The City of Chicago City Council Rules of Convict for Public Meetings 2023 to 2027. Pursuant to the Chicago City Council rules of Order and Procedure Rule 49, the sergeant at ARM sets forth the following rules of convict to be followed during the public comment period. And the duration of all committee and city council meetings. Profane, vulgar, threatening, abusive, or disruptive language is not permitted, demeaning, discriminatory, or harassing behavior and speech directed towards others is not permitted. Disruptive behavior, including disruptive or disrespectful conduct during others presentations is not permitted. Banners, pliers, or signage are not permitted. Backpacks, large bags and sharp objects are not permitted. Clear bags not tinted in color that do not exceed 12 by 12 by six inches will be permitted in our subject to search. Health, food and beverages, including in metal canisters are not permitted. Cell phone. Okay. Uh, or you want me to bring a remote? Oh, okay. Can we, can we keep it down? Can we keep it down? We're gonna get started in just a second. Mr. Sims. Mr. Sims. Mr. Sims, we're gonna get started right now. Tech supporter. Are we good to go? Okay. This meeting, this meeting is now getting started. Mr. Sims. Mr. Sims, I would kindly ask, I would kindly ask that you keep your comments confined to public comments so that we can get started. The Committee on Ethics and Government Oversight will now come to order. There is one item on today's agenda, a subject matter hearing on the Office of Inspector General's report entitled, staffing Sworn Chicago Police Department members Assigned with Patrol Duties. We will begin with a roll call. Please note that you're a yes or present response will be deemed a yes vote when this, uh, quorum call is used for reference. Vote for later items. Chairman Martin is present. Vice Chair Hadden Wo Lee Alderman. OSHA will be remote. We'll get to you in just a second. Alderwoman Taylor Ris. Scott Talia, far Alderman Wapac. Alderman Spaza. Alderwoman Nugent, alderman Vasquez, alderman Riley Alderman Lawson. We will be getting to momentarily actually, right now. Um, alderman, OSHA and Lawson have requested remote participation in the committee meeting under Rule 59. Is there a motion to allow both of them to attend today's meeting remotely? Vice Chair Hadden. So moves all those in favor signify by saying Aye. All those opposed say no. And the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. And alderman, OSHA in Lawson are allowed to attend committee meeting remotely at this time. Will we begin? Thank you. We will begin. Public comment, uh, the period is set for 30 minutes and out of respect for everyone's time, each speaker is limited to three minutes of public comment. We have four people signed up for public comment. We will begin with Michael Young Bay. Mr. Young Bay, please come up to the public microphone. Uh, I ain't concerned with no quorum. Y'all ain't got no agenda or, or whatever. Y'all just putting a sign up there, um, was assigned to parole patrol duty of the police force. So, you know, how is the public knowing what's going on and what's in detail of what's happening with the issues that's here. You know, just coming in these meetings and y'all, um, just doing them, how y'all doing them, you know, we should be able to at least have an agenda to see, you know, what's going on with the subject matters. And that's right, because then it becomes a hidden agenda because you ain't got no agenda here. So Yo sworn CPD members assigned to per patrol duties, where is they assigned to? What neighborhoods they assigned to? You know, we need to know these things. The public paying, they tax dollars and seller. We need to know these things because in certain neighborhoods we see them on bikes, but in other neighborhoods, we don't see 'em. You don't see 'em in Inglewood unless they doing arrest. They, you know, normal routines or whatever the case may be. Chatham, Woodline, Lawndale, et cetera. But if you go in other neighborhoods, you know, whether it's River North, uh, magnificent mile area, et cetera, you see highly patrol, you see, you even see officers just sitting in, in the car in the middle of the street that's not patrolling, that's actually, um, sitting down on the job when they can be patrolling these communities. So, uh, y'all need to do better because what people paying they property taxes for taxes in the store, et cetera. We're not reaping the rewards. We are not reaping the services. And it's a disgrace and it's a dishonored honor to the people and the citizens of Chicago. You know, and then the patrol we do get is to inc criminalize our people, lock our people up, et cetera. You know, the violence, et cetera, from the police. That's why our people don't trust the police. What you need to patrol is these migrants out here on these streets. You need to patrol, get them off them corners, because as that was our people, or I ain't gonna say our people, if that was the citizens of the United States period, y'all to, you know, get them off the corner. Take they women, y'all take they children, how you got children that should be in school outside with they, with they parents selling candy. Thank you. Next up, uh, uh, Twan Sims, then George Blake Moer. Mr. Sims, uh, you can, you can direct your questions to public comment up here. Uh, I, I don't have that number immediately in front of me, but you can go ahead and provide co public comment before we get to the subject matter portion. Portion. Can you explain to me what a quorum is? Please? Members are present at the meeting and if you don't have the members present at the meeting, if not a formal, uh, uh, a, a meeting because you don't have a code. So here it's very dis discre it. I don't know what this mess they cooked up today. And it says, uh, inspector Jones. They Inspector Jones is supposed to inspect. She right there. Burg right there, Deborah, right there. Okay, Mr. Sims, do you wanna make any public comment? Mr. Mr. Sims? If there's any public comment you would like to make, I'd ask you to direct it into the microphone. Young, Young Martin. Young Martin, look, I'm gonna try to respect you because you not that fat dog, Irving, what I'm telling you right now, this is not a respectable meeting, sir. This is not a meeting. We came to sit down and have an ethics meeting with the ethics committee. That was, this was the hangup the other day. This is not a meeting. This is a disrespect to the citizens to us. I just drove back over here to sit down and speak with this one. But I wanna speak to the people in a ethics meeting, in a meeting, in a formal meeting, not disrespect it. And y'all don't get it. Y'all want us to freak out or flip out? Mr. Martin, we're here and that's the og OIG, but they got you. But right now, you know, they disrespecting us, Ms. Berg, but you going, you look, you don't, you gonna hang us up. So I don't wanna speak in your mic, Mr. Blakemore. You could, you could tell them what a um, form is. Yes, you have. So many members are present. Mr. Sims, if you're, if you are done with your public comment, then if Mr. Sims, if you're done with your public comment, then we will proceed to Mr. Blakemore. Next. I I want you to be aware that you have, uh, 30 minutes left to say anything else you want to during public comment. If you're done, then we will proceed to Mr. Blakemore. Mr. Blakemore, you have three minutes. This, I have Mr. Sims. I'd ask you to let Mr. Blakemore speak. Mr. Blakemore, you have three minutes. This, Uh, inspector Jones, they had one before and they, he didn't do anything. Now he was civic federation. You're not gonna do nothing either. All of this is just a dog and pony show. You're not going do nothing. And then I want the general public to know how many people, uh, uh, have, uh, attending this meeting. 