments? Alderman Irvin? Was that an answer or was I just talking to myself? No, I heard you. Okay. You were asking for the same, the similar information that we are asking from the previous project. Okay. All right. Very well. I got that. This was clear. Alderman Lopez. Thank you, Chairman. I guess to Chairman Irvin's point, is there anyone that could answer that question so we don't have to have it on hold for Wednesday? This is the same developer, Mr. Reschke. The same issue applies as opposed to specifically identifying the subcontractors that will receive rewards. That won't be for probably at least 60, 75 days before we go to market and actually start awarding the work. So it's the same issue, though, and we know what the rules are. We know what the targets are. We expect to exceed those targets. And, of course, the funding of the TIF is contingent upon meeting those targets. So, of course, we're going to meet and exceed the targets. Thank you. Can I get a motion to approve item number three? So moved by Alderman Villegas, recommending do pass. All those in favor, signify by saying aye. Opposed? In the opinion, Alderman Lopez is reported as a no. In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. And the do pass a recommendation of the ordinance will be reported out on April 16th, again pending, receiving some information, which we will talk to the Department of Housing about after this meeting. There being no further business before the committee, can I get a motion to adjourn? So moved by Alderman Irvin to adjourn. All those in favor, signify by saying aye. In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. The committee on finance is hereby adjourned.