You know what? Yeah. Can you get them please? No, this person go right here, right. Okay, thank you. Good morning everyone. Uh, the committee on contracts oversight and Equity will now come to order. I want to wish each and every 1 of you a happy New Year. We're going to start off by um roll call. Uh, chairman mitz president. Vice chair of chairman Dow. German Mitchell. Is on his way. Jim Harris. Ramirez. Thank you. Coleman Automan present. Alderman. Bernette Admin Irving. On my telephone. I'm in Vegas. I have 7 members present. We have a quorum Peru. Um, pursuant to rule 59, we have members who would like to join remotely. Those members are ottoman. Dow Nugent. Gardener. Lasp. Harris and Taylor. Can I get a motion to recommend these other persons who have joined as part of the Corn? So moved. Armin Coleman all in favor. Signify by saying I Opposed. There's 9. Alderman Moore as a non-member would like to, uh, be recorded as present as well as part of uh the Roll Call to determine the quorum At this time, we are be yes. Or more know I was saying thank you. Oh, you're welcome. Thank you. At this time we began the public comment period. This period is limited 30 minutes out of respect for everyone's Time. Each speaker is limited 3 minutes. Uh, if you haven't signed up, there are pink sheets available in the back. Um, the male is going to start. the speaking public speaking role call, Good morning. Our first speaker will be Mr. Aaron novky. Hi. Good morning committee members. My name is Aaron novky. Good morning. Good morning. I'm a union organizer with Unite Here. Local 1 hotel, and restaurant and gaming. Uh, Union here in the city of Chicago. Here giving comment about the ballet's casino facility. Uh, so we represent over 12,000 members including about 130 workers at the BS temporary facility in downtown Chicago. this includes the cooks and the bartenders stewarding, the restaurant servers, the runners, the hosts, the cocktail servers, uh, overnight, heavy duty cleaners, the EVS cleaners, as well as the slot attendants. Majority of our members at BS, our African-American. And women of color. And through a collective bargaining agreement, that we've reached with BS our members right now, earn living wages with excellent employer paid Healthcare. Our members have pensions, which allows them to retire with dignity and they have other great benefits such as paid vacation and paid maternity leave. In short, our members at BS right now, earn a living wage that allows them to buy homes. Allows them to send their kids. To college, allows them to take care of their Elders, allows them to to live and prosper here in Chicago. And so I'm giving comment because we are excited to continue to work with BS as the permanent facility gets ready here in Chicago uh when it's all said and done. And the permanent facility opens in stores, we expect about a thousand of these good permanent jobs to be here in Chicago. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Our next speaker. Edith, Moore. Greetings, my beloved people. Um, this morning, I want you to listen because I'm coming from revelation. All week long, you know, it's been about housing, real estate zoning. And all this Contracting inequality is all about, you know, this money thing. Okay. But the city, this money thing. And these these houses developments, and whatever y'all trying to do here, you know, it's still not going to save Chicago. Chicago is already in a mess. Okay, Chicago is desolate. Chicago, is there this people of this city is destitute. The soul have left Chicago. That is the problem. You know, people don't smile, they don't laugh. This is ridiculous. But see what you got. Is a pimp for a mayor, he's a pimp Okay, he's a pimp slash. Uh, tree John, whatever you say. A lot of people think uh, pimp is on the corner, but you got a pimp right here that he's going to destroy the city and him. And his wife is going to be gone. This city will only be a shell. That's it. Because the only thing that's keeping this city moving is the cars on the street. That's it. You know and see I know everybody know that the real estate and Contracting. You know everybody pockets. Get lying you but who's getting the ball. Who's get the ball of it, huh? Who's getting the book of the money. Then next in line after hemp is his Yes Man the Yes Man. And then after him, you know, is the FIS the rusty, you are getting the crumbs. So he's playing y'all. You are the trick, y'all become the trick and see. And then he have y'all pulling your pants down, putting in your pants down, but he laying it on you and y'all think that feel good. But, hey, my time is up, but like I heard a 60 years ago, in AA, You know, 1 of the slogans is 1 day at a time. So you here for me the next Thank you, Mr. Moore Our next speaker is Jake Barrett. Good morning, chair. 1 mes All right, Vice chair and members of the committee. Thank you for the opportunity to speak. My name is Jake behrendt. I'm the director of communications at the Chicago Federation of Labor. The CFL represents 300 affiliate unions who in turn represent, half a million working people in Chicago and Cook County. I'm here to speak today on behalf of Labor, in support of the casino, in the thousands of good-paying union jobs, that it brings to the city. The B's Casino has made good on their commitment to provide good jobs in our communities and will be 1 of the largest Union employers In the City. By the time, the new site is fully operational. This means the attendant who Parks your car, the dealer at the poker table, the server, who brings your drink, the stage hand who sets up the show and the engineer who keeps the building running are all earning Fair wages and benefits to support their families. In addition to those permanent jobs, thousands more construction jobs will be created when bali's breaks ground on the new site by the Chicago River. For those who work on the years-long project to build the casino and the workers who staff it, that means the chance to earn family sustaining wages and benefits. The good union jobs, created will be fed by workers who come from all of Chicago's 77 neighborhoods. This casino brings a major economic impact for the entire city of Chicago. On behalf of Labor. I support the B's Casino developments and look forward to the new casinos opening. Thank you. Our next speaker will be Teresa. TJ Hughes Good morning, good morning, Madam chair. Good morning and Alderman. My name is Teresa. TJ Hughes I am here. Um, To support. The moving of The Valleys contracts out of housing. Into. um, Finance. And Procurement Services actually procurement services. Based on the fact that housing should be dealing with housing. They had enough issues out here. That people are not You know, being able to keep their homes and homelessness. So I don't understand why housing is involved in a revenue Generating. Contract. That is really. Out of their league. So I just want to come in here to voice my support for moving the contract to procurement Services because they are the arm for the city of Chicago. Everything has to come through them anyway, and, uh, it just makes more sense. So, That's basically what I wanted to just. Put my little 2 cents in this morning, Madam chairman. Thank you. Our next speaker will be Jessica Jackson, followed by Melissa Williams. Um, good morning, Alderman mids. Um, It's good to see you chair. A committee. Um, it's good to see that. I guess my issue is from being here for almost 2 years now. Um behind my issue about my property. you know, the fact that I'm watching how the black, all the alderman, Um and all the women are not in the Forefront of what's needed for our communities at all. You know, we're the the black aliment are not bringing to to the table, any ideas, any ordinance, any? Um, anything that's going to help our communities, but then I sit in here and I watch you all support, the contract plans and stuff of others. But you never seem to be able to come up with something for our communities, from you all. And that's very disappointing because it's 20 of you in here. And the black community has entrusted their economic development for their communities, where we pay our tax dollars to and the fact that we're not getting anything. The fact that no matter what issue we bring to the black Alderman, there's never a solution. It can never land in our favor. But we're sitting here watching you all move Heaven and Earth for illegals. All the way to the point where our country, our city is in debt like this. You all have done anything to stop. Brandon Johnson from destroying this city and he's destroying the city. This thing of not wanting to come against him because he's black while his Blackness is destroying black communities. It's absurd. You know, it's like and and to hear the ultimate, say over and over again is nothing they can do, he's the mayor, it's nothing we could do then, it simply means you all don't know the Constitution. Because if you did, you would know that he would not have absolute rule like this, you would know that he could not just put the city in financial world like this. He cannot just intentionally be negligent to the black community and get on TV and act like he's this Pro black person. Is so insulting and you all need to stop and it's costing you all your seats. Because he's not getting the in the in the mayor seats. Again, white people in the city is not going to allow it. If we want to be dumb enough to let it happen, they're going to stop it. And y'all going to lose your jobs. Miss Jackson. The next speaker, Melissa Williams. Good morning Alderman, good morning, Mitch and awe. My name is Melissa Williams, and I am the chief of operations for trino Inc. We are the Dei consultant to ballast. And in charge with the monitoring reporting on its MBE, wbe and Workforce hiring goals. And I just wanted to express that. It has been a Awesome opportunity to work on a project but we have also had many challenges with the reporting aspects, you know, reporting to various departments. And I just wanted to emphasize the importance of moving, the monitoring of the project to procurement, where we can work with, that department to, you know, develop programs that will make a even greater economic impact, you know, for the project that has already been done and thank you. Okay, thank you. Our next speaker is. Zou late Lee. Followed by Mr. George Blackburn. Happy New Year. Um, Basically women's Jessica said is straight on and as y'all know that I've also