1, 2, 3, 4, and these other people right here, I don't know they purpose, right? But this is not only a meeting. You don't even have a call a game that being played here. And we, you don't even have another agenda. You made it so general. So it's something wrong here. And then I sometime, I was just wondering, they say that red hair, what? Uh, he's half white or whatever. I'm talking about you, sir. You, you are disgrace all what? Well, what's going on here? Now? I thought you was a black man. I, I thought you knew our struggle, but you seem to, to be carrying on this do and pony show with us about us. So stop it. Can I, can y'all see here? Can you see? Come here. Go red. Can you see nobody here? Or how many Tums do you have here? One Four. Is that a cover? No. No, it's not. No, it's not. Stop this. Stop it now and don't touch me. Go and get one of the police. The Sergeant Obama have no authority to put to place their hand on. No, there's not. Look here. I want y'all this not. And then Our final public speaker is Jessica Jackson, Ms. Jackson. And as you're coming up to the microphone, I wanna recognize all alderman Chris Talia Farro, who is participating remotely. Ms. Jackson, please proceed. Um, okay, so, um, if you notice, I'm wearing the same thing today that I wore yesterday, and I did that because yesterday my rights, along with others were violated for public speaking. And so I showed up again today with the same thing going to make city council understand that it's not about what a person wears, but since you all are into symbols, you know how the Democratic Party is. I came and read again, you all need to understand it's a frame of mind. The frame of mind is that you no longer allow your rights to be disrespected like this by your government, especially when you have another choice. And the other choice is the Republican party. Trump is their candidate, but I'm in line with the party Now, one reason for that is like what the previous speakers talked about. I have tried to utilize this system as a citizen. I have put a report into the Inspector General Deborah Berg. I have put a, a, a report, a complaint in with the Inspector General for Cook County, Anthony, Nigel, and those reports, those complaints go dormant. You don't get any re result. And because of that, we have a rogue city hall. We have a mayor that disregards the rights of the citizens all day, all day. And he's allowed to get away with it because City Hall allows 'em to do it. I gave you my information. Like they say you a civil rights attorney. I'm not tripping off your race. I'm saying as a civil rights attorney, how is it that you didn't move on The information that I gave you except for you were told by Mayor Johnson more than likely to step away from the case. The same thing that Richardson Lori did. Perhaps the same thing that Deborah Wisberg is doing, the same thing that the Cook County Inspector General Mr. Nigel is doing, which is why this corruption is allowed to go on and on and on and on. Within this party, there are those of us who know better. We know that we do not have to suffer under this party. I'm looking at, she's going to put up a report that's gonna talk about fraud, that's gonna talk about misconduct, that's gonna talk about wasted resources, all of which I've given her that information for all of which I've given the other Cook County General, uh, uh, information for all the violation of rights that go on in here at every meeting all day, every day. And nothing at all is being done about it. But then you are at fault because you wanna vote a different kind of way. You would be an idiot to keep doing the same thing and not get different results. That concludes public comment. Uh, our first order of business is the Rule 45 report from September, 2024, which was sent to the committee. Can I have a motion to approve that report? Vice Chair Hadden. So moves all those in favor signify by saying aye. All those opposed in the opinion of the chair. The ayes have it. We will now begin our subject matter hearing regarding the Office of Inspector General's report on CPD staffing. I'd like to introduce Inspector General. Deborah Wisberg, if you could identify yourself for the record, anyone else from your office, and then provide a brief summary of that report. Thank you very much. Thank you chairman, um, for having us. Good afternoon, members of the committee. I'm Deborah Berg. I'm Inspector General for the City of Chicago, and I'm here with, to borrow Richardson, who is our Deputy Inspector General for public safety. Um, we are, uh, here to talk about some descriptive and data work we have done around staffing levels in the Chicago Police Department, specifically staffing levels for sworn members assigned with patrol duties. This is a report published in July within a accompanying data dashboard update. There are no accompanying, there are no findings or recommendations here. This is, as I say, descriptive and transparency work. Um, the, the backdrop of this work, the, the, the driver here is the observation that measuring CPDs patrol presence in a particular location in the city. That is to say how many CPD members are patrolling any one neighborhood in the city. Um, is is a complex, opaque and imperfect exercise that is, it is surprisingly difficult from inside the department or outside to tell how many people are working and where. One important framing here, there's a lot of discussion about CPD staffing and staffing models and staffing analyses. One important distinction here is the difference between point in time data. That is to say a, a capture of how many people are working at any one point versus predictive modeling. That a predictive staffing model is a tool which allows inputs and outputs in a dynamic way to reflect changing needs and priorities and so on for staffing. So what, what we have done here, what we are after is the first of these things point in time data capture so that we can measure present point in time staffing levels, which is, is a necessary precursor to making well-informed predictive tools and using them effectively. Um, we have had OIG g has had on our information portal, a longstanding data dashboard showing some information on CPD staffing levels across districts and units. Accompanying this report in July, we published an updated dashboard. So it still contains all of the information that it ever did, but it, it contains both more and more accurate data. And I'll talk a little bit about what those differences are. When we published, uh, prior to publishing the new dashboard and the report that accompanied it, we as our, as is our regular practice provided a draft of those documents to CPD, uh, and OPSA, the Office of Public Safety Administration. Um, the city, those city departments noted that there are data sources within the department, which are not reflected on the dashboard. That is certainly the case. We have been seeking access to those data sources for more than a year, um, and have not, those have not been provided, uh, that, that delay is, is, um, noted in the report as well as, as to the independent monitor monitoring implementation of the consent decree. I'll also note, um, and, and folks from CPD are here today, and so maybe there's an opportunity for some updated information today, but we also asked the department to demonstrate how someone within the department themselves would, would measure point in time staffing data and would determine how many people are working and where, um, no demonstration has been provided. So in terms of, um, sort of definitions of what we're talking about here, when we talk about patrol duties, the thing we are after is the real life experience of how many CPD members are working in somebody's neighborhood. So to sort of try to get a handle on that, there's a general order CPDs general order oh 1 0 2 0 4 on the organization and function of the Bureau of Patrol. And that directive sets out, um, a definition of the responsibilities of patrol members, which is, which is here on the slide. We identified members as for purposes of this data work as those assigned with patrol duties, if they were assigned or detailed to a, uh, geographic district or beat with responsibilities that align with those identified in the directive. So much of the police department is out, is staffed into these geographic designations districts and beats, which are subdivisions of districts, but not all CPD members are. There are non geographic units within, uh, the department as well. Um, notably there are certainly some CPD members not assigned to a geographic district or BEAT who might be undertaking patrol duties. So, for example, when, um, particularly when there were many, many department members assigned to the community safety team, that was a citywide unit that was not a geographic district or beat, but there certainly were members of the community safety team outworking patrol duties in the neighborhoods that is not captured in, in the CPD data that we've been able to use. This is our work here is by no means the first or the only effort to increase the transparency of CPD staffing. This is a longstanding public conversation, including in this room, in this body, in this committee. Um, CPD itself has commissioned staffing analyses and has discussed those publicly a number of times over the years. There was a 2010 study, which was never made public. There was a 2016 study, uh, the resulting recommendations from which were never in implemented. Um, there was a 2022 model built, which was discarded before implementation. The consent decree entered in Illinois versus Chicago requires CPD to conduct staffing analysis for certain purposes. Um, the independent monitor has noted that the department must complete a comprehensive staffing study to inform a realistic, uh, and effective staffing approach. There are also, as you all know in this committee, there have been legislative efforts over time to improve transparency. There have been questions in successive years at CPD budget hearings, including by some of the, the members of the committee present, um, for more and better and clearer information about CPD staffing. Um, I think the observation there, I won't speak for those of you who have asked those questions, but personnel costs in the Chicago Police Department are a very, very significant piece of the city's annual budget. And, and I think that is an important piece of context around transparency efforts on CPD staffing. This is, this is not an academic question going into budget season. Um, there was also, as you all know, an ordinance passed out of this committee, uh, earlier this year requiring CPD to engage an outside entity to conduct a staffing analysis. And at critically, from my perspective, to do accompanying public reporting on the status of that effort. So I offer all of that as some sort of historical background and context to, to talk about the fact that we have elected to go forward with this work, our updated dashboard. And it's an it's accompanying report, not because those things are based on perfect data, they're not. Um, but because of the pressing need for improved transparency on this question and the lack of other available resources. So, um, motivated by the notion that some information is better than none, and that information about how taxpayer dollars are being spent at spent belongs to the taxpayers. Uh, we, we've put forth this, this updated dashboard and this product, this report, so this is a static, this is a, a screenshot of the dashboard, but it is found on our information portal ig chicago.org. You go to our information portal and to the public safety section, and that's where you'll find the dashboards. So, um, this is what it looks like. There are different tabs. This is the map function of the dashboard, and I wanna talk about what makes, what, what we have improved and, and what makes this tool hopefully better and and more useful even than its predecessor tool. So a couple of quick notes on our data methodology. We have, um, this, our data dashboard draws on data sources, uh, in a best effort to, as I say, capture the best available information to answer this surprisingly elusive question of how many CPD members are, are patrolling the city and where at any given time. So we have obtained members assignments and detail data from our regular monthly polls of CPD data, an assignment when a CCPD member is in an assignment that is a long-term, sort of semi-permanent work assignment. A detail is a temporary move of a CPD member to one place or another. So someone might be assigned to a district, but temporarily detailed to another, assigned to a district, but detailed to a, a specialized unit or team of some kind, et cetera. So we've taken assignment and detailed data. We have taken information from a and a records assignment and attendance records that show a variety of pieces of information about, about CBD members who are working, including their work days, um, their actual presence for duty, whether they are they are present or absent on any given day, um, they're beat their work hours, et cetera. What, you know, which part of the day they are working. We have in our data analysis in, in populating the dashboard, we have found missing data in some, some of those across those categories. And we have supplemented missing data with historical information. So where we have been able to find in, uh, in historical sources information about a member's work hours or beats, et cetera, we've used that information to try to fill in missing, missing pieces of information. Um, the data is provided in the new dashboard at both a district and a beat level. So in our, in the prior version of this dashboard, you could look at staffing over time by district. That is an important piece of information, but people live on their block, not not in the whole district. And so we now provide information by beat. We also have a resource where people can identify their beat. If, if that's not a number that people know. So we have information at the district and beat level. We've also documented actual presence, documented presence for duty so that we can account for things like members who are on furlough or who are injured and not at work. So that we, the, the staffing levels that are appearing on our dashboard are at least significantly closer to real numbers of people who are out on the street working. We have work hours accounted for for the first time. CBD members in are scheduled to work a wide variety of watches. A 24 hour day is divided up into many different schedule blocks in different different operational units in the department. In order to sort of simplify that for use, we have, we have divided members into, um, early morning daytime and overnight hours, um, to account for changing presence levels over the course of a day. Um, and finally, we, the data is displayed on our dashboard for one day each month, and that is to capture variation over time as well as to reduce the risk of systemic bias in the data capture. That is to say, to reduce distortion if there are more people working at one time of year, for example, than another. If we have more people on the street in the summer and fewer in the winter, we wanna sort of account for that by, by displaying data over time one day per month. There are significant and important limitations on this data, both in terms of its completeness and its accuracy. Um, some CBD members are assigned or detailed to a district, but not to a specific geographic beat. So, you know, non geographic duties within a district might include supervisors, for example. They don't, they would not necessarily be assigned to a specific geographic beat. This is important because those people certainly contribute to patrol presence in a district. And so they would be captured in our data, in our counts at the district level. They would not be captured at the beat level because they're not necessarily assigned to a specific geographic beat. There are non-specific and non-standard descriptions of job duties in some of the CPD records, which can make it challenging to ascertain who is actually doing what members may travel outside of their district to perform patrol duties or, or off of their beat. If there is, for example, a call for service, which requires response by multiple units, some of those units are gonna come from beats other than where that incident took place that is not captured in the data. Um, beats are captured in the, in the attendance records when they are, where people are working during their regular work hours, but not when they are working overtime. So if we have CPD members working overtime and they be maybe working somewhere other than they usually do, that may not be captured. So we note these things because these are important limitations on the data and, and these are among other factors, the things which, which weigh on any ability in the current state of affairs to comprehensively accurately capture staffing information in spite of these limitations. As I mentioned, we have provided the data that is available, um, because some transparency on this question is better than none. Um, these are important limitations and these are some of the data quality and completeness obstacles which need to be overcome for the sort of accurate and comprehensive point in time data capture, which would then facilitate a, a prospective, um, data, uh, staffing model. Uh, and I'll leave it there. I'm happy to answer any questions, chairman. Thank you, general. Um, next, I believe we have Deputy Chief Dan O'Connor. Uh, deputy, if you can introduce yourself for the record as well as any colleagues you have with you in the box. Yes. Uh, good afternoon chairman, and thank you for the opportunity to, um, come and speak with the, uh, ethics committee. Uh, I'm Deputy Chief Daniel Jay O'Connor, and I'm the deputy chief of the Bureau of Patrol. With me is, Uh, assistant director, no, Uh, strategic Conditions division. Great. And if you wanna proceed with your remarks, deputy. Yes. Um, most of our remarks are already, uh, contained in the superintendent's response in Appendix G, and, um, I'm happy to answer any questions that the committee may have. Great, Thank you. And with that, we will open it up for committee