been coming down uh going on. uh 2 years and make 2 years in June, uh and uh, Honestly. It's sad, you know, it's sad to see that. We have no strong leadership you know, like I said on Tuesday, if I was to run for office and or I was in 1 of y'all positions and someone did come to me, 1 of my constituents and said that my building or something is wrong with my building or my house mind you. This is, this is your where you live, you know? This is what this is, especially someone right now, with all the property taxes, with, with all the rent, all of this, this person just knocked the building, the city, just knocked the building down. You have all the evidence to show, you know, my mother came nicely and all of that and then no 1 could do anything. Not 1 person, could do anything. Like I said I would have 2 to DC and I would have talked to whoever I could talk to in a Department of Justice, I would have talked to whoever and HUD or whoever makes these decisions. Like I would have have, just not just say, well, I mean, there's nothing we could do. And then, while you guys go into your communities and hand out backpacks in turkeys and make it like, you guys are really for the community, when a person really has a real issue like Illegal, eminent domain that's been going on for a long time but y'all don't want to go against someone like Marlene Hopkins because that's when your homie and y'all buddy. Well hey your homie and your buddy is is is is is is is is is is running an illegal eminent domain scheme, through the department of buildings and and lying and saying that y'all can knock down buildings through um police powers and build in violations without going to the building's Court. You got you, you can't do that. You're no, no policies. Do not override the federal laws. No policies override the US Constitution, that's the supreme law of land. I don't understand how you guys can take Oaths or and and say you're going to uphold the Constitution and then it's like y'all don't uphold it. You know, and we are we, we, we pay your taxes. We pay we we we I mean, we pay y'all, y'all. Y'all, uh, you know, salaries, we pay our salaries. So I'm just not understanding how we can't get any help and we can't get help. We have no leadership. It's embarrassing. It's sad to see that. We have no leadership that the fact that I got to keep coming down here, I'm organizing to figure out who can run against every 1 of y'all because it does not make any sense, how I can't get no help. Or Miss Jessica or anyone else that comes down here. I have emails, full of PE. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Mr. George Blake Moore, followed by Alicia Garcia Abner. A culture of corruption. Black Faces in high places, deliver nothing. I I was listening at these 2 white gentlemen, talking about the union and talk about black and color. I have no interest in color. I'm black. And to know that we only get 2% of the contracts. This has been going on in the black community long before Brandon Johnson. if a culture of corruption here, House in. Samos Angel, mamas, call out. This is A f p down here. And all of them are Democrats. Note democracy? No third party. No uh uh different party. It's sickening. It's it's, it's funky. It's, it's terrible. the negative effect that it has on the black community and who I hold responsible for this are the black people they've been beat down. Stalked on. Peed on. In what a slave mentality. You have to teach these people how to treat you, if they don't know how you have, no black leadership. Baba. Nothing. But you have black faces and it just didn't happen with Brandon Johnson. It's been here. It's a culture here. And I have always advocated when I heard that Trump was running, I wanted him to come and clean up the sex poop. But no good white 1. No no. Good black 1 but no good. Hispanic and Asian 1 or 1 party shifter. It's just like in in a home. And you have only mamas. And no Daddy. It has been proven that a 2 party. A 2 family. They can succeed. Well, somebody say, well, you can have a strong a family with, with a strong black woman. Here is a successful. What I'm trying to do is connect the dots we need. Do the Tango 2 or 3 parties. So all of you are responsible for forth because you have a slave mentality on the plantation. The white man made her in and that's what you act like these Showers of blessing. My you very much, um, Let me, let me recognize. Uh um, ottoman Moore. Um have joined us which for the German. Ottoman Mitchell. It's Alicia Garcia Abner. Good morning and happy New Year and we want to start 2025. On a bright. A Brighter Day. We're here today, we have representatives from valleys. That will be reporting on what they have achieved so far. My name again, is Alicia Garcia Abner. I am the President of trino Inc. You've heard from my colleague a little earlier. We are a local MW dbe company that is certified with the city of Chicago. And we provide reporting program management relative to projects and contracts. Assistance with our clients and we are proud to be on the ballet's project. You never get in a lifetime, a project like with ballet is Yes, we may have goals on a project generally, but when the project is over with, it's over here, ballet is here to stay. The goals, will also be on the component under operations. And bellies is going to be here when the rest of us are gone. So can you imagine that the city's never had a project like this and its Revenue generating? yes, we've had some challenges relative to, you know, the interactions with the different user departments because when you have a developer that's willing to commit to a number of initiatives, it is a lot less challenging if we're dealing with 1 particular department and that in my opinion, having been the director of certification for the city of Chicago. Having been the director of contracts management for CPS. Having been in business for almost 28 years that this oversight should be what the procurement Department because then we can go beyond just looking at numbers, which the goals are, just the floor, not the ceiling. We want to focus on capacity, building with companies and a project. Like this will allow us to have that type of capacity building and that when they're done with the permanent project, we can move them on to operate. And opportunities and operations Department. Again, we want to maximize our opportunities. We want to centralize that that monitoring of M and wbe with procurement who we have, sat down with Miss rock, with Miss Roberts. Who is the chief of Opera? I said, the chief procurement officer as you know. And she's open to this. She's open to us working and leveraging, our Resources with Outreach. She's open to um, assisting us and looking at different initiatives that can impact our small businesses. Our small businesses is the key to the success of this city. We just ask for that consideration. We're proud to present today and show you what our achievements are. Thank you. Thank you so much. This concludes all our speakers. Thank you very much. all right, I will, if there's no more speakers at this time, this will conclude the public comments um, first item on to the agenda for today is the approval of the money rule 45 report from August. 2024 September 2024 October 2024, November and December the committee on contracts, oversight and Equity. Can I get a motion to approve? don't move by German Urban all in favor signify by saying I And P. The chairs, the eyes have it. uh, we'll move to the third item on the agenda. Uh, which is item number before I go to the item. I would like to, uh, request for approval for ottoman listado vice, vice chair to attend, um, remotely by Route, according to rule, 59, and get a motion. So, some move by ottoman. Rodriguez, all in favor. Signify by saying, I and opinion chest eyes have its so Vice chairless body, you may be able to attend uh, The Substitute ordinance for today. Uh, item number at 020024 D. 000001 3659, is a substitute ordinance for management. Service program responsibilities executed with local initiatives support cooperation creation of quarter maps, and Lead management responsibilities over a quarter of manager. Can I get a motion to accept a substitute? Uh, so moved by. Vice mayor Bernett. All in favor. Signify by saying, I Pin your chest eyes have it. Uh we have a letter that's been sent we received from uh John Paul Jones, president of the SEI sustainable Englewood initiative regarding um 02024 D 00013, 659. Which, uh, has been sent to the committee. And will be placed in the file. Um, we have with us, Deputy Commissioner of Department of dpd. Jim Harbour who's here to give us um, a overview of the substitute ordinance and what we're doing today. Thank you. Thank you, madam chairwoman And members of the committee, uh, for the record. My name is Jim Harbin. My Deputy Commissioner with the Department of planning and development. The Substitute ordinance before you today. Seeks to authorize the department of Planning and Development to fund a 1 year marketing program agreement between the local initiative, support Corporation known locally as Lisa Chicago serving as the project manager and the City of Chicago for the corridor manager program. The requested 1.4 million of funding for the program. Include 2 additional commercial corridors. Both of which will be added to the existing 12 priority corridors identified in the original ordinance. The current marketing program agreement with Lisa Chicago expired, at the end of 2024 and the city. Now, plans to enter into a new 1 year contract in 2025, with modify strategic elements of the original scope of services. To provide some background in 2020. Lisa, Chicago entered into a 5-year marketing program agreement with the city to manage selected Community Based organizations, working on priority, corridors selected by the department. The agreement focused on goal setting tracking progress on Corridor specific projects and issuing regular reports on the economic development, work being conducted along their respective corridors. The quarter managers were chosen through a request for application. Process was sought to Lo with sought out local leadership support for coordinating ongoing public and private Investments within their service areas selected. Organizations were eligible for up to $80,000 a year to ensure a full-time equivalent capacity to support the work being done, on each of the corridors, The administrative cost coverage list, Chicago staff support with assisting, the quarter managers with executing marketing activities and related work on active, Redevelopment plans, taking place on the corridors. Board of managers were selected in part for their leadership skills which include which included their experience with managing Local Economic Development, activities. Strong relationships with local businesses and property, owners and good working relationships with Community stakeholders. This year's marketing agreement will have a modified scope of work for 2025. The project manager will complete a series of organizational assessments initiated in 2024 that evaluates each organization's capacity to fulfill their respective missions. The assessments will continue to survey each agency's board member expertise and review their organizational bandwidth to execute strategic Visions for their specific corridors list Chicago and his Consultants will also facilitate a series of customized trainings that will lay the groundwork for quarter managers to lead and support physical development and infrastructure projects along their respective. Corridors training will include adapting strategic elements from the program. Managers emerging development, developer curriculum, designed to suit the corridor manager, audience, and plot the delivery of several training modules, at the end of this year, the project manager will Leverage The findings from those from their assessments summarize collected every data and demographic data and build upon the customized trainings to establish a more refined infrastructure for the program Beyond 2025. The city would like to continue to leverage. The Chicago's capacity to manage this type of work. This has helped to attract over 7 million dollars in additional Financial financial support for the program. Over the past 4 and a half years. Support included attracting additional, city state and private grants to the program as well as advocating for other commercial financing Partners to engage with local developers needing special assistance with their projects. The city also leverages list experience and developing customized work plans, tracking data and communicating the impact of each organization's activity. And vision, there also exists a Project's manager's ability to recruit and attract seasoned construction and marketing professionals to the program. To train the quarter managers on how to better manage and support Capital Improvement projects taking place on their corridors. The older persons in both the 20, the 20th and 21st Warsaw. Have requested this type of support for local organizations conducting Corridor marketing work in their communities as a result, 2 new corridors are being recommended to the program. The West Pullman community in the 21st. Ward hosted, from 95th Street to 116th Street, and the Woodline community in the 20th. Ward 63rd Street, from King to Dorchester and Cottage Grove from Keen to 67 Street. All of the impacted Tif districts have been confirmed within the department and the impacted, all the persons on the program. Have been notified. The quarter manager was designed to support the reactivation of neighborhood. Cores that have historically, served as focal points for pedestrian. Activity shopping hubs, local service. Localized Services, Transportation Centers, Public spaces and quality of life amenities for local residents, the quarter managers act as a catalyst to maximize public investment by helping to attract additional private Capital to their neighborhoods responding to commercial Trends and enriching each neighborhood's, local culture. The department of Planning and Development seeks to authorization of the funnel 1 year, marketing program agreement between Lisa, Chicago and the city for the quarter and manager program. I want to thank you again, Madam, chairman and members of the committee that ends my presentation today and I'm happy to take any of your questions. Thank you. Um, for the record I would like to acknowledge we have uh from this uh the executive director Megan hearty and program officer uh Caroline and um thank you all for being here. Um, at this time, we have questions by committee members. Are they any questions? Ottoman Coleman. Jim is so good to see you and the rest of the team and Meghan, I did not recognize you and those cool specs. Yeah, I did have a question about uh or just confirmation that the dollars that were allocated for the original 5 years ago um invest Southwest Corridor, when it was that for the manager that those that 20% of those dollars was put back where Yeah, when if we don't spend those dollars, all of them, they just stay within the Tif. Okay, I think that answers your answers, your question. Yes, this is. My question is exactly. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Um, I'm in Vegas. Thank you. Uh, thank you chairwoman. Um, so this contract's been in existence for 5 years. The existing the contract at the beginning of the program expired, at the end of 2024, this will be a brand new contract and you speaking to the mic, but there's already been they were under list was already under contract already, right? So it can list talk to some of the deliverables that were completed under this time. Um Absolutely. Um what someone from this state, your name for the record and uh ottoman viegas is asking if you can talk about um some of the roles that you play Within the program. Thank you that you may have or success stories. Thank you, madam chair and I'll do Vegas for the question. I'm going to hand it over to Caroline Randon who's our senior program officer who has been overseeing this for the last 5 years. And you need to speak up so we can hear. Something wrong with the mic. Hold up. Just so we can get it. Okay, how about now? Yes, here we go. Uh, thank you again for the question. So, the over the Last 5 Years, um, we've seen uh, the corridor managers as uh as organizations that are Community Based really build their own capacity to engage with the communities around them, the business and Property Owners on the on the court on those commercial corridors and we've seen increased investment Jim spoke to You an additional 7 million in a on top of what the city committed in Tif funds 5 years ago, that was invested. And that was, uh, that's a direct result of the work that the quarter managers did to bring in, um, private investment. Uh, lending capital from, uh, for folks who are improving their small businesses or their properties, um, in sort of material ways and, uh, their um, other just grants and capacity, building opportunities for those quarter managers to strengthen their own organizational operations, and continue to advocate for Equitable Economic Development and their in their corridors. So the 7 million dollars is 1 of our big, big outcomes, but I think we've also really built a strong Foundation, uh, for those organizations to be peers and to network with 1, another really strengthening, and, and economic development, ecosystem, throughout the the city of Chicago and on the South and West sides in particular. Can, um, Madam chair through the, through the chair is it possible to get a list of these, um, organizations that are being contracted. So, Lisk is the Fiscal Agent. I take it, and then you've selected other not for profits, that deal with not with the economic development. Is that accurate? Yes, we did the program design, um, and technical assistance in addition to, uh, sort of the financial Administration and then through an RFP process Corridor managers on the ground business development organizations on each of these corridors. Where I Identified to carry out the work and and with list support so. So they're collaborating with the SSA, I take it as well. Yes, some rssa, some are chambers, some are other uh, business development organizations. So so then you just said some are SSA so SSA is already fund. Some of these Chambers of Commerce that work there. So, now are they getting additional funding? Um, from these through this corridors that they represent. Is that what I'm hearing? Yes, it's focused on Tiff related activities. Um, that are separate from SSA activities. So this is about real estate development, and other supports for small businesses, in accessing resources or delivering other other uh opportunities for small businesses. Okay. And then from with the leverage of 7 million, could you talk about that a little bit more like what able to leverage over 7 million of additional financing? What does that mean? So through the connection with lisc and some of our and in the work that the organizations have done, they've been able to get a variety of things so we can we can share um with the chair, some of those direct ones. But some of some of those are grants that Lisk has secured through corporate, uh, entities and Caroline can talk a couple about a couple of those. Some are dceo grants through the rebuild distress communities, that list administers for dceo. Um, some of those have been accessed on these corridors and then others is support through neighborhood opportunity. Fund or other local resources that that through technical assistance in the support of the bdo's, small businesses were able to access. So is it fair to say that in some instances ssas? That, that collect tax revenue. And then also our receiving funds from this program also receiving funds from dco dcoe. Also receiving funds from neighborhood opportunity fund is that an accurate statement that in some cases ssas will receive multiple sources of revenue. The Entity that runs the SSA could for a variety of activities that they need to do in addition to SSA activities. Yes. Okay. If you could provide a list of those organizations. Appreciate, thank you. Yes. Thank you, um, on NBA this, um, for the Austin Community. Um, we have a s, um, quarter of manager Malcolm Crawford, who's been working, uh, from the beginning and, uh, this program and, um, He's done a lot of great work and trying to help to improve uh Chicago Avenue for 1 of 1 good reason. Is there a criteria? I would ask. When it come to other parts of money. And especially from list. I do. You share that information with the local Ottomans. So we'll know. Um, Some of the duties I think they're. A little lack of. Knowing. I I know the work that they're doing but are there other funding sources? That are being given and what are their duties, um, for the community, some may not necessarily know his role and I haven't seen uh this description of what that job description