questions. Um, I, I'll ask the first one, which is, uh, directing initially to general and then deputy, if, if you wanna chime in as well. Um, uh, general, you had mentioned additional data sources that, uh, you're aware of your office is aware of, but are not reflected, uh, in, in the dashboard. Are you able to provide any, uh, more specificity around what those data sources might be and what the, um, end product is of their absence from, from your work? In short, is this like potentially large because of the number of sworn, uh, patrol members that might be captured in that, or is it, or maybe you don't even know that, maybe it's a small number. Hoping you can shed some light on that. I appreciate the question. I'm not sure we are in a good position to quantify the impact of the data because we haven't been able to access it. Um, but there is certainly some, some time sheet data that we have been seeking access to as well as, um, some further overtime data. I don't know if there's anything, Tamara, that you wanna add to that. Um, oh, go ahead, please. Oh Yeah, we, um, we are, uh, working with the igs office, um, both through her letter, her the response to the superintendent's letter. And we're, um, looking forward to, um, working on any sort of data issues, um, like that there may be, Is there an approximate date or date range that you expect that work will conclude such that there's a mutual understanding of what additional data sources exist and when that information associated with the sources will be shared with, uh, OIG? Um, I don't have that date, sir. Um, but I can, If you could provide that through the chair, through the chair, I'll be, we'd appreciate that. Just so we know when to follow up. Um, another question I would ask is, uh, around the workforce allocation study, uh, that was made reference to, um, are you aware of any updates about the status of, of that work, including, um, whether a finalized contract exists with the vendor? Yes, sir. So, um, CPD has completed its review of that. It is now, um, awaiting signature on, um, on both sides. We anticipate it to be signed, uh, very soon. Um, but we'll have a more robust update at, um, at the, uh, budget hearing Noted. Um, questions from committee members? Vice chair, Hadden. Thanks Chair. Um, thank you for the presentation. Um, uh, and, uh, info, a couple small questions. One, um, if you could speak a little bit, like, I think you gave a good overview of the type of data sources that go into this. Um, what's the, what's the work look like continuing to keep this updated? So thinking about just like, you know, roughly how much of your team's time is there somebody dedicated to this? What does that look like now that you have the system set up? Um, some of our data scientists are here, and I won't, um, so I won't risk getting wrong. Their ski, their, uh, time al their own time allocation. Um, I, this is, this is a dashboard like the others on our information portal, which is set to update automatically. So we have an ETL in place where the data updates one day each month. The date of the last update is visible on the dashboard. So this certainly requires some ongoing maintenance, but it is not a manual process every month. The, the heavy lift here is, is in building the tool and, and, um, piping in the data and setting up the system to clean and validate it. That will, um, there will be another sort of large effort like that when we are eventually able to get access to the additional information, which would supplement what we have here. And then looking at this tool, is there, I know it's specifically for staffing and one, it's very helpful to have, um, I can't tell you how many times at community meetings people wanna know, how many police officers do we have in our district, um, and they wanna know in comparison to other districts. So, um, uh, this will be a helpful tool, I think, for the public. But I'm thinking of other questions that, um, your department has helped answer and other dashboards that you have. And wondering about the ability to cross reference some of those things and, and what that looks like and how these systems, uh, speak to one another. Um, the first thing that comes to mind is, okay, great, how many officers and what are they doing in our district? But then that next question is, how many officers have complaints, right? How many officers are kind of in that category? And, you know, wondering if these systems speak to one another? This is, this is a good question. I appreciate the question. Um, we are, we have started to build connections between, between and among some of our data dashboards. So for example, I mentioned that we have a resource where people can look up their beat and their district. That is, we now have an address lookup dashboard where somebody can put in their home address and they can see all kinds of city services and designations that are associated with their address, including their district and beat. And so we've now built a connection between those dashboards, for example, um, there is a geographic, um, there is some geographic information on our dashboards showing CPD complaints or complaints against CPD members that those that is not at present connected in any way to our staffing dashboards. Although I will say as we continue to, to develop and expand those, those are the kinds of opportunities we are looking for. So I appreciate that question. We can take that back. Thank you. And, and then for our, uh, uh, commander, uh, thanks for being here. Um, this is less about the dashboard and, and more about general staffing. Um, and maybe this is something again that we'll get into a little bit more during budget hearings, but, um, through these from, from 2010 through 2022, um, I think at the heart of some of council and the public's questions around staffing allocation, um, and my district and the 24th district could be summarized to, to one major concern, which is where are our foot patrol officers? Um, so I know we've been in this time period of, um, I, lots of, lots of very complicated issues, whether it's what the different needs or things are or issues that we're asking police to address. Um, and then of course the things that, uh, the expectations we might have, um, on some of those changing issues. Um, but I know, um, in our neighborhoods, a lot of, a lot of the things come down to, you know, we wanna see, we, we want to see police kind of out and about. And I, I'm just wondering when we'll get to have that conversation and maybe during budget around, okay, this is helpful to see kind of how officers are being assigned. I know it's not fully reflective necessarily still of like, what are they doing on any given day, but with a tool like this available, I think it's gonna be even more imperative for, uh, the superintendent to be able to, you know, address the, I don't, I, I'd like to see a vision that addresses that and trying to get back to that because I know, you know, our commanders, um, you know, don't feel like they don't have the, the staffing for it. And I think that this information gets down to maybe helping you all as well, um, share with us what the challenges are. And so just, you know, uh, if you can speak to it here, great. Otherwise, I feel like it's part of an ongoing discussion of, you know, what are the, the things we're asking you to do, what are the human resources that you have, where are the gaps? And how can we work with you to help prioritize filling those gaps, um, for some of the things that we want to see, um, in different districts, but especially in the neighborhoods. Um, and thank you, and thank you for, uh, acknowledging the complex nature of, you know, of, um, of not just staffing, but of, um, all sorts of police work and the, you know, and the jobs that we do. Um, as far as, um, as far as the district level staffing, obviously, uh, the bureau of patrol prioritizes the, the primary B cars, right? That's where, um, you're all good, Sam. That is what we, uh, so you're fine. Again, um, that's our priority to staff first and then obviously, you know, um, having our like department down over 1600 officers since 2019, uh, you know, it's a, it's a, it's a balance and it's a managing of the resources that we do have. And then how can we best use those resources? Um, uh, I know the superintendent will have a more robust answer at, um, all of the budget hearings, but, um, I hope that leads us in the right direction for heading there. And if you have any other questions, I'd be happy to answer them. Thank you for that. And I, you know, I think that was sufficient to maybe let me know that we're all trying to, uh, find solutions to the same question to that. So I look forward to, um, to more from the superintendent on that. Thank you. Um, yeah, Alderwoman Lee. Thank you Chair. Um, hello again ladies. Hello. Nice to see you. Um, back to talk about more data, uh, just a couple of questions and thank you for the, the report. Um, you mentioned earlier, um, the attendance and assignment sheets as a critical component of the data used to assess staffing levels, um, but also pointed to issues around accuracy. Mm-Hmm. What do, what do these sheets look like and can you say a little bit more about the limitations in their sort of current state, um, to give us a bigger picture of just staffing levels and ccp DM Like, what, what could we perhaps do differently to collect better data? Um, I, I will defer on some of those questions to the department in terms of like the operational use of those records. But broadly, those records are, um, in, as their name suggests, they are intended to capture both attendance and assignment, which is to say what people are supposed to be doing and whether they're there doing it. And so the, the forms capture information, including by member, um, what people are supposed to be doing, where they're supposed to be working, what vehicle they are assigned to that data is not reflected on the dashboard, but it is on the a and a sheets, uh, et cetera. Whether they, you know, whether they're present for work, they do not capture things like, as I mentioned, overtime. So if somebody is working overtime, either they, meaning they stay on the beat, they are working for more hours, or they're working in unrelated overtime shifts somewhere else altogether, those would not be captured on the regular work a NA sheets. Um, in terms of how those are used operationally, what else they might capture, I, I would defer to the deputy chief. So, just a follow up question. 'cause you mentioned overtime then this might be for CPD. Um, how is overtime tracked then, if it's not using the, the a NA sheet? Uh, we have a separate application to track overtime, A separate application for that. So I work overtime on a shift at the, do I fill that out within a certain time period for when I was, when I work the hours? Is that how that works? I'm sorry for the ignorant questions, you guys. Yes. At the, um, at the completion of your tour, then you, um, complete it and online, uh, it's an overtime slip, but it's automated and it's all centralized in one location. Okay. Thank you. Um, And to answer your, um, appendix E has a sample of what an a, a uhhuh, uh, sheet like looks like. Um, it's just a screenshot, but just a sample on, uh, page 24 of, Of the report. Okay. I'll take a look at that. Thank you. Um, how does CPD determine day-to-day? Um, I guess how many staff on hand that you would like to have and what, and what you have are two totally separate things, right? Um, 'cause I imagine, and I know, you know, just working closely with our commanders in the ninth district, you know, we'd love to have X number of people like on, on a good day. We wanna have every single beat car, um, you know, with people in them and not having to sort of share between beats. Um, when you are looking at just day-to-day staffing though, and what you have on hand, um, what, what sort of drives the priorities? Um, like how do you determine, let's say you're a short, you know, a handful of officers, um, uh, what's, how does it get prioritized, um, where you put cars and where you put people, let alone foot patrol? I'd love to have foot patrol too, just for the record. I think many of us would, and I, and I think the police department would like to have foot patrol. I would love to give you foot patrol. Yeah, I would love to give every all the foot patrol. Yes. Um, but on a day-to-day basis, so like to watch staffing is, um, our other priority is to staff the primary B ccar, right? And just, um, when there is a gap, when there is a shortage in that the primary, the B ccar, there are other resources that are in every district and within every area that, um, help to cover that gap as well. So, um, if there is a, um, if there is a primary like B card that, um, it can't be filled that night, then um, we also have our fourth watch teams. You know, we have our TAC teams, our like caps personnel, our dcos, which can, you know, uh, help to supplement that. Um, we have our area teams, which can, you know, be like directed if, uh, like directly to a district or like to a b if need be, if we need to cover that. Um, we also can, and it's not reflected in the a, a sheets, but we can do, um, extension of tours. So, um, if I'm working a third watch and the first watch needs the coverage, there can be a, you know, like a watch extension there to help cover the gaps as well. And then, um, if need be, um, the use of RDO, uh, the person knows well to come in and cover those gaps. Um, and then obviously for any sort of, if there's a significant event or multiple events in one district, which, um, it does happen, then we can pull in resources from surrounding districts surrounding areas to help cover those gaps as well. Um, but there is, even if a primary B car, um, is not staffed for that shift, there are resources there to answer the calls for service and to respond to the citizens. Great. Thank you. Of one other question, or My computer just went to sleep. Um, and back to the, um, inspector general, uh, during a our, our last hearing, um, on ShotSpotter, there was some debate around it. And one of the difficulties we found was just quantitatively how to make an argument for keeping it, um, that could speak to the sort of qualitative, um, lived experience that officers, uh, and, and frankly constituents have had. What do you think we can do as a council to help CPD work on more data collection? Um, and I, 'cause I recognize so often, you know, people ask these questions about what more the police department can do. Part of that responsibility is on us to make sure they have the resources they need to be able to, to track the information that we want 'em to do, the things that we'd like for them to do. Yeah, I think that is a, that is a critically important question. You, you, you and I have talked before, and you all have heard me talk before about the notion that we ought to decide which outcomes are appropriate for the police department to pursue and then equip them to succeed at pursuing them. Um, I, I won't presume to speak for the department in terms of everything it needs, but I will say that when, when there are data quality and completeness challenges, when those things are an obstacle for us from an oversight perspective, they are also an obstacle for the department from a management perspective. Mm-Hmm. Certainly one contributing factor there. And this, this is even captured a little bit in this in our discussion about overtime records. One of the challenges is in having generations of legacy information systems, which sit sort of alongside each other, but don't integrate well across systems, um, that's a problem. Uh, good information systems aren't free. This strikes me as one of the many situations we talk about where reform takes resources. Um, so there are cer are certainly systems challenges which are susceptible to improvement. And I think that those would, those things would improve outcomes. Um, thank you for that. And I, I, I hear you loud and clear on it, and I, I, we'll be looking forward to more of these conversations during the, the budget hearings. Um, certainly an investment in technology that can help streamline things, uh, make reporting easier for police officers as well, saving time. Um, I know that that is something that is, um, very cumbersome, very, also very important, but there's gotta be a way that we can digitize a lot of that, um, and, and make, you know, certain self-reporting things a little bit easier. I, I think, uh, Alder woman, Hadden and I were talking on a, on a different subject recently and she said how easy it was for her to file a report in Oakland when her rental car got hit. Um, 'cause you could do that online. So I imagine there's things that we could also look at that would help take some of that burden, um, of the lower level things, uh, you know, off the, off of the police department. Um, but also create, uh, create better systems that can actually talk to each other, which will make obviously tracking information a lot easier. Um, you know, I don't know that CPD has a wishlist of things that, you know, efficiencies. And maybe that's the question we need to be asking you all as well. Um, where do you see opportunities, you know, where, where do you feel like you're, I don't wanna say wasting time, but where are you spending more time? Um, that it, it becomes more of a challenge to be more responsive to the calls that are coming in. 