is. So just so that I could be clear and sharing with them and we don't get off track with, who's whose job because it can become a little confusing with the chambers and other business. And I know, you know this, but I'm sure that it can all work out when we get the right information this year. Are there any other questions? If there's another questions, can I get a motion to approve? Don't move by vice mayor Barnett. All in favor signify by saying I And the opinion of the chair is the eyes, have it. This matters passed then will be reported out at the city council meeting. Thank you, thank you. All right. Um, the second item on the agenda is Anna hearing on the Chicago Casino compliance report. and uh, to today's meeting Of this of this committee on contracts oversight and equities being conducted for suing to the ordinance that established the city. Chicago s Casino it calls for the chief procurement officer. The commissioner of Department of planning and development. Transportation housing and the chief procurement officer to appear annually. At a public hearing during the casinos Construction. Today's hearing fulfilled, the annual requirement for 2024. now, we had to reschedule this hearing, Uh to today because of budget timing and challenges with uh achieving a quum around the holidays. So during this year and there will be opportunity to address the resolution by ottoman Hopkins that requested information on the financial viabilities of balance Casino. so now I'm going to turn um, immediate over to our Witnesses. With the first being our Chief Financial Officer. Followed by a representative from the Department of planning and development. Department of Transportation. Then the commissioner on housing and chief procurement office. Together with their appropriate staff. The CPO there. Yeah, yeah, yeah. First speaker. First Speaker would be uh, Chief, uh, Financial Officer. If we can get him, confront Okay. So we have Gio yes, good morning Gorski. And your team with you Jill? Sure, good morning. This is Jill Jaworski. I'm the CFO for the city of Chicago. Um, we have, uh, the uh, uh, commissioner for the Department of Housing. Um, we have representatives from BS. We have, um, our uh, legal Representatives here, our outside counsel who work with us on the casino project uh Ethan Gilman, who is um the project coordinator and day-to-day all things Casino for the city. Um, are all here as well as I believe the commissioner from dpd. Has rep has a representative here today. Um, we have a presentation for you here as part of our report um that we would like to walk through with everyone who's here today. Um, thank you. Um, and welcome Alderman, and alderwoman to the annual hearing on the Chicago, Casino compliance reporting before the city council committee on Contracting, oversight and equity. This annual hearing is required per the ordinance, that establishes, the Chicago Casino due to the budget timeline and other end of year scheduling difficulties, the city and consultation with the chair decided to move. The 2024 annual hearing previously scheduled for December 12th 2024 to today. Uh, we are also here to respond to Alderman. Hopkins request for a subject matter hearing regarding the Chicago, Casino financing and have representatives from ballet, um, who are here in the Box in attendance to answer questions. The relevant requirements and goals. For this report are outlined in the host Community agreement, which you'll often hear referred to as the HCA between valleys and the city of Chicago. Valleys is required to report, quarterly to the city regarding commitments outlined in the HCA. The city is then required per the ordinance to provide quarterly reports to the city council committee on Contracting oversight and equity and attend an annual Hearing in front of that same committee, which we are doing here today during construction of a casino in the city of Chicago. Uh, therefore myself, uh, leadership from dpd Transportation Transportation housing and the chief procurement officer along with relevant, staff are here today to provide that annual report in front of the committee. We also recently submitted the quarter 3 2024 compliance report to this committee on November 15th which will be the basis for uh, many of the numbers provided in this presentation. Uh, the final report for, uh, 20204 will be received, uh, in the first quarter of 2025. Uh, so if we flip to the, um, agenda Um for this report, um we will first provide a high level update on the temporary, Casino performance, and the permanent Casino, uh, Demolition and construction progress. Uh, we will then get into the primary, uh, compliance reporting reporting, components for the temporary Casino project, um, which include the design and construction, spend the construction jobs, operation, jobs and operations spent For the compliance reporting sections. We will provide a quick overview of Valley's Outreach and uh, walk through the reporting numbers that are provided. Uh, we will also like to outline what the future holds and solicit. Any relevant feedback from this body. If we move to the first slide, uh we've got some highlights here of the casino. Uh the temporary Casino has over 1.7 million visitors uh, served to date. This is the second highest, uh, Casino admissions in the state in, uh, 20124. And uh, we think it was a critical driver of foot traffic post pandemic um in the uh near North downtown area. Uh the the city has received over 67 million dollars in new revenues um from the uh Casino. These are both from the gaming tax revenues, which are dive from the operations of the casino. Um, and from the uh gaming receipts that Valley's receives and include, also the Forty million dollar initial payment made by valleys in the 8 million dollars in 2 years of annual payments uh to the city. In addition uh over 600 new permanent jobs have been created. Uh, 71% of those jobs are Chicago residents 82% are minority 47%. Women and 23% are from socially and economically disadvantaged areas in the city. Uh, the project also generated over 500 construction jobs, uh, during the uh, construction of the temporary Casino. If we flip to the next side we'll touch on this uh briefly. briefly. Um, this is a summary. I know probably hard to read up on the screen of the, uh, this is a summary of the, uh, reporting requirements and goals for BS. Um, we'll get all through many of these, um, in this report, but I think the big picture you can see from this is that, uh, many of the goals that were set have been met for this casino uh, have been met by BS, uh, but there's a few that have not been met and we are in continuous conversation with BS, working with them uh to make adjustments, going forward um to continue to make progress um towards Meeting those goals. If we slip to the next, we're already there. Um, this is a summary of the casino, revenues and projections. Um so the temporary Casino, you know, as mentioned has been, I think very beneficial for the city with a total of 67 million dollars received. But 1 of the things that we can see from the table on the left is that despite the, the revenues we did not meet the original projections, um, that we had. Um, this there's a couple items, uh, here on this. Um, on this, uh, on this page on the right is the What's called the casino privilege tax structure. And what that shows is that as there are more gaming revenues, the tax rate that the city receives goes up. So as we see more gaming revenues, um, which will be particularly a focus. When the permit casino is developed, not only will be receiving more taxes generated to just a larger volume of Gaming revenue, but we will also be getting taxes at a higher rate which will increase the revenues um, even further. This year, we had about 16 million in gaming tax, uh, revenues in addition to the $4 million payment. Um, this was below the 34 million dollars in projections, um, which were, uh, derived from, uh, a consultant that, um, set that analyze our original projections prior to the temporary Casino opening. Uh, if we move to the next slide, I think to sort of walk through the performance. Um there's there's 3, main categories actually 4 main categories that we want to focus on here. Um, we really focused on the and the um, gaming revenues per admission at the temporary temporary casinos. So if we look on the left, uh, as you see the gray and the sort of maroon chart there, that's the admissions and the admissions are at about 80% of what? Was originally anticipated. So those are very close to the um, projections. And what we see is that it has really succeeded in driving people to the urban core of the city, um, postco uh in that regards um the amount of gaming revenues though, uh, per admission is lower than the original projections that's about 65% of what was originally projected. Um, we feel this is due to a larger than expected impact from a lack of amenities and on-site parking compared to the permanent Casino. Um, we did review some of these numbers with the Illinois gaming board and I believe 1 of the things, the, uh, 1 of the pieces of information that they had showed us. That's not on this slide is that the time that is spent in the casino, um, is about half of the time that's spent in, uh, some of the other casinos in the state that are full casinos. And again, that goes to the point that I said earlier about the lack of amenities, um, you know, as 1 of the things to remember, is that This is just a temporary Casino. It's a short-term project and it was a buildout of a building that was not originally built for the purpose of a casino. So it doesn't have the design and functionality to have all of the restaurants and entertainment and things you would expect to have that key people in the casino for longer. So if you combine that admission at 80% and the gross revenue per admission, you get to around 52% of Casino revenues compared to the projection. And then when we dial down further into the city revenues, we're about 47% of the projections. And that's because if you remember it on the prior page, there was the uh, privilege tax escalator that graduated tax. So since we have lower revenues we're also in a lower tax category and so we're not getting quite as high percentage and and that's the way that we've that The numbers have uh, sort of worked out where we've gone to sort of that 80% of foot traffic. That was projected down to 47% of our projected, um, revenues I mean, 1 of the key takeaways um that we really