'cause we hear from constituents all the time. We call the police, they don't come. Um, and you know, we explain every time just sort of how things are prioritized when you call 9 1 1, you're not getting through exactly to the police right away. There, the calls are routed based on priority. Um, also it becomes very demoralizing for the public. So, you know, anything that we can do to cut the response times or to have somebody else do a follow up call, um, I, I think there's ways to do that. But if you have any sort of comment on that, I'd, I'd be interested. Otherwise, you know, I think I'm done probably with my questions. Uh, I will just, uh, mention on the data system. So we do have a pretty robust data warehouse. There's like over 4,000 different data tables there. Um, most of those tables do integrate some way, right? So we are able to tie people's overtime records to their, to the days they work and whatnot. Um, it is a little, uh, complicated 'cause there are a lot of legacy systems, so to speak, right? There's some systems on one application, some on another, but generally, again, it's a relational database. We find a way to connect those two. Um, and we'd be happy to kind of help you guys out, uh, if there's some particular question you want to tie to it. Um, that's always something we're willing to do. Um, in terms of the response time, I'll, I, I'll defer to Deputy Chief O'Connor, but, uh, I know the, or actually before I forget, uh, we are in the process of acquiring a new record management system. Uh, I believe it is not, or it just got posted, uh, maybe last week or two weeks ago. Uh, I, I remember correctly that the, that'd be a better question for PSA, but hopefully the idea is that that, uh, that system will replace some of these legacy systems that we have and replace it with one all encompassing, uh, record management system that should streamline some of these data. And as far as, um, we are looking at various types of technology and, and like anything that can help us do our job or, or help our interaction with the citizens is something that we are obviously gonna wanna look at. One of the things that we have done is, um, we have created a wash sheet application. Um, it's briefly mentioned in the report here, and citywide what has done it, it has standardized our worksheets. So prior to that it was, um, it was a combination of a paper based and, um, a computer based system. But now everything is standardized. We have standardized all of the beat, um, all of the radio call signs. So, um, that is all like standard. And then in what this watch sheet application done is, uh, it does, is it pulls from our existing like databases and helps us automatically let us know, um, what the available like manpower is for that day. So, um, it, um, it pulls from our, uh, from our training, from our court, from our medical and IOD. So if members are assigned to the district, if they are available for work, like that day on their, um, assigned watch. And then with that as well, there's a way to forecast, you know, however long out, um, you know, where we can see where our gaps may be like that are upcoming, you know, whether it be based on training or furloughs or, you know, it, it can go by the day or we can look in the aggregate and see where we may need to have additional resources present, um, based on what our data systems are telling us. So, um, that is currently in place and that's in all the districts now. Um, so I think that that's a useful tool. Um, and it is easier to manage. It's, you know, it's the Windows base, it's drop and drag, it's, you know, um, it's just a system that, uh, I think is gonna benefit us and it'll benefit our scheduling, which then will benefit, benefit, um, where we see where our manpower needs are. So I know you had a comment. I just have one follow up question. Uh, and it just popped into my mind. We have so many special events in this city, um, that draw away, um, police resources. Um, I, I don't necessarily understand the process today, like how, how the police department interacts with D case, let's say, um, to coordinate, um, because it seems to me we have a lot of overlapping events. Um, and then we have local needs as well, right? So if someone's, if I have like a church that's having a big, you know, procession in the neighborhood, I will generally need, you know, two cars, one at the front, one and the back to help with traffic control. Um, but if that happens to be on the same day as, let's say the Chicago Marathon or something, or, or NASCAR or something else that's drawing police resources away, you know, I, I feel really bad putting that upon the, the police district. Uh, but I'm just wondering like, how much, at what point are you all communicated with about, and do you get to approve or deny anything, uh, in that process? Just looking at, you know, especially in the summertime with all the summer festivals that we have in the different neighborhoods, I I imagine it's a, that's probably the worst time for us, actually. Yes. Um, we learned a lot this year with the DNC and with the multiple events on the same days. And there is, um, a broader conversation amongst all the city agencies about how, um, how can we the better manage that in the upcoming years. Um, uh, I don't wanna speak for other agencies or beyond, um, my bureau, but those, the conversations are starting to happen and, um, the allocation of those resources to these large events is, um, a topic of conversation. Yeah, and I'd, I'd love to see us as a city make sure that we're, we're, uh, we're charging enough for these fees for permits, um, considering the amount of security that we're providing. Inspector General, Thank you very much. I just, uh, and apologize, I didn't mean to interrupt. I just wanted to note, um, the additional data resources that have been described here are the ones, um, for which we've been waiting for access for over a year. So I, I just wanna note that I sincerely appreciate CPDs commitment today to facilitating that access. Um, we look forward to that. And in terms of what help we need doing that, that would be the demonstration that we've requested. So I just wanna note, I appreciate CPDs commitment here in the hearing today to providing those things. Thank you. That's all I've got. Chairman, Thank you. Alderwoman, alderman, alderman Vasquez. Thank you. Thank you very much, chairman. Um, thank you all for the conversation. I, I kind of to follow up on some of the questions, I appreciate that, like, there's a conversation about upgrading some of the technology here. Is there ever, um, studies or conversations about what other cities do as far as comparable software? Like is this something that all other cities are going through? Is it something Chicago's unique in? How do we rank, We have not done that comparative analysis, I assume that CPD is in contact with its peer departments on that question. Yeah, so we re recently went through a process of selecting a new RMS. Um, it had some hiccups. Long story short is we had to go kind of reengage that process. Uh, but as part of that process, we did review, uh, different city agencies and what they were using. We, uh, looked for referrals. We kinda, uh, sought out experts on how they were making use of the system. So there is a process in place. Um, and again, I don't wanna speak. A lot of this is is handled now by PSA, but there is a process in place where we went through and we sought those referrals. We talked to those experts that were making use of these systems. Um, we had different presentations, uh, uh, pre presented, uh, from a group, uh, making the selection. So, uh, there is something to to say about, yeah, that we have done some of those things. So, I mean, thank you very much. I know o obviously OPSA kind of oversees all of it. Uh, this is literally just opinion. 'cause obviously looking at other cities, is there one that to you stood out and said like, Hey, you know, what, the way they're handling it, the reason I ask that is we know that there's a lot of, a lot of departments where we're very antiquated in how we do this stuff. And I'm always curious as to like, who does it best to kind of measure ourselves against? And just wondering if you had any opinion based on things that you'd seen. No, I mean, and, and kind of to what the Inspector General has mentioned. I haven't, I didn't take the exercise up to say, oh, Philly's doing a great job. New York's doing a great job, LA's doing a great job. I kind of took it more as an experience to try to learn to what worked for, uh, Chicago in that sense. Uh, but certainly there's a lot to learn from these other agencies. Uh, and that's something I went into again to this, uh, selection process. So hopefully we'll make use of it. Sure. I appreciate that. Um, I think, uh, I, I, I have to find the actual reference point. 'cause I remember reading this somewhere, and I can't remember the city, but there was, I think a mayor at that point had a conversation with their police department and they were able to list the things that they felt shouldn't be their job at all in a way that was actually very informative to identify which departments could do something else. 'cause then it allows CPD to focus in this instance, it would allow CPD to focus on what I believe are the core functions, right? Investigation, apprehension, emergency response when appropriate. When we ask y'all to do everything, including somebody's parking in a, in a wrong permit, parking spot, there's a cat stuck in a tree, there's a homeless person that shouldn't be part of your job and I think makes the overtime problem even worse. Has there ever been that conversation between the department and the city as far as a list of things that y'all are like, Hey, you know what shouldn't actually be our responsibility? Um, it's a very complex question and I, uh, there's a lot of good points there on just the complex nature of, um, of what our calls for service entail and the different sort of aspects for it. But, um, I will, uh, defer those questions to the budget hearings. Um, and um, to the, the superintendent who can better answer that. Okay. And Then I'll, I'll add Alder and just in case, um, you may be aware, but others may not. I know that there is a working group, for lack of a better term, that has been convened, that involves representatives from CPD from the mayor's office, OEMC. It might be something that, um, deputy Mayor Gary and Gatewood could be able to speak to. Uh, I don't know what the scope of that work is or the timeline for completion, but, uh, there is some work underway there. Oh, no. Tha thank, thank you for that. I mean, I, as, as some other working groups we hear about, it'd be great to have alders in there. 'cause I think we all need to provide insight as being on the ground and it doesn't happen enough. But I think, um, the answer may be complex. The question's pretty simple. What are the things you guys don't want to do or shouldn't do? And I think us all working together can help so that way the overtime isn't going extra. I mean, the number one thing that I've heard is the special events, right? Like, for example, we had pride where there were officers the whole day knowing that there was really not a need during the day. 'cause in the evening is when the activity was kicking up, right? Um, have we not had the conversation about making people throw in the events, pay for their security, reimburse us for the overtime. Maybe we just have a liaison from CPD that could be there as opposed to having that much force there. Have, have those conversations occurred at all? Uh, yes. Those, uh, I said ultimately, uh, we learned a lot from this year from the DNC and all the major events that happened kind of, um, often on the same weekend. And those conversations happen started not just with the department, but with, um, like the city and, uh, all of our C agencies. Okay. What, what, what, have there been results or what's that looking like as far as those conversations so far? Uh, I don't wanna get into the conversations. I wasn't a part of there, but I know that they are ongoing. Okay. I, I definitely threw the chair. Anything that can be provided, we'd like, 'cause as we're heading into these large budget deficits, knowing, I mean we, I've been saying it now for over two terms. I think we do need to audit and independent audit audit departments and we can start with the biggest one, which happens to be CPD and work our way down just for efficiency and effectiveness. And it, it seems to always come back to the, the events and the overtime there that some of it feels like it should just be the mayor and his authority saying, you know what? We're not gonna continue doing that. So if you want to do an event, you're gonna have to pay for it or reimburse us for the overtime. And I'm sorry, but that's just the way it has to be 'cause the city can't afford it. And so I just, I guess that's kind of the last point I'll leave it at. I think as we get studies and information, the more we have these conversations in a sincere manner, the better it's gonna be. 'cause these officers are getting burned out working all the hours they are, can't take the days off that they need to. They, they need mental health supports they're not even able to take advantage of 'cause they're so burn out and we just wanna make sure we have a system that works properly. So thank you for being here. Thank you for your help and thank you Chairman. Thank You. Alderman Beck. Thanks chairman. Um, inspector General, just, uh, if you could, um, speak to that a little bit. Alderman, uh, alderman, when Lee started on it about, you know, just the different, um, pieces of information that you're bringing in, do you talk to D case, um, about what their requests are and does that filter into your staffing, um, reports here? Uh, no. Um, and, and that relates to this, this distinction between point in time data capture and a predictive tool. Things like special event requests would, I think be a really important piece of that predictive tool where we have inputs and outputs, which should be, uh, definable to needs changing, needs changing strategies, including things like special events. So all we are capturing here is how many people are working and where not any questions about why they are, where they are or what brings them there. Okay. Yeah, because I think that, um, you know, the conversation started a few years ago about this with the department. Um, you know, and I, uh, just last year I had an, or this year have had a couple events, especially related to the DNC where we told the, um, the event organizers, they would have to hire private security because we were not gonna push to have officers at those events. Um, and I think a good message came out probably from the department through the commanders, that that was gonna be the case as well. Um, now some events, uh, did, you know, adhere to that, but I, I think our bigger problem is, you know, we, even though we've started this conversation, we still see private organizations pushing the, the limit here and actually creating the need for those officers to come out. And, you know, as was stated, that leads to overtime problems at leads to injuries for, you know, having to deal with fights at these events. Um, but it, it honestly, colleagues, it's also alderman driving these events as well. And some of these events should not be repeated where we have officers, um, in my cases being pulled off of our beats to deal with mass, uh, brawl, massive brawls at events with, uh, constant, you know, overtime being called in or officers from other beats and districts having to come in by the dozens to deal with, um, problems that are created by private organizations running out of control events. So I think those, that data has to be included in this as well. It can't be on the police department just to say, well, here was the OT that we got, but we have to redress it at the front end so that we don't have DK signing off. And if, and as a lot of colleagues know, we get the event and the police department's told, you need 20 officers at this event each day, or whatever it might be. And they're put in a corner that the event's already been signed off on by D case or the mayor's office and they have no choice. So to me it doesn't make sense to, you know, if we're gonna just push the narrative that it's the police department alone that's creating this situation. It really is D case and the private organizations that are putting our officers in a position to have to respond and commit to those events. I think as we've seen over and over again, and this was brought up with D case last year and the, and the year before, and we've had a little bit of a response, but it's not a matter of just saying, Hey, you know, if the organization wants to pay the extra money for those officers, that's, that's not good enough. It should be, they're gonna have to start paying for private security because we really can't afford to pull all those officers out of, out of districts or put 'em on for overtime or whatever it was that we're all talking about. So I know that's not part of what is in your data, but um, the other departments, the other agencies, the other, uh, businesses that are pulling the officers into these situations need to be accountable as well. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you Alderman. I think that's a set of really good points by a number of older people, um, general and, and deputy, maybe you can share a little bit about, uh, your, your audit plans and maybe timelines that we should have in mind. 'cause obviously we as city council can't dictate exactly what you audit, but I know that there is a collaborative relationship between you and various departments, you and city council and you and the public. If you can share, you know, maybe how baked your, your audit plans are and then regardless of what that schedule looks like, it sounds like a number of us would welcome you taking that up in addition to conversations that we'll continue to have with C-P-D-E-B-A-C-P and others. Absolutely. That's exactly right. Our project planning process is very much a collaborative one. The object of the game from my perspective is that we direct our oversight resources at the things that matter most to Chicagoans. And so, uh, at the end of each year leading into each new year, we put out a draft project plan for our public safety section where we identify topics we are considering. It's sort of a menu of options. We're not gonna do every project on that list, and we'll do some projects that are not on that list, but it is an exercise in planning and we post a draft for public comment. Um, we welcome comment from all of you directly as well as from your constituents. Some of you have invited us to your wards to talk about those project topics and to gather feedback. We would, we would be happy to come to all 50 wards and do that. Um, and we are, so there is this annual process. We are also very happy at any other time of the year to hear from you and your constituents about those things, which, about which you are most concerned and which you think are most pressing. Um, so that is just to say, uh, now and any other time I would be happy to take, uh, this, this and any other information about things that you think all you that, that you all feel are pressing. I'll also say, if I could just hijack this answer momentarily, um, I, I wholeheartedly agree with the notion that staffing and, and how much staffing is enough is, is critically tied to this question of which functions we want the police department to perform this from my perspective is about right sizing the footprint of the police department. I think it is certainly true that we ask the police department to be the first line of defense and the last resort to an ever-growing number of problems that is not sustainable, particularly in what we are currently painfully aware to be a resource constrained environment. There are not infinite resources and, and particularly against that backdrop, we ought to be making thoughtful and strategic decisions about which functions belong within the footprint of the police department and which functions are best performed elsewhere by another agency, another city department, another entity, et cetera. Um, and then to sort of reiterate one of our early points of discussion this afternoon, once we have made those decisions about which functions belong within the footprint of the police department, we ought to equip the police department to succeed. We ought to equip the department for successful outcomes at those functions. Great. Um, I'm gonna get to alderman OSHA first who had his hand raised, and then we'll come back to you. Alderman Vasquez, alderman, osha. Thank you Chairman. Um, I just wanna piggyback on what some of, uh, my colleagues have stated. This has been a ongoing topic at, at several budget hearings in a row. And, and you know, we can point to specific examples this summer alone where the city of Chicago or D Case scheduled multiple events in a weekend. Those events where you need hundreds and hundreds of officers deployed, uh, those are officers whose days off are canceled, so they're getting overtime. Those are officers that are being deli of deprived of rest. Um, but oftentimes the very people in the coming weeks during budget railing about police overtime, they're the people that are calling for these events where hundreds of officers need, need to work. Um, and we, we've seen it where in many of these events, the event itself has such a large number of people that you need a large number of law enforcement officers, whether it be a parade route, which is, you know, scaled out couple blocks wide by a mile, two miles long. Um, or just the, the, the sheer amount of people that come into a, a specific area like a, a, a grant park or Millennium Park or wherever. Um, but then also it's the aftermath of the event. The event is two hours or four hours long, but the event goes on all night, then long after everybody should have left the community. Um, that's tens of millions of dollars it costs every single year. And we really should explore what, what are those top 10 or 15 events, uh, per year. And then D Case, the city of Chicago, uh, should make sure that we, we be reimbursed for that. Um, especially when we're gonna be talking and, and you mark my words in the coming weeks, we're, we're gonna be told we need to scale back on investments we've made in the police department, like mental health, uh, like peer support, um, that will be discussed. It's not something I'm gonna support. And I would hope anybody, uh, on this meeting today wouldn't support that. But these are real problems that are exacerbated by the large scale events that require hundreds of officers to work. And in, in this summer alone, those were on somewhat short notice. Thank you, chairman. Thank you Alderman. Um, Vesquez? Yeah, uh, I, I, one I wanna thank uh, alderman Oscha for that point. 'cause I think it can be easy for us sometimes to point the finger at D case when we are the ones who also want the events. And I think it is about us having a conversation as to what protocol should look like and options to really know there's different scales of events. So I just wanted one, thank you for that. But the question I had was more related to something that the general had said at a prior, uh, hearing, and it was related to Shot Spotter. So we were going over, uh, I think the latest studies, I think about a week or two ago. Um, and something that I thought was spot on was this idea that ShotSpotter was helping in lifesaving when it occurs as far as incidents. And that if it is about lifesaving directing those more to ambulances, more to different departments might be a way to actually address that as far as improving outcomes. So I guess my follow up to that, 'cause I think that's how, how it was framed is what's doing something like that also helped take some of that off of officer so they could best be allocated in other places. I, I, I don't know how how deep you did analysis on that, but I just thought when you said it, it made sense as a way to pivot. So instead of just saying we're removing it completely to say, Hey, you know what, it's gonna not go to police. So it's not over policing. For those who have the concern, it's gonna go to ambulances. So C, FD and them can actually bring up their need for resources too. I'm not sure I have a specific answer there. I will say, as a general matter, I think the right way to approach all of these issues is as resource allocation questions. We have finite resources, we have constrained resources. And looking ahead at the city's short and medium term budget horizon, that looks likely to be true for a while. Um, staffing resources are finite, as are other kinds of resources. And so when we think about allocation decisions, we should be thinking about those enterprise wide, not just within the police department, but across other city entities, other partner agencies, et cetera, who might be equipped and in fact better equipped in some cases, um, to provide services. So that, again, back to this notion of right sizing the footprint, we've allocated responsibilities appropriately and then allocated resources to, to get good outcomes in those responsibilities. Thank you. Yeah, I just think as we keep trying to find different ways to really be specific on what we want CPD to do because the resources are finite, I think that's actually was really, I really appreciated you saying it. 'cause it really got me to rethinking about the whole shot spotter conversation in a way that I think could have led to a less contentious outcome. So thank you very much for that. Thank you. Thank you. Uh, seeing no other hands, um, I think, uh, we're done with, uh, the business before the committee. So can I get a motion to adjourn vice chair and so moves all those in favor signify by saying aye. All those opposed in the opinion of the chair. The ayes have it. The meeting is adjourned. Thank you all. I.