have from the performance of the temporary casino, is that for a casino to really Thrive, you need all of the other amenities that people accept expect from these types of, uh of of a places. And so we are very excited continue to be very excited about the permanent Casino which is going to offer all the amenities and entertainment that you would expect when you go to a full-blown Casino. Um, we can move to the next slide. Um, so when we think about the future Casino um in Chicago quick summary, uh this is a 1.7 billion dollar investment in the city of Chicago. Um, comparing that to the Forty million dollar buildout of the Mina temple temple. So this is a much larger permanent project. There's going to be 4,000 gaming positions, a 500 room Hotel over 3,000 parking spaces on site um as well as an entertainment center, um, and a single floor, Casino design with many about their amenities. So we're expecting the permanent Casino uh, to generate hundreds of millions of dollars to support our police and fire pensions to, which our our, our Casino revenues are dedicated, as well as thousands of construction and operation jobs for Chicagoans. Um, this these numbers do not include the additional indirect, uh, benefits of major investment of this kind can have um, 1 of the things that we continues to give us confidence is we can come point to um other jurisdictions like Rockford that had a temporary casino and then opened a permanent Casino. Um, the permanent Casino which recently opened has substantially outperformed, its temporary Casino. Um, we also, um, can point to analysts from the Illinois Commission on government forecasting and accountability. Um, who recently wrote that some believe that a Chicago casino with a permanent facility, Will eventually be the top Revenue producing Casino in the region. Um, and we can rep point to B's recent financing announcement, which shows confidence in the prospects of the permanent Casino. Um, and uh, if you have filed as closely, um, you would remember that the uh amount of the financing that Bali announced was larger than what they had originally expected. Allowing them to build out the full hotel instead of the portion of the hotel that they were required to build under the HCA. We can move to the next slide. Um so um regarding the financing and design of the permanent Casino Valley's announced in 2024 that it entered into a financing transaction with gaming. And Leisure properties also known as glpi for construction financing of the Chicago casinos. as part of this announcement, valleys is now requesting approval to build the entire 500 room hotel, in a single phase on the south end of the casino site as part of the broader Casino project, the city recently engaged, the Chicago Casino Community advisory Council which is made up of local community representatives and aldermanic offices to discuss these updates to the site plan and will be issuing a site plan approval for the changes. Um, it's important to note that BS continues to adhere to their require their requirements in the HCA and prior commitments. And the new design changes are primarily to the hotel location in casino building. While most of the broader site components remain the same. The city will continue to post relevant information to the Chicago Casino website uh regarding the project as it is available. Um, flipping to the next slide. Um, as far as progress on this permanent Casino, the demolition of the uh the the Tribune site began in September of 2024. Um it's expected to finish demolition by February of this year. Um, and in fact, our understanding is, it might be, uh, even done this month. Um, this slide shows the most recent update that was provided on December 8th. Um, for the demolition progress following the completion of demolition construction will commence for the expected Casino, which is a projected to open in the third quarter of 2026. Um, now we will, uh, switch over to, um, the Department of Housing, to walk through, the compliance report reporting, components of this report. Thank you. Oh, I'm sorry. I've skipped 1 page. The uh, brief overview of the compliance reporting. Um, as I mentioned earlier, this is a this report um is required and this hearing is required by ordinance, um, and it was established as part of the compliance goals in the HCA, Um and the city's major goals. Um in regards to this project are to ensure that BS Works to increase opportunities and build capacity for diverse individuals and businesses in Chicago. We want the Chicago casino to be built by Chicagoans and we wanted to be operated by Chicagoans. We worked closely with ballet to ensure they're making good face efforts to meet these goals and we will continue to actively Monitor and hold valleys accountable through the Chicago Casino project. Again we are still in the early stages of this project, while it may feel that we are a long way along given that the temporary Casino has been open for over a year. Now that was just the very early stage of the project. The permanent casino is uh, is the project that we have been focused on and valleys has been focused on from day 1 and this 1.7 billion. Dollar investment will provide many more opportunities for Chicago and, and Chicago businesses. So this is a long-term partnership uh, between valleys and the City of Chicago. And now for real, I will pass it on to To commissioner, let Castaneda of the Department of Housing. Good morning all. Good morning. Um, as has been stated, I am commissioner Lisa Garcia for the Department of Housing. Since the beginning of this project, the Department of Housing has been monitoring design, and construction, spend construction jobs, and operation. Spent for the casino project. This is due to our contract Management Authority, do monitors construction and compliance for many dooh dpd projects. Since the casino is a revenue generating project that does not include any City funds. And therefore was not procured through the department of procurement Services. It has been treated similarly to other department of Planning and Development projects, due to this dough has engaged in monitoring and related compliance goals in coordination with DPS, the office of the CFO dpd and other relevant departments. Therefore our construction compliance Team Works closely with BS regarding reporting requirements and Outreach opportunities next slide. Bally's construction management team is the Chicago Community. Builders Collective a Consortium of minority owned firms. As shown on this slide leading the construction of the Chicago Casino. Valleys and the CCBC work with local, Chicago groups and organizations to help with Outreach and meeting project goals. The CCBC has participated in many engagements and sponsorships and not reach events for both. The temporary and permanent Casino construction. CCBC is Outreach overview. Prior to the temporary Casino. Construction can be found on the slide. Next slide, please. Valleys and the CCBC Outreach efforts for the construction of the temporary Casino have yielded. These results as shown on the slide and provided in the Q3 report. The data represents the numbers for the temporary Casino, build out at 100% of reporting. For the temporary, Casino design, and construction ballet has met their MBE goals and is within half a percent of the wbe goal. You can also find the ethnicity breakdown attached on this slide. As you can see, ballet has utilized a diverse team for the buildout of the temporary Casino. Next slide, please. Additionally, the interior buildout of the Madina Temple consisted of 536, jobs the construction jobs commitment is broken down by labor hours. As you can see B's met the city of Chicago residency, labor requirement. And was about half a percentage Point within the sieda, socially and economically. Disadvantaged areas. Residency labor hour, requirement We have provided an overview of the trade classification to give an understanding of the type of work that was done. The data shows that BS made an effort to hire Chicago and and residents of Ceda areas for the construction of the temporary Casino. Next slide. To give you a better understanding of what the sieda goal is. We have provided a map utilized by bali's for their Ceda Outreach. This map represents areas of Chicago based on census tracks that are the most socioeconomically disadvantaged with regard to household income, poverty rate, and unemployment rate for the temporary Casino. The city utilized, the 2023, Sada map. The map was recently updated for 2024, and the 2024 map will be utilized for the permanent Casino goals and temporary Casino operations reporting. We expect valleys to continue to reach out to see the communities for the permanent Casino construction, and to provide opportunities within the cities areas, with the most economic need next slide, As discussed prior, the permanent casino is currently under Demolition and is expected to begin construction next year, the CCBC has participated in many engagements and sponsorships and Outreach sessions for opportunities for the permanent Casino. The city makes sure to send these Outreach sessions and other available engagements to our networks. Including all of the Alder people to ensure residents are aware of opportunities at the casino next slide. At this time, we do not have a formal permanent Casino reporting information in the system. However, we expect to begin, providing reporting information to the committee. In our Q4, 2024 report to be delivered in the coming weeks. We would like to note some high-level information regarding the work that is ongoing and has been completed so far for the permanent Casino. Valley's demolition, contractor is brandenberg International Inc. Brandenberg has engaged with 7 divers for Demolition and 8, diverse firms. For excavation the demolition work has consisted of 57 employees and the excavation work is ramping up. And currently includes 4 employees as of mid December 2024. The city will continue to coordinate with ballet's regarding their construction of the permanent casino and will continue to make information available to our networks as we receive it next slide. As mentioned, the permanent Casino construction reporting will use the 2024 Ceda map, which has been updated for the recent census data. The 2024 Ceda map is based on the lowest ranking of 25% of households in the area shown on the slide. I will now pass it over to the Department of Planning and Development to talk about operations jobs at the temporary Casino. Thank you. Mark state, your name for the record. My name is Mark Sean and I will be reporting on behalf of commissioner Boatright. The dpd compliance team has been working with BS and monitoring their operations since the Inception of the project. These jobs at the temporary Casino are well-paying, long-term jobs for Chicago residents. Next slide. Prior to opening the temporary Casino bellies engaged in extensive Outreach to the community for job opportunities. This included hosting 2, large job fairs at. UIC and McCormack Place working with city, colleges to develop the B's, Chicago dealer school, and reaching out to many organizations for Workforce Outreach. The dealer schools specifically is an opportunity for Chicagoans to receive free of charge table games, dealer school, training for purposes of obtaining, a highly respected job title in the casino industry. Bali's hosted, many dealer school information sessions around the city, prior to opening of the temporary Casino. since opening the casino ballet's continues to engage in these efforts, including job fairs or organizational, Outreach targeted Recruitment and dealer School classes. We expect balsz to continue these great Outreach efforts during the time of the temporary Casino operations, and eventual hiring for the permanent Casino. This Outreach has delivered for Chicago, shown on this slide is a map of bali's Chicago employees by ZIP code. As you can see, B's employees represent almost every Community throughout the city, the operations Workforce consists of almost 650 jobs. 91% of which are full-time of these workers 71% are Chicagoans and 23% come from our social and economically disadvantaged areas. The diversity breakdown of the workforce is shown on this slide. BS also supports Workforce Development initiatives for their employees, including internship, programs tuition, reimbursement, and a management development program. These are long-term operations at BS that should carry over to the permanent Casino. Additionally. The management at the temporary casino is also representative of our city. 68 percentage positions at the temporary Casino, our minority, while 43% are female This is an encouraging story for Chicago and demonstrates bal's dedication to develop a diverse local Workforce for the Chicago Casino. And I will pass it back to commissioner. Keneda to discuss the operations spend. Thank you. Again, for the record, I am Alisa Casta. The commissioner for the Department of Housing, the compliance team at the oh, also monitors, the operations spend goals for the temporary, Casino operations, spend consists of the sourcing of goods and services during operations including things, like Professional Services, purchasing of materials, food and beverage office supplies, repair and maintenance and more. Operations, spend does not include the provision of gaming equipment or related services or spend related to the adjacent garage operations. Ballet has engaged in extensive Outreach efforts as shown on the slide for the sourcing of goods and services opportunities. At the temporary casino. This includes targeted Outreach to certified. Firms attending sourcing Fairs around the city and hosting a yearly diverse supplier. Vendor fair, which occurred on June 11th 2024, However, both the city and valleys recognize that there is room for growth for operation, spend at the temporary Casino as it relates to the goals in the HCA next slide. This slide breaks down by spend category for the year to date as well as the information provided in the Q3 report. Valley has sourced 16.9 of their operations, spend in 2024 to certify, diverse firms, including 15.5 to mbes and 1.4 to wbes Valleys does engage with some firms that are certified with other reporting agencies, outside the city and Cook County. This spend has not been reflected in the numbers above Ballet has not engaged yet with any bve or bees in their reporting so far. However, they continue to engage in Outreach to certified firms and have indicated. They were onboarding, both a vbe and a BPD in Q4 of 2024. B's also recently met with the city's director of Veteran Affairs to discuss ways in, which they can improve Outreach to the veteran Community regarding opportunities at the casino. we recognize that there are barriers to meeting the operations spend goals and the city is continuing to work with BS to improve their Outreach and operational spend and ensure that they are making good. Faith efforts to utilize diverse suppliers at the temporary Casino. The city will also continue to encourage firms to get certified to expand their opportunities and build their capacity next slide. Specifically due to B's operations spend numbers. They have provided some information regarding their strategy for utilizing diverse firms in 2025. This includes continuing to engage with the city's database of certified firms for opportunities. Requesting, that firms, achieve certification and working to replace expired contracts with diverse firms. The city looks forward to continuing to work with BS in these efforts and I will now pass it over to DPS. Thank you so much, commissioner. Um, I'm Sharla Roberts, Chief procurement officer for the city of Chicago. Um, hello. Hello everyone. As we think about the future, we want to emphasize the opportunities that it's in front of us today. Next slide. Not only is b b's currently operating a temporary Casino. but they, Are building a billion dollar. Permanent casino. That will provide many opportunities for Chicagoans. once this permanent casino is built, there will be even more operational sourcing opportunities for Chicago businesses to take advantage of We will continue to do our work to address industry and certification barriers, for our businesses, including continuing to learn from the temporary Casino operations, and the permanent consent, permanent Casino construction to maximize this opportunity for Chicagoans. And we will continue to encourage our diverse firms to get certifi certified so that they can take advantage of these opportunities next slide. However, we also need your support. You can help us further amplify opportunities at the casino by keeping our residents, businesses and stakeholders informed. This includes adding information to your newsletters, encouraging businesses in your Awards, to get certified and provide and providing expertise in how we build capacity for our diverse Chicago firms. Next slide, This is still the early stages of this conceito process. The temporary Casino has been operating for a little over a year and the permanent Casino has just started Construction. We understand there is plenty of room to improve and grow. but we also want to recognize that the success is so far, and the opportunities, for Chicago businesses and Residences residents that have been created from this project. We look forward to continuing to work with all of you and we will now take any questions or comments. You may have thank you. Thank you. next, we have, um, from Valley. Valley cooperation attendees. Uh, there's anyone who wants to speak from valleys. at this time, if if not, we'll go straight to questions and I'll start off with, um, 1 of the questions that I have from. Page. Page 4 of your report. Um, there are color code. For key. and doing it and then um, the circle with the gold or the yellow if you want to say, Is in progress. Uh, that's 25% minority ownership of the casino. Can someone speak on that? And give us an overview? Sure. Uh, for the record, Christopher JW at senior vice president, corporate development for BS. Okay? Uh, so going back and rewinding as part of the, uh, the procurement process and the bidding process. Uh, the city had required a minority Equity stake, uh, within any casino bid, uh, to be part and a portion of your bid. There's also a state requirement to make good faith efforts within the gaming act. With that being said, um, bies Has bid and accepted within the HCA. It's documented, uh, that our Target goal is 25%. Minority ownership in the project. Uh, with that being said, we've been working diligently uh with an army of lawyers uh to essentially take Bali, Chicago public. Uh and what that means is there's a public offering whereby. Folks that qualify uh based on the language that is within the HCA uh, which is minority and women. Uh, based on Municipal Code, they can own uh a portion of the Chicago, Casino or a share. Um ultimately that was launched in late December. Uh, we're hopeful in the next month or so for that to close, uh, IE to, you know, collect the equity stake, you know, the the cash required, uh, from folks and ultimately, to issue those shares, I know you said was launched in December, do you have? Uh, um, there's a So there is, uh, you can find more information right at bali's Chicago. Invest.com. So I'll invest.com correct with that website lead you to uh Were you able to invest 100%? So the website is set up to provide an investor presentation, that will give an entire overview, uh of the project itself and the various categories of investment. And then ultimately for those that are interested, uh you have to create a login, uh, whereby you provide your personal information that will get validated uh through a know. Your customer kyc process and ultimately you can indicate your interest, you know, transfer money. And we're working with a Chicago based firm, which I'm sure many of, you know, uh loop capital markets to uh facilitate this. There was loop capital right? Correct. Correct. Okay. All right. Just wanted to um, more on record stating that and um I'm not sure if we had a PowerPoint, I guess the because there are categories that you can choose correct. Correct so uh I guess to simplify, yeah, um, there's 4 classes of shares. Every share is worth 25,000. Uh, a class A4 share you, you would put up 25,000 in cash a class. A1 share. You would put up 2, 5, 0. when is the, um, anticipated deadline for Replying. The application process is open. It's been open for a couple of weeks now, uh, our Target to close the application process, and ultimately process. Issuance of shares is in the next couple of weeks, Okay? So we've got a marketing campaign out there. Uh, We've communicated via press release, uh, emails to those that have expressed interest, uh, previously. We just sent it to all of the Ottomans, uh, from a, I think, from a legal perspective, I don't have our lawyers here, I don't think we, um, I don't think we can tell you to do that but, uh, legal legal legal. We have a, a lot of Department here. The 1 here, from the Law Department. Oh, he left. uh, chairman I'm not from the Law Department, this is Ethan Gilman uh a business neighborhood team in the mayor's office. Uh we can connect internally and censor the chair. the chair. But we feel is appropriate with regards to the, uh, public offering. We will be sharing, um, information on what the ethical guidance is, um, from both our office, as well as, uh, the law department and the ethics office. So we will, I don't want to be able to that they could, uh, everyone could put it on their website emails or whatever and send it out to their constituents. I mean, just transfer because All understood real coordinate, internally and follow-up. Okay, very good. Um I'm a VA Thank you. Thank you, madam chair. Uh, along those same along those same lines. As relates to, uh, minority and minority investment. Um, so is it under the state statute or ordinance? That requires the minority partic. Minority investment participation. Is it under? So the uh I believe uh I guess for the record Christopher J with B's for the record. I record. I believe the state uh the state gaming act requires good faith efforts for. I think it's 16%, uh, MBE and W and 4% WBEE. So 20% in total, uh, and we've exceeded that with our goal of the 25%, which we expect to be met so, um, But this is open to everyone, correct? It's all it's only open to folks that qualify under Municipal Code that essentially in in simplifying identify as minorities and women or specific language within the municipal code uh and within the HCA that ultimately identifies who would qualify Gotcha. Um, so then, um, if I go to this website, And I select 1 of the 4 categories that's available. Then there's a a prompt that will ask me whether or not I qualify for this type of investment. Correct. Correct and then there's a and there, there's a verification process, the know your customer process, uh, going through the portal, you essentially have to submit per, you know, pretty detailed personal information, um, you know, similar to like buying stocks which is essentially what you're doing. You have to put in your, you know, your social security number or tax ID number. Um if you're buying it under a you know, a minority or women-owned um You know, uh investment vehicle, um, you know, driver's license, things like that will be verified in order to ensure that we're compliant, got you? And then um you stated that it's a goal. So let's say, for example, that uh, you don't meet that goal is, is are you guys open to Um, allowing other types of Investments that are higher than 25,000. Because 25,000 seems like Um relatively low threshold. I know there's some I mean obviously I love I appreciate the $50. Um, Opportunity to invest in something like this but there are other folks that may want to invest a little bit more. Is that something that you guys are contemplating or yeah? So that is contemplated uh, Alderman. So the 25,000 per share is just a per share pricing. So for example, if if you know uh, Uh a resident wanted to invest, you know, 500,000 dollars. They could do that or 250,000 just doing, you know, the simple math. Okay. They could, they could own 10 shares. Theoretically okay. I I thought the limit was 25,000 so no. Yeah each share is just valued at 25,000. Okay. And who set that price? Uh, that that's been set by by us in our Underwriters. Okay, cool. Thank you, madam chair. Thank you. Are there any other questions from committee members? May there's a question from ottoman David Moe, but I'm not a Committee Member. All right, I am more no questions um, from committee members, ottoman Moore, Yes, uh, thank you. Um, chairman, I'm sorry, I couldn't get earlier in terms of when uh we were talking about um the corridor managers. My phone was acting up but I'll address address that later on but here, um, I need to understand and and um, I, uh, well, capable Commissioner of housing explained it. Um, and but I want her to come back to explain it because, I'm not sure, sure, and she does great work in housing, but I, I'm not understanding why the compliance part is in housing and why it's not in, um, procurement. Um, I'm, I'm just, I'm just lost on that. Um, explanation and I think I'm gonna be talking about compliance, um, and in terms of development, even if it was in dpd, but I think it belong, I think it should be in procurement, so help me explain that part why. It's in housing, you you sort of explained it, but please break it down for me, further because I'm not Understanding why we're conducting compliance for this um, Economic Development, um, entity out of um, out of housing. Thank you, Alderman, Moore, happy to answer that. Um so not every contract, goes through the department of procurement Services, some of the Departments such as the Department of Housing and the department of Planning and Development have contract Authority. So, um, many of the Alders have experience working with us when we're doing, for example, an affordable housing project or when uh dpd does an economic development project that requires Tif money, for money, for example. So because we have that Authority, we also have the responsibility to do construction, compliance monitoring so in this case, this project was treated like a typical dpd project because it was not procured through the department of um, through the department of procurement services. But instead the HCA is held with the office of the CFO so again, because we have contract Management Authority, we have the setup to do construction compliance monitoring, because it is important to us to ensure that our projects are reaching the same. Um, wbe MBE standards that are set for all the projects in the city of Chicago. So the Department of Housing houses, a staff of 8 that does just construction compliance for do and dpd projects. And this project was treated like a dpd project and then my next question, would be who treated it like a dpd project because there are some dpd projects. And I know those dpd projects that has a most of them have a housing arm if I'm if I'm constructing a um, commercial. Um, um, facility, um, um, that's not a part of, um, housing. Um, then that becomes under, um, dpd or, you know, um, procurement. So what you said is contracted, Authority. So do dpd get Contract Authority. dpd sometimes also, Yes Alderman dpd also has Contracting Authority and so you have to, you don't have to go, I get it, I get it. So what I'm trying to get at is what what decision was made to put contract Authority for this development under housing who ultimately made when was that decision made under the previous administration. And if so all I'm asking is the why? Because I just don't feel like it belongs in that. If even if it was in dpd, I could see that it procurement. I'm just not seeing the housing portion of it, just for it being in housing sake. So I need, I just need someone to explain that to me. Um, yes. So I I can let some folks who maybe who were here before in the prior Administration when it was executed speak to that. I will, I will say we allow Ethan. Uh, if you could answer that question for ottoman more, thank you. Commissioner. Uh yes uh thank you for the question Alderman. Um so the Authority for the HCA actually falls under the CFO generally as as was determined in 2022. Um because of that and of course the C CFO does not have um you know the compliance reporting components uh like other departments, like the Department of Housing. Uh it was made, the determination was made to treat it like a department of planning and development project. Uh, that determination was made in coordination with the, uh, In the prior Administration and coordination with the CPO. Um, so yes, that's how we've been monitoring the project, uh, since the Inception. okay, so okay, so I just want to be clear and and based on what you just said and you wanted to create like a dpd project, even that my mind was then, tell me dpd would have had contracted Authority. I just if some if it's just hey we just did it that way. Fine because I'm not I'm fully not understanding why something like this is under housing. I I understand what everybody said. I I get that part but it just doesn't make sense to me. And so if it was just because that's the way they wanted then say that and then what I agree with it or not, you know, that's another story but I'm just feeling like some a project like this uh, shouldn't be under a housing off. Just like, I wouldn't but 1 of the housing something that was contracted under the housing to be under, you know uh contract Authority for um um, C dot, you know. So I'm just trying to, um, you said it it, was it, it was then under the CFO, which I get that part and then ultimately, it was just put under housing by what Rhyme or Reason. That's all I'm asking. Is it just done that way? Because we just did it or is there a Rhyme or Reason to it? Thank you. I remember, I think you he's sharing some of the concerns that some of us have as well, including myself, I couldn't understand how um, it wasn't under contracts oversight and equity in from the beginning, given the fact that we have a housing issue and we need all staff like trying to work on housing, you know a lot to do but uh, it was done that way and um, I suppose It may have been, uh, due to the previous administration. Uh, some of it came from there, as well. So um, where we at now? Um, ottoman Moore where you finish. I get that part chairman but I still that my, the you haven't got your question answered right satisfactory. I get my, my my, my second part to my question. After everybody has to which I get is that okay? It was under the the CFO but then on CFO doesn't have a compliance area. So then I'm just asking why who somebody still got to be here to say why it went to housing versus dpd or, um, procurement? That's all I'm saying. Um, Ethan, what's the rhyme of reason to it, if that's just the way it is, then we say, just, that's the way it is, ottoman. More Ethan is going to try and answer it again. Oh, yes. Uh, to clarify um, the There was no City funds, uh, in in the steel. And so that's why we felt it was more appropriate to not, uh, monitor it through the department of procurement Services. Um, DP. Uh, do had the reporting components and systems in place, uh, to properly monitor this project. Um, and again, similar to a department of Planning Development project, where do also does the monitoring and compliance, uh, that's where it made the most sense, uh, to sit and that decision again was made, uh, during the prior Administration following, uh, the signing of the HCA. Um, so again, because there was no City funds in the deal, um, it felt more appropriate to treat it like a, a department of Planning and Development deal. Where do the compliance monitoring? Okay. And then my last question to that is, I understand when you said it was done the prior Administration I left as as we discussed, this can, this can that be changed. Or we have to keep it under there, can it be changed and put under procurement? In theory, I would say yes. Uh but we have been following this consistent process, uh, since the Inception of the project and have put components in place, uh, to monitor this project, we coordinate across the Departments, uh, including with the office of the CFO deliver the reports to this committee. Um, and to report and monitoring of all of the components of the casino, similarly, the department of Planning and Development, uh, monitors the operations jobs reporting. So So it is a cross departmental coordination. Uh, as we deliver reports to the committee, All right, I have my conversation. But I, I encourage the chairman of contract, uh, chairman of contract, oversight and Equity to, uh, sit with these different departments and, you know, uh, uh, our role with my chairman and then you, you know, you decide based on that chairman, uh, since we possibly can move it. Uh I don't I really don't see any stringent reason. Why we shouldn't be a shouldn't be able to is just something I think we just need to delve into and and confess I've been I think there's been some concerns um throughout with some other uh Alderman as well as including yourself chairman and I think we just need to lay this to rest and and make a decision on It. Ultimately, that's all I'm saying. Thank you are more and we'll be happy to uh work with you. and, and see if, um, We can uh, resolve that issue. Um, all right. Thank you. Armen Taylor. Did you have your, do you have your hand up? I did. Thank you, chairwoman. Um in the beginning of this conversation and maybe I missed missed it and I'm gonna apologize that he said that there were parts of the track. The contract that they're not in compliance of, can they repeat what those are and what they are doing to make sure that they stick to the contract. Yet. Um, someone hit a question who's going to respond? Automat. Taylor can you repeat that question? Uh, you just wanted to know uh what is being done by uh contracts that are not? You can they repeat? What? What is not? Care woman was not in compliance. And what are they doing to reinsure that they get into compliance? Absolutely. Yeah, let me uh start off by answering that the areas of non-compliance, or in the operations state, your name. Uh, Joe. Yeah, Jill Jaworski CFO for the city. Uh the areas of non-compliance are in the areas of operation spending, um, and this has been, um, a, a consistent issues since the beginning that we have spent a good bit of time talking to BS about. I know there are some challenges uh, related to this area and the limited amount of spending and the limited amount of vendor. But if BS is able to answer the question about the operation, spend I think that would be helpful for everyone. Sure. Um this is Amit Patel from uh B's Corporation. I'm senior vice president and uh Regional general manager. Um, I'll answer the question in really 2 parts. Part. 1 is to why we are not in compliance so far and and good faith efforts are being made. Um, and and the progress is also being made on a, on a quarterly basis. Where every quarter we continue to increase the number of diversity vendors that we are registering, um, under umbrella and and spreading, um, the amount of spend that we can. The, the challenge is that, that Jill mentioned earlier, 1 of them, is really some of the large categories of our spend, um, ends up in in our national spend such as, uh, we listen to our customers as to why they want to come back to BS. how are they, how are they coming back and what they find of value and 1 big example of that is they they like having gift cards as 1 of the rewards for their loyalty to our membership and and those gift cards are of much higher value when we go to a national supplier versus a local supplier. And, and we, when we spend that kind of money in gift card program for our customers, it does end up creating this imbalance as to how we cannot end up spending it locally here and what are we doing about something like that? um, Oldman is we we created this community Rewards program as you're aware of where we're taking this gift card program and making sure that we go to surrounding businesses and and make sure we, we start spreading those spend within our neighborhoods and, and within the the, um, the suppliers that that are registering with us. Um, number 1 is a challenge just to get the number of minority suppliers in different categories of those pain. But I can assure you that every quarter that we've looked at in 2024, we continue to register more and more number of um, uh, of minority suppliers and, and women based businesses as well, uh, locally. You all need. Yeah, you all need to do a better job at working with us. Cuz yesterday was the first time that I'm hearing of this and second of all, we are supposed to be partners. And so what I've said to others is the advertisement is not that great. Um, I see more advertising for Horseshoe, that's not even in Chicago than I do for the 1 that we actually have. And so there's some things that we can do by working together so that we can reach out to our community to get these better numbers. Can you tell me what else? Um, CFO Gio is not in compliance. Uh, this is the primary area um, is the operation spending. Um, There's um some other areas where, for instance, um, on the the temporary Casino, uh, buildout. Um, the uh, MBE spend was in excess of the requirements and the, but the wbe spend was, uh, very close but did not quite meet the requirements. um, the um labor hours for uh Ceda residents was uh slightly slightly under um, though, the labor hours for Chicago residents, um, was exceeding, the goal. So, there's those are areas that are, um, Clothes. And then the other area is that the it it again goes to operations. Um but it's to hiring is that the number of veterans is below the goal, though, the number of minorities and women is above the goal. will we be able to rectify this before the permanent sites or or is there some type of What are we doing to reinsure that? They meet these goals? Because reporting is what it is but what are we really doing? To make sure that they meet the goals. I'm excited that they're over in a bunch of goals but we need all the goals to be met because to be honest a lot of us didn't feel like this casino was going to do what it said is going to do and it seems like I is struggling now and just the the temporary phase. We don't want to get to the permanent phase. And how do you same issues? That's all I got to share with them and thank you. Thank you. Uh, thank you madam chair and this is not so much a question, so much a comment to the body that as it relates to compliance. Uh, I think there's been a lot of questions around compliance whether dpds in charge of that or do or procurement services. And I think that this is an opportunity if the body show chooses to introduce legislation that would house it under 1 department. So that way there's accountability uh and not a mishmash of of departments that are dabbling in in matters that are not their subject matter expertise. So if that's something that the body chooses, uh, I would be more H, more than happy to co-sign, because I think that there needs to be some uniformity around compliance procurement housing, dpd, and let those folks that actually our Specialties in those areas, do their job and focus on what it is that they're a commissioner of uh and so if the body chooses to do that I'd be more than happy to work with my colleagues on that. Thank you. I look forward to doing that with you all to make this ultimate more. Thank you. Let me ask a question about um, veterans. Uh, are we down in terms of the numbers for veterans? and, If so what are we doing to? Increase that number for the new. Uh, Casino. Short. This is for the record. This is Amit Patel again with B's Corporation. Um off the categories of employment that we have right now. Um just remember putting in respective um chairman is we have 650 some jobs that we've created with Madina Temple operation this 650. Number exponentially grows to 3,000 people that we are going to employ with the permanent Casino, if you look at our compliance records right now, minority, you know, we we have our our goals were 60% in minority. We're exceeding that to 82%. If you look at our women goal, 45% we're exceeding that to 47% um disability uh 5% goal. We're exceeding that to 9% where we are short to your point is on the veteran side. Our goal is 5% and we are at 2% right now. Um, I think the city has done an outstanding job in partnering with us, when Recently, they've also introduced us to the Department of Veterans Affairs, office of the mayor, uh, particularly Uh, Kevin berzak. And we are closely working with them and we feel we're cautiously optimistic and we feel very comfortable that we will be able to meet or exceed this goal on the veterans category as well. I was noticing that and so, um, I just wanted to say that There's a um, a lot you could do. Um, but when you say City I don't know who you prefer referring to because that could be, I think that you need to be working with. There are a lot of veterans organizations that are out there. And there's no way we should have 2%, so somebody's not doing a, the city is not doing a good enough job. We need to make sure we get out here and where the ottomans are at and find out these organizations and get referrals. That's all Uh and and make sure that we get those numbers up. And I'll appreciate it if that would be done. Um, Are there any other questions? Well. We've come to the end of this year. Uh, there'll be no further questions before this committee. Uh, this was a no subject matter hearing which uh, all items will be reported out on um, January the 15th at the next city council meeting and this will conclude their generic committee on contracts and oversight and Equity. There be no further business before the committee, ottoman Coleman's move that we adjourn